Sg[KY YTSU rRqSRTSjaR

jlRsSvl{jRTSjYRu
Rg}uhReaiSUu e g|eaJeaJ eJ
XiUTYxU`YlgTYXiUxTlWgwUlhU[lL
XiUTYxU`TixTssf[TYWkig

mdYjR
VT` qxW lc nW VUW iTicT lT [ O \cWT Th }g
YTicpT sUT ~}l YfUT Y`Ux VlM UTg` c iSTgTg`T
TiWTi]M[ULfUTSWTp[T~ppf[TqxWuU[TwMnhT
knqix[ThTUnY`[ZU{TiTfTgYfUT}itTlc[~
\cW fTgT yTiT uU[iT  gj hT UwU[iT i U Vlc tT gj
ggxTwLyTiTlL~ITTWXiTicTY`ig~klciU~it
XgSU~LULifJiUW ITTYicwYWTi]M[WsW[i[[TZUitT
UWTfTgYfUT}itTw
ggc[ YW iTicT lT c[ is w YnT h v \cWT Ux[
VUl[TZTi|[Thgcp[TVUlcT]~Xi]NTYTZTi|[T
lnTuUxnTY`[iTicT
}pYWWs|T}lTvbslT}liTicTVUl[TWUYiUT [[
~ \cWT Th  Ij` h[ p[ [ i XUUc ^h Tgf[lUW YiSTg
UYwUxnTYUsTVUlcknTYic][WTVlUc_UiWXip
Z[nTinUWTuUxnTYVUlcWbslT}lTYW][^hIUW
}lThUW[l[[T
gj[lnTuUxnTXiWZUW[l[YiSTgT}pVUWTL\cWTitLg
VUl[T [ [T TxT W YiUU~ bslT }lT UW[l [T [ w UWU{
h U[ \cWT XgUjT Tw V|[ Z[W]L gj[ [T TxT wUxnT YWT
iTicTlTj[[TZUcTYw`fil[Tc[UW_SU[T
`SU[[\UcWZUwrXgw\cWTai[UYiSTgT}pYW

We

}itT YlTigW IUWT UlT \cW ji U ip V`W n[ Y[ uin LgW Ugw
UrxW hfL [T UW YSUT UWT qxW fUT ITgT [ kU YsUW YfUT
}l[T~VUWTYWTTgf[lT]XiUcTsUT~fUTp[Y~ixTZUp[UW
]YiTicTYcTiTw XgxWZUUWThfTgYlUTYiTicT }itTLXM`UTZU
>@ nXgU[xTUWT
inUWkUUL{i UwircTi]tc[ iW[Wl~_SU[ThYnUgw
}l[T~VUWTTgf[lTg`w mUTg[cTvT
fgTTiU[fT~IUsfMWUWTITgLIlTiiWZUlUTTi`LhTUWTIUj~ IUx~
c~ >@ YWTwgl~LUfUlTITT^TifPW[[TYxTY[TZUc[~VUWT
[ctT lnTVUl[T[wWU`Oi]M[ZThYWTMWiUxTqxWl[
ZUc[~UW

}l[T~VUWTTgf[lTurWschTITiTqiUx[U]gi`ihWlUiW[x
ggx^U[cUY]WWs[YwYp[Lp[iTipTYWxpOgNU
ZTil[TcT STgWTWYiUYwrTYTZUlTigT

Uin~n[WVUWUW}ljWY`iUfTYfTgTXiTicTZU`igwUlTi|[Tn
sl[TwLYSY`ig ggc~YfTgTITTXiTicY`igiTi[lTtc 
>@YSZU`ig TcWYiTicTYcTiTggcw ^if`iUfTITT

YWUTZTi|[TY~Us|VUWfUTITgg[pT\cWTTh}gT
hTg`T[Y]WYlYp[ZTiTihUf[UWpaUlTVUlcTkU
YY`igLOw[iTipTx
U[lTiglUSTgLwXi]NTYTZTi|[Tggc[YWfUTlTc[Wh[
T[TVlTU]Up[[lTigZTi|[TgcLiU[fT]i]LL\cW~U
TNlTwYWU`p
`qjR{jSUWgS{jRUYjfRjlRsSvlRWuUS^Mg[KYWU

YUZaUR]

lSiSj`\cWT[

grRGh^R

fUT lT w Xi]NT YT ZTi|[T qTix[lT f YW fUT lT c[

] fUTYWTITgYTYlTigisTb[~}gWU[UwXi]NTZTi|[Tggc[~ YW
L YlTigT h  ZTi|[T UW gc[ L ZW][ YlTigT w [[l hT UsT ggc[
kUlLwYWYcrT_SU[W^if[
U[lTig[[ZTi|[TSTggc[W[c[_Ij`TTh_

UqYRGh^R

}lTUWl[[TuUxnTYW[iUUiYWTUWl[[[TlnTuUxnTYVUlc
WixTUxTiUcpw_SU[Tx[Wbl[Y~Ti|`vTXgw~bslT
ITi`TTVlUcT wi][^hIUWwg[xSTi[lTIj`TTh~_T
\cWYSUTY`[pUc[ViU`[T_SU[ITi[lT]wViU`[T

WUdSRGReRuVg[LRWRXRgzYR

iUx lnT uUxnT  WT }l UWl[ [T YiTicT YUsT Y {eR gzY
VgSaRXRgY}Rd{jTSjYRJ~aY  lSiT}gU~STgWTWYiUT
TIU[nVUl[TwLc[ifLYcU UpLUWUl[TchTr~TgWU~
i]TZTi|[T g`qixfUTYWTITgL~Xi]NT ZTi|[T iWggwU
tcZTi|[ThvUx[T~\cWTUslnTuUxn }lTVUl[TwTi]M[
YUWTZTi|[T g`qixUW UTigW}lTnWYsW[iTi{ZTi|[TZW][
gzYR tZaURSvY
v[[STgWTWYiUT
w vTTxUsL
Xgc

Ui UWUlc[
uUxnTvj[Ut[TqTi[~UW
YUlTYWT~

9
9
9
9
9

Y[]YwTIUWWUlc[
YscTbslTYlUx USj`

i]N[ Twwg[xi|[
\cWTZTi|[U~
i{~tx\gc
uUxnTVUl[TZUL
lnT

2
2

WjRgeR|jSjJgzY 9
i|[v[Ti]M[T ZW]
STgWT wWs ZW]
UiUWUlc[
UiUWUlc[
UiUWUlc[
UiWUlc[

9
9
9
9

uUxnY\cWTqi[
Z[nTuUxnT]U[kxT 9
YscTipUxTi]M[gc[
QReURUWgSRgSv gzY
{eR

g[LYYRWjQgRXRgzYR
tUSYRgzYRWu

jRug[LRgzYR
WUgRgaR
tR
ogvRqRqd

[li|[
ilRsS}YgRWRhS^YR
[li|[
[li|[
WdSR{grR
WUgRgaRTSjYR u Vg[LRsSvlRsRJ
knToTf vT
glSURjlRsSvlR
YfUT}itT
knToTf vT
XYlRjlRsSvlR
YfUT}itT
Z[nTinUWTuUxnT
ivRjlRsSvlR
UxbslTYlUxT
YlUxTbslTvY`TT
YscTbslTXiTicY`ig bslTiTicT uUxnT
UxY`TTUxU[]UxWT
YscT
oTf}lTXiTicY`ig
}lTiTicTgT
fTgUWXiTicTdUT}lT
uUxnUW
IUlYwUxnTXiTicTY`ig
WURmRd WU
YjgzY
WURl
[li|[ vWiwXiSTgTc[Ut
[li|[
bslYSrToTfT
sSvlRWUgRgaRTSjYR
vT knTUTjYWTn
sSvlWpgvRWaSjR
Z[T~Ti|`T
vT knTUTjYWTn
qjRWRh
Z[T~Ti|`T
inUWTuUxnTu` qSjRjlR sSvlR Vel
kxTZ[nT
ITj`LL }lTYTj GSj {jRW^R Sv
YWTbsl
ITj`LL }lTYTj {jRUW^RRSv
YcUlvYWTbsl
ivR sSvlR geSn
ifTuUxnTigUp
gRgaR
WUSjRXRgzYRUg[KY
S^RgRgaRTSjYR
sSvlR

lnTuUxnTYWiTicTVUl[TwXi]NTYlSiTZTi|[T  g`

p[UWYWTl`iWwXiTicTU[T p[T

ZU{TiT}[YUc~YWTl`iWwXiTicTU[TgxgTgj
SUlTgf[lTgwi]M[TThUW U[iTicY`igZW][ YfTgT
XgUl[Y`[YpUfyTiTXiTicY`igi|[Wbl[c[YWUl
lXiTicTVil[[YWTyTi~|n[fUlTITT

^iUfUWITTXiTicY`ig
fTgUWXiTicTY`ig
XiTicTY`ig~c[Tu
fTgUW
fTgOXiTicTUilgx
yTiT
YlnTITTXiTicY`ig

][lnTuUxnTVUl[TY`[YWTbslXiTicY`iggTgj[
6RO$LU7HPS
`iUfTbsl gj[ 6RO$LU7HPS YlnTXiTicTY`ig
tTVU`YWlUW[UWknqixTYWTVT`gc YWTbslUl[Ti{fl[T
`iUfT
LYWToTflw}[[jTifM[TXi[~gxW
gM[\cWY`UcW YWfTgTbslTfl[~hi]Lit YWTbslUl[Ti{fl[T
fTgT
xWsTcUWITZTiU[ghTUl[Ti{fl[TYc
Y`[VUWTjwVxpT~UiTicTiWxUXgUwYWTl`
IUnTXgUYiTicTYpT
ULUYg[jwZU[Yx[i}U[WOIUcT^gjUn
IUnTXgUYiTicTYxlT
U iTsWT YcslT}lofiTg[TIUs|Tg[[
YWTl`iTicTjxT
YiTicTU[xliTicTUjw
iTicTgUW[TbslYcUl
YfTgTyTiTXiTicY`igZW][gw WlTUi]M[gTgjTh
LU ^iUfTfTgTWXiTicTZU`ig~iUTXgUjU[UW
YcUlgjUbslT}lTYcUlw gj[YWTbslYcUl
XiTicThU

yTiTfTgxWsTcUWITTYicwYWTi]M[ cT

XgiWyTiTlMWITT\cyTiTuU[iTXgUjWiTicT^ig[Ti]M[gTgj
^ig[T
~YcTiUWkUlcTgjUflTITTgwUp[Y`[XiTicwL~UW fTgiTicT
VU{~Xj XiTicTY`igsl[i|[gw{iinWUW|nTyTiTlL
yTiT
YiTicTYcTiTwxTUi]M[gi|[TThYTYT\cWVs }[T
g`YUc~wT OY~i|TITic[cZTiU[[[iTicT^ig[Y`[
ITTYic
Ufg yTiUWITflL gwUp[hTITT^ifYWTwMWZUc[~
g`v
ITTUThO XiTicTY`igqf~WU`Oi]LUZUc[Tgg`IT
YWUWZUc[~
>@YcTiUWTixnVWl[UlITTYicLU YWXiTicY`ighfTgT
ITTXgUlv`[[ UlLYc~ZUc[Tg`L YWUWZUc[~g`gwYUc~ YSTTXgUlT
gx[~YWfTgTbslTXiTicY`iggj[cTi]M[WYWTyTi~fTgfUlT
YfUlT
UcslWXiTicTZU`igiU~oY`[YWTl`iWwp[UWXiTicTUil
i{fl[T
WlUic[YWxpcUWyTiYfUlTYSTTXgUlTXiTici]M[p
Ul[T
\cWOY`UcWurTTh XinUWfUlTfTgTbslTuUxnUWUp
YWTbsl
ITTThic[w g`O Ul[Ti{fl[Ti]M[vYpUf i]M[c[
fTgT
Zg`T}[TZTgxwcTgTjyTiT`cgTjU
cTZTiU[iTicT^ig[Ti]M[gTgjTUyTiTuU[iTgTjU
}[TVU{~YWU`OZTi]M[
yTiUxT|[lTgUp[TgTfTgIUWTgw
WUsTuU[iTgj[[TYfUTcTZUgUp[TU
hTIUWT~qiT|[lTUxh\cYWTU
uU[ipLgcWUcUXgUw

yTiToTf

yTiT`c
yTiTuU[iT

yTiT}U[
i{~Wv[TyTiT`c
YfUTqTi{T
Tgf[lTLWTsY~UrTYWU
bslT

YWUWiTicTlT wXi]NTZTi|[T  g`

YlTigUW Un  iT ^hT L {i W XgiTT ZTi|[T i]M[ l g` }p
uUxnUW VUl[T YlTig [ [c YW iTicT l U[ ~ [ h YT
fp[UWUU[[\c ZTi|[Tain g`fUW UUlXi[WY`
\cWTITj`LUW

TSUR{juSvlRTSjYR

MnTThWULiU
gjL}liTicTVUl[TVUWTTgf[lT
qix[ YWUWs|T}lTTIj`TitlnTVUl[T[YWTMWN R
uUxnUUWqix[[ UlYWTLUUWTwUtWYWT[UWlnTuUxn
}lTw lnTVUl[TUTgf[lU~tT~ifTUWYxnUVU`qix[hO
`iUfTbslT YcUlMWyTiT`ciWL[cYWTnLU bslT
YWTbslXgUjY`[uUxnqixT}lTbslgjYWTTgf[lTMWN S[R
U YiT}pYWTYUc~}xrT Us|[[T}lTYcslTXiSTgTYcUlw
XinUWTYxnTVUl[T~i~LwgjY[[nTYxnTlnTVUl[T}wUr
o {i L XinUWT YxnT  VUl[T L ~ LiT Th VUcpL n W tT Y`[
U`[TUULYiT}pYWTbslwuUxnTgUx[Y`[uUxnYrixTYcUlT
UU[[rU[[`[TpUOOYccpYwZUgLgWLiTL{i
YiUTUU i]M[VUlcgwY`[ LiU~
Tit  XihT ZTi]M[ T VUlcUW  VlUc _UiW h[ p[W U]cUWT U g
bslT }lTYWTh}liTicTVUl[TWYiUT]UgUWUlcYWxp

WUUqzR{juSvlRTSjYRTSjaW}

lnT uUxnT Xgn ggc[ knT sl UTj ggc[ cTi YxWiL w VUlcT Yw [[
 bslT}lTUW[l[T[]YWTUW[l[[TuUxnTZUVUlc

TSjYRTSjaSeuYYRWraR euilRqjSRheeaY

>@__YxU`WZis[T 6RODU'UXP YlnTYcTYisW UTjTVUlc[

lLiTw[[TYjT[TZUcTYw`Xip~knTZTiUl][wg[x[
]]^hTThc[[YiTZU]]TVUlciswvTqiwsfUl[YTjW
v`SU[ZWUs[YisThWsVlUc_UiWis[[girUi^hOgUxWT
>@ UU[UWUs[Y~ixTYlnTTiUlTsSTif
XYlRevRjlRsSvlRVeleeaY
>@ Tg`T h U Z`[[lT [T ZgUxT $6+5$( Tg` w TgU[wT h [
~xqiwsfgwZ[nTsUlTlnTuUxnTXgnYwUl ZUsl[vr[ZgUx
WUi|[[[TlnTuUxnYlUTZUUWTWUWZU~[fTg`{ix
U >@ $6+5($ Uwg[x[YiUxTZUTgf[lUWYgULOYgYg
(QHUJ\3OXV  '2(  ]Ugf[l[UgXg[xTiT][T_TiWL
WURSUYjYYRXSRTSja
slYTjWuUxnT[[YWTYs~YWTUWl[[[TYUsTYVUlcVxpT
bslT}lTVUl[TUWVl[c[TYisUWVUl[TVUlcilxTLxUY[f
YWTbsll[W)LQLWH(OHPHQW ggc[TYU[ZTgcTYisTgf[lT[YnThc [
 nWbrUU~L UlLiYWTl[ i|pTYU[bslTXiWYw`O
$6+5$($PHULFDQ6RFLHW\IRU+HDWLQJ5HIUHJHUDWLQJDQG$LUFRQGLWLRQLQJ(QJLQHHUV
'2(%XLOGLQJ(QHUJ\6LPXODWLRQ6RIWZDUHWRRO'HYHOSHG6XSSRUWHGE\'HSDWPHQW 2I(QHUJ\86$

(QHUJ\3OXV/DWHVW%XLOGLQJ(QHUJ\6LPXODWLRQ6RIWZDUHWRRO6XSSRUWHGE\$PHULFDQ*RYHUQPHQW

v` YWTVUl[TggcSTj`L wYUl[YTjWknTU wsl[

Z[nTinUWTuUxnTbslThVUl[T
w ViU`[T ITi`T [ g _UiWT IsW gTj ZUWUlcT Yg ZgTj ZUl[T ggw gTj U
OU~LYWTl[Ij` OYiT}pYWTuU[iTl[LZW]~Y[fZUl[
UiThTgf[lUW\cWT_SU[VUlc[Th LVUlcT~MsfY`igcUwUs
h~YW{iTYUc~wLYgZU`igTgf[lUWbl_UiWT
[ U Uc[ Uc [ XiU[f  Yw`W YiUT is w _SU[T Yl  c[T [ g
>@ XiTtY~ixTUnUW[ThTtTnYiU
WURf{jRWaqjRGRh^R`qjR{jTSjYRTSja
bslT YcUl slTYTjU[` inUWTuUxnTXgn VUl[T
YrixT}lTYWlVUlcUWYscT}lTYcslTITj`TwYWTt sUlT[
YWTt ~YcT[inUWTuUxn
ITi`Tgf[lT[|n[Ygc[T 6LPXODWLRQ0RGHO YiTXUUcT^hIUWgxW
Wi`[^hwUUcT

lnTVUl[TVUlcW]cUWTYslTWis[[hT 6RO$UF'RPH _UiWYnUnn

\cWT_SU[^U[[lTgf[lT[hT YcslT}lTVUW

Ug^YR \fR 

U[s|[WlLWYiUT[ UgUxWLvWislZThYrTi[~TY~i{
~Lbsl}l L
vWiTvrUisUlYi}pYWh}lV
iU[ffYwUl }lTgW UWl[[TlnTuUxnTYVUlc[
UxTTsgWTlwYUXipIUsw  YlTinin

VUlc[bslT}lTYWTW[l[hTZ[nTuUxnTinUWTuUxnT VUlc[
}lTbslTIj`TwYWT[hTtT
ggxYWi`[Tvl[[] qiwsfwvrTi[~TvwViU`[TtxZ[
O qixTssfn[ZTi|[T

TSUuSvlRTSjYgR[YR]QSYaYogu WUqYRWjRgeR

WgR{nWURf{jR`qjR{jRgRgaRTSjYRWgS

YWTh}lT

bslT}lT

bslT}lTYWTVUl[LWiT

YWThbslT}lTTIU[nUpU`TiTicTVUl[TWYiUT n
g` tcTZUwUlYwUl }lTUW[l[TuUxnTYbrcligw
VUl[TY ~UWZU~[fTil[YWTh}lTbslT}lTWYcrTiT~
XgUj v U`ig[ kn WUl[T gTj[ \c nT li` VWg cW bslT }lT j[
ZrfT U h gxW qf ] XitT YwUl Y pL O p knT uU[iT YTj
YrfTYTjTZThYxn~T}lTUW[lToslTYTjXgUjY`[knT
f XiW ZTgUjT [  Uw nW bslT }lT w YWT h }lT UW[lT gj
}lTx`UXitTgwUW[lT~iTT[UWVi|TViiUWTaUWpTZUwUl
Y`[ knT in gi`W YwilW VUl[T gj \c  UWl vlL cW j[ YWT h
xWsnWgTj[UWYrfTuU[iTYTjZThknYlLiTWnYWTVT`Y`T
bslT}lT]XitTgw

WURf{jRTSjYR|XYlRsSvlRglSURsSvlRge 

wXitTXi[~fYWTh}linUWT lnTuUxnTVUl[Tinf
h}lZ[nTlnTuUxnTVUl[TULTUW~wgjUWbslT}lT
TVUl[TU[UW  TTsbslT}lTVUl[T}xrViU~YWT
YTj[cYlTinUW~ii[ sTTh TTswLYWTh}l
gjUYWTh}linUWTlnTuUxnTVUl[Tgj\cpTknTuU[iT
YlTinUWfiTT

XYlRsSvlRW^YTSjYR

RTSjYR

YWTh}lT

glSURsSvlRW^YTSjYR

bslT}lT

bslT}lTZ[nTuUxnTinUWTuUxnY`[iTicTVUl[TWYiUT n
qiwsfinfYWTh}lT

{jR`qjRGh^WURrRg[KY 

qUfT gw VUl[T qUfT sT  gW g

ITj`T w YWT t gUgj knT uU[iO YTj
UxTlnTVUl[TU}lTYcslT
bslT Ij`T \] O p tT rW }l
zW }lT  bslT Ij`T L tc ThO
s~ }l Y~T YcUlT U`T  Tc
igUW Ti]N   tT L sT  U
VUl[T~igLYpUfYip[T
UslYTjXgUjVWlWknTYTjqUfTgw
~i~TwLYWTl`~VUl[TW~w
pg brTiUWtT}lT ~VUl[T
Ij`TwYWTt brsl n
i~T}UxrL TcO
}lTbslT

RS^RgRgaRTSjYR 

gTgcTw}[f[YWlWbslT}lTwYWlnTVUl[pTgcTgTgj
ZUwUl iTicT VUl[T v` [ U VUl[T ~ iUT w iWx gcT i pT
g`it YlTin ~VUl[TYiU[TVUl[TU`TVUlciUT
bslT}lTwTIU[n  Up  gjYWTh}lU`TTVUl[TL

inT
bslT
}lT
VUl[T

YWTh}lT VUl[T

 }lTYWT VUl[TYWl
 XgUj YSTYWlT

YWTh}lTbslT}lTUW[l[TTU`TlnTuUxnTYYiU g`
YwUl ZTYlTin ~

ogvRqd|gzYRg[KY 

qiwsf Un qiwsfgwZi`LZUWUlcYZUlTigWZ[YWUlT_SU[Ttx

O qiwsfg[[lTWixTUxTiUcpUwZT XiUT
qixTssfUWwWs[YUxT_SU[TLgM[TV`ThUn
Uit~Un [cUn qiwssfwZUWUlcTZi`Lg
}lT w YWT h }lT VUl[T gj \c i|[ gW YiU UxT U`[T iTi[lT 
VUl[TqUfT{i }pT~UwTg[wTIU[nT~XiWZTgUjTit[bslT
v[UTIU[nT
IT[lTsfwUgx[WTUTIU[nT}pT~VUl[TWYUwiTTgTgj[ 
IT[lTsfw Ugx[WTUbslT}lTYWTVUl[T WiUTgTgj 
VUl[TXgUjY`[YUnTqixTssfgwbrTnWTIU[nYWWU`Ti]M[TgTgj 
UsUW[iTwgU[xTip[TkwXgiUWT}itT~Xg[UcniUlnT
n~ZUiUTh_SU[ qxWit[ XiUcT}itUW
sf

qiw

iW[Wl

iU

sf

qiw

sf

qiw

Xggx[Y~Ti|`vT~YWTh}lTbslT}llnTVUl[TYiU n

WndR
WSvR]QSYR 

uU jlRsSvlW^YgRgaRTSjYRY TSUSU{jRWqzY z

SYgSeu   U_RgYYWUjUS^RR TSjYRehY ivR
WaSjRi}`qj{jU
bslT}llnTVUl[TwUlnTVUl[Tgj\c;TIU[nWU`Oi]M[YW z


 YUnTqixTssfgw YpUf
IT[lT sf w gxWUW YcslT }lT VUWT ZTh }lT VUl[O W iUT gTgj z
 w gj[ UW zW qiwsfgw;UpTlnTVUl[T~XgUjU~

qiwsfgw  zW qiwsfgw

]QSYRuWSXSra

OUplnTVUl[TXgUj~]YWWlVU`g`Z[W]L\cWT_SU[L{i z
YWTITgLYlTiggW Thj`igp~UfUYWTTgf[lTg`gxWvsTx[ UL
ZTi|[T v`U[iUsT~
UYi[`TpTfi|[[}lT YcUlgTgj[bslT }l gWYWTTgf[lT gw z
XgUjUW}lTuU[iOi|[U;UrLi|[yTiT`cLtclnTWUl[Tgj
Yi}pTYWTYUc~Y~i|Tqiw}p
yTiT~iTicT^ig[TwYWTi]M[LZW]YUc~ YWU`O[g`cT~XgUjTh
fUlTITT^if~gwUl[YWTwL~ZUc[~g`LYiTicTYcTiUWixnTgj
YWwUxnTVUl[TXgUjWlTi]M[TqxgITgT~WUUYUcTh~
}[TUcLXgUjWTgg`UWlTi]M[}r[`cTXgUj~YTZU{TiT YUc~UL
ifLisWhYiUYWTwY`[UT`cTuU[iTXgUjZTi]M[YlTiggwUT z
Ui{LvLiLWW}l[TL}lTVlv~i]`cTuU[iTXgUj

XSnYR

ITgT w ZTi|[T  ggc ggw i]M[ T [T w \cWT Th ji[ VpT g z
YYlTigOY`UcWTj[ [TifTVT`TggxTUVUWUW}l[fUT
wuU[iTvITiTicT^ig[Ti]M[ ITTYicwYfTgTcTZTiU[i]M[]
UjxYSTisTYWTl`iWwp[UWXiTicTU[ThYiTicTYcTiT
L YsWTi[TYssfT\UcWTggwUn]cWuinW[W U]cUWTp
fUTVUWTITgw[OpT}gWYgiT\UcWTYllTw

t^RgR
mk 
  mp >@
  
 ^
mk 
  mp >@
  
 ^

>@:DWVRQ' /DEV.&OLPDWLF'HVLJQHQHUJ\HIILFLHQW%XLOGLQJ3ULQFLSOHVDQG
3UDFWLFHV0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ<RUN86$SS
>@&KHXQJ.37KHVXQDQG%LXLOGLQJ'HVLJQ3URFHVV8QLYHUVLW\RI+RQJ.RQJ

$YDLODEOHDWKWWSDUFKKNXKNWHDFKLQJOHFWXUHVKWP

l  m     m m  p G >@

 ZGp 
X
 m 
 pp >@

>@ 'XIILH-$ HW DO 6RODU (QJLQHHULQJ RI WKHUPDO 3URFHVVHV -RKQ :LOH\ 
VRQV1HZ<RUN86$SS
 nm  gp >@

4XDQWLWDWLYH(YDOXDWLRQRI6KDGLQJ3DWWHUQVRI
'RPHV$QG,WV,PSDFWRQ5RRI6RODU*DLQ

$KPHG$KPHG)HNU\3K' $EEDV0HO=DIDUDQ\3K'
$VVRFLDWH3URIHVVRU)DFXOW\RI(QJLQHHULQJ&DLUR8QLYHUVLW\
/HFWXUHU)DFXOW\RI5HJLRQDO 8UEDQ3ODQQLQJ&DLUR8QLYHUVLW\
$EVWUDFW
,WLVFRPPRQWRUHFRPPHQGXVLQJGRPHVIRUURRILQJDV DSDUWRI
GHVHUW DUFKLWHFWXUH OHJDF\ LQ WKH PLGGOH HDVW $SDUW IURP
KLVWRULFDODQGDHVWKHWLFDVSHFWVVRPHFOLPDWLFDQGHQYLURQPHQWDO
GHVLJQHUV EHOLHYH WKDW GRPHV KDYH D SRVLWLYH HIIHFW RQ FOLPDWLF
SHUIRUPDQFH RI EXLOGLQJV :KLOH RWKHUV EHOLHYH WKDW WKH\ GRQW
KDYHDFOLPDWLFHIIHFWDQGWKHLUXVHLVIRUVWUXFWXUDODQGDHVWKHWLF
YDOXHRQO\
7KHDLPRIWKLVSDSHULVWRHYDOXDWHWKHFOLPDWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI
GRPHV DQG WKHLU LPSDFW RQ LPSURYLQJ WKH RYHUDOO EXLOGLQJ
SHUIRUPDQFHWRUHGXFHWKHXQFHUWDLQW\ OHYHODVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKH
WRSLF
7KLVWDVNLVUDWKHUFRPSOLFDWHGEHFDXVHGRPHV DUHFRPSOLFDWHG
V\VWHPV WKDW DIIHFW DOO DVSHFWV RI WKHUPDO SHUIRUPDQFH RI
EXLOGLQJ VR WKH SDSHU VWDUWV E\ DQDO\]LQJ WKH SHUIRUPDQFH RI
GRPHVGHILQLQJWKHTXDQWLWDWLYHYDULDEOHVWKDWUHSUHVHQWGRPHV
EHKDYLRU
7KHQVHOHFWLQJRQHRIWKHPWRWKRURXJKO\HYDOXDWHGRPHVLPSDFW
RQLW
6RODUJDLQRIURRIVZDVVHOHFWHG
7KHREMHFWLYHRIWKHSDSHULVWRDQVZHUWKHTXHVWLRQ
'RHVXVLQJGRPHVUHGXFHVVRODUJDLQRIURRIVRUQRW"
$GLJLWDOVLPXODWLRQPRGHOZDVEXLOWRQDSHUVRQDOFRPSXWHUWKH
VRIWZDUH GHYHORSHG E\ WKH UHVHDUFKHUV VSHFLDOO\ IRU WKLV SDSHU
FDQ HYDOXDWH VRODU JDLQ GXH WR GLUHFW DQG GLIIXVHG UDGLDWLRQ  RI
ERWKGRPHVDQGIODWURRIVDQGLWVLPXODWHVWKHGRPHVVKDGRZRQ
IODWSDUWVRIWKHURRILWFRYHUVUHSUHVHQWLQJWKLVE\QXPEHUVDQG
E\YLVXDODQLPDWLRQDVZHOO
7KHFDOFXODWLRQSURYHGWKDWXVLQJGRPHVLQFUHDVHVVRODUJDLQRI
URRIV E\  LQ VXPPHU DQG  LQ ZLQWHU IRU GRPHV EXLOW LQ
&DLUR QRUWK
'RPHV EXLOW LQ RWKHU ODWLWXGHV KDYH WKH PDLQ RYHUDOO SDWWHUQ
GLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQGRPHDQGIODWURRIDQGEHWZHHQVXPPHUDQG
ZLQWHUJDLQVLQFUHDVHLQQRUWKHUQODWLWXGHVDQGGHFUHDVHFORVHUWR
HTXDWRU