Explain what your visual text shows about the concept of
discovery and how this has been done.
Text one, Wanderer Above the Sea of Fog by Caspar Friedrich, is an oil painting showing a lone man standing on an elevated rock looking down at the sublime landscape before him. The text conveys the discovery of nature, combined with solitude, as one that can lead to physical and spiritual fulfilment. The character is placed in high salience to emphasise his isolation. His costuming suggests that he has trekked up the mountain to reach this isolated place and has hence attained physical fulfilment. The gaze of the character is on the sublime landscape, in particular the fog. The fog is symbolic of the unseen, and the character seeks comfort through nature knowing that uncertainty is a normal facet of life, allowing him to attain spiritual fulfilment. Therefore, it is evident how, through the use of techniques, the composer is able to convey the way in which the discovery of nature, with solitude, will lead to physical and spiritual fulfilment. How does this text show a different aspect of discovery than is seen in text one? While text one depicts discoveries as physically and spiritually fulfilling, text two explores the opposite notion. In The Road Not Taken by Robert Frost, the persona reaches a fork in the road and chooses the one less travelled by. Here, discoveries are portrayed as deeply personal yet unfulfilling as they lead to uncertainty of the future. The poem begins by saying Two roads diverged in a yellow wood. The word yellow is of particular significance as it is a metaphor for Autumn or Fall. This connotes that the choice is being made when the narrator is old and his future is uncertain. This uncertainty is further exemplified in To where it bent in the undergrowth. Undergrowth is symbolic of aspects of the speakers future that are uncertain as a result of the discovery of the fork in the road. In ages and ages hence repetition is used to show the narrator speculating about his future that is influenced by the decision he makes right now. Hence, we can clearly see that, unlike in text one, text two conveys how discoveries can be unfulfilling and often lead to uncertainty. Explain what this text shows about the concept of discovery. The text conveys how discoveries can be reassessed overtime for their value in light of an individuals experiences. The text details a young couple moving into a supposedly immoral neighbourhood where the children are always screaming and ones privacy is disregarded. Throughout the story, the couples attitude slowly shifts from perturbance to acceptance as they gather experiences with their neighbours. When the woman becomes pregnant she is overwhelmed with the wishes and presents she receives from her neighbours. We can see that her opinion of them is torn in flattered, claustrophobic, grateful, peeved. The use of oxymorons highlights her conflicting emotions and conveys that she is in a transitional state from perturbance to acceptance. This contrast between the couples attitude at the start of the story to the end is
paramount in highlighting how discoveries can be reassessed overtime in
light of recent experiences which provide renewed perspectives.
In your opinion, which text is most effective in exploring the
concept of discovery? Explain your choice with close reference to the text, elaborating on how the composer has executed his/her ideas. In my opinion, the text that was most effective in conveying the concept of discovery is text one Wanderer Above the Sea of Fog by Caspar Friedrich. This text provides commentary about the human condition and and reveals a personal discovery about an individuals place in this world, which is something that everyone can relate to. When we first look at the image, we notice that the character is placed in high salience in comparison to the surrounding nature. This serves to emphasise the deeply personal nature of the discovery that he is undergoing. The fog in the landscape is symbolic of the unseen, and the character seeks comfort in nature knowing that uncertainty is a normal facet of the human condition. A wide angle shot is used in the image to place more emphasis on the landscape than on the character suggesting that nature plays a significant role in revealing personal discoveries to an individual. The character is gazing out at the landscape in deep introspection, which emphasises the power the landscape has over him and the insignificance of humanity.