Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Audit Stage
Compliance
State of Mind
S1
Appropriate
Management Style
Definition
Full time or very high - increase attention The staff in question use the element, but only
if score is low or falls back.
because the they are being reviewed.
Risk
Audit Scoring
The staff in question do not see any benefit in If the review process were taken away the
using the element, or they are actually resisting element usage would probably stop
its usage.
immediately.
Closed Ended
Questions:
"Mechanical Compliance"
Understanding
S2
Coach
Open Ended
Questions:
Usage
S3
Support
The full benefits are derived and modifications / It can be assumed that the system element
improvements may also be volunteered.
will continue to be used. At this stage the
management can begin to rely on delegation
of system elements rather than any direct
review or supervision.
Demonstrative
Questions:
1
Shift Handover
(Process kiln-3)
Daily
Sr. No.
FREQUENCY
Responsible
Accountable
System Elements
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
Shift Inchar
Sr. Manag
(Process kiln-3)
S3:
Usage
Daily
Shift Handover
Mechanical
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
Shift I
Sr. M
S3:
Usage
Daily
Shift Handover
(E & I)
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
Shift
Sr.
S3:
Usage
Daily
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
Shift
Sr.
S3:
Usage
Daily
Breakdown Slip
( Kiln- 3)
Engineers
Managers
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS)
Engineers
Managers
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
Daily
Engine
Breakdown Management
System (BMS)
Manag
S2:
Understanding
Daily
Line Walk
S1:
Compliance
Managers
anager (Maintenance)
S3:
Usage
S2:
Understanding
Daily
Managers
Line Walk
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following questions to help you decide which
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of the MCS Tools being assessed
Have the information flow became more effective with the templates?
Has all the information has been shared during shift handover.?
Whether template is filled completely?
Whether all concerned people have signed the template?
Whether any remark mentioned on the sheet?
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by shift incharge?
Whether the complete sheet is understood by the shift incharge?
How shift handover process has been improved?
Have the information flow became more effective with the templates?
Has all the information has been shared during shift handover.?
Whether template is filled completely?
Whether all concerned people have signed the template?
Whether any remark mentioned on the sheet?
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by shift incharge?
Whether the complete sheet is understood by the shift incharge?
How shift handover process has been improved?
Have the information flow became more effective with the templates?
Has all the information has been shared during shift handover.?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations person completely?
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenance perosn completely?
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both Maintenance and Operations
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finish time is important?
What analysis of information about breakdowns captured should be done on weekly basis ?
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using the Breakdwon Slips?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your yesterdays
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high response time, correct desc
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feeding person completely?
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by the data operator?
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both Maintenance and Operations
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finish time is important?
What analysis of information about breakdowns captured should be done on weekly basis ?
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using the Breakdwon Slips?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your yesterdays
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high response time, correct desc
resolution of breakdown etc.
Is line walk schedule prepared? Is it is done as per schedule.?
Is line walk log sheet is filled properly and reported as on the day?
Is line walk is done properly by the assigned person?
Are all the codes underdstood by the person.?
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has to do the line walk?
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Are task has been assigned with its priority?
Are all the high priority issues has been closed?
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
100%
100%
94%
90%
82%
79%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Actual
S1-Compliance Plan
S2-Understanding Plan
Actual
S3-Usage Plan
Actual
100%
S1-Compliance Plan
Actual
S2-Understanding Plan
Actual
S3-Usage Plan
94%
88%
90%
82%
79%
80%
82%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Wk-31
Wk-32
Wk-33
100%
Actual
S1-Compliance Plan
100%
94%
90%
80%
Actual
79%
94%
82%
70%
60%
50%
Percentage
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Week
88%
82%
82%
100%
S1-Compliance Plan
94%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Actual
S3-Usage Plan
94%
92%
88%
90%
80%
Actual
S2-Understanding Plan
79%
82%
82%
82%
83%
Actual
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
S1-Compliance Plan
S2-Understanding Plan
S3-Usage Plan
100%
94%
94%
92%
93%
88%
90%
80%
Actual
79%
82%
82%
82%
83%
78%
S2-Understanding Plan
Actual
S3-Usage Plan
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Wk-31
Wk-32
Wk-33
Wk-34
Wk-35
Wk-36
Wk-37
S1-Compliance Plan
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
92%
90%
89%
90%
91%
Actual
S2-Understanding Plan
94%
88%
92%
90%
S3-Usage
S3-Usage Plan
92%
92%
90%
91%
90%
90%
Section
S1-Compliance
S2-Understanding
S3-Usage
Progress
Plan
Actual
Plan
Actual
Plan
Actual
Wk-31
Wk-32
Wk-33
Wk-34
90%
80%
100%
70%
79%
90%
80%
94%
70%
82%
90%
80%
88%
70%
82%
90%
80%
94%
70%
82%
Graph data po
updation aft
Wk-35
Wk-36
Wk-37
Wk-38
Wk-39
Wk-40
Wk-41
Wk-42
90%
80%
92%
70%
83%
90%
80%
93%
70%
78%
90%
80%
93%
70%
87%
90%
80%
90%
70%
85%
90%
80%
93%
70%
85%
90%
80%
93%
70%
87%
90%
80%
93%
70%
80%
90%
80%
100%
70%
82%
Wk-43
Wk-44
Wk-45
Wk-46
Wk-47
Wk-48
Wk-49
Wk-50
90%
80%
100%
70%
85%
90%
80%
100%
70%
88%
90%
80%
100%
70%
88%
90%
90%
100%
90%
87%
90%
90%
100%
90%
89%
90%
90%
100%
90%
90%
90%
90%
100%
90%
89%
90%
90%
100%
90%
88%
Wk-51
Wk-52
Wk-53
Wk-54
Wk-55
Wk-56
Wk-57
Wk-58
90%
90%
100%
90%
88%
90%
90%
100%
90%
85%
90%
90%
100%
90%
92%
90%
90%
93%
90%
85%
90%
90%
93%
90%
85%
90%
90%
100%
90%
92%
90%
90%
95%
90%
88%
90%
90%
90%
90%
88%
Wk-59
Wk-60
Wk-61
Wk-62
Wk-63
Wk-64
Wk-65
Wk-66
90%
90%
94%
90%
89%
90%
90%
100%
90%
88%
90%
90%
95%
90%
88%
90%
90%
90%
90%
85%
90%
90%
94%
90%
85%
90%
90%
94%
90%
81%
90%
90%
94%
90%
86%
90%
90%
94%
90%
85%
Wk-67
Wk-68
Wk-69
Wk-70
Wk-71
Wk-72
Wk-73
Wk-74
90%
90%
93%
90%
83%
90%
90%
94%
90%
86%
90%
90%
92%
90%
86%
90%
90%
92%
90%
86%
90%
90%
94%
90%
86%
90%
90%
94%
90%
82%
90%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
90%
95%
90%
89%
Wk-75
Wk-76
Wk-77
Wk-78
Wk-79
Wk-80
Wk-81
Wk-82
90%
90%
93%
90%
88%
90%
90%
90%
90%
87%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
85%
90%
90%
90%
90%
88%
90%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
90%
90%
90%
88%
90%
90%
88%
90%
88%
Wk-83
Wk-84
Wk-85
Wk-86
Wk-87
Wk-88
Wk-89
Wk-90
90%
90%
88%
90%
86%
90%
90%
90%
90%
88%
90%
90%
89%
90%
85%
90%
90%
89%
90%
88%
90%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
90%
89%
90%
88%
90%
90%
89%
90%
87%
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
89%
Wk-91
Wk-92
Wk-93
Wk-94
Wk-95
Wk-96
Wk-97
Wk-98
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
88%
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
91%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
89%
Wk-99
Wk-100
Wk-101
Wk-102
Wk-103
Wk-104
Wk-105
Wk-106
90%
92%
90%
91%
90%
89%
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
89%
90%
90%
90%
91%
90%
88%
90%
94%
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
92%
90%
92%
90%
90%
90%
91%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
90%
-
90%
90%
90%
-
Wk-107
Wk-108
90%
90%
90%
-
90%
90%
90%
-
Responsible
r. Manager / Manager
FREQUENCY
Accountable
Daily
Sr. No.
System Elements
Daily
Daily
Shift Incharge (E
Sr. Manager / M
intenance)
Managers
Weekly
DRM Chairman
n)
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
Managers
Engineers
Daily
7
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
Monday, Wednesday, Friday
8
Shut Down Job Scoping
Kiln Phase 2
GM
Departmental HOD
9
Root Cause Analysis Phase 1
Sr.Manager / Manager
Weekly
10
Shutdown Review
Meeting
DRM Chairman
Process In charges
As
As and
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
Is line walk log sheet is filled properly and reported as on the day?
Is line walk is done properly by the assigned person?
Are all the codes underdstood by the person.?
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Are task has been assigned with its priority?
Are all the high priority issues has been closed?
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Are you carrying out root cause analysis for Bad actor (Equipment's) at
Are you filling up and updating RCA tracker ? Please show the RCA tra
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA tracker log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
10
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
13-Dec-14
REMARKS
93%
87%
40%
REMARKS
ACTION PLAN
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
ager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
- General Manager
10
14
Sr.Manager / Manager
Weekly
Required
ge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Man
Sectional - General
13
er / Manager
12
(Engineer)
As When Required
As When Required
15
/ Manager
14
- During
es
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
Retraining by the
departement heads
Retraining by the
departement heads
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
10
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
16-Dec-14
REMAR
No Bre
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not A
Not A
Not A
Not A
Not A
Not A
92%
79%
46%
REMARKS
placed with log sheet and merge with the IMS in this
placed with log sheet and merge with the IMS in this
No Breakdown
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
The usage will built up only when there proper flow on informatio
A special training has to be provided on how to generate bad actor list based up
the given data
the phase head should make sure that all the jobs are being complete on time a
per the shutdown job scoping and planning
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
very good.
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
5
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
27-Dec-14
REMAR
system is not us
It is not used
Analysis is in progress
Not Re
Not Re
Not A
Not A
87%
85%
46%
REMARKS
sed in detail
Not Required
Not Required
Not Audited
Not Audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
KPI and its correlation should be made such so that KPI could be achieved.
Sectional HOD should have to take responsibilty of RCA out come and
analysis
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
BMS sheet.
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
9
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
3-Jan-15
REMAR
Not Re
Not Re
Not A
Not A
not re
0
not re
0
93%
93%
63%
REMARKS
curate
ieve KPI but root cause analysis should be done on weekly basis.
Not Required
Not Required
Not Audited
Not Audited
not required
not required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
g is done by manager
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
10
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
7-Jan-15
REMAR
Not Audited
Not Re
Not Re
Not A
Not A
not re
0
not re
0
100%
92%
58%
REMARKS
ieve KPI but root cause analysis should be done on weekly basis.
Not Required
Not Required
Not Audited
Not Audited
not required
not required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
ager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
- General Manager
10
14
Sr.Manager / Manager
Weekly
Required
ge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Man
Sectional - General
13
er / Manager
12
(Engineer)
As When Required
As When Required
15
/ Manager
14
- During
es
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
6
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
8-Jan-14
REMAR
Not a
Not a
Not a
Not a
Not a
Not a
Not audited
Not audited
94%
100%
72%
REMARKS
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
6
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
9-Jan-14
REMAR
Not a
Not a
Not a
Not audited
Not audited
92%
92%
64%
REMARKS
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
14
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
10-Jan-14
REMAR
Not a
Not a
Not a
Not a
Not audited
Not audited
100%
100%
67%
REMARKS
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
Managers
10
GM
When Required
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
rtmental HOD
Monday,
GM
12
eneral Manager
eekly
Departmental HOD
11
er / Manager
Departmental HO
GM
10
equired
(Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
13
/ Manager
12
(Engineer)
As When Required
As When Required
15
/ Manager
14
- During
es
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
8
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
30-Jan-15
REMAR
Not Audited
0
Not Audited
0
Not A
0
Not A
Not A
Not A
Not A
Not A
not re
0
not re
0
94%
96%
75%
REMARKS
s not done by BMS system and also they have to install separately
in their phase
s not done by BMS system and also they have to install separately
in their phase
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
not required
not required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
8
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
7-Feb-15
REMAR
not a
0
Not Audited
0
Not A
0
Not A
Not A
Not A
Not A
not re
0
not re
0
93%
93%
73%
REMARKS
not audited
one
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
not required
not required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
g sheet
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
8
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
14-Feb-15
REMAR
Not audited
0
Not Audited
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
not re
0
not re
0
93%
100%
80%
REMARKS
e is little bit low this week due to unfilled of section so usage can
ed section should be filled to do proper analysis
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
not required
not required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
so it must be updated with job end time so it will be easy for analysis and also break down
register help in making chart which can give description of equipment went majorly through
shut down
Usage is high because decision taken is based on RCA and hence usa
is now fully achiedved for this section.
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
g sheet
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
9
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
21-Feb-15
REMAR
not a
not a
3
Not audited
0
Not Audited
0
not au
0
not au
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
not au
0
not au
0
93%
100%
85%
REMARKS
not audited
not audited
not audited
not audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
not audited
not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
Managers
10
GM
When Required
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
rtmental HOD
Monday,
GM
12
eneral Manager
eekly
Departmental HOD
11
er / Manager
Departmental HO
GM
10
equired
(Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
13
/ Manager
12
(Engineer)
As When Required
As When Required
15
/ Manager
14
- During
es
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
10
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
18
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
27-Feb-15
REMAR
92%
100%
92%
REMARKS
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
Marking done around that job and it will soon get completed and tomorrow on
more audit of BMS of phase 1 will be done
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
omorrow
omorrow
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
5
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
5-Mar-15
REMAR
Approval was
some job is
1
95%
100%
79%
REMARKS
ow compliance
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
oon as possible.
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
7
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
14-Mar-15
REMAR
Not a
0
Not a
0
88%
94%
82%
REMARKS
Not audited
Not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
department in DRM
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
7
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
21-Mar-15
REMAR
Not required
0
Not required
0
Not re
0
Not re
0
Not re
0
Not re
0
Not Re
0
Not re
0
94%
88%
82%
REMARKS
Not required
Not required
Not required
Not required
Not Required
Not required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
job.
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
7
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
27-Mar-15
REMAR
.
3
Not a
Not a
0
Not a
0
Not required
0
Not re
0
Not re
0
Not Re
0
Not re
0
Not a
3
Not a
3
88%
94%
82%
REMARKS
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
Not required
Not required
Not Required
Not required
Not audited
Not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
From SID side and Power Side sheet need to be exchanged by email to each
other.
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
ng is scheduled
ng is scheduled
ob is finishing
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
arges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
man
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
10
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
18
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
2-Apr-15
REMAR
Not Audited
0
Not a
Not a
0
Not a
0
Analysis is not
Analysis is not
Not required
0
Not re
0
Not re
0
Not Re
0
Sheet is sub
3
Temperature sca
1
92%
92%
83%
REMARKS
Not audited
Not audited
Not audited
Not required
Not required
Not Required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
Analysis is done on monthly basis by MAT member.But training ism not given t
MAT member yet due to PM checklist submission work.
Analysis is done on monthly basis by MAT member.But training ism not given t
MAT member yet due to PM checklist submission work.
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
arges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
man
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
9
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
11-Apr-15
REMAR
Export is no
1
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not A
0
Not Re
0
Not Re
0
Not Re
0
85%
93%
78%
REMARKS
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
Audit taken and physical check up of CO analyser is done and issue raised in D
to respective department.
Audit taken and physical check up of CO analyser is done and issue raised in D
to respective department.
Issue will be discussed in Monday DRM meeting and corrective action then will
fixed.
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
made
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Daily
Daily
Electrical
Engineers
AGM (oper
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
Engineers
ental HOD
Monday, Wed
Managers
10
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
en Required
Engi
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Mana
ly
Manager
Departmental HOD
Departmental HOD
GM
11
GM
ral Manager
10
ired
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
gineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
13
nager
12
gineer)
15
nager
14
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
uring
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
8
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
18-Apr-15
REMAR
DRM is installed
3
Export is li
1
Not A
Training is no
Not A
Not Re
0
Not Re
0
Not Re
0
Not Re
0
Not Re
0
Not Re
0
Not A
0
Not A
Not A
0
93%
93%
87%
REMARKS
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
Not Audited
Not Audited
Not Audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Daily
Daily
Electrical
Engineers
AGM (oper
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
Engineers
ental HOD
Monday, Wed
Managers
10
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
en Required
Engi
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Mana
ly
Manager
Departmental HOD
Departmental HOD
GM
11
GM
ral Manager
10
ired
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
gineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
13
nager
12
gineer)
15
nager
14
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
uring
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
5
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
25-Apr-15
REMAR
Not Re
Not Re
Not Re
Not Re
Not Re
Not Re
Not Re
90%
90%
85%
REMARKS
unfilled
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
nd on compliance mode
Not Required
Not Required
Not Required
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
t Incharge
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Daily
Daily
Electrical
Engineers
AGM (oper
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
Engineers
ental HOD
Monday, Wed
Managers
10
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
en Required
Engi
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Mana
ly
Manager
Departmental HOD
Departmental HOD
GM
11
GM
ral Manager
10
ired
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
gineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
13
nager
12
gineer)
15
nager
14
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
uring
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
9
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
2-May-15
REMAR
Export
1
Not A
Not A
0
93%
93%
85%
REMARKS
Export is high
Not Audited
Not Audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
e Sectinal HOD
nimized
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Daily
Daily
Electrical
Engineers
AGM (oper
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
Engineers
ental HOD
Monday, Wed
Managers
10
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
en Required
Engi
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Mana
ly
Manager
Departmental HOD
Departmental HOD
GM
11
GM
ral Manager
10
ired
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
gineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
13
nager
12
gineer)
15
nager
14
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
uring
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
8
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
9-May-15
REMAR
Export is no
1
Not A
0
Not Re
Not A
0
93%
93%
87%
REMARKS
Not Audited
Not Required
Not Audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
e Sectinal HOD
D and IT department
o the HOD
n progress
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
8
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
Taskforce
16-May-15
REMAR
.
3
Not a
0
Not a
0
No t audited
0
Not audited
0
Not re
0
Not re
0
Not Re
0
Not re
0
Not a
0
Not a
0
87%
93%
80%
REMARKS
Not audited
Not audited
Not required
Not required
Not Required
Not required
Not audited
Not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)
ng is scheduled
ng is scheduled
22-05-2015
Sr. No.
System Elements
Accountable
Responsible
FREQUENCY
Daily
2
Shift Handover and log
sheet - Phase 2
Managers
Weekly
Shift I
Sr.
4
Daily Review Meeting
DRM Chairman
AGM (operation)
Electrical HOD
Daily
General Man
Dai
Daily
Electric
Engineers
AGM (op
Managers
Managers
Engineers
Daily
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 1
Managers
Engineers
GM
nd When Required
Managers
10
Engineers
Breakdown Management
System (BMS) - Phase 2
partmental HOD
Monday
12
Weekly
nager / Manager
Departmental HOD
As and When R
Departmental
GM
11
GM
l - General Manager
10
en Required
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Manager
14
arge (Engineer)
Weekly
Sr.Manager / Mana
Sectional - General M
13
ger / Manager
12
16
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
Daily
rge (Engineer)
As When Required
As When Require
15
ger / Manager
14
ired - During
n
harges
Monthly Power
Generation Plan
Daily
17
Preventive Maintenance
Planning
rman
16
18
Process In charges
DRM Chairman
Shutdown Review
Meeting
Categories
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
S1:
Compliance
S1:
Compliance
S2:
Understanding
S3:
Usage
OBSERVATIONS
(Based on ACTUAL observations and Interviews, use the following quest
best represent the level of compliance/understanding/usage of
Is the line walk personnel understood the scope or area where he has t
What is the benfit of doing line walk?
Is line walk log sheet is reviewed by HOD?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily Stats sourc
solutions identified prior to meeting commencing?
Is Terms of reference understood by all DRM Members?
Are all members aware of their roles in the meeting?.
Do DRM Members understand the importance of the meeting.?
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documentated action logs is reviewed and points are being cl
Did Template mailed or received on time?
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by Operations
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being filled by Maintenanc
Did you review breakdowns for previous day ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you discussed with your manager on action points based on your
suggestions/message/pending jobs in breakdown slip?
What are the actions taken based on issues like spare information, high
resolution of breakdown etc.
Have all the details related to breakdown are being filled by data feedin
Have all the details related to Breakdown are being correctly filled by th
Did you review the data of breakdowns slip before feeding ?
What benefit is expected by recording breakdowns? Do you think both
should get involved in recording of Breakdown slips?
Please give us reason why breakdown start time plus job start and finis
Demonstrate how you are doing basic Root Cause Analysis by using th
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Whether template is filled completely ?
Whether all the inter departmental jobs are incorporated?
Availability of spares and other critical equipment is done as per job sco
Why do we need to fill the sheet?
Whether all blocks has been completely understood by HOD?
Whether they are aware of how to track the system?
Whether the concerned people planning daily jobs as per Schedule?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Whether the information flow became more effective with the template
Has the information helped in taking pro active actions?
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Are you carrying out root cause analysis as per RCA Policy?
Are you maintaning a RCA documentation file? Please show the RCA lo
Does "5 why" format exist and used please show.
What is the need for RCA policy?
Why do we need to Maintain RCA log book. ?
What is the benefit of using 5 Why template ?
Show if any repetitive problem were corrected by using root cause anal
Please provide one example based on last RCA done?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Have you documented the actions and can you link the actions to the im
Whether the Job checking is done as per shut down planning?
Whether the job checking is done by the team formed?
Whether remarks are mentioned against poor quality of jobs?
Whether the team Is aware of importance of job quality checking?
Whether all plans & Checklist has been completely understood by conc
Whether concern people know how to perform PM?
Has the equipment life been improved with this plan?
Has the PM Plan helped in improving MTBF?
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Is monthly generation plan prepared by the department?
Is monthly production plan of SID taken into account?
Is the plan ready on the first working day of the month?
Why do we need to make the monthly generation plan?
Is the power gneration plan has been completely understood by the con
Whether sponge iron department head was aware of the planning?
Has the overall power generation has increased??
Has the monthly generation plan helped in better weekly and daily pow
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Was the generation plan on track??
Did meeting start on time? Are all members reached at time?
Is Terms of reference & Agenda is prepared and followed?
Was the necessary pre-work done by participants i.e. Daily work done ,
Were actions, responsibilities and due dates assigned on the Action Pla
Have you used the system to achieve the KPI's?
Were the documented action logs is reviewed and points are being clos
AUDIT BY
AUDIT DATE
Rating Scale
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
0
(NIL)
1
(PARTIAL)
3
(HIGH)
7
18
TOTAL COMPLIANCE
TOTAL UNDERSTANDING
TOTAL USAGE
16-May-15
REMAR
.
3
Not re
0
Not re
0
Not Re
0
Not a
0
Not a
0
88%
100%
88%
REMARKS
ot mentioned in sheet
Not required
Not required
Not Required
Not audited
Not audited
ACTION PLAN
(Key in the required action that needs to be taken to address issues - th
must be done for System Elements with a yellow or red scores)
N
taken to address issues - this
th a yellow or red scores)