Israel's Attack on the USS Liberty

Questions By Justin Cowgill

On June 8, 1967, the armed forces of Israel attacked the American intelligence ship USS
Liberty for 90 minutes in international waters following several hours of close, low-level
reconnaissance. Israel was later to claim the attack was a mistake, a simple case of
misidentification, but survivors maintain otherwise. And some researchers contend that
the attack was a deliberate attempt to prevent US Intelligence from witnessing the
massacre of Egyptian Prisoners Of War.
According to eyewitness accounts by Israeli officers and journalists, the Israeli Army
executed as many as 1,000 Arab POW's during the 1967 war. Historian Gabby Bron
wrote in the Yediot Ahronot in Israel that he witnessed Israeli troops executing Egyptian
prisoners on the morning of June 8, 1967, in the Sinai town of El Arish.
Bron reported that he saw about 150 Egyptian POWs being held at the El Arish airport
where they were sitting on the ground, densely crowded together with their hands held on
the back of their necks. Every few minutes, Bron writes, Israeli soldiers would escort an
Egyptian POW from the group to a hearing conducted by two men in Israeli army
uniforms. Then the man would be taken away, given a spade, and forced to dig his own
grave.
"I watched as (one) man dug a hole for about 15 minutes,?Bron wrote. afterwards, the
(Israeli military) policeman told him to throw the shovel away, and then one of them
leveled an Uzi at him and shot two short bursts, each of three or four bullets.?
Bron says he witnessed about ten such executions, until the grave was filled. Then an
Israeli Colonel threatened him with a revolver, forcing him to leave the area.
As these executions were underway, America's most sophisticated intelligence platform,
USS Liberty, was less than 13 miles from El Arish.
Could the USS Liberty have intercepted voice radio messages authorising these killings?
Did senior Israeli officers sanction the murders, or did they learn of them? How would
they have reacted to the knowledge that USS Liberty was nearby and might have heard
incriminating radio traffic?
We may never know because Israel, America's Ally,?launched a murderous attack on the
virtually unarmed American intelligence ship.
To this day, many Americans are unaware that this attack even took place. But recently,
PRAVDA.Ru took the opportunity to interview Mr. Hrankowski, a survivor and crew
member of the USS Liberty.
Greetings Mr. Hrankowski! We at PRAVDA.Ru greatly appreciate this exclusive
interview. We feel that, as a USS Liberty survivor, you are in the unique position to shed

light on actually what happened and why. It is a great tragedy that 34 young American
sailors died while serving their country. It is an even greater tragedy that the general
public knows next to nothing about this event.
What position did you serve on the USS Liberty?
My position on the USS Liberty was in the Engineering Department. I was a boilerman. I
also worked for the chief engineer in the log room office.
One of the main questions regarding this attack is whether or not the Israeli attackers
knew that they were attacking an American ship. The Israelis have claimed that they
misidentified the Liberty for the Egyptian horse carrier El Quseir, but it has been
reported that the USS liberty flew an American flag and was distinctly marked with US
markings. It is also known that slow moving recon plans flew over the USS Liberty
numerous times. Is there any doubt in your mind that the Israeli military knew that they
were attacking an American ship?
There is no doubt in my mind that the Israeli attack on the USS Liberty was deliberate.
Israel has claimed that it was a mistake and that they were firing upon an Arab horse
freighter. The El Quesir was the name of the Arab ship. It was tied up and not sea worthy
during the Six Day War, and the Israelis knew this.
As for our Flag. All American ships fly the flag. Ours was flying until the Israelis shot it
down and within seconds another was put up. It was our holiday Ensign, sized 9 feet by
13 feet.
As for the slow moving aircraft. Planes started flying over us and checking us out at
5:30am and did so 9 to 13 times until the attack at 2:00PM. There is no doubt in my mind
that they knew who they were attacking.
It has been reported that the USS Saratago, responding to a SOS from the Liberty,
launched jets to help the Liberty approximately 15 minutes into the Israeli attack. Why
were the jets recalled? One could say that this act left American sailors to be murdered
by an enemy force?
A message from the USS Liberty got to the USS Saratoga 9 minutes into the attack. The
USS Saratoga launched a flight of fighters immediately and they were called back. This
happened three different times throughout the attack. Robert MacNamara called them
back twice, and President Johnson called them back once, saying his thoughts were not
for the USS Liberty. He did not want to embarrass his ally Israel. That act did leave us to
get murdered, and what it actually is called is abandonment.
Once your captain, William Loren McGonagle, realized that the Liberty was in danger of
sinking, he ordered the crew to abandon ship. At this point, there were only three life rafts
left that weren't damaged. Your crew placed as many wounded into the life rafts and
lowered them over the side of the Liberty. Please tell us what happened next.

The order was given by the captain to abandon ship, because he thought we were going to
sink. Three life rafts were in the water, but then Israeli Torpedo boats came up to them
and shot two of them up and grabbed one on the boats. That is against the Geneva
Convention.
What prompted the Israelis to terminate their assault?
I'm not sure what caused them to terminate the attack, but after 2 hours, they could not
sink us. I would think that their time had run out.
How long did it take for American help to arrive?
It took 16 hours for the American fleet to get to us. But that night, while we were sailing
to the sixth fleet, a Soviet ship offered help to us. They said that they would stay just at
the horizon and if our ship was going to go down, they would help us.
In a recent letter to President Bush, survivor Phillip F. Tourney claimed that the crew of
the USS Liberty were ordered to remain silent under threat of court martial,
imprisonment, or worse, and we all know what worst meant.?Did you yourself
experience such threats?
Admiral Kidd was the one who ordered us silent. That was a direct order to all of the
crew. I heard it myself that day.
If what has been reported is true, the Israeli attack on the USS Liberty can only be
described as deliberate. In your opinion, why did this attack take place?
As for why the Israelis attacked us, I'm not sure. I would not be able to give you a reason,
because it would only be a guess. There is a new film out by the BBC called Dead in the
Water. It was released in England on 6-10-02 and it gives some startling new evidence as
to why the attack happened.
Has the American government considered reinvestigating the attack?
There are a few Congressional personal interested in helping us. We're hoping that they
are really willing.
It would seem that this event has been covered up. Given all the information that has
come forth and the testimony of such people as Secretary of State Dean Rusk and former
JCS Chairman Admiral Thomas Moorer, the version that this attack was a mistake is very
hard believe, which means that it was covered up for some reason. Why, in your opinion,
was such a tragic event as an attack on US sailors covered up?
You ask if the USS Liberty attack was covered up. My answer is simple: yes, it was. The
question still remains today as to why. And with a Congressional Investigation, all the

facts should be laid out and the reasons known.

Your commanding officer, Captain William Loren McGonagle, received the
Congressional Medal of Honor for his services to his country. However, unlike tradition,
when the president of the United States bestows the Congressional Medal of Honor,
Captain McGonagle was awarded his medal in the Washington Navy Yard. In your
opinion, why wasn't your captain awarded the medal according to tradition?
Our Captain did receive the Congressional Medal of Honor but not in the White house
like it usually is given, but in a shipyard in Washington DC. Not many of us knew that he
got it until many years later. On his written citation, there is no mention that Israel was
the attackers. The same goes for all of our medals and citations; the Israelis are not
mentioned at all.
In your opinion, if the general American public were to become fully aware of Israel's
attack on the Liberty, could this affect the special relationship that America shares with
its ally Israel? For instance, if many Americans learned of the attack and the cover-up,
they might be less willing to bankroll Israel with financial and military aid.
I'm not sure if that would happen. I think that if the truth be known about the attack it
would hurt for a little while, but it would be a piece of history finally put to bed.
Do you keep in contact with fellow Liberty survivors? If so, do they express hope that
American will reinvestigate the attack?
We USS Liberty survivors are always in contact. We all fight for the same thing. They
want the investigation to happen soon, so we can all go on with our lives.
Is there anything else that you would like to add?
I thank PRAVDA.Ru for the time to express my views of the June 8, 1967 attack on my
ship, the USS Liberty. I do hope your country will be able to see the new film by the
BBC Dead in the Water by Mr. Christopherer Mitchell. There is also a new book that
goes along with the new film. It was written by Pulitzer Prize winner Mr. Peter Hounam
and is due to come out very shortly. The film and book open the incident up very well.
http://english.pravda.ru/main/2002/07/04/31794.html