Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
Abbreviation
Adv
Amm-N
Anthro
B.A.
B.Sc
Bhd
BOD
BW
CAN
COD
dbh
Dev
Dip
DO
DOE
E
ECD
EIA
Env
FCC
FMU
GIS
Gn
GPS
ha
Hons
ICSB
INAWQSM
ITP
JV
K
Kg
Km
LFC
m
M.
M. Sc.
Med
Mgmt
N
NBT
NEP
NFM
NO3-N
O&G
OH & S
Pdct
PhD
PRA
Advance
Ammoniacal Nitrogen
Anthropology
Bachelor of Arts
Bachelor of Science
Berhad
Biological Oxygen Demand
Benta Wawasan
Cultural, Adventure and Nature
Chemical Oxygen Demand
Diameter Breast Height
Development
Diploma
Dissolved oxygen
Department of Environment
East
Environmental Conservation Department, Sabah
Environmental Impact Assessment
Environment
Faecal Coliform Count
Forest Management Unit
Geographical Information System
Gunung (Hill or mountain)
Global Positioning System
Hectare
Honours
Innoprise Corporation Sdn Bhd
Interim National Ambient Water Quality Standards for Malaysia
Industrial Tree Plantation
Joint Venture
Potassium
Kampung (Village)
Kilometre
Luasong Forestry Centre
metre
Master
Master of Science
Medicine
Management
North
North Borneo timber Bhd
New England Power Plant, United States of America
Natural Forest Management
Nitrate Nitrogen
Oil and Grease
Occupational Safety and Health
Production
Doctor of Philosophy
Participatory Rapid Appraisal
Abbreviations
CKSB
CK/0303/246/00
Abb - i
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
RBJ
RIL
RM
SAFODA
Sc.
Sdn
SEIA
SFD
SFI
SFM
Sg
Socio.
spp
SSB
STD
SUAS
TCC
TDS
Temp
TOC
TOR
TPFM
TSP
TSS
USA
Vet
VJR
WD
WWF
x
YS
Abbreviations
CKSB
CK/0303/246/00
Abb - ii
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.
2.
INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................. 1
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
PROJECT DESCRIPTION.................................................................................................... 5
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
P ROJECT STATUS............................................................................................................. 7
2.5
2.5.1
2.5.2
2.5.3
2.6
3.
4.
2.6.1
2.6.2
SCOPING ACTIVITIES........................................................................................................ 9
3.1
P URPOSE ........................................................................................................................ 9
3.2
3.3
3.3.1
3.3.2
3.3.3
Wildlife.....................................................................................................................11
3.3.4
3.3.5
General Pollution.......................................................................................................12
3.3.6
Land-use...................................................................................................................12
4.1.1
4.1.2
4.1.3
Flora Ecology............................................................................................................17
4.1.4
Socio Economics........................................................................................................18
4.1.5
4.1.6
4.1.7
Forest Fire................................................................................................................22
Table of Contents
CKSB
CK/0303/246/00
TOC - i
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
4.1.8
4.2
P OSSIBLE M ITIGATING MEASURES FOR THE KEY I MPACTS TO BE S TUDIED AND RECOMMENDED
UPON :
23
4.2.1
4.2.2
4.2.3
4.2.4
4.2.5
Biomass / Waste.........................................................................................................26
4.2.6
4.2.7
Forest Fire................................................................................................................26
4.3
4.3.1
4.3.2
4.3.3
Flora Ecology............................................................................................................28
4.3.4
4.4
5.
Appendices
A
General Definitions
Table of Contents
CKSB
CK/0303/246/00
TOC - ii
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GN. RARA FOREST RESERVES,
TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
1.
INTRODUCTION
These Terms of Reference are for the preparation of a Special Environmental Impact
Assessment (SEIA) for the proposed Sino-Malaysia JV Forest Plantation at Kalabakan and
Gunung Rara Forest Reserves, Tawau District, Sabah. For brevity, the proposed JV Forest
Plantation is known as Proposed Plantation or Project.
The Proposed Plantation covers an area of about 241,400 ha. It is made up of 81,270 ha of
the Sustainable Forest Management Agreement of Yayasan Sabah, and 160,130 ha of the
Tree Plantation and Forest Management Agreement of Benta Wawasan Sdn. Bhd. (BWSB), a
wholly owned subsidiary of Innoprise Corporation Sdn. Bhd (ICSB)1. (See Figure 1.0).
The Proposed Plantation is located in Kalabakan and Gunong Rara Forest Reserves about
100 km North-West of Tawau District Town. Administratively, the project area lies within the
Tawau District. It is further linked to the Kalabakan District at the Southwestern part.
1.1
In addition, the TOR provides a written framework for the proposed SEIA and allows the SEIA
to proceed in a scheduled manner. Table 1 below illustrates the general procedure of the
Special EIA in Sabah.
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 1
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
Project Proponent
Consult with ECD if the project is a Normal EIA or Special EIA
Step 2: Selection of
consultants
Project Proponent
EIA Consultant
EIA Consultant
Identify and Assess key and additional environmental impacts
Identify and assess key and additional mitigating measures
Identify and assess key and additional monitoring programmes
Step 5: Preparation of
SEIA report
EIA Consultant
Adhere to the ECD requirements and Standard Table of
Contents in the preparation of the SEIA report
Prepare the SEIA report in line with the ECD chapter-bychapter recommendations
EIA Consultant
Submit the SEIA report to the ECD
Undertake the public hearing activities required for SEIA
Participate in the review meetings
Submit additional information if required and finalise the SEIA
report
Step 7: Agreement of
Environmental Conditions
Project Proponent
Review of the draft Agreement of Environmental Conditions
prepared by ECD
Co-sign the Agreement of Environmental Conditions
Implement mitigation measures and monitoring programmes
Source: State Environmental Conservation Department (ECD) Sabah, 2000. Handbook fro Environmental Impact
Assessment (EIA) in Sabah.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 2
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
1.2
Project Background
In 1997, the State Government of Sabah signed a Heads of Agreement with The Peoples
Republic of China and the Lion Group of Companies of Malaysia to set up a pulp mill and
forest plantation in Sabah. This incidentally was an extension of an earlier MOU made
between the Federal Government of Malaysia and China signed in 1996. The Joint Venture
Project was initially proposed in the interior of Kudat District. However, preliminary
investigation showed that this area is less favourable as compared to the proposed project
area.
With the above decision, a joint venture agreement to undertake the development of a forest
plantation in the proposed project area was signed on 18th August 1999 between ICSB,
China Pulp and Paper Industry Company Ltd and Lion Management Sdn Bhd.
1.3
Project Proponent
As mentioned above, the Proposed Project is a Sino-Malaysia Joint Venture between the
Governments of Malaysia (Sabah) Government and the Peoples Republic of China.
The addresses and contact persons of the Joint Venture partners (hereafter refers to as the
Project Proponent, whereby one company will be formed later to manage the project) are:
Innoprise Synergy Sdn Bhd (A Wholly Subsidiary of ICSB)
12 th Floor Wisma Innoprise
Teluk Likas,
88817 Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, Malaysia.
Tel: +60 (088) 326300
Fax: +60 (088) 326529
Contact Person:
Mr. Chiang Wei Chia
Lion Management Sdn Bhd
C/o Sabah Forest Industries
Kompleks S.F.I No. 10 Jalan Jeti
W.D.T. 31 89859
Sipitang, Sabah, Malaysia.
Tel: +60 (087) 801018
Contact Person:
Encik Johari Ho
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 3
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
1.4
EIA Consultant
Chemsain Konsultant Sdn Bhd has been appointed as the Principal Consultants for this
Special Environmental Impact Assessment (SEIA). The address and contact person for
Chemsain Konsultant Sdn Bhd is as follows
Chemsain Konsultant Sdn Bhd
Lot 5, B1-1 and B1-2 , 1st & 2nd Floor
Block B, Iramanis Centre, Jalan Lintas
88450 Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, Malaysia
Tel:+ 60 (088) 381277
Fax:
Contact Person:
The consultants for this SEIA study are listed as below and their curricula vitae are attached
in Appendix B.
1.
2.
3.
Name
Dr. John S.T. Chan
Qualification
PhD Chemistry
B.Sc (Hons) Chemistry
Felicia Choo Phui M. Sc. Env Mgmt & Dev
Eng
B.Sc Agriculture (soils)
Dr. Edwin Jack Bosi
Masters of Philosophy
Report Contribution
Project Director & Water
Quality Management
Project Co-ordinator, soil &
Legislative Review
Fauna Ecology
Dr of Vet Med
Dip. Animal Health & Pdct
4.
5.
Jay Blakeney
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Peter Chang
M.Sc Ocenaography
PhD Geological Eng.
M. Sc. in Geophysics
M.Sc. in Geology
B.Sc. (Hons) Applied
Geology and Slope Stability
Geology
D. Phil. (Oxford),
Forest Entomology
Post grad. Dip. Taxonomy
B.Sc. Hons.
B.Sc. (Hons) Marine Biology & Aquatic ecology
Zoology
T ERMS
CKSB
Flora Ecology
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 4
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
11.
Name
Tan Shwu Mei
12.
Anthony Rentap
Enchana
13.
14.
Zaffeer Ahmad
Kiprawi
15.
16.
Awang Abdullah
Awang Abdul Razak
Lim Sze Fook
17.
18.
Qualification
M. Env. Mgmt
B.A. (Hons) Anthro. & Socio
M.Sc. EIA
Adv Dip Applied Chemistry
Dip. Sc
M. Sc Env. Eng
B.Sc Civil Eng
M. Env Mgmt
B. Sc (Hons) Nuclear Sc
PhD (Filariasis)
Dip Applied Parasitology &
Entomology
B.Sc. (Entomology)
B. Eng (Civil)
B.Sc. (Hons) Physics
Report Contribution
Socio Economy
Land use & Environmental
Management Plan
Waste Management &
Infrastructure
Fire Risk and Emergency
Response Plan
Medical Entomology & Public
Health
International Advisor
2.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
2.1
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 5
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
(RIL) project4 and the Luasong Forestry Centre5 are all located within the proposed plantation
site, but excluded from the Proposed Sino-Malaysia JV Forest Plantation Project (see Figure
1.0).
2.2
Project Objective
The proposed forest plantation at Kalabakan covers an area of about 241,400 hectares (see
Figure 2.0). The main objective of the project is to establish a forest plantation with fast
growing hardwood species such as Acacia mangium, Acacia hybrid (Acacia mangium x
Acacia auriculiformis) and other related Acacia species (Acacia crassiarpa, Acacia
aulococarpa) the raw material source for a proposed pulp mill6. This mill, which is planned to
have a production capacity of 500,000-750,000 tonnes per annum of air-dry Kraft pulp mill will
be situated in Tawau, Sabah.
2.3
Project Concept
The proposed project would be developed through 6 management units called Forest Farms
with approximate sizes of 20,000 60,000 ha each (See Figure 2.0). The planting target is
aimed at 20,000 - 30,000 ha per year with 7 8 years planting rotation. Table 2 below shows
the general sizing of the forest farms.
Table 2: The Proposed Forest Farms within the Proposed Project Area
Forest Farm
Ulu Kalabakan
Maliau
Tamboku
Imbak
Kuamut
Pinangah
Region
9
1
2
6
8
5
3
4
Size (Ha)
35,723
14,113
12,090
13,315
46,575
39,758
27,576
15,240
7
10
Total
15,690
21,320
241,400
35,723
39,518
46,575
39,758
58,506
21,320
241,400
Source: SSB Research Dept Dec 2000, Draft Forest Management Plan Benta Wawasan Forest Plantation 2024 for the
Proposed Project area.
An Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report will be prepared for the proposed mill once the plan is finalized.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 6
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
2.4
Project Status
At the initial stage of the development of the Proposed Plantation, logging will be carried out.
At the time of preparing these Terms of Reference, some of the Project area have been
logged and planted with Acacia mangium. Currently, about 1,400 ha of the proposed project
site (Coupe 1998) have been planted with Acacia mangium.
An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the Proposed logging Operation for Benta
Wawasan Licence Area (1998-1999) at Kalabakan, Tawau District has been submitted to the
Environmental Conservation Department in February 2001 for approval (see Figure 3.0).
As for logging in coupes 2000-2001, an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the
Proposed Logging Operation for Benta Wawasan Licence Area (coupes 2000-2001) at
Kalabakan, Tawau District (see Figure 3.0) was submitted in June 2001.
2.5
Project Activities
With the proposed development, it is envisaged that planning of development phasing,
scheduling and coordination of the general operation will be carried out in details to ensure
smooth execution. The followings are some of the key activities anticipated:
2.5.1
2.5.2
Land preparation;
Operation Phase
Silvicultural treatment;
Plantation harvest;
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 7
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
2.5.3
Abandonment Phase
Rehabilitation and enrichment programme (in case the project were abandoned due
to unforeseen circumstances).
2.6
2.6.1
SUAS Project (3,300 ha) is located in the southwest corner of the proposed forest
plantation project;
INNIKEA Project (14,300 ha) is sited in the centre of the proposed forest plantation
project;
Luasong Forestry Centre (LFC) and its water catchment area (16,230 ha) is also in the
centre of the proposed forest plantation project;
RBJ/NEP RIL Project (1,685 ha) is located south of the INNIKEA Project and close to
the southern boundary of the proposed forest plantation project;
Brantian-Tatuid Virgin Jungle Reserve (4,140 ha) is located to the south eastern part of
the proposed forest plantation project; and
Ulu Sg Nagapon Virgin Jungle Reserve (523 ha) is located directly to the north of
INNIKEA Project area.
Sabah Softwoods Berhad (60,618 ha) is sited to the south and southeast of the
proposed forest plantation boundary;
Maliau Basin Conservation Area (58,840 ha) is situated to the east; and
Danum Valley Conservation Area (43,800 ha) is situated to the northeast of the
proposed forest plantation.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 8
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
In terms of hydrology, the area is located on the headwaters of major rivers including Sg.
Kalabakan, Sg. Brantian, Sg. Kuamut, Sg. Anjeranjermut, Sg. Tiagau and their tributaries,
which discharge into the Cowie Bay.
The project area is sparsely populated. The only settlements within the site are logging
campsites. During the initial field survey, approximately 15 logging camps with an estimated
total population of about 900 people were found scattered throughout the Project area.
In terms of land tenure, both the two licence agreements, the Tree Plantation and Forest
Management (TPFM) of Benta Wawasan Sdn Bhd (160,130 ha) and the Sustainable Forest
Management (SFM) of Yayasan Sabah (81,270 ha) where the Proposed Project Area is sited
have a land tenure agreement of 99 years (See Figure 1.0).
2.6.2
3.
SCOPING ACTIVITIES
3.1
Purpose
The purpose of scoping is to determine the focus, scope and content of the environmental
impact assessment and initial assessment of the potential impacts, possible mitigating
measure and monitoring programmes and thereby to a large extent determines the framework
for this EIA.
One of the scoping activities undertake by the consultant has been to look into the existing
forest plantations in Sabah such as the SFI (35,075 ha) 7 and the SAFODA (25,524 ha) 8
Plantations and evaluate the environmental problems encountered by these projects and use
these as an indicator for the assessment of this proposed Sino-Malaysia JV Forest Plantation
project.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 9
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
3.2
3.3
3.3.1
3.3.2
The forests are mainly lowland Dipterocarp forests with some of the hilltops reaching
the Lower Montane Forest belt. Typically, these forest types are extremely rich with
a large variety of species and where naturally all size classes would be represented
if the area had not been logged.
Some of the project areas have been logged during the early 1970s, 1980s and
1990s.
The residual forest is relatively poorly stocked with commercial trees. This is
especially prominent at lower elevations, which therefore presently are uneconomical
to log.
Residual forests at higher elevations, steeper slopes and in the riverine reserves are
richer in species composition and contain larger commercial volumes.
Pioneer species dominate severely damaged logged over forest as well as forest that
suffered fire in the 1980s.
Old skid trails (or main skid trails) have been rehabilitated prior to logging and the
maintenance of these skid trails is noted to be of reasonably good standard.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 10
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
3.3.3
3.3.4
There is no immediate evidence of marking for the riparian reserve or steep area in
the logging areas. Such marking has either not been carried out or has been of
insufficient quality.
Some extraction roads are noted to be constructed on steep slope with more than
25 o gradient.
Most of the smaller streams or waterways are noted to be blocked by felled logs or
debris.
Temporary crossings and stream crossings have been constructed using rejected
logs.
No control measure such as cover crop is presented in the planted area especially in
the erosion prone areas.
Wildlife
Evidences of wildlife activity are noted especially to the north and east of the project
site.
The species noted or reported to be found include the Sumatran rhino (Dicerorhinus
sumatrensis), Elephant (Elephas maximus), Orang Utan (Pongo pygmaeus),
proboscis monkey (Narsalis narvatus), sun bear (Helarctos malayanus), clouded
leopard (Neofelis nebulosa), Tembadau (Bos javanicus), barking deer (Muntiacus
muntjac), mouse deer (Traganus sp.), wild boar (Sus barbatus), hornbills (Buceros
sp), Gibbon (Hylobates muelleri) and Argus pheasant (Argusianus argus).
Abandoned Orang Utan nests were noted in the eastern part of the project area.
Hunting of wildlife (wild boar, deer, pheasant, monkey) is noted to be a norm among
the workers, the contractors and the nearby settlers.
Only one illegal settlement or Kg Harapan Baru Mukandut (former NBT workers
from Kuamut area) is found within the Kalabakan Forest Reserve (i.e. within the
Luasong Forestry Centre and this Centre is excluded from the Sino-Malaysia JV
Forest Plantation Project development).
All the logging camps have reported Malaria cases and other communicable
diseases.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 11
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
3.3.5
3.3.6
Clean drinking water is reported to be one of the problems among some of the
logging camps and their workers.
Almost half of the workers (from the subcontractors) are foreign workers (the
Philippines Philippinos and the Indonesian).
Some of the workers are reported to have little or no formal training in terms of heavy
machinery, equipment handling or correct tree felling techniques.
Most of the workers are not aware of the Wildlife Enactment, Environmental
Conservation Enactment or any other relevant, Sabahan legislation.
Many small sub camps are found scattered in the logging sites causing damages to
the forest ecosystem. These are also potential pollution sources.
Most of the logging camps have poor sanitary or living condition and poor
housekeeping except for a few established and some mobile (container) logging
camps.
There is no report of any cultural or historical site within the project boundary.
Basic utilities and facilities in Luasong Forestry Centre, Brumas Camp of Sabah
Softwoods Bhd and Danum Valley Conservation Area are modern and adequately
provided for its workers.
General Pollution
No proper instruction seem to have been given on how to contain used oil or to
attempt to clear up any spillage of oil and greases onto the ground or waterways
from the workshop or other service areas.
Dust pollution is a common occurrence for all the roads especially during dry
weather.
Land-use
Substantial areas surrounding the proposed plantation area have been opened up for
oil palm plantations and other industrial tree crops especially to the southern region
of the project site.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 12
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
4.
4.1
b)
c)
Flora Ecology
d)
Socio Economics
e)
f)
g)
Forest Fire
h)
4.1.1
4.1.1.1
Soil Erosion
Preliminary ground survey and studies of topographical maps reveal that parts of the project
site are relatively flat to undulating while others are hilly to mountainous. Any development in
the hilly terrain may bring about serious soil erosion problems and thus affect the water
quality in the rivers. With the proposed phased development of 20,000 - 30,000 ha per year,
soil erosion is expected to become a major environmental issue.
One of the methods proposed for soil erosion study will be to analyse the thematic data layers
based on the factors that control erosion i.e. slope, rainfall, vegetation cover, infrastructure
development, permanent streams, catchment boundaries (see Section 4.1.1.3) and intended
land-use. Sites identified to be of high-risk will be further investigated using soil and rainfall
maps. The resulting hazard map will be verified through ground truthing.
For this study, assessment of impacts will be carried out for 2 scenarios, i.e. with local and
with regional perspective. Under the local perspective, the assessment will examine the
buffer zone, riparian reserves, high risk or steep areas, infrastructure l ayout, water catchment
and drainage system (including water intake points, if any). In addition, the assessment will
cover the schedules for logging and planting and the impacts due to wood harvesting and
clear felling during operation phase (harvesting) on soil properties. The evaluation will
examine available technology practiced within Sabah, and nearby regions.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 13
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
On the regional perspective, the assessment will cover the development of 6 Forest Farms
gradually as well as simultaneously, timing and phasing of the plantation development,
catchment areas and clearing phasing. In addition, the downstream impacts of the project, for
example sediment accumulation in Cowie Bay and the river estuaries will also be
determined.
In terms of infrastructure development, the proposed forest plantation will change the existing
natural environment into a well-developed property with infrastructure and facilities such as:
roads, forest nurseries, offices, mechanical workshops, workers housing, fire lookout towers,
log storage and scaling yards, recreational areas, car parks, sanitation and water supply, telecommunication and electricity supply facilities. All these developments would have some
impacts to the environment especially increase in surface runoff if there are sited within the
sensitive or erosion prone area. Impacts will be assessed based on thematic data layering
and appropriate mitigation measures will be prescribed for these infrastructure developments.
4.1.1.2
4.1.1.3
Hydrological Impact
Logging operations and land clearing of any type will inevitably disturb the soil surface and
affect the site hydrology. When vegetation is removed the hydrological cycle is altered as
water that would have been returned to the atmosphere by means of plant transpiration
processes, under undisturbed circumstances, now remains within the soil layer. The impact or
additional volume of water retained, increases approximately in proportion to the amount of
vegetation removed, therefore the greater the amount of vegetation removed, the greater the
hydrological impact. Absence of vegetation also allows a greater proportion of direct rainfall to
reach the forest floor. The additional rainfall and reduced rates of evapotranspiration translate
into increased volumes of water leaving the catchment (ECD, 2001).
When the amount of disturbed and compacted surfaces are high; there will be an
accompanying increase in the fast routing of surface runoff or the storm flow component of
the stream flow. However, most of the additional water drains more gradually through the soil,
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 14
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
contributing to the slower base flow component of hydrological routing. Studies have shown
that if forest roads and skid trails cover more than 12 per cent of the land area being logged,
then there may be significant increases in storm water runoff. Up to 50 per cent of the land
area may be disturbed/exposed during intensive logging operations (ECD 2001).
Although it is popularly reported that deforestation results in an increased incidence of flood,
however, it must also be borne in mind that floods are a natural hazard, particularly in areas
that receive heavy rainfall. The speed at which water runs off into a river system determines
the height and duration of a flood. Again the changes in volume and timing of storm runoff will
be approximately proportional to the extent and amount of reduction in vegetation cover
(ECD, 2001).
Since the headwaters of major rivers such as Sg. Kalabakan, Sg. Brantian, Sg. Kuamut and
their tributaries, which discharge into the Cowie Bay are located within the project area, one
potential impact of the proposed forest plantations is the effect on flood levels and sediments
accumulation in the Cowie Bay and estuaries due to the increase in less impervious areas.
Base on preliminary site investigations, only Sg Kalabakan, Sg Brantian and Cowie Bay are
populated with settlements, hence assessment will focus on impact of flooding and sediments
in these river systems and the Cowie Bay. Hydrological impacts such as flooding frequency
and floodwater surface elevation on these settlements before and after the forest plantation
development will be assessed. For this, hydrological computer modelling will be employed to
transform rainfall to runoff and routing of the runoff through the Sg. Kalabakan and Sg.
Brantian river system. Flood frequency analysis of 10 years return period for before and after
development scenarios will be carried out using either HEC-HMS9 hydrological Modelling
system, Version 1.0 or similar hydrological modelling, as required to create a hydrological
model for Sg Kalabakan and Sg Brantian Catchments. The proposed fieldworks to be carried
out include river profile survey, river flow velocity measurement, water level measurement and
rainfall data. Different development scenarios will be generated reflecting different methods of
land clearing and size of area to be cleared. The models will include an advanced soil
moisture accounting procedure, primarily based on the GREEN-AMPT infiltration model (see
footnote # 9) or similar model as required.
Another impact is the alteration to the natural water flow regime of catchments within the
project area as a result of the development. Significant flow changes can have a direct
9
The system uses hydrologic elements that will be arranged in a dendritic network, and computation will be performed in an
upstream-to-downstream sequence. Subcatchment of Sg. Kalabakan and Sg. Brantian that are located outside of the proposed
project area will be computed in a lumped mode. In a lumped mode, precipitation and losses are spatially -averaged over the sub catchments. Sub catchments that are located inside the proposed project area and that may be affected by the proposed forest
plantation will be computed in a linear-distributed mode. In the linear distributed mode, rainfall is specified on a grid basis, and loss
and excess are traced separately for each grid cell in a sub-catchment. Losses for each grid cell will be determined using the Green
and AMPT infiltration model. Excess will be transformed to direct runoff with the modified CLARK method.
Routing of the runoff through Sg. Kalabakan and Sg. Brantian river systems will be performed using the Kinematic Wave and
MUSKINGUM-CUNGE methods. Standard geometric shapes or cross sections and estimated Manning values will be used in the
computation.
Based on the rainfall storm event with a ten years recurrence interval the response discharge signal of a base model and three
scenarios will be computed for Sg. Kalabakan and Sg. Brantian. The results will be compared with discharge records of historical
rainfall storm events.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 15
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
impact on water quality, aquatic habitat and associated ecology. An estimation of values for
the catchments and routing-reach parameters of the numerical models as mentioned in the
above (see footnote #9) will be estimated based on observed stream flow data, physical soil
parameter etc. River cross sections will be gathered as input parameter for the MUSKINGUMCUNGE methods or similar methods as required. The discharge of Sg. Kalabakan and Sg.
Brantian might be influenced by tides. Therefore, the discharge records will be carried out for
neap and spring tides.
In addition, other hydrological conditions such as characteristics of the catchment area (or
delineation of catchments and the natural drainage pattern of the affected river basin) for
these rivers and water uses will be examined.
4.1.2
4.1.2.1
10
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 16
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
The proposed field investigations include transect lines into particular habitats (based on
vegetation), habitat characteristics, food availability, roosting, breeding and nesting, refuge
areas, species diversity and others. Aerial survey will also be conducted to assess the overall
forest cover and the land uses surrounding the project area. Review of available literature
and consultation with local community or residents and camp work will be carried out to assist
with the field investigation.
4.1.2.2
Aquatic Life
The distribution of aquatic species and biodiversity will be identified through net casting and
trawling (see footnote 11 and 12) and available secondary data. The significance of the
aquatic habitats will be assessed based on information about species diversity and
importance to the fishing industry etc. Potential impact on aquatic life due to the discharge of
sediment loads and pollution during project development will be given due consideration too.
4.1.3
Flora Ecology
The project involves conversion of a large area of natural forest to a monoculture tree crop.
This will result in considerable loss of natural habitat and biodiversity. For this SEIA, the
general diversity of species and their habitats will be identified initially through existing
vegetation maps and satellite imagery. Aerial survey will be carried out to gain a general
overview of the area, selected habitats of ridge tops, logged over sites and rivers. Ground
survey on selected habitats by using logging roads and to assess the existing vegetation in all
the Licenced Area (see Figure 3.0). Surveys along skid trails recording the floristic
composition will also be carried out. A team of flora and fauna specialists will be working
together to enable both teams see the common conservation sites for both plants and
animals.
This study will also look into the impacts due to the establishment of monoculture tree stand
to the natural environment for example the invasiveness of the intended plantation species. It
is envisaged that rich, local biodiversity in the natural forest is bound to suffer a diminution,
simplification and change. Given that the conservation areas of Maliau Basin and Danum
Valley are internationally known for their biological uniqueness, assessment will look into the
protection of these areas.
The existing diversity in habitat types, specific variation and genotypic differences shall be
assessed. Aerial survey is to determine the different habitat types and followed by ground
checks. Line surveys of different sites determine the various species composition.
In terms of Forest plantation management, careful planning of the development phasing and
direction of clearing must be undertaken in order to preserve critical forest areas along water
courses and areas which provide special habitats and migration corridors. e.g. rivers,
streams, springs, salt-licks, limestone formations, etc.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 17
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
As for the proposed management system, the assessment will examine the Interim Benta
Wawasan Management Plan by the Sabah Softwoods Bhd for the Proposed project area on
pests and disease management (see Section 4.1.6), weed management, soil protection and
enhancement, tree establishment and maintenance as well as harvesting. Recommended
actions or considerations will be suggested, where appropriate.
4.1.4
Socio Economics
Socio economic issues of significance are mainly related to human settlement, vector-borne
diseases, source of livelihood (job opportunities), workers safety (occupational and
communicable diseases) and waste management. For this study, mixed methodologies will
be employed for the assessment. These include review of available literature, discussions
with the project-related personnel, participatory rapid appraisal (PRAs) 11 (see Appendix E),
visits and discussions with relevant government agencies and site visits . Based on the
findings, the result will be presented diagrammatically showing all the settlements, base
camps, proposed regional administrative centres, conservation areas, burial grounds,
historical sites (if any), stakeholders aquaculture farms, water-intakes for the villagers,
roads, rivers and air, water and noise monitoring locations.
The main issues relate to plantation establishment such as the followings:
Water Pollution since most of the waterways are noted to be highly turbid and some
are reported to be polluted with domestic waste, it is imperative to determine clean
potable water sources for the future workers as well as for the existing settlements. The
proposed methodology to assess the water quality is in-situ testing (pH, DO, temp) and
laboratory testing of sampled water for BOD, COD, turbidity, TSS, TDS, Amm-N, K, NO3N, oil and grease, pesticides, Total Coliform count and Faecal Coliform count (see
Appendix D for details). The proposed locations are current water intake points,
upstream, midstream and downstream of project area (see Figure 4.0). Visual
observations for any indiscriminate dumping of waste in the base camp and waterways
will also be carried out.
11
Participatory Rapid Appraisal (PRA) is a qualitative research or survey work that seeks to provide in-depth understanding of a
community or situation. It seeks to incorporate/involve local people in the assessment and to reduce the time and costs of
preparation. It is semi-structured and is designed to acquire quickly new information on and about the community lifestyle. Each
PRA group is limited to 5-10 participants, as small groups tend to facilitate the free flow of discussions. The study team presented
the questions/issues in the course of interviews. The atmosphere was informal, resembling a conversation. The interview ot ok
extensive notes that were developed later. A PRA session generally lasted between 1 to 1.5 hours. PRAs focused not only on
project impacts but also on affected person's fear, worries and expectations.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 18
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
Land ownership the same illegal settlement has staked claim to about 500 acres of
land (forest reserve) surrounding their village. With the implementation of this project,
this may bring about some land ownership issues.
12
The use of cast net for sampling of aquatic habitat has been used by many researchers like Inger & Chin 1990, Samat, et. Al 1995, Department
of Fisheries, Sabah and others. Fishes were caught at each station by incidental collecting activity. The use of cast net for sampling provides an
indicator group of fishes at each station particular to that area. This can be used for comparative purposes from area to area.
Cast net provides a sample down the water column giving a range that covers the pelagic as well as the sedentary fishes as the net sinks to the
bottom where bottom fishes are scared out of the substrate. The mesh size determines the sizes of fishes that can be caught thus limiting the
catches to only specific species. This method of sampling is non-destructive as fishes caught can be released after counting. The use of gill net
is more specific as catches are usually confined to pelagic species only. On occasions sedentary species may be caught accidentally. Fish traps
and hook and lines are used by artisan and subsistence fisherman to catch fishes that are for consumption. This method is highly selective as it
depends on the bait and location of fishing.
1 3 This method of sampling is to determine the present catches of the fishing industry operating in the area as an indicator of the richness of the
area in terms of total biomass of the different groups of marine organisms landed. This is determined by the biomass landed per catch effort for
that location.
Catch effort = speed of trawling X width of trawler mouth X total time of trawling.
This method of fishing is the most widely used technique in this area and is a good indicator of the present standing population and composition of
the benthic and sedentary population of fishes in the area. It also covers a relatively large area in one sweep when compared to any other
method such as gill nets, traps, hook and line that are used in the area.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 19
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 20
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
the main settlements (same locations as the air monitoring locations see Figure 4.0)
and this will serve as a reference level in the evaluation of future noise pollution related
to project implementation. This is to gauge the noise level during the peak (day) and offpeak (night) under existing environment and then project the future traffic volume
generation.
4.1.5
Other land use surrounding the project area ICSB operates a few projects within the
boundary of the proposed project area. There are the Luasong Forestry Centre, the
renowned international collaboration projects namely INNIKEA rehabilitation project
(Rehabilitation of Tropical Rain Forest for IKEA, Sow a seed), Swedish University
Agricultural Sciences (SUAS) project, RBJ/NEP Reduced Impact Logging (RIL) project
and Virgin Jungle Reserves (VJR). The development of the proposed project may affect
these projects through creation of islands and threatening the security and sustainability
of these areas. Based on ground observations, the VJRs in some of the oil palm
plantations have been severely degraded either due to natural dieback or human factors.
For this SEIA, the assessment will look into the history and current status of these
projects or areas and corridors between SUAS, INNIKEA and the LFC.
Cultural or historical site as the proposed site is of significance size, it may have
some historical sites within its boundary. So far, based on available literature and initial
survey and interviews with the locals, the area is void of any significant historical site.
Nevertheless, the study will look into the potential of such historical or cultural sites
through survey along the major riverines, interviews with the local communities,
consultation with the Museum Department and review of literature.
Biomass / waste
It is envisaged that significant amount of vegetative waste will be generated during the land
clearing. Method of disposal will be considered in views of the previous fire and haze
situation in the State. The potential fire hazard and as well as potential pest breeding ground
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 21
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
if the biomass were to be naturally degraded, will also be examined. Assessment will also be
undertaken in relation to the disposal of domestic waste and sewage as well as the usage of
agro-chemicals during the operation phase of the plantation.
4.1.6
4.1.7
Forest Fire
This SEIA, evaluation will cover the risk of forest fire to the proposed plantation and its
surroundings. Uncontrolled forest fire is a serious risk in forest plantations. The assessment
will look into the proposed forest management plan and the proposed development phasing.
The evaluation will emphasize fire prevention strategies consistent with contemporary
philosophy on the management of risk. Assessment will also examine the risk of forest fire
from the nearby plantation to th e proposed project area and vice versa.
4.1.8
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 22
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
4.2
4.2.1
4.2.1.1
4.2.1.2
Suggestion of rehabilitation of old skid trails, if possible, and construct appropriate road
sizes follow ing JKR standard and forest requirement;
Suggestion of appropriate drainage size design and intensity according to local soils
condition and topography;
Hydrology
The following are some of the potential mitigating measures that will be recommended for the
hydrological impacts. Other recommendations will be suggested depending on the outcome
of the assessment.
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 23
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
4.2.2
4.2.2.1
4.2.2.2
Terrestrial Ecology
Establishment of riparian reserves along all waterways and green belts between
INNIKEA, SUAS, NEP/RJB - RIL and LFC projects;
Development phasing or directional clearing (escape path for wildlife during land
clearing);
Aquatic Life
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 24
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
Establishment of buffer belts for all the VJRs and ecologically sensitive area;
Establishment of green belts for genetic exchange and also as fire breaks and buffer
zones for invasive plantation species like the Acacia mangium14;
Establishment of exclusion zone for development especially in the steep area and
riparian reserves;
Enabling the protection of rare and endangered species especially the protected
species listed in the Forest Enactment 1968 and the Wildlife Conservation Enactment,
1997; and
Supporting public health programme and draw awareness to the screening of Malaria
and other communicable diseases especially for the foreign workers;
Establishment of basic safety gear or wear requirement for highly risky job;
14
Acacia mangium trees like other secondary species e.g. Macaranga are very aggressive as they can tolerate very degraded
habitats where primary forest species have difficulty of establishing fast. Thus when an area is disturbed the indigenous secondary
forest species will colonise the disturbed site gradually but if there are Acacia trees present the seeds easily dispersed by birds will
be brought into the site and germinate fast and owing to their numbers they form a carpet and will over dominate the local species.
Once it establish itself its rapid reproductive cycle and abundant flowers and fruits will form a source for moving into any disturbed
areas. It must be noted that each tree produces large quantity of small seeds. The seeds are covered with hard testa that can
survive for years in the ground (seed bank) waiting for the opportunity of a clearing to be formed and germinate fast to dominate.
The seeds are also resistant to fire thus form the most persistent tree cover in a burnt area. Its aggressive habit is shown by its
ability to spread along the road all the way to Mt. Kinabalu National Park Headquarter.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 25
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
4.2.5
Biomass / Waste
The key possible potential control measures that may be recommended for biomass and
waste management are as follows. However, other suggestions will be considered upon
completing detailed assessment of the project.
4.2.6
Biomass - Zero burning (natural degradation during land clearing); prescribed burning
may be required during the maintenance phase to reduce fire risk in the plantation;
Hazardous / scheduled waste contained and disposed off by authorized handler; and
4.2.7
Maintain green belts to preserve some of the natural ecological balances which keep
insect and disease outbreaks in check.
Use certified seeds and different sources or parental stock seedlings; and
Get approval or clearance from Department of Forestry and Agriculture Department for
imported seedlings.
Forest Fire
The key potential mitigating measures that will be recommended upon for forest fire are as
follows. However, other recommendations may be made depending upon the outcome of the
assessment.
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 26
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
4.3
Regular maintenance of forest ground cover and biomass (potential fuel). For example:
prescribed burning as one of the control measures.
Provide adequate road network and access for fire fighting and general forest
operations.
Compliance Monitoring
The main compliance-monitoring programme to be studied and recommended upon is specific
to the mitigating measures and locality or point which photographic or otherwise to be taken.
The Project Proponent to conduct self-monitoring programme on the work progress and
record keeping on the demarcated area and worked area at regular interval. Large
scale map showing the demarcated and worked areas, pictures as well as GPS
locations as per map and recommendations in the SEIA report are to be included.
The provisions of aerial photograph or satellite imagery by the Project Proponent for
the monitoring requirement and time schedule will be recommended upon.
The contractor to report to the Project Proponent on their work progress and to provide
evidence of the implementation of control measures at their designated work area.
The Project Proponent to conduct regular monitoring for any blockage along the
streams or waterways.
The External Environmental Consultant to prepare and submit the environmentalcompliance report to the Project Proponent and the Environmental Conservation
Department (ECD), Sabah and the frequency will be recommended upon.
The Project Proponent to establish security gates and to keep a record of all incoming
and outgoing vehicles (car, trucks etc) into / from the project area.
The Project Proponent together with relevant Departments to carry out random checks
in all coupes or blocks on security measures such as encroachment of riparian reserve,
sensitive habitat & wildlife corridor etc.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 27
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
Wildlife Department to conduct random checks in all the camps for any keeping of wild
game or birds.
The Project Proponent to conduct regular aerial surveillance & ground checking on
buffer zone, VJR and area concerning development limits. The frequency of the survey
will be recommended upon completion of the assessment.
The Contractors to report to the Project Proponent on the status of workers at least on
a regular interval e.g. quarterly basis;
The Contractors to submit health certificates / medical reports for all foreign workers to
the Project Proponent on a regular interval, e.g. quarterly.
The Contractors to submit report or evidence to show that all workers have basic safety
gears and that the workers are using the safety gears provided.
The Project Proponent and the contractors to provide potable water supply for their
workers.
The Project Proponent to carry out internal environmental audit or random checks in all
the base camps, logging coupes and development blocks for any non-compliance.
The Project Proponent to engage external environmental consultant to carry out water
testing and the samples should be analysed by an accredited laboratory. The duration
for the monitoring will be recommended upon.
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 28
SEIA FOR THE PROPOSED SINO-MALAYSIA JV FOREST PLANTATION AT KALABAKAN AND GUNUNG RARA FOREST
RESERVES, TAWAU DISTRICT, SABAH
4.4
5.
The Project Proponent to engage external environmental consultant to carry out water
testing and the samples should be analysed by an accredited laboratory. The duration
for the monitoring will be recommended upon.
WORK SCHEDULE
The proposed schedule for the SEIA is attached below:
T ERMS
CKSB
OF R EFERENCE
CK/0303/246/00
Page 29