Professional Documents
Culture Documents
George D. Nasser
9
R.C.
FLAT
Z
N
N
w
Z
SLAB
P. C.
FLAT
PLAT
Q/t=30
t/t=45
Y 7
C)
_
S
I-
00
J
N
to
20
30
SPAN, FT
P.C.SLAB
WITH
DROP
PANEL
40
50
Fig. 1. Slab thickness vs. span for reinforced concrete slabs, prestressed
flat plates, and prestressed flat slabs
with drop panels
t
45
where L is the span length in feet.
Unfortunately, the above formula
does not hold in the case of very
high live loads and for variations in
the density of concrete.
Average compressive prestress. The
average compressive stress, F/A, is
a good "indicator" of how the design can proceed. The average stress
varies inversely with the slab thickness. It would seem, then, that to
obtain the minimum thickness of
slab, we should use the maximum
average prestress. This course, however, does not always produce an
economical design because a high
average prestress also means a larger
prestressing force (i.e., more prestressing steel and larger jacking
forces). In addition, for stresses over
500 psi, there is the danger of excessive elastic shortening, shrinkage,
and creep in the slabs. Again, we do
not want to have too little slab
thickness because in long spans
there is a sensation of "springiness"
when walking on the floors and also
a danger of undesirable vibrations.
On the other hand, the lower limit of
200 psi is required to minimize
66
where F/A is the average compressive stress and the modulus of elasticity E is calculated from:
3. Creep
A=L(E,+E,+E,)
For a typical normal weight concrete slab, with low average compressive stress (say about 250 psi)
the total elastic shortening can be
expected to be about 3/4 in. per 100
ft. (i.e., 3/s in. at each end). To minimize shrinkage cracks it is good
practice to provide a nominal
amount of unprestressed reinforcing
steel in the top part of the slab over
the columns.
PCI Journal
F=
W1L2
2h
where L is the length of the span,
Wb is the balanced superimposed
load, and h is the tendon drape.
Since the prestressing force will
be the same throughout each slab
span, there will be one governing
span. The tendon profiles of the remaining spans will then be adjusted
accordingly (see later discussion on
tendon reversals).
Fire resistance and cover requirements. Adequate data exist that
properly designed post-tensioned
flat plates satisfy code fire requirements 115, es
For fire protection purposes and
for corrosion protection, building
"ACI Building Code (318-63) allows structures to be designed without analyzing the
effects of alternate span loading when the
live loads do not exceed 75 percent of the
dead loads. Prestressed slabs can be designed within the same limitations.
December 1969
M..=0A,fsu(d a/2)
f3 ,,/0.85f'b
where
b'd(3.5V+0.3ff,)+Vp
67)J
CRACK BETWEEN
/ EXTERNAL WALL OR
COLUMN AND
INTERNAL PARTIT.
INTERNAL
PARTITION
, CORRIDOR
%, `TILT OF WALL
DEFLECTION
crease slightly with increasing distance from the jack. However, with
some modern systems this is generally not necessary.
In general, the maximum length of
a slab between construction joints is
limited to 100 or 150 ft. to minimize
the effect of slab shortening and to
avoid excessive friction loss of prestress.
Transfer of bending from slab to column. The flexural interaction between column and slab is usually
treated from the concept of effective
width, that is, the width of an imaginary beam of the same depth, span
and stiffness against rotation as that
of the column-slab under consideration. For moments from vertical
loads on the slab, the effective reduction in stiffness should apply to
the columns rather than to the slab.
Since prestressed flat plates have a
relatively high torsional rigidity, a
reasonable value of effective width
may be taken as one-third to onehalf the bay width (13
High live loads and earthquake motions. It is imperative that in the
event of high overloads adequate
provisions be made to ensure that
ultimate flexural capacity governs
rather than ultimate shear, as in the
latter case collapse would be sudden
and without warning( 16> . Thus, it
would appear essential that yielding
take place in the columns rather
than the slab.
To avoid sudden collapse in the
case of high overloads, Rozvany and
Woods( 22 ) suggested that the average concrete prestress be made
greater than the modulus of rupture
and presented supporting experimental evidence for their theory.
However, experience in the United
States indicates that it is preferable
to keep the average prestress low
and to add unprestressed bonded reDecember 1969
TOP CRACK
TOP
CRACKS
i 50TT0M
k CRACKS
^^^
I'
ROTATION
SECTION
PLAN
Fig. 4. Cracking mechanism due to rotation of column head
The
overwhelming majority of prestressed flat plates in the United
States are constructed using unbonded post-tensioning tendons.
Nevertheless, there has been, for
many years, dissenting opinion as to
the merits of bonded vs. unbonded
tendons. Early European practice
favored bonded tendons. Even today
some overseas codes (notably in New
Zealand) and a few highway agencies in the United States restrict the
use of unbonded tendons. The following are apparently the major
reasons:
1. Bonded tendons provide a
greater ultimate strength than
do the same amount of unbonded tendons.
2. Bonded tendons decrease the
chance of total collapse in the
event of a local failure.
Nevertheless, both the above objections can be overcome by the addition of calculated amounts of unprestressed bonded reinforcement to
supplement the unbonded tendon
design. The probability of corrosion occuring in either bonded or
unbonded tendons appears to be
statistically about equal and remote
under current practices allowable
72
73
CONCLUSIONS
The following are the major conclusions resulting from this study:
1. There is currently about $120
billion worth of building construction on the drawing boards. A sizeable share of this market could go to
prestressed flat plate construction.
2. For spans ranging up to 35 ft.,
a prestressed lightweight concrete
flat plate system provides a functional and economical solution for medium and high rise buildings.
3. The vast majority of prestressed flat plates in the United
States are constructed using cast-inplace post-tensioned unbonded tendons.
4. The simplification of design
techniques is the single most important reason for the accelerated
growth of prestressed flat plate construction.
5. The majority of prestressed flat
plate designs are based on the load
balancing method plus service load
and ultimate strength checks using
ACI 318-63.
6. When ultimate strength is exceeded, it is general practice to add
unprestressed bonded reinforcement
rather than increasing the level of
average prestresss.
7. Ultimate strength is controlled
primarily by the total amount of
tendons (plus any unprestressed reinforcement) rather than by the tendon distribution.
8. To prevent any chance of an
abrupt punching shear failure, it is
good practice to pass at least some
of the tendons directly over the columns.
9. With the introduction of
high strength lightweight concrete
and improved post-tensioning techniques there has been a trend towards thinner slabs. However, there
is a lower limit (approximated by
76
2.
3.
4.
5.
18.
19.
20.
nal of the Prestressed Concrete Institute, Vol. 8, No. 5, October 1963, pp.
68-79.
11. Rozvany, G. I. N. and Hampson,
A. J. K., "Optimum Design of Prestressed Flat Plates," Journal of the
American Concrete Institute, Proceedings Vol. 60, No. 8, August 1963, pp.
1065-1082.
12. Brotchie, J. F. and Russell, J. J., "Flat
Plate Structures," Journal of the American Concrete Institute, Proceedings
Vol. 61, No. 8, August 1964, pp. 959996.
13. Blakey, F. A., "Towards an Australian
Structural FormThe Flat Plate,"
Architecture in Australia, Vol. 54, No.
3, September 1965, pp. 115-117.
14. Candy, C. F., "Prestressed Flat Slabs,"
N. Z. Engineering (Wellington), Vol.
19, No. 7, July 15, 1964, pp. 258-261.
15. Ellen, Peter E., "Ultimate Load Balanced Design of Prestressed Concrete," Parts 1, 2 and 3, Lift Slab
Australasia, Sydney, 1966, pp. 1-27.
16. Power, Cedric A., "Prestressed Flat
Slabs," N. Z. Engineering (Wellington), Vol. 21, No. 8, August 15, 1966,
pp. 321-327.
17. Grow, J. B. and Vanderbilt, M. D.,
"Shear Strength of Prestressed Lightweight Aggregate Concrete Flat
Plates," Journal of the Prestressed
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
Discussion of this paper is invited. Please forward your discussion to PCI Headquarters
by June 1 to permit publication in the August 1970 issue of the PCI JOURNAL.
December 1969
77