Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Page 1 of 18
WTS 4 & 6
Page 2 of 18
WTS 4 & 6
Page 3 of 18
Performances. The teacher knows how to use a variety of media communication tools,
including audiovisual aids and computers, to enrich learning opportunities.
WTS 4 & 6
Danielson Domains
Domain 1: Planning and Preparation
Component 1a: Demonstrating Knowledge of Content and Pedagogy
Component 1c: Selecting Instructional Goals
Component 1d: Demonstrating Knowledge of Resources
Component 1e: Designing Coherent Instruction
Component 1f: Assessing Student Learning
Domain 3: Instruction
Component 3a: Communicating Clearly and Accurately
Component 3c: Engaging Students in Learning
Component 3d: Providing Feedback to Students
Component 3e: Demonstrating Flexibility and Responsiveness
Page 4 of 18
WTS 4 & 6
Page 5 of 18
Pre-assessments
Self-Reflection Assessment of Student Performance and Learning Environment
I am in my third year of teaching Biology at Baraboo High School which is a rural school
within the Baraboo School District located in south central Wisconsin. I currently teach four
sections of Biology which is a required course for all students. My four sections are composed
of 86 students (43 males and 43 females), of which 81 are ninth graders, three are tenth graders,
one is an eleventh grader, and one is a twelfth grader. Ten students are identified as
Hispanic/Latino, five are Native American, two are African American, one is Asian, and 68 are
White. Four students are identified as Learning Disabled (LD), two are identified with
Emotional Behavioral Disorder (EBD), one is diagnosed with Autism, and ten are identified as
at-risk of academic deficiency. One of my sections of Biology is supported with a special
education assistant to assist the special education students in that section. There is a wide variety
in abilities in both math and reading skills ranging from below grade level to advanced
placement. When planning lessons for this course, I keep in mind the length of activities, ways
to incorporate movement, and delivery of notes to accommodate these students.
The unit I am currently teaching in Biology is the Genetics unit. Past experience has
taught me that this unit requires a lot of differentiation, as having adequate math skills is required
to excel in this unit. Given that there is a wide range in my students math abilities, I need to
differentiate each lesson so the pace is appropriate for each student. At the beginning of each
unit, my students complete a pretest where I can assess their level of understanding for each
standard within the unit. The standard I have chosen to assess is their ability to apply concepts of
ratios and Punnett squares to explain the variation and distribution of expressed traits in a
WTS 4 & 6
Page 6 of 18
population. This standard is directly related to the Next Generation Science Standard HS-LS3-3.
Apply concepts of statistics and probability to explain the variation and distribution of expressed
traits in a population. This is an expansion on what they learned about genetics in their middle
school life science class. Their pretest (Artifact A) included questions about probability of
outcomes and complete dominance Punnett squares. Many of these questions, including the
complete dominance Punnett square should be a review from their middle school course. When
analyzing my students responses (Artifact C) on the pretest it became clear that some needed a
lot of direct instruction, while others needed a quick review of the rules. Fifty six students scored
a 3 or below and 50 scored 4 and above on the 6-point scoring guide (Artifact B). A score of 4
has been set as the threshold for proficiency.
Technology Selection and Instructional Strategies to Guide Learning Process and Growth
As a result of my students performance on the pre-test, I have chosen to incorporate a
technology that students could use to quickly review the key concepts instead of going through
notes in the traditional direct instruction manner. EDpuzzle is as free software that allows you to
insert questions into an instructional video. The students are unable to continue viewing the
remainder of the video until they correctly respond to the questions. If they respond with the
incorrect answer, it will replay that section of the video and provide students another opportunity
to answer the question. Another great feature of EDpuzzle is that students responses to the
questions are recorded and could be used as a formative assessment. A limitation of EDpuzzle is
that while I can insert as many questions into the video as I would like, the questions must be
selected response (i.e. multiple choice). I have selected EDpuzzle because it will allow my
WTS 4 & 6
Page 7 of 18
students who are accelerated to move at a faster pace while I am still able to work in small
groups with students who need further explanations.
After reviewing my students performance on the pretest, I have chosen to incorporate
EDpuzzle into just one of my four sections of Biology. I chose to incorporate this technology
into my 4B section because this is a group of students that have strong math skills, many of
whom are accelerated in their math course, and made simple mistakes on their pretest that I feel
will be easily corrected with a brief review of complete dominance Punnett squares. After going
over the correct responses to the pretest and an introductory activity that reviewed the essential
vocabulary for the genetics unit, I assigned students the EDpuzzle (Artifact D). The link to the
EDpuzzle I created was posted to our Google Classroom page. The instructional video I chose to
use for my EDpuzzle was from the YouTube channel Amoeba Sisters. My students have been
previously exposed to the Amoeba Sisters channel when reviewing content in previous units.
When students finished the EDpuzzle, students were instructed to complete their homework
assignment, the post assessment (Artifact E) which was comprised of four practice complete
dominance problems, and submit their answers on our Formative classroom page. In my other
three sections of Biology, I chose to use direct instruction for the delivery of the notes on
complete dominance Punnett squares based upon the needs of my students in terms of their math
skills and the nature of the mistakes made on the pretest. All of my students completed the same
post-assessment, regardless of the delivery of instruction. My hypothesis is that EDpuzzle will
be a successful mode of instruction and there will be no noticeable difference between students
who view the EDpuzzle or receive direct instruction.
WTS 4 & 6
Page 8 of 18
Post-assessments
Comparisons and Insights of Student Performance and Learning Environment
The post assessment (Artifact E) my students completed consisted of four, multipart complete dominance problems. They submitted their answers for each problem on
our Formative classroom page. The questions I chose to review for the post assessment
are a representative sample of all the skills assessed on the pretest for complete dominance
Punnett squares. After reviewing the results of the post-assessment in all four of my
sections of Biology, I did not notice a strong difference between the sections that received
direct instruction and those that completed the EDpuzzle for their instruction.
In reviewing the data from the post assessment from my students, I was pleased to
see that all students who were present in class for the complete dominance lesson showed
growth. While initially, only 30 students scored a 4 or higher on the pre-assessment, 68
students scored a 4 or higher on the post-assessment, with 41 students earning a perfect
score of 6/6. It was encouraging to see that 87% of my students reached a proficient or
advanced level with only one day of instruction and practice.
When directly comparing my sections that received direct instruction versus the
EDpuzzle, I noticed that the section who viewed the EDpuzzle slightly outperformed my
other three sections that received direct instruction. The section that viewed the EDpuzzle
nearly 92% of my students achieved proficiency compared to 87% of my students
achieving proficiency in the sections that received direct instruction. While I am pleased
to say the EDpuzzle was an effective means of instruction, I am hesitant to say that it is a
more effective means of instruction. In the section that viewed the EDpuzzle, there is only
WTS 4 & 6
Page 9 of 18
one student identified as special education and twelve that are placed in accelerated math
courses. The ability to complete these types of genetics problems requires strong math
skills. In this section all but one student is at or above grade level in their mathematics
abilities. Their strong math skills likely played a large role in their successes in
completing complete dominance Punnett squares.
What surprised the most in comparing the two different methods of instruction was
how the learning environment changed. In the sections that received direct instruction, the
students were much more relaxed and comfortable with the mode of instruction. They
responded as a class when asked informal formative questions. Those who had questions
interjected when appropriate. However, in the section that viewed the EDpuzzle, the
students seem much more uncomfortable with the mode of instruction. They felt the
strong need to write down everything they read in the questions that were inserted into the
video. They also wanted confirmation from myself that they were answering the questions
correctly, even though the computer notified them about the accuracy of their responses.
After a few students received affirmation that they were doing a great job, they seemed to
become more at ease with the EDpuzzle. I contribute a lot of the change in the students
responses to the fact that at this point in the semester there are well established routines to
our classroom. This was a completely new form of instruction for them. Despite their
apparent discomfort at the change in instruction, they did exceptionally well on the postassessment. I am hopeful that when using EDpuzzle in the future, students will become
more familiar with this routine.
WTS 4 & 6
Page 10 of 18
WTS 4 & 6
Page 11 of 18
be more likely to see it as an instructional activity and more confidently progress through the
video.
3. Providing headphones for the students while they view the EDpuzzle would be beneficial so that
they do not become distracted by the noise coming from their neighbors computers.
WTS 4 & 6
Page 12 of 18
WTS 4 & 6
Page 13 of 18
WTS 4 & 6
Page 14 of 18
Section
Pretest
Post-test
Student 1
2A
Student 2
2A
Student 3
2A
0 missing
Student 4
2A
Student 5
2A
Student 6
2A
Student 7
2A
Student 8
2A
Student 9
2A
0 missing
Student 10
2A
Student 11
2A
Student 12
2A
Student 13
2A
Student 14
2A
0 missing
Student 15
2A
Student 16
2A
Student 17
2A
Student 18
2A
Student 19
2A
WTS 4 & 6
Page 15 of 18
Student 20
2A
Student 21
3A
Student 22
3A
Student 23
3A
Student 24
3A
1 missing
Student 25
3A
Student 26
3A
Student 27
3A
Student 28
3A
2 missing
Student 29
3A
Student 30
3A
2 missing
Student 31
3A
Student 32
3A
Student 33
3A
Student 34
3A
2 missing
Student 35
3A
Student 36
3A
Student 37
3A
Student 38
3A
Student 39
3A
Student 40
3A
0 missing
Student 41
3A
Student 42
3A
Student 43
3A
Student 44
3A
Student 45
1B
Student 46
1B
Student 47
1B
Student 48
1B
2 missing
Student 49
1B
Student 50
1B
Student 51
1B
Student 52
1B
Student 53
1B
Student 54
1B
Student 55
1B
0 missing
Student 56
1B
Student 57
1B
Student 58
1B
WTS 4 & 6
Page 16 of 18
Student 59
1B
Student 60
1B
Student 61
1B
Student 62
1B
Student 63
4B
Student 64
4B
Student 65
4B
Student 66
4B
Student 67
4B
Student 68
4B
Student 69
4B
Student 70
4B
Student 71
4B
Student 72
4B
Student 73
4B
Student 74
4B
Student 75
4B
Student 76
4B
Student 77
4B
Student 78
4B
Student 79
4B
Student 80
4B
Student 81
4B
Student 82
4B
Student 83
4B
Student 84
4B
Student 85
4B
Student 86
4B
WTS 4 & 6
Artifact D: EDpuzzle
Link to view the EDpuzzle that was created for my students to view.
Link to EDpuzzle
Page 17 of 18
WTS 4 & 6
Page 18 of 18