Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ii
Environmental Environment
NEW
THE
In a recent briefing on eapitol
Hill, sponsored by the anti-Kyoto
Protocol Cooler Heads Coalition,
Lindzen delivered a scathing critique of the IPee process and its
recent "third assessment" climate
science report. The "most egregious problem with the report,"
says Lindzen, "is that it is presented as~a/consensusthat
involves hundreds, perhaps thousands, of scientists and none of
them were asked if they agreed
with anything in the report
except for the one or two pages
they worked on." Lindzen is the
Alfred P. Sloan professor of
meteorology at MIT and a lead
author of the IPee Third Assessment Report.
Lindzen charges that the IPee
process uses summaries to misrepresent what scientists say; uses language that means different things
to scientists and laymen; exploits
public ignorance over quantitative
matters; exploits what scientists
can agree on while ignoring disagreements to support the global
warming agenda; and exaggerates
scientific accuracy and certainty
and the authority of undistinguished scientists.
Most press accounts characterize the IPee report as "a consensus of 2,000 of the world's leading
climate scientists," Lindzen complains, adding that "the emphasis
isn't on getting qualified scientists, but on getting representatives from 100 countries, only a
handful of which do significant
research. It is no small matter that
routine weather service functionaries from New Zealand to Tanza-
May 2001
NEW 5
Foe U 5
awaiian environmentalists
have set back plans by the
Department of Energy to inject
tons of e02 into the sea off the
Kona coast in August, to study
the effects of sequestering excess
e02 in the ocean. Faced with public opposition, the Natural
Energy Laboratory of Hawaii
Authority (NELHA) has voted to
exclude the experiment from its
Kona waters.
The laboratory's board of directors earlier gave preliminary
approval to the experiment, but
the board voted against it this
time because of "concerns about
its scientific merits, legal ramifications, a change in scope, public
opposition, and opposition by the
Keahole Point Tenants Association," said authority executive
director Jeff Sltlith.
Gerard Nihous, the scientist in
charge of the experiment, con- .
ceded, "We have faced a mountain
of public opposition." A "planning
ballet" under way since 1997
would make it difficult to transfer
the $5 million project elsewhere in
the world, he says, adding that
"environmental studies [like those]
of the Kona waters would have to
be started from scratch elsewhere."
The NELHA exclusion applies
only to a patch of ocean at Keahole
Point about two miles wide and
extending about 2.6 miles out to
sea. "The experiment might still be
done in the general area, perhaps
outside the state's three-mile-wide
territorial waters," Nihous said.
THE
According to Nihous, "The
experiment will pump small
amounts of liquefied CO2 to
depths of about 1,000 meters, over
the course of one to two weeks,
two hours at a time, increasing to
7.6 metric tons in two hours."
Nihous said he still holds hope
that the tests can be done on schedule in the fall.
NEW
MEETINGS
U S
ERE
Conference
Date
Place
Sponsor
Contact
June 22-24
Portage County
Fairgrounds,
Amherst, WI
http://www.the-mrea.org
Oct. 21-23
New Orleans, LA
202-508-5000
http://www.eeLorg
Oct. 21-25
Buenos Aires,
Argentina
+54-11-48132219
caddet@caddet-ee.org
THE
an average of more than 1,250 KW
a month, compared with a national
average of 866 KW.
The NRC's operating license for
Browns Ferry 1 is to expire in 2013.
Unit 2's license will expire in 2014
unless TVA is granted an extension. The license for reactor unit 3
is to expire in2016.
TVA saicht will use comments
generated from this week's meeting to prepare a supplemental
environmental impact statement
for its proposal to keep the
Browns Ferry units operating an
additional 20 years. The report is
expected to be completed by the
end of the year.
TVA board members have also
discussed converting the incomplete Bellefonte nuclear plant in
Scottsboro, AL, into a new power
plant. Construction of the $4.6 billion plant was stalled in 1988 when
TVA announced decreased demand
for power and delayed the facility's
construction. Since then, the agency
has said it could not go forward
with construction unless its gets a
financing partner.
Annals of Competition
May 2001
NEW
Foe
U S
Restructuring Notebook
THE
were on the shaky power situation in California.
In February, a task force formed
by Governor Jeb Bush presented
its plan for the first phase of
deregulation, the spinning off of
the industry's power-producing
sector. Throughout the remainder of the ye,U", the group is to
continue studying the state's $13
billion electric industry, and a
more comprehensive plan may
emerge. The initial proposal, now
in legislators' hands, would
require the state's investorowned utilities to sell off their
generating plants to subsidiaries.
It would also permit other power
companies to enter the state,
build new plants, and sell the
power to electric companies.
But as legislative committees
began to debate the proposal from
Bush's 17-member Florida Energy
2020 Study Commission, many
questions remained. Lawmakers
wanted to know what went wrong
in California and how Florida
could avoid similar problems.
They wanted a thorough economic
analysis of the deregulation planone that would show that residential and commercial customers
would benefit from restructuring.
Uncertainty over plant valuation
has led to fissures in the 2020 commission. Although its members
unanimously endorsed the wholesale deregulation plan, several are
having second thoughts about the
power plant issue. "This proposal is
dead on arrival in the legislature,"
said state Sen. Tom Lee, one of the
members of the study, commission.
State Rep. Jeff Miller, head of the
NEW
Foe
U S
THE
sold the remainder of the energy
into the wholesale market.
The state Public Service Commission initially approved the
plant, but in-state investor-owned
utilities (IOUs), including Florida
Power & Light, took the matter to
court. The state court agreed with
the IOUs and ruled that the plant
could not be built because state
law requires that power plants
serve retail, not wholesale, load.
According to the New Smyrna
Beach petition filed with the U.S.
Supreme Court, the Florida court's
ruling violates the supremacy and
commerce clauses of the U.S. Constitution. "The Florida court's decision would empower the vertically
integrated in-state utilities to use
their retail monopoly to severely
limit, or completely foreclose, competition in the wholesale power
market," the city said in its petition.
It was this court case that prompted
Governor Jeb Bush to form the
Energy 2020 Study Commission to
review the state's utility laws.
The U.S. Supreme Court's decision to deny review means that the
Florida Public Service Commission
will now dismiss other requests to
build wholesale power plants,
including one proposed near Port
St. Lucie and another southwest
of Fort Pierce.
May 2001
NEW
Foe U 5
Power, Consumers Energy, Dayton Power & Light, Detroit Edison, Dominion Virginia Power,
and FirstEnergy). The Alliance
covers some 175,000 square miles
in 11 states, with a population of
39.8 million, owning 54,000 miles
of transmission lines.
"We are pleased with the outcome of this proceeding," said
Stan Szwed, FirstEnergy vice president and chairman of the Alliance
management group. "This agreement acknowledges the development of two RTOs with different
business structures in the region,
while addressing seams issues that
THE
on its marginal costs, to be used by
the ISO to establish the real-time
market clearing price when mitigation is appropriate.
Market clearing price. "All
energy offers that are accepting the
real-time market should be paid
the applicable market clearing
price./I
NEW
I N
Foe
U S
THE
most likely operation, acting Bonneville CEO Steve Wright told the
Northwest Power Planning Council, will wipe out the agency's
salmon restoration plans, required
under the Endangered Species
Act (ESA) for normal hydro operation. The warned-of change could
reduce juvenile survival by as
much as 6.5 percent, depending on
the species.
Power production at federal
dams in the Northwest has been
limited by a salmon protection
plan under the ESA that requires
water to be held in storage for
release during spring and summer
fish migrations. The plan also calls
for some water to be sent through
spillways instead of turbines to aid
downstream juvenile migration
and survival. These measures
would reduce federal power generating capacity by over 1,000 MW
during the spring and summer
runoff.
Wright's report said that water
conditions have steadily declined
since January. Bonneville can normally count on an average of 106.5
million acre-feet of water from
January to July. At the time of
Wright's testimony in March, the
January-July forecast was for 58.6
million acre-feet-45 percent
below normal. That's down from a
February forecast of 66.4 million
acre-feet, and a January forecast of
80.4 million acre-feet.
Wright said it is possible that less
than 52.7 million acre-feet of rain
and snow could fall in the Columbia Basin this year, which would
make this the driest year since
1929, when record-keeping began.
May 2001
NEW
Foe
U S
~~'
T
Submission
Guidelines
Editor-in-Chief
The Electricity Journal
6830 Rosewell Lane
Suite 300
New Albany, OH 43054
Please include three (3) hard copies of the text and graphics with
your submission, a floppy disk in Word, as well as complete biographical and contact information for all the authors. Please contact
RCohen8114@aol.com with any questions on these guidelines or for
information on themes planned for upcoming issues of the Journal.
10