Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
| Log In | Sign Up |
Like
6.1m
Follow
ADVERTISEMENT
Interviews
Advanced Search
Hom e City India Budget 2014 World Business Tech Sports Cricket Entertainm ent Life & Style Travel Wom en Spirituality NRI Real Estate Photos Tim es Now Videos
Opinion
Blogs
Auto
Polls
Speak Out
Science
Environment
Education
STOI Headlines
Specials
Campaigns
Classifieds
Mocktale
Connect with us
LIV E
Share
201
A
Tw eet
114
1ST ODI
102
Share
19 Comments
139/4
More
SL 24.5 ov
304/5
50.0 ov SA
READ MORE
RELATED
Fahadh Faasil perfectly fitted
the bill to play a cop: Arun
Kumar Ara...
Producers Association calls
1 by Tw o director Arun
Kumar Aravind a r...
PU may approach cops over
fake texts for UBS seats
UBS dow ngrade of Infosys
pulls share price dow n
Sreenu Vaitla invested all his
savings
What is the measure of this 'black economy' in India and how much of it is stashed
away in foreign tax havens?
My estimate is that more than 50% of India's economy is black. About half of this is consumption
while the remaining half is savings.
Of these savings, about 20% is taken out of the country . That means, of the total black economy ,
about 10% is in foreign banks. Some is consumed there (yachts, houses, vacations) and some is
routed back to India through various means including hawala, or through the Mauritius route. If
all the money that has been illegally taken out were to be invested back in India, the gain would
be equivalent to $2 trillion (about Rs 120 lakh crore). This is not the amount of money stashed
abroad it is the opportunity cost of that.
7/6/2014
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
First of all, I think going after just the foreign component of black money is a diversion. The bulk
of the money is right here in the country! It is very difficult to get money out of foreign tax
havens unless someone has been really stupid. Let me clarify that all Indians with foreign
accounts are not criminals. If it is untaxed, unreported income then it needs to be tracked and
brought to book. No amount of agreements to avoid double taxation or infor mation sharing will
yield information on real account holders. There are devious means by which money is
transferred through several layers of shell companies. If you ask a Swiss bank, they might tell you
the 'names' they have but these are not the real people. It will require a great deal of meticulous
work here to get the right persons. This is what the US did in the case of its citizens who had
stashed money in UBS. They prepared a case in US and presented it to the Swiss. That's what
India should do.
Hi there,
Login w ith your Facebook ID to see
w hat your friends are reading on
Times of India.
The only other way is to wait for somebody to steal the data as happened in the case of LGT the
Lichtenstein based trust.
The present government seems to be very active in pursuing black money. Will this
yield results?
Since 1948, about 40 committees, commissions, etc have looked at the problem from different
angles. There have been raids, there have been amnesty schemes. The result is zero. My feeling is
that the Special Investigation Team (SIT) set up by the government under Supreme Court
pressure will be of limited use.
TOP STORIES
It is going to look at existing cases and go by what is offered to it - nothing more. The problem is
that there is a triad of vested interests that runs everything in the country -business, politicians
and the executive arm of the government. The Radia tapes have shown a glimpse of this nexus.
This triad is the main beneficiary of the black economy . So, there has never been a political will to
tackle the black economy in the past, and I doubt that the present government has it. Otherwise,
Modi can order a crackdown on all hawala operators and all other routes of illegal money flows.
Only pressure from people's movements will force the government to crack down on the black
economy .
Would the black economy cool down if taxes were lowered?
This is like saying that if the red light was not there you would not be charged with jumping it!
Remember, India has one of the lowest direct tax to GDP ratios in the whole world.
Chidambaram used to say that our tax-GDP ratio has improved. But that's because of the
enormous increase in corporate profits. Calculations show that just the top 0.1% of the population
earns more than the bottom 55%. This is because of deregulation and concessions in taxes. Y et the
black economy is flourishing.
Post a comment
more
MOST POPULAR
Read | Com m ented | Shared
From Hom e
Whales are engineers of ocean ecosystems:
Experts
1,000 foreign students keen to join Nalanda
university
Second list triggers spate of cancellations at DU
Former Karnataka CM HD
Kumaraswamy caught on tape asking for
bribe 06 Jul 2014
more
Across Tim es of India
2014
Jul 2014
PARTNERED CONTENT
BBC
Recommended by
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Swiss-accounts-are-a-diversion-Bulk-of-black-money-is-right-here-in-India/articleshow/37879250 2/8
7/6/2014
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
FEATURED TODAY IN TRAVEL
Subscribe
eFiling Made Sim ple on Taxsm ile. Start Filing IT Returns Now! : www.t axsmile.com/Income-Tax-Ret urns
A ds by Googl e
ALSO ON TOI
more
Caught on cam :
Officer beats w ...
US Independence
Day: Firew orks...
North Carolina:
Coast Guard su...
Joey Chestnut
w ins Nathan's
ho...
All
TOI
My Profile
Inte rv ie ws
Your comment
POST COMMENT
Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Recommended (1) | Most Discussed | Agree | Disagree
chhandas naikw ade (nagpur,INDIA)
20 mins ago
Bronze: 68
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Great piece of knowledge..often it happens about many topics which are very
important to be known to us in right detail,and we know just the shell of
nut.....
Shajahan (Salem)
3 Follow ers
31 mins ago
Silver: 1.3K
There is so much of talk about black money in swiss accounts. Do you think
that, those who possess large amount of black money still continue to keep it
in Swiss accounts. They must have thought of some innovative idea and the
money would have been transferred to some the country.
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Swiss-accounts-are-a-diversion-Bulk-of-black-money-is-right-here-in-India/articleshow/37879250 3/8
7/6/2014
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
Offensive
ratan (bbsr)
10 Follow ers
1 hr ago
Silver: 992
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
This is just grate , Modi will be of no use , its just a matter of time , unless
we get out on streets and protest for it to ban all the illegal money transfer
route .
Gandhi ()
4 Follow ers
1 hr ago
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Silver: 3.3K
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Best way to stop black economy is to stop FDI from Tax Haven countries
(Mauritius, Malta, Luxembourg)
Platinum : 19.7K
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
All of us must understand that those officials one who is saying BLACK
MONEY is actually what ? PROFIT FOR A MAN ONE WHO WORK WITH
HIS EXTRA ORDINARY SKILL THAN HE IS OFFICIALLY ESTIMATED.. In
this decade money which made inside India can't be compared with NRI
income. See, there is no tax to send money to India for NRIs but the same
way income of Indians have taxable money . So in this age either NRI should
get equal status of the non NRIs in India. Or it will be an one way status .
Silver: 1.1K
Platinum : 24.8K
Google "90% of corrupt money is with forward caste". * Vodafone tax Scandal
= $1.9 billion (forward caste) * Saradha Group financial scandal = $4
billion(forward caste) * IGI Airport scam = $32 billion(forward caste) * Coal
Mining Scam = $213 billion(forward caste) * Granite scam in Tamil Nadu
$2.8 billion(forward caste) * Maharashtra Irrigation Scam $12 billion(forward
caste) * Kinetic Finance Limited Scam $34 million(forward caste) * Ultra
Mega Power Projects Scam $5 million(forward caste) * Karnataka Wakf
Board Land Scam = $39 billion(forward caste) * Andhra Pradesh land scam =
$20 billion(forward caste) * Central Excise Duty fraud = $3.82 billion(forward
caste) * Gujarat PSU financial irregularities = $3.39 billion(forward caste) *
Maharashtra stamp duty scam = $126 million(forward caste) * Highway scam
= $13.97 million(forward caste) * Ministry of External Affairs gift scam =
$100,000(forward caste) * Himachal Pradesh pulse scam =
$200,000/month(forward caste) * Flying Club fraud = $38 million(forward
caste) * Jammu and Kashmir Cricket Association scam = $10 million (MC) *
Punjab paddy scam = $3.59 million(forward caste) * Arvind Joshi and Tinu
Joshi = $50 million(forward caste) * Uttar Pradesh seed scam = $9.98
million(forward caste) * Obsolete French Fighter Jets = $11 billion(forward
caste) * NHRM = $2 billion(BC) * Goa mining scam = $700 million(forward
caste) * Noida Corporation farm land scandal = $40 million(SC) * Bellary
mines scandal = $3.2 billion(forward caste) * BL Kashyap EPFO Scam =
$118 million(forward caste) * Hasan Ali Khan = $8 billion(MC) * ISRO-Devas =
$300 million(forward caste) * Cash-for-votes = $715,000(forward caste) * 2G
spectrum(FC/BC/SC/ST/MC) = $6.9 billion * Adarsh Housing Society(forward
caste) * Commonwealth Games = $15.5 billion(forward caste) * LIC Housing
Loan scam = $200 million(forward caste) * Belekeri port = $12 billion(forward
caste) * Lavasa = $80 million(forward caste) * Uttar Pradesh Food Grain =
$44 billion(BC) * APIIIC = $2 billion(forward caste) * IPL Cricket = $8
billion(forward caste) * Madhu Koda = $800 million(SC) * UIDAI = $1
billion(forward caste) * Vasundhara Raje land scam = $4.4 billion(forward
caste) * Satyam = $1 billion(forward caste) * Scorpene Deal = $10
Agree (1)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (1)
Offensive
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Swiss-accounts-are-a-diversion-Bulk-of-black-money-is-right-here-in-India/articleshow/37879250 4/8
7/6/2014
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
Silver: 3.0K
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
During the Emergency, I was fighting a "service" matter case in the Court.
During a casual conversation, my advocate, a very senior and highly
respected man, told e there was an Income Tax raid on one of his colleagues.
The colleague and his family threw out suitcases containing Rs.70 lakhs into
a back lane to avoid detection. They were prepared to lose that much
(remember, it was the year 1975, and you can estimate today's equivalent)
because it was only a fraction of the black money he had -- just ready cash.
This anecdote will give you an idea of the size of black money. Also, my
experience was that the lawyers would not normally give any receipts for the
fees they received, and they usually insisted on cash.
Silver: 523
Agree (2)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Bronze: 94
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
We need independent body like Supreme court to investigate with full power
and control without involvement of politicians and business man and take
action public to give the clear message that should prevent people from
involving in any activities of generating black money.I don't see currently what
been done and also in past would anyway yield any result and these are just
some kind of joke in our system with zero results all the times.
R.Singh (NCR)
16 Follow ers
4 hrs ago
Silver: 3.0K
If you are mystified by the sentence, "This is not the amount of money
stashed abroad -- it is the opportunity cost of that", here is my conjecture of
what happened. "opportunity" is a misprint for "approximate".
3 hrs ago
Silver: 1.1K
Agree (1)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Swiss-accounts-are-a-diversion-Bulk-of-black-money-is-right-here-in-India/articleshow/37879250 5/8
7/6/2014
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
economic woos of India .If proved wrong, hang me in public. This was also
perhaps taken as insane voice of a lunatic. On May 18, 2011,there was a
National Seminar on Black Money at India Habitat Center New Delhi i I had a
chance to be present there. I had raised this issue there also, but trouble with
such seminars in India is that these seminars start with lectures and end with
that. There is no follow up action afterwards. Pro.f.Kumar in his brief interview
has failed to address the biggest source of generation of black money,. bribe
and kick back
Silver: 1.1K
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
m vsridhara (Unknow n)
23 Follow ers
4 hrs ago
Gold: 15.8K
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Black money and black economy are issues that politicians are using against
one another's alleged adversaries. Black money is untaxed and unaccounted
income; and it is not necessarily big income and taxable income. And black
money has all along contributed to a wrong assessment of national product
and of whether so and so is poor or rich or non-poor or non-rich. Take the
case of a watchman in charge of a construction site; and several tools are
dumped under his watch and some times he may lend them for others, let us
say a ladder or a painting stool. He may charge some fee for it and the user
of this tool may find it far cheaper to pay a fee rather than hire a transport
vehicle to ferry this article, ladder or a stool. This watchman earns some
unrecognised income and it is unrecorded and it is black. Many doctors,
tuition teachers, accountants etc., earn unaccounted incomes and are all
considerably black because the earner does not declare that income. From
the point of view of the government the individual is earning Rs 500,000; but
his actual income is 8-10 lakhs. Thus taxes are not duly collected and the
country/government suffers from paucity of resources. A construction worker
or an electricity employee cuts tree branches and roots and carries the
proceeds as fuel for himself and this is his income, a piece of non-monetary
income and is not counted as his income; or, an underreporting of personal
income though not a piece of taxable income. Thus black money is being
earned and spent in various ways and the government is finding it hard all
along to duly tax various even high incomes. Generally spending of black
incomes does not result in collection of taxes and government is thus
proportionately disabled from spending on development or infrastructure; and
country remains less productive as a result. Though difficult, black money
needs to be unearthed; as has been remarked here efforts made inside the
country to seek out these black money hoards it will benefit the country
surely and proportionately. In sum, more people operate black money than
are generally believed; many of our neighbours and many of us may be
indulging in black money. And are quite thick skinned about it. Paying due
taxes may be the most patriotic deed. Jai Hind!
Gold: 12.0K
If you ask a Swiss bank, they might tell you the 'names' they have but these
Agree (0)
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Swiss-accounts-are-a-diversion-Bulk-of-black-money-is-right-here-in-India/articleshow/37879250 6/8
7/6/2014
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
If you ask a Swiss bank, they might tell you the 'names' they have but these
are not the real people. It will require a great deal of meticulous work here to
get the right persons. This is what the US did in the case of its citizens who
had stashed money in UBS. They prepared a case in US and presented it to
the Swiss. That's what India should do.
Bronze: 78
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Why did you just copy paste from the article above ??
KIM ()
30 Follow ers
6 hrs ago
Gold: 7.3K
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Great Article !!
Kevin (Location)
161 Follow ers
6 hrs ago
Gold: 19.8K
Agree (0)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Platinum : 31.6K
Agree (1)
Disagree (0)
Recommend (0)
Offensive
Pure white opinion on Black Money.. Mostly it might be in the form of assets,
properties, dummy companies, invested in green pastures.... within India &
abroad... How many Income-tax or other raids were conducted on the obvious
suspects of very high powerful clan... or their coteries... or near & dear
ones... Who will bell the cat, the cat itself.. ?? GOK
INDIA
WORLD
BUSINESS
TECH
About us
Privacy policy
New sletter
Sitemap
Advertise w ith us
Feedback
TOI Mobile
Archives
Services
Book print ads | Online shopping | Free SMS | Website design | CRM | Tenders
Matrimonial | Ringtones | Astrology | Jobs | Tech Community | Property | Buy car
Bikes in India | Deals | Free Classifieds | Send money to India | Used Cars
Restaurants in Delhi | Movie Show Timings in Mumbai | Remit to India | Buy Mobiles
Listen Songs | New s | Real Estate Developers
Trending Topics
Watch TV Show s | Photogallery | You Tube | Delhi Travel Guide | Katrina Kaif
Photos | MS Dhoni | Hindi Songs | Yoga | Gautam Gambhir - GoCricket.com |
Facebook | Sunny Leone Photos
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Swiss-accounts-are-a-diversion-Bulk-of-black-money-is-right-here-in-India/articleshow/37879250 7/8
7/6/2014
Swiss accounts are a diversion. Bulk of black money is right here in India - The Times of India
Copyright 2014 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. For reprint rights: Times Syndication Service
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Swiss-accounts-are-a-diversion-Bulk-of-black-money-is-right-here-in-India/articleshow/37879250 8/8