Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WASTE DISPOSAL
BY THERMAL
OXIDATION
Castable
Refractory
Lining
Stack
Brick Lining W/
Castable Refractory
Back-Up Lining
Thermal
Oxidizer
Waste Stream
Castable
Refractory Floor
Fuel
Combustion Control
Package
Burner
Air
Figure A: Basic Thermal Oxidation
Ideally, the flue gas resulting from high-temperature oxidation of hydrocarbons (HC) contains
CO2 , H2O, N2 , O2 and some acceptable levels of oxides of nitrogen (NOx ) and oxides of
sulfur (SOx). In reality, the flue gas from a combustion process contains CO2 , H2O, N2 , O2
and some concentration of carbon monoxide (CO), unburned hydrocarbons (UHC), NOx and
SOx .
PRODUCTS OF COMBUSTION
IDEAL
REAL
CO 2 , H 2O, O 2, N2 , NO XA *, SO XA *
FG
* Sub A designates acceptable level.
CO2 , H2 O, O 2 , N2 , NOX, SO X
UHC,CO
Environmental concerns require that the flue gas exiting a TO meet certain emission
requirements mandated by local and/or federal regulatory authorities. Thus, it is important not
only to destroy the organic portion of the waste completely, but also to limit the quantities of
pollutants which are produced by the combustion process or were originally in the waste but
not destroyed by combustion. For example, oxides of sulfur and C12/HCI produced by
thermally oxidizing wastes containing sulfontated or chlorinated components must be removed
down-steam. Similarly, inorganic salts or ash contained in the waste are unaffected by
combustion and must be removed to meet particulate emission requirements.
Figure C is an example of how this information is used to determine concentration of UHC and CO
in the flue gas. In this example, we assume methane is being burned with 25% excess air in a
horizontal T.O., having a residence time of 1.0 seconds and operating at a temperature of T2 . Air
injected into the T.O. is in addition to the 25% excess air and is used to lower methanes 3200 F
adiabatic temperature to T2 .
The destruction efficiencies obtained from the graph for CO and HC are 99.88 % and 99.985 %.,
respectively. The heat and mass balance calculations determine flue gas concentrations of 7.1 and
56.8 ppm V (dry) for unburned HC (assumed as CH4 ) and CO, respectively.
EXAMPLE:
What is the concentration of CO and unburned hydrocarbon in the flue gas
when the residence time is 1.0 second and operating temperature is T2 ?
Use air to cool operating temperature to T2 .
CO graph reading = 99.88 %
HC graph reading = 99.985 %
CH
3200 F
Heat Loss
Combustion Air
Horizontal T. O.
Basis 1 mole of CH
CH4 + 2O2
CO2 +
Stoichiometric Air =
125% Air (Burner) =
Flue Gas:
N2
=
O2 =
2H2O
9.52
11.90
9.40
0.50
Stack
( 2/0.21 )
( 9.52 x 1.25 )
( 11.9 x 0.79 )
((11.90 - 9.52) x 0.21)
Figure D is a plot of adiabatic flame temperature, volume percent combustibles and volume
percent oxygen versus percent of stoichiometric combustion air for # 2 fuel oil and natural gas.
The figure indicates a theoretical flame temperature of 3200F when methane is burned with
125 percent of stoichiometric combustion air (25% excess). In the previous example, air was
used to cool the 3200F products of combustion leaving the burner to the TO exit temperature
of T2.
Meeting stringent pollution control regulations governing the amount of inorganic acids (SOx,
NOx, H3PO4, Cl2/HCl) and particulate matter in the exit flue gases requires the use of
additional equipment downstream of the basic TO system. This paper furnishes the reader
with a method of selecting the most appropriate waste disposal process.
WASTE CATEGORIES
Wastes are supplied to a disposal process in the form of either gas, liquid or solid, or a
combination thereof. Thus, wastes can be systematically divided into the categories of gas,
liquid, solid, gas+solid, liquid+solid and gas+liquid. Table 1, Industrial Waste and Pollutant,
lists these categories in the left-hand column. Note the absence of a gas+liquid category. A
gas+liquid waste, both fluids, versus a gas-only or liquid-only waste, requires the choice of an
appropriate burner rather than a process.
The second column lists a typical waste for each category, with the related waste pollutant(s) listed
in the third column. For example, a fume stream which is predominantly air containing
approximately one percent (10,000 ppmV) HC is listed as a gas waste, whereas a biosludge is
listed as a liquid+solid waste. Obviously, this second column does not contain all known industrial
wastes. However, it is likely that a particular waste is sufficiently similar to a listed waste so an
appropriate process can be chosen.
The fourth column is a list of process numbers which identify processes applicable to dispose of
waste listed in the corresponding row. For example, Process 6 is used to treat a gas+solid stream
consisting of CO, H2O and small combustible particulate.
DISPOSAL PROCESSES
The eight similar but separate processes to dispose of industrial wastes are described by the
following text and diagrams.
Gas or Liquid Waste - High Levels of NOx and/or SOx
The following six diagrams illustrate each of the six configurations of a process to dispose of
either a gas or liquid waste which produces a flue gas containing acceptable amounts of SOx
and/or NOx. Configuration 1.1 is simply a T.O. which is supplied with waste, fuel and
combustion air. Fuel is required when the wastes combustion energy is insufficient (endothermic)
to produce an appropriate operating temperature. An exothermic waste requires a cooling medium
such as excess air, steam, or water for temperature control.
WASTE
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
Gas
Liquid
Waste
Air
Fuel
Stack
T. O.
EXAMPLE
Tail Gas Organic
Acid
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOXA, SOXA
FG, NOXA
Steam
Flue Gas
Waste
Air
Fuel
T. O.
Boiler
Stack
Configuration 1.3 shows a T.O. fitted with a gas-to-gas heat exchanger. In the heat exchanger, the
hot flue gas from the T.O. is used to heat the incoming waste gases. This method of heat recovery,
when heating a 60 F waste gas to 800 F with a 1600 F operating temperature, can reduce a
16.8 MM Btu/hr without preheat fuel requirement, to approximately 9 MM Btu/hr.
(Refer to Figure 1A for savings.)
WASTE
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
Gas
Liquid
Waste
Air
Fuel
T. O.
H. Exchanger
Stack
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0
200
400
600
W aste Preheat Tem p (F)
800
1000
1200
Configuration 1.4 is a T.O. fitted with a gas-to-gas exchanger and a heat recovery boiler. The heat
exchanger heats incoming combustion air or waste gases, and the boiler further extracts the heat
available in the flue gas discharged from the exchanger. This configuration offers flexibility in the
amount of steam produced versus fuel usage.
WASTE
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
Gas
Liquid
Waste
Flue Gas
Air
Fuel
T. O.
H. Exchanger
Boiler
Stack
Configuration 1.5 illustrates a Catalytic Oxidizer fitted with a gas-to-gas exchanger. The
heat exchanger preheats contaminated air which is routed to chamber containing catalyst
material. The catalyst causes oxidation of the HC to occur at much lower temperatures than
in a thermal oxidizer, thus greatly reducing the fuel usage. The HC content of the air is
generally limited to less the 0.75 % because of temperature limits of the catalyst.
WASTE
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
Gas
Liquid
Contaminated Air
Fuel
Catalytic Oxidizer
H. Exchanger
Stack
Configuration 1.6 displays a regenerative oxidizer which uses refractory packing to absorb and
transfer heat to the outgoing or incoming air stream. Inlet and outlet ductwork, valves and an
induced draft blower provide the means for the contaminated air to enter and exit the chambers
independently. The paths of flow are controlled by action of inlet and outlet valves. HC contents
is usually limited by the lower flammability limit instead of by overall HC concentration.
WASTE
Gas
Liquid
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
T. O.
Chamber No 2
Chamber No 1
Chamber No 3
Contaminated Air
Flue Gas
Purge
Fuel
Stack
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
Gas
Liquid
VCM
PCB
Pesticides
H2 O
Flue Gas
Caustic
Hydrochloric
Acid
Waste
Salt
Effluent
Air
Fuel
T. O.
Quench
Absorber
Caustic Scrubber
Stack
WASTE
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
Gas
Liquid
VCM
PCB
Pesticides
Waste
Steam
Flue Gas
Caustic
H2O
Hydrochloric
Acid
Air
Salt
Effluent
Fuel
T. O.
Boiler
Acid
Absorber
10
Caustic
Scrubber
Stack
When the waste stream is highly exothermic, a cooling medium such as air or water or steam is
added to the T.O. to control the flue gases to the boiler.
Flue Gas
Stack
Make-Up
Caustic
Solution
Scrubber
Salt Solution
Waste Liquid
(Exothermic)
Steam
Absorber
Combustion Air
Acid
Waste Liquid
(Exothermic)
Fuel
T. O.
Boiler
Quench Section
WASTE
Gas
Liquid
Waste
CO2
H2
CO
H2O
N2
EXAMPLE
Tail Gas Organic
Acid
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOXA, SOXA
FG, NOXA
Flue Gas
Steam
Recycle Flue Gas
Air
Fuel
Air
Reduction Furnace
Quench Section
ReOx Furnace
Boiler
Stack
12
WASTE
Gas
Liquid
EXAMPLE
Tail Gas Organic
Acid
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOXA, SOXA
FG, NOXA
Steam
Feed Water
Fuel
Steam
Reduction Furnace
ReOx Furnace
Boiler
Stack
13
WASTE
Liquid
EXAMPLE
Chlorinated Amine
CO2
H2
CO
H2O
N2
Waste
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, Cl2/HCl, NOX
Flue Gas
Steam
H2O Or
Caustic
Fuel
Air
ReOx Furnace
EXAMPLE
LIQUID/SOLID
NaCI SOLUTION
POLYPROPYLENE/CATALYST
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
H2 O
WASTE
FLUE GAS
AIR
FUEL
T. O.
QUENCH
WET SCRUBBER
STACK
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
NaCI SOLUTION
FG, NOXA, PARTICULATE
POLYPROPYLENE/CATALYST
FUEL
ESP
FLUE GAS
WASTE
INJECTION
AIR
THERMAL OXIDIZER
600 F
AIR
AND / OR
H2O
DRY SALT
OR 350 F
BAG HOUSE
CONDITIONING
TOWER
STACK
DRY SALT
EXAMPLE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
NaCI SOLUTION
FG, NOXA, PARTICULATE
POLYPROPYLENE/CATALYST
FUEL
FLUE GAS
ESP
WASTE
INJECTION
AIR
THERMAL OXIDIZER
WATER
AIR
AND / OR
H2O
350 F
DRY SALT
STEAM
BOILER
OR
BAG HOUSE
CONDITIONING
TOWER
SaltMaster TM
DRY SALT
SALT SOLUTION OR SUSPENSION
STACK
Figure 5A is a schematic of a down-fired salt system with a wet particulate removal system
(High Velocity Scrubber). Alternatively, a venturi scrubber may be used. The schematic shown
in Figure 5B is of a down-fired salt system with heat recovery.
Natural Gas
Thermal Oxidizer
Vent Stack
Quench
Pot
Mist Eliminator
Make-Up Water
High Velocity Scrubber
Combustion
Air Blower
Acid or Salt
Solution or
Suspension
Make-Up Water
Vent Stack
Recycled Gas
Thermal Oxidizer
Recycled Gas
Boiler
Conditioning
Tower
Steam
Salt Solution
and / or
Suspension
Economizer
BagHouse
Make-Up
Water
Salt Master TM
Combustion
Air Blower
Dry
Salt
Soot Blowers
Waste Containing Combustible Fine Solids Acceptable Levels of NOx and/or SOx
The following two block diagrams show configurations of a process to dispose of a waste-containing
combustible fine solids (less than 500 microns particle size), which produces flue gas containing
acceptable amounts of SOx and/or NOx.
Configuration 6.1 consists of a cyclonic T.O. in which a high radial gas velocity causes the denser
solid particles to be preferentially slung to the wall, thus markedly increasing their retention time.
WASTE
GAS / SOLID
EXAMPLE
CO + H2/C
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOXA
FLUE GAS
HOPPER
AIR
FUEL
CYCLONIC T.O. STACK
Configuration 6.2 shows a cyclonic T.O. fitted with a heat recovery boiler which produces steam
to lower the flue gas temperature to 350 F.
WASTE
GAS / SOLID
EXAMPLE
CO + H2/C
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOXA
STEAM
FLUE GAS
HOPPER
AIR
FUEL
CYCLONIC T.O.
BOILER
17
STACK
Gaseous Wastes Containing Combustible Fine Solids Acceptable Levels of NOx and/or SOx
The following two diagrams illustrate configurations of a process to dispose of a gaseous waste
containing a combustible fine solid (less than 500 microns) which produces flue gas containing
acceptable amounts of SOx and/or NOx and excessive amounts of particulate.
Configuration 7.1 consists of the following equipment:
A cyclonic T.O.
Either a quench column, which by directly contacting the flue gas with water, cools it to its
saturation temperature; and a wet scrubber which removes the particular matter or a conditioning
tower, which by directly contacting the flue gas with water and/or air cools it to either 600 F to
350 F, depending on the dry particulate removal system selected.
An ESP or baghouse.
An unlined vent stack.
WASTE
GAS / SOLID
SOLID
EXAMPLE
CO + H2/C + ASH
COAL FINES
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOXA,PARTICULATE
FG, NOXA,PARTICULATE
HOPPER
H 2O
Quench
AIR
FLUE GAS
Wet Scrubber
FUEL
Make-Up Water
CYCLONIC T.O.
Conditioning
Tower
ESP
OR
STACK
DRY ASH
350 F
DRY ASH
BAG HOUSE
WASTE
GAS / SOLID
SOLID
EXAMPLE
CO + H2/C + ASH
COAL FINES
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOXA, PARTICULATE
FG, NOXA, PARTICULATE
STEAM
HOPPER
FLUE GAS
ESP
AIR
350 F
DRY ASH
FUEL
DRY ASH
CONDITIONING
TOWER
BOILER
OR
STACK
350 F
Recycled Gas
DRY ASH
BAG HOUSE
CO2
H2
CO
H2O
N2
EXAMPLE
MELAMINE SLURRY
DNT CELLULOSE
PRODUCTS OF OXIDATION
FG, NOx
FG, NOx
FLUE GAS
STEAM
RECYCLED GAS
AIR
FUEL
AIR
CYCLONIC REDUCTION
FURNACE
QUENCH
T.O
BOILER
STACK
Recycle flue gas cooling is an integral part of the process to minimize NOx formation and
maximize heat recovery.
19
SUMMARY
The description of pollutant control processes found in this paper is a tool which can be used
to identify the basic process needed to destroy pollutants in various types of waste streams.
Although this cookbook approach is a simplified version of the real world method of
specific equipment selection, it provides a good general understanding of what process is
best-suited for the destruction of various pollutants found in todays industries.
20