Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sir Ratan Tata Trust & Navajbai Ratan Tata Trust would like to acknowledge
the contributions of several people who we can remember and many more who
we apologise for not being able to mention here.
We profoundly thank Dr. K. V Kishore Kumar (author), Consultant Psychiatrist,
NIMHANS for selflessly sharing his work for production of this book. We thank
Dr.H. Sudarshan, Honorary Secretary, Karuna Trust; Mata Pragnamayeec,
Trustee, Karuna Trust, Dr. Kantharaju C. Kalegowda, Project Manager, Manasa,
Karuna Trust; Mr. R. Abhinandan, Social Worker (Ex-employee), Karuna
Trust; Mr.Srinivas Jadav, Ms. Prathibha and other staff of Manasa, Ms. Rosa
A. Ferdinando for her editing inputs and asking very relevant questions and
Mr.Raghpathi Bhat for his detailed illustration, on the cover. We thank Professor
Dr B.N Gangadhar, Professor of Psychiatry, NIMHANS for writing the preface of
this collection of short stories. The designing and printing inputs given by Corporate
Communication Services are also acknowledged.
Most of all, we thank the residents and staff of Manasa who openly welcomed us
and shared their life stories. The names of the women have been changed to protect
their identity.
We hope this book does justice to them and promotes provision of mental health
services in our country.
P re fac e
evere mental disorders affect individuals across all ages and spare no social class. Thanks to the progress
in allopathic medicine, a majority of these disorders are treatable and outcomes are positive. Ignorance,
stigma, poverty and non-availability of professional help can lead to delay and even denial of treatment to
most patients. As a consequence, there exists a large treatment gap for people with severe mental disorders. Most
patients are exposed to long periods of untreated psychosis. Even in those who are treated, adherence to treatment is
unsatisfactory and relapses are very common. One of the dreaded consequences of this is illustrated with examples
in this book.
Individuals, who are mentally ill and not in touch with reality need attention and comprehensive care. They
tend to withdraw from social situations and wander away often becoming homeless. Their state of mind might
prevent them from acting judiciously, which may lead to separation from family. Once rendered homeless, they are
exposed to the hazards of society including exploitation and the violation of human rights. Women may be sexually
exploited with untoward consequences, whereas men are often mistaken for people of an antisocial nature. In the
latter scene, the public resort to cruelty leading to physical assault, emotional hurt and other types of abuse. The
inability to act logically is likely to prevent the severely mentally ill from carrying out effectively planned violence
against other civilians. Yet, the public image against the severely mentally ill is that they are dangerous.
Though mental illness is not communicable (infectious), people shun the mentally ill as they fear their unpredictable
behaviour. This also deters public action and samaritanship to help the mentally ill. The case studies should help
allay these fears/concerns and motivate the public to come to the aid of these unfortunate mortals. A humane
approach by civilians as well as the law and the staff of the health department can bring about a sea change in these
souls by initiating appropriate treatment as early as possible.
Early detection and treatment- initiated at the primary care level can help intervene at an early stage which may
prevent the severely mentally ill from becoming severely disabled and consequent wandering away. The district
mental health program is about empowering the primary health care staff to be able to intervene at an early stage.
Diligent implementation of this program has an important role in closing the treatment gap (proportion of patients
who do not get the required treatment) in psychosis. The law and home department should become sensitive to the
issue of severe mental disorders in the community and help reach the carer (mental health team), assist the ill/their
kin to reach the treatment facility and also undertake public awareness measures.
Only a concerted approach by different departments can help contain the consequences of mental disorders in a
public health program.
Case illustration
Mansi
Case illustration
Case illustration
Neha
Case illustration
Swapna
Case illustration
Shashi,
After the initial care to bathe her, feed her and remove
head lice, she was medically evaluated and diagnosed
with schizophrenia. Antipsychotics were initiated but
three groups of drugs failed to control her symptoms
despite an adequate dose given over a sufficient period
of time. It was decided to change the medication to
Clozapine (a drug administered to a person who
is resistant to conventional drugs). Following eight
months of care and treatment, her family members were
located in Chamrajnagar town. She was relocated to her
house and her elderly parents were very pleased to see
their daughter alive and wondered about her recovery.
Case illustration
Case illustration
Babita
Her son did not have any health problems and was
pursuing an education in engineering. He was keen on
settling down with his mother from the moment he
starts earning.
The following were the key issues in the case:
Middle-aged lady with chronic mental illness.
Rescued in time by the Shakthidhama team and
referred for psychiatric care.
Significant improvement with medical
intervention.
Lots of gaps with respect to information about
Babita and her past.
She had to be accommodated in Shakthidhama
as she had no relatives.
Currently engaged in agricultural work.
Her sons education was supported by the local
philanthropists and other socially conscious
people in the community.
Facilities like Shakthidhama have played a very
crucial role in supporting organizations like
Manasa without which, not much would have
been achieved in this case.
The possible revolving door phenomenon, quite
prevalent in such situations, was avoided by good
networking on the part of Manasa.
It is heartening to note that organizations like
Shakthidhama and Manasa have redefined
dignity and safety for vulnerable women like
Babita.
10
Case illustration
11
Case illustration
12
Case illustration
Payal,
10
13
Case illustration
11
14
Case illustration
12
15
Case illustration
Lata
13
16
Case illustration
14
17
Case illustration
Nisha
15
18
Case illustration
16
19
Case illustration
17
20
Case illustration
Lalita,
18
21
Case illustration
Priyanka
19
22
Case illustration
Sonali,
20
23
Case illustration
Jyothi
21
The son who had to take over the reins from the father,
did not live up to the fathers expectations. He was
preoccupied with issues in his own family and even
reduced the number of visits to his parents. He had
even stopped taking his sister to the hospital for a review
despite working in NIMHANS, which is considered one
of the best psychiatric centres in the South East Asian
region. With all the pain, sorrow, misery, suffering and
disappointment, the old father is able to stand up on his
weak legs to take his daughter periodically for a review,
to the hospital. He apologetically says Anyway I have
to do what I have to do for my daughter; regardless of
my poor health. I do not want my daughter to wander
away once again.
Jyothis father has been purchasing medication on his
own and encouraging her to take it regularly. Despite
regular treatment she continues to have symptoms and
disability. It would have been beneficial if she were taken
to the doctor for regular reviews so that new drugs could
be administered to make changes in her life.
The following were the key issues in the case:
Long-standing illness with significant disability.
Mother of two children.
Stigma and discrimination.
Separated from husband who provides practically
no support to her.
Primary carers are elderly parents.
Continues to be symptomatic despite regular
treatment.
Very poor follow-up care.
Disability welfare benefits would have been of
great value to her.
24
Case illustration
Sonam
22
25
Case illustration
Sunila
23
26
Case illustration
Anushka
24
27
Case illustration
Shreshtha
25
28
Case illustration
26
29
Case illustration
27
school and used to live with her parents. After the death
of her parents, it was her responsibility to take care of
her brother, which she did to the best possible extent.
Following the onset of illness, Juni and her sisterin-law did not get along very well, because she was
considered a burden. She developed psychotic illness
and stopped doing household work. As she could not
play a meaningful role in the family she was rebuked,
constantly. Juni became a source of conflict in the
family. Her sister-in-law considered Juni to be a lazy
person, and a liability for the family.
Juni was never treated for her mental illness, which she
suffered from for more than 12 years. They physically
restrained her, rebuked her if she made a mistake,
locked her up if she was disruptive, starved her if she
was aggressive and so on. About eight years ago, she
went missing and the family members thought that she
was dead. The conflicts reduced dramatically after Juni
disappeared from the home.
30
Case illustration
Ashabanu
28
31
Case illustration
29
32
Case illustration
Bhavana
30
33
Case illustration
Lalitha
31
34
Case illustration
Sharada
32
Case illustration
Garima
33
35
Case illustration
34
36
Case illustration
Karishma
35
belonged to a middle-income
agricultural family, who lived in Hassan district. The
family consisted of two daughters and a son. Karishma
was one of the daughters. After she completed ten years
of schooling the father got her married to a person of
equal status in the same district.
Karishma who had been ill after her marriage, found
it difficult to adjust with the family. She realized that
things were not all that well in her life. She learnt that
her husband was already married and that she was
not aware of the same. She was then sent back to her
parents house in Hallimysore and she never returned to
her husbands home.
Karishma started exhibiting strange behaviour. She was
very suspicious, irritable, refused to eat, and seemed
very sensitive to routine comments at home. The family
members thought that she was upset because of her
broken marriage. Her father tried to convince her that
he would take the responsibility to sort things out. He
soon realized that his son-in-law was not a trustworthy
person and so did not want to go back to their house
when they cheated him, so blatantly.
Karishma was missing from the home, when a couple of
days later, they received a telephone call from the local
police station stating that they had found a person who
belonged to Hallimysore and that she was unwell. The
father went to the police station and brought Karishma
back. The entire family consoled her. They did not
realize that she was ill and required treatment. Everyone
kept a close vigil, as though containing her, would cure
the mental health problems she had.
37
Case illustration
Reshma
36
38
Themes
Some of the following themes are prominent in the case studies along with several other issues. The
reader might have come across many more. We would be interested to know of any issue that the reader
finds significant in ensuring provision of care, to persons with mental illness.
S. No.
Themes
Faith healing or no treatment before getting dislocated from home 1, 7, 8, 18, 32, 35, 36
2, 6, 21, 33
4
Need for Long Term Care due to inadequate psycho-social support 5, 9, 11, 12, 13, 16, 26,
19, 26, 31
5
Need for proactive Home Based Care or assertive community care 14, 15, 17, 20, 26, 27
22, 23, 29
3, 4, 7, 19, 28
39
Afterwo rd
Sir Ratan Tata Trust & Navajbai Ratan Tata Trust
Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT) & Navajbai Ratan Tata Trust (NRTT) are amongst the oldest philanthropic foundations in India. The Trusts have collaborated with Non-Profit Organizations (NPOs) on the issue of Mental Health
for over a decade. The Mental Health Initiative (MHI) was born out of a need felt by the Trusts for a nationwide
action on the issue. The Trusts supported Manasa under MHI, since 2007.
These case stories are part of an assessment study commissioned by SRTT & NRTT in 2010. The evaluator and
the author of these case studies, Dr. K.V. Kishore Kumar, Professor of Community Psychiatry, National Institute
of Mental Health and Neuro-Sciences (NIMHANS), Bengaluru, personally visited each of the women mentioned
in the story, in their habitat.
To know more about the Trusts & MHI, please visit www.mentalhealthinitiative.in / www.srtt.org
40
Shakthidhama Mysore
Shakthidhama has been housing women who are exploited and abused in the society, since 1997. Shakthidhama
gives them shelter till they find a better place to live. The women who stay here have the chance to become selfreliant. Work in Shakthidhama is conceived as a therapy. Continuous involvement in work helps the inmates overcome lingering delinquencies, that they might have acquired in their past life.
The inmates who are literate teach other inmates who are illiterate. A family counseling center is run and regular
counseling is given to the needy families as well as the relatives and parents of the inmates. The inmates often need
psychiatric consultation and the same is provided as and when needed.
Shakthidhama also runs a helpline, provides free legal aid and medical treatment for distressed women.
41
Published by Sir Ratan Tata Trust & Navajbai Ratan Tata Trust