Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ARTICLE NO.
0271
AND
B. L. FINLEY
*McLaren/HartChemRisk, 16755 Von Karman Avenue, Irvine, California 92606; and McLaren/HartChemRisk,
1135 Atlantic Avenue, Alameda, California 94501
Received February 21, 1996; accepted June 29, 1996
Absorption and Elimination of Trivalent and Hexavalent Chromium in Humans Following Ingestion of a Bolus Dose in Drinking
Water. KERGER, B. D., PAUSTENBACH, D. J., CORBETT, G. E., AND
FINLEY, B. L. (1996). Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 141, 145158.
These studies investigate the magnitude and valence state of
chromium absorbed following plausible drinking water exposures
to chromium(VI). Four adult male volunteers ingested a single
dose of 5 mg Cr (in 0.5 liters deionized water) in three chromium
mixtures: (1) Cr(III) chloride (CrCl3), (2) potassium dichromate
reduced with orange juice (Cr(III)-OJ); and (3) potassium dichromate [Cr(VI)]. Blood and urine chromium levels were followed
for 13 days prior to and up to 12 days after ingestion. The three
mixtures showed quite different pharmacokinetic patterns. CrCl3
was poorly absorbed (estimated 0.13% bioavailability) and rapidly
eliminated in urine (excretion half-life, 10 hr), whereas Cr(III)OJ was absorbed more efficiently (0.60% bioavailability) but more
slowly (half-life, 17 hr), and Cr(VI) had the highest bioavailability (6.9%) and the longest half-life (39 hr). All three chromium
mixtures caused temporary elevations in red blood cell (RBC) and
plasma chromium concentrations, but the magnitude and duration
of elevation showed a clear trend (Cr(VI) Cr(III)-OJ CrCl3).
The data suggest that nearly all the ingested Cr(VI) was reduced
to Cr(III) before entering the bloodstream based on comparison
to RBC and plasma chromium patterns in animals exposed to
high doses of Cr(VI). These findings support our prior work which
suggests that water-soluble organic complexes of Cr(III) formed
during the reduction of Cr(VI) in vivo explain the patterns of
blood uptake and urinary excretion in humans at drinking water
concentrations of 10 mg/liter or less. q 1996 Academic Press, Inc.
Many studies have examined the pharmacokinetics of hexavalent chromium using radiolabeled compounds or total
chromium measurements, but definitive information on the
process of Cr(VI) reduction in vivo is not available. Hexavalent chromium [Cr(VI)] is much more toxic than trivalent
forms [Cr(III)] (OFlaherty, 1993, 1994; Anderson, 1994)
and is readily reduced to Cr(III) by organic materials in
many exogenous and endogenous media (De Flora et al.,
1987; De Flora and Wetterhahn, 1989; Kerger et al., 1996b).
The United States Environmental Protection Agency
145
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$301
10-08-96 09:15:40
0041-008X/96 $18.00
Copyright q 1996 by Academic Press, Inc.
All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
toxas
AP: Tox
146
KERGER ET AL.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$302
10-08-96 09:15:40
toxas
AP: Tox
1
A chromic trichloride plus orange juice group was not studied here
because the orange juice was intended to mimic the in vivo reduction process
of gastric juices/contents. There is limited evidence that high doses of
ascorbate (60 mg/kg) in guinea pigs may alter the disposition of zinc, iron,
and manganese (Seaborn et al., 1994); however, the relevance of these
findings to the relatively small amount of ascorbate remaining after Cr(VI)
reduction in orange juice in the current study is unclear.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$302
10-08-96 09:15:40
147
toxas
AP: Tox
148
KERGER ET AL.
RESULTS
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$302
10-08-96 09:15:40
(Cr(III)-OJ; conducted in July 1995); and (3) potassium dichromate (Cr(VI); conducted in August 1995). In each study,
three or four volunteers ingested 0.5 liters of 10 ppm chromium solution (i.e., 5 mg Cr), which was consumed within
a 2-min period in the morning between 9:00 and 12:00 to
simulate high-dose ingestion on an empty stomach. One volunteer (H4) was common to all experiments.
The single dose studies were designed to obtain kinetic
information on the acute time course of chromium uptake
into the blood and excretion in urine. Blood and urine chromium levels were followed for 13 days prior to and up to
12 days after the single dose ingestion.
Urinary Excretion
Data on the time course and magnitude of urinary excretion following single dose administration of the three chromium mixtures are presented in Table 1 and Figures 2, 4,
and 6. The ingestion of 5 mg of the various forms of chromium resulted in differential uptake and urinary excretion
that was highly mixture-dependent.
Ingestion of chromic chloride resulted in the lowest percentage absorption corresponding to an average bioavailability of only 0.13% (range for all 4 subjects, 4.0 to 12 mg Cr
or 0.08 to 0.24%) as shown in Fig. 2 and Table 1. Following
administration of chromic chloride, total urinary excretion of
chromium was clearly elevated above prestudy background
levels on the first 3 days following exposure. During the
first 3 days, the volunteers excreted 7082% of the total
chromium measured in urine within 7 days. Peak concentrations in individual voids averaged 8.9 mg Cr/g creatinine
(range, 4.0 to 13 mg Cr/g creatinine). The calculated average
urinary excretion half-life for this mixture is approximately
10.3 hr (range, 4.8 to 15.4).
Administration of potassium dichromate [Cr(VI)] reduced in orange juice (presumably to Cr(III)-organic complexes and Cr(III) ions) resulted in a significantly higher
apparent uptake than chromic chloride, corresponding to
an average bioavailability of 0.60% (range for all four
subjects, 15.5 to 41.0 mg Cr or 0.31 to 0.82%) as shown
in Fig. 4 and Table 1. This mixture produced an elevated
urinary chromium for 4 to 5 days. Within the first 3 days
the volunteers excreted 90 to 96% of the total chromium
measured in urine. Peak urine chromium concentrations
averaged 24 mg Cr/g creatinine (range, 18 to 36 mg Cr/g
creatinine). The calculated urinary elimination half-life
for Cr(III) formed in orange juice averaged 15 hr (range,
10.1 to 19), which is considerably longer than that observed for Cr(III) chloride (10.3 hr).
Ingestion of potassium dichromate [Cr(VI)] resulted in
apparently higher and more variable uptake compared to the
other mixtures, corresponding to an average bioavailability
of 6.9% of the administered dose (range for all four subjects
toxas
AP: Tox
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$7948
10-08-96 09:15:40
toxas
AP: Tox
0.13 { 0.04%
(6.3 { 1.9)
0.09%
(4.5)
0.08%
(4.0)
0.09%
(4.5)
0.24%
(12)
10 { 2.2
15
9.6
11
4.8
Elimination
half-lifeb
(hr)
24 { 4.3
18
18
36
23
Peak
(mg Cr/g creat.)
0.60 { 0.11%
(30.1 { 5.5)
0.31%
(15.5)
0.71%
(35.5)
0.82%
(41.0)
0.57%
(28.5)
Bioavailabilityb
[% of dose absorbed
(mg Cr in urine)]
15 { 4.0
19
17
10
13
Elimination
half-lifeb
(hr)
209 { 128
77
143
585
29
Peak
(mg Cr/g creat.)
6.9 { 3.7
(343 { 186)
2.4%
(120)
6.4%
(320)
1.2%
(57.5)
17.5%
(875)
Bioavailabilityb
[% of dose absorbed
(mg Cr in Urine)]
Potassium dichromate
39 { 1.7
37
36
43
41
Elimination
half-lifeb
(hr)
a
Mean background total urinary excretion of chromium for the eight volunteers ranged from 0.3 to 1.5 mg/day. For nondetects, 12 the detection limit was used. No background adjustments
were made to postdose urinary excretion values.
b
Bioavailability and elimination half-life calculations are described under Methods.
8.9 { 2.0
H10
Average {
standard error
13
H9
H8
H6
4.0
H5
H7
11
7.4
H4
H1
Subject
Peak
(mg Cr/g creat.)
Bioavailabilityb
[% of dose absorbed
(mg Cr in urine)]
Chromic chloride
TABLE 1
Urinary Excretion of Chromium in Human Volunteers Following a Single Bolus Dose (0.5 Liters at 10 mg Cr/Liter) as Potassium Dichromate,
Potassium Dichromate Reduced to Cr(III) in Orange Juice, or Chromic Chloride in Watera
149
150
KERGER ET AL.
FIG. 1. Cr(VI) and Cr(III) uptake in red blood cells. This schematic
depicts how Cr(VI) readily enters the red blood cell, where it is reduced
to short-lived reactive intermediates [Cr(V), Cr(IV)] and bound to hemoglobin (Hb) and soluble ligands (L) such as glutathione and amino acids.
Essentially complete binding of intracellular Cr(VI) to hemoglobin occurs
because 30% of red blood cell mass is hemoglobin. The hemoglobinbound Cr complexes remain part of the red blood cell for its entire life
span. Conversely, water-soluble chromium(III) moves across the cell membrane via much slower diffusion and perhaps other processes related to the
chemical structure of the attached ligands.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$303
10-08-96 09:15:40
toxas
AP: Tox
151
FIG. 3. Daily (A) plasma and (B) RBC chromium concentrations in 4 volunteers ingesting bolus dose of 0.5 liter of 10 mg Cr(III)/liter in 2 min.
Peak blood chromium measurements from the dose day were used for Day 2 values. Mean RBC and plasma background (plus 1 standard error) of all
volunteers from measurements taken prior to dosing are represented by the dotted lines BR and BP , respectively. Data points are connected using a
smoothed-curve function. Clotting of blood samples from volunteer H7 following the dose day led to an incomplete dataset.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$303
10-08-96 09:15:40
toxas
AP: Tox
152
KERGER ET AL.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$303
10-08-96 09:15:40
toxas
AP: Tox
153
FIG. 5. Daily (A) plasma and (B) RBC chromium concentrations in 4 volunteers ingesting bolus dose of 0.5 liter of 10 mg Cr(VI)OJ/liter in 2
min. Peak blood chromium measurements from the dose day were used for Day 2 values. Mean RBC and plasma background (plus 1 standard error) of
all volunteers from measurements taken prior to dosing are represented by the dotted lines BR and BP , respectively. Data points are connected using a
smoothed-curve function.
DISCUSSION
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$303
10-08-96 09:15:40
lent chromium is probably reduced rapidly to trivalent chromium prior to RBC uptake and systemic distribution. However, one of the four volunteers exposed to 10 mg Cr(VI)/
liter exhibited an elevation in both plasma and RBC chromium that was sustained above background levels for at
least 12 days. The sustained elevation of chromium in both
RBCs and plasma seems consistent with two plausible explanations: (1) the observations reflect tissue loading with
Cr(III) in organically complexed forms that are slowly excreted and in equilibrium between RBC and plasma compartments, or (2) some small fraction of the Cr(VI) escaped
reduction in the plasma and was then rapidly sequestered
and reduced within the RBC fraction of blood. In either
toxas
AP: Tox
154
KERGER ET AL.
case, we cannot exclude the fact that Cr(VI) may have been
absorbed in minute amounts that are below the detection
limits of the methods used here.
We believe that these findings more strongly support the
conclusion that Cr(VI) ingestion at these doses resulted in
increased chromium uptake in the form of Cr(III) complexes
that induced a tissue loading effect in some individuals at
10 mg/liter. First, these results are not consistent with intravenous or intratracheal Cr(VI) exposures in animals which
demonstrate that chromium levels in plasma do not remain
consistently elevated as do RBCs (Gray and Sterling, 1950;
Weber, 1983; Edel and Sabbioni, 1985; Wiegand et al.,
1988). Concurrently and almost equally elevated RBC and
plasma levels observed in the current study may indicate an
equilibrium process with Cr(III). Second, previous studies
show in vivo formation (Ronai, 1969; Sanderson, 1976; Levis et al., 1978; Edel and Sabbioni, 1985) and enhanced
uptake of chromium (III) organic complexes (Mertz, 1969,
1975; Mertz and Roginski, 1971; Gonzalez-Vergara et al.,
1981; Edel and Sabbioni, 1985; Kortenkamp and Beyersmann, 1987; Gargas et al., 1994); the process of Cr(VI)
reduction in vivo likely involves formation of trivalent chromium complexes that are more readily absorbed than inorganic Cr(III) forms. Third, systemic uptake of Cr(VI) as
organic Cr(III) complexes is also consistent with the longer
observed half-life for urinary excretion of chromium. Fourth,
in a previous study we found no detectable Cr(VI) (1 to
2 ppb) in plasma or urine in volunteers who ingested up
to 10 mg Cr(VI)/liter, even during the rapid uptake and
distribution phases (Kerger et al., 1996a). And finally, none
of the volunteers exhibited signs or symptoms or gastrointestinal irritation or any clinical indications of toxicity to the
kidney, liver, or blood.
Our data are consistent with published pharmacokinetic
models of Cr(III) behavior in mammals. Aitio et al. (1988)
have suggested that the half-life of chromium in humans is
based on distribution and elimination rates of chromium
from three separate compartments: the fast elimination compartment (t12 7 hr), the moderate elimination compartment
(t12 15 days), and the slow elimination compartment (t12
3 years) (Aitio et al., 1988). Lim et al. (1983) reported a
similar compartment model, suggesting chromium half-lives
of 0.5 to 12 hr in blood (fast compartment), 1 to 14 days in
storage organs like the liver and spleen (medium), and 3 to
12 months in other solid tissues (slow compartment) (Lim
et al., 1983). Our data for CrCl3 appear to be consistent with
the fast compartment elimination (half-life, 10 hr), while the
data for Cr(III)OJ (half-life, 15 hr) and Cr(VI) in water
FIG. 6. The excretion of chromium in urine of 4 volunteers ingesting
0.5 liter of 10 mg Cr(VI)/liter within 2 min. The elimination half-lives
for volunteers (A) H4, (B) H5, (C) H8, and (D) H10 were 41, 43, 36,
and 37 hr, respectively. The mean (plus 1 standard error) background
values for volunteers H4, H5, H8, and H10 are 0.6, 0.7, 0.3, and 0.3
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$303
10-08-96 09:15:40
toxas
AP: Tox
155
FIG. 7. Daily (A) plasma and (B) RBC chromium concentrations in 4 volunteers ingesting 0.5 liter of 10 mg Cr(VI)/liter (bolus dose). Peak blood
chromium measurements from the dose day were used for Day 2 values. Mean RBC and plasma background (plus 1 standard error) of all volunteers
from measurements taken prior to dosing are represented by the dotted lines BR and BP , respectively. Data points are connected using a smoothed-curve
function.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$303
10-08-96 09:15:40
toxas
AP: Tox
156
KERGER ET AL.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$303
10-08-96 09:15:40
In conclusion, this study demonstrates that oral administration of Cr(VI) at low doses in drinking water results in a
pharmacokinetic profile in blood and urine that is consistent
with predominant reduction of Cr(VI) in the stomach and
small intestine followed by systemic uptake, distribution,
and excretion as Cr(III) organic complexes. Administration
of both Cr(VI) and Cr(III) at or below 10 mg Cr/liter can
cause temporary elevations in RBC and plasma chromium
levels, with more extended excretion times probably influenced by Cr(VI) reduction, binding to organic ligands, and
distribution to different pharmacokinetic storage compartments compared to inorganic Cr(III). This pharmacokinetic
mechanism of Cr(VI) reduction via the oral route helps to
explain why subchronic and chronic drinking water administration at relatively high concentrations (e.g., 11 to 140 mg
Cr(VI)/liter) did not demonstrate appreciable toxicity in animals (Gross and Heller, 1946; MacKenzie et al., 1958; Anwar et al., 1961; Borneff et al., 1968).
REFERENCES
Aitio, A., Javisalo, J., Kiilunen, M., Kalliomaki, P. L., and Kalliomaki, K.
(1988). Chromium. In Biological Monitoring of Toxic Metals (T. W.
Clarkson, L. Friberg, G. F. Nordberg, and D. R. Sager, Eds.), pp. 369
382. Plenum, New York.
Anderson, R. A. (1994). Nutritional and toxicologic aspects of chromium
intake: An overview. In Risk Assessment of Essential Elements (W. Mertz,
C. O. Abernathy, and S. S. Olin, Eds.), pp. 187195. International Life
Sciences Institute, Washington, DC.
Anderson, R. A., Bryden, N. A., and Polansky, M. M. (1996). Lack of
toxicity of chromium chloride and chromium picolinate. Fundam. Appl.
Toxicol. 30, 299. [Abstract]
toxas
AP: Tox
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$304
10-08-96 09:15:40
157
Korallus, U. (1986b). Chromium compounds: Occupational health, toxicological and biological monitoring aspects. Toxicol. Environ. Chem. 12,
4759.
Korallus, U., Harzdorf, C., and Lewalter, J. (1984). Experimental bases for
ascorbic acid therapy of poisoning by hexavalent chromium compounds.
Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health 53, 247256.
Kortenkamp, A., and Beyersmann, D. (1987). Uptake of chromium(III)
complexes by erythrocytes. Toxicol. Environ. Chem. 14, 2332.
Langard, S., Gundersen, N., Tsalev, D. L., and Gylseth, B. (1978). Whole
blood chromium level and chromium excretion in the rat after zinc chromate inhalation. Acta Pharmacol. Toxicol. 42, 142149.
Levis, A. G., Bianchi, V., Tamino, G., and Pegoraro, B. (1978). Cytotoxic
effects of hexavalent and trivalent chromium on mammalian cells in
vitro. Br. J. Cancer 37, 386396.
Lewalter, J., Korallus, U., Harzdorf, C., and Weidemann, H. (1985). Chromium bond detection in isolated erythrocytes: A new principle of biological monitoring of exposure to hexavalent chromium. Int. Arch. Occup.
Environ. Health 55, 305318.
Lim, T. H., Sargent, T., III, and Kusubov, N. (1983). Kinetics of trace
element chromium(III) in the body. Am. J. Physiol. 244 (4), R445-R454.
Lindberg, E., and Vesterberg, O. (1983a). Monitoring exposure to chromic
acid in chromeplating by measuring chromium in urine. Scand. J. Work
Environ. Health 9, 333340.
Lindberg, E., and Vesterberg, O. (1983b). Urinary excretion of proteins in
chromeplaters, exchromeplaters and referents. Scand. J. Work Environ.
Health 9, 505510.
MacKenzie, R., Byerrum, U., Decker, C., Hoppert, C., and Langham, F.
(1958). Chronic toxicity studies: Hexavalent and trivalent chromium administered in drinking water. Arch. Ind. Health 18, 232234.
Mertz, W. (1969). Chromium occurrence and function in biological systems.
Physiol. Rev. 49, 163239.
Mertz, W. (1975). Effects and metabolism of glucose tolerance factor. Nutr.
Rev. 33(5), 129135.
Mertz, W., and Roginski, E. E. (1971). Chromium metabolism: The glucose
tolerance factor. In Newer Trace Elements in Nutrition (W. Mertz and
W. E. Cornatzer, Eds.). Dekker, New York.
Miksche, L., Lewalter, J., and Korallus, U. (1994). Determination of chromium in erythrocytes: A new principle for biological monitoring in chromium (VI) exposed workers. In Proceedings of the DOE Symposium on
Biomarkers. February, San Diego, CA.
Minoia, C., and Cavalleri, A. (1988). Chromium in urine, serum and red
blood cells in the biological monitoring of workers exposed to different
chromium valency states. Sci. Total Environ. 71, 323327.
Mutti, A., Pedroni, C., Arfini, G., Franchini, I., Minoia, C., Micoli, G.,
and Baldi, C. (1985). Biological monitoring of occupational exposure to
different chromium compounds at various valency states. In Carcinogenic
and Mutagenic Metal Compounds Environmental and Analytical Chemistry and Biological Effects (M. E., R. W. Frei, W. Hardi, and C. Schlatter,
Eds.), pp. 119125. Gordon & Breach, London.
OFlaherty, E. (1993). A pharmacokinetic model for chromium. Toxicol.
Lett. 68, 145158.
OFlaherty, E. (1994). Comparison of reference dose with estimated safe
and adequate daily dietary intake from chromium. In Risk Assessment of
Essential Elements (W. Mertz, C. O. Abernathy, and S. S. Olin, Eds.).
ILSI Press, Washington, DC.
Ottenwaelder, H., and Wiegand, H. J. (1988). Uptake of 51Cr(VI) by human
erythrocytes: Evidence for a carrier-mediated transport mechanism. Sci.
Total Environ. 71, 561566.
Paustenbach, D. J., Throop, L., Fritch, D., McDougal, M., Overman, S. K.,
toxas
AP: Tox
158
KERGER ET AL.
AID
TOX 7948
6h12$$$304
10-08-96 09:15:40
USEPA (1991). National primary drinking water regulations-synthetic organic chemicals and inorganic chemicals; monitoring for unregulated
contaminants; national primary drinking water regulations implementation; national secondary drinking water regulations. Fed. Regist. 56,
35263597.
USEPA (1996). Chromium. Washington, D.C.: Integrated Risk Information
System (IRIS). Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency. Down-loaded from National Library
of Medicine on-line service, January 25.
Weber, H. (1983). Long-term study of the distribution of soluble chromate51 in the rat after a single intratracheal administration. J. Toxicol. Environ. Health 11, 749764.
Wiegand, H. J., Ottenwalder, H., and Bolt, H. M. (1988). Recent advances
in biological monitoring of hexavalent chromium compounds. Sci. Total
Environ. 71, 309315.
toxas
AP: Tox