Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The demand for bigger, faster and lighter moving vehicles, such as ships, trains, and buses has increased the importance of
Efficient structural arrangements. In principle two approaches exist to develop efficient structures: either application of new
materials or the use of new structural design. A proven and well-established solution is the use of composite materials and
sandwich panels. In this way more strength to weight ratio and minimum weight can be obtained. The sandwich structures have
potential to offer a many range of attractive design solutions. In addition to the obtained wt. reduction, these solutions can often
bring space savings, fire resistance, noise control and improved heating and cooling performance. Laser-welded metallic
sandwich panels offer a number of outstanding properties allowing the Designer to develop light and efficient structural
configurations for a variety of applications. These panels have been under active Investigations during the last lots of years in the
world. Out okumpu has been participating in several collaborative projects in this area. In Finland the research related to all steel
sandwich structure was initiated in 1988 in the Ship Laboratory of Helsinki University of Technology.
Keywords: Design Optimization, Hoist able Car deck, Laser Welding
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
I.
INTRODUCTION
The demand for bigger, faster and lighter moving vehicles, such as ships, trains, and buses has increased the Importance of
efficient structural arrangements. In principle many approaches exist to develop efficient structures: either application of new
materials or the use of new structural design parameter. A proven and well-established solution is the use of composite
materials and sandwich structures. In this way more strength to weight ratio and minimum weight can be obtained. The
sandwich structures have potential to offer a many range of attractive design solutions. In addition to the obtained weight
reduction, these solutions can often bring space savings, fire resistance, noise control and improved heating and cooling
performance. Laser-welded metallic sandwich panels offer a number of outstanding properties allowing the designer to develop
light and efficient structural configurations for a large variety of applications. These panels have been under active
investigations during the last 15 years in the world. Outokumpu has been participating in several collaborative projects in this
area. In Finland the research related to all steel sandwich panels was initiated in 1988 in the Ship Laboratory of Helsinki
University of Technology. The first study focused on the application of sandwich panels in the shell structures of an icebreaker.
Since then in a considerable number of research projects in Finland, such as Shipyard 2000, Weld 2000 and the Kenno Light
Structures Technology Program, manufacturing, design and optimization of steel sandwich panels have been investigated. The
work is based on several R&D projects driven jointly with VTT Industrial Systems, technical universities in Finland, stainless
steel manufacturer Outokumpu Stainless as well as Finnish sandwich panel manufacturers. In this article the results of the earlier
mentioned R&D work in steel sandwich structures and applications is summarized from the stainless steel material point of view.
The research related to design and design optimization of steel sandwich panels has been summarized by Romanoff and Kujala
Steel Sandwich Panels: Types, Benefits and Production
Sandwich structure in general can be classified as: composite sandwich and metallic sandwich structure. Composite sandwich
panels consist of non-metallic components such as FRP, foam etc. and are typically applied as load carrying structures in naval
ship vessels and leisure yachts, and mainly as non-load carrying elements on merchant and large cruise ships. For metallic
sandwich structure there are basically two types of panels: panels with metallic face plates and bonded core such as the SPS
panels and panels with two metallic face plates and core welded together. The metal material can either regular, high tensile or
may be stainless steel, or aluminum alloys. In This paper focuses on steel sandwich panels welded by laser. The steel sandwich
panels can be constructed with various types of cores as summarized in Figure 1. The choice of the core depends on the
application under consideration. The standard cores such as Z-, tube- and hat profiles are easier to get and they are typically
accurate enough for the demanding laser welding process. The special cores, such as corrugated core (V-type panel) and I-core,
need specific equipment for production, but they usually result with the lightest panels. Naturally, during the production process
or after welding of faceplates plates and core together, the steel sandwich panels can also be filled with some polymer, mineral or
rock wool, concrete etc. to improve the behavior for specific targets. All kinds of sandwich panels have a number of common
368
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
benefits, like good weight to stiffness ratio, high pre-manufacturing accuracy etc. and problems, e.g. integration in a ship
structure, while the various variants also show a number of specific advantages and disadvantages. Steel sandwich is relatively
light and the total costs are very competitive to other light structures solutions. Typically, normal strength steel is used with steel
sandwich panels as buckling or displacement is the dominating failure criteria, therefore high strength steel does not usually give
any major benefits. For areas with high demands for corrosion protection or easy maintenance stainless steel can be also
applied. Laser welding require relatively high investment costs, therefore the price of the panels is strongly related to the volume
of the production.
However, as the material costs are smaller due to the decreased weight, typically the price of the steel sandwich panels/unit
area is about the same magnitude as that of conventionally stiffened steel panels.
Proposals for the construction of sandwich-like components were made in different industrial branches as early as the
1950s. However, the application of laser welding started to be increasingly discussed only after the high power laser sources
became available on the market at more affordable prices. Due to its high energy intensity resulting in a low heat input and a
deep penetration effect, laser welding offers a number of benefits for the production of all-metal and hybrid-metal sandwich
panels. High pre-fabrication accuracy of the components, high welding speed and the possibility to connect internal stiffeners
with the face sheets from outside have led to a wide application of laser welding in the construction of metal sandwich
panels. In the 1980s the United States Navy led the development of laser welded sandwich panels with a robot system at the
Navy Joining Centre at Pennsylvania State University. The development resulted in some prototype panels, first strength tests
and first limited applications, such as antenna platforms on the US Navy ships. Between the late 1980s and early 90s Europe
took over the lead in research related to laser welded sandwich panels. Research was initiated especially in Britain, Germany and
Finland. In Britain the strength of spot welded steel sandwich panels was studied by the School of Civil Engineering at the
University of Manchester. They performed both theoretical and experimental investigations on the behavior of steel sandwich
panels under various loading and boundary conditions. A large German project [10] conducted by Meyer Werft between 1994
and 1999 investigated both the production and application of sandwich panels in cruise vessels. This led to the development of
the I-Core panels.
In Finland the research related to all steel sandwich panels was initiated in 1988 in the Ship Laboratory of Helsinki University
of Technology. The first study focused on the application of sandwich panels in the shell structures of an icebreaker. Since then
a considerable number of research projects in Finland, such as Shipyard 2000, Weld 2000 and Kenno Light Structures
Technology Program, investigated manufacturing, design and design optimization of steel sandwich panels. The European
research project SANDWICH joined forces between the main actors in Europe and continued the development based on
previous national projects. One very important outcome of the project was the first DNV guidelines for the classification of these
panels in marine applications.
369
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
Material
The results of the studies have indicated that the austenitic stainless steel grade 1.4301 (AISI 304) can be used for laser
welded sandwich panels with good mechanical and general corrosion behavior in different applications. To increase the
corrosion resistance and to improve the resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion the austenitic stainless steel grade 1.4401
(AISI 316) can be used. The use of higher strength austenitic stainless steels like grade 1.4318 (AISI 301LN)
Composition of material:
Stainless steel type 316 is part of a family of stainless steel alloys (301, 302, 303, 304, 316, and 347). The 316 family is a group
of austenitic stainless steels with superior corrosion resistance to 304 stainless steel. This alloy is suitable for welding because it
has carbon content lower than 301 to 303 series alloys to avoid carbide precipitation in welding applications. The addition of
molybdenum and a slightly higher nickel content make 316 Stainless Steel suitable for architectural applications in severe
settings, from polluted marine environments to areas with sub-zero temperatures. Equipment in the chemical, food, paper,
mining, and pharmaceutical and petroleum industries often includes 316 Stainless Steel.
Nominal Composition in Percentage:
Ni
12.00
Cr
17.00
Mo
2.50
Fe
Balance
Si
1.00
Mn
2.00
C
0.080
P
0.045
S
0.030
304 and 316 are very expensive and can be overkill in the exhaust application. Try Cromgard 18-1. Just Google Cromgard
and the company pops up. Its used a lot in the automotive industry for exhausted systems because of resistance to corrosion and
low cost
Flow Chart of Work
370
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
371
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
Circular Geometry:
372
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
373
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
Square Geometry:
374
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
375
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
Sample code 02
Material M.S.
Description Circular
Date 24.02.2016
Sample width 100 mm
376
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
Sample code 03
Material M.S.
Description Square
Date 24.02.2016
Sample width 100 mm
DEFORMATION
(mm)
0.01223
0.02145
0.031233
0.03943
0.05631
0.0642
0.07521
0.0844
STRESS
(mpa)
15.182
20.00
29.56
40.06
52.17
61.90
70.85
82.07
STRAIN
0.0000562
0.0001
0.000178
0.0002
0.00023
0.00031
0.00037
0.00042
377
FEM and Experimental Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Panels for Weight Reduction
(IJIRST/ Volume 3 / Issue 02/ 060)
Circular Component:
LOAD
(N)
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
DEFORMATION
(mm)
0.00234
0.00431
0.00642
0.00863
0.01
0.0128
0.0154
0.017
STRESS
(mpa)
4
8.212
11.56
15.123
18.12
22.21
27.023
30.05
LOAD
(N)
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
DEFORMATION
(mm)
0.0146
0.02103
0.0312
0.04332
0.052081
0.06105
0.073
0.088
STRESS
(mpa)
15.8942
19.274
29.12
39.37
46.712
59.87
66.12
73.156
STRAIN
0.000025
0.00004529
0.0000678
0.000089
0.0001
0.00013
0.000147
0.000175
Square Component:
STRAIN
0.000057
0.000059
0.00013
0.00016
0.00023
0.000295
0.0003325
0.00038125
IX. CONCLUSION
Three components are tested by using UTM machine and ANSYS workbench.
The geometry of component tested is Triangular, Square, circular component, compressed by giving loads from 1000N
to 8000N. Equivalent deformation, equivalent stress & equivalent elastic strain are calculated. From the above result we are
concluded that, the maximum deformation is takes place in the Square component than the triangular and the circular
component. Hence the Square component is more suitable than other component at maximum loading.
REFERENCES
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
[18]
[19]
O.T. Thomson et al. (eds), sandwich structures 7; advancing with Sandwich Structure and materials, 3-12.
Kolhe K P 2014. Testing and Ergonomically Evaluation of Tractor Mounted. And Self Propelled Coconut Climber. Intl Journal of Engineering and
Technology ISSN 2321-1163. 3(9) Pp. 357-362.
Kolhe K P. 2015. Stability analysis of tractor mounted hydraulic elevator for horticultural orchards World Journal of Engineering, 12(4) 2015, Pp. 399406.
Kolhe K P. 2015. Testing of Tractor Mounted and Self Propelled Coconut Climber for coconut harvestings World Journal of Engineering. , 12(4) 2015,
Pp. 309-315.
Kolhe K.P. Development and testing of tree climbing and harvesting device for mango and coconut trees. Indian coconut journal, published by Ministry of
Agriculture, CDB board Kochi Kerla (ISSN No 0970-0579) 2009, LII (3) Pp.15-19.
Kolhe K.P. 2013 Development and Testing of TMSPCC for coconut Orchards. Indian Journal of Scholarly Research. 2(9) Pp. 23-33.
Kolhe K P and Jadhav B B Testing and Performance Evaluation of Tractor Mounted Hydraulic Elevator for Mango Orchard. American Journal of
Engineering and applied sciences. DOI.10.3844/ajeassp.2011. ISSN 1941-7020 2011, 4(1) Pp.179-186
Pawan Kumar, K P Kolhe, S J Morey and C K Datta Process Parameters Optimization of an Aluminum Alloy with Pulsed Gas Tungsten Arc Welding
(GTAW) using gas mixtures. Journal of Materials Sciences and Applications doi:10.4236/msa.2011.24032 (http://www.scirp.org/journal/msa) 2011, (2),
251-257.
Kolhe K. P., Powar A.G., Dhakane A.D. and Mankar S.H. Stability and Ergonomic Design Features of Tractor Mounted Hydraulic Elevator American
Journal of Engineering and applied sciences. DOI. 10.3844/ ajeassp.2011. ISSN 1941-7020, 2011, 4(3) Pp.380-389.
Kamlesh Ambule, K.P. Kolhe A Review on Design and Analysis of Stainless Steel Sandwich Structure (IJSRD/Vol. 4/Issue 03/2016/069)
Aydncak, lke investigation of design and analyses principles of honeycomb structures
Jukka Synjkangas and Tero Taulavuori, Outokumpu Stainless Oy, Finland A review in design and manufacturing of stainless steel sandwich panels
stainless steel world oktober 2004
Tomas Nordstrand, Basic Testing And Strength Design Of Corrugated Board And ContainersDivision of Structural Mechanics, LTH, Lund University,
Box 118, SE-221 00 Lund, Sweden.
Pentti kujala, Alan Klanac, Steel Sandwich Panels in Marine Applications Prihvaeno, 2005-05-05
Jani Romanoff Bending Response of Laser- Welded Web-Core Sandwich PlatesISSN (printed) 1795-2239.
Pentti Kujala Steel Sandwich Panels From Basic Research to Practical Applications 2Vol. 16/ISSN 0784-6010 2002
Narayan Pokharel and Mahen Mahendran Finite Element Analysis and Design of Sandwich Panels Subject to Local Buckling Effects
Pentti kujala ultimate strength analysis of all steel sandwich panelsRakenteiden Makaniikka,vol.31 Nrot 1-2,1998,s. 32-45
A.Gopichand , Design And Analysis Of Corrugated Steel Sandwich Structures Using Ansys , International Journal of Engineering Research &
Technology (IJERT) Vol. 1 Issue 8, October 2012.
378