You are on page 1of 20

Basins of Attraction of the Two-Dimensional

Poor Mans NavierStokes Equation


 

!#"%$&('()*+',-/.021*34(*321
56*3798*3;:<#">=?;@'(AB:DCFEGIHJ*321#BCK=ML&N4OP2ORQBS,OT2OVU
W XYX[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJb
;c8#">$&('()*+',-.021*34(*321def$g3)h*+'(8
56*3798*3;:<#">=?;@'(AB:DCFEGIHJ*321#BCK=ML&N4OP2ORQBS,OT2OVU
ABSTRACT

i bjlk,mj,]nVk,Z(bo jqp nkIrl^stn_[^J_ aJ^J _ a?mu/^Jkvrqr,^wZm^J_ jvr9k,`ZmrdxIjIy2_Rr9b r9 Z{z| ^2Z|}ry2~wjI`


aJkIj,Z]nV 
{ 0h^| j0` j, _ af jIZ|kImr9y_ nw Z]n jIy2jvr9|hj \\j9sc^Jk`j,_d nk,am ywj, ` nBr9^_ j0^Vs
r9` kI
` m_Rr6 ^ljmtq|k,F0Fl  ^J`r9 _ r9b F mk,}znBr9^_^sr,b Fr ^B  wm_ j, ^J_n + \x,^2^Jk6XnV_j
n]z2|k2r,^Jmj,~ X |`nBr9^_sckI^Jr,b  #\ _ Z|^wp kI|jIj,
  n]z2mk#r9^JV|j{|`nVr,^J_gr9^

/M` j,m_jI` Z(bh^ m jwn_ kI|p^JkIrk,mj,` }r9jwsckI^J j,`


j,|` m_RrM_` h|kIZ|n l_RzJmjIr9 aRnVr,^J_ jm_
^J` kk,mj,` }r9j{|hp bnjIjjp nZ|mY^J_r9bw` _ |kIjIr(nV_  _a^s0r9b fj,m_ j,}r9}z}ryor9^[_ r9n KZm^J_  }r9 ^J_ j
_ b mk,m_r%_[r9b  #\X |`nVr,^J_4%qj,_ajIy2jvr9|pnk,nwr9mk,jl |  _ ]nBr9sc^J` kIr,|m_oryp|j
^s6
/mbn]z ^JklnjIj,^2Z|nBr9|l}r9bdr9bjl\\dn_ <jIb ^Dnhp |j!^s6]nVZ(b i bj!jIr,` y j!n?p k,mZ|` kIj,^Jk
r9^r9b^Jj,n k,|nyw` _  mkI nDy< _Z|` kvzJ rIr9_a?jIy2jIr,|
 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_pnk,nhmr9mk zVn `|j^sGr,b B#\
0X r9^okI| mzVn_Rrp bRy2j, Z]n pnk9nVwr9|kIj |1R zJm ^2Z|}ryYak9n  |_Rr9j9n_j,p|Z|n Zm^J_ jI mk9nVr,^J_
l  
>aJ z|_dr,^r9b >Zm^J_ jI|` |_Z||j^sGr9b  j jvr9` yd^J_^J` k n
  ry?r,^? jIZ||kI_[np p Z]nV
qk9n_aJ|j^Vs

 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_p nk9nhmr,|kzVn ` |jsc^Jkr,b {n_n ^JaJ^J`jlB#\X 


i  r9  #\0X <`nBr9^_

1. Introduction

n kIaJ| y j, ` nVr9 ^J_ 0j^_ ^slr9b n_RyYp k,^j,p|Zmr, zdn]y2j?r9^gh^ m 0r,` k,
` |_Rr
^Dlj| i k9n r9 ^J_n Mm_r9n jp|kvsc^Jk,h_aw  k,mZmr>jI` nVr,^J_<^str,b  nDz2 |k#2r9^JV|j>m`nVr9 ^J_ j
^J_gaJk,  jr,bnVr>nk,jI`hZ| |_Rr9 }yoZ|^Jnk,jIsc^Jksc|nj,
Z]n Z|` nVr9 ^J_ jllb  nVrIr9mwpr,_ ahr9^dh^2 | 6r9b 
j,`
ak,2j,Z|n  nV_n ^a[^Vs r9b
 lmy2_ ^J  j{jIr9kI|jIj` jI_ a[ nkIaJ| }yob m` k, jIr,Zw {&h^ m j j,|
mk,wn_ ^ {-}
   
o_ r9b pnjIrqy2  _n_ XMZ]\>^J_^J` aJb     
bn]zp/^J _Rr9|^J`rr,bnVr
w^2 | _ ar,` k,
` |_Z|> _wr9bj0s;nVj,b  ^J_dnZr9`nV  yfZm^Jk,kI|jIp/^J_ j r9^w^2 m _ank,jvrI^k, mk!nz|Zmr,^J_
_Rr9mk9nZr9^_?
/r m|_jI`
aJkIj,Z|n !nV_ f nkIaJj,Z]nV  ^D l r,bwnjI|Z|^_ ^k, mk u/` j,}zJ!^Jp|k,nVr9^Jkm
i b my<p kI^Jp^Jj,V_ jvr9]nV r9^fh^ m 4r9bjIn }j,Z]nV %Zm^J_Rr9kI
`r,^J_jr9^?r9b  e2e27B*; |-(8 _
n>aJ|_ mk9n r,` k,
` m_ Z|!h^|  _ a%pk,^2Z||` k,!r9bmyr,|k, n  }r9}zJ r,` k,
` |_Rr mZ|^Jhp^Jj,}r9^_  i \
r9bnVr{ nj_Rr,k,^2 ` Z|m Z|^_ j,  |k,n
y|nk, mk{
Ry XMZ]\>^_ ^J` aJb n_ 0y nVr9mk        
[_Yr9b 
Z|` kIk,|_RrqzJmk,j, ^J_[^sK i \ r9b{jInV  }j,Z|n qzJ| ^Zm ryd | < j!k,|pk,|jI|_Rr9mo
Ry


lb |kI   Z]n_
/lz2m0|dnjr,b qj,wn  j,Z|n  p/^Jkvr9 ^J_w^Vs4r9b` jI`n 0f |Zm^Jhp/^JjI r,^J_f^s4 |p|_
 |_RrlzVnk,n
mj|

! #"  ! #" %
('*),+  -.  
+
$   & #" 
lb |kI  ! #" ! |_ ^Vr9|jqr9b  nkIaJ^kqkI|jI^J z|j,Z]nV p nkIr|_oF  jn_nVwp  r,`  >s;nZr9^Jk
 |kI zJm sckI^J0
/^J w^Ja^Jk,^Dz&j,Z|n  _ aJj jI|V |1R}
C 1 k, j,Z(b   2
4 3   jfn_ n_ jI^r9kI^JpRy Zm^Jk,kI|Zmr,^J_
Z|^Jhp `r,|oz2nwr,b  8D',-S+8*3?*3-}*3: bRy2p^r9b mj, j|hp ^DyJmg_oy_ nw Z? {h^ m j  |kIn_^
  5
n_  jr,b MxIjIr,^Z(bnVjIr9 ZznVk,nV
m~r9bnVrl _Rr9k,^2 ` Zm|j!r9br,` k,
` m_rv > ` Zmr,`nVr9 ^J_ jm
l|Zm|_Rr9 }y i \ bnj
|m_ sc`kIr9b|kdm_ bn_ Zm|
Ryr9b  kI|Zmr<|k,}zVnVr9 ^J_^sr,b g_ ^JkIn 7 6m|
jIr9^2Z(bnjvr9 Z zVnkIn
   sck,^J r9b  \>_ Zm^Jhp k,mj,j,
  /|`nBr9^_  XMZ]\>^_ ^J` aJb n_ 
`n_a  8 8
 i b jwxIp^2^Jk!nV_j  |`nVr,^J_ ~nj 1 kIjIZ(b    29
r9mk,h|[j,h nk `nV k9nVr,Z
npj|jnjIy2jIr,| ^s/ jIZ|k,r9qy2_nhZ|n |`nBr9^_ j0|k,}zJm` jI_ ann |k, _?p k,^2Z|m ` k,q^J_hr9b 
1 ^` k, |klpn_ |/_ Zm^Jhp k,mj,j,
  /m2` nVr9 ^J_on_haJbRrq
/{z2m0|onjr,b jIhp mjIrqp^Jjv
j,
 [xIjIb | w^2 | ~ j,m0^Jb k -}:
   
^s6r9b  |`nVr,^J_ i b  #\X <|`nVr,^J_
j!aJ}zJ|_[b mk,
J =; <?>C!K M
J L G ;<?>C!NE<?>C 
;=<?>@BA&C  ; <D>EC&F=GIH 
NE<?>@BA&C  5N <D>EC&F=OPH QJ N5?< >C!K JRL O ;<D>EC&N5<?>CTS

JnR



\>}u4mk,m_r,n
 qy2_nhZ]nV /jvyjvr9mwjln_ jIZ|k,r9>y_ nw Z]n jIy2jvr9|hj|j,` Z(b[nj!Fj| Rbn]zJ

/m|_ jvr9`   |&sc^Jk^Dz|kn[Z|m_r,` kIy  ^J _ Z]nkVU  W


]n_ ar9^MnV_yjIaJ_ Z|n_Rr_ _ aj| 1 ^Jk
_sc^JkInBr9^_^J_r9b  jtj,`
YXI|Zmr0k,sc|ktr,b k,|n mkKr9^>r,b k,z2m
Ry.l` m    E W
Rn_ r9^>r9b r9r
^s    aJ^2^ G-}Z
   
6rj m  _ ^Dl_r9b nVrt\\2jjI` Z(b?njF2jm RGnk,Z]np n
^s p k,^2 ` Zm_ a
 [>_ fbRy2p/^r,b |jIjm6pk,^Jp^Jj,m
\
y q` m  ?n_  i nm_ j   W25

'()2B*+' r9 wjI|kI|j  Xn]yJ   W nJ


.
nw^_ a^r9b|k,jmjtr9b nVrFr9` kI
` |_ Zmq jnZ(bn^r,Z!p b m_ ^Jh|_ ^_ k9nVr,b |kFr9b n_hnk,n_  ^ ^J_ ]Fn_ fj
nwZ|^_ j,m2`|_ Zm?^sn xvjIr9k,n_ aJnVrIr9k9nVZmr9^k,~^VsKr9b  /|`nBr9^_l ^r,b_` h|k, Z]n 6n_p bRy2j, Z]n
p/mk, wm_r,j|t _ Z| `   _ ar9b ^JjI^sl^J `
Yn_  |_j,^J_     8
6bn]zJdpk,^Dz2 m j,` pp/^Jkvrsc^k{r,b j
r9b m^JkIy^VsKjvr9k9nV_ aJ{nVr,r,k9nZr9^JkIjlnjl^Jp p^Jj,m[r,^?r9b sc^JkIwmk nV_ n`^JpsKbRy2p/^Vr9b mj,jl^sKnr9^JkI^J n
nVr,r,k9nZr9^JkZ|^JkIk,|jIp/^_  _adr9^n_gzJmk_ Zmk,]nVj,_ad_` 
|k>^sZ(bnVk9nZr9|kIjvr9Z{sck,m2`|_ Zm|j ] n_ n`
n_  }scj,b }^r 6V  2


i b aJ^RnV R^s^J` k6Z|`k,k,m_RrK0^Jk,j r,^%_sc` j,Z(bn^r,Zy2_nhZmj _Rr9^qw^2 | jG^sr,b  jI`


aJkIj,Z]nV 
` Zmr,`nVr,^J_ jG^s2r9bz| ^Zm ry>`j,_alr,b  #\ X {|`nBr9^_r,^lp k,^2 ` ZmjIpnVr,n y%n_ r9mwp^Jk9nV  y
nZ|Zm` k9nVr, #\r9`k,
` |_ Zmlj,` nVr,^J_j _^r9!r9b^J` aJb?r9b nVr2`|jIr,^J_jZm^J_ Zm|k,__ ar9b !kI]n 76|n
  ry
^s \r,` k,
` m_ Z||_ bnV_ Z|{  w}r(nVr,^J_ j0^s #\j,` nVr,^J_j(sr9b  #\X [|`nVr,^J_[j!r9^

/w` j,m _ Y^k i \ nVjp kI^Jp/^j,|4Kr9b  (B8*38#";I2'*+B ^sr,b dnVsc^k,|h|_Rr,^J_ m \\
` jIrh
M|  _ ]nBr9|4 [>_ }y r9b m_Z|n_ 0Z(b^^JjIMjI`  r9n
k9n_ a|jh^s>pnVk9nhmr,|k?zVn ` mj?r9^&
/
` j,m_fr9bqpk,^2Z||jIj ^s/Z|`kIzJq r,r,_ ap|kIh|_Rr(nV nVr(nj,^r9b nVrk,| nVr9 ^J_ jIb p jF
mr0|m_r9b%\\

 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_pnk,nwr9mk,jFn_?p bRyjIZ|n zVnk,n


|j |1R zJm ^2Z|}ryak9n  |_Rr9j9Z]nV_h
 r9mk,h_ mK

nj, _^s6nVrIr9k9nVZmr9 ^J_ ^2^Jj,m yf _ |4j!nZm ^JjI|j,rl^s6_ }r9n Z|^J_  r,^J_ jr9bnBr!p k,^2 ` Zm|j!jIh nVk
^J_ aBr9mk,
|bn]z2^Jksc^Jk>aJ}zJ|_ozVn ` |j^Vs0
 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_Mpnk9nVwr9|kIj  %  aJ^2^2 - }    
s 
lj,b r9^  m  _ ]nVr,[r,b |jIo
njI_ jh ` jIr` j,Z|^Jhp `r9nVr9 ^J_n y 4 hZ|m_Rrp k,^p/mkIr9 |jhr9bnVrZ]n_
Z|^J_ jIjvr9|_Rr, yY jvr9_aJ` jIbY
mr0|m_ r,b wn_Ry&p/^j,j,
hry2p/mj^sl ^_ aMr,|k,
|bn]z2^k|oq|kI 
_RzJmjIr9 aRnVr,zVnk, ^J` j0\\hp kI^Jp|kIr,mj|jvr(nVr,jvr9Z|n `n_Rr9}r9mj|n_ r,` k,
` m_ Z|>p nk9nhmr,|kIj0sc^Jk` j,
_<r9b  jZ|npnZm ryMn_ Mhp mwm_r!r,b ^JjIsc^J` _r9^w
/{w^jIrj,` ZmZ||jIjIsc` tnj _   Z]nVr,^Jk,jl^sF
nj, _ j^Vs
nVr,r,k9nZr9^_^sr,b nVp p _aJj|Fj| Rsc^k!j,| |Zr9 z| }yZ(b ^JjI|_jImr,j^s
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_pnk,nwr9mk,j|
2. Mathematical Formulation

|kI0l j,` hwnk, 6|r9b  |kI zVnVr,^J_<^str,b  #\ 0X Mm2` nVr9 ^J_aJ z|_ _Mh^JkI r(n
q

yYX[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJbYn_  q`n_ a  8 8 5


  h
|aJ _l}r9br9b  
\ _ Zm^Jhp k,mj,j,
  / |`nVr,^J_
p k, ^ XImZmr,| _Rr9^hn?  z|k,a|_ ZmsckI|^J
^J zdjIpnZ|3
 $  $  
  $    $ 

  

 nR



n ^J_al r9br,b  1 ^` k, |k!pnV_  |[zJm ^2Z| ryk,mp k,mj,|_Rr9nVr9 ^J_ j53
 &  " 

;  "    & 

2 nR

 

2

 !  "  
N  "   & S
 
 r9b m_onjIj,` hr9b {
njIjlsc` _ Zmr,^J_j|  nk,{_<r9b {j,p nZ|   r,bnVrlr9b yMnk,{  z|kIaJ|_ Zm+sck,|
n_ ^kIr9b^JaJ^J_nV +n_ {r9bnBr6r,b myx,nVZmr6  |~qZ|^wp p/^J_|_Rr9n j l r,bkI|j,p|ZrKr,^ }u4mk,m_r,nVr,^J_4
0ydnVp p y2 _ an{n |kI2 _p kI^Zm| `k,n_r9b %^JkIr,b ^JaJ^J_ n }ry?Z|^J_jIr9k,n_Rr0lb  %k,r(n _ _a^J_ yh^J_ 
n]zJzJmZmr,^Jk}rljsc^J`_ r9bnVrlr,b |`nVr,^J_ jqn
^DzJj, wp  s3yfr,^
; 
N 


J  < A&C ;"! J# < ! C ;YN J

%$'&($ !^; 

J*) < A&C&N ! J) < ! C&;YN J

$+&,$ ! NS

 nR



_Fj|  0bn]zJ jI` p p kI|jI|?r9b  j,`


j,Z|kIprK_ ^r9nVr9 ^J_ 3Vr,b   - nV_  ).- 0/    nk,0njIj,^2Z|nBr9|
l r9bn mk,_<r9kIp p k, `Zmr9j jI|?& X[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJbonV_ oq`n_ a  8 8 5
n_ 21jqnh_ ^Jk,wn 76]nBr9^_

Z|^J_ jvr(n_Rr|tjI_ ansc^JkI nkIF` |kGp Z|}rr9 wKjIr9mp _r,|aJk,nVr9 ^J_n_{r,b n aJm
k9nVZtjI`
jIr, r,`r9 ^J_
QJ 


$+& $ ! 

 < A&C

y |  jlF2jm R
scmnVj,p|Zmr,j>^sr9b  j mk,}znBr9^_MnVk,^Vstpnkvr9 Z|` nklhp/^Jkvr(n_Z| 1 ^Jk,mw^Jjvrqjlr9bnVr%Fj| R
nk,_ ^r!n` _ ` %k,|jI` r ^s6Fj|  2
`r^J_ yh^J_%^sG __ }r9| }y?wn_RyZ(b ^Z|mj|pnkIr,Zm` nkI yr,bnVr
Z|^JkIk,|jIp/^_  _ar9^{r9b k,r9|_Rr,^J_w^s^J_ yf^J_ qn]z%zJmZmr9^k| nVj,j,`wmr9^{
/_wnk,n_ aJqj,` hZm|_Rr, y
b aJb&r9^M
/h^s!` jId_&j,`
aJk, jIZ]n wh^2 | _ a  1n`r9 ^J_` jIr
/w|kIZ| j,| lb|_Z|^_ j,  |kI_ a
r9b ` _  z|kIj9n  ry<^sFjI^J `r9^_ jqr,^dFj| R!
/mZ]n`j,}r j_ ^Dl_or,bnVrqr9h jIZ|kImr9 6]nVr,^J_[Z]nV` j,mj
|k,kI^Jk,j _dr9b>j,^J `r9 ^J_ j0^s6  u/|kI|_Rr9n /m`nVr9 ^J_ jmnj_ ^Vr9|<
Ry0aJaJ%n_ < ^b    29
 1 ` kvr9b mkv
w^JkIk,m nVr,^J_j,b  p jl
/r m|_gr9b  |* "@2(',;*+B,98 F=G F=O L G L O ln_ opby2jIZ|j>nk,{_ ^r
jIr9k,nabrIsc^JkI nkIYnV_ nVk,?  j,Z|`j,j,m
Ry&XMZ|\>^J_ ^J` abn_q`n_ a   8 8 5
fmk,?0hl  KkI|jvr9k, Zmr
^J` kqjIr9`yMr,^hr,b jI`
jIpnZ|^sFpnk,nhmr9mkqzVn ` |jllb mk, F=G  F=O  F nV_  L G  L O  L  i b |jI
nk,0_ ^rtZm^Jhp r9| }y{nk,
 r9k,nkIyZ(b^JZm|j|Jnj F=G n_ F=O bn]zJ r,b j9nVw0k,| nVr9 ^J_ jIb pr9^qr9b Z
 lmy2_ ^  j
_2`
/mk|
`r%nk,{p kIwnk, ywn{sc^JklZm^Jwp`r(nVr,^J_ n 4r9k,nZmr9n
  ry 1 k,^ r9b  jq0Z|n_Zm^J_ Zm `  
r9bnVr% fwnDyM
?^Jw}r,r,_ awj,^Jhp bRy2j, Z]n yMk,]nV jvr9 Z
|bn]z2^Jkm^Jk>p^JjIj,
 yM_Rr9kI^ `Z|_ap bRyjI}
Z]n y|k,kI^J_ m^J` j
/mbn]z2^JkmR
y^J_ yZ|^_ j,  |kI_ a{Fj| Jl r9bfnVk,
}r9k9nVkIy
 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_p nk9nhmr,|kIj|
 `r]r9b sc^Zm` j%b mk, j%jIp/mZ| Z]n y<^J_r,b u4mZmr,j^s_ }r9n Z|^_   r,^J_j^J_Mr9b jI^J `r9^_ j^VsFr9b 
#\ 0X |`nBr9^_n_ r,b |jIZ]n_M
/p k,mj,m_r,|h^JjIrZ| ]nkI y
Ry[hp mwm_Rr9_awFj| Rlnj
{bn]zJ{ ^J_ b mk,V
i ^<Z|^J_Rr,_` 4 sF0wnVk,r,^ | _ |nVr9{r9b ?
nVj,_j>^s0nVr,r,k9nZr9 ^J_o^sFj| Rq0?` jIr>
/fn
 
r9^gnZmZ|` k,nVr9m yY jvr9 _ aJ`  j,b jI^J `r,^J_&ry2p/mj?_n_ n`r9^nVr,Zfs;nj,b^J_ `j,_aoj,^J `r9 ^J_p nk9nhmr,|k
znV ` mj{Z|n Zm` nBr9| `k,_a[r,b w}r9mk9nVr,^J_gjI|` |_Z||jm<%_Ryj,` Z(bpnk9nVwr9|k` jIr
/f4 wZmm_r{r9^
Z]n Z|` nVr9{n_ M_ ^rqk,m` kIZm|jIj, z?Z|^Jhp `r,|kqjIr,^Jk9na
|Z|n` j,njqn_Ry 8 r,k99n XImZmr9^k,mjwn]y

/Z|^_ j,  |kI|[ ` k, _ ahn?j,_aJ kI` _ i b |kI{nk,r9bk,|wn_Zm njIj,mj^sj,^ `r,^J_pnVk9nhmr,|k,jr,bnVr


Zm^J_ j,  |ksc^k r9b  jp ` kIp/^j,y2_nVw Z]n jIy2jIr,|hjlj,p|Z|}ZaJ|_ mk9n 4jIr(nBr9jvr9 Z]n n_dr9` kI
` m_ Z|
j,p|Z|}Z[pnk9nVwr9|kIj| i b MkI|wn_ |k?^sr9b  jfj,|Zr9 ^J_ j? |  Z]nVr,| r9^& jIZ|` jIj,_aYr9b|j,<r9bk,|
ryp|jq^spnk,nwr9mk,j|

2.1 Dynamical systems specific parameters

\ r9mk,h_  jIr9 Z_ ^J_ _]nktjvy2jIr9mwj0j,` Z(bnjF2jm Rtbn]zJq


||_wp k,^p/^JjI|fr9^ mj,Z|kI
%n` }r9
>
r9`   ^sp bRy2j,Z|n pk,^2Z||jIj,mj _ Z| `   _ aqr,` k,
` m_ Z| _bRy2 k,^2y2_nhZmj   ^Jb k 6-    
 l` | 
n_  i nV|_ jm   W5
n_    ^JkI !- }   W
Zm^J_ Zm|_Rr9k,nVr9 ^J_ jq^stjIp/mZ|mj _MZ(b|hZ]nV k,]nVZmr9 ^J_ j
 q^u4wn_ - }    W
4n_ g
 ^J ^aJZ|n p/^p ` nBr9^_y2_nhZmj  Xn]yJ  W

n_ gj,`
j,m2`|_Rr
n_n }yjIjt^Vs/jI` Z(bfjIy2jIr,|hjbnjF
||_?0|  ^2Z|` h|_Rr9mF\\jKp k,^2 ` Zmlnjtr9b mk m__ a^J`r,p `rn
r9hj,mk,mjFnj6r9b 0 r9mk9nVr,^J_{p kI^Zm| ` kIp kI^JaJk,mj,jI|j|FjKjvr(nVr,|?
Ry q` m      W9
Br9b mj, r,hjI|kI|j
` j,`nV  yb 
 rr9k,n_ j, |_Rr0
/mbn]z ^Jksc^J  ^0|h
Rywn_Ryw^_ ^Vswn_Ry?ryp|j0^s jvr(nVr,^J_nVkIy?
|bn]z2^k|
k9n_ a_ ad _oZ|^wp  ry[sck,^jvr9]nVyr,^Z(bn^r,Z/r9bnVr>Z|^JkIk,|jIp/^_ gr9^ndpnVkIr9 Z|` nk ;;,2'B ^Jk
j,`
jIpnZmd^s ) ^J_Ylb  Z(br9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkImj^sr,b h r9mk9nVr,^J_j{Zm^J_RzJmk,aJV_ aJbRr{^sr,b jmr,b aJ^Jn
^sqy2_nhZ]nV jIy2jvr9| nV_n y2jIj jw^jIr?^s3r,|_r9^&nVr ]nVjIr?`n  r9nVr9}zJ| }yJt}sq_ ^rf`n_Rr9}r(nVr, z| y
 mr,|k,h_>r9b aJm^Jwr9kIZjIr,k,` Zr9` kI^sKr,b {nVr,r,k9nZr9^Jk
| _ afZ|^J_j,|k,m
i bh^JjIr0| 2_^l_d\\?p nk9nhmr,|kmr,b !r9 w!jI|k, |jmnjF0ql  jI|Vy2m  jF` jImsc` k,mj,` }r9j

sc^Jkwn_`n J _ j,p|Zr9^_^J_ yqlb m_ |n  _ a l}r9br9b Fh^Jjvrr9kI z2n V


/mbn]z2^JkIj| *;;| DjIr,]nyVp|kI^2 ZV
^DsckI|` |_Zmy&j,`
bnk,h^J_  Zn_ &  z|kIaJ|_Rr] i b|k,sc^Jk,h h` jvrkI| }y^J_Yh^JkIhjI^Jp b  jIr,Z]nBr9|
n_n }y2r,Z|n /r,^^J j_<^J`kqjI^J `r9^_ m_r, Z|nVr9 ^J_p kI^Zm| ` kI
i bh^JjIrhZ|^wh^J_ }yk,sc|k,m_ Z|m\\pnk9nVwr9|kIjnVk,<r9b  yRnp `_ ^Dz_` 
|kwn_  yRnB
p ` _ ^DzMp/^_ |_Rr]  _  _ aZ(bnVk9nZr9|kIjvr9Z^sF }u4mk,m_r,n
 y2_nhZ|n GjIy2jIr,|hj>j 8D8*3*37D*3;:
#*3*3*;-F'(Be*3;*+B8 1! i b  yRnp` _ ^Dz_` 
/mk>p k,^Dz2|j>nww|nj,` kI^str,b k,nVr9r9bnBr%r0^
_ }r9nV  yY_ |nk,
Ryr,k99n XImZmr,^Jk, |jdjI|pnk,nVr9onjr9 w[mz^J z|jm>n_  r9b  yJnp ` _ ^Dzp/^_ |_Rr<jwr9b 
_nVr9`k9n G ^aRnk,}r9b ^str9b yRnp` _ ^Dz_` 
/mk jI^Jhmr9 wmjkImscmk,k,mr9^njr,b Z(b nk9nZr9mk,jvr9 Z
p/^J_|_Rr i b ^J` abfr,b mynk,0s;nkI yaJ^2^_   Z]nVr,^Jk,j^sry2p/mj^s
/mbn]z ^Jk|Vr9b Z|n Zm` nBr9^_^sr9b|j,
pnk9nVwr9|kIjkI|`  k,|j{r9b hmzVn `nVr,^J_&^s r,b  W nVZ|^J
n_&nVr,k, g^sr,b hjIy2jIr,| nVr|nZ(b }r9|k,nVr9 ^J_
n_ `j,q^s4r,b jFr9^{Z|^_ jIr,k,` Zr!np k,^2 ` Zr wnVr9kI}/ i bjp k,^2Z|mj,j0j_` wmk, Z]n y`_ jIr9n
qn_wr9b` j
l  /_ ^rq
` j,mb mk,
_f^Jk,
}rKr,bnVrt jt_ ^J_p/mk,^2  Z n_hb njFn>p^Jj,}r9 z yRnVp ` _ ^Dz?p^J_ m_Rrjt _ mwnVjFn>Z(bn^r,Z
^Jk,
}r]% ^_ al r9b 1%Z(bn^Vr9Zl^JkI
 r,jn jI^b 
}rFlbnVr0jF_ ^Dl_njnaJ|^wr9k, Z]n yoxvsck9nVZmr(nV ~
nVr,r,k9nZr9^Jkm 1 k,nZmr9n JaJm^Jwr9kI|jGnVk,F ^2^JjI| y _ |njr9b^Jj,Fr9b nVrGbn]zJZ|^Jhp 
^J` _nk, |jmB^Vs3r9|_
k,|p]nBr9|jIr9kI` Zmr,` k,mj jI| sj, w nkI ry nV_ nMZ(b nk9nZr9mk,jvr9 ZxIjI7 6|m~h]njI` k, ^s3r,|_ kImscmk,k,mr9^
njdn_njIy2hpr9^Vr9Z[^Jkhp bRy2j,Z|n qw|nj,` kI!^Jkh  wm_ j, ^J_r9bnBr jw_ ^Vrdn__Rr9maJ|km _ aJ|_|k9nV +
Z||kvr(n _wwnp p_ aJjnVk,qZ|^J_ jI mk,mdnj` j,sc` _h2r9k,nZmr,_ a{_sc^Jk,wnVr9 ^J_?n
^J`rr,b jZ(bnk,nZmr,|kIjIr,Z
w|nj,` kI |1R ^J _ Z]nVVk  U wnp jmVr,h| n]y{wnp j|n_ pbnj, p/^Jkvr9k,n r,j  l` | V  W
 %  aJ^2^2
>- } E  
 i b |jIwry2p|j^Vswnp p  _ aJjp kI^ `Z|fz j,`nV  y_Rr9mk,mjIr9 _ aMn_ &_sc^JkInBr9 z?p ^Vr9j
n_ &_r9bhZ|nj,h^s  | nDyonpjnVk,fpnkvr^Vs!n<_ |Zm|j,j,nkIy&jvr9|p_k,mZ|^J_ jvr9kI` Zmr,_ an_nBr,r9k,nZmr,^Jk
sck,^J pnVkIr9n FnVr9nnj{sckI^J nV
/^Jk,nVr9^kIyop/mk,h|_Rr,j(
`rnk,h` j,m mj,j _&r,|kIwj{^sln`r9^JwnVr9 Z
Z]n Z|` nVr9 ^J_d^sk,m mzVn_Rrqpnk,nhmr9mk,j!jI` Z(bonj!0nVk,nVrIr9|hpr,_ a?b mk,V
i b^J` aJbr,b |kIdnkIw`_  ^J`
r9| ywn_Ry^r9b mky_ nw Z]n jvyjvr9mwjZ(bnk9nVZmr9mk, 6]nVr,^J_ j |j,p
Z|nV  yZ|^k,k,m nVr,^J_f  wm_ j, ^J_hn_  /^J h^JaJ^JkI^Dzm_r,k,^JpRylbZ(bw0nk,ls;n _ ar9^{Z|^J_ jI mk|2w^jIr
nk,?jIh nVklr,^r9b ^JjIhn
/^Dz?_or9b nVrr9b ynkI?Z|^Jhp `r9nVr9 ^J_n y<_  hZ| |_Rr^Jk>kI|` kI&xI
n
Ry2j,}rI
r9_aJ~
Ryor9b f` jI|k ` kI_ ar,b fZ]n Z|` nVr9 ^J_ i b2`j|G fl K_ ^rmwp ^DyonV_yoy2_nhZ]nV tjIy2jIr,|
j,p|Z|}Zpnk,nwr9mk,j!sc^Jk!j,^ `r,^J_Z(bnVk9nZr9|kI7 6|nVr9 ^J_<_dr9b{pk,|jI|_Rr>jvr9` yJ
2.2 General statistical parameters

 wn9XI^Jk,}ry%^Vsn Jp/^j,j,
jI^J `r,^J_Z(b nk9nZr9mk,76|nVr9 ^J_pnk,nwr9mk,j6Z|^Jhtr9^q` jGsck,^J r,b F| ^Vs
jIr(nBr9jvr9 Z]n nV_n y2jIj jI|%XMZ]\>^_ ^J` aJb F-}   
sc^Jktr9kI]nVr,wm_r^s/r9b mj,q_hnk,| nVr9mwZm^J_Rr9r(
i b h^JjIr{Zm^Jwh^J_aJm_ |k,n jIr(nBr9jvr9 Z]n tpk,^Jp|kvryY jr9b fr9 wfn]zJmk9na^sn_^J
j,|kvzVn
f^s r9b 
jIy2jIr,|[z|k,naJ|jm6n ^J_al r,bor9b ?wnBwnn_gw _ wnnk,?|nj, y[Z|^wp `r9|gl}r9bgh_  n
jIr9^k9naJ{k,m` kI|h|_Rr9jm/
`r%p kI^Dz  {  rIr9 >` j,sc` 6_sc^JkInBr9^_n
^J`rqr9b {jIr,k,` Zr9` k,n 6np p]nk,n_ Z|
^sGr9b %r,h%jI|k, |jln_Z]n_ _^r!
` j,m[b|k,V i b jIr9nVr9 jIr9 Z]n `n_Rr9}r9 |j zVnkIn_ Zm>n_[jvr(n_nk,
 mz2nBr9^_p kI^z2  h^Jk,_sc^JkInBr9^_[r,bn_r,b ?n]zJmk9naJVyJr_ |}r9b mk>j%n
r9^ jvr9_aJ` jIb

r m|_&nwp|kI^2 Zr9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkvynV_ gnjvr9]nVyMr,k99n XImZmr,^JkIy i b` j>r9b|j,nk,n jI^` _ jI`  r9n
sc^Jkq` j,
_<j,^J `r9 ^J_Z(bnk,nZmr,|kI7 6]nBr9^_[ _dr9b p kI|jI|_Rr>jvr9` y
 w^k,`j,msc` Kpnk,nhmr9mk jr,b Z|^k,k,m nVr,^J_[^stzVnkIn
 |jm_Mr9b Z|nj,^sF^J` k%\\[0Z]n_
Z]n Z|` nVr9%r,b Z|kI^Jj,jqZ|^JkIk,m nVr,^J_
mr0|m_Mr9b @ n_  7 z| ^Zm ryZm^Jwp^J_ m_Rr9jqnj
   
      


H  <D>EC J  K H  ?< >C J  K
>  A











! 
 <D>EC J  ! 
?< >C J
>  A
>  A


  jlr9b Z|^JkIk,|jIp/^_  _ad_ ^JkIM/n_ o^Dz|kv


lb |kI    |_ ^r,|j%r,b ` jI`n  !  _ _ mk%p kI^ `Zmr] 

nk,j_   Z]nVr,wr,b dr9 wwn]zJ|k,naJVY_ ^r9b|k wp^JkIr9n_Rrjvr(nVr,jIr,Z|n p k,^Jp|kvry  _r9b kI|jI]nkIZ(b ^Vs
  u/|kI|_Rr9n
{y2_nhZ|n GjIy2jIr,|hj>jlr9bp/^D0|kj,p|Zmr,k9n  |_j, ry \4q|kI0bn]zJ`j,|n
jIr(nV_ nkIdk9n} s;njIr 1 ^J` kI|kFr,k9n_ jvsc^Jk, 1 1Ki tr9^Z|^J_ jvr9kI` Zmr0r9b \ r9^Z|^J_ k, ^J` kj,^ `r,^J_
ryp|jm
`rl_ ^Vrlnjln_<n`r9^JwnVr9 Z]n yRZ|n Zm` nBr9|?jI^J `r9^_dZ(bnk,nZmr,|k, 6]nVr,^J_p nk9nhmr,|k l r,bdr9b 
Z|mpr9 ^J_njl_ ^r,|[_MmZ^sp kI^ `Z|_ah^Dz|k9nV  kI|aJ wwnp j9
2.3 Turbulence specific parameters

i 0^p nk9nhmr,|kIj>r9bnVr{^DzJmk, npZ]nVr,|aJ^JkImjnVk,?j,Vml_ mj,j?nV_ &nVr9_ mj,jm ^Vr9b&nk,fjvr(nVr,jIr,Z|n


p k,^Jp|kvr9 |j_gr,bnVrr9bmygZ(bnVk9nZr9|kI76mfr,b Yxvr(nV ~^sn  jIr,k,
`r9 ^J_   ` wmk| W
 i |_ _|mj
n_  `w myJ  W
  Z]nV Z|` nVr,>r9b j,Vml_ mj,j>^Vsr,b zJ| ^Zm ryZ|^Jhp/^_ |_Rr9jqnjm



J

A  A >  A H  <?>C  K
S



! 



J
!
  ! 

A  A >  A  <?>C 
i b {nVr9_ mj,jm^k!2`kIr9^j,jm^sKn?z| ^Zm ryZm^Jwp^J_ m_Rr! {Z]n Z|` nVr9l r9br,b |`nVr,^J_


 


H  <?>C J  K
A
8

>  A
A
 
S


!
!

J !
 ! 

A  A >  A  <?>C 
_ Zmr,b |jIfnk,^s3r9m_g` j,mg_op|kIh|_Rr(nV 6r,` k,
` |_Z|jvr9`   |j%0 jIrqr9b| _r,b jZ]nVr,|aJ^Jkvy
n_ [` j,
^r9bMnj!j,^ `r,^J_Z(bnVk9nZr9|kI76|nVr9 ^J_<pnk9nVwr9|kIj|
_ ^r,b |kt wp^Jkvr(n_Rrp bRyjIZ|n h]njI` k,mwm_Rrtr9bnBrtj^s3r9m_?nV   jr9b!n]zJ|k,naJ _ mr,Z m_ |kIay
^sr,b ` Zr9`nVr,^J_j| i b jzVnkIn
 > j!aJ z|_[
yr,b sc^Jk,` n

 

$  ! K
H  !


>  A

H  <?>C J  K ! $

H  <?>C J  K ! S

i bYkI|wn_  _ a pnVk9nhmr,|k|hp ^y| sc^Jkj,^ `r,^J_Z(b nk9nZr9mk,76|nVr9 ^J_ _r9bjjIr,` y  jdr9b 
j,|Zm^J_ ^Jk,|k%jvr9kI` Zmr,` k,{sc` _ Zmr,^J_4  {_ ^r,r9b nVrlr9b {sc^Jk, 0` jI jq_^rr,b `j,`n G^J__Rz^J zR
_ ar9bh u/|k,m_ Z|f
mr0|m_zVn ` mj^s!n`n_Rr, rynVrr0^MjIpnVr,n t ^Z|nVr9 ^J_ jm
`r{k9nBr9b mkndsc^JkI
_Rr9kI^ `Z||
Ry W m_ j,m_ -}  E  5
j,p|Z|}Z]nV  y[sc^Jk>jvr9` y _ a<j,b m  th^2 | j| 1 ^k%r9b 
    ^JkI |k
jIr9kI` Zmr,` k,sc` _ Zr9 ^J_r9b  jr(nV|jlr9b sc^JkI
  

$

 
> $

lb |kI   j{r,b jIb | 0 _  B3n_   j{r,b |p|_  m_Rr?znVk,nV


f^sr,b     j,b m  tn_    _ ^D
 |_ ^Vr9|j!r,b r9hn]zJmk9na i b {\\> d
/m_ a?Zm^J_ j,  |kI|[b |kI| _MbnVjlnfjIp/mZ|}ZjIr9kI` Zmr,` k,{_dr,bnVr
 r{Z|^J_j,jvr9j^s!^J_ }y&nMjI_ aJ fj,b m    
`r{r9b mk,nk,fr ^MznVk,nV
mjnVj,j,^2Z|nVr9mYl}r9bYr,bnVr
j,b m  +  >b nDzZ|^J_jIr9kI` Zmr,|<jIr,k,` Zr9` kI>sc` _ Zr9^_ j
nVj,|<^J_^J_ yh^J_>^s r9b|j,`j,_ar9b sc^Jk,` n
R
  ; !  S

!
i b2`j|r9b mj,qnk,!Zm ^JjI| }yk,m nVr,|r,^
`r_ ^Vr m_r,Z|n l r,b6r,b l2 _ mr,Zm_ |kIay?^s4F J  i b 


k,]nV |k j _ ^?^J`


rln] nk,%^sGr9b >a|_ mk9n /Z|^J_ _|Zmr,^J_
mr0|m_<2 _ mr,Z|_ mk,aydn_ j,mZ|^J_^JkI |k
jIr9kI` Zmr,` k,[sc` _ Zr9^_ jnV_  r,jf` j,M_ Z|^J_ jvr9kI` Zmr,^J_^Vs /^J h^JaJ^k,^Dz jIZ]n _ aJj naRn _ jI| 1 kIj,Z(b
  2

3. Results and Discussion

q|kIl0l pk,|jI|_Rr0k,|jI` r,jF^J


r9n_ msck,^J^J` kK_2`wmk,Z|n p/mk,h|_Rr,jF^J_?r9b l\\^s/Fj|
R i b >r ^fwn_aJ^Rn j ^sGr9bjjvr9` ynk,%r,^? mr,|kIw _ %r9bw^Jjvr! hZm|_Rr! n]y^s6 | _ |nVr9 _ a
r9b l
njI_ j^snVr,r,k9nZr9 ^J_?^s Fj| Rtn_ fr9b m_wr,^{mr9mk,h_ !r,b l
nj, _ j^s nBr,r9k,nZmr,^J_sc^k0njIn
j,`
jImr{^sFr,b ?|_Rr9 k,p nk9nhmr,|k>jIpnZm? k9n]l_aZ|^J_ Zm ` jI^J_j>Z|^J_Z||kI_ _a<r,k,m_  jn_ gjvr9kI` Zmr,` k,mj
l r9bgkI| nVr9}zJ wp^JkIr9n_ Zmr9^Zm` kIz? r,r,_ adr,b  #\ X o|`nVr,^J_ j
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_opnk,nhmr9mk,j
r9^&p/mk, wm_r9n !nVr9n i b |kImsc^JkI _ abr^s%r,b < jIZ|` jIj,^_ jw^VsmZ [_RzJmjIr,aRnVr,r9b 

nj, _ j^snVrIr9k,nZmr,^J_nj r9|kIw _ |


Rywr9b     Z|^JkIk,| nVr9 ^J_2j,Vml_ mj,j|nVr,_ |jIj|  _ mr,Z>m_ |kIayJ
n_ jI|Zm^J_ ^Jk, mk%jvr9k,`Zmr9`k,sc` _Zmr9 ^J_[Z|^J_Rr9^` k,jm i bjlnj%nZ|Zm^Jhp  j,b mM
Ry[  z2  _ a?r,b ^Jp|_
` _  r0j,`nVk,>^sGZm^J_Rr9 _2`^J` j _  r,n Zm^J_  }r9 ^J_ j ( 1%j9sc^Jk0jm J_Rr,^|`nV  yhjIpnZ|m( 1%aJk,  j
8 lb|k, ;   N         _gj,| |ZrZ]njI|j 
w|nj,` kI_ a   
J
 
J

n jI^zVnkIy[r9b gxIaJk, jIpnZ| _ aJ~d`j,_adznV ` mj%^s ^s 8 S 8R 8 S 8 8 S 88 2 nV_  8 S 8 8R 2 r9^d r9mk,h_ 
 str,b 
njI_o
^J` _nk, |j%np p]nkqsck9nZr(n  1 ^Jkn  6^str,b 
njI_ j%p k,mj,|_Rr,|b |kIr9br9 w{j,mk,mj|
p/^D0|kqj,p|Zmr,k9nhn_ <p bnVj,{p/^Jkvr9k,n r,j mk,{p ^Vr,r9mr9^fZ|^J_k, r,b ryp^sj,^J `r9 ^J_
X[^JjIr!^Vs r9b >Z|n Zm` nBr9^_ jk,|p^Jkvr9|d0|kIp/mkIsc^JkIwm _dj,mk,mj^Jk0pnk9nV  m w^2 q` j, _ a ^J`

p k,mZ|jI^J_nk,}r9b hmr,Zf^J_&r9b %` p|kI ^JhjIy2hwr9kIZh` r,p kI^Zm|jIj,^JknVr{r9b _ }zJ|kIj,}ryY^Vs
/m_Rr9` Z(Ry 1 ^Jhp `r,_ a 1 m_Rr9|km0  }r9^_n Z|^Jhp `r9nVr9 ^J_ j00|kIn>^J_[n?% W J  8 0^JkI2jvr(nB
r9^_M _[r,b  1 ^Jhp `r9nVr9 ^J_n 1 `  [\%y_ nw Z|j n
^Jk9nVr,^JkIy[nBrqr,b q_  z|kIj, ry<^Vs /|_Rr9` Z(Ry i b 
k,` _ jaJ|_|k9nV  yZm^J_ jIjIr,| ^Vs 2 8  r9mk9nVr,^J_j{^VslF2jm Rsc^k|nZ(b j,r^s_ }r9nV tZ|^J_  r,^J_ jm
;   N   i bw njIr 8 }r9mk9nVr,^J_ j mk,h` j,mY _r,b hnp p kI^Jp kInVr,jIr9nVr9 jIr9 Z]n tn_n }yjI|j^s|ZV 
^D mkjIp/mZmr,k9n? mk,Z|^Jhp `r,|<` jI_ a?r9b njvr   p^J_Rr,j!^sGr9b r9 wj,mk,mjl` j, _ ahnfjvr(n_nk,
k9n  1 1Ki 
i bwr9b ^2^VsFp k,^2 ` Zm_ awk,maJhnpj  #\
 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_< naJk9nVwj9!^VsF2jm Rlb nj%
|m_
r9b ^JkI^J` aJb y  j,Z|`j,j,m
y XMZ|\>^J_ ^J` abn_  q`n_ a   8 8 5
n_ 0l _ ^rr,k,|nVrr,b j{sc` kIr,b |k
Z|mprFr9^_ ^Vr9 r,bnVrFnV_&xIwnaJp k,^2Z|mj,jI_ aJ~nV aJ^JkI r,b  mj,Z|kI
|f| j,lb |kI  XMZ|\>^J_ ^J`aJb  8 8J

nj` jI|r,^njIj, aJ_n_` h|k, Z]n zVn ` !r9^{]nZ(bhry2p/q^s


|b nDz2 ^Jk^J
j,mkIz|_?r,b p^D mk0jIp/mZmr,k9n
|kI 0 ` p Z|nVr9r9b 0p k,^2Z|m ` k, ` j,mh
RyXMZ]\>^_ ^J` aJbn_ ?q`n_ a   8 8
sc^ksc^J` kj,r9jt^s _  r,n
Z|^J_  r9 ^J_ j ^J_ _<]nVZ(b^s6r9b sc^J`kq`nV k9n_Rr,j^s6r9b` _ rlj,`nVk,Dr9^fp kI^` Z|sc^J` kln_ n ^Ja^J` j
k,|ahnpjqr,bnVrll _ Z]nBr9r9b {
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_<pnk9nVwr9|k!zVn ` |jlr9^h
/{Z(b ^JjI|_ojI` Z(br,bnVrqr9b 

nj, _ jf^s%nVr,r,k9nZr9^_ nk,<p^r9m_r,n yxI_Rr,|k,mjIr,_ a  ~ i b |jIMkI|aJ wwnp jfnkI<j,b ^Dl_ _ 1 aJjm


nn ^_ al r,b<r,b Z|^J ^Jkr(nV
n_[Zm^Jk,kI|jIp/^J_ _ ahj,^ `r,^J_dry2p|jq_ 1 a D
|`nVr,^J_ p kI^` Z|mjfr,b kvr9m|_   u/|kI|_Rrfry2p/mjh^Vs
 <j,m<sckI^J 1 a  r,bnVr?r,b  #\ X

/mbn]z ^Jk|GZm ` _ a< }zJ|kIaJ|_Z| i b j jn[`Z(bY nk,aJmkk9n_aJf^s


|b nDz2 ^Jk,jr9b n_nVk,f` j,` n  }y
nVr,r,k,
`r9mdr9^?r9b  #\ ^aJjvr9Zqwnp    aJ^2^  -     
  >lj,br,^?_RzJmjIr9 aRnVr,Z]njI|j jImr9j
^st
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_[pnk9nVwr9|k!zVn ` |j9!sc^Jk!lb  Z(bMr,b 
nVj,_j^stnVr,r,k9nZr9 ^J_l  pk,^Dz2 {_sc^k,wnVr9 ^J_
Z|^J_ Zm|kI_ _ awr9b  1 ^sF|nZ(bg^str,b |jIry2p/mj>^sF
|bn]z2^k>n_ _ jIaJbRrq_Rr9^wZ(b ^2^Jj, _ a _  r,n Zm^J_
  r,^J_ jl `k,_ahr,b Zm` kIz rIr9_awp kI^Zm|jIj%h|_Rr9 ^J_ |[p kImz2^J`j, ys3r,|kq` Z(boZm^J_ jI mk9nVr,^J_< 
bn]zJhZ(b ^Jj,m_jImzJm_Z|nj,mj{r,bnVr|_Z|^JhpnjIjr,b jpb  ^Jj,^Jpby  fkI|wnk,[r9bnVr{nV_& _   Z]nVr,^J_o^Vs
r9b u4mZmr9jl^s6 _  r,n Z|^_   r,^J_j!nk,>n kI]nywj,`aJaJ|jvr9m
Ry 1  a  F_<pnkIr,Zm` nkm2r,b |kI{nk,>Zm^J_
j,|k9nV
? }u4mk,m_ Z|mj{ _gj,^J `r9 ^J_ory2p/mj{sc^` _ _gjI`
k,maJ^_ jr9bnVr{nVk,?Z|^wh^J_osck,^^J_ ?p nkIr










0.2

2.0

(a)

0.2

1.6

0.6

1.2

(b)

1.0
1.0

1.5

(e)

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

0.8

0.4

12 Broadband w/o fundamental

0.0

13 Divergent
11 Broadband w/ different fundamental

0.4

10 Broadband w/ fundamental
09 Noisy quasiperiodic w/o fundamental
08 Noisy quasiperiodic w/ fundamental
07 Noisy phase lock
06 Noisy subharmonic

0.8

05 Quasiperiodic
04 Phase lock

1.0

1.5

2.0

03 Subharmonic

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

02 Periodic w/ different fundamental


01 Periodic
00 Steady

4.0

4.0

(d)

3.5

3.5

3.0

3.0

2.5

2.5

2.0

2.0

1.5

(c)

1.5

1.0

1.0

0.5

0.5

0.0

0.0

0.5

0.5

1.0

1.0
1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

qmaJhnVp j%` jI_ awr9b ( 1% j53 nR ; <  C  8 S    N <  C  8 S 


 ; <  C  8 S   N <  C  8 S 
1 aJ`k, Q
ZD ; <  C  8 S  N <  C  8 S nV_   ; <  C  8 S 22  N <  C  8 S   n ^J_al r9b D r9b Zm^J ^Jkr9n


^sKr,b aJ` kI{r,^hr,b _2r]0r% j!k,]nVj,^J_nV


r9^fp|Zr%r9b nVrlr9b  jqjI|_ jI r, z2 rydr,^wjInV  Z(bnV_ aJ|j_

 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_pnk9nVwr9|k0znV ` mjl  r9k,n_ j, nVr9r9^h 1 n_   _  m| r,b j l  /


/ mw^_ jIr,k9nVr,|<_
r9b j,m` | 
S  L  J 8 S W 
i b{kIjIrqZ]nVj, {p k,mj,m_rj!r,b j,hp |jIrl _r9|kIwjl^sj,^ `r,^J_dry2p|jlr9bnVrl0{l  /nh_ 
n_ gZ|^k,k,mj,p^J_  jr9^Fj| Rll}r9b F  S  L  J 8 S W   1 kI^J 1 aJjm nl0?j,mr9bnBr%sc^Jk
r9b mj,zVn ` mj!^s
 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_pnk9nVwr9|kIjr9b jI^J `r9^_ j!nkI| r,b |k! _dr9b p|kI^2 Z k,m
njI_^Jk
r9b  }zJ|kIaJ|_Rr
 nZ(
njI_sc^Jkr,b ^Jj,sc^J`k!j,mr,j^VsK _  r,n Z|^_   r,^J_j| i b 
njI_ j!^VstnVrIr9k,nZmr,^J_
j,b ^Dl_&_ 1  a  nVk,? m _]nVr,|g` jI_ a_mr9 Z|_|k,aVyoZ|^_r,^J` kIjnV_ gZ|^JkIk,mj,p^J_ r9^Z|^2^JkI _nBr9
nB|jtkI|p kI|j,m_Rr9_a%r9b 0_ }r9n JZ|^_   r,^J_j| ;  nV_  N  kI|j,p|Zr9}zJ| }yJtjKZ|n_
 j,m|_  z|k,a|_Rrn_ 
p/mk,^2  Zr9k9n XI|Zmr,^Jk, |jnkInVp p k,^]wnVr,| y|`n y? V| yl r,bwp|kI^2 Zr,k99n XImZmr9^k,mjZ|^J_ Zm|_Rr9k,nVr9m
w^JkIb |nDz2 yn ^J_adr9b ? naJ^J_ n jq^sr9b ?` _ rjI2` nk,V  ?^w}rr,b fp/^D0|kj,p|Zr9k,nMn_or9h
j,|kImjsc^kKr9b  jFZ]njIqnjt qnjIj,` h!r9bnBrtr9b lkI]n mkFjts;nh nk l}r9br9b|j,lr0^sc`_ nh|_Rr(nV ryp|j
^sK
|b nDz2 ^Jk|

3.1 Case 1 (periodic / divergent): F 

50 X 50

100 X 100

(0)

(0)

0
1

(0)

0
0

1
1

400 X 400

(0)

(0)

200 X 200

(0)

(0)

0
0

(0)

0
0

1 aJ`k, >njI_ j%^s0nVr,r,k9nZr9^_sc^Jk>


}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_p nk9nhmr,|k%zVn ` |j%^s F 

S  L  J 8 S  W  nj
 mr,|k,h_|&
ygr,b f_ r9Zfm_ |kIayJdkIgk,_ mwm_rZ| ^Z(Rl j,fsck,^Jr,^Jp& ms3r| 2 8 2 8  88
8 8  8 8 8 8  8 8  8 8


i b&jI|` m_ Z|Y^s{pnVr,r,|kI_ j<_ 1  a   jp k,^2 ` Zm|


yk,_ _a r,b g_ r9n qZ|^J_  r9 ^J_aJkI
j,pnZm_ a<nVj |jIZ|k,
/m_&mZ  i b ?jIpnZ| _ a
mr0||_YaJk, op^J_Rr9j%j>Zm^J_ j,mZ|`r, z| yobn z|&nj
{p k,^2Z|m|M_<r9b Z| ^Z(Rl j,{ kI|Zmr,^J_4  {jIr(nVkIrll r,b[r,b p ^rl _[r,b {` p p|kv s3rlbn_ [Z|^JkI_ |k


` j, _ afnaJk, dj,p nZ| _ af^s 8  8R ` _ }r9j!n_[m_ <_r,b  ^D0|k# s3rbnV_ <Z|^JkI_ |k!` jI_ afnak,j,pnZm_ a
^s 8  8 8R 2 `_  r,j| 1 k,^ ^J
jI|kvznBr9^_ j0^Vs/r,b 
nj, _ jnj0ak,fkIm_ mwm_Rr  jp|kvsc^Jk,h|?0Zm^J_ Zm `  
r9bnVr0r9b  j0p nkIr,Z|` nk
njI_wnpnp p]nkIj r9^ jIp n]ywn{sck,nZmr9n x#r9^Jp^J ^ay2~n }r9b ^` aJbw0>bn]z>_ ^r
nVr,r,|hpr9mMnfk, aJ^JkI^J` jp kI^^VsK^s6r9bj|
S  L  J 8 S8 2
1 kI^J 1  aJj| n240 jI|r9bnVr6sc^JkG
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_pnk9nVwr9|kIj znV ` mj^s F  S  n_  L  J 8 S 8 2
r9b mk,>nVk,nVr ]nVjIrr ^{ryp|j0^s
|bn]z2^kr,bnVr0Z|^2jvr] i b q( 1%j^Vs 1  aJj| nRFn_ 
F_ Z]nBr9
2` nj, p/mk,^2  Zr9k,n9XI|Zr9^JkImj|6n_ gr9b^Jj,?sck,^ 1  aJj| Z]>n_  % _   Z]nVr,p/mk, ^  Zr9k,n9XI|Zr9^JkImj|
i b M
nj, _ jf^snVrIr9k,nZmr,^J_sc^Jk?jI` Z(bp|k, ^Zn_`njIp|k, ^Zd
|bn]z2^k,jhnk,[j,b^l_ _ 1  a 
nRFn_dZ|^JkIk,mj,p^J_ wr,^r,b zVn ` |j^s4r,b %jvr(nVr,jvr9Z|n p kI^Jp/mkIryf^sj,l_ |jIjl^s4r,b  @ Z|^Jhp^J_ |_Rr
^szJ| ^Zm ry i b gsc^J` kd nk,  ^r9j<^s 1  a  nRw _   Z]nVr,r9b g( 1% j[`j,| _Zm^J_ jvr9k,`Zmr9 _ a r9b 
k,|ahhwnp j{^s 1 aJjm nD2n_ Zm^J_kI r9b wj,^J `r9 ^J_gry2p/mjsc^J` _ Y_r9b ^j,kI|aJ wmjnpj|
i b wZ(b|Z(mk,
^RnkI
nj, _^s 1 a nJ j{n_Ynwp f^s!n[
njI_&aJ|^Jhmr,kIygZm^Jhw^J_ yojI|m_ _
r9b <Z|^_r,2rw^s>kI| nBr9 z| }yjIhp 
|bn]z2^kfn_  bnjwn jI^g
/m|_^
j,mkIzJmsc^Jk?Zm^J
 _nVr9 ^J_ j^Vs
j,`
b nk,h^J_  Zfn_ &2` nj, p/mk,^2  Zr9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkI|jm |1R}C lb |kI F=G  F=O  S 2W  L G  L O  J 8 S 8R
n_ <sc^Jk!_p bnjIn_ [^J`rv^sp bnjIp/mk,^2  Z%r9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkI|j! _[nfjIh nk jvr9` y ]1 k y2 n_    

2_ Zmhr,b |kInkIhn_Y __ }r9f_` 
|k^s p/^J _Rr9jl r,b _]nVZ(b
njI_ wZ]n_&_ zJ|k{r9mjIrmzJmkIy
p/^J _Rr` j, _ ar9 wojI|kI|j[n_ p^D mk<j,p|Zmr,k9n nV_n y2jI|jr9^ r9mk,h_ n %p^Jj,jI
g
/mbn]z2^JkIj|
_ jIr,]n0k,m y^_Mr9b '(B8*84': ^sr9b {_` h|k, Z]n zVn ` |jq^sr9b { m_Rr9 Z]nVr,^J_<pnk,nhmr9mk,j
^s 2|Z {n_ h^J_hr,|jvr9_a{^Vsk9nV_  ^Jh yj,m |Zr9mp^J_Rr9jFl}r9b  _h|nZ(b
nj, _  ql   jIZ|` jIjr,b j
_[w^JkI |pr,bo nBr9|km\>` r9^hr9b {2r,|_ jI zJ ` k9nBr9^_M^sK^J_ {^str,b p|kI^2 j! Z]n_[z2j,
ydj,|
r9b h`nj, p/mk, ^  Z_nVr,` k,h^s0r9b   Zm^Jwp^J_ m_Rr{z| ^Zm ryor,h?j,|kImj^s n_Ynhp r,k99n XImZmr9^kIy
1  a 
,l_own_Ry[Z]njI|j%r,b ^J` ab`njIp|k, ^Z|}ryjq_ ^r>njnp pnkI|_Rrn_M0` jvr>k,m y<^J_
r9b \ sc^JkFjI^J `r9^_hZm^J_kInBr9^_ i b%\sc^ktr9b  jZ|nj,q^s42` nj, p/mk,^2  Z
/mbn]z2^JkjjIb ^Dl_
_ 1 a ZD

3.2 Case 2 (periodic / quasiperiodic): F 

(b)

(a)
u velocity

Scaled time

(0)

Power, (dB)

(c)

(0)

Frequency, , (normalized)

1 aJ`k, nRl_ |jIjZ|^_r,^J` kIjfsc^k F 

S   L  J 8 S 8 2
`njIp|kI^2 Zhr9hjI|kI|j?^Vs

@ Zm^Jwp^J_ m_Rrqz| ^Zm ryJ ZD`njIp|kI^2 Z>p^D mklj,p|Zmr,k9n

S 2 2  L  8 S
_ Z]nVj,& &Z|^J_Rr,_` gr9^zVnkIy F n_ L j,^ r9bnVr0&Z]n_ j,b^ nhp mj^sr,b |_Rr9 k,
j,p|Zmr,k,` ^s
|bn]z2^JkIjnjIj,^2Z|nBr9|ol}r9br,b  \ X m2` nVr9 ^J_ i b ry2p|j^s
|bn]z2^ksc^Jk
r9b MZ]njIlb |kI F  S 2 2 n_  L  8 S jh` _ Z|mkIr9n_sc^kwr9b^Jj,M( 1% jd^s 1  aJj|
22!
`r
sc^Jkr9bo( 1% ^s 1 a  nRh0gp|Zmr< zJmk,aJm_Rrr9k9n XI|Zmr,^Jk, |jm [%r,b |kp^Jj,jI
jI^J `r,^J_ ryp|j
np p]nkr,^h _ Z| `  >jI`
bnVk,h^J_ ZV _ ^J jIyj,`
b nk,h^J_  Z _ ^jIy`nj, p/mk, ^  Zn_ [
k,^Jn
n_<

sc` _ nh|_Rr9n Gnh^J_ a?^r,b |kIj|


i bw
nVj,_  |_Rr9}Z]nBr9^_onVp&pk,^2 ` Z|mY
Ryor,b  @7 Z|^JkIk,m nVr,^J_gnV_ YjIb ^Dl_Y _ 1 a   nJj
k,]nVj,^J_nV
w_Yr,bnVr r jIp n]y2j{r0^g
njI_ j^sqnVrIr9k9nVZmr9 ^J_ 3t^_ Zm^Jk,kI|j,p^J_ _ ar,^oj,`
bnkIw^J_Z

/mbn]z ^Jkfn_  ^J_ Zm^Jk,kI|jIp/^J_ _ ar9^_ ^jIyj,`


bnk,h^J_  Z
/mbn]z2^Jkm `r|nVs3r,|k?_j,p|Zmr,^J_^Vs
r9b h
njI_ j{^slnVrIr9k,nZmr,^J_|_Rr9}|Y
yr,b w^Vr9b mkpnVk9nhmr,|k,jn_ Yj,`
j,|` m_Rrfp/^D0|kjIp/mZmr,k9n
n_n }yjIjm! rhjhsc^J` _ r,bnVrwr9b  jjh_ ^rwr9b MZ|^JkIk,mZmr
nVj,_npp _ a i bjmk,kI^Jk jn_ nVr9` k,n
Z|^J_ jI|` m_ Z|d^Vs0r,b wm_ }r9 ^J_^s0r,b     Z|^JkIk,| nVr9 ^J_ i b f _ }r9^_& wp mj%r9b nVrlb |_Yr9b 
@ ln_ 7 Z|^Jhp^J_ |_RrqzJm ^2Z| r,mj%nkInVrIr9k,nZmr,|r,^r9b j9nh _  r,sck,m` |_ Zyo^JjIZ|  nBr9^Jkqn_ onk,
_p bnjI njwr,b mynk,[_ r9b  jwZ|nj,]hr9b nVrwr,b     Z|^k,k,m nVr,^J_ l !bn]zJgnzVn ` [^sp^Jj,}r9}zJ
^J_ Fr,b j9nh<njfnjIj,^2Z|nVr9m l r9bjvr9|ny r,k99n XImZmr9^k,mj|Y% jI^ F_^` kZ|^wp `r(nVr,^J_ j <bn]zJ

3.3 Case 3 (subharmonic / noisy subharmonic): F 

1 (a)

1 (b)

(0)

(0)

0
a (0)

40 (c)

0.7

80

0.5

a (0)

(d)
u velocity

Power (dB)

100
40
80
120

0.3
0.8
0.6
0.4

Frequency, , (normalized)

Scaled time

S 2 2  L  8 S ` j, _ a nR    Zm^Jk,kI| nBr9^_gn_ 


nVr9_|j,j{n ^J_ a
l r9b ZDfp/^D0|kdjIp/mZmr,k9n ^s @ Z|^Jhp^J_ |_Rrdz| ^Zm ry ^s_ ^jIy j,`
bnkIw^J_Z<r9k9nXI|Zmr,^Jk, |j
`
aJk,m|_!n_ [j,`
bnkIw^J_Z>r9k,n9XI|Zr9^JkImj  aJbRr!aJkI||_lnV_  nhp >r,h>j,mk, |jl^s]nZ(b
1 aJ`k,  1 ^J_Rr9^J` kIjsc^Jk F 

Z|^J_ jvr9kI` Zmr,|<r9b >}r9mk9nVr,^J_wj,|` m_ Z|jI^r9bnVr lb |_< r j np pnkI|_Rr!r9b nVrlnr,k99n XImZmr9^kIyd j  }zJmk,aJm_r
r9b m_<r,b jIr9nVr9 jIr9 Z%h]njI` k,mjqnk,njIj, aJ_ |<jIp/mZ| |zVn ` mj| m`n r9^?^_ _dr,b Z]njI^sGr9b     
Z|^JkIk,| nVr9 ^J_2n ^Dl_ asc^Jks;njvr9|k0Z|^Jhp `r9nVr9 ^J_ jm i b |jInk,qr9b k,|nj,^J_j lbRywr,b      Z|^JkIk,| nVr9 ^J_
8

 ^mj_ ^r  jIr9 _ aJ`  j,br,b lZ|^JkIk,|Zr


nj, _fnp4Rj,b ^Dl_ _ 1 a 
2njF r9mk,h_ mh
Ry?r,b !nVr9_|j,j
Z|^J_Rr9^` k,j{n_ &Z|^_r9n__ a<n
njI_^s0  z|kIaJ|_ Zmw _gr9b ?` pp/mk{kIaJbRrvbn_&Zm^Jk,_|k|  fk,mnkI
r9bnVr _n
 }ryM^Vs Zm^Jk,kI| nBr9^_ j%r9^<  jIr,_ aJ`j,bosc`_ nh|_Rr(nV  yM }u4mk,|_Rr{y2_nhZmjk,mj,p kI|j,m_Rr9jn

nj, Zdn]  _ n_Ry h^ m  _ ar9mZ(b _  2`[kI| }y _ ag^J_ Z|^k,k,m nVr,^J_j| |1R n_Ry sc^JkI ^s lmy2_ ^J  jv
zJmk9na| n]z |k2r9^|j l hmr9b^
_ 1  a   Z] jI|>r,b >k,jvr!nhp >^sn_ ^J jIyp/^D0|k!j,p|Zr9kI` Zm^Jk,kI|j,p^J_ _ ar,^fn_ ^Jjvy
j,`
b nk,h^J_  Zdr9k9n XI|Zmr,^JkIy i b MkI| nVr9 ^J_ j,bp
mr0||_ r9b <_ ^j,<jIb ^Dl__ 1  a   ZDnV_  r,bnVr
^J
j,mkIz| _ p/mk, wm_r,jbnVj_ ^r|!njhyJmr|l
/m|_mjIr(nV
 j,b mln_ 0op kI^Jp^Jj,[r9bnVrnVrw |njIr
j,^Jhwp/mk,h|_Rr9n F_ ^J j,hZ]n_Y
/hnVrIr9k,
`r,|Yr,^MjI^J` kIZ||j^r9b|kr9bn_Yp|k, wm_Rr(n Fmk,k,^k| i b 
@ Zm^Jwp^J_ m_Rrz| ^Zm ryr,h!j,|kImjsc^ktr9b  j
|b nDz2 ^JkjFj,b^l_w
Ry?r9b lr9^Jpfp ^r^s 1 a    i b 

/^rIr9^J p ^r9j^sr9b mj,?aJ` kI|jZm^Jk,kI|j,p^J_ gr,^dr9b p^D mkj,p|Zmr,k,` n_  @ Z|^Jhp/^_ |_Rr>z| ^2Z|}ry
r9h>jI|k, |jmkI|jIp/mZmr9}zJm yJ sc^kr9b j,`
bnkIw^J_Z>r9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkImj|
1nVj,{ jIp n]y2j0r,b Zm^Jhw^J_ y?^J
j,|kvzJm[`nV k, nVr,|k9nV k,|a^J_h^s  }zJmk,aJm_r
/mbn]z ^Jk
nZ(

nj, _^s 1 a  


I i b mj,>kI|aJ ^J_ j` j,` n  }yf^ZmZ|` k nVr kI| nVr9}zJ| }y?b  aJbwzVn ` |j^s F n_ L   Z]n_
j,|>r,b j  |p|_ |_ Zy<_r,b k,maJhwnp^s 1 a  nJ i b  j!j0hp/^Jkvr(n_Rr
/mZ]n` jI> >l  nV_r
r9^>n]z^J{` j, _ ar,b |jI  _  r,n VZ|^J_  r9 ^J_ jG_r9b p|kIh|_Rr(n k,n_ aJmj^sZ|` kvzJ rKpnVk9nhmr,|k,jGlb m_
nVr,r,|hpr9 _ a{r,^{r
|bn]z2^Jksc^J` __fr9b|j,%k,|a^J_ j^s
 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_fpnVk9nhmr,|kznV ` mj|XM^k,|^Dz|k|
j,`
ak,2j,Z|n  w^2 | jt|hp ^y2 _ a>r9b mj,lwnp jF` jvr
/lZm^J_ jIr,k,` Zr9mhr,^nV`r9^JwnVr,Z]nV  y{n]z^J?jI` Z(b
k,|a^J_ jm i b |jI?k,maJ^J_j>^s }zJ|kIaJ|_Rr
|bn]z2^kzVnkIy[l r,bor9b Z(b ^JZm^s
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_p nk9nhmr,|k
znV ` mj|n_ r,b nZmrj,p nZ|^s_nVp p k,^p k,nVr9> _  r,n Z|^_   r,^J_j!jyJrr,^f
/jIr,k, Zmr9 }ym_ m
S W  L  8 S  J
_gr,b j>Z|nj,0fnkIr9mjIr9 _ a<nVrjIaJ_ Z|n_Rr9 y[b  aJb F zVn ` mj S W qn_  L znV ` mj &8 S  J n_ 
p/mZmrFr,^>j,m!j,^Jh^sr,b Z|^wp Z|nVr9m
|bn]z2^JkIjFnjIj,^2Z|nBr9|l}r9bZ(b n^Jj|K_fs;nVZmr]Vr9b 
|b nDz2 ^Jk,j
nk,?jI`hZ|m_Rr9 yZm^Jhp nj>r,^[wnVh
nj, _&  |_Rr, Z|nVr9 ^J_gw^k,?  wZm` r%r9bn_&_gr,b ?p k,z2^J` j
Z]njI|j|[_ 1  aJj| 2 nB0|h^J_ jIr,k9nVr,hr,b j{  wZm` ryl}r9bYr,b h_ ^J_` _ }sc^Jk,h ryg^Vsr9b w
njI_ j
njf | _ |nVr9m
Rysc^J` k? u/|k,m_RrwjI^J `r9^_ Z(b nk9nZr9mk,76|nVr9 ^J_ jm    Zm^Jk,kI| nBr9^_F_ r9Z<m_ |kIayJ
j,l_ |jIj|n_ gjI|Z|^_ ^k, mk>jIr,k,` Zr9` kIsc` _ Zmr,^J_4>_or9b sc^J  ^l _ afpnk,naJk9nVp b j%0l 6j,Zm` j,j
r9b q^J
jI|kIz|dj,Zmk,mpn_ Zm|j0nh^J_ ar9b|j,qpnk,nhmr9mk,jn_ w mr,|kIw _ !lb Z(b}sn_RynkIlZ|^JkIk,|Zr]
q|kI b nDzdhp |h|_Rr9mYr9mjIr,_ ao^Vslk9n_ ^J  _  r,n KZ|^J_  r9 ^J_ jn ^J_aMr9b ;   N  n_ 
;   J N  nmj|  !bn]zJ!sc^J`_ ?r9bnVrKsc^JkKr9b!n_Ry( 1% jF lbn]zJ!r,|jIr,|fp^0|kjIp/mZmr9k,nn n]yj
_   Z]nVr,r9b?j9nhry2p/?^Vs
|bn]z2^k|4r,bnVr^s
kI^Rn
n_ gl r,b ^J`r>r,b sc` _  nwm_Rr(n KsckI|` m_ Zmy

^r,r,^J ^s 1  a  2 DI  qn jI^j,b ^D nV_hnwp !^s/n>r9 wjI|kI|jnjIj,^2Z|nVr9mfl}r9b?r9bjF
njI_hnVr
r9b {
/^Vr,r9^ ^s 1  a  2 s(_gn  r9 ^J_r9^fr9b  j
nj, _  z|k,a|_Rr%r,k99n XImZmr9^k,mj|/njq_<r9b {p k,z2^J` j
Z]njI nVk,%  |_Rr, md_hr9b 2` n k, nVr,|k,n 
nj, _ _wr9b%` p p|k k,abrvbnV_ wZm^Jk,_|k^s4r9b ( 1%aJk, 
%j0p k,z2^J` jI yYwm_Rr9^_ | r,b d }zJ|kIaJ|_RrfkI|aJ ^J_ jnj,jIaJ_| n     Zm^Jk,kI| nVr9 ^J_^sqp^Jj,}r9}zJ
^J_ n_j,`k,p kIj, _ aJ }ydr9b {Z(bn^Vr9Z
nVj,_n ^_ a?r9b { nVaJ^J_n j! jIp n]y2jqZ|^Jhp r9Z|^k,k,m nVr,^J_^Vs
r9b  @ n_ 7 Z|^Jhp/^_ |_RrFzJm ^2Z|}r9mj|J ]n_ a>r,^r,b s;n ` kI^sr9b     Zm^Jk,kI| nBr9^_r9^  jIr9 _ aJ`  j,b

/r m|_Yr,b |jI?


njI_ jm i b ?kI]njI^J_gsc^Jk%r9b?p/mkIsc|ZrZ|^JkIk,m nVr,^J_[l r9b_or9b?Z(bn^r,ZkI|aJ ^J_l

/ ` h_ nVr9mj,b^JkIr, yJ


i bd
njI_ wnp p  _ a`j,_aMr9bd_ r9Zw|_ mk,ayYZ|^_r,^J` kIjj,b ^Dl_ _ 1  a  2
tj,m|hjr9^
/
w^JkIkI]njI^J_n
  _Mr,bnVr>}r%j,p n]y2jr9bk,|{ry2p/mj>^s
|bn]z2^Jkm_on  }r9^_ 1 aJjm 2 Z]n_  
 jIp n]y<sc^J` kq_  z2 ` n G
nj, _ j>nV_ gnkI`n }r(nVr, z| yd_   jIr,_ aJ`j,b n
>sckI^J ^J_ ?nV_ ^r9b|k| i ^
mzVn `r9r,b nZmZ|` k,nZmy^s!r9b mj,
nVj,_j d k,jIrf ^^nVrr9bzVn ` ^s!r9b 2 _ mr,Zdm_ |kIay 1  a 

3.4 Case 4 (phase lock / broadband w/out fundamental frequency): F 

2
In ^_ agr9b  ;  

N  n_  ;  

J N  nBmj|  <j,m[r,bnVrfr9bjzVn `dznVk,mjfj,^JhmlbnBr]


_   Z]nVr,_ ar,bnVrr,b  _ mr,Zm_ |kIayYj 1 sc^JkZ(b n^r9 Zhr,k9n9XImZmr,^Jk, |j|tnj00^J` p/mZmr|%j
Z]n_
/[j,m|_sckI^J 1  a  2
r,b jf
nVj,_ jfjIr,  jvr9 _ aJ`  j,bn
 _ r9bjfZ]njI [%r9b|kIl j,[r9b 
  u/|kI|_ Zm|j{
/r m|_ 1  a  2
n_  1 aj| 2 Z nw^` _Rrr9^<r9b f_ r9 Zhm_ |kIay  jIr9 _ aJ`  j,b  _ a
^J_ yh^J_>^r9b|k ry2p>^s6
/mbn]z2^Jk Zm `   _ a }zJmk,aJm_ Z|]0lb  r9b>j,Vml_ mj,jn_ j,mZ|^J_^JkI |k
jIr9kI` Zmr,` k,sc` _ Zr9 ^J_<^sr,b  @ Zm^Jhp/^J_|_RrlzJ| ^Zm ry jvr9_aJ` jIbr ^wn  }r9 ^J_n ry2p/mj|

(a)

(0)

(0)

(c)

Power (dB)

(0)

(e)

(0)

Frequency, , (normalized)
(f)

(d)

(0)

(0)

u velocity

(b)

(0)

(0)

Scaled time

S W  L  8 S  J ` j, _ a nR     Zm^Jk,kI| nVr9 ^J_


?_ r9Z<m_ |kIayJ
ZD>jIml_|j,j?^Vs @ Z|^Jhp/^_ |_RrzJm ^2Z| ry >j,mZ|^J_ 2^JkI |k{jIr,k,` Zr9` kIhsc` _Zmr9 ^J_&^s @ Z|^Jhp^J_ |_Rr
zJ| ^Zm ryn ^J_ all r9b ]6p^0|kKj,p|Zmr,k9nn_s( nhp r,h0jI|k, |j6sc^JkK|nZ(bk,mj,p|Zr9 zlnVr,r,k9nZr9^Jkm
1 aJ`k, 2 1 ^J_Rr9^J` kIjwsc^Jk F

i b |_Rr9 Z]n Gp^0|kqj,p|Zr9k,nwsc^Jklr9b r ^_Rr9mkIrl_|


nj, _ jwn_ah`pr9b {wn_<p^JkIr,^J_
^s 1 aj| 2 Z]%n_  %nkIj,b ^Dl__Mr9b r,^Jpor0^p ^r,j>^s 1  a  2 ]%n_ g _   Z]nVr,p bnVj, ^2Z(m
r9k9nXI|Zmr,^Jk, |jm  j,^%r9b  @ Z|^Jhp/^_ |_Rr<zJm ^2Z| ryr9hgj,mk, |j<sc^Jk^J_ r9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkvyZ(b ^JjI|_ sckI^J
l r9b_o|nZ(bY^Vsr,b |jIf
nj, _ jnkI?j,b ^Dl_&_r,b r9^pr0^<p ^Vr9j>^s 1  a  2 s9 i b |jIf
nj, _ jbn]zJ

/m|_& mr,|k,h_|
Ryo_` h|k,^` jr9|jvr9jr9^<
r9b ?j,nh?j,^J `r9 ^J_ol r,bor9b  @ n_ 7 Z|^Jhp/^_ |_Rr
zJ| ^Zm r,|jjIl r,Z(b _aoznV ` mj
/r m|_
nj, _ j| i bnVr? j|^J_ ^Vsqr,b dzJm ^2Z|}r9mjn }n]y2jr(nV|jf^J_
r9b h^Jj,Zm nVr,^J_ j^sr,b ?r9^Jp&r9h?j,mk, |j|Kn_ &^J_ wn n]y2j^JjIZ|  nBr9|jnVj{r,b fw   r,h?j,mk,m5j 3
 jvr9_aJ` jIbn
w
nj, _ j_ Z|nVr9nk,zJ|kIj9n !^Vs!r9b  jp k,sc|kI|_ Zm&_ r9b dZ|nj,^Vs _ mr,Zm_ |kIay
 rjsc^` _ r,bnVr> u/|k,m_ Z|mj>
mr0||__` h|kIZ]nV 6zVn ` |j_Mr,b r0^p bnjI ^2Z(|g
nj, _ j>nkI^J_
r9b q^Jk,|k ^Vs 8   `qr,^k,^` _ ^u[|k,kI^Jkn_ w_ }r9nV r9k,n_ j, |_Rr9j9r0^^JkI |kIj0^Vs nVaJ_  r,`  l mj,j
r9bn_w r,jzVnkInVr,^J_hn ^J_ ar9bZ(bnV^r9 Z%nVrIr9k,nZmr,^Jkn_ wr,b` j
| ^r9b qp ^Vr,r9 _ ak,mj,^J `r9 ^J_:
 [>_hr9b 

^r9b mkb n_ 6r9b fzVnk,nVr9 ^J_ j^sr,b h_2`wmk,Z|n FzVn ` mj^Vsj,Vml_ mj,jhn_ Yj,mZ|^J_ 2^JkI |kjIr9kI` Zmr,` k,
sc` _ Zmr,^J_
^r,bM
nVj,|M^J_[^J_ y^J_ {Z|^Jhp^J_ |_Rrq^sr9b zJm ^2Z|}ry
mr0|m_r9b r0^p bnVj, ^2Z(m

nj, _ jnk,waJ|_ mk9n yor0^o^JkI |kIj^sna_  r,`  faJk,|nVr9mk{r,bn_&r9b hznVk,nBr9^_ j^sr,b |jIj,^ `r,^J_
pnk9nVwr9|kIj|_` h|k, Z]n RzVn ` |jn ^_ a!r9b 0Z(bn^r,Z0nVr,r,k9nZr9^Jk6n_ nk,r9b` j6z2j,
V i bj6wr9b ^2^Vs
_Rr9mk,p kImr9 _ ar,b %
nj, _dp ^Vr9j0n_ r,|jIr,_ ap/^_Rr9jl r9b_h]nZ(b
nVj,_wsc^Jk0Zm^J_ jIjIr,|_ Zyw nj!nV  ` |
r9^p kImz2^` j, }yJ 1 ` kIr,b |k0 jIZ|` jIj, ^J__r,b %sc^J ^Dl_ajI|Zmr,^J_j l pk,^Dz2 nV_dp n_nVr,^J_w^sGr9b 
p k,^Jp|klpnVk9nhmr,|k,jr,^f
/` jI| _sc`r9` kIjIr9` mj
S  2 2  L  8 S  2
1nVj,   jjI`hZ| |_Rrmz2|_ Zm r9bnBrKsc` kvr9b mkKjIr,`   |jK^Vsr9b 0Z|^J_ jIjvr9|_Zmy^Vsj,^J `r9 ^J_p nk9nhmr,|kIj|
r9b dZmkIZ|` hjIr9n_ Z|mjsc^Jklb  Z(b noj,p|Zm m p nk9nhmr,|k{l 
dZ|^JkIk,mZmr]n_b ^D r,^nDz^Jhj#
 m_r, mYjI^J `r9^_g
nj, _ jnk,f_ m| m_YZ]njIfzJw0hZ|^J_ jI mk^J_ yr9b f_ r9 Zhm_ |kIay&n_ 
nVr9_|j,jqZ|^_r,^J` kIj|  j,p nDy|[_ 1  aJj|  nRn_
kI|jIp/mZmr9}zJm yJ

3.5 Case 5 (noisy phase lock / noisy quasiperiodic w/ fundamental): F 

(c)

Power (dB)

1 (a)

(0)

Frequency, , (normalized)

0
0

a (0)

1 (b)

u velocity

(d)

Scaled time
(e)

(0)

v velocity

(0)

Scaled time

1 aJ`k,  1 ^J_Rr,^J` k,jqsc^Jk F  S  2 2  L  8 S  2 ` j, _ a nR!2 _ mr,Z|_|k,aVyon_


lnVr,_ |jIj>n ^J_ a

l r9br,b  ZDp^D mkqjIp/mZmr,k9nnV_   D nVwp Z|^Jhp^J_ |_Rr!r,hj,|kImj|

1 aJ` kI  nRtjk,mw _ jIZ|m_r0^s 1 a  2


F_fr9bnVrr9bzVn `^s4r9b q_ r9Zq|_|k,aVyhzVnkImj n ^J_ a
r9b  na^J_n j n_dj,b ^Dlj  rIr9 lZ(bnV_ aJ> _wr9b>k,mn _  mk0^s4r9b >_^J_  }zJ|kIaJ|_Rr!
nj, _t% j,^ 1  a 

{jjIh nVkr,^ 1  aJj|  ZV{_r,bnVr?}r|_Rr9}|jfn_ nV   r,^J_ n j,^J `r9 ^J_
njI_ n ^J_ a[l r9b

r9b ^JjI>|_Rr9}|w
yhr9b%_ r9 Z%|_|k,aVyJ i b mj,^J
jI|kvznBr9^_ j ]nw` j r9^p|Zmr!r,bnVr0j,^Jh%pbnj,
  u/|kI|_ Zm{habr
/k,mj,p^J_ jI
sc^kr9b _Z|^J_ jIjvr9|_Rrl
nVj,_[wnp p  _ aJj|

1nVj, 2  jIp n]y2jZ(bnk,nZmr,|kIjIr,Zmj Z|^Jhw^_>r9^!h^JjIr


nj, _{p ^r,j m_Rr9 |_>r,b jjvr9` y/xI _ mj,~
^slj,^J `r9 ^J_ jn ^J_aMr9bd nVaJ^J_n jnV_  njIy2hwr9kvyJF_Yr9b  jZ]nVj,
`r?h^JjIr^s3r9m_jIy2hwr9kIy
n
/^`rlr9b  ;   N  n_ 4j,^Jhmr,h|j| r,b  ;   J N  nB|j| _Mr9bjlZ]njI{r,b |jInBmj l r9b[j,^w
Z|mpr9 ^J_ jn ^J_ a ;   
J N  nk,mr9mk,h_ mr9^Zm^Jk,kI|jIp/^J_r9^_ ^J jIy{`njIp|k, ^Z|}ryl r,br9b 
sc` _ nh|_Rr9n sck,|` m_ ZmyMjIr, p k,mj,m_r
^r,r,^J p ^r9jl^s 1 aJjm  Z(2DI i bp kI|j,m_Rrnjvyhhmr9kvy
^str9bnVr,_ |jIjZ|^J_Rr,^J` k,jm 1  a  
jqj,m|_gsc^Jkq
nj, _ j%^VsF_ ^J jIy[p bnjI ^2Z(|
/mbn]z ^Jk|  jIr9 _
aJ` jIb |
yhr9b>p/^D0|kjIp/mZmr,k9n?n_ wr9hqj,|kImj^sr,b %r9^pn_ dh lp ^r9j0^s 1  a   Z(2D n_ 
jnaRnV_? ` lr9^r,b lk,mz|kIj9n ^s/
/mbn]z2^JkF^s4_  z2 ` n 2z| ^Zm ry?Zm^Jwp^J_ m_Rr9j| i b |jI%aJm_ |k,n }r9mj
nk,0^JkIr,byd^st^J`klnVr,r,|_Rr9 ^J_n_Mb mk,0{sc^2Z|` jl^J_r,b Z]n` j,nVr9 ^J_<^sj,` Z(bMp/mZ|` nkI r9 |jm
1 ^_ j,  |kqnaRnV_dr9b #\0X |`nVr,^J_[k,lk, rIr9m_[b|k,njm

J =; <?>C K M
J L G ;<?>C!NE<?>C 
;=<?>@BA&C  ;<D>EC&F=G H 
NE<?>@BA&C  N5<D>EC&F=OPH QJ N5?< >C!K JRL O ;<D>EC&N5<?>CTS

 nR
 

jm 0%j,mqr,bnVr
i ^{jIr,` yfr9b ljI^J `r,^J_hn ^J_ ar9bp kIwnkIy nVaJ^J_n 2 j,r ;   N   1 k,^J
lb |_[ k,mjIr,k,Zrlr9b 
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_pnk,nhmr9mk,jlj,`Z(bMr9b nVr F=G  =F O n _  L G  L O {
 nkI ms3r l r9b
 m_r,Z|n |`nBr9^_ jl_ ^D^s6r9b sc^JkIM
J  <D>EC K JRL  <D>EC  <?>C S
 <D>E@BA&C  F  <D>EC H Q

92

i b jlj!kI|jIp/^J_j,
 sc^Jkr9b{`_ `   _ |j!^VsKjI^J `r,^J_jln ^J_a ;   N  nV_ [n jI^hp n _ jlbRy<r9b 
@7 Z|^JkIk,m nVr,^J_jFn }n]y2jFp^Jj,}r9 z!n ^J_ ar,b jK _J _  |p|_ |_Rr^sj,^ `r,^J_{ryp i b!j9nh ry2p/
^sn_nV y2j, j%Z]nV_o
/p/mkIsc^JkIwmMsc^Jklr9b  _ ^s( 1% jn ^J_ a ;   J N  nV_ o^J_ {_  j% m_r,Z|n
|`nVr,^J_ jl^s6r9bsc^k,[
J L  <?>C H QJ  <?>C K 
 <?>@BA&C   <?>C F H J  <?>C K M
J  <?>C!K,S
 F J L  <?>CH Q

E  Rn
 


i ^?_Rz|jIr,aRnBr9% _dnh^JkIaJm_ |k,n 4wn_ _|k0r,b %^2Z|Zm` k,kI|_ Zm^sGjIy2hwr9kI|j_wr9b 


nj, _dwnp
p _ aj ^s r,b j0jIr9`yw0>
|aJ _l r,br9b%aJm_ |k,n /sc^JkI` nsc^Jkr9b %Z|^2^Jk,  _nVr,|j ^Vs ( 1% j!jIy2hwr9kIZ
n
/^`r!r9b  ;   N  nB j|
;   N 
A
!
N  ;  S
A
!

 W Rn
9 W


E nR

|kIjI`
j,Zmk, pr9jnk,<r9b M_ }r9n Zm^J_  }r9^_ _` 
|kwn_  j,` p|kIj,Zmk,pr9jnkI[r,b [` j,`nV }r9|k,nVr9 ^J_

Z|^J` _Rr,|k|0yMj,`
jvr9}r9`r,^J_g^s0Fj| 9W q _Rr9^<Fj|  4n ^J_al r,bor9b ?
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_p nk9nhmr,|k
k,|jvr9kIZmr,^J_j| F=G  F=O n_ L G  L O  mk, zr9b {\\sc^Jk!]nVZ(b_ r9n Z|^J_  r,^J_
; <?>@BA&C  ; <?>C F
A
A
N <?>@BA&C  N <?> C F
A
A


J ; <?>C  JML ; ?< >C N D< >EC 

A
A A
J N ?< >C  J L ; <?>C N <DE> C S
A
A A




; ?< >@BA&C  N <?>C F


A
!
N <?>@BA&C  ; ?< >C F
A
!




J N <?>C  J L ; <?>C N <D>EC 

E nR

J ; <?>C  JML ; <?>C N <D>EC S




1 Ik ^J F2jm  n_   {0j,mdr9bnBr? s!r,b d_ r9n FZ|^_   r,^J_jnkIdaJ z|_


RyFj| 9W r9b m_
; <?>@BA&C  N <?>@BA&C n_  ; <D>E@BA&C  N <D>E@BA&C /_  mp/m_  m_r^Vs F n_ L  i bj> _  Z|nVr9mjr,bnVrjvyhhmr9kvy
j A 4('((8(8|! : sc^Jk{n FZ|^J! ` p |&
}A sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_pnk9nVwr9|kzVn ` |jn_ 6_ maJ mZmr9 _ a<znVk,nBr9^_ j> ` fr9^
k,^J` _^uo|k,kI^Jk,jmp/mk, ^  Z%r9k,n9IX |Zr9^JkImjnVk,_ mZ||jIj9nkI }y  8  maJk,m|jq^J`rI^spbnj,V
rKjG_ ^D nz2 j9n
r,^kI|Zm^J_ j,  |kZ]njI  l r9b{r9b  j_m _j,abr| i b ^J
Rz2^J`j` mjIr9 ^J_ j6lbRy
 ^ojIy2hwr9kIZh( %
1  j_ ^r jIp n]y&jIy2hwr9kIZhnpp _ aj` jI_ aMr9b wj,l_ |jIjnV_  j,mZ|^J_^JkI |k

Ij r9kI` Zmr,` k,{sc` _ Zr9^_ i b nV_ jI0|kqr9^wr,b jl` mjIr9 ^J_o jlsc^` _ o
Ry< ^2^J_awnBrr,b m_Rr9kIb  jIr,^JkIy^Vs
r9b {znVk,nV
mj| 1 ^Jk%nhj,b ^kIr>p|kI^2j,^Jhmr,h|jl` _  mk 8 8  r,|k9nBr9^_ j|r9bzJm ^2Z|}ry<Z|^Jhp/^_ |_Rr9j
nZmr nj pk,|Zmr,|d
RyF2jm   n_    XnZ(b  _ %kI^J` _ 2^u[|kIk,^Jkjr9b|_dkI|j,p^J_ jI
qsc^k0jIn
 mz2nBr9^_ jsck,^ r,b jjvy2whmr,kIyJ i b _m r,k9n_j,m_Rr9j^s3r,|_ |n
nVZ(r9^g^Jpp/^JjI r,| y&p b nj,m
nVr,r,k9nZr9^JkIj|Z|^JkIk,|jIp/^_  _awr9^n_gnVrIr9k,nZmr,_ af|op^J _r^sFj| J i b jp bnjI }u4mk,m_ Z|Vnj
_ ^r9mo
msc^JkInZ|Zm^J` _Rr9jsc^Jk!r9b  jIZ|k,mpn_ Zmmj%_<r9bzVn `|jq^sKr,b jIml_|j,j{n_j,mZ|^J_^JkI |k
jIr9kI` Zmr,` k,{sc` _ Zr9^_ n ^J_ahl}r9b<r9b {^r9b|klzJ| ^Zm ry<Zm^Jwp^J_ m_Rr%jIp/mZ| ZpnVk9nhmr,|k,j9qnV_  jqkI
j,p^J_ j,
lsc^Jkr9b _ Zm^J_ j, jIr,|_Rr!wnp p  _ aJj^s 1  aJj| 2
22 i b |kImsc^JkI r0j0nz2j,n
qr,bnVrm r,b |k
r9b f_ r9 Z?|_ mk,aygZm^J_Rr9^J`k,j|G^JkZm^Jhp/^J_|_Rr{_  mp/m |_Rrsc^JkI` nBr9^_ j%^s0^r,b |kjI^J `r,^J_gZ(b nkv
nZmr,|k, 6]nVr,^J_pnk9nVwr9|kIj|
?` jI|_osc`r,` k,?jvr9` |jnV_ gj, ` nBr9^_ j%nVj>r9b Z(b nk9nZr9mk,7 6|nVr9 ^J_ j
j,b ^J` <
/wnZ(b  _  Br,k9n_j,m_Rrl_  mp/m_  m_r|
3.6 Case8 68 (noisy quasiperiodic w/o fundamental / broadband w fundamental): F
S W2  L  S  

 y_ jIp/mZmr9 ^J_&^s 1  aJj| n> rjbnVk,r9^[ jvr9_aJ` jIbglbnVrry2p/mj^s


/mbn]z ^Jk|6nZr9 }yJ

l  G
j,m|_osc^Jkqr9b mj,zVn ` |j^s F n_  L 4
`r>0Z]n_gp/mZmr>r,bnVr>r,b 
|bn]z2^kl G
/` }r9
Z|^Jhp  Z]nVr,|_  |mr9b <r9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkImjwsc^Jkfr9b  jfZ]njIgnk,[` }r9wnVr,| yY r9|kIw _ | r9^&
/M_ ^Jjvy
2` nj, p/mk,^2  Zl r,b ^J`r!r,b sc` _ nVwm_r9n 4sckI|` |_Zmy[n_ <
kI^Rn
n_ l r,b<r,b >sc` _  nwm_Rr(n 4sckI
2`|_ ZyJ
1 ^_ j,  |kI_ agr9b[kI|jI` r,j?^sr,b p kImz2^J`jhZ|nj,mj| <Z(b ^2^Jj,r,^&mwp ^Dyr,b _ r9Zm_ |kIay
Z|^J_Rr9^` k,jKnj6r,b  jIr,_ a` jIb _ alZ(bnVk9nZr9|kI7 6|nVr9 ^J_ _{r,b  pk,|jI|_RrFZ|nj,V i b r9b kI|
nj, _ jjIb ^Dl_?_
1 a  W nR6Zm^Jk,kI|jIp/^J_fr,^>_ ^J jIy`nj, p/mk, ^  Zl}r9b ^`rtr9b sc` _ nVwm_r9n sckI|` m_ Zmyp k,mj,|_Rr ;  
N  n_  ;   J N  nmj(4
kI^Rn
nV_ Ml}r9bMr,b sc`_ nh|_Rr(nV GsckI|` m_ ZmyMp k,mj,m_r h^JjIr^sF` _ r
j,`nkIDtn_  zJmk,aJm_Rr ` p p|kkIaJbRrvbn_&Zm^Jk,_|k(r9k,9n XI|Zr9^JkI|jm  w^J
j,|kvzJr,bnVr{r9b hp^0|k
j,p|Zmr,k,` _r,b !` p p|kFp ^rt^Vs 1 a  W
haJbRrt|nj, y
/ Z]n |
k,^RnV
n_  
V^>sc` _ nVwm_r9n 3

`rh^Jk,{Z]nVk,msc` K_j,p|Zmr,^J__   Z]nVr,|jqk,mw_nV_r,j>^sjIp/mZmr9k,n Kp]nV2j>nVr>_ ^k,wn  6||<sck,m` |_ Zmmj


_ ]nk 8 S  n_  8 S  4r,b` jhp y2_a`njIp|k, ^Z|}ryJ 1 k,^J _` wmk,^J`jr,|jvr9j^s( 1% jl r,b _or,b j
k,|a^J_d0bn]zJ|jvr(n
jIb |r9b nVr 1  a  W nR  j!n_<nZmZ|` k,nVr9
njI_wnp p  _ a  i b^J` aJbr9b2 _ mr,Z
|_ mk,ay Zm^J_Rr9^J` kIjM^ b
}r[n jI|_ jI r, z2 ryr,^  _  r,n qZ|^_   r,^J_j_r9b Z(bnV^r9 Z&
nj, _ j|%r,bnVr
j,|_j, r, z2 ryjjIn Zm^Jhpnk,mr9^r9b  }u4mk,m_ Z|mj[ _r9b &n]zJmk9nazVn ` |j
mr0|m_r,b _ ^Jjvy
2` nj, p/mk,^2  Z
nj, _[n_ Mr,b 
k,^Jn
n_[l}r9b<r9b sc` _ nVwm_r9n sck,m` |_ Zy[
nj, _%_[nhp 
^sGr9b  @ Z|^wp^J_ m_r zJ| ^Zm ryhr9 wj,|kImj sc^Jk
^r9bwr9b _ ^jIyw`njIp|k, ^Zn_ dr9b
k,^RnV
n_ 
nVr,r,k9nZr9^JkIjnkIMjIb ^Dl__ 1 a W Z] [>_ jIb ^J` n j,^&_ ^r,Z|<r9b nVrwr,b Mnk,|nY^s zJmk,aJm_ Z|Mj
Z|^J_ jI mk9n
 yYw^JkIw_ nk,kI^ r,bn__Yr9b dpk,mz2 ^J` jr0^gZ]njI|jfnVrb aJb|kzVn ` |j^s L n_  ^D0|k
2

1 (a)
Power (dB)

(b)

Frequency, , (normalized)

(0)

u velocity

(c)

0
0

(0)

Scaled time

1 aJ` kI W /_ r9 Z>|_ mk,ay<Zm^J_Rr9^J`k,j!sc^Jk F  S W2  L  8 S 8   

znV ` mj%^s F  i b  j%jI` aJaJmjIr9j>r,bnVr%  z|k,a|_ Zm? |p|_ jw^JkIb |n]z y[^J_r,b zVn ` ^s L r,bn_ F
_[naJkI||h|_Rrll r,b 1 aJjm n2
F G O 
3.7
8 8 Case 7 (Broadband w/ fundamental / Broadband w/o fundamental):
J

S W

S   L G O 

i b%k,jvrr9b_ a^J_ >_ ^Vr9Zm|jlb |_ nVw _ _ ar9b>


njI_dp ^r9jsck,^ zVnkI^J`j0jI^J `r,^J_wZ(bnk,nZ
r9|kI76|nVr9 ^J_Mp nk9nhmr,|kIjqsc^JkqZ]nVj, W jlr9bnVrj,m|h_ a y<_ ^r0^d^sKr9b pnk9nVwr9|kIj%nVZmrnV Vlq|k,
qnkI
 r,k9nkI yZ(b^^JjI!r9^j,b ^D r9b !
nVj,_f  |_Rr9}Z]nBr9^_?^J
r(nV_ msck,^Jr9b zVn ` |jF^sr9b!j,|Zm^J_ 
^Jk, mkljIr9kI` Zmr,` k,sc` _ Zr9 ^J_<_ 1 a W nR,
 [>_ jIr,k,` Zr9` kIZm^Jhw^J_ yh m_Rr9 |[
yn  p nk9nhmr,|kIj|
naRn _j0r,b >
nVj,_Z|^JkIk,|jIp/^_  _ar9^r,b  ;   N  n_  ;   ,
J N  nBmj| i b jmr,b |_j0r,b  k,jIr

nj, _[0 _RzJ|jvr9 aRnVr9 _M mpr9b4_  m|/n  p^J _r,j!r9|jvr9ml r,b _r9bjl
njI_Mnk,{^sKr,b { jvr9_Zmr
ryp{j,b ^Dl_
Ryr,b r9^Jp<p^0|kqj,p|Zr9kI` ^s 1 a  
!n_[r,b r9^Jp @ Zm^Jhp/^J_|_RrlzJ| ^Zm rywr9h
j,|kImjq^Vs 1 a   Z] i b  jryp^s6
/mbn]z2^Jk! j!2_^l_Mnj!p|kI^2 Zql r9b[n? }u4mk,|_Rr!sc` _nh|_Rr(n 
n_ }rtp kI^ `Z||jzJ| ^Zm ry{Z|^wp^J_ m_r,jKr9b nVrt^JjIZ|  nBr9
/r m|_?r9bk,|0znV ` mj _^rtkI]n  y r9mZmr9m
^J_r9b j,Z|n ^s6r9b{p ^r|
`rq]nVj, }yjI|m__[n?p bnVj,{p/^Jkvr9k,n r(
2r 0% _RzJ|jvr9 aRnVr9!r,b jImr ^s( 1%j0j,` kIk,^J`_  _a{r,b %p|kI^2 Z!
nVj,_fr9b nVrr9b  m_r, Z|nVr9 ^J_
pnk9nVwr9|kIjKnVk,Z|^J_sc`j,_a :
 [%s r,b 0wn_Ryp^J_Rr9jG0 bn]zJ0r9|jvr9ml r,b _r9b  jkI|aJ ^J_ 0bn]zJjI|m_
r ^  jIr,_ Zrry2p|j>^sp^D mk>j,p|Zr9k,n i b k,jvr%ry2p/j%_ ^Dl_nj
k,^Jn
n_l r,bgn }u4mk,|_Rr
sc` _ nh|_Rr9n 0sckI|` |_ZmynV_ jj,b ^Dl_ _r,b dh  h^s 1 a 
 i b j,mZ|^J_ ry2pdjjI|m_
^J_&r,b f
/^Vr,r9^^s 1 a 
n_ &j_ ^Dl_ nj
kI^Rn
n_ l r9b^J`rr9bfsc`_  h|_Rr(n tsckI|` m_ Zmy
p k,mj,|_Rr|
1 kI^JZ|^J_ jI mk9nVr,^J_^sr9b0r9 wj,mk, |jKsc^JkGr9b|j,
/mbn]z ^Jk,j h  n_ 
^r,r,^J^s 1  a   Z],
?aRnV_ _ j, aJbRr> _r,^wlbRyr,b jI^J `r,^J_Z(bnk9nVZmr9mk, 6]nVr,^J_Mpnk9nVwr9|kIj>hj,
|b nDz 1  k,jvr]_ ^r9 Z|
E

1 (a)
Power (dB)

(b)

(0)

Frequency, , (normalized)

u velocity

(c)

(0)

Scaled time

1 aJ`k,  > + ^k, mkqjvr9kI` Zmr,` k,sc` _ Zr9^_[Zm^J_Rr9^J`k,j!sc^Jk F  S   L 

J 8 S 8 W 

r9bnVr>
/^r,bg^sFr9b?Z(bn^r,Zr,k9n9XImZmr9^k,mj>Z]nV_np p kI^D nVr,zJmkIyZ| ^j,| }yMr,b p|kI^2 Z{r9k9nXI|Zmr,^Jk, |j
sc^Jk%r,|_ |p/mk, ^ j^sFr9 w ms3r%bn st^sp ^Vr9j% _ 1  a   Z],llbZ(bnkIsc^J ^D mo
Ryxv
` k,jvr9jI~
^sr,` k,
` m_rf
|b nDz2 ^Jk| i b  jf
/mbn]z ^Jk?bnj?
|m_njIj,^2Z|nVr9m l}r9bry2p/<I,{_Rr9mk,h r,r,|_ Zy
Ry
XMZ]\>^J_^J` aJbfn_f`n_a   88 5
 1 k,^Jr9bjK}rtjIb ^J` ?
/!` }r9^J
Rz2^` jKr9b nVrF ^_ a%r9mk,jIr9nVr9 jIr9 Z|j
l 
dnzJ|kIj,m ynBu4mZmr9m
RyYr,b j{ryp^s!
|b nDz2 ^Jk|o_Ys;nZmrr9b dZm^J_Rr9k,njIr,_ aop^D mkj,p|Zr9k,n
Z]n_&
/?pk,^2 ` Z|mY
Rygr,b ?j9nh?r9 wjI|kI|j
RyozVnkvy _ ar9b ?j,nhp ?jI7 6|f^Jk ^Z|nVr9 ^J_sc^Jk%` j,h_
Z|^J_ jvr9kI` Zmr,^J_[^sKr,b 0\ p ^r] 1 k,^J ^2^J_ afnVrlr,hj,|kImj^J_<r9b^JkI |kl^s 8   r,|k9nBr9^_ j 
bn]zJl r,_ |jIj,| _ ^gkI| nVw _nk, 6]nVr,^J_&^slr9bdzJ| ^Zm ry&|  n_  Z|^_r,_` m r,` k,
` m_rYxv
` k,jvr9jI~
^z|kn? nkIaJ>j9nVwp ^s6r9b r9mjIr,| _  r,n Z|^_   r,^J_j|
4. Conclusions

_r,b j0jIr9`yd0bn]zJp|kIsc^k,h|<n
njIZ> _RzJ|jvr9 aRnVr9 ^J_^VsKn_^z| jI`
aJkIj,Z|n <xvjIy2_Rr9b r9Z
zJ| ^Zm ry2~?h^ m /r,^?
/` jI|[_d  }r9 z i `k,
` |_Rrq\>|Zm^Jhp/^JjI r,^J_hr9` kI
` m_ Z|jI` nVr,^J_ jmKr
bnj
|m_j,b ^Dl_dr,bnVr0 m_r, Z|nVr9 ^J_h^s r9b qry2p/mj^s jI^J `r,^J_j0^s4r9b  j\\/_ ^Dl_<nj0r,b  ^2^Jk
Xn_ j n]z2mk2r9^|jmJ|`nBr9^_JjKp/^JjIj,
0_?n_fnV`r9^JwnVr,ZZ]n Z|` nVr9 ^J_{l}r9b ^`rt^DzJmkIlb m h_ a
Z|^Jhp `r9nVr9 ^J_n GjIr,^Jk9nVaJ^Jkqr9h{` j, _ adzVnk, ^J` j>\\jvr(nVr,jvr9Z|n +/n_ or,` k,
` m_ Z|pk,^Jp|kvr9mjnj
j,^J `r9 ^J_ry2pZ(bnk,nZmr,|k, 6]nVr,^J_p nk9nhmr,|kIj|
 bn]zJjIb ^Dl_r9b kI^J` aJb
}sc` k,Z|nVr9 ^J_  naJk,nwjmKp^D mk?j,p|Zmr,k9nn_Z|^Jhp/^_ |_Rrz| ^2Z|}ry
r9hjI|kI|jdr,bnVrdr,b  \ 0X |`nVr,^J_Z|n_p kI^ `Z|or9bkIr,|m_  u/|k,m_Rrdry2p/mj[^Vs
/mbn]z
^JkmnV ^J_ a l r,b }zJ|kIaJ|_Z|sc^JkM
 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_ znV ` mj_r9b  k,n_ aJmj^s S 8 F   S 8 n_ 
J S  L   S 8 & l<nk,k,nDy^sq
 sc`k,Z]nBr9^_ j,m2`|_ Zm|j| j,^JhZ|^J_k,h|
Ry p|kIh|_Rr9j
W

_ r9`k,
` |_ Zm<n_  j,^wnVjyJmrf`_ j,m|_0bn]zJ<
/m|_ j,b^l_ r9^g
^J
r9n_ n
w
RyzVnk,nVr9 ^J_^Vs

 sc` kIZ]nVr,^J_Mpnk,nwr9mk%zVn ` mjn_  V^Jk> _  r,n Zm^J_  }r9^_ j% _  Z|nVr9 _ awr,b p|Zr9m&
  ry<^Vs
r9b  j0\\r9^{h^ m _ ^J_ ^Z|n zVnkIn
|jn_
Ryf _sc|kI|_ Zmr9b qp/^j,j,
  ry^s4r,b   /|`nVr,^J_
r9^pk,^2 ` Z|h_ ^J_` _` jI^J `r9^_ j| i bj{ nkIaJ?k9n_aJw^Vs!
/mbn]z2^JkIj|KzJm_ _ #\  _   Z]nVr,|jr9b 
p/^r,|_Rr9n sc^ktr9b  j\\r9^
/!jI` Z|Zm|jIjIsc` _?kI|p Z]nBr9_a%r9b ljIn jIZ]n ` Zmr,`nVr,^J_ jF^Vs/r,` k,
` |_Rr
zJ| ^Zm ry<Zm^Jwp^J_ m_Rr9j| _Ms;nZr]r9b wr9b ^2[^sXMZ|\>^J_ ^J`aJb -     
bnjq
/m|_ojI` Z|Zm|jIjIsc` y
np p |dr,^ #\ 
\ nBr(nf
y  n_ a -    8 8 5
_dr,b Z|^J_Rr,2r%^Vsr,b  #\X |`nVr,^J_4
i bhh^Jjvrhp/^kIr(nV_r_   _ aJj _or9|kIwj^Vs0r,b ?hp  Z]nVr,^J_<r9^dr,b fZ|` kvzJ? rIr9_ap k,^2Z|m ` k,
bn]zJ
|m_r9b  |kI zVnVr,^J_<^str,b _|Z|mj,j,nkIyjIy2whmr,kIy< `r9^wr9b {Z|^J`p mo
 sc`k,Z]nBr9^_MpnVk9n?
mr9mk,j^sFr,b jjIr,` ygnV_ or9b znVk,nBr9^_M^sr,b k,maJ^_ j%^s zJmk,aJm_ Z|fnVj>
 sc`k,Z]nBr9^_pnk,nhmr9mk,j
n_  V^k!_ }r9nV Zm^J_  }r9 ^J_ j!nkIznVk,m 1 `r,` k,jIr,`   |j!_r,b ` Z(b[w^k,hp^JkIr9n_RrZ]nVj,^s6r9b 
B#\ X |`nVr,^J_bn]zh
|m_ n`aJwm_Rr9|
Rygr9b? mr,|k,h_ nVr9 ^J_g^s0j,| |Zr9 zfZ|k,}r9mk,nr,^<
/
` j,m_jI^J `r9^_wZ(bnVk9nZr9|kI7 6|nVr9 ^J_nV_ d_waJ|_|k9nV 4n{
nj, Z%` _ |kIjIr(nV_  _a^sr,b r,^^J j0_|Z|mj,j,nkIy
_<_RzJmjIr,aRnVr,_ ar,b mu/|Zr9jq^sK _  r,n Z|^_   r,^J_j!^J_[\\j!^s6r9b  jq_ nVr9` kI

 
  


^ k,V W | }n` mk| i \   


 )2D8(C%;9|e@';*+B?!:V?*+',:D88 pk,_aJ|km   J^ k,


  aJ^2^45/? i }


0aJaJV W  0^Jb +2!   2
Ix \>msc^JkInVr,^J_jt^s4r,b l
 sc`k,Z]nBr9^_hnaJk,n
r,^J_4~ $gc)  B%4    8  

0` h|kmXYof    W
 *34'* -(8#"

` qr,^j,Zmk,r976|nB

 +*8;*+'(8 \>^DzJmk|   ^JkI

 
0^Jb k| i  W |_ jI|_2X&{ Kn n _4J? ` p n_ B   
:B?*+',-  D: 88! R(|2'()
#" @2 |@-4'( 1n
k,aJ_ zJmk,jI ry[Fk,mj,j|1n
k,  aJD
 29
1 kIj,Z(b4t   2
"q5%$&h5 EG.('
z|kIj, rykI|jIj|
1 n
kI aJ]

 .)")fEG+1R2':&#"*+'=?B-,12B9B7 1 n
kI aJw_}

 
1 k y2 n_ 4 W    
 9|e@'*+BM#

 _ a  k, jIr9^ 3

 )2D8e  D)94'( _ jIr, r9`r9>^sKFbRyjIZmjF`


 jIb

 W9
|kInV_ ^ 2XY} F^wm  J{ XM^J _2 1n
^r]  2   5
xI\%y2_nhZ`
ak,Z|n 
F y,> j,Z|^j, ry<XM^| + ~  )2:8|.--@2*;eB80/21 9W 8 9W  2 

 m_ j,^_/   8


x,Xn_Rygk,^`r9mj>r9^r9` kI
` |_RrZ|^J_Rz|Zmr,^J_4~54 6--@2*;e
 
^J `
W  63
$&('()7898     W 8 
 
q^u/n_4/? ?} XMZ 1 ^Jk,hZ(  4\ ^Jj 6mr9 Z56m` jm:K h^Dy{4}3 l_ _ yJ { 
   W
x,q_  z|k,j,n }ryJ` }r9 p  Z| rynV_ Mr,b u4mZmr%^sKr,b  k,^J_[hp ` kI r,|j _<r9b  | ^J` jI^zR
:4b n
/^Vr9_j,/k,]nVZmr9 ^J_ ~,4  )h  )2:8|<;>=   
 8
ly2 _4! 1%

XMZ]\>^J_^J` aJb W XY    


x 1 bn^r,Z 2n }#Z]n 5m ^2Z|}ry 1  |  jgnj
FkI^Jj,p|Zr9 zXM^2 | jwsc^Jkw_k,|jI^J z| i ` k,
` m_ Z|o _n_%  }r9}zJo\>mZ|^Jhp^Jj,}r9^_ ^Vsr9b 
n]z |k2r9^|jqF`nVr,^J_ jm~ + 4 
--@2*;eh$Y('()3$q(8|<?9= 2  2W 
E

 J
W m_ j,m_XY} n n_? ` p n_+R  E 5
xI_Rr9mk,h rIr9|_Zmyw_dnZ]njIZ]n h^2 | sc^Jk
r,b k,m h|_ jI^J_ n /r,` k,
` |_Z| ~  )2:D8|.$l7B%  1 W   8 2 


n_n`

\

 scj,b r^6V!XY  2



- -@*;e?$Y('()*+'(8 |kIaRnh^J_[Fk,|jIj|B[2sc^Jk,


XMnDy,{tXY  W n
,x hp hwnVr9b mnBr9Z|n w^2 m jl}r9b z|kIy Z|^Jhp  Z]nVr,|Yy2_nhZ|jm~
';@9*?9=37  2   W 
 
XMnDy% XY  W


" )(B9;*+',-G.l'(B-,1: 

sc^k,

[
 *34'* -(8?e  R-*+',*+B8  nVZ(0| + %

 929
X[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJb W  XY3 0y nVr9mk|  W    
x nk,aJvZ|n tu4mZmr9j^_
1 b n^r9 Z{^J `r9 ^J_ j r,^w0` k,aJmk,jm`nBr9^_~     4 ? G    8 

^2Z]nV twn }v2Z]n 

 
X[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJb W X&9

0y nVr9mk| { W    


x i ` kI
` m_Rr>2^J `r,^J_j sck,^J n_[_n]z|k9nVaJ|
  }r9 z\>|Zm^Jwp^JjI r9 ^J_%pp  |r9^  ` kIaJ|kIj|qF`nVr9 ^J_ ~ -B@2 B "@ |@2- --
wmk, Z]n_[^2Z| mry^VsFXMmZ(bn_  Z]n GF_ a_ m|k,j > X W 

 9W9
X[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJb W VXY JXM` V|k XIR/} 1 b2`_ a /   
xI nVr(n rIr9_aqpk,^2Z||` k,sc^JkGZ(bn^r,Z
r,h>j,mk, |j| ~ R-} $g3)  B%@+    
 
X[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJb W FX&(q`n_ a 0XY i   8 8 5
xI

p^2^Jkwn_ j n]z2mk#2r,^Jmjf|`nVr,^J_}
|k,}zVnVr9 ^J_[n_ o_` h|kIZ]nV 6p/mk,h|_Rr,jr,b  \ Z|nj,V~ 5G*37B0#"{=?;@'(AB:h$Y('().021m
$lB
 
 8>1 8.7 `
w}r,r9mr9^ + 4 .
'>@2m6$Y3).--@2*;eB8 8 8 

 
X[Z]\>^J_ ^` aJb W X&  8 8R
xv%_hn`r,^JnBr9Z0Z| nj,jI Z|nVr9 ^J_p kI^Zm| ` kI!sc^JkF a r(nV 2p^D mkj,p|Z

r,k9n ~f_p kI|p|k,nVr9 ^J_

 8
6^J_Z]nkVU   E W
EG(8$&c)|e2(8
' B@27-3-(8[e2-}$Y('()*|@

{nV`r9b  |k# >  nk,jmKnkIj(


l` m  V\
EW  

 -(8(CB-}+e  (C

 i nV|_ jm 1    W25
x^[>_r,b _nVr,` k,%^sGr9` kI
` m_ Z|V~  B?h4$3)  )2:D8|>? 8

 J
l` m  V%\  W
2 )2B;*+'.07B-@2*+Be

 I2122%;I2'#B98(C ")M8;*8;*+',--:8*8

#"{;*38D*+(80"]B?e2?*3*8*+'4B-*34,8:88 1n
kI aJ_ zJmk,jI rykI|jIj| 1n?

k,aJD


i |__ |V|j|/9

` w my W 

  EW

 -*398  B@98D{*3 "@ |@2-4'( XM i kI|jIj(

 

nV_ a i }XMZ]\>^_ ^J` aJb4 W FXY}(


 W nZ|^
W K\   8 8 5
x  p/^2^Jk{n_4j n]z |k2r9^|j
m`nVr9 ^J_ h^2 | ^Vsr,` k,
` |_Rrl^Dlj| ~ `
w}r,r9mr9^     4  

 29

^ k,V W F  ^JkI !F\  XMn  mrIKnkImr| W   W


x ^JkI|_=6 Z(bn^Jjf_ ngpnkvr9n
 u/|k,m_Rr9nV 4|`nBr9^_[sc^Jkln?b |nVr9m[ ` < ^2^Jp ~  2) :8*+',h ? G W  

E