Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
2
3
a possibility that I added impurities from my hands, thus causing a melting point
depression. The amount of impurity would be very small, though, due to the crystals
still having a tight melting point range, and being so ambiguously close to the
melting points of both mandelic and benzoic acid. Referring back to the idea of a
slightly soluble compound; if the identity of the crystal is mandelic acid, it would be
very soluble in water, and likely a significant amount could have been lost. I would
have also seen the crystals dissolve in the flask, which I did not observe. According
to YALKOWSKY,SH & DANNENFELSER, RM (1992), the solubility of mandelic acid at room temp is
181,000 mg/L. (show math above) This means that 30 mL of water would dissolve 5.43 grams. I only lost
0.098 grams of crystal. Even though it was washed with ice water, the crystals would have dissolved when
I washed them out with all that water, and they hardly did. Additionally, benzoic acids solubility in freezing
water is 1.7g/L (show math above) which means that 0.051 g would have been lost, which is much closer
to the 0.098 grams that I lost. The remainder could have been from when I brushed crystals off the filter
paperI could have lost a small amount. This leads me to believe that I simply made an observational
error during the melting point portion of the experiment, and that the identity of the crystal is benzoic acid.