Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
In submerged arc welding process, the understanding of temperature distribution is essential in order to control the
dimension of heat affected zone and to get the required weld bead shape and size etc. Moreover, the temperature profile
is required to estimate the stress distribution in thermo mechanical analysis of the process. In this work, a numerical
solution for moving heat source with Gaussian distribution of heat flux density over the volume of oval shape is
derived using finite difference method. Heat transfer in welded plates during welding from fusion zone to heat affected
zone (HAZ) is assumed to be conductive heat transfer. Convective and radiative heat losses are also considered for
remaining zone of welded plate. With the help of the numerical solution, transient temperature distribution is estimated.
HAZ widths are also measured experimentally. Decent agreements between predicted and experimental values are
achieved.
Keywords: Submerged arc welding, Gaussian heat distribution, Oval heat source, Finite difference method.
1. Introduction
Critical investigation of the transient temperature
distribution is important for maintaining quality of the
submerged arc welding of plates. Temperature history of
welded components has a significant influence on
temperature distribution in the welded plate. Such
transient heat transfer problem having simple
geometries with simplified boundary conditions can be
solved analytically. But many problems encountered in
practice involve complicated geometries with complex
boundary conditions or variable thermo physical
properties, and cannot be solved analytically. In such
cases, sufficiently accurate approximate solutions can be
obtained using numerical method.
Goldak et al. (1984) proposed double ellipsoidal
heat source and the welding problem was analyzed by
ASGARD, a nonlinear transient finite element (FEM)
heat flow program. However, they have not considered
the convective heat loss. A three-dimensional, steadystate thermal model of the GMA welding process with a
moving coordinate framework was formulated by Pardo
and Weckman (1989) and was solved by the finiteelement method. Kumar and Bhaduri (1994) developed
a 3D finite element model to predict the transient
temperature distribution in the work piece for GMA
welding process. Their results were validated with
experimental data. Ohring and Lunt (1999) investigated
the gas metal arc weld pool considering radiation,
evaporation and viscous stress in the deformable free
surface boundary conditions. Sabapathy et al. (2000)
530-1
2. Experiment
A semi-automatic welding machine with constant
voltage and rectifier type power source with a 1200-A
capacity was used to join two C-Mn steel plates as butt
joint. The C-Mn steel work piece (30015020 mm) is
cut and V groove of angle 60o as per the standards are
prepared. The chemical composition of work piece
material is described in Table 1. One mm root opening
is selected to join the plates in the flat position keeping
electrode positive and perpendicular to the plate. The
job was firmly fixed to a base plate by means of tack
welding and then the submerged arc welding was finally
carried out. The welding parameters were recorded
during actual welding to determine their fluctuations, if
any. The slag was removed and the job was allowed to
cool down. Welding is carried out for the square butt
joint configuration. Temperatures were measured at
different points of the welded plates except welding line
by infrared thermometers (OMEGA SCOPE OS 524E,
temperature range 2482 C, accuracy is 1% or 2 C
whichever is greater, resolution 1 C, response time 10
ms). Finally the welded plate was cut at the center of the
bead to obtain 10 mm wide test specimens. The standard
metallographic process (i.e., metal polishing with a
series of empty sheets and disc polishing using diamond
paste from 5 m down to 0.5 m, was carried out. The
established color etching procedure for steel was
employed to identify different region of the weldment.
An optical research microscope (NEOPHOT-32) was
used for the purpose. With the help of the microscope
HAZ widths were measured.
Table 1 Chemical composition of C-Mn steel
work piece (in weight %)
C
0.18
Sn
0.36
Mn
1.58
P
0.023
S
0.027
S
0.027
Cr
0.06
Ni
0.03
Mo
0.01
Cu
0.04
Al
0.05
Al
0.05
Fe
97.5
530-2
5th International & 26th All India Manufacturing Technology, Design and Research Conference (AIMTDR 2014) December 12th14th, 2014, IIT
Guwahati, Assam, India
3. Theoretical modeling
3.1 Heat source
(7)
2
2
A
A
3
3
Similarly, it is derived that b
and c
(8)
2
2
B
C
Considering a rectangular region in which heat
conduction is significant in the x- and y-z-directions.
Heat is distributed on the welded plates. Let heat density
expression be
q& ( x, y , z , t ) = e
[ ax 2 + ( by 2 + cz 2 ) e mx ]
(2)
(4)
(9)
where, x, y, and z are the position of electrode at time t
and v denotes velocity of the moving heat source. Note
that ax2 in equation (2) is replaced by a(xvt )2 in
equation (9) since the electrode is moving.
T720 C
C p (T ) = 22543T
0.501
(10a)
(10b)
(11a)
(11b)
530-3
T550 C
(12a)
(12b)
T
n
= h (T T ) + (T
4
T ) for t > 0
T
n
= h (T T )
for t > 0
(16)
(14)
(15)
i +1
= (1 6 ) T m , n , o
k (T )
4 k (T )
i
i 2
i
i 2
i
i 2
(T
Tm1,n,o ) + (Tm,n+1,o Tm,n 1,o ) + (Tm,n,o +1 Tm,n,o1 ) (17)
m +1,n,o
k (T )
C p (T )
2 h l
k (T )
T + 2
k (T )
l
k (T )
m , n ,o
T 4 ( T m , n , o i ) 4
i
i
i
i
i
+ (Tm +1,n ,o + Tm 1, n,o + Tm , n +1,o + Tm ,n 1,o + 2Tm ,n ,o +1 )
530-4
5th International & 26th All India Manufacturing Technology, Design and Research Conference (AIMTDR 2014) December 12th14th, 2014, IIT
Guwahati, Assam, India
i 2
q& ( x, y, z, t ) l
(18)
k (T )
As for the regions, GHJIghji, CDEFcdef, and
IJKLijkl can be, respectively, derived as
l
i 2hl
T 4 (Tm,n,oi )4
6 )Tm,n,o +
T + 2
k (T )
k (T )
i
2
q& ( x , y , z , t ) l
i
i
i
i
+ (Tm +1,n,o + Tm 1,n,o + Tm ,n +1,o + 2Tm ,n,o+1 ) +
(20)
k (T )
and
l
i 2hl
T 4 (Tm,n,oi )4
6 )Tm,n,o +
T + 2
k (T )
k (T )
i
2
q& ( x , y , z , t ) l
i
i
i
i
+ (Tm +1,n,o + Tm ,n +1,o + Tm ,n 1,o + 2Tm ,n,o +1 ) +
(19)
k (T )
Tm,n,o
Tm,n,o
Tm,n,o
i +1
i +1
i +1
= (1
= (1
= (1
4hl
k (T )
4hl
k (T )
6hl
k (T )
6 )Tm,n,o +
2 hl
k (T )
T + 2
l
k (T )
T (Tm,n,oi )4
i 2
q& ( x , y , z , t ) l
i
i
i
+ (Tm +1,n ,o + Tm ,n +1,o + 2Tm ,n ,o +1 ) +
(21)
k (T )
2
l C p (T )
6 k ( T ) + hl
(22)
(23)
530-5
Temperature(deg C)
1500
x=110mm,y=15mm
x=110mm,y=25mm
x=110mm,y=35mm
x=110mm,y=45mm
1000
500
0
0
50
100
150
Time(s)
200
250
300
Temperature(deg C)
1500
1000
Estimated data
Measured data
500
0
0
50
100
150
Time(s)
200
250
300
5. Conclusions
To estimate the transient temperature distribution on
welded plate in submerged arc welding process, the heat
source was assumed as oval in shape (oval shape raised
due to heat source and convection in fusion zone) and
thermo physical properties of materials were considered
as function of temperature. Convective and radiative heat
losses were also considered. The experimental
measurement shows that the peak temperature was higher
and the cooling rate was larger for a work piece closer to
welding path with respect to other part of welded plate as
convection heat loss is proportional to temperature
difference between welded plate and atmospheric
temperature. The numerical solution for oval shape heat
source was used to calculate transient temperatures at
selected points on C-Mn steel plates which were welded.
530-6
5th International & 26th All India Manufacturing Technology, Design and Research Conference (AIMTDR 2014) December 12th14th, 2014, IIT
Guwahati, Assam, India
References
Bianco, N., Manca, O., Naso, V. (2004a), Numerical
analysis of transient temperature fields in solids by a
moving heat source, HEFAT2004, 3rd Int. Conf. on Heat
Transfer, Fluid Mechanics and Thermodynamics, Paper
no. BN2, June 21-24, 2004, Capetown, South Africa.
Bianco, N., Manca, O., Nardini, S. (2004b), Two
dimensional transient analysis of temperature distribution
in a solid irradiated by a Gaussian lesser source, Proc.
ESDA2004-58286 7th Biennial Conf. on Engineering
Systems Design and Analysis, July 19-22, 2004,
Manchester, United Kingdom.
Bianco, N., Manca, O. S., Nardini, S., Tamburrino (2006),
Transient heat conduction in solids irradiated by a moving
heat source, Excerpt from the Proceedings of COMSOL
User Conference, November 14, 2006, Milano, Italy.
Biswas,P., Mandal, N.R. (2010), Thermo mechanical
finite element analysis and experimental investigation of
single-pass single-sided submerged arc welding of C-Mn
steel plates, Proc. IMechE, Part B: J. Engineering
Manufacture,Vol.224, pp. 627 639.
Cho, M.H. (2006), Numerical simulation of arc welding
process, PhD Thesis, School of the Ohio State University,
USA.
Elsen, V.M., Baelmans, M., Mercelis, P., Kruth, J.P.
(2007), Solutions for modeling moving heat sources in a
semi-infinite medium and applications to laser material
processing, International Journal of Heat and Mass
Transfer ,Vol.50, pp. 48724882.
Goldak, J.A., Chakraborty, A., Bibby, M. (1984), A new
finite element model for welding heat sources,
Metallurgical Transactions B ,Vol.15B, pp. 299-305.
Kazemi, K., Goldak, J.A. (2009), Numerical simulation of
laser full penetration welding, Computational Materials
Science, Vol.44, pp. 841849.
Klobcar, D., Tusek, J., Taljat, B. (2004), Finite element
modeling of GTA weld surfacing applied to hot-work
tooling, Computational Materials Science, Vol.31, pp.
368378.
Kumar, S., Bhaduri, S.C. (1994) Three-dimensional finite
element modeling of gas metal-arc welding, Metallurgical
Transactions B, Vol. 25B, pp. 935-941.
Lindgren, L.F. (2001), Finite element modeling and
simulation of welding Part-1: increased complexity,
Journal of Thermal Stress, Vol. 24, pp.141-192.
Mahapatra, M.M., Datta, G.L., Pradhan, B., Mandal, N.R.
(2006),Three-dimensional finite element analysis to
predict the effects of SAW process parameters on
temperature distribution and angular distortions in singlepass butt joints with top and bottom reinforcements,
International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, Vol.
83, pp.721729.
Ohring, S., Lunt, H.J. (1999), Numerical Simulation of a
time Dependent 3-D GMA weld pool due to a moving arc,
Welding Journal,Vol.79, pp. 416-s 424-s.
Pardo, E., Weckman, D.C. (1989), Prediction of weld
pool and reinforcement dimensions of GMA welds using
a finite-element model, Metallurgical Transactions B ,Vol.
20B, pp. 937-947.
Sabapathy, P.N., Wahab, M.A., Painter, M.J. (2000), The
prediction of burn-through during in-service welding of
gas pipelines, International Journal of Pressure Vessels
and Piping, Vol.77, pp. 669677.
Scutelnicu, E., Iordachescu, M., Blasco, M., Iordachescu,
D. (2008), Arc welding of dissimilar metals: FEA and
experiments, , Proceedings of the 8th International
Conference on trends in welding research, pp. 241-246,
June 1-6,2008, Callaway Gardens Resort, Pine Mountain,
Georgia, USA.
Yeh, R.H., Liaw, S.P., Yu, H.B. (2003),Thermal analysis
of welding on aluminum plates, Journal of Marine
Science and Technology, Vol. 11, pp. 213-220.
Yeh, R.H., Liaw, S.P., Tu, Y.P. (2007), Transient threedimensional analysis of gas tungsten arc welding plates,
Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A,Vol.51, pp. 573-592.
Khanna, R.M. (1991), Analytical geometry of two and
three dimensions, New Central Book Agency, Kolkata,
WB, pp. 326.
List of Symbols
a,b,c,m
A,B,C
Cp
h
I
k
l
q
Qo
t
T
U
V
x,y,z
530-7
530-8