Professional Documents
Culture Documents
~qSSUWRgvRWYR SlW^gRW^[RgSvR
WRganR
ueSlgd ieR
glURjRWje
glURjRWjeUWqUYgRvR
wUOg[l[TxTL[`Ug[lUwj[iYwklLgg`w
ssf[TXiUxTOY~UrUW inWTlTYlg
i~[UWYWl[Yis~XiWfWUxmUx[Tw;TigUYlUTZUSWTh`Wi]TL
YslWYxWsgTZTgL
gT v` Xiir Y c Y`[Ti[lT bWpL YTicpT sUT O YTixT Y[UW `[T
c[YcU[TZUUTY~U}t[wx[YgYlgYwY`Vs[UWYWixT
YxWsYSW~Y[T[UnYWlUTcTgU`LwXigUYjT[YUx~YTiwY[
Y]Ti[T Y~U]T ZTiUW[wT YUlT iUxT iUsO ~ h YTicpT sUT ] YWxp
YT
UxinWTipxT_g} ULUTNlwgiTggnjU`PW\cWTU[
;Ti]M[YUx~i]LwnWYTixTY[TZUlTigssf~lSi
wi~
WRganR~qSRWQU
ZU`igYUwUWifW[TZgx LU~iUsTslgxY~U`sU
ifYs}[fcTu[TIT[cTLUpTTUW[UWj[[XiTicT
YTYcUlT TcWUxT~iUcpYTYcUlTig[
IUs|ToSUpfrTiTZUpYWlUWULgcdUTwgU[wTYUc~h YlWU
W iT]YlWUTYcUl TcOp[gYTiUcpTYcUlP~[UWT
Tc][YTicp q
TiLOUlTi]M[VWlWZc[[TYcUlTig[Th
ITicpT ] WixT UxT rTiL YxlUnT iUcpT gl[ YlWU YT YcUlT
vWiThT ITicpTglTipWYWTYWi|TITicpTYWTYiSTj`TYU[iT
YWixTXij`TWn~UfT
WRganRWQURtSvYglURjR
fg[TW[c eiU[TiWwYTicpTsUTvWixTsTlTUx[TvW[[L
Y[ c[ U]UcWL U[TgL }t[ YUlT klT UgL W vr [U[W xT lgT
YlUTYSWT[vUx[T~b`UTinWTlYflTigwTliL\cYc`UYTiw
SUl~ugWLuUs[lTIUTvUx[~ ipcT U]TWlx~U[UvmUx[T
ZUs[lT gUW UcT U[ ~ sTT g` UW [lT gni[ tc x`
UwpcT}U[uU[iTU[ig{iUWUYfrZU[lYTicpTYinWT
iT x[` l n[ w Zisl [T WixT sTT ZUl
iUTWliWUwL}rUW[l;Uppf ;USTg;UUgix` YTiTYUlTZUlT
Ti[cTYUcgTj`U[cUWgj[[WO^ixisTr YTg;Yx[nT
V{Lx`~rUW[lTUiTgL}i{Wp~g~Ti`Yppf[ppf
UlTWViUwU[`TwU[[inwMWUc[TfTgTws[}SUtTZUc[T
YlU YSW ~ X n ;UlU[ wU[`T UUW kUlcT w ;TiWx[ p[T gc UrxW
LWTVsTgf[lU~U;TIj`iUW[wUW[U`Uc YSWTg[lTYxWsTiTtTdUT
ixngT~ixnZWUOYpUfZUpTvrlIUW[SW~i~[Ti`cT
UaUiTZTgp}lfTuh`}xloWTgTwLgf[lTiTg`TLWT
ZTi`gWT}TZit~U]TWlwXg`WYgTZWT~ iUW|TITT[
giW[TXi[lTY[
RgvRWQURSjRUeSUYRuS}YRjRgqYR
~Xi]NYxilXi[lYwYlY`WXiUtUlTglTis[TL
Y~U w YxilT ZTi|[ Y`[ \gc UW i[l [T YSWT ~ ;Uppf XUcT n
[U`U[cIUriOUlTZUW{iYWU`[lThWTg`TZU[lT
jRgqYRWH
xWsTVUf[UWis[TYJ\gc[isTlTOY~UrUWSUWJZUlIUWT\iT[
]Ux[lT UTYit gTiTVUf[UWZTi|[~UWipxTrihT
] lT is[T Xgg` R`U nW ZUl it L YWi`[T Y`[ Vl[T lT
is[TZTTscT }[UUWtU[cT wgx[TLjUWVlUcUopf[
}itUW;p[bWpLU YwiUl[TYS`UT[UwTgWO[Ti|[vipxTYlbWpLlT
p[ lT is[T ~ kU` ~Ti|`T vj[T i]M[ g O SgT in[ YSWT
i]UWv~g[gg`TlTg[igpUiW[wTYscTYSWT}itT~R`UTi|[UW
XgSUlTYpTOUc[Yc[TZUlTY`igOZUlT
`T ~ YrxT [Tig o UW qw ZTig eiU[T i`~ h Ul xT b g
rUTWsUWiOXiThTU[cUTj[fTUgUW[iU~TY{UpTMg~uU~gT
]ip[T~XiWfT Vl[TUgp;U~TgLip[LUlTYwUs[lT~bWpLirUcT
Y~ixT[[x[TVig[Tisw`O`[[XiWfT[;USn~;USnh[T
gg`LmfgxhTUlTgYW{iVl[lY~ixT }fTO}lT
W[lTUlOT;UgUwiTbWpLsigU|i~UlLW;Ti]ggi[UUgxW
YUT}[TTYsTUWsTZitLU~WlgTgx[lTYwilYSU[WY]gcTZU`[T
YWiT [WUpL hT gTg`L O YWlYSUT iT O gT ZjU`[Zin[T [c VlUcT
gg`vsUTr~iW Xi iUsTYNiujT
U[~YiTVl[LLOYlUYTicpYSW~mUwgWixTUlTL{iUW
W U[iTgOUcw[igZUc[TIU]LiWTgTfggwYircTYgpUWl
~Ui{XiUTvSUsTilxTsUslT ]YtwgIUnO~SUTinWTcU`
Xj Ypfn gT [ Zx` YUlO ZUlZTiWfUO Xi`T T TwT
YgTYlTgTU[iUjgwT[cUixn[l
sUT O YSUT gT ZTgTg[T L Xgg`T gT i]T iUn[T v UcT ZT ~
YITTc[~n~{iUWgSUlT ;UiUx;UTiw Wi|TsTLg`YTicpT
OY~UrUW[[cT[TYSWTw;UgTiO ljwwUlTZiW`LYinWTLYSWT
ipcT U]TWlwUcTV{L~[ilLwW v[`Tw gTiT UpT
U~ Tig` kWc UlT x`[ [T ZU`[T Xj`T i]W ;Tgj lT bWpL
Xj`T Zi[T YgTZUxTYWnWVlUcTYwUlTiTgwx[[T[TWjU[T
x~gWY`iUfTYSWT[c~`U[cU i~[[TUi{}[TXj`LYrUiT
Yx`nZl~Zg`LXigUYTixTZU{TiTYti{YxlTuiTnU~fTgTO
ixnSUxTLilTsWTi[Tg` \cWi|TlTvVlU[Th U~IUWTw
i` hT [UW SUWL w [c kUT w | UW [Uc XgcUW Wi|T sTT
ZThTwgU[wTY[lTY`cWXiWl~hjU
VlL Y]gcT sT ZJ }iUT ] vilT sT Xj`L Y~U eWsUW Zi~[
kgf[l[WixTZWT~UWsZWTXglyi[gwXjU`TYxsTU[~Wi{
`[WiwlWYWi{ZU[Tgf[lTLUw[UcSTiWYWixTZTsXj`T
n~ZW]UUwilWi|TVl;Tg[YnxT}i{weWUsTb[i]T
W^RW^gRW^[RgSvR
WRganR~qSSUWRgvRWYRSl
qxW O jU`PW inL inWT lT Ylg Y` Uw Zj[iT [T xT f
inWsUnjiUinWTlT_g[[TYWs[TY`iTY`]TiUxT
Y`[UTLUYWcUpTYTixTY[TUnY`TYTicpTsU`T[Tv
OxlhTjT[Tc[UlSiU~gYTg[lY[T[[[cUw
WRganRWQURRgvRU^RhRYR
aU`Y[TssfU`T[[TUnTLXgcT[iTi[lTjT[TThwtUcTL
sW[iTSWTUtTc[YlTigV`YTicpTsUT~YTg[lTc[YTixTY[T
YSWT |n Y~g[lT ZUwU`T ~ gTi~ $GDSWDWLRQV Y[T YlT ZUWU`[lUW
&RQFHSW RI 3RSXODWLRQV Y`T ZUwU`T h Yw ggc[ Xgg`T YTixT
\c YinWT YSWT tT ] ZUx[`T klM[ YlUlT YWT iW[x[ [T (FRORJ\
YSWT ~ ;W[l iUn[T T Yic t[ Yc ZfTg[ ZUw f ;Ux UgTi~L wU[
ggc[OUgZUwU`Thil
; ] VU`TZUlWYU[TY~ixTLU YTicpT
ssf O in[ [T Yj Xi[~ f Yx[T 7ROHUDQFH /HYHOV c[T ZU[l
Y~U]T`cTggc[~[YwU`Tr /RFDO'LVWULEXWLRQ gTi~UTvj[T
hwpic[lLwUi|[cgiTlWUTvj[TsW[i
ZUwU`T YWTi ~ gf[l hT 7KH DJH VWUXFWXUH ixT Vi[T YlTig
U w oi~ZUxU` kiTg iwYS~ Y`Uc ggc[ h YUlT
ssfT iTiT hf[ b[ UW gxWT gT w YTixT Y[T Ysf T YicW x[
W[hTVlUTvTiU[fTYTixTY[TYsf~lLiT~Tvl[TgVUlc
c[[lpVUx[lTwXgg`TYTixTYSWTXig;UrLgg[TTh
glURjRgvReR
gi~ U~ ic[ [T Y~Ti|`T YcUlT +RPH 5DQJH [WT gT l[
ipUxT P~ WixT sT YWlUW YlT Y`lT [UsUn kiU YUlT YwU`T
LgW[ lT xT U ] XgUWxT igW LgW[ YTixT YSWT iWw U[T ic[ YWhU`T
fTg Yl~U YWhU` ipUw g` ~ Yl[T bi[T UL n[ ;U`ig[ [ YWhU`T YT
i~[TixTssf[TIU]LiUW[wT~vrhUi{YwThTjU[TXj`L]lT
U[ri~[T[jw`if[sn[wU[`Tl[[TYTixTYiUxTipUxT
YcinT l UWs ggc[l inWT lUW sW[iT gT Th YxT YipxT w
YUlT YicT W p g ipL ggc XiUlUW UlT sUW[iU~ Y~g[lT YwU[`T
~i[TLZUgfT jTiOTilUxsLUlY~UlpLggc[ YUT
[UcYliUYWlUTYfTgTZUcUlTUrLUT~YW{iTgUgxW
uSY^RqURgYRW^[R
gTi~L W sUW[iT pT[T c[ ~ YWixT gUW TixT ssf[T ~ Wi|T sT n~
Xi[lZUci`[hxWslYwU`TO[xWsWUlTgcTTv[`T
ZUw f w gwUl[ YS }it gU`O L f w gwUl j ssf[ipwgU`
ZUw it O gN U }iUx[T IUT w x[ UlT W Y Xj YwU[`T
vvWsUW YTicpT YSWUWUppfUIU[UW;Tixnf[Yj[Yc`UYwU[`T
ZUgfT i~ iU`[ ji c YlT ZTgcT v`[~ Y[ThT YppfT w tUcT
LLYlig cv[`[LLIU[YST}itTi~ZTk~YiirT
XgcYlTXiU`TZiW[wTsTThYWsT}itTfOgNYgp[c
gc ssf[TipxT 0LQLPXP7HUULWRULDO&RPPXQLW\ i|pYcUl
Ti`TWYYwU[`TZUwfwgwUlgYlTXiU`TY`~iWc[U~
YilTZUxTU~[[TYc`UYYwU[`TZUxTU~[[TZUx[`T
v[`Tw] YSUx`iUfTscTwkxhTYlU[YsWTi[YSUxT
gSvRRgvRlYR
[ ThO Uc ~ ipWT \[T O gN YlT i{ YlT YUlT ZU~ip[T L
U`TgxWTU~uTiYfrTYTixTZUwinTZU`U[cTY~UW[ZUp[T
YsUW iUxT TixT n[T ~ c[ inWT lT P~ U[UW UlO gxW
YTicpT
j[TwXigTgbWTgiTU~}MYU`TVT`TU~Vr[[TOYcUTYSWU~
U[wUWTnYgTr~jU`[gW YTicpTYSWT~bWT`TW
TgxT i~U[ Uf[ U isT n YiUxT jisT ~ XgSUlT YSTnxT ~T sfW
YU`TYlT[cUT;UcpYSliU]JUUITirfTZUcslT
W^YR
ZU`UcZUWs[c[wXigUWT[cZit[TYiUxTYssf[TkiTgTgx[
UrLvilTis[TYxYWTTUnTc YUOUgx[\gcTipxT~UlT
UcgiTTYxWsTYSWTwITg[wTY[TssfWgUp[TY`TwXigTgw
YxXgg`Y`ssfTlggyTiTThLgg`witZT
YgUTU`TUlYSTZUlTigTgTgwO~ic[T[
XSnYR
YTicpTsUUWYTiwY[uinXgU`TYgTSWTi]T[YlTiggTgwO
YppfT Ys [cT SWT iUT SWT NW[T STgWT iU[fO w gM[T v
YWiTsUTuin
UxU`Wi]TxYW[lTXitTiTiTwYig Y`i[ii[UWT
ggxTlT YwU[`TxYgTY`T
t^RgR
/RUHQ] .RQUDG = 6WXGLHV LQ $QLPDO DQG +XPDQ %HKDYLRU9RO +LOO
&RPSDQ\1<
+80$1%(+$9,25(1*,1((5,1*
(WKRORJLFDODQG(UJRQRPLFDO6WDQGDUGV0HHWLQJ
$UFKLWHFWXUDODQG7ULEDO3UREOHPVLQGHVHUW$UHDV
.+$/,/5$6+$'$/,
(QYLURQPHQWDO6WXGLHV6XSHUYLVRU
'$5$/205$1
$EVWUDFW 7KH 3\UDPLG RI WULEDO GHYHORSPHQW QHHGV PDLQO\ WKUHH EDVLFV WR EH
FRPSOHWHGWKRVHDUH
7KH KXPDQ EHLQJ HQYLURQPHQW DQG WKH WULEH +RZHYHU LW ZLOO QRW FRPSOHWH XQOHVV
HDFKEDVLFRIWKHDERYHLVHQRXJKVWURQJDQGORQJVXFKWKDWLWJRHVKDQGRQKDQGZLWK
RWKHUV*HWWLQJEHWWHUOLIHIRUPDQNLQGLVWKHUHVXOWRIWKHGHYHORSPHQWWKURXJKILQGLQJ
D ZHOOHVWDEOLVKHG HQYLURQPHQW WKDW FRPSRXQG ZLWK WKH QDWXUDO HQYLURQPHQW
DFKLHYLQJDQDFFHSWDEOHEDODQFHEHWZHHQWKRVHLWHPV
,Q PD\ SRLQW RI YLHZ WKH KXPDQ EHLQJ KDV QRW WDNHQ LQWR FRQVLGHUDWLRQ LQ WHUPV RI
VWXGLHV UHODWHG WR WULEDO GHYHORSPHQW )LQGLQJV SURYHG WKDW DV VRRQ DV WKH KXPDQ
DFWLYLW\ VWDUWHG WR XVH WKH WULEDO HOHPHQW WKHQ PDQ\ PDMRU FRUUHFWLRQV PDGH ZKLFK
FRQFOXGH WR YDULHW\ RI SUREOHPV RFFXS\LQJ GLIIHUHQW DXWKRULWLHV HIIRUWVFRQWLQXRXVO\
VRDVWRVXIILFLHQWVROXWLRQVFDSDEOHDOZD\V WRPHHWWDUJHWVRIWKHGHYHORSPHQW
7KHUHIRUH QHZ VWDQGDUGV DUH QHFHVVDU\ WR FRQQHFW KXPDQ DFWLYLW\ ZLWK SODQQLQJ DQG
RUJDQL]DWLRQHQJLQHHULQJ6RP\UHVHDUFKFRQFHQWUDWHVRQWZRDVSHFWVFRQWUROOLQJWKLV
DFWLYLW\WKHDVSHFWVDUH
(WKRORJ\ RULJLQDWHG IURP ]RRORJ\ WHPSRUDU\ DOWKRXJK , KDYH FDOO LW DV
+XPDQ %HLQJ %HKDYLRU (QJLQHHULQJ VLQFH KXPDQ DFWLYLW\ RULJLQDOO\ LV D
FROOHFWLRQRIJHQHWLFDOO\RUDFFHSWHGEHKDYLRUVIOH[LEOHIRUFKDQJLQJGHYHORSLQJ
DQG PRGLI\LQJ GLIIHUHQW VWDQGDUGV RI HQJLQHHULQJ LQ GHVLJQLQJ SURFHVV \LHOGLQJ
LQ D UHODWLRQ LOOXVWUDWHV KRZ FORVH WULEDO GHYHORSPHQW HOHPHQWV DQG WKH
GHYHORSPHQWRIKXPDQEHKDYLRU
(UJRQRPLFV FRQFHUQHG LQ PHDVXULQJ WKH ZRUN GRQH GXH WR EHKDYLRU RFFXSLHG
ZLWKLQLGHQWLFDODUFKLWHFWXUDOOHQJWKVRUVSDFHVDQGWKHLUVXLWVIRUFRQVXPHGHIIRUW
LQPDQDJLQJKXPDQDFWLYLW\WKURXJKEHKDYLRU
7KHUHIRUHZHFDQFDOOLWDV+XPDQ%HLQJ$FWLYLW\(QJLQHHULQJ
(WKRORJ\ DQG (UJRQRPLFV ZHUH WKHQ FRQQHFWHG WR D GHVHUW HQYLURQPHQW WKDW LV
FKDUDFWHUL]HG ZLWK XS QRUPDO FRQGLWLRQV LQ WHUPV RI FOLPDWH RU HFRORJ\ \LHOGLQJ D
W\SLFDODUFKLWHFWXUDODQGWULEDOPRGHOWKDWVDWLVILHVWKHUHTXLUHGEDODQFHEHWZHHQDUPV
RIWKHS\UDPLGRIWULEDOGHYHORSPHQWPHQWLRQHGDERYH