Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Objection
O,1] To make films on Holy and Noble Personalities are trangrssions and to
watch them approches to Blasphamy, while normal Hollywood films are
transgressions but do not approach to Blasphamy and disgrace.
But the cunning mind of this Engineer cleverly hid this issue.
O,2] He Cleverly hid the Point that the Iranian Films are not based upon the
True Traditions of Books like Bukha:ri , Muslim etc. but on the fake books like
'Al Kafi, Nahj . So they cannot be trusted, since they did contain concocted
matterials from most unauthentic and unreliable sources of traditions."Ali:
Mirza: cannot prove that the Persian Film on the People of Cave uses
Authentic Traditions Only. If it uses unauthentic traditions then it is not
suitable to watch even upon the standard of a person like "Engineer "Ali
Mirza: .
But latter Jabai explicitly stated that Human beings are the
Creators of their Acts whether they are good or evil or else,
and 'ALL-H is not the Creator Of Them, 'Astaghfarullah.
'Ahlussunnah differentiate between a Creator Of an Act and
an Agent [Doer/Fa:"ilun] of the Act in principle.
So stated Above acts are Creations Of 'ALL-H and ALL-H is
not a Doer Of them but The Only Creator Of Them.
It is clear from this lecture:133 of the Engineer and some
previous lectures of him that he fallows the Opinion of Jabai
or Pre Jabai Mu"tazilites over the issue.
WE ON THE CONTRAY BELIEVE THAT 'ALL-H IS NOT THE
DOER OF ACTS OF HUMAN , JIN ,ANGEL ANIMAL etc. Beings
but the Creator of them.
We differentiate between the word Agent and Creator, when
the word Agent is used in the meaning of Doer.
Majority Of Ahlussunnah how ever do believe that Deity
['ALL-H] is the Creator and the Agent of His Own Acts say
Divine Acts.
Minority of 'Ahlussunnah believe that Divine Acts are Neither
Creations nor Eternal, yet they believe that Acts of Created
Rational Beings are Creations Of Deity.But the opinion of the
Majority is Rational and Logical. But none of them believe
that the acts of Created Beings are NOT Created by 'ALL-H
the Only Deity.
SUMMARY:=
S,1]'ALL-H Is the Creator and Doer of His His Acts.
S,2]'ALL-H is the Creator but not the doer of Acts Of Rational
Supposita [ say Human Beings etc.] .
Bidh:dh:a:t.
To be one eyed is a Naqs: [N-qs:] so this Principle canbe used
as a defence against Dajja:l as well.
As Incarnations ,Manifestations Theophanies ,Formatrions
are Naqa:'is: , they all are Muh:a:l Bidh: Dh:a:t Upon 'ALL-H
SUBH:ANAHU Va TA"A:LA:.
So The claim of Dajja:l is falsified by this 'Isla:mic AXIOM.
NOTE: We Believe that Naqs: "Alallah Va "Alas:s:ifa:tidh:
dh:a:tiah as Muh:a:l Bidh:dh:a:t, but Naqs:
"Alas:s:ifa:tilfi"liah as Muh:a:l Bil Ghair , "Ali: Mirza: cannot
argue against our stand by claiming that this answer even
goeth against us.
How ever if it is some how accepted that Naqs:
"Alas:s:ifa:tilfi"liah as Muh:a:l Bidh: dh:a:t instead of Being
Muh:a:l Bil Ghair "Ali: Mirza: cannot argue against the the
Divine Power Over Falsehood, since truth of Divine Speech is
an Attribute of an Attribute of 'ALL-H and not the Attribute Of
'ALL-H, since an Attribute Of 'ALL-H is not ALL-H.Engineer
"Ali: Mirza: cannot argue unless and otherwise he claims that
Qur'a:n Is 'ALL-H and 'ALL-H is Qur'a:n.
Athough 'ALL-H and Qur'a:n both are Uncreated but Neither
'ALL-H is Qur'a:n Nor Qur'a:n is 'ALL-H.
So if Qur'an Just an Attribute Of 'ALL-H but Not 'ALL-H then a
Relative Attribute Of Qur'a:n is an Attribute Of an Attribute
Of 'ALL-H but not an 'ATTRIBUTE of 'ALL-H.
AN ATTRIBUTE of Qur'a:n can only be an Attribute Of ALL-H if
and only if Qur'a:n is ALL-H and ALL-H is Qur'a:n.
SUMMARY:
RESULT:=
If it is supposed that Naqs UPON ALL-H and His
Atttributes are Muh:a:l Bidh:dh:a:t , it is Certainly NOT
Implied that Naqs: Upon the Attributes Of Attributes
Of 'ALL-H are also Muh:a:l Bidh: dh:a:t.
I once my self wrote a letter TO THE FORMER teacher
of "Ali: Mirza: namely Zubair in support of Divine
Omnipotence over Falsehood but not over Eating ,
Hunger, Sleeping ,Incarnation, Sexual ACTIVITIES,
Madness etc. but he did not responded poperly.
Actually Zubair "Ali: Zai was also against Saiyiduna 'Ash Shah 'Isma:"i:l
Shahi:d RH:, BUT he did not exposed his enimity explicitly. We are proud of
'Ash sha:h 'isma:"i:l Shahi:d.