Professional Documents
Culture Documents
juncture, Jinnah resurrected the Muslim League like a phoenix from its ashes. Had there been no
such reorganization the League would have seen the same fate in 1945-46 general elections.
The historical situation during the 1937-1947 decade presented and permitted of two alternative
paths of development of Muslim politics i.e.
These alternative paths were presented at least on six different but specific occasions i.e. 1937,
1939, 1940, 1942, 1945 and 1946. But on no occasion did Jinnah waver, and each time he chose
for himself and for Muslim India the path towards establishing Muslim, religio-political identity
on a constitutional plane. The path concertized since 1940 in the Pakistan platform. Starting from
Jinnahs presidential address to All India Muslim League at Lucknow session (1937), he always
remained over the Muslim separatism and independent line of action for the league. Thus by the
beginning of 1940, Muslim politics took a new and significant turn, and departed from pre 1937
policy. Jinnahs presidential address on March 22, 1940, at Lahore is a hallmark in the history of
Muslim Nationalism in India. He made the concept of Two Nation Theory clear and out rightly
rejected the idea of Indian nation. The historic resolution that ensured his address became the
clarion call, as well as morning star in the two hundred years dark night of the slavery of Indian
Muslims. The mole which was roaming aimlessly in the desert of despondence started marching
towards its destination under the leadership of capable, brave and upright leader indeed the great
leader Muhammad Ali Jinnah.
The Cripps Proposal-a devise of British diplomacy to appease Indians and to jet their
cooperation in the 2nd World War against Axis Powers was an evil design to counter the
Muslims demand for separate homeland. Nevertheless, non-accession clause opened the way for
partition of country. The formation of Pakistan, as resolved in 1940, was dump by other clauses
of formula. It was Jinnah who perceived the mischievousness of the scheme and out rightly
rejected the plan.
It is true that Jinnah accepted the cabinet mission plan initially, but his acceptance, though
genuinely sincere at the time, primarily motivated by the fact that the plan contained the seeds of
Pakistan. The plan provided for a somewhat limited Muslim religio-political identity in a
confederal India with the prospects of Pakistan after a decade, if the proposed arrangement failed
to work to the satisfaction of the Muslims.
It may be argued that the fateful decision to continue boycott of the constituent assembly after
having got the Muslim League entrenched in the Interim Governments declarations of 6 th
December 1946 and of 20th February 1947 which paved the way for the partition. Not only in
regard to this constituent assembly boycott decision but in several other crucial decisions during
the moments 1937-1947 decade as well, Jinnah alone mattered, and Jinnah alone or for the most
part, determined the cause. Muslim India and Muslim politics were to traverse.
3rd June Plan of Lord Mountbatten and Radcliff Award, no doubt, eclipsed the Muslims optimism
of restoring their land by the right justification of numerical majority of the areas especially
Bengal and Punjab, yet it was Jinnahs sagacity to handle Mountbatten who had no intention to
give Jinnah a Pakistan. The allegations against Jinnahs accepting the moth-eaten Pakistan can be
refuted through the evidence on the record. In fact, Jinnah had no expediency other than to
accept the offer, because refusal of the offer must have amounted to be lingering on the process
of transfer of power.
Conclusion
Indeed, even as late as June 1946 whatever the political forces and conditions at work likely and
more imminent choice, and it was Jinnah alone who made the crucial decision that led Muslim
India directly to Pakistan within a year that transformed the possibility of an independent Muslim
homeland into actuality. Thus Jinnahs person was crucial and critical in the making Pakistan.
The whole world acknowledged that had there been no Jinnah there would have been no Pakistan
and the nation rightfully acclaimed him Quaid-i-Azam, the great leader.
Rehabilitation of Refugees
Constitutional Problem
Economic Constraints
Defence
Riots in Punjab
Choice of Capital
Language Problem
Pakhtoonistan Movement
But in spite of all these problems, Jinnah did a lot to extricate the infant state from unthinkable
difficulties. He was successful to redress these problems turn by turn
Steps Taken By Jinnah as a Governor General
Accession of Kallat
Membership of UNO
Conclusion
Already drained Jinnah could no longer witness his newly created state becoming mature. But
the time he got form the Lord was fully utilized by him to build Pakistan into a strong and
organized state where the Muslims of sub-continent could live according to the ideas of Islam.
His efforts to put the infant state on the path of stability and progress are uncountable. His efforts
to enthuse people, steps for rehabilitation of refugees, endeavours to settle internal disputes and
his maneuvers in diplomatic arena speaks of his sagacity and iron-will against all hazards.
Rehabilitation of Refugees
books in Urdu. As a counter proposal, certain Hindu leaders of Benaras proposed that the Urdu
language written in Persian script should be discontinued in the government courts and therefore
should be replaced by language written in Devnagri script. It was the first occasion when he felt
that it was now impossible for the Hindus and the Muslims to progress as a single nation and for
anyone to work for both of them. Simultaneously, he met the commissioner of Benaras and
discussed the problems of Muslim education. The British official was surprised at the change and
said, Hitherto, you have always been keen about the welfare of Indians in general, this is the
first occasion that I have heard about the progress of Muslim alone.
Allama Muhammad Iqbal
Allama Iqbal was a poet and philosopher of India. He too was an ardent advocate of Indian
Nationalism and Hindu-Muslim unity in his early career. He was shifted from this stance in
England during his study of Western Nationalism. The local political situation and HinduMuslim rifts left its impression over his mine. But the thing which transformed him form a great
exponent of Indian Nationalism to the advocate of Internationalism and Pan-Islamism was the
modern nationalism which had divided nations into warring groups resulting into two World
Wars. This was a positive approach. He wanted to solve Hindu-Muslim problem for once and all.
In his early career, he did his utmost to integrate Indian nations but the time proved that his
spiritual and ideological change was the exigency of the time.
In 1909, when he was invited to Amritsar to attend a meeting of cosmopolitan organization with
the membership open to the Hindus and the Muslims, Iqbal politely declined the invitation and in
the course of correspondence that ensured, he wrote, I have myself been often view that
difference should disappear from this country, and never now, I act on this principle in my
private life. But now, I thank the preservation their separate nation entitle is desirable for both
Hindus and the Muslims. The vision of a common nationhood for India is a beautiful ideal, and
heads a poetic appeal. But looking to the present conditions and the unconscious to the present
conditions and the unconscious trends of the two communities, this idea appears incapable of
fulfillment.