Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AND IDENTIFICATION
IN THE NETWORK SOCIETY
THE IMPACT OF NEW MEDIA
ON INTERCULTURAL
COMMUNICATION
Risk, language
identification
in the network society.
ANA and
MARIA
MUNTEANU
The impact of new media on intercultural communication
AIDA TODI
CONSTANTIN IOAN MLADIN
RISK, LANGUAGE
AND IDENTIFICATION
IN THE NETWORK SOCIETY
THE IMPACT OF NEW MEDIA
ON INTERCULTURAL
COMMUNICATION
EDITURA UNIVERSITAR
Bucureti
3
Colecia FILOLOGIE
Copyright 2011
Editura Universitar
Director: Vasile Muscalu
B-dul. N. Blcescu nr. 27-33, Sector 1, Bucureti
Tel.: 021 315.32.47 / 319.67.27
www.editurauniversitara.ro
e-mail: redactia@editurauniversitara.ro
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION .......................................................
15
17
29
30
32
Bibliography .............................................................
35
41
44
51
63
70
Bibliography .............................................................
84
93
93
Introduction
In post communist countries the media coverage of
changing processes has frequently been reduced to the
theatrical production of the truth behind the disease1:
corruption, mentalities, political, administrative inefficiency, etc., and this dramatization of politics has
emphasized the difficulties encountered by the European
project (a complex idea correlated with legal instruments
and structural adjustments) competing against the
conflicts of interests of the media corporations, thus the
positive effects of the EU integration have passed
unnoticed2, being obscured by media sensationalism by
conflicts and scandals, simulacra of a real public debate
area. In this context of crisis, the youth have been
massively drawn towards the Internet, a real imaginary
in-between space, where the constraints of the everyday
life, the disintegration of the authority or the gap between
words and realities are suspended. The voice of young
people from former communist countries made a distinct
mark among critical opinions on globalization in the
1
10
11
13
14
Part I
LANGUAGE AND SOCIETY IN THE
GLOBAL TECHNOLOGICAL AGE
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
20
22
23
24
25
ritualized through ephemeral discussions. This phenolmenology of the communicative behaviour covers the
double edged issue of standards: they faces the social
facticity but like a leverage tool to meet order and justice
in everyday life situations to a certain extent shaped by
the influence of the networks and the users attitude
towards language.26
The semiotic mapping the level of culture
redistributes, "rearranges" the cognitive elements by
production and reading of personal narratives, selected
and presented as they express exemplary (vicarious)
experiences and routes. This level the culture of
existential change and the crisis that accompanies it
reflects the social and national identity crisis, as liminality
(in the sense of social crisis, especially in the van Gennep
-Turner model27), a passage rite ich is practiced in
interpersonal communication in the online space - from
the lack of horizon of the life "back home" to regaining the
self in a new career, job, etc. in Western countries. The
crisis moments succeed one another in stories, they
create a common pattern with a symbolic function as well,
26
26
27
29
30
30
31
33
34
39
40
41
43
40
44
45
46
47
47
48
49
50
55
Marcoccia.
GRIMM-GOBAT.
57
See for Romanian language: ARMANCA, BOICEA,
CPLESCU, CINTEC, COLTUC DINIC, CONSTANTINOIU,
DRAGOMIR, LIMBA ROMN, LIMBAJUL IRC, LIMBAJUL
SMS, MATIE, MIHILESCU, MOISE, PDURARU, CHIOP,
SMS-UL, ULMANU, VORBII MESAGEREZA, VORBII
MESENGEREZA.
58
On the same topic see, also: FERENCZ, GROSSECK
NEGRU, MLADIN 2005, MLADIN 2005a, MLADIN 2009b,
MOISE, POMIAN, URUCIUC, VLAICU.
56
51
LANDROIT.
DORZE.
61
DACOS.
62
Obviously the number of recurring deviations
approximations / clumsiness / lexical, orthographic, grammatical
- morphological and syntactic, stylistic slippages are
increasing. However, not only the young but the adults, even
teachers, use the texting language forms.
63
CASTELLS, p. 127-169.
60
52
53
54
56
57
58
68
Anis 2002.
60
61
Consulted on 3aug.2011.
63
of
use,
accessing
70
64
71
65
69
71
http://abc-netmarketing.com; http://kitten.joey.free.fr/Communicate/
Regles
74
See also Krassimira Petrova, 2001: Emoticons in on-line
communication, in Slama-Cazacu, T. (ed), Human and Computer.
Verbal communication and interaction via computer, Constanta,
Europolis, p. 141-149.
73
http://fr.messenger.yahoo.com/emot.html; http://tchateuses.free.fr/
smiley.htm; etc.
76
http://www.fr-dawson.com/chat.htm; http://web.icq.com/;
http://www. ploiesti-chat.org/reguli;
http://chat.net4u.ro/regulament.html;
http://tchat.voila.fr; http://www/fr-dawson.com/chat.htm;
http://www.abc-netmarketing.com/article;
http://kitten.joey.free.fr/Communicate/Regles;
74
75
Time
Content
Behaviour
78
Positive elements
Disturbing elements
that contribute to
that interrupt the dialogue
maintaining dialogue
pleasant manner of inappropriate attitude and behavior
approach, appropria- -vulgar language (most common
te mode of exprecause), lying, hiding intentions,
ssion, communicatend partner invasion of privacy
tive orientation of
excessive insistence partner in
both partners
finding the details, attitude, appearance, illiteracy, lack of respect
common subjects of
exhaustion topics conversation,
conversation and
suddenly changing the subject,
hobbies affinities and
boredom occurs sometimes in
similarities of
conversation
behaviour common
interests, commun
friends
time availability
lack of time
http://www.coupdepoucepc.com/modules/freehtml/?page=chat.htm
76
77
Some basic parenting tips for parents with a child on the Internet, in
http://members.tripod.com/~ComputerLab/chat2.htm.
79
80
the
texting
language
(the
cyberl@nguage / cyber-writing) need to be approached
as a process of radical change in relation to a given
medium. This interdependence generates an entirely new
language that raises a number of issues and aspects,
difficult to be parameterized (because of its many
variations and transient circumstances), since it is pushed
and pull by the technological environment to find effective
solutions simultaneously: (1) to meet the standard (in
order to fulfill its function of communication), (2) to cope
with physical difficulties imposed by a specific contexts,
(3) to be permeable to the fashionable trends stimulated
by the design of the digital networks, by the marketing
campaigns and the ways in which the texters themselves
use the facilities as well as the limits of the new technical
devices. At the same time, there is a convergence
between the modes of communication mentioned above
which can be explained by: (1) the time pressure which is
81
common, (2) the nature of their content mainly emotionnal and relational than logic (3) the social dimension
(users belong to a group sharing common cultural
values).
If the evolution of the language as a part of social
order reflects a relationship between language and power
(economic / political / social / cultural power(s)81) then the
interdependence between language and the communication technology need to be nuanced and even
methodologically reconstructed in what it follows using an
interdisciplinary framework. Bootstrapping methods and
arguments but mantaining an anthropological perspective
will draw attention to the fact that such massive deviant
forms from the standard language have more than a
technological explanation in terms of facilities and
spacetime reframing but also develop a pivotal force in
terms of sense and topicality. This symbolic power
pushes texters and other users towards a legitime
recoding in the linguistic practices that will make
normalising operations as designed by computation
linguistics more difficult than they appear. According with
Campbell and Parks, the very act of using a mobile
phone involves the simultaneous engagement with more
senses than we use for other computational devices as
we simultaneously touch, hear and see via the mobile
phone in order to keep in touch with our boddies. This
integration with the senses and corporeal attachment
81
82
83
cronica-tv---razboiul-sms-urilor-inculte1_50ac99c97c42d5a6638696c9/index. pdf].
Campbell, Park 2008: Scott Campbell & W. Yong Jin
Park, Social Implications of Mobile Telephony: the
Rise of Personal Communication Society, Sociology
Compass 2/2 (2008), p. 371-387, 10.1111/j.17519020.2007.00080.x.
[http://et2050.eu/Et2050_Library/docs/tech/society/s
ocial_implications_mobile_technology.pdf].
Cplescu 2005: Romulus Cplescu, Telefonul mobil n
slujba tehnologiilor politice, 18 November 2005
[http://adevarul.ro/entertainment/celebritati/telefonulmobil-slujba-tehnologiilor-politice1_50ad4eb57c42d5a66392b1d2/index.html].
Castells 2007: Manuel Castells, Mobile youth culture, in
Manuel Castells, Mireia Fernandez-Ardevol, Jack
Linchuan
Qiu,
and Araba Sey,
Mobile
Communication and Society: a Global Perspective,
MIT Press, p. 135-136.
Cntec 2003: Otilia Cntec, SMS-urile i ortografia, 04. 08.
2003
[http://www.ziarulevenimentul.ro/
stiri2/Tabloid/sms-urile-si-ortografia-29199.html].
Coltuc, Dinic 2006: Daniel Coltuc, Mirela Dinic, Lol
avei idee ce nseamn, in Libertatea, 26 march
2006 [http://www.libertatea.ro].
Constantinoiu 2008: Marina Constantinoiu, Robii SMSurilor, in Jurnalul Naional, 31 april 2008
[http://new.jurnalul.ro/articole/121041/robii-smsurilor].
85
limbajul-adolescentilor-din-generatia-messenger1114801].
Vorbii mesengereza 2011: Vorbii mesengereza ? Ce
faci cnd nu mai nelegi nici mcar ce scrie copilul
tu, 2 June 2011 [http://jurnalul.ro/special-jurnalul/
vorbiti-mesengereza-ce-faci-cand-nu-mai-inteleginici-macar-ce-scrie-copilul-tau-580051.html].
http://abc-netmarketing.com;
http://fr.messenger.yahoo.com/emot.html;
http://kitten.joey.free.fr/Communicate/Regles;
http://members.tripod.com/~tassiedevi/chat.htm;
http://searchwebservices.techtarget.com;
http://support.tiscali.fr;
http://chat.net4u.ro/regulament.html;
http://www.coupdepoucepc.com/modules/freehtml/?page=
chat.htm;
http://tchat.voila.fr;
http://tchateuses.free.fr/langagedunet.htm;
http://tchateuses.free.fr/smiley.htm;
http://web.icq.com/;
http://www.ados.fr;
http://fr.audiofanzine.com/chat/;
http://www/fr-dawson.com/chat.htm;
http://www.noukylinkworld.net/info_dicochat;
http://www.ploiesti-chat.org/reguli;
92
Favell 2008:
93
Mahroum 2000.
Coe, Bunnell 2003.
94
95
86
Metaphors
of
emerging
Contemporary
Migration. National/
International
in
Romanian
Language and Culture
LITERARY
HISTORY AND
CRITICISM
SOCIAL SCIENCE
ANTHROPOLOGY
SECTIONS
2011
YEAR
SHARE OF
PARTICIPATI
ON OF
REPRESENT
ATIVES OF
DIASPORA
(AND R.OF
MOLDOVA) IN
RELATION TO
THE
COUNTRY
26%
Fig.1 Major issues, dilemmas and questions addressed in the agendas of the conferences
86
organized by the Romanian Academy Iai the Institute of Romanian Philology Al Phillipide) ,
Ana Maria Munteanu, Aida Todi, Constantin Ioan Mladin
Romanian Culture
and
Identity.
Present-day
tendencies
as
reflected in the
Romanian
Diaspora
Workshop:
Linguistic,
literary
and
ethnologic
lexicography
in
European Context
The
Romanian
Cultural Diaspora
linguistic,
literary
and ethnofolkloric
paradigms Workshop:
Cultural
2010
2009
LACK OF
DATA
26%
LINGUISTICS
ANTHROPOLOGY
96
2007
2008
97
Romni majoritari/
romni minoritari:
interferene
i
coabitri lingvistice,
literare i etnologice
Contemporary
circuits, practices
and
meta-morphoses
of
Romanian
migration
Distorsions
in
Romanian
linguistics,
literature
and
ethnofoklore in the
context
of
the
integration process
35%
23%
LINGUISTICS
ANTHROPOLOGY
LITERARY
HISTORY
2005
2006
INTERCULTURAL
COMMUNICATION
AND EUROPEAN
INTEGRATION
ROMANIAN
IDENTITY
IN
EUROPEAN CONTEXT
Lack of data
34%
98
LANGUAGE AND
COMMUNICATION
ETHNOLOGY
IDENTITY
LITERARY
CRITICISM
LINGUISTICS
99
LITERATURE AND
COMMUNICATION
100
2004
Spaiul lingvistic i
literar
romnesc
din
perspectiva
integrrii europene
51%
LINGUISTICS
LITERATURE
ANTHROPOLOGY
ROUND- TABLE
CULTURAL
DIALOGUE
ETHNOLOGY
101
102
Todi 2009.
103
www.cotidianul.ro.
106
framing issues related to Romanian language. Participants' interest did not focuse on the correctness of the
written language as illustrated by the article (probably
because thats assumed that the author must be a
competent person in question), but with the purpose to
add and complete with examples providing from personal
findings and experience.
In the article-report How is distorted spoken Romanian language on radio and TV.?" (Cum se mai stlcete
exprimarea la radio i TV. Limba romn, victima unei
game largi de perversiuni90) are inventoried a number of
"mistakes and aberrations" collected during the
monitoring lead by a team from the Institute of Linguistics
of the Romanian Academy, in collaboration with the CNA
(Consiliul National al Audiovizualului). The author of the
article points out himself various forms of negligence and
ignorance: pleonasms and clichs, disagreements
between subject and predicate, increased errors or
spelling, the misuse of the relative pronoun, the adverb
"more" misused in the genitive case, the errors in written
short texts displayed on TV screens like comma between
subject and predicate, or incorrect duplication of letters.
Thus, the comment titled Bilingual illiterate refers
primarily to the use of a non-existent word in Romanian (a
colanta to stick a bumper sticker on a car ") but touching
90
http://www.gandul.info/media/limba-romana-victima-uneigame-largi-perversiuni.html.
107
91
108
109
93
110
111
Bibliography
Coe, Bunnell 2003: N. M. Coe1 & T. G. Bunnell,
Spatializing knowledge communities: towards a
conceptualization of transnational innovation networks Global networks, 18 2ept./2003, p. 437-456.
DEX 1996: Academia Romn, Institutul de lingvistic
Iorgu Iordan, Dicionarul explicativ al limbii
romne, ediia a II-a, Univers Enciclopedic,
Bucureti, 1996.
DN 4: Florin Marcu, Noul dicionar de neologisme, Editura
Academiei Romne, Bucureti, 1997.
DOOM 1: Academia Republicii Socialiste Romnia,
Institutul de Lingvistic din Bucureti, Dicionarul
ortografic, ortoepic i morfologic al limbii romne,
Editura Academiei, Bucureti, 1982.
DOOM 2: Academia Romn, Institutul de Lingvistic
Iorgu Iordan Al. Rosetti, Dicionarul ortografic,
ortoepic i morfologic al limbii romne, Ediia a II-a
revzut i adugit, Univers Enciclopedic,
Bucureti, 2005.
Favell 2008: A. Favell, The New Face of East West
Migration in Europe, Journal of Ethnic and Migration
Studies, Vol. 34, No. 5, July 2008, p. 701-716,
Routledge.
http: //www.sscnet.ucla.edu/soc/faculty/favell/01New
FaceFAVELLweb.pdf
Graur 1968: Alexandru Graur, Tendinele actuale ale
limbii romne, Editura tiinific, Bucureti.
112
114
PART II
LANGUAGE AND SPACE IDENTITY
115
116
117
118
121
122
98
123
125
126
alterity
in
127
103
Cornel Ungureanu, Postfa, in Adriana Babei, Corne Ungureanu, Europa Centrala Dileme, Nevroze, Utopii, Polirom,1998.
104
Ilustrated among others by the Austrian Volkertafel or
Tableau of Nationalities (Stanzel et al. 1999).
105
Bntean prin cultur i bercenar prin adopie, eram i mai
sunt, din pcate, oripilat de mahalagismul verbal i comportamental al concitadinilor. Privilegiai cei care dispreuiesc pe
128
129
130
131
109
133
It became clear for all, specialists and nonspecialists, that the problem of Romanian identity is
ultimately influenced by the socio-economic status of
Romanians inside and outside the country without
inevitably being experienced as such:
Well what to do? ... I'm Moldovian, and here (in
Moldova) I grew up. During childhood, when looking
over the Prut I saw mother Russia. Oh, what a
great joy was then! But growing, I left the country
togo in the West because there was a great poverty
in Moldova. The question is whether the West gets
me or just jokes with me? But if West gets me, what
shall I do from now?!... [17]110.
134
138
communication
niches?
This
modalization
has
implications for the sociology of language. How do the
interactions actor / relocated networks stabilize and
enhance by using messages in Romanian to be able to
speak of a tipicalization (institutionalization)? What is the
role of cultural identification in these processes and how
can be evaluated continuity, connection, convergence as
properties of the cultural space, namely topological
properties?
Our research aims to define the subject through a
methodological nuancing of the relationship between
culture as multiplicity vs. binary (two-way) as defined by
Deleuze and Guattary in Thousend Plateaus (1987) in
relation to the book-thought-world analogy and community, a concept defined by Ulrich Beck in The Brave New
World of Work (2000), as related to risk awareness.
Methodological background
The importance of the interdisciplinary scientifically
rooted theme is grounded in developmental psychology
and cultural anthropology which grants the mother tongue
and culture a status of key concepts of human ecology
(Worthmann 1994, Super, Harkness 1986, 1999, 2002,
Harkness, Super 1992, Weisner 2002).
Language and culture are factors of social organization, with a systematic regularity; they offer many
141
152
164
about
the
Romanian
pivoting
from
the
180
181
182
GENERAL BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abdallah-Prtceille 1986: Martine Abdallah-Prtceille,
Quand linterculturel nest quune ontologie
culturaliste dguise, in Actes du premier Colloque
de lARIC Socialisations , CIEP de Svres, 13-15
March 1986, Presses Universitaires du Mirail,
Toulouse, p.165-172.
Anis 2002: Jacques Anis, Communication lectronique
scripturale et formes langagires: chats et SMS,
Colloque Scrire avec les outils daujourdhui,
Universit de Poitiers / Maison des Sciences de
lhomme et de la socit, avril 2002 [http://oav.univpoitiers.fr/rhrt/2002/actes%202002/jacques%20anis.
htm].
Appadurai 1996: Arjun Appadurai, Modernity Al Large:
Cultural Dimensions of Globalization, University of
Minessota Press, Minneapolis.
Armanca 2006: Brndua Armanca, SMS i mass-media,
11
January
2006
[http://www.bizwords.ro/stiri/tendinte/1878/SMS-simass-media.html].
Arvinte 20083: Vasile Arvinte, Romn, romnesc,
Romnia. Studiu filologic, Casa Editorial Demiurg,
Iai.
Bachelard 1994: G.Bachelard, The Poetics of Space,
Boston, Beacon Press.
183
[rsum:
http://www.unibuc.ro/studies/doctorate2011august/
ferencz%20aida%20%20limbajul%20tinerilor%20in%20italia%20si%20ro
mania/rezumat.pdf].
Fiske, Hartley, 1978: John Fiske & John Hartley, Reading
Television, London, Methuen.
Floria 2007: Florinela Floria, Identitate i alteritate.
Prolegomene la o lingvistic antropologic coerian, in Evoluia i funcionarea limbii perspective
normative n noul context european (coord. SandaMaria Ardeleanu), Partea I, Editura Universitii
Suceava, Suceava, p. 222-226.
Friedman 1980: Y. Friedman, About Critical GroupSize,
The United Nations University, printed in Japan,
GPID20, 1980, http://www.transcend-nordic.org/
doc/10%20GPIDUNU%20Working%20Papers/HSDR-GPID20.pdf
(accessed on february 2010).
GALR 2005: Gramatica limbii romne. I-II, Academia
Romn, Institutul de Lingvistic Iorgu Iordan Al.
Rosetti, Editura Academiei Romne, Bucureti.
Granovetter 1973: Mark Granovetter, The Strengths of
Weak Ties, American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 78,
issue 6, May 1973, p.1360-1380.
Granovetter 1985: Mark Granovetter, Economic Action
and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness. American Journal of Sociology, 91 (3), p.
481-510.
188
190
195
200
http://tchateuses.free.fr/smiley.htm;
http://web.icq.com/;
http://www.ados.fr;
http://fr.audiofanzine.com/chat/;
http://www/fr-dawson.com/chat.htm;
http://www.noukylinkworld.net/info_dicochat;
http://www.ploiesti-chat.org/reguli;
www.9am.ro
www.capital.ro
www.cotidianul.ro
www.dexonline.ro
www.gardianul.ro
www.kudika.ro
www.mediawebdesign.ro
www.plugin.ro
www.stiripescurt.ro
202