Professional Documents
Culture Documents
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/39402796
CITATIONS
READS
449
1 author:
Diego Villana
GANASA
28 PUBLICATIONS 449 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Diego Villana on 01 January 2017.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
VB DE LOS DIRECTORES
Junio 2007
AGRADECIMIENTOS
No es fcil aceptar que tu hijo te llene la casa de egagrpilas, plumas,
cangrejos, culebras, tortugas, ratoneros, lechuzas, picarazas, cardelinas..., que
en lugar de jugar al ftbol como el resto de zagales se pegue el da subiendo a
los rboles o con las redes japonesas de Pao, que te haga construir una
pajarera y una balseta para las tortugas...en fin, no es fcil. A pesar de todo se
le perdona porque, al fin y al cabo, a lo hijos hay que quererlos no?. El lmite
llega cuando, despus de haber acabado la carrera y haber conseguido trabajo
de veterinario en una clnica de Huesca con horario de tienda y pijama verde,
pilla el cro y se te marcha a Ciudad Real, de becario precario a estudiar las
cagarrutas de las perdices..., eso es que no hay quien lo entienda. Pues no,
ellos s lo entendieron y lo respetaron, y es ms, en lugar de darme una colleja
para que se me fuesen los pjaros de la cabeza, me animaron a continuar por
este camino tan raro pero tan bonito que he escogido. Por eso, por haber
estado siempre ah, dndome todo lo que tenan y ms, incluidas muchas dosis
de paciencia, y haberme permitido optar por esta vida, tengo que estar
agradecido a mis padres. Gracias.
Tres cuartos de lo mismo para el resto de mi sufrida familia, en especial a
mi hermana Lidius, porque la dej en Sangarrn siendo una crieta y cuando
volv ya se me haba convertido en una mujerona. Por esas horas que le
correspondan a ella y que tuve que pasar en Zaragoza o en Ciudad Real, y
que nunca me ha echado en cara, tambin gracias. Tambin para Javier por
aquello de yaye vamo al pampo, los primeros prismticos y la primera gua.
En fin, a todos. La verdad es que la familia no se elige y es una suerte que te
toque una de la que te puedas sentir tan orgulloso. Gracias.
En la facultad, hay mucha gente a la que agradecer muchas cosas, Llus
Lujn me ech una importantsima primera mano para poder comenzar con
esto del bicho de monte en la Alfranca y en la sala de necropias. La gente de
AVAFES fue una segunda familia para mi, tantas cervezotas juntos, tantos
cursos... y que decir de Javier Lucientes, cuanto fro anillando en el carrizal de
Sangarrn, pobre buenazo que se dej engaar por el que subscribe para que
le dirigiese una tesina con las mosquetas de los Monegros. Sin su apoyo ni se
me habra pasado por la cabeza llamar a las puertas de IREC, y esta Tesis
nunca habra visto la luz.
De la poca del IREC, el primero debe estar Christian Gortzar; que se dej
engaar y dio una oportunidad al coletas de Avafes que haba hecho la tesina
con papa Lucientes. Es de agradecer la paciencia que ha demostrado tener
conmigo todo este tiempo, y la confianza en que al final saldran las cosas (yo
dud de mi capacidad en ms de una ocasin). Ms de lo mismo para rsula
Hefle, la cual, a pesar de andar siempre corriendo de aqu para all, supo
sacar el tiempo necesario para ensearme a ver algo ms que tripas en la sala
de necropsias, a ser Eduardo manos-pipetas y por hacer inteligible mi
ingls. Con el resto del clan del submundo; Pela, Xuacu, Isabel, Chute, Paqui,
Vane, Moni, Eli, Maricln, Oscarn, Manoln y Pablo me une mucho ms que
una amistad, somos desde luego hermanos de sangre (y de bazos, de
riones, de garrapatas...). Fuera de coas, viajar a otras partes, conocer
mucha gente, pero veo difcil que en ningn sitio pueda llegar a sentir ms en
casa que con vosotros, gracias. De los primos de ecologa y de gentica
mucho y bueno, muchos conteos de todo tipo de bicho viviente, muchos cafs
en los que se aprenda ms que en algunas charlas de catedrticos, muchas
caitas con tapa, esos marcapginas finos de Rouconen, en fin, lo dicho,
mucho y bueno. Y mencin especial para el clan del micro pollo con Sarva
Quillo Ariquitaung, Fabi el torero churriego, el Triquiuelas terror de la noche
culiparda y sobre todo Loren, que tanto ha aportado al desarrollo de esta tesis.
Y si en Ciudad Real estuve bien, que no decir de Asturies. Cuanto que
agradecer a Maria, Emilio, Pilar y Pepe, que me acogieron como a uno ms de
su familia y que mostraron paciencia infinita cada vez que, en lugar de cortarme
la coleta por llenarles la cuadra de vsceras de corzo, jabal, ciervo, zorro u
otras lindezas, me esperaban con quesn de ese bueno de la peral, sidra
abundante y sarandonga para arreglar el mundo. Gracias.
Aunque me estoy alargando demasiado, no puedo dejar de nombrar a los
compaeros de Navarra; Isabel, Jse, Javi, Alex, Enrique y el resto de gente de
Viveros, con los que contino disfrutando de mi trabajo y de los que cada da
aprendo algo y a Lorenzo Bintanel, que puso el toque artstico con los dibujos
de esta tesis.
INDICE
I. ESTRUCTURA DE LA TESIS. 3
II. INTRODUCCIN GENERAL.... 4
II.1. Descripcin y distribucin de la especie 4
II.2. Importancia ecolgica y socioeconmica............. 6
II.3. Tendencia de sus poblaciones 8
II.4. Factores implicados en la disminucin de las poblaciones10
II.5. El papel de las enfermedades..11
II.6. Enfermedades y parsitos de la perdiz roja.. 13
II.7. Las repoblaciones como herramienta de gestin..... 22
II.8. Bibliografa... 27
III. OBJETIVOS 38
IV. CAPITULO 1.. 41
Las repoblaciones con aves de granja como focos de
introduccin de nuevos parsitos en las poblaciones silvestres
de perdiz roja.
V. CAPITULO 2 56
Variaciones en el resultado de los anlisis coprolgicos
preventivos actuales en funcin del tipo de heces analizadas y
de la hora de recogida de las mismas.
VI. CAPITULO 3.. 77
Efectividad de los tratamientos antiparasitarios como mtodo
para prevenir la introduccin de nematodos en el campo.
I. ESTRUCTURA DE LA TESIS
al., 2001). A esta distribucin natural hay que aadir la poblacin del sureste de
Inglaterra, originada a partir de unas primeras sueltas de perdices francesas en
1.770 (Tapper, 1992) y mantenida, probablemente, gracias al continuo aporte
de aves de granja (Tapper, 1999).
Tradicionalmente se han diferenciado tres subespecies de perdiz roja: A.
rufa rufa, A. r. hispanica y A. r. intercedens. La primera de ellas distribuida por
el sur de Francia y norte de Italia, as como en las poblaciones introducidas del
Reino Unido; la segunda, ocupara la franja noroeste de la Pennsula Ibrica,
constituida por Catalua, Aragn, Navarra, Pas Vasco, Cantabria, Asturias,
Galicia, Castilla Len y el norte de Extremadura; y la
tercera y ltima
5
4,5
3,5
3,5
3
2,5
3
Capturas
Perdices / UTM 10
4,5
2,5
Abundancia
20
02
20
00
19
98
19
96
19
94
19
92
19
90
2
19
88
19
86
10
Lagpodos cazados
1500
1000
500
Zona control
Zona tratada
0
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
12
Etiologa
Importancia
Viruela aviar
Avipoxvirus
New Castle
Paramyxovirus tipo 1
Gumboro
Birnavirus
Laringotraquetis
Herpesvirus alfa
Cabeza Hinchada
Pneumovirus
Descrito en perdices
silvestres en Espaa.
Altas mortalidades
Descrito en perdices.
EDO*
Plan de erradicacin.
Altas mortalidades.
EDO*
Descrita en perdiz.
EDO*
Descrito en perdices
silvestres en Espaa.
Bronquitis infecciosa
Coronavirus
Gripe aviar
Virus Influenza
West Nile
Flavivirus
Descrita en perdiz.
EDO*
Descrita en perdiz.
EDO*
Zoonosis altamente
transmisible.
Recientemente
descrita en A. chuka.r
Referencias
Gortzar et al., 2002b
Buenestado et al., 2004
Randi et al., 1985
OIE, 2007
Sacristn et al., 2005
OIE, 2007
OIE, 2007
Pizarro y Elices 1997
Cavanagh, 2005
OIE, 2007
Humberd et al., 2006
OIE, 2007
Hayes et al., 2005.
OIE, 2007
CDC, 2007
14
15
Esta afeccin es, sin lugar a dudas, la primera causa de bajas en las
granjas de perdiz roja en Espaa donde se controla mediante el uso, a menudo
inadecuado, de antibiticos, lo cual da lugar a numerosas antibioresistencias
que dificultan su control y que obligan en ocasiones a realizar el vaco sanitario
de la explotacin afectada.
A nivel de campo, solamente aparecen casos en aves procedentes de
sueltas para ojeos o caza intensiva, pero nunca en aves autctonas.
Aunque menos frecuentes, existen otras dos enfermedades descritas en la
perdiz roja y que, por ser transmisibles al hombre, merecen ser consideradas.
Una sera la Salmonelosis, causada por S. typhimurium, S. pullorum y S.
gallinarum (Pennycot et al., 2002), especies todas transmisibles al hombre y
que producen graves diarreas en perdices de granja.
La otra zoonosis a tener en cuenta es la Tuberculosis aviar, producida por
Mycobacterium avium y descrita en perdices silvestres del sur de la Pennsula
Ibrica (Milln et al., 2004c).
Otras enfermedades bacterianas descritas en la perdiz roja son la
pasterelosis, la clamidiosis, la micoplasmosis o el coriza contagioso pero su
importancia en esta especie es mucho menor (ver Tabla 2).
Tabla 2. Principales enfermedades causadas por bacterias descritas en la perdiz roja.
(*Enfermedad de declaracin obligatoria).
Enfermedad
Etiologa
Colibacilosis
Escherichia coli.
Salmonelosis
Salmonella typhimurium,
S. pullorum y S. gallinarum
Mycobacterim avium
Tuberculosis
aviar
Clostridiosis
Clamidiosis
Pasterelosis
Micoplasmosis
Importancia
Frecuente en granjas.
Resistencias.
Referencias
Zoonosis.
Frecuente en granja.
Zoonosis.
Milln et al (2004c)
Descrita en perdices
silvestres.
Clostridium perfringens
Zoonosis.
Stuve et al. 1992
Descrita en galliformes
silvestres.
Chlamydia psittaci
Zoonosis.
Erbeck y Nunn 1999
Descrita en galliformes.
OIE, 2007
EDO*.
Pasteurella multocida tipo A, Descrita en perdices.
Cucco et al., 2007
serotipos 3, 5 y 7
Frecuente en granja.
Graves prdidas.
Mycoplasma gallisepticum, Descrita en perdices.
Cookson and
M. imitans, o M. synoviae EDO*.
Shivaprasad 1994
OIE, 2007
16
Referencias
Eimeria sp.
Eimeria coturnicis
Eimeria gonzalezi
Eimeria kofoidi
Eimeria legionensis
Eimeria padulensis
Romero, 1974; Romero y Lizano, 1974; Cordero del Campillo et al., 1994.
Eimeria phasiani
Eimeria procera
Romero, 1974; Reina et al., 1992 ; Cordero del Campillo et al., 1994.
17
18
Referencias
Acuaria sp.
Masala, 1986
Acuaria gruweli
Acuaria harmulosa
Acuaria spinosa
b
r
g
g
Allopoda spp.
Masala, 1986
Aonchoteca caudinflata
Ascardia sp.
Ascaridia comprar
Ascaridia galli
Tibbits y Babero, 1969 ; Reina et al., 1992 ; Milln et al., 2004a ; Foronda et al., 2005
Aviosperpens mosgovoyi
Baruscapillaria obsignata
Baylisascaris larvae
Capillaria spp.
Govoni y Maestrini, 1979 ; Githkopoulos, 1984 ; Belleou y Leonard, 1991 ; Reina et al., 1992
b
g
r
Capillaria anatis
Capillaria caudinflata
Capillaria contorta
Githkopoulos, 1984 ; Reina et al., 1992 ; Pizarro et al., 2000 ; Calvete et al., 2003
Capillaria obsignata
Varela, 1974 ; Masala, 1986 ; Reina et al., 1992 ; Calvete et al., 2004
Capillaria phasianina
Githkopoulos, 1984
Cheilospirura gruvelli
Gozdev, 1956 ; Varela, 1974 ; Calvete et al., 2003 ; Calvete et al., 2004 ; Milln et al., 2004a
Cheilospirura spinosa
Cyrnea eurycerca
Gozdev, 1956
Cyrnea parroti
Varela, 1974
Cyrnea seurati
Eucoleus contortus
Eucoleus annulatus
Eustrongyloides mergorum
b
r
Canguleterakis sp.
Vasilev, 1992
Canguleterakis altaica
Canguleterakis macroura
Vasilev, 1992
Canguleterakis tenuicaudata
Heterakis sp.
Vasilev, 1992
Heterakis dispar
Heterakis tenuicauda
Oxyspirura schulzi
Gozdev, 1956
Oxyspirura rijikovi
Borgarenko, 1970
Seudocyrnea colini
Seudocyrnea eurycerca
Heterakis gallinarum
g
g
Streptocara crassicauda
Vasilev, 1992
Strongylida sp.
Subulura brumpti
Gozdev, 1956
Subulura coturnicis
Subulura differens
Subulura suctoria
Varela, 1974 ; Tarazona et al., 1979 Calvete et al., 2003 ; Calvete et al., 2004
Tetrameres sp.
Tetrameres timopheevoi
Trichostrongylus tenuis
Gozdev, 1956
r
b
r
r
Tarazona et al., 1979 ; Masala et al., 1986 ; Calvete et al., 2003 ; Calvete et al., 2004 ; Milln
r
et al., 2004a
19
Rhabdometra
Hymenolepis spp.
Referencias
r
b
g
c
Tarazona et al., 1979 ; Masala et al.,1986 ; Belleauy Lonard, 1991 ;Vasiliev, 1992 ; Cordero
r
r
r
del Campillo et al., 1994 ; Calvete et al., 2003 ; Calvete et al., 2004 ; Milln et al.,
r
b
2004a ;Foronda et al., 2005
g
g
Gozdev, 1956 ; Belleau y Lonard, 1991
Hymenolepis carioca
Hymenolepis graeca
Mesocestoides sp.
Johri, 1960
g
r
r
r
Gozdev, 1956 ; Varela, 1974 ; Tarazona et al., 1979 ; Calvete et al., 2004 ; Foronda et al.,
b
2005
r
Milln et al., 2003b
Metroliasthes sp.
Metroliasthes lucida
Choanotaenia infundibulum
Lyruterina nigropunctata
b
g
Paradicranotaenia anormales
Raillietina bolivari
Raillietina cesticillus
r
b
Raillietina circumvallata
Gozdev, 1956
Raillietina echinobothrida
Raillietina friedbergeri
Raillietina graeca
Gozdev, 1956
Raillietina korkei
Gozdev, 1956
Raillietina micracantha
Raillietina skrjabini
r
g
Tetrathyridium variable
Variolepis farciminosa
Smith, 1986
Skryabinia bolivari
20
Por ltimo hay que mencionar al grupo de los trematodos, del cual se han
descrito un menor nmero de especies parasitando a la perdiz (Tabla 6) pero
que, en determinadas zonas, pueden ser unos de los helmintos ms
frecuentemente encontrados (Calvete et al., 2003).
Tabla 6. Principales trematodosis descritas en el gnero Alectoris. (A. rufa=r, A. graeca=
g
, A. chukar=c, A. barbara=b)
Trematodo
Referencias
Brachylaemus sp.
Brachylaima fuscatus
Conspicuum alectoris
Varela, 1974
Corrigia corrigia
Gozdec, 1956
Corrigia skrjabini
Dicrocoelium petroni
Hypoderaeum conoideum
Vasilev, 1992
Postharmostomum gallinum
Gozdev, 1956
Tamerlania zarudnyi
Gozdev, 1956
Dicrocoelium sp.
r
g
g
21
PERDCAZA
90
70
50
30
10
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
1.96*Std. Err.
1.00*Std. Err.
Mean
AO
2001, Milln et al 2003a), existen sospechas de que las cifras reales superen
los 10 millones de ejemplares por ao. Si tenemos en cuenta los datos de las
estadsticas oficiales de caza que, como se coment anteriormente, cifraban en
torno a los 3,5 millones las perdices capturadas anualmente (Baragao y Otero
2001), podemos darnos cuenta de la importancia alcanzada por las sueltas de
aves de granja en la actualidad.
II.6.1. Viabilidad de las repoblaciones
En el uso de las perdices de granja cabe distinguir dos alternativas: (1) los
refuerzos de poblaciones naturales para aumentar la poblacin estable
(repoblaciones o refuerzos poblacionales segn la terminologa de la UICN), y
(2) las sueltas para caza inmediata o refuerzos de caza, tpicos de los cotos
comerciales o intensivos. Entre ambas cabe encontrar diversas situaciones
intermedias, como por ejemplo el refuerzo de poblaciones naturales en las
primeras jornadas a fin de aliviar la presin cinegtica sobre las perdices
salvajes, tal como ocurre en algunos cotos del Valle del Ebro, o la repoblacin
con perdices juveniles en verano para su adaptacin al terreno de cara a los
ojeos de otoo, manejo frecuente en Castilla La Mancha.
La viabilidad de las repoblaciones con aves de granja con fines cinegticos
es en general muy baja, y normalmente incapaz de recuperar las poblaciones
silvestres (Hessler et al.,1970; Birkan, 1971; Lernoz y Castien, 1989; Dowell,
1992; Robertson, 1988; Brittas et al., 1992; Sodeikat et al., 1995; Capelo y
Pereira, 1996; Gortzar et al., 2000; Milln et al., 2002; Prez et al., 2004;
Alonso et al., 2005). No obstante, la suelta masiva de perdices de granja,
acompaada
de
un
manejo
intensivo
del
hbitat
incluyendo
el
24
Por ltimo hay que tener en cuenta que las perdices en granja estn
expuestas a una serie de parsitos que, como se ha demostrado en trabajos
previos, son diferentes a los presentes en las poblaciones naturales (Milln et
al., 2003, 2004). La liberacin al campo de estas aves supone, por una parte, el
cese de los tratamientos sanitarios que controlaban a los patgenos propios de
la granja, y por otra, la exposicin a nuevos patgenos con los que no habran
tenido contacto previo. Si a esto aadimos la inmunodepresin causada por el
estrs de la suelta, parece lgico pensar que la capacidad de respuesta de las
aves de granja frente a las enfermedades va a ser muy baja, y que ste va a
ser un factor muy importante a la hora de mermar la supervivencia de las aves
liberadas (Villana et al., 2006).
II.6.2. Las hibridaciones.
A pesar de estar terminantemente prohibido por la ley, se han venido
empleando para repoblar hbridos entre perdiz roja y perdiz chukar (Alectoris
chukar), debido a su elevada productividad en cautividad (Padrs, 1991), y a
que en su segunda generacin son prcticamente indistinguibles por rasgos
externos de la autntica perdiz roja (Negro et al., 2001; Milln et al. 2001). Esta
prctica se ha generalizado de tal manera que a da de hoy resulta difcil
encontrar
poblaciones
silvestres
puras
mucho
menos
granjas
sin
26
II.8. Bibliografa
1. Aebisher, N. J. y Potts, G. R. (1994). Redlegged partridge. In: Tucker, G.
M. y Heath, M. F., Birds in Europe. Their Conservation Status. Birdlife
Conservation Series n3, Birdlife International, Cambridge, UK.
2. Aebischer, N. y Kavanagh, B. (1997). Grey partridge. In Hagemeijer,
W.J.M., Balir, M.J. (eds.), The EBCC Atlas of European Breeding Birds, their
Distribution and Abundance. TyAD Poyser, London, pp. 212-213.
3. Akhumyan, K.S. y Khanbegyan, R.A. (1982). The helmint fauna of wild
galliforms in Armenia (Coturnix coturnix, Alectoris graeca, Perdix perdix,
Lyrulus mlokosiewiczi and Tetraogallus caspius). Zoologischeskii Sbornik,
Akademiya Nauk Armyanskoi SSR, Institut Zoologii (Fauna parasitov
Zhivotnykh I vyzyvaemye imi zabolevaniya) 18: 9-45.
4. Alonso, M.E., Perez, J.A., Gaudioso, V.R., Diez, C. y Prieto, R. (2005).
Study of survival, dispersal and home range of autumn-released red-legged
partridges (Alectoris rufa). British Poultry Science, 46(4): 401-6
5. APROCA (1998). La caza en la provincia de Ciudad Real. Ciudad Real.
6. APROCA (2004). Jornadas de sobre la cra de especies cinegticas.
Madrid, Noviembre 2004.
7. Baratti, M., Ammannati, M., Magnelli, C. y Dessi-Fulgheri, F. (2005).
Introgression of chukar genes into a reintroduced red-legged partridge
(Alectoris rufa) population in central Italy. Animal Genetics, 36(1): 29-35
8. Belleau, E. y Lonard, P. (1991). Le parasitisme digesttif chez la perdrix
bartavelle (Alectoris graeca saxatilis), le lagopede alpin (Lapogus mutus),
letetras-lyre (Tetras tetrix), dans le departement des Autes-Alpes. Gibier
Faune Sauvage, 8:161-174.
9. Birkan, M. (1990). La perdrix rouge. Brochures techniques O.N.C., Paris. 36
pp.
10. Blanco-Aguiar, J.A., Virgs, E. y Villafuerte, R. (2003).
Perdiz Roja
(Alectoris rufa). En: Mart R. and Del Moral. J. C. (Eds), Atlas de las aves
reproductoras de Espaa.
27
28
de
zooparsitos
ibricos.
Secretariado
de
Publicaciones,
29
mongolicus)
and
partridges
(Alectoris
chukar).
Hellenike
densities
of
the
red-legged
partridge
(Alectoris
rufa)
in
30
31
69. Milln, J., Gortzar,C. and Casanova, J.C. (2003b). First occurrence of
Mesocestoides sp. in a
(Perdix perdix). Effect of sex and age on the immune response to sheep red
blood cells (SRBC), newcastle disease virus (NDV) and
(Buck 19).
perdix)
and
red-llegged
partridge
(Alectoris
rufa).
Ornis
35
102.
Tibbits, F.D. y Babero, B.B. (1969). Ascaridia galli from the chukar
competition
between
pheasant
and
grey
partridge:
preliminary
113.
37
III. OBJETIVOS
La presente Tesis Doctoral ha sido concebida bajo un enfoque
eminentemente prctico, tratando de responder a las dudas de carcter
sanitario que se le plantearan a cualquier persona interesada en la
conservacin de la perdiz roja y que barajase la posibilidad de recurrir a las
sueltas de aves de granja como herramienta para recuperar las poblaciones
naturales.
La primera pregunta sera probablemente la siguiente: Qu riesgos
sanitarios podra tener la liberacin de las perdices criadas en cautividad?
Dado que una tesis anterior demostr marcadas diferencias entre las
parasitocenosis de las perdices de granja y las perdices natrales (Milln 2004 a
y b), mediante el estudio parasitolgico de las perdices cazadas en fincas con
distintos modelos de gestin, se trata de constatar o desmentir la introduccin
de nuevos parsitos en el medio mediante las sueltas de perdiz de granja. Este
objetivo se desarrolla en el capitulo 1.
En caso de demostrase que realmente las aves liberadas pueden introducir
nuevos parsitos en el campo, una de las posibles soluciones sera la de la de
liberar aves que no estuviesen infectadas. Para ello deberamos contar con un
mtodo seguro que nos permitiese identificar a las aves parasitadas, lo cual
nos planteara la siguiente pregunta: Son los controles llevados a cabo
actualmente en las granjas de perdiz roja suficientemente eficaces como para
evitar esta introduccin de parsitos? Para responder a esta pregunta se ha
realizado una experiencia controlada donde se comparan los resultados de los
anlisis coprolgicos realizados a las mismas aves a distintas horas del da y
con distintos tipos de heces, con el fin de detectar los posibles fallos del
mtodo de control seguido en la actualidad. Este objetivo se desarrolla en el
capitulo 2.
Si los controles actuales fuesen insuficientes para garantizar que las aves
liberadas no son portadoras de parsitos, el siguiente paso sera el de plantear
el tratamiento de todas las aves antes de la suelta para as asegurar que
lleguen al campo desparasitadas. Esta actuacin planteara la siguiente
pregunta: Son los tratamientos antiparasitarios actuales suficientemente
eficaces como para evitar la introduccin de parsitos en el campo a travs de
38
39
Son
los
tratamientos
antiparasitarios
actuales
40
IV. CAPITULO 1
Las repoblaciones con aves de granja como fuentes de
introduccin de parsitos en las poblaciones silvestres de
perdiz roja.
41
IV. CAPITULO 1
Las repoblaciones con aves de granja como fuentes de
introduccin de parsitos en las poblaciones silvestres de
perdiz roja.
Sanitary risks of red-legged partridge releases: introduction of parasites.
European Journal of Wildlife Research. Villana, D., Prez-Rodrguez, L.,
Casas, F., Alzaga, V., Acevedo, P. and Gortzar, C. (Aceptado).
RESUMEN
Se ha estudiado la parasitofauna y la condicin fsica de 99 perdices rojas
(Alectoris rufa) cazadas en Ciudad Real (zona centro de Espaa). Cuarenta y
seis de ellas procedan de dos fincas de caza donde anualmente se lleva a
cabo la suelta de un importante nmero de perdices de granja. Las cincuenta y
tres restantes fueron muestreadas en fincas naturales en las que no se realizan
repoblaciones con aves de granja y de localizacin prxima a las fincas con
suelta.
Se identificaron cuatro nematodos (Heterakis gallinarum, Aonchoteca
caudinflata, Eucoleus contortus y Cheilospirura gruveli) y dos cestodos
(Raillietina (R.) tetragona y Skryabinia bolivari). Las fincas con sueltas de perdiz
de granja presentaron una mayor diversidad de especies de parsitos, con
mayores prevalencias e intensidades de parasitacin para todos los helmintos
encontrados. Tres de estas especies son tpicas de aves criadas en granja y
dos de ellas, A. caundinflata y S. bolivari, fueron encontradas parasitando aves
adultas, lo cual pone de manifiesto la introduccin de estos helmintos en la
poblacin natural reproductora. Las aves muestreadas en las fincas naturales
mostraron una condicin fsica mejor que la de las de la zona con sueltas, pero
esta relacin aparentemente no estaba relacionada con la parasitacin.
Los resultados obtenidos sugieren que la suelta de aves de granja, prctica
cada vez ms comn en los cotos de caza espaoles, puede suponer un riesgo
para la conservacin de la poblaciones naturales, ya que se estaran
introduciendo nuevos patgenos al medio. Sin embargo, los resultados
sugieren tambin que, a da de hoy, el simple cese de las sueltas podra tal vez
42
Managed (n=45)
Mean
3.77 %
17.39 %
5.01
<0.05
Aonchoteca caudinflata
0%
6.52 %
3.56
ns
Eucoleus contortus
0%
2.17 %
1.16
ns
Cheilospirura gruveli
1.89 %
10.87 %
3.49
ns
Raillietina tetragona
3.77 %
6.66 %
0.42
ns
0%
4.44 %
2.4
ns
Heterakis gallinarum
Skryabinia bolivari
46
The intensities of these parasites followed the same trend, but in this case
the significance level was reached by H. gallinarum and Ch. gruveli (Table 2).
Table 2. Helminth burdens found in red-legged partridges from the two different
management models and significance level of their differences by the Mann-Whiney U
test.
Wild (n=53)
Managed (n=45)
Mean
min-max
SD
Mean
Heterakis gallinarum
0.04
0-1
0,19
0.36
Aonchoteca caudinflata
0.00
0,00
Eucoleus contortus
0.00
Cheilospirura gruveli
0.13
Raillietina tetragona
Skryabinia bolivari
min-max
SD
0-5
0.93
-1,22
<0.05
0.18
0-3
0.68
-1,89
ns
0,00
0.04
0-2
0.30
-1,08
ns
0-7
0,96
1.89
0-30
6.82
-2,17
<0.05
0.13
0-4
0,68
0.40
0-8
1.61
-0,67
ns
0.00
0,00
0.91
0-30
4.72
-1,54
ns
No relationships were found between parasite burdens and the two body
condition indexes pectoral muscle thickness, PMT, and regression residuals of
the body mass on the cube of tarsus length, RBMTL (Spearman correlation
tests, rs-0.31 - 0.28, p>0.05). PMT was higher in the wild populations (26.52.4
mm) than in the managed areas (24.33.1 mm)(Figure 1), but this difference
was only significant in the case of juvenile males (Table 3). No differences were
found in the RBMTL.
Table 3. Mann-Whiney U test results for the body condition indexes (pectoral muscle
thickness, PMT, and regression residuals of the body mass on the cube of tarsus length,
RBMTL) found in the different age and sex groups in two different management models.
RBMTL
Males
z
p
Adult
Juvenile
-0.71
0.10
ns -1.84
ns
PMT
Females
z
p
2.01
Males
Females
z
p
ns
1.60
ns
0.52
ns
ns
2.40
< 0.05
1.65
< 0,1
47
Figure 1. Body condition in the two different management models measured with the
regression residuals of the body mass on the cube of tarsus length (RBMTL) and the
pectoral muscle thickness (PMT).
50
40
30
RBMTL
20
10
0
-10
-20
-30
29
28
27
PMT
26
25
24
23
Mean
22
SE
21
SD
Wild
Managed
48
DISCUSSION
All parasite species found in our study have been previously described
parasitizing the red-legged partridge (Lpez-Neyra 1947; Carvalho-Varela and
Ferradeira 1997; Cordero del Campillo and Rojo 1999; Calvete et al. 2003;
Milln et al. 2004a, 2004b).
The species richness detected in this study (6 species in the managed area
and only 3 in the natural one) is lower than those reported in two previous largescale studies (13 different species by Calvete et al. 2003; or 14 different species
by Milln et al. 2004a), but similar to the richness reported by Milln et al.
(2004c) in a small study area in southern Spain (4 species). However,
prevalences and abundances are markedly lower than those reported in these
studies.
Milln et al. (2004a, 2004b) found that the parasite community in wild
populations of red-legged partridges was different from that of farm-bred birds.
They suggested that new parasites could be introduced into the field with the
release of farm-reared birds. Three species identified in our study, Heterakis
gallinarum, Cheilospirura gruveli and Raillietina (R.) tetragona, are usually
found in natural populations (Lpez-Neyra 1947; Tarazona et al. 1979; Milln et
al. 2004b, 2004c). However, the other three ones (Eucoleus contortus,
Aonchoteca caundinflata and Skryabinia bolivari), are more usually found in
farm-reared birds (see Milln et al. 2004a). These were found in our study
parasitizing birds sampled in the managed areas only.
Furthermore, two of these species were found in adult birds in our study.
Partridges released for hunting are usually juveniles. Thus, the presence of
these parasites in adult birds suggests: a) that there had been a transmission
from farmed to wild birds; b) that we found birds released in the previous year
that had kept the infection for a whole year; or c) that some adult birds were
released. Releasing of farm-bred birds had occurred two months before the
samples for this study were taken. This implies that the partridges parasitized
by these helminths must be birds that survived in the field for two months, or
even wild birds. Any of these hypotheses are consistent with the introduction of
these parasites into the field through releases of their farm-bred hosts.
The transmission of parasites from released partridges to wild birds could be
facilitated by an increased parasite excretion after releasing, as experimentally
49
shown in the case of the pheasant (Villana et al. 2006a). This in turn could be
due to the absence of antiparasite treatment and the stress immunodepression
that follows releasing into an unknown habitat.
The introduction of new pathogens into a wild population can be an
important conservation problem because natural populations could have lower
resistance to a pathogen to which they have had no previous contact (Newton
1998). In our study area, some endangered steppe birds share habitat with the
red-legged partridge. So, the introduction of new non-specific parasites
supposes an additional problem for their conservation (Villana et al. 2007a).
The detection of higher parasite burdens in the managed areas in this study
could be an indicator of the low effectiveness of the preventive measures to
reduce parasites in the released animals. Current preventive measures applied
prior to the release of farm-reared game birds (if they exist) are based on: i) a
coprological analysis performed in faeces collected in the aviary soil, and ii)
antiparasite treatment following the same protocol that is used in the case of
poultry (Villana et al. 2007b). The first point of this protocol has the problem
that there are a lot of factors such as host reproductive status (Ruz de Ybaez
et al. 2004), weather (Vicente et al. 2005), season (Kumba et al. 2003), random
day-to-day variations (Giver et al. 2000), phase of the parasitic infection (Giver
et al. 2000), or hour of sampling (Villana et al. 2006b), that can modify
propagule excretion, and are not always considered. In addition, the
effectiveness of antiparasite protocols in game species is insufficient to prevent
introducing parasites into the field as recently shown in the case of Albendazole
treatment against Aonchoteca caudinflata and H. gallinarum in red-legged
partridges (Villana et al. 2007b).
If the preventive protocols are not enough to eliminate the parasites from the
released birds, the other option taken is antiparasite treatments administered in
the field. Previous studies evaluated the effect of administering anthelminthic
drugs in the field together with the supplementary food (Woodburn et al. 2002;
Draycott and Sage 2005). These authors found that the birds given anthelmintic
treatment and supplementary food had significantly lower worm burdens and
increased their productivity. Nevertheless, some authors think that treatment of
free-living birds is not practical (Cole 1999) and the pros and cons of the
50
52
10. Draycott, R.A.H. & Sage, R.B. (2005) Parasite control and breeding
success in pheasants (Phasianus colchicus). In: Pohlmeyer K (ed) Extended
Abstracts of the XXVIIth Congress of the International Union of Game
Biologists, Hannover, pp 76-77
11. Duarte, J. & Vargas, J.M. (2004) Field interbreeding of released Farmreared red-legged partridges (Alectoris rufa) with wild ones. Game and
Wildlife Science, 21: 55-61
12. Give,r H., de Vlas, S.J., Johansen, M.V., Christensen, N.O. & Nansen, P.
(2000) Schistosoma japonicum: day to day variation in excretion and
hatchability of parasite eggs in the domestic pig Suis suis. Expl Parasitology,
95: 8-18
13. Gortzar, C., Villafuerte, R. & Martn, M. (2000) Success of traditional
restocking of red-legged partridge for hunting purposes in areas of low
density of northeast Spain Aragn. Zeitschrift fr Jagdwissenschaft, 46: 2330
14. Gortzar, C., Villafuerte, R., Escudero, M.A. & Marco, J. (2002) Postbreeding
densities
of
the
red-legged
partridge
(Alectoris
rufa)
in
53
between
pheasant
and
grey
partridge:
preliminary
31. Viggers, K.L. & Lindenmayer, D.B., Spratt, D.M. (1993) The importance of
disease in reintroduction programmes. Wildlife Research, 20: 687-698
32. Villana, D., Acevedo, P., Hfle, U., Rodrguez, O. & Gortazar, C.
(2006a) Changes in parasite transmission stage excretion after pheasant
release. Journal of Helminthology, 80(3): 313-318
33. Villana, D., Prez-Rodrguez, L., Gortzar, C., Hfle, U. & Viuela, J.
(2006b) Avoiding bias in parasite excretion estimates: the effect of sampling
time and type of faeces. Parasitology, 133: 251-259
34. Villana, D., Casas, F., Viuela, J., Gortzar, C., Garca de la Morena,
E.L. & Morales, M.B. (2007a) First occurence of Eucoleus contortus in a
little bustard Tetrax tetrax. A negative effect of red-legged partridge Alectoris
rufa
releases
on
steppe
bird
conservation?.
Ibis
(in
press) doi:
10.1111/j.1474-919x.2006.00620.x
35. Villana, D., Prez-Rodrguez, L., Rodrguez, O., Viuela, J. & Gortazar,
C. (2007b) How effective is pre-release nematode control in farm reared
red-legged partridges (Alectoris rufa)?. Journal of Helminthology, 81(1): 1013
36. Woodburn, M., Sage, R.B. & Carroll, J.P. (2002) The efficacy of a
technique to control parasitic worm burden in pheasants (Phaisanus
colchicus) in the wild. Zeitschrift fr Jagdwissenschaft, 48: 364-372
55
V. CAPITULO 2
Variaciones en el resultado de los anlisis coprolgicos
preventivos actuales en funcin del tipo de heces analizadas y
la hora de recogida de las mismas.
Avoiding bias in parasite excretion estimates: the effect of sampling time and
type of faeces. Villana, D., Prez-Rodrguez, L, Gortzar, C., Hfle, U. &
Viuela, J. (2006). Parasitology,133: 251-259
56
V. CAPITULO 2
Variaciones en el resultado de los anlisis coprolgicos
preventivos actuales en funcin del tipo de heces analizadas y
la hora de recogida de las mismas.
Avoiding bias in parasite excretion estimates: the effect of sampling time and
type of faeces. Villana, D., Prez-Rodrguez, L, Gortzar, C., Hfle, U. &
Viuela, J. (2006). Parasitology,133: 251-259
RESUMEN
El creciente inters de los eclogos en las relaciones parsito-hospedador
hace que hayan proliferado los estudios en los que se recurre a diferentes
mtodos con los que estimar el grado de parasitacin. En el caso de los
parsitos intestinales, el mtodo ms utilizado es la cuantificacin de
propgulos parasitarios en heces mediante tcnicas coprolgicas. Sin
embargo, la excrecin parasitaria puede verse influenciada por numeros
factores tanto endgenos como exgenos. La identificacin de estos factores
es imprescindible para obtener resultados correctos.
En el presente estudio, se ha analizado el efecto de la hora de recogida de
las heces en el resultado del anlisis coprolgico cuantitativo para dos
parsitos intestinales, Aonchoteca caudinflata y Eimeria sp., presentes en la
perdiz roja (Alectoris rufa). Adems, se evaluaron tambin las posibles
diferencias existentes en el conteo de parsitos en heces corrientes y en heces
procedentes de los ciegos.
En Octubre de 2004, ocho perdices rojas fueron separadas durante un brote
de capilariasis en una poblacin de granja. Tras confirmar la infeccin por
capilarias en todas las aves y por coccidios en seis de ellas, se inici un
protocolo de recogida de heces de manera individual en cuatro momentos del
da y durante un periodo de tiempo de varios das.
Se pudo detectar una importante variacin en los valores del anlisis
coprolgico de ambos parsitos en funcin de la hora de recogida, con un claro
y constante incremento de la excrecin conforme avanzaba el da. El da de
recogida influy de manera significativa en los dos casos, as como su
57
58
Hour of the day exerted a very strong effect in propagule counts, excretion
of both types of parasites showing a clear and constant increase from dawn to
dusk. Day of sampling affected significantly in both cases and interacted
significantly with the individual in the case of capillarid eggs. Also, capillarid
eggs were more abundant in intestinal than in caecal faeces, whereas the
inverse pattern was found for coccidian oocysts.
Our results show that hour of the day at which samples are collected can
drastically affect parasite excretion estimates. Standardization of the hour of
sample
collection
or
statistical
control
of
this
variable
is
therefore
recommendable to prevent this bias. Similarly, in the case of bird species with
long caeca, consistent collection of one type of faeces (ideally that one where
propagules are most abundant) may avoid important errors in parasite burden
estimates.
Finally, this study stresses the importance of gathering more information
about the studied host-parasite system in order to develop adequate sampling
methods leading to obtain more reliable data.
KEYWORDS: Alectoris rufa, Aonchoteca caudinflata, Eimeria, nematoda,
coccidia
INTRODUCTION
In the last two decades the interest of behavioral ecologists in the effect of
parasites on host fitness has increased. Parasites may affect host body
condition (Hall 1985; Gulland 1995; Delahay et al 1995), survival probabilities
(Vorsek et al. 1998; Murray et al. 1997), some reproductive parameters (Newey
&Thirgood 2004; Albon et al. 2002) or population dynamics (Holmes 1982;
Hudson et al. 1998; Tompkins et al. 2001). Therefore, parasites seem to be an
important factor in host life-history and may exert a strong selective force on
host evolution (Clayton & Moore 1997).
This relatively recent focus on host-parasite interaction has lead to an
increasing number of ecological empirical studies in which parasite load is
related to different measures of host fitness. It uses to be relatively easy to
determine the prevalence and intensity of ectoparasite infection as they can be
directly counted or estimated by exploring the skin, hair or feathers of the
59
and anatid birds (Anderson 2000). Female worms lay eggs that mature after
ingestion by earthworms (Allobophora caliginosa, Eisenia foetida), the
necessary intermediate hosts.
In many avian taxa, like Galliforms and Anseriforms, intestinal caeca are
specially elongated. In these species, caecal faeces represent a significant
proportion of the total amount of faeces produced and can be easily
distinguished from intestinal faeces by their appearance. In this paper we also
analyse the differences in propagule content of both kinds of faeces in the redlegged partridge. We finally discuss the implications of our results in the design
of and data analysis of empirical studies involving parasite estimation from
faecal counts.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Data collection took place during October 2004 in the experimental redlegged partridge farm of the IREC in Ciudad Real (Spain). During late summerautumn of that year there was an outbreak of capillariasis in one of the outdoor
aviaries of the farm. As soon as the parasite was identified and before starting
any medication, a sample of 15 birds of the affected aviary was isolated in
individual outdoor elevated cages and individual samples of feces were
collected. The coprological analysis showed that eight of the birds (six females
and two males) were infected by capillarids and these were subsequently
employed for the experiment. Also, six of them were infected by coccidia,
allowing the combined analysis of the daily variation of excretion of both
parasites in the same sample of birds.
During the days 5th, 6th, 12th, 13th, 14th, 15th and 16th of October individual
faecal samples were collected from all birds (except from one of them the day
14th due to an error of sampling) at 08:00, 12:00, 16:00 and 19: 30 hours.
Faecal samples were obtained by placing a large piece of fresh paper on the
ground just below each one of the cages slightly before the designated times
The first droppings produced by each bird during the following 30 minutes were
collected and stored in Eppendorf tubes. Most of the faeces obtained were
intestinal faeces, which is the most common type of faeces produced by
Galliforms. However, when caecal faeces where also found at sampling times,
they were collected separately allowing a posterior comparison. Caecal faeces
61
order to assess whether there was a common tendency during the five
consecutive days previously analysed. In both models the number of
propagules (either capillarid eggs or coccidian oocysts) per gram of faeces
(after log10+1 transformation) excreted at 19: 30 hours of each day was entered
as dependent variable whereas day -as a continuous variable- and the
interaction between day and individual were entered as fixed factors. The
individual was again entered as a random factor.
To test for differences between caecal and intestinal faeces, propagule
content of caecal and intestinal faecal samples collected at the same hour of
the same day from each bird were compared by means of Wilcoxon Matched
Pairs Tests (raw data were employed in this analysis because the larger
number of zero values in this data set made impossible data normalization).
RESULTS
Effect of the time of the day and day-to-day variation on propagule excretion
GLIMMs results for capillarid eggs and coccidian oocysts are shown in Table
1. In the case of capillarid egg excretion the hour of the day at which samples
where collected was the most important factor, explaining the 42.17 % of the
deviance of the model.
Capillarid egg shedding followed the same temporal pattern in all birds,
showing a clear and constant increase from dawn to dusk that was repeated
during all the days of sampling (Fig. 1). In fact, the amount of capillarid eggs in
faeces was on average 27.414.2 times higher in samples collected at 19: 30
than in those samples collected at 8:00 from the same birds.
Day of sampling also exerted a significant effect (explaining a 7.6% of the
deviance). As can be observed in Fig. 1, in some individuals (e.g. bird 54, bird
59) the line signalling the daily pattern for some days was almost five times
higher than for other days, showing a strong day-to-day variation. In contrast,
such day-to-day variation was minimal in other individuals (e.g. bird 61, bird 72).
Consequently, the deviance explained in the final model was greater for the
interaction between day and individual (27.5%) than for day as a single factor,
suggesting that day-to day-variation in capillarid egg excretion followed a
particular pattern for each bird. To assess whether such effect of the day of
sampling indicated a common tendency during the five consecutive days of
63
study we analysed the amount of propagules shed only at the hour of maximal
excretion (19: 30) entering day as a continuous variable (see Methods for
details about the model). We found a common trend to increase during the five
consecutive days of study (GLMM, parameter estimate=0.21, F1,33=30.1,
p<0.001), although the interaction between day and individual was significant
(GLMM, F1,33=29.3, p<0.001), indicating that not all individuals showed such
trend.
Regarding coccidian oocysts, the results were quite similar to those reported
for capillarids (Table 1).
Table 1. GLIMMs with normal error and identity link function for capillarid egg and
coccidian oocysts excretion. Hour of the day (nested in day), day and individual*day
interaction were included as categorical fixed factors. The model for capillarid eggs
explained a 59.6 % of the original deviance, whereas the model for coccidia oocysts
explained a 41.6%, without considering the deviance explained by the individual which
was included as random term in both models (Z=6.96, p<0.001, and Z=0.38, p=0.35,
respectively). Statistics for non significant variables correspond to the step at which they
were rejected from the model.
Dependent Variable
Capillarid eggs
Coccidian oocysts
Fixed Factors
Hour
Day
Individual*Day
Hour
Day
Individual*Day
d.f.
% Deviance Explained
4.50
5.00
1.89
3.20
3.13
1.25
15,97
4,97
34,97
15,85
4,86
25,66
<0.001
<0.001
<0.01
<0.001
<0.05
0.230
42.17
7.65
27.5
41.6
8.35
64
Figure 1 Number of capillarid eggs per gram of faeces from eight red legged partridges
collected at four different hours of the day and during five consecutive days. Dashed
lines show daily patterns whereas solid lines indicate mean values. Error bars have been
eliminated for clarity.
Bird 54
Bird 62
15000
9000
10000
6000
5000
3000
0
8:00
12:00
16:00
8:00
19:30
Bird 57
6000
10000
4000
5000
2000
12:00
16:00
8:00
19:30
27000
9000
18000
6000
9000
3000
12:00
19:30
12:00
16:00
19:30
Bird 71
Bird 59
8:00
16:00
Bird 69
15000
8:00
12:00
16:00
19:30
8:00
12:00
16:00
19:30
16:00
19:30
Bird 72
Bird 61
9000
2700
6000
1800
3000
900
0
0
8:00
12:00
16:00
19:30
8:00
12:00
Hour of sampling
65
Hour of the day was again the most important factor, explaining the 41.6% of
variance of the final model, and showing the same pattern of increase described
for capillarid eggs (Fig. 2).
Figure 2 Number of coccidian oocysts per gram of faeces from six red legged partridges
collected at four different hours of the day and during five consecutive days. Dashed
lines show daily patterns whereas solid lines indicate mean values. Error bars have been
eliminated for clarity.
Bird 61
Bird 54
7500
6000
4000
5000
2000
2500
0
0
8:00
12:00
16:00
8:00
19:30
Bird 57
30000
14000
20000
7000
10000
12:00
16:00
19:30
Bird 62
21000
8:00
12:00
16:00
8:00
19:30
12:00
16:00
19:30
16:00
19:30
Bird 71
Bird 59
12000
15000
8000
10000
4000
5000
0
0
8:00
12:00
16:00
19:30
8:00
12:00
Hour of sampling
Day of sampling affected significantly, although in this case the interaction
with the individual was not significant (Table 1). A further analysis revealed that
coccidian oocysts shedding tended to increase across the five consecutive days
entered in the analysis (GLMM, parameter estimate=0.22, F1,24=12.3, p<0.01).
66
Interaction between day and individual was not significant (F1,24=0.00, p=0.99),
indicating that this pattern was common for all individuals infected with coccidia.
Effect of type of feces on propagule counts
Capillarid eggs were much more abundant in intestinal faeces compared to
caecal faeces shed by the same individual at the same hour and day (Wilcoxon
matched pairs test: Z=4.8, N=34, P<0.001, Fig. 3). In contrast, the pattern
observed was totally opposed when the abundance of coccidian ococysts was
analysed (Z=3.5, N=33, P<0.001, Fig. 3), the oocysts being more abundant in
caecal than in intestinal faeces (matching by bird, hour and day in the analysis).
Propagule counts of both types of faeces were not correlated in the case of
capillarids (rS= 0.15 , N= 34, P=0.37), but this relationship was significant for
coccidian oocysts (rS= 0.44 , N= 33, P<0.05).
Figure 3. Mean number of oocysts and capillarid eggs in caecal (solid columns) and
intestinal faeces (open columns). Bars indicate standard errors.
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
capillarid eggs
coccidian oocysts
67
DISCUSION
Our results indicate that the hour of the day may exert a very strong effect
on parasite propagule excretion. This point was confirmed in two different
parasite species coming from two extremely different taxa (Nematoda and
Protozoa) infecting the same bird host species (the red legged partridge). In
both cases propagule shedding increased as the day progressed, reaching
maximal values in the late afternoon. Scarce attention has been paid in the
literature to the existence of this kind of consistent daily trends in parasite
propagule excretion, especially for birds or host-parasite systems with little or
no relevance in human health or economy. For example, Giver et. al. (2000)
found no consistent pattern across individuals when comparing morning and
afternoon egg counts in faeces of domestic pigs artificially infected with the
trematode Schistosoma japonicum. In contrast, Boughton (1933) and Brawner
& Hill (1999) described a diurnal periodicity in the eliminiation of oocysts of the
genus Isospora in two avian passerine species (house sparrows and house
finches, respectively) consistent with the pattern found in this study. However,
the diurnal trend found for coccidia in our case does not seem to be as
pronounced as that found by Brawner & Hill (1999). This may be due to intrinsic
differences between host-parasite systems, or to the fact that the intensity of
coccidian infection in our experimental birds was not as high as those studied
by Brawner & Hill (1999). However, to the authors knowledge, this is the first
report of the existence of a consistent within-day pattern of excretion in a
nematode parasite of a bird species.
Although the hour was by far the most influencing factor in both parasites,
we also found an effect of the day of sampling. In particular, we found a
tendency to increase parasite propagule excretion during the course of the
study which was stronger for coccidian oocysts than for capillarid eggs. In our
study, samples were collected during five consecutive days just to exclude the
effect of any seasonal variation in propagule excretion as described in other
studies (e.g.: Shaw & Moss 1998; Theodoropoulos et al. 1998; Vicente et al.
2005). It is widely known that propagule excretion varies throughout the course
of a parasitic infection (Cordero del Campillo et al. 1999). Birds employed in this
study were naturally infected during an outbreak of capillariasis that affected our
captive population. As a result, birds may have been in different phases of the
68
evolution (Clayton & Moore 1997). Apart from ectoparasites, intestinal parasites
are the most commonly studied ones as possible factors affecting several
components of host fitness. Interestingly, both coccidia (Hillgarth 1990;
Buchholz 1995; Vorsek et al. 1998) and nematodes (Hudson et al. 1998;
Murray 2002; Newey & Thirgood 2004) are the most commonly endoparasite
taxa employed in such ecological studies, and most of those surveys that do not
involve culling the animal require indirect parasite load estimates based on
counts of the number of propagules in faeces. In parasites from these two taxa
we have found a marked diurnal periodicity in propagule excretion. However,
despite that the hour of the day at which samples are collected may be of vital
relevance, this variable is never controlled for in any study.
The great magnitude of within individual variation in propagule excretion
during the day may covey serious errors in non-invasive parasite load
estimates. Experiments in captivity may easily control for this effect by sampling
all the birds approximately at the same hour, preferentially in the late afternoon,
when propagule shedding is maximal and therefore differences between
individuals are maximised. However, such kind of data standardization is
difficult in the wild. Moreover, most of wild birds are trapped in the morning
hours, when propagule shedding is minimal, thus diminishing the power to
detect differences in intensities of parasite excretion between individuals. As
parasite estimates from birds sampled at morning and late afternoon hours may
not be comparable, the best way to solve this problem in studies in wild is to
control statistically for the hour of sampling in all the analysis by including it as a
covariable. Either the methodological standardization or the statistical control of
the effect of this variable may prevent from fatal errors and will lead to sounder
results. Similarly, studies where faecal samples are collected from the
environment instead of directly from the animal should take into account this
source of variability. Collection of fresh drops exclusively and during the same
hour of the day may be a good option, although the effect of weather in faecal
drying time should be considered. Alternatively, sample collection from places
where individuals are only during a determinate and known period of the day
(roosts, for example) may allow to increase the reliability of the results obtained.
With regards to the differences in parasite counts between types of faeces,
the main implication of our findings is that researchers should pay attention to
70
the life cycle of the parasite to develop the most appropriate protocol for sample
collection in species with long caeca like Galliforms or Anseriforms. In our
particular case, we have shown that parasite counts coming from intestine or
caeca are not comparable for this two parasite species. The ideal procedure
should be to count each parasite only in that type of faeces where it is more
abundant. However, caecal faeces are only a minor proportion of the total
amount of faeces produced by the bird. Therefore, it is very difficult to have the
opportunity to choose what type to collect, especially in the wild, and the
researcher will have to be satisfied with the type of sample excreted by the bird
when trapped (usually a intestinal drop). In our case, consistent collection of
intestinal faeces is suitable for capillarids, but seems to be acceptable for
coccidia too, as caecal and intestinal counts were correlated in the latter.
Although in the two parasites studied here the hour of the day and the type
of faeces were by far the most important factors affecting individual variation in
propagule counts, other possible factors may also affect. As said above, we
found an effect of the day of sampling that varied between individuals in the
case of capillarids. Other authors have found a day-to-day variation in
propagule counts that seems to be due to variations in propagule production by
the parasite or to aggregation of the propagules in the feces, leading to
sampling errors (e.g. Yu et al. 1998; Giver et al. 2000; Utzinger et al. 2001).
Also, great differences in propagule excretion may occur along the course of
infection (Giver et al. 2000; Cordero del Campillo et al. 1999). Moreover, in
some parasite species, fecal propagule counts may not necessarily reflect the
number of adult parasites present in the body of the individual (Welch et al.
1991). Density-dependent constraints may also alter the relationship between
parasite burden and faecal counts (Anderson & Shad 1985; Tompkins &
Hudson 1999). Hence, the use of propagule counts to indirectly estimate
parasite burden should ideally be addressed in any host-parasite system before
being employed.
It is remarkable that we found identical diurnal trends in two extremely
different taxa of parasites. Although previous studies in other coccidian species
showed the same pattern (Boughton 1933; Brawner & Hill 1999), more research
involving different parasite and host taxa is required to confirm whether such
kind of diurnal variation is common across host-parasite systems. This study
71
remarks the point made by other authors (McLennan & Brooks 1991; Zuk 1992;
Brawner & Hill 1999) about the necessity of gathering more information about
the studied host-parasite system studied. A survey to identify the best method
for assessing parasite prevalence and burdens is recommended as a previous
step for any host-parasite study (e.g.: Seivwright et al. 2004; Brawner & Hill
1999). A better understanding of the dynamics of infection as regards for
example fluctuations in propagule number within and between days or between
types of feces may lead to obtain more reliable data and give the opportunity of
a more throughout understanding.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Elisa Prez, Salvador Jess Luna and Paqui Talavera for
assistance during sample collection and analysis and Jess Martnez-Padilla for
statistical advice. Financial support was provided by the Research Project PAI02-006 of the Junta de Comunidades de Castilla-La Mancha and by the
agreement between CSIC and Principado de Asturias. Lorenzo PrezRodrguez was supported by a FPU grant from the Ministerio de Educacin y
Ciencia.
REFERENCES
1. Albon, S.D., Stien, A., Irvine, R.J., Ropstad, R. & Halvorsen, O. (2002)
The role of parasites in the dynamic of a reindeer population. Proceding of
the Royal Society of London, Series B. Biological ciences, 269: 1625-1632.
2. Anderson, R. M. & Schad, G. A. (1985) Hookworm burdens and faecal egg
counts: an analysis of the biological basis of variation. Transactions of the
Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 79: 812-825.
3. Anderson, R.C. (2000). Nematode parasite of the vertebrates: their
development
and
transmision.
Second
edition.
CAB
International,
72
of
parasitism:
effect
of
developing
infection
of
Berlin.
73
L.G.
gastrointestinal
&
Zimmerman,
nematodesof
G.L.
(1992)
The
epizootiology
of
74
40. Zuk, M. (1992) The role of parasites in sexual selection: current evidence
and future directions. Advances In Study Behaviour., 21: 39-68.
76
VI. CAPITULO 3
Efectividad de los tratamientos antiparasitarios actuales para
prevenir la introduccin de nematodos en el campo.
77
VI. CAPITULO 3
Efectividad de los tratamientos antiparasitarios actuales para
prevenir la introduccin de nematodos en el campo.
How effective is pre-release nematode control in farm reared red-legged
partridges (Alectoris rufa)?. Villana, D., Prez-Rodrguez, L, Rodrguez,
O., Viuela, J. & Gortzar C (2007). Journal of Helmithology (in press).
RESUMEN
La cra de la perdiz roja en granja lleva asociado a un alto grado de
parasitacin capaz de disminuir la productividad de la propia granja y la
supervivencia de las aves una vez liberadas, adems de suponer un riesgo
para las poblaciones naturales. En el presente trabajo se ha evaluado la
efectividad de albendazol (V.O. 20 mg/kg) en perdices de granja infectadas de
manera natural con Aonchoteca caudinflata y Heterakis gallinarum.
Las aves tratadas mostraron una clara mejora de su condicin fsica y se
redujo la excrecin de propgulos parasitarios y el porcentaje de hembras
grvidas de A. caudinflata, pero no se consiguieron eliminar los parsitos
adultos. La efectividad encontrada fue de un 36,8 % en A. caudinflata y de un
17,1 % en H. gallinarum.
Estos
resultados
indican
que
el
tratamiento
antihelmntico
usado
78
79
Faecal samples were obtained on day 0 at dusk (time of the day of maximal
nematode egg excretion, Villana et al. in press) for a quantitative coprological
analysis in MacMaster chambers as described by Melhorn et al. (1992), which
confirmed the infection of all birds with capillarid nematodes (later identified as
Aonchoteca caudinflata).
Five randomly selected individuals were treated orally with 20 mg/kg of
albendazole (Albendavet, Divasa Farmavic, S.A.) on day 1 and day 15,
according to the manufacturers instructions. The same volume of water was
given as a control to the other three infected birds. Fifteen days after the second
administration all birds were humanely sacrified and necropsied.
The necropsy included a second coprological analysis and the examination
of the digestive tract searching for parasites using a stereomicroscope.
The efficacy (E) of albendazole treatment on worm burden was calculated
as follows after Reina et al.(2000):
E=
The nematode sex-ratio (SR) and fertility (F) were calculated as follows after
Kassai (1998):
SR=
N female nematodes
N total nematodes
F=
N gravid females
N total females
80
RESULTS
All birds deposited eggs of capillarid nematodes immediately prior to the
experiment. This deposition decreased significantly (-90.75%) after treatment in
the medicated group (Wilcoxon test; Z=2.02; p<0.05) but not in control birds,
where deposition was even higher (+ 80.67%) in the second analysis (Wilcoxon
test; Z=1.6; p>0.05) (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Deposition of Aonchoteca caudinflata eggs per gram of faeces before (
after (
) and
9000
8000
7000
Propagule / g
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
Control
Treatment
After treatment, dosed birds showed higher values for fat index, pectoral
angle and residual body weights than control birds (Figure 2). However, only the
increase in relative body weight of the dosed group was significant when
comparing pre and post treatment values (Wilcoxon test; Z=2.02; p<0.05).
81
Residual weight
60
30
-30
Pectoral angle ()
17
16
15
14
M ean
SE
95%C .I.
13
Control
Treated
82
Control birds
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Heterakis gallinarum
5,8
6,6
Aonchoteca caudinflata
20.2
21,2
0.42
A. caudinflata fertility
0.51
Statistical analysis
Efficacy
7,8
Z=0.74; p>0.05
17,14%
32
20.4
Z=0.75; p>0.05
36,87%
0.20
0.43
0.01
0.30
0.68
0.19
Nematode Species
DISCUSSION
Despite a small sample size, the results show a limited effect of albendazole
treatment on Aonchoteca caudinflata and Heterakis gallinarum infection, with an
efficacy that is lower than that described for other benzimidazole anthelmintics
in different galliforms. Fenbendazole for example, was 99.2% effective against
Capillaria species when administered to chickens for 6 days in feed (Taylor et
al., 1993). Kirsch (1983) reported that administration of 100 ppm of
fenbendazole in feed to ring-necked pheasants Phasianus colchicus and grey
partridges Perdix perdix, for four consecutive days, reduced the deposition of
83
Heterakis gallinarum and Capillaria obstignata eggs and the number of adult
worms by more than 90%.
In the present study, a similar reduction in Capillaria egg counts was
obtained, but not in worm burden.This suggests that albendazole has some
limitant effect on the reproduction of nematodes, but it does not eliminate the
infection. This may be due to an insuffcient dosage. In the present study the
dose administred was that recommended for chickens by the manufacturer, so
future studies should confirm whether a dose increase would improve the
efficacy of the treatment.
In conclusion, the study shows that the treatment currently used by game
bird farmers in Spain may help to improve body condition of farm-reared
partridges, but is not enough to avoid the introduction of parasites into the field
after release. Alternative drugs, higher doses, or other administration methods
must be evaluated.
This study also highlights that coprological analyses alone are not enough to
ensure the absence of a given nematode species in farm-reared birds.
Sanitary screenings of farm-reared birds should preferably include some
complete necropsies, for example of casualties, rather than rely exclusively on
non-invasive sampling.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This contributes to the agreement IREC - Principado de Asturias. We
acknowledge Galiana facilities (FGUCLM) and thank E. Prez and F. Talavera
for their help. L. Prez-Rodrguez has a FPU grant and O. Rodrguez a Torres
Quevedo contract partly supported by MEC. Two referees improved the ms.
REFERENCES
1. Andersson, S.(1992) Female preference for long tails in lekking Jacksons
widowbirds: experimental evidence. Animal Behaviour, 43: 379-388.
2. APROCA (2004) Jornadas de sobre la cra de especies cinegticas. Madrid,
Noviembre 2004.
3. Kassai, T. (1998) Helmintologia Veterinaria. Ed. Acribia. Zaragoza, Espaa
259 pp.
84
85
VII. CAPITULO 4
Posible transmisin de nematodos propios de perdices de granja a
especies amenazadas.
86
VII. CAPITULO 4
Posible transmisin de nematodos propios de perdices de granja a
especies amenazadas.
First occurence of Eucoleus contortus in a little bustard Tetrax tetrax. A
negative effect of red-legged partridge Alectoris rufa releases on steppe bird
conservation?. Villana, D., Casas, F., Viuela, J., Gortzar, C., Garca de
la Morena, E.L. & Morales, M.B. (2007). Ibis, 149: 405-406
RESUMEN
Cinco adultos de Eucoleus contortus fueron encontrados en el buche de un
macho de sisn, Tetrax tetrax, procedente de Ciudad Real (Espaa, UTM
0421739 4311458).
En la zona en la que se recogi el animal se llevan a cabo munerosas
sueltas cinegticas de perdiz roja (Alectoris rufa) criadas en granja.
El nematodo Eucoleus contortus nunca haba sido descrito en sisones ni
avutardas (Otididae), pero es un parsito comn en perdices de granja. Por
ello, este hallazgo pone de manifiesto la importancia de realizar estudios
parasicolgicos comparativos en aquellas zonas sometidas a repoblaciones
para la caza.
ABSTRACT
Five adult forms of Eucoleus contortus were found in the crop of a male little
bustard, Tetrax tetrax, from Ciudad Real (Spain, UTM 0421739 4311458).
This area is subject of many releases of farm bred red-legged partridges
(Alectoris rufa) for hunting.
Eucoleus contortus had never been reported in bustards (Otididae), but is a
common parasite of farmed gamebirds. Hence, this finding highlights the
interest of compared parasitological studies in areas managed for hunting.
KEYWORDS: Eucoleus contortus; Game management; Tetrax tetrax; Partridge
releases; Bird conservation
87
exclusively found in farmed gamebirds (Milln et al. 2004b) and had, to the best
88
of our knowledge, never been found in members of the Otididae family (Cordero
del Campillo et al. 1994).
E. contortus can affect the hosts body condition (Bosch et al. 2000), and
make their hosts more vulnerable to predation (Milln et al. 2002).
Our results suggest that the release of farm reared gamebirds can
eventually introduce new pathogens to wild populations of different species,
many of which are of conservation concern, as it is the case in the little bustard .
As hypothesized by Tompkins et al., (2001), if these parasites are able to find a
new host, they can become an additional problem for its conservation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This is a contribution to the agreement between IREC and Principado de
Asturias and to the CICYT Project CGL2004-06147-C02/BOS. We wish to thank
I. Hervs, R. Agudo, R. Mateo, M. Martnez and S. Luna for their assistance in
the field. F. Casas has a JCCM grant and E. L. Garca de la Morena was
funded by the Ministry of Educations FPU Program. This experiment was made
following European, National and University of Castilla La Mancha Ethics
Committee regulations.
REFERENCES
1. Anderson,
R.C.
(2000).
Nematode
parasites
of
vertebrales:
their
89
6. Garca de la Morena, E.L., De Juana, E., Martnez, C., Morales, M.B. &
Surez, F. (2004). Sisn Comn, Tetrax tetrax. In Madroo, A, Gonzlez, C.
& Atienza, J.C. (eds.), Libro Rojo de las Aves de Espaa. Direccin General
para la Biodiversidad-SEO/Birdlife. Madrid (pp. 202-207).
7. Milln, J., Gortzar, C., Tizzani, P. & Buenestado, F.J. (2002). Do
helmints increase the vulnerability of released pheasants to fox predation?.
Journal of Helminthology, 76: 225-229.
8. Milln, J., Gortzar, C., Martn-Mateo, M.P. & Villafuerte, R. (2004a).
Comparative survey of the ectoparasite fauna of wild and farm-reared redlegged partridges (Alectoris rufa), with an ecological study in wild
populations. Parasitology Research , 93(1): 605-611.
9. Milln, J., Gortzar, C. & Villafuerte, R. (2004b). A comparison of the
helminth faunas of wild and farm-reared red-legged partridges. Journal of
Wildlife Management 68(3): 701-707.
10. Tompkins, D.M., Greenman, J.V., Hudson, P.J. (2001). Differential impact
of shared nematode parasite on two gamebird hosts: implications for
apparent competition. Parasitology, 122: 187-193.
90
VIII. CAPITULO 5
Factores limitantes de la abundancia estival de perdiz roja en Aragn.
Posibles alternativas a las repoblaciones con aves de granja.
91
VIII. CAPITULO 5
Factores limitantes de la abundancia estival de perdiz roja en Aragn.
Posibles alternativas a las repoblaciones con aves de granja.
Factors affecting summer densities of the red-legged partridge (Alectoris
rufa). Ibis. Villana, D., Acevedo, P., Escudero, M.A.,
Marco, J. and
92
93
94
Figure 1. Aragn region boundaries and hunting estate boundaries are shown in
black. The white circles show partridge transect locations (N=184). Relief of Aragn
region and biogeographical areas are displayed (darkest greys showing higher altitudes).
95
Aragn has a diverse raptor and carnivore community, but the red fox is
clearly the most important predator for small game species (e.g. Villafuerte et al.
1996, Gortzar 1997, Gortzar et al. 2000).
The climate is Mediterranean, more continental as it gets away from the
sea, with an Atlantic influence in the western Pyrenees. Wood and scrublands
cover 13,518 km2. Fifty percent of the 1.2 million inhabitants concentrate in the
largest city, Zaragoza. Rural abandonment has been especially severe during
the industrial development of the sixties, allowing the natural vegetation to
recover (Bielza de Ory 1993).
Within this area, 5 biogeographical areas can be distinguished (Gortzar et
al. 2002), see Figure 1: (1) the Pyrenees (yearly mean temperature (T) lower
than 12C, annual rainfall (R) 800-1700 mm), (2) the Pyrenean foothills (T: 1214 C, R: 500-800 mm), (3) the Ebro depression (T: 13-15 C, R: 250-500 mm),
(4) the northern Iberian mountains (T: 10-14 C, R: 400-700 mm) and (5) the
southern Iberian mountains (T: 8-11 C, R: 400-800 mm). The last 4 areas are
occupied by the red-legged partridge and were included in our research.
Hunting in Aragn has not the commercial character typical from the south
of Spain, and the main part of the 2,091 hunting estates present in the region
are managed directly by the local associations. This social character makes
game bird releases rare. For this reason, hunting estates included in our
research have only natural populations of red-legged partridges, with no
restocking with captive-bred game birds in the last ten years.
Partridge densities
Partridge densities (individuals/100 ha) were estimated in 36 different
hunting estates throughout the study area (Figure 1) using the censuses
included in the wildlife monitoring scheme (Aragn Government). Censuses
were carried out in August and September because the aim of this monitoring
plan is to know the hunting species abundance just before the hunting season,
in October. In each hunting estate, 5 fixed transects were placed selecting open
areas of high visibility. Transects were georeferenced (by means of GPS,
Garmin eTrex Vista) on the Forest Map of Aragn (vector map produced by
Aragn Government, scaled 1: 50,000). The censuses were repeated during 7
consecutive years (from 1998 to 2004) for a total of 1,112 transects (552
96
km/year). As described Gortzar et al. (2002), each fixed transect was 3,000 m
long and 100 m wide (30 ha), and was censused by 3 observers, thus the
transect width for each observer was 34 m. The short distance between
observers, and the selection of rather open habitats, should reduce the bias due
to visibility (see Bibby et al. 1992), and made us confident of having little
underestimation. We assumed that all birds within the transect width were
detected. Censuses began shortly after dawn until 3 to 5 hours later and were
done by foot. In order to reduce variability, only days without wind, rain or other
unfavourable meteorological circumstances were selected.
Partridge density for each transect was estimated with Kelkers method
(see Burnham et al. 1980), using the formula:
D=
n
LW 106
where D is the partridge density per 100 ha, n is the number of partridges
seen inside the 100 m counting strip, and LW 106 is the surface of the counting
strip in 100 ha units (i.e. 300010010-6= 0.3). Annual partridge density for each
hunting estate was calculated as the average of partridge densities obtained in the
fixed transects (generally 5 per hunting estate).
Weather conditions
Meteorological data were taken from 24 official meteorological stations of
the National Institute of Meteorology located across the study area from 1998 to
2002. To select the most representative parameters, a preliminary correlation
analysis was made with the different meteorological data. After this first
selection, we used the following indicators:
97
Patch Density (PD): the total number of patches per unit area (number of
patches/m2). We considered the number of patches of each vegetation class
(vegetation-class level) and/or the total number of patches per sampling unit
(landscape level) to calculate the PD index.
Average Edge length per unit Area (AEA) of each vegetation class (m-1).
The orography characteristics were obtained from a digital elevation model
98
99
RESULTS
Descriptive: partridges and foxes
The red-legged partridge average densities expressed in number of
partridges per 100 ha were the following (mean SE, n, minimum - maximum):
22.91 3.24, n= 20, (12.13 74.49) in the Pyrenean foothills, 21.64 2.02,
n=37, (0.00 49.29) in the Ebro depression, 16.75 1.56, n=77, (0.00 58.75)
in the northern Iberian chains, and 18.56 1.78, n=79, (0.00 67.78) in the
southern Iberian chains. No clear population trends have been observed for the
study period at a regional scale (beta = -0.18, p>0.05). Among the
biogeographical areas, partridge densities varied between years, as is shown in
Figure 2, but it can be observed that only the Pyrenean foothills area showed a
significant decreasing trend.
Figure 2. Annual variation (1=1998, 2=1999, 3=2000, 4=2001, 5=2002, 6=2003, and 7=2004,
in horizontal axis) in red-legged partridge summer densities for each biogeographical
area. The B coefficients show the population trends for each area (+=p<0.05, and
n.s.=p>0.05).
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 2 3 4
5 6 7
Pyrenean foothills
B=-0.77 +
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 2 3
4 5 6 7
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Ebro depression
B=-0.01 n.s.
N. Iberian chains
B=-0.29 n.s.
S. Iberian chains
B=0.34 n.s.
100
VARIABLES
d.f.
p-value
Estimate
97.5
2.54
0.048
-0.0666
84
7.21
0.008
-0.0168
Cultures mosaic PD
17.8
5.20
0.035
530.2100
Fox trend
111
0.42
0.216
-0.0011
101
DISCUSSION
This paper presents an analysis of red-legged partridge population densities
over seven years in many localities in north-eastern Spain, combined with a
look at several factors that may affect these densities. Truly the only conclusive
statement this study makes is that in the whole region of Aragn (about 10% of
the Spanish mainland), partridge population densities are not significantly
decreasing, which is a very considerable finding in itself.
Partridge densities
A wide range of red-legged partridge density values is described in the
literature. The highest densities, over 400 partridges per 100 ha, were found in
intensively managed hunting areas from south-central Spain (Nadal 1998).
However, in some natural populations without this kind of management,
partridge densities were around 50 to 100 partridges per 100 ha (e.g. in French
scrublands, Pepin & Blayac 1990; and in Spanish olive groves, Duarte 1998).
Our results showed much lower partridge densities, only similar to those
obtained in released populations (Carvalho et al. 1998, Mereggi & Mazzoni
della Stella 2004), and in areas with low partridge densities (e.g. in Portuguese
agricultural lands, Borralho et al. 1996). The lower densities found in Aragn as
compared to other areas were documented previously by Gortzar et al. (2002).
We used the same fixed transects than the previous study. They attributed the
low densities obtained to two possibilities, the use by different authors of a wide
number of field methods to estimate partridge densities, and a true effect of
environmental constraints.
No clear population trends were observed for the study period at a regional
scale. This is in contrast with the hunters perceptions and with previous authors
(e.g. Carvalho et al. 1998). Among the biogeographical areas, partridge
densities varied between years but clear population trends were not observed,
and even a slight increase occurred in the southern Iberian chains.
The lowest partridge densities were obtained in the Iberian chains, which
showed the most stable population trends during the study period (see Figure
2). In the northern Iberian chains some areas have a well-preserved habitat and
a favourable climate. In contrast, some of the higher zones in the south Iberian
chains have a lack of cereal crops due to rural abandonment and most areas
102
are above 1,000 m a.s.l., with frequent frost that may limit the reproductive
success of the partridges (Slagsvold & Grasaas 1979). The highest densities
were obtained in the Pyrenean foothills and Ebro depression populations, the
trend being slightly decreasing in the 7 studied years. These differences could
be do to the intensification of agricultural practices in some areas of the
depression (mainly in the 1980s), while traditional agriculture still dominates in
the mountain areas (Gortzar et al. 2002).
Influence of meteorological factors
Our results suggest that meteorological conditions are the main factors
affecting the summer abundance of red-legged partridges, even over the habitat
quality or predation. Most authors think that climatic conditions are key factors
limiting the galliform densities (Slagsvold & Grasaas 1979, Hermes et al. 1983,
Green 1984, Lucio 1990, Panek 1992, 2005), the weather conditions causing
only annual fluctuations (Panek 2005). The latter author suggested that the
weather conditions were an additional reason for the inter-annual density
changes, and consequently partridge populations oscillated around their
equilibrium level due to density-dependent parameters. We found that extreme
temperatures and hail were negatively related with partridge densities. This can
be explained in different ways:
i) Decreasing the chick survival: chick survival is a fundamental factor in
galliform population dynamics (Potts 1986), and the differences in this
parameter may produce the year-to-year changes in population densities (Blank
et al. 1967). Weather characteristics can influence the partridge chick, affecting
the quality and availability of food to both chicks and adults. Some studies have
shown that changes in temperature limit the number of chicks per pair in natural
populations of grey partridge, Perdix perdix, (Panek 1992) and red-legged
partridge (Lucio 1990). The influence of temperature on the number of chicks
per pair was shown experimentally (Hermes et al. 1983). These authors found
two explanations for this influence. First, excessively low temperatures in winter
may motivate a decrease in insect abundance (Panek 1992) that is positively
correlated with chick survival rates (Green 1984, Lucio 1991, Panek 1992).
Second, the relationship found between maximum temperature and partridge
103
densities can be related with chick death-rate during the harvest period. High
spring temperatures can bring forward the development of vegetation (Lucio
1990), but this is associated with bringing forward the harvest period. Hence, it
can increase the chick death-rate by agricultural machinery (Ricci 1985, Lucio
1990, Nadal et al. 1996, Meriggi & Mazzoni della Stella 2004).
Additionally, extremely high summer temperatures may increase the death
of partridges due to miopathy-like syndromes, that are reported in other lowland
partridge habitats in Spain (Hfle et al. 2004).
ii) Decreasing the productivity: it is well known that the climate influences a
birds fertility and productivity. Slagsvold & Grasaas (1979) working with
capercaille (Tetrao urogallus) found a positive relationship between the early
defrosting and autumnal densities. The food critical period can influence the
nest size (Lack 1968). The percentage of successfully hatched eggs may also
depend on factors such as temperature, storms, hail and rainfall (Green 1984).
iii) Increasing the predation of adults: the activity of partridges decreases
with low temperature and wet weather (Green 1984). This can make the birds
more vulnerable to predators, and can cause a loss of condition, again
increasing the vulnerability.
Normally, these demographic parameters do control the partridge population
dynamics. This is well known in grey partridge populations. The grey partridge
decrease in Great Britain between the 1960s and the 1990s was a result of a
decrease of both brood-production rate and chick survival rate (Potts 1986,
Potts & Aebischer 1994). Nevertheless, the grey partridge decrease in France
in 1990s was mainly an outcome of a decline in the survival rate of adults birds
(Bro et al. 2000, Reitz 2000). The population decrease of grey partridges in
Poland showed that it was connected with the drop of reproductive success,
including both the brood-production rate and the chick-survival rate, as well as
with the decline of the annual survival rate of adult birds (Panek 2005).
104
Habitat structure
Our results showed that cultures in mosaic were the habitat type with most
influence on red-legged partridge densities. This type of habitat is associated to
traditional agriculture schemes. These traditional schemes were based on the
distribution of cultures in small patches where the hedges were a key landscape
structure feature.
The development of agriculture was characterized by the increase of plot
dimension, hedge destruction, monocultures and development of harvesting
mechanization (Myers et al. 2000). Intensified agricultural practises and habitat
changes are believed to be key factors in explaining the decline of many
agricultural bird species (Chamberlain et al. 2000, Siriwardena et al. 2000).
Fuller et al. (1995) argued that the decrease in area of semi-natural grasslands
has reduced their capacity for farmland birds. Prt & Sderstrm (1999) argued
that the combined effects of good foraging habitat close to safe nesting sites are
critical factors for breeding farmland birds. The negative effect of modern
agriculture on partridge populations was suggested before by several authors
(Ricci 1985, Lucio1991, Nadal et al. 1996, Fortuna 2002, Meriggi & Mazzoni
della Stella 2004). The grouping of agricultural plots that has taken place during
the last decades has already been indicated as a constraint for red-legged
partridge density in the north-west of Spain (Lucio 1991). Hedge reduction also
has a negative effect on partridge density in Spain (Fortuna 2002). Hedges are
areas with high availability of food, nesting-sites, shade and cover. The last two
characteristics can also be supplied by other types of vegetation, such as
vineyards or olive trees (Borralho et al. 1998). In our study, vineyards and olive
trees (noted woody cultures) were not related with the highest partridge
densities. These habitat types give shade and protective cover and are rich in
hedge-like microhabitats, but are intensively managed with agrochemicals and
machinery.
Hunting pressure
The over hunting pressure are considered for a lot of authors one of the most
important causes of of the Red-legged partridge decrease (Potts, 1986; Pepin y
Blavac, 1990; Lucio y Purroy, 1992; Borralho et al., 1997). Our findings in this
study are in contrast with this result, but is with the limited data on hunting
105
106
death for a majority of the localities in our study then there would be a negative
correlation between the two species population parameters. This finding agrees
with similar results obtained in analysing fox and rabbit trends in Aragn
(Williams et al. 2007).
Conclusions
We found that the meteorological circumstances were the most important
factors
that
limited
summer
partridge
densities.
Hence,
the
climatic
characteristics of a territory are, in our opinion, the main factor that determines
their environmental potentiality as far as the red-legged partridge summer
abundance is concerned.
Within a given bioclimatic area, some habitat characteristics such as small
plot size and high boundary proportion do also benefit the partridge densities.
One of the main conservation challenges in Mediterranean areas is the loss of
this habitat type caused by the intensification of agricultural practices.
According to the premise that red-legged partridge exploitation should be
sustainable, populations with low densities generate questions regarding the
management of the hedges in the landscape, regeneration of agricultural
mosaics to improve partridge densities.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Partridge censusing is part of the game management actions of Asesora de
Caza y Pesca, Direccin General de Medio Natural, Gobierno de Aragn.
Special thanks to Emilio Escudero, Adela Garca and Gaspar Len who
coordinate the scheme. This work would never have been done without the
enthusiastic collaborations of Aragns Game Rangers. Joaqun Vicente helped
us with the statistical analysis. D Villana and P Acevedo were supported by the
joint project CSIC/Principado de Asturias.
REFERENCES
1. Aebischer, N. & Kavanagh, B. (1997). Grey partridge. In Hagemeijer,
W.J.M., Balir, M.J. (eds.), The EBCC Atlas of European Breeding Birds, their
Distribution and Abundance. T&AD Poyser, London, pp. 212-213.
107
2. Aebischer, N.J. & Potts, G.R. (1994). Redlegged partridge. In: Tucker, G.
M. and Heath, M. F., Birds in Europe. Their Conservation Status. Birdlife
Conservation Series n3, Birdlife International, Cambridge, UK.
3. Baratti, M., Ammannati, M., Magnelli, C. & Dessi-Fulgheri, F. (2005).
Introgression of chukar genes into a reintroduced red-legged partridge
(Alectoris rufa) population in central Italy. Animal Genetics. 36(1): 29-35.
4. Barnes, R.F.W. & Tapper, S. (1984). A method for counting hares by
spotlight. Journal of Zoology of London, 206: 273-276.
5. Bernabeu, R.L. (2000). Evaluacin econmica de la caza en Castilla-La
Mancha, (PhD Thesis, Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha, Espaa).
6. Bibby, C.J., Budgess, N.D. & Hill, D.A. (1992). Bird census techniques.
London : Academic Press.
7. Bielza de Ory, V. (1993). Atlas geogrfico-temtico de Aragn. Diputacin
General de Aragn, Zaragoza.
8. Blank, T.H., Southwood, T.R.E. & Cross, D.R. (1967). The ecology of the
partridges. I. Outline of population processes with particular reference to
chick mortality and nest densitiy. Journal of Animal Ecology, 36: 549-556.
9. Borralho, R., Rego, F. & Vaz-Pinto, P. (1996). Is driven transect sampling
suitable for estimating Red-legged Partridge Alectoris rufa densities? Wildlife
Biology, 2: 259-268.
10. Borralho, R., Rego, F. & Vaz Pinto, P. (1997). Demographic trends of redlegged partridges (Alectoris rufa) in southern Portugal after implementation
of management actions. Gibier Faune Sauvage, 14: 585-599.
11. Borralho, R., Rito, A., Rego, F., Simoes, H. & Vaz-Pinto, P. (1998).
Summer distribution of Red-legged partridge (Alectoris rufa) in relation to
water availability on Mediterranean farmland. Ibis, 140: 620-625.
12. Blanco-Aguiar, J.C., Virgs, E., Villafuerte, R. (2003) Perdiz roja,.
Alectoris rufa. In: Mart R, del Moral JC (eds) Atlas de las aves.
reproductoras de Espaa.
13. Blank, T.H., Southwood, TRE, & Cross, DJ (1967) The ecology of the
partridge. I . Outline of population processes with particular reference to
chick mortality and nest density. Journal of Animal Ecology, 36: 549-556.
108
14. Brickle, N.W., Harper, D.G.C., Aebischer, N.J. & Cockayne, S.H. (2000).
Effects of agricultural intensification on the breeding success of corn
buntings Milaria calandra. Journal of Applied Ecology 37: 742-755.
15. Bro, E., Sarrazin, F., Clobert, J. & Reitz, F. (2000). Demography and
decline of the grey partridge Perdix perdix in France. Journal of Applied
Ecology 37: 432-448.
16. Bro, E., Reitz, F., Clobert, J., Migot, P. & Massot, M. (2001). Diagnosing
the environmental causes of the decline in grey partridge Perdix perdix
survival in France. Ibis. 143: 120-132.
17. Burnham, K.P., Anderson, D.R. & Laake, J.L. (1980). Estimation of
density from line transect sampling of biological populations. Wildlife
Monographs, 72: 1-202.
18. Caldern, J. (1983). La perdiz roja, Alectoris rufa (L.). Aspectos
morfolgicos,
taxonmicos
biolgicos.
(PhD
Thesis
Universidad
109
25. Crick, H.Q.P., Dudley, C., Evans, A.D. & Smith, K.W. (1994). Causes of
nest failure among buntings in the UK. Bird Study. 41: 88-94.
26. Delibes, M. (1988). La caza de la perdiz roja en Espaa. Destino (eds.).
Barcelona.
27. Delibes M. & Hiraldo, F. (1981). The rabbit as prey in the Iberian
Mediterranean
ecosystems.
Proceedings
of
the
World
Lagomorph
densities
of
the
red-legged
partridge
(Alectoris
rufa)
in
110
36. Hermes, J., Woodard, A., Vohra, P. & Snyder, R. (1983). The effect of
ambiental temperature and energy level on reproduciton in Red-legged
partridges. Poultry Science, 62: 1160-1168.
37. Hfle, U., Milln, J., Gortzar, C., Buenestado, F.J., Marco, I. &
Villafuerte, R. (2004). Self-injury and capture myopathy in net-captured
juvenile red-legged partridge with necklace radiotags. Wildlife Society
Bulletin 32: 344-350.
38. Lack, D. (1968). Ecological adaptations for breeding in birds.Methnen Ed.
London.
39. Lucio, A.J. (1990). Influencia de las condiciones climticas en la
productividad de la perdiz roja (Alectoris rufa). ARDEOLA 37: 207-218.
40. Lucio, A.J. (1991). Seleccin de hbitat de la perdiz roja (Alectoris rufa) en
matorrales supramediterrneos del NW de la cuenca del Duero.
Aplicaciones a la gestin del hbitat cinegtico. Ecologa 5: 337-353.
41. Lucio A.J. (1998). Perdiz roja. In: F.J. Purroy (ed.) Atlas de las aves de
Espaa. Barcelona: Lynx.
42. Lucio, A.J. & Purroy, F.J. (1992). Caza y conservacin de aves en
Espaa. ARDEOLA, 39(2): 85-98.
43. Mereggi, S. & Mazzoni della Stella, R. (2004). Dynamics of a reintroduced
population of red-legged partridges Alectoris rufa in central Italy. Wildlife
Biology, 9: 1-9.
44. Myers N., Mittermeier R.A., Mittermeier C.G., da Fonseca G.A.B. & Kent
J. (2000). Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature, 403: 853958.
45. Nadal, J., Nadal, J. & Rodrguez-Teijerio, J.D. (1996). Red-legged
partridge (Alectoris rufa) age and sex ratios in declining populations in
Huesca (Spain) applied to management. Rev. Ecol. (Terre Vie) 51: 243-257.
46. Nadal, J. (1998). La bioecologa de la perdiz roja. In: Federacin Espaola
de Caza (eds.). La perdiz roja. Madrid. Federacin Espaola de Caza, pp.
33-45.
47. Panek, M. (1992). The effect of environmental factors on survival of Grey
Partridge (Perdix perdix) chicks in Poland During 1987-1989. Journal of
Applied Ecology, 29: 745-750.
111
112
59. Siriwardena, G.M., Crick, H.Q.P., Baillie, S.R. & Wilson, J.D. (2000).
Agricultural land-use and spatial distribution
of granivorous lowland
European Journal of
113
114
115
116
disminuir los sntomas y minimizar las bajas, pero desde luego no basta
cuando lo que se busca es conseguir aves con plenas garantas sanitarias de
cara a su liberaracin en el medio natural.
La misma situacin de falta de conocimientos especficos que hemos
comentado para el caso de los tratamientos es la que nos encontramos al
revisar los protocolos diagnsticos utilizados. Los resultados expuestos en el
captulo 2 ponen de manifiesto cmo factores tan simples como la hora de
recogida de las muestras o el tipo de heces analizadas, son capaces de hacer
que se diagnostique como sana a una perdiz intensamente parasitada.
Mediante un experimento controlado, se pudo detectar un aumento muy
significativo en la excrecin de E. contortus y Eimeria sp. a lo largo del da,
hasta el punto de que en las heces de aves que a las 8:00 de la maana
estaban libres de excrecin, doce horas ms tarde se cuantificaban ms de
15.000 propgulos por gramo para el caso de Eucoleus contortus o 30.000
ooquistes por gramo para el caso de Eimeria sp. Una situacin semejante
suceda al comparar los resultados de los anlisis coprolgicos realizados
sobre heces corrientes o sobre heces de ciegos, con una ausencia casi total de
propgulos de Eucoleus contortus en las de ciego y una presencia mucho
menor de ooquistes de Eimeria sp. en las heces corrientes.
Estos errores
117
118
ligadas este medio, entre las que se encontrara la perdiz roja (De la Concha et
al., 2006).
Bibliografa
1. Birkan, M. (1990). La perdrix rouge. Brochures techniques O.N.C., Paris. 36
pp.
2. Capelo, M. y Castro Pereira, D. (1996). Sobrevivncia e disperso de
perdizes (Alectoris rufa L.) largadas em duas operaes de repovoamento
cinegtico. Revista Forestal, 9: 245- 253.
3. De la Concha, I., Hernndez, C y Pinilla, J. (2006). Medidas beneficiosas
para las aves financiables a traves del nuevo reglamento de desarrollo rural.
Sugerencias para su diseo y aplicacin en NATURA 2000. SEO/Birdlife.
Madrid. Espaa.196 pp.
4. Daz, M., Baquero, R.A., Carricondo, A., Fernndez, F., Garca, J. y Yela,
J.L. (2006). Bases ecolgicas para la definicin de las prcticas agrarias
compatibles con las Directivas de Aves y de Hbitats. Convenio Ministerio
MEdio Ambiente-Universidad de Castilla la Mancha. Informe Indito.
5. Gortzar, C., Villafuerte, R., y Martn, M. (2000) Success of traditional
restocking of red-legged partridge for hunting purposes in areas of low
density of northeast Spain Aragn. Zeitschrift fr Jagdwissenschaft, 46: 2330.
6. Kirsch, R. (1983) Treatment of Nematodiasis in Poultry and Game birds
with Febendazole. Avian Diseases, 28(2): 311-318.
7. Milln, J., Gortazar, C., and Villafuerte, R. (2001) Marked differences in
the splanchnometry of farm-bred and wild red-legged partridges (Alectoris
rufa L.). Poultry Science, 80: 972-976.
8. Milln, J., Gortzar, C., Tizzani, P. and Buenestado F.J. (2002) Do
helmints increase the vulnerability of released pheasants to fox predation?.
Journal of Helmintology, 76: 225-229.
119
between
pheasant
and
grey
partridge:
preliminary
120
121
Perspectivas y reflexiones
122
123
124
View publication stats