h'ENERATION&LASHvINCORPORATESREVISEDVERSIONS
OFTHETEXTSCOMMISSIONEDFORWWWWHITNEYBIENNIAL
COMANDHTTPWWWELECTRONICORPHANAGECOMBIEN
NALE"OTHEXHIBITIONSWEREORGANIZEDBY-ILTOS-ANE
TAS%LECTRONIC/RPHANAGEh/N54/0)!vWASCOMMIS
SIONEDBY&UTUREFARMERS

'ENERATION&LASH
,EV-ANOVICH

4HISARTICLEISABOUTh&LASH'ENERATIONvANDNOT
ABOUTTHE7EBSITESMADEWITH&LASHSOFTWARE-ANY
OFTHESITESWHICHINSPIREDMETOCONSIDERh&LASHAES
THETICSvARENOTNECESSARILYMADEWITH&LASH4HEYUSE
3HOCKWAVE$(4-,1UICKTIMEANDOTHERMULTIMEDIA
7EBFORMATS4HUSTHEQUALITIES)DESCRIBEINTHISTEXT
ASBEINGSPECIFICTOh&LASHAESTHETICSvARENOTUNIQUETO
&LASHSITES
&ORINSTANCETHEWORKOF,ISA*EVBRATT*OHN3IMON
AND'OLAN,EVIN



'%.%2!4)/.&,!3(
,EV-ANOVICH















































4HEDIFFERENTSECTIONSOFTHISESSAYEXAMINETHEPHENOMENONOF
&LASHGRAPHICSONTHE7EBWHICHHASATTRACTEDALOTOFCREATIVETALENT
OVERTHEPASTFEWYEARS&LASHAESTHETICSAREMUCHMORETHANTHEPROD
UCTOFAPARTICULARSOFTWAREHARDWARECONlGURATIONLOWBANDWIDTH
LEADING TO THE USE OF VECTOR GRAPHICS  4HEY EXEMPLIFY THE CULTURAL
SENSIBILITYOFANEWGENERATION4HISGENERATIONDOESNOTCAREIFITS
WORKISCALLEDARTORDESIGN)TSREPRESENTATIVESARENOLONGERINTERESTED
INTHEhMEDIACRITIQUEvTHATHASPREOCCUPIEDMEDIAARTISTSFORTHEPAST
TWODECADES)NSTEADTHEYAREENGAGEDINASOFTWARECRITIQUE)NSTEAD
OFSAMPLINGCOMMERCIALMEDIATHEYWRITESOFTWARECODEINORDERTO
CREATETHEIROWNCULTURALSYSTEMS4HERESULTISANEWMODERNISMOF
DATAVISUALIZATIONSVECTORNETSPIXEL THINGRIDSANDARROWS"AUHAUS
DESIGNINTHESERVICEOFINFORMATIONDESIGN2EPLACINGTHEBAROQUEAS
SAULTOFCOMMERCIALMEDIATHE&LASHGENERATIONDISHESUPMODERNIST
AESTHETICSANDTHERATIONALITYOFSOFTWARE)TUSESINFORMATIONDESIGN
ASATOOLTOMAKESENSEOFREALITYANDTRANSFORMSPROGRAMMINGINTOA
TOOLOFEMPOWERMENT




3EEHTTPWWWPOTATOLANDORGLANDFILL


4URNTABLEAND&LASH2EMIXING
FORWWWWHITNEYBIENNIALCOM

4URNTABLEISA7EB BASEDSOFTWARETHATALLOWSUSERSTOMIXUPTO
SIXDIFFERENT&LASHANIMATIONSINREALTIME5SERSCANALSOMODIFYTHE
COLORPALETTETHESIZEOFINDIVIDUALANIMATIONSANDOTHERPARAMETERS
4HEARTISTSPARTICIPATINGINWWWWHITNEYBIENNIALCOMWEREINVITEDTO
SUBMITSHORT&LASHANIMATIONS4HESEWEREEXHIBITEDONTHESITEBOTH
SEPARATELYANDASPARTOF4URNTABLEREMIXES3OMEREMIXESCONSISTED
OFANUMBEROFANIMATIONSBYTHESAMEARTISTWHILEOTHERSUSEDANI
MATIONSBYDIFFERENTARTISTS

)THASBECOMEACLICHTOSAYTHAThWELIVEINAREMIXCULTUREv3URE
WEDO"UTISNTITPOSSIBLETOGOBEYONDTHISSIMPLESTATEMENTOFFACT
&OR INSTANCE CAN WE DISTINGUISH BETWEEN DIFFERENT REMIX AESTHETICS
7HAT IS THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN REMIXES MADE WITH ELECTRONIC AND
COMPUTERTOOLSANDEARLIERFORMSSUCHASCOLLAGESANDMONTAGES7HAT
ARETHESIMILARITIESANDDIFFERENCESBETWEENAUDIOANDVISUALREMIXES
4HINK LOOP !S THE BASIC BUILDING BLOCK OF AN ELECTRONIC SOUND
TRACKTHELOOPHASASSUMEDASURPRISINGLYSTRONGPOSITIONINCONTEM
PORARYVISUALCULTURE7HENLEFTTOTHEIROWNDEVICES&LASHANIMATIONS
1UICK4IME MOVIES AND THE CHARACTERS IN COMPUTER GAMES WILL LOOP
ENDLESSLYnORUNTILTHEUSERINTERVENESWITHACLICK!S)HAVESHOWN
ELSEWHEREALLNINETEENTHCENTURYPRE CINEMATICVISUALDEVICES RELIED
ONLOOPS4HROUGHOUTTHENINETEENTHCENTURYTHESELOOPSKEPTGETTING
LONGER AND LONGER n EVENTUALLY TURNING INTO A FEATURE NARRATIVE
4ODAYWEAREWITNESSINGAMOVEINTHEOPPOSITEDIRECTIONARTISTSARE
SAMPLINGSHORTSEGMENTSOFFEATURElLMSOR46SHOWSARRANGINGTHEMAS
LOOPSANDEXHIBITINGTHESELOOPSAShVIDEOINSTALLATIONSv4HELOOPHAS
BECOMETHENEWDEFAULTMETHODFORCRITIQUINGMEDIACULTUREREPLACING
THESTILLPHOTOGRAPHUSEDINTHEPOST MODERNCRITIQUESOFTHES!T
THESAMETIMETHELOOPHASSUPERSEDEDTHESTILLPHOTOGRAPHASTHENEW
INDEXOFTHEREALSINCEWEALLKNOWTHATASTILLPHOTOGRAPHCANBEDIGI
TALLYMANIPULATEDITAPPEARSTHATASHORTMOVINGSEQUENCEARRANGED
INALOOPISABETTERWAYOFREPRESENTINGREALITYFORTHETIMEBEING 

4HINK )NTERNET 4HE PHENOMENON THAT IN POST MODERN TIMES

WASREFERREDTOAShQUOTINGvhAPPROPRIATIONvANDhPASTICHEvNOWNO
LONGERREQUIRESANYSPECIALNAME)TISSIMPLYTHEBASICLOGICOFCUL
TURALPRODUCTIONDOWNLOADIMAGESCODESHAPESSCRIPTSETCMODIFY
THEMPASTETHENEWWORKSONLINEnCIRCULATETHEM.OTEONTHE)N
TERNETTHEALWAYSEXISTINGLOOPOFCULTURALPRODUCTIONISMUCHFASTER
ANEWTRENDORSTYLEMAYSPREADOVERNIGHTLIKEAPLAGUE 7HEN)ASK
MYSTUDENTSTOCREATETHEIROWNIMAGESBYTAKINGPHOTOGRAPHSORBY
SHOOTING VIDEO THEY HAVE A REVELATION IMAGES DO NOT HAVE TO COME
FROMTHE)NTERNET
3HALL)ALSOREVEALTOTHEMTHATIMAGESDONOTHAVE
TOCOMEFROMATECHNOLOGICALDEVICETHATRECORDSREALITYTHATTHEYCAN
BEDRAWNORPAINTEDINSTEAD
4HINKIMAGE!NDCOMPAREITTOSOUND)TSEEMSPOSSIBLETOLAYER
ALARGENUMBEROFSOUNDSANDTRACKSWHILEMAINTAININGLEGIBILITY4HE
RESULTSBECOMEINCREASINGLYCOMPLEXANDINCREASINGLYINTERESTING6I
SIONSEEMSTOBEWORKINGDIFFERENTLYTHESEDAYS/FCOURSETHECOM
MERCIALIMAGESTHATWESEEEVERYDAYON46ANDINTHECINEMAOFTEN
CONSISTOFMANYLAYERSASWELLSOMETIMESRUNNINGINTOTHETHOUSANDS
BUTTHESELAYERSWORKTOGETHERTOCREATEASINGLEILLUSIONISTICORSUPER
ILLUSIONISTIC SPACE )N OTHER WORDS THEY ARE NOT BEING PERCEIVED AS
SEPARATEIMAGES7HENWESTARTMIXINGARBITRARYIMAGESTOGETHERWE
QUICKLYDESTROYANYMEANING)FYOUNEEDPROOFOFTHISJUSTVISITTHE
CLASSIC$IGITAL,ANDlLLSITE (OWMANYSEPARATEIMAGETRACKSCAN
BEMIXEDBEFORETHECOMPOSITEBECOMESNOTHINGBUTNOISE3IXSEEMS
THERIGHTNUMBERnWHICHISEXACTLYTHENUMBEROFIMAGETRACKSYOU
CANLOADONTO4URNTABLE
4HINKSAMPLEVERSUSENTIREWORK)FWEAREINDEEDLIVINGINARE
MIXCULTUREDOESITSTILLMAKESENSETOCREATEWHOLEWORKSnIFTHESE
WORKSWILLBETAKENAPARTANDTURNEDINTOSAMPLESBYOTHERSANYWAY
)NDEED WHY PAINSTAKINGLY ADJUST THE SEPARATE TRACKS OF A $IRECTOR
MOVIEORAN!FTER%FFECTSCOMPOSITIONWHYTRYTOGETITJUSTRIGHTIF
THEhPUBLICvISJUSTGOINGTOUSESOMEFREESOFTWARETOhOPENSOURCEv
THEMINTOTHEIRINDIVIDUALTRACKSANYWAY/FCOURSETHEANSWERISYES
WESTILLNEEDART7ESTILLWANTTOSAYSOMETHINGABOUTTHEWORLDAND
OURLIVESINIT7ESTILLNEEDOUROWNhMIRRORSTANDINGINTHEMIDDLE

'ENERATION&LASH
,EV-ANOVICH

!FTER'5) BASEDAPPLICATIONSSUCHAS(YPERCARD
$IRECTOR0HOTOSHOPANDOTHERSBECAMECOMMONPLACE
MANYCOMPUTERARTISTSCONTINUEDTODOTHEIROWN
PROGRAMMINGWRITINGCUSTOMCODETOCONTROLANINTER
ACTIVEINSTALLATIONPROGRAMMINGANINTERACTIVEMULTI
MEDIAWORKIN,).'/ETC4HISWASNOTREFERREDTOAS
SOFTWAREART)TWASTAKENFORGRANTEDTHATEVENINTHE
AGEOF'5) BASEDAPPLICATIONSAREALLYSERIOUSARTISTIC
ENGAGEMENTWITHCOMPUTERSREQUIRESGETTINGONESHANDS
DIRTYWITHCODE


OFADIRTYROADvAS3TENDAHLDElNEDARTINTHENINETEENTHCENTURY9ET
WEALSONEEDTOACCEPTTHATFOROTHERSOURWORKWILLBEJUSTASETOF
SAMPLES OR MAYBE JUST ONE SAMPLE 4URNTABLE IS THE VISUAL SOFTWARE
THATMAKESTHISNEWAESTHETICCONDITIONPAINFULLYOBVIOUS)TINVITES
USTOPLAYWITHTHEDIALECTICOFTHESAMPLEANDTHECOMPOSITETHEIN
TERPLAYBETWEENOUROWNWORKSANDTHEWORKSOFOTHERS7ELCOMETO
VISUALREMIXING&LASHSTYLE
4HINK4URNTABLE




























!RT-EDIA!RTAND3OFTWARE!RT
2ECENTLYhSOFTWAREARTvHASEMERGEDASTHEDYNAMICNEWlELDIN
THENEWMEDIAARTS&LASHS!CTION3CRIPT$IRECTORS,INGO0ERL-!8
*AVA3CRIPT*AVA#ANDOTHERPROGRAMMINGANDSCRIPTINGLANGUAG
ESARETHEMEDIUMOFCHOICEFORASTEADILYINCREASINGNUMBEROFYOUNG
ARTISTS4HEMATICALLYSOFTWAREARTOFTENDEALSWITHDATAVISUALIZATION
/THER AREAS OF CREATIVE ACTIVITY INCLUDE THE TOOLS FOR ONLINE COLLAB
ORATIVEPERFORMANCECOMPOSITION EYSTROKE $*6*SOFTWAREAND
ALTERNATIVES TOCRITIQUES OF COMMERCIAL SOFTWARE !UTO )LLUSTRATOR 
ESPECIALLYTHEBROWSERSEARLYCLASSICSLIKE.ETOMAT7EB3TALKERAND
MANY OTHERS THAT HAVE EMERGED SINCE THEN  /FTEN THESE ARTISTS CRE
ATENOTSINGULARWORKSBUTSOFTWAREENVIRONMENTSOPENFOROTHERSTO
USE SUCH AS!LEX 'ALLOWAYSh#ARNIVOREv  3TYLISTICALLY MANY WORKS
IMPLICITLYREFERENCEVISUALMODERNISM*OHN3IMONSEEMSTOBETHE
ONLY ONE SO FAR WHO HAS EXPLICITLY WOVEN MODERNIST REFERENCES INTO
HISWORKS 
3UDDENLYPROGRAMMINGISCOOL3UDDENLYTHETECHNIQUESANDIM
AGERYTHATFORTWODECADESWEREASSOCIATEDWITH3)''2!0(GEEKNESS
ANDBADTASTETHEVISUALOUTPUTOFMATHEMATICALFUNCTIONSPARTICLE
SYSTEMS THE 2'" COLOR PALETTE ARE A WELCOME SIGHT ON THE PLASMA
SCREENS OF GALLERY WALLS )T IS NO LONGER /CTOBER AND 7ALLPAPER BUT
&LASHAND$IRECTORMANUALSTHATAREREQUIREDREADINGFORANYSERIOUS
YOUNGARTIST
/FCOURSECOMPUTERARTISTSHAVEBEENWRITINGTHEIROWNSOFTWARE
SINCE THE DISCIPLINES EARLY DAYS IN THE  S )N FACT UNTIL THE MID
STHEONLYWAYTOMAKECOMPUTERARTWASTOWRITESOFTWAREORAT
LEASTUSESPECIALVERYHIGH ENDPROGRAMMINGLANGUAGESDESIGNEDBY
OTHERSSUCHAS:GRASS 3OWHATSDIFFERENTABOUTTHERECENTPHE
NOMENONOFSOFTWAREART!NDISITNECESSARY
,ETSDISTINGUISHTHREElGURESTHEARTISTTHEMEDIAARTISTANDTHE
SOFTWAREARTIST






)NTHENINETEENTHCENTURYANDTHElRSTHALFOFTHETWENTIETHCEN
TURYTHEROMANTICMODERNIST ARTISTWASVIEWEDASAGENIUSWHOCRE
ATEDFROMSCRATCHANDIMPOSEDTHEPHANTOMSOFHISIMAGINATIONON
THEWORLD
7ITH MEDIA ARTISTS A NEW lGURE ARRIVED ON THE SCENE IN THE
 SnS CORRESPONDING TO THE POST MODERNIST PERIOD  /F
COURSEMODERNISTARTISTSALSOUSEDMEDIARECORDINGTECHNOLOGIESSUCH
ASPHOTOGRAPHYANDlLMBUTTHEYTREATEDTHESETECHNOLOGIESTHESAME
WAYTHEYDIDOTHERARTISTICTOOLSASAMEANSOFCREATINGANORIGINALAND
SUBJECTIVEVIEWOFTHEWORLD)NCONTRASTPOST MODERNMEDIAARTISTS
ACCEPTTHEIMPOSSIBILITYOFANORIGINALUNMEDIATEDVISIONOFREALITY
THEIRSUBJECTMATTERISNOTREALITYITSELFBUTTHEREPRESENTATIONOFREAL
ITYBYMEDIAANDTHEWORLDOFMEDIA4HEREFORETHESEMEDIAARTISTS
NOT ONLY USE MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AS TOOLS THEY ALSO APPROPRIATE THE
CONTENT OF COMMERCIAL MEDIA! TYPICAL MEDIA ART STRATEGY IS TO RE
PHOTOGRAPH A NEWSPAPER PHOTOGRAPH TO RE EDIT A SEGMENT OF A 46
SHOWORTOISOLATEASCENEFROMA(OLLYWOODlLM46SHOWANDTURN
ITINTOALOOPCONSIDERTHEWORKOF.AM*UNE0AIK$ARA"IRNBAUM
$OUGLAS'ORDON0AUL0FFEFER*ENNIFERAND EVIN-C#OY .ATURALLY
A MEDIA ARTIST DOES NOT HAVE TO USE COMMERCIAL MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES
PHOTOGRAPHYlLMVIDEONEWMEDIA 3HECANALSOUSEOTHERMEDIA
FROMOILPAINTTOPRINTINGTOSCULPTURE
4HEMEDIAARTISTISAPARASITEWHOLIVESOFFCOMMERCIALMEDIAn
THATISOFFTHECOLLECTIVECRAFTSMANSHIPOFHIGHLYSKILLEDPEOPLE)NAD
DITIONANARTISTWHOSAMPLESFROMSUBVERTSPOKESFUNATCOMMERCIAL
MEDIACANULTIMATELYNEVERCOMPETEWITHTHEM)NSTEADOFAFEATURE
lLMWEGETASINGLESCENEINSTEADOFACOMPLEXCOMPUTERGAMEWITH
PLAYABILITYNARRATIVE!)ETCWEGETACRITIQUEOFITSICONOGRAPHY
4HIRTYYEARSOFMEDIAARTANDPOST MODERNISMHAVEINEVITABLYLED
TOACOUNTER MOVEMENT7EARETIREDOFTAKINGTHEEXISTINGMEDIAAS
ASTARTINGPOINT7EARETIREDOFBEINGSECONDARYANDONLYREACTINGTO
WHATALREADYEXISTS




%NTERTHESOFTWAREARTISTnTHENEWROMANTIC)NSTEADOFWORKING
EXCLUSIVELYWITHCOMMERCIALMEDIAINSTEADOFUSINGCOMMERCIALSOFT
WARETHESOFTWAREARTISTLEAVESHISHERMARKONTHEWORLDBYWRITING
THEORIGINALCODE4HISACTOFCODEWRITINGISHIGHLYSIGNIlCANTREGARD
LESSOFWHATTHISCODEACTUALLYDOESINTHEEND
! SOFTWARE ARTIST RE USES THE LANGUAGE OF MODERNIST ABSTRACTION
ANDDESIGNLINESGEOMETRICSHAPESMATHEMATICALLYGENERATEDCURVES
ANDOUTLINEDCOLORlELDS TOGETAWAYFROMBOTHlGURATIONINGENERAL
ANDTHECINEMATOGRAPHICLANGUAGEOFCOMMERCIALMEDIAINPARTICULAR
)NSTEADOFPHOTOGRAPHSANDlLM46CLIPSWEGETLINESANDABSTRACT
COMPOSITIONS)NSHORTINSTEADOF1UICK4IMEWEGET&LASH)NSTEADOF
THECOMPUTERASAMEDIAMACHINEAVISIONHEAVILYPROMOTEDBYTHE
COMPUTERINDUSTRYANDMOSTCLEARLYARTICULATEDBY!PPLEINTHEIRPRO
MOTIONOFTHE-ACASAhDIGITALHUBvFOROTHERMEDIARECORDINGPLAY
INGDEVICES WElNDOURWAYBACKTOTHECOMPUTERASAPROGRAMMING
MACHINE
0ROGRAMMING LIBERATES ART FROM ITS SECONDARY STATUS VIS VIS
COMMERCIALMEDIA4HERECENTPOPULARITYOFhSOUNDARTvPROBABLYHAS
ASIMILARBACKGROUND7HILECOMMERCIALMEDIANOWMAKEUSEOFEV
ERY POSSIBLE VISUAL STYLE COMMERCIAL SOUND ENVIRONMENTS STILL HAVE
NOTAPPROPRIATEDSOUNDSPACEINITSENTIRETY!LTHOUGHROCKANDROLL
HIP HOP AND TECHNO HAVE ALREADY BECOME STANDARD ELEVATOR MUSIC
ATLEASTINTHEMOREHIPELEVATORSINPLACESLIKETHE(UDSON(OTELIN
.9# ITSEEMSTHATTHERHYTHM LESSREGIONSOFSOUNDSPACEARESTILL
UNTOUCHEDnATLEASTFORNOW











'ENERATION&LASH
,EV-ANOVICH


54/0)!IN3HOCKWAVE

54/0)!ISA3HOCKWAVEPROJECTBY&UTUREFARMERSFORTHE)NTERNET
SECTIONOFTHE4IRANA"IENNALE&UTUREFARMERS!MY&RANCESCHINI
AND3ASCHA-ERG52,HTTPNUTRISHNIAORGLEVEL

54/0)!ISPLAYFULYETDECEITFULPRETENDINGTOBEMOREINNOCENT
SIMPLERANDLIGHTERTHANITACTUALLYIS!TlRSTGLANCEWEMIGHTMISTAKE
ITFORSOMETHINGMADEFORCHILDRENnORFORADULTSWHOSEPOINTSOFREF
ERENCEARENOT ARL-ARX3IGMUND&REUD2EM OOLHAASAND0HILIP
3TARKBUTTEXTMESSAGING'NUTTELARETRO!TARIGRAPHICSANDNETTIME
4HISISTHENEWSGENERATIONOFARTISTS)NCONTRASTTOTHEVISUAL
ANDMEDIAARTISTSOFTHE SnSWHOTOOKAIMATMEDIAADS
CINEMATELEVISION THISNEWGENERATIONDOESNOTWASTEITSENERGYON
ANYMEDIACRITIQUE)NSTEADOFBASHINGTHECOMMERCIALMEDIAENVI
RONMENTITCREATESITSOWN7EBSITESMIXESSOFTWARETOOLSFURNITURE
CLOVESDIGITALVIDEO&LASH3HOCKWAVEANIMATIONSANDINTERACTIVES
4HENEWSENSIBILITYTHAT5TOPIAEXEMPLIlESSOWELLISSOFTELEGANT
RESTRAINEDANDSMART4HISISTHENEWSOFTWAREINTELLIGENTSIA,OOKAT
THETHINLOW CONTRASTLINESOF54/0)!PRAYSTATIONCOMANDSOMANY
&LASHPROJECTSFEATUREDATTHE4IRANA"IENNALE7HEREASTHEIMAGES
BY THE PREVIOUS GENERATION OF MEDIA ARTISTS n FROM .AM *UNE 0AIK
TO"ARBARA RUEGERnSCREAMEDATTHETOPOFTHEIRLUNGSANDTRIEDTO
COMPETEWITHTHEINTENSITYOFCOMMERCIALMEDIATHENEWDATAARTISTS
SUCHAS&RANCESCHINI-ERGWHISPERINOUREARS)NCONTRASTTOMEDIA
ARROGANCETHEYOFFERUSINTELLIGENCE)NCONTRASTTOTHEMEDIASTREAM
OFENDLESSLYREPEATEDICONSANDSOUNDBYTESTHEYOFFERUSSMALLAND
ECONOMICAL SYSTEMS STYLIZED NATURE ECOLOGY AND THE GAMEMUSIC
GENERATOR,EGO LIKEPARADEIN54/0)!
&UTUREFARMERSAREAMONGTHEFEW&LASH3HOCKWAVEMASTERSWHO
USETHEIRSKILLSFORSOCIALRATHERTHANSIMPLYFORMALENDS4HEIRPROJECT
hTHEYRULENETvISASHININGEXAMPLEOFTHEWAYSSMARTPROGRAMMING
ANDSMARTGRAPHICSCANBEUSEDFORPOLITICALENDS)NSTEADOFPRESENT
INGAPACKAGEDPOLITICALMESSAGETHEPROJECTGIVESUSDATAANDTOOLSTO
ANALYZETHISMESSAGE)TKNOWSTHATWEAREINTELLIGENTENOUGHTODRAW

THERIGHTCONCLUSIONS4HISISTHENEWRHETORICOFINTERACTIVITYWEARE
CONVINCEDNOTBYLISTENINGORWATCHINGAPREPAREDMESSAGEBUTBYAC
TIVELYWORKINGWITHDATAREORGANIZINGITUNCOVERINGTHECONNECTIONS
BECOMINGAWAREOFCORRELATIONS
54/0)! DOES NOT HAVE AN EXPLICIT POLITICAL CONTENT )NSTEAD IT
CONVEYSITSMESSAGETHROUGHAVISUALALLEGORY,IKE3IM#ITYANDSIMI
LAR3IMSTHEPROGRAMPRESENTSUSWITHANENTIREMINIATUREWORLDTHAT
OPERATESACCORDINGTOITSOWNSYSTEMOFRULES!LLTHEANIMATIONIN
54/0)!ISTHERESULTOFCODEEXECUTIONnNOTHINGISHAND ANIMATED
4HECOSMOGONYOFTHISWORLDREmECTSOURNEWUNDERSTANDINGOFOUR
OWNPOST #OLD7ARPLANETDOMINATEDBYSUCHTHEMESASTHE)NTERNET
ECOLOGY'AIAANDGLOBALIZATION.OTICETHETHINBARELYVISIBLELINES
THATCONNECTTHEACTORSANDTHEBLOCKS4HISISTHESAMEDEVICEUSED
INTHEYRULENET )NTHEUNIVERSEOF54/0)!EVERYTHINGISINTERCON
NECTED AND EACH ACTION BY AN INDIVIDUAL ACTOR AFFECTS THE SYSTEM AS
AWHOLE)NTELLECTUALLYWEKNOWTHATTHISISHOWOUR%ARTHFUNCTIONS
ECOLOGICALLYANDECONOMICALLYBUT54/0)!REPRESENTSTHISFUNCTION
ALITYONASCALEWECANPERCEIVEANDGRASP



















4HELINESALSOSERVEANOTHERPURPOSE$ESPITE#..'REENPEACE
THEGLASSROOFOF"ERLINS2EICHSTAGANDOTHERINSTITUTIONSANDDEVICES
INTENDED TO MAKE THE INNER WORKINGS OF MODERN SOCIETIES TRANSPAR
ENTTOTHEIRCITIZENSMOSTOFITISNOTVISIBLE4HISISNOTONLYBECAUSE
WEDON@TKNOWTHEMOTIVESBEHINDTHISORTHATGOVERNMENTPOLICYOR
BECAUSEADVERTISINGAND02CONSTANTLYMAKETHINGSAPPEARDIFFERENT
FROMHOWTHEYREALLYARE4HEWAYSINWHICHSOCIETIESFUNCTIONARENOT
VISIBLEINANYLITERALSENSE&ORINSTANCEWEDONTKNOWWHERETOlND
THEhCELLSvTHATMAKEOURCELLPHONESWORKWEDONTKNOWTHEEXACT
STRUCTUREOFTHEPRIVATElNANCIALNETWORKTHATENCIRCLESTHEEARTHWE
DONTKNOWWHATCOMPANIESARELOCATEDINTHEBUILDINGSTHATWEPASS
ONOURWAYTOWORKEVERYDAYANDSOON"UTIN54/0)!WEDOKNOW
BECAUSETHELINKSAREMADEVISIBLE54/0)!ISAUTOPIABECAUSEITISA
SOCIETYWHERECAUSEANDEFFECTARERENDEREDTRANSPARENTANDCOMPRE
HENSIBLE4HEPROGRAMRE WRITES-ARXISMASVECTORGRAPHICSITSUBSTI
TUTESTHElGUREOFhCONNECTIONSvFORTHEOLDlGUREOFhUNVEILINGv
54/0)!ISSERIOUSBUSINESSBEHINDAPLAYFULFAADEnBUTITSNOT
ALLBUSINESS54/0)!ISAVISUALANDINTELLECTUALDELIGHTTHATDRAWSON
THECURRENTFASCINATIONWITHCOMPUTERGAMESANDINTERACTIVEIMAGE
SOUNDSOFTWARE)TIS4ETRISMEETS-ARXMEETSDATAMININGMEETSTHE
CLUBDANCEmOOR)TISAGAMEFORANEWGENERATIONTHATKNOWSTHATTHE
WORLDISANETWORKTHEMEDIAISNOTWORTHTAKINGVERYSERIOUSLYAND
PROGRAMMINGCANBEUSEDASAPOLITICALTOOL













4HE5NBEARABLE,IGHTNESSOF&,!3(

4HE)NTERNETSECTIONOFTHE4IRANA"IENNALEWWWELECTRONICOR
PHANAGECOMBIENNALE WASORGANIZEDBY-ILTOS-ANETAS%LECTRONIC
/RPHANAGE 4HE EXHIBITION PRESENTED A FEW DOZEN PROJECTS BY 7EB
DESIGNERSANDARTISTSMANYOFWHOMWORKWITH&LASHOR3HOCKWAVE
-ANETASCOMMISSIONED0ETER,UNENFELD.ORMAN LEINANDMYSELFTO
WRITEANANALYSISOFTHESHOW4HISTEXTISMYCONTRIBUTIONMANYOFITS
IDEASEMERGEDFROMTHECONVERSATIONSTHATTHETHREEOFUSHADABOUT
THEWORKSONDISPLAY4HENAMESINBRACKETSREFERTOTHESHOWSARTISTS
PLEASEGOTOTHESHOWSITETOVIEWTHEIRPROJECTS

"IOLOGY
&LASH ARTISTS ARE BIG ON BIOLOGICAL REFERENCES !BSTRACT PLANTS
MINIMALISTCREATURESANDCLOUDSOFPIXELSDANCEINPATTERNSTHATSIGNAL
hLIFEvTOTHEHUMANEYE'EOFF3TEARNSDECONCEPTCOM6ITALY,EOKU
MOVICHUNCLICKABLECOM$ANNY(OBARTDANNYHOBARTCOMUNCON
TROLCOM /FTENWESEESELF REGENERATINGSYSTEMS"UTTHISISNOTLIFE
ASITNATURALLYDEVELOPEDON%ARTH2ATHERITLOOKSLIKESOMETHINGWE
ARELIKELYTOENCOUNTERINSOMEBIOTECHLABORATORYINWHICHBIOLOGYIS
PLACEDINTHESERVICEOFINDUSTRIALPRODUCTION7ESEEHYPER ACCELER
ATEDREGENERATIONANDEVOLUTION7EWITNESSCOMPLEXSYSTEMSEMERG
INGBEFOREOUREYES-ILLIONSOFYEARSOFEVOLUTIONARECOMPRESSEDINTO
AFEWSECONDS
!NOTHERFEATUREDISTINGUISHESLIFELA&LASHFROMREALLIFETHEAB
SENCEOFDEATH"IOLOGICALORGANISMSANDSYSTEMSAREBORNDEVELOP
ANDEVENTUALLYDIE)NSHORTTHEYHAVETELEOLOGY"UTIN&LASHPROJECTS
LIFEWORKSDIFFERENTLYSINCETHESEPROJECTSARELOOPSTHEREISNODEATH
,IFEGOESONFOREVERnORMOREPRECISELYASLONGASYOURCOMPUTERIS
CONNECTEDTOTHE.ET

!MPLIlCATION&LASH!ESTHETICSAND#OMPUTER'AMES
!BSTRACT ECOSYSTEMS IN &LASH PROJECTS HAVE ANOTHER CHARACTERIS
TICTHATMAKESPLAYINGSOPLEASURABLE*OEL&OX 4HEYMAKEBRILLIANT
USEOFTHECOMPUTERSPOWERTOAMPLIFYUSERACTIONS4HISPOWERPUTS

'ENERATION&LASH
,EV-ANOVICH


ACOMPUTERINLINEWITHOTHERMAGICALDEVICES.OTSURPRISINGLYTHE
MOSTOBVIOUSPLACETOSEEITISINGAMESALTHOUGHITISALSOATWORKIN
ALL OF OUR INTERACTIONS WITH A COMPUTER &OR INSTANCE WHEN YOU IN
STRUCT -ARIO TO STEP TO THE LEFT BY MOVING A JOYSTICK YOU INITIATE A
SHORTDELIGHTFULNARRATIVE-ARIOENCOUNTERSAHILLHESTARTSCLIMBING
THE HILL THE HILL TURNS OUT TO BE TOO STEEP -ARIO SLIDES DOWN TO ITS
BASE -ARIO GETS UP SHAKING ALL OVER .ONE OF THESE ACTIONS REQUIRE
ANYTHING FROM US!LL WE HAVE TO DO IS MOVE THE JOYSTICK ONCE 4HE
COMPUTER PROGRAM AMPLIlES OUR SINGLE ACTION EXPANDING IT INTO A
NARRATIVESEQUENCE
(ISTORICALLYCOMPUTERGAMESWEREALWAYSONESTEPAHEADOFGENER
ALHUMANCOMPUTERINTERFACES)NTHE SANDSUSERSCOMMU
NICATEDWITHCOMPUTERSUSINGNON GRAPHICALINTERFACESTHEYENTERED
THEPROGRAMONTOASTACKOFPUNCHCARDSTYPEDACOMMANDLINEAND
SOON)NCONTRASTSINCETHEIRBEGINNINGSINTHELATE SCOMPUTER
GAMESHAVEMADEUSEOFINTERACTIVEGRAPHICALINTERFACES)TWASONLYIN
THESTHATTHESEWEREINCORPORATEDINTOPERSONALCOMPUTERS
3IMILARLYTODAYSGAMESUSEWHATMANYCOMPUTERSCIENTISTSTHINK
WILLBETHENEXTPARADIGMIN(#)ACTIVEAMPLIlCATIONOFTHEUSERSAC
TIONS)NTHEFUTUREnORSOWERETOLDnAGENTPROGRAMSWILLWATCHOUR
INTERACTIONSWITHACOMPUTERRECORDTHEPATTERNSANDTHENAUTOMATE
MANYOFTHETASKSTHATWEDOREGULARLYFROMBACKINGUPDATATOlL
TERINGOUTANDANSWERINGOUREMAIL4HECOMPUTERWILLALSOMONITOR
OUR BEHAVIOR AND ATTENTION LEVEL ADJUSTING ITS BEHAVIOR ACCORDINGLY
IE SPEEDING UP SLOWING DOWN AND SO ON )N SOME WAYS THIS NEW
PARADIGMISALREADYATWORKINAVARIETYOFAPPLICATIONS&ORINSTANCE
)NTERNETBROWSERSOFFERUSALISTOFSITESRELEVANTTOOURSEARCHESTHE
-ICROSOFT/FlCE!SSISTANTTRIESTOGUESSWHENWENEEDHELP(OWEVER
THERE IS A CRUCIAL PROBLEM WITH MOVING TO SUCH ACTIVE AMPLIlCATION
ACROSSALLOF(#)4HEMOREPOWERWEDELEGATETOACOMPUTERTHELESS
CONTROLWEHAVEOVERWHATITISDOING(OWDOWEKNOWTHATTHEAGENT
PROGRAM HAS IDENTIlED A CORRECT PATTERN IN OUR DAILY USE OF EMAIL
(OWDOWEKNOWTHATACOMMERCEAGENTHASGOTTENUSTHEBESTDEAL
WHENNEGOTIATINGWITHOTHERAGENTSONTHE7EB(OWCANWEBESURE
ITHASNTBEENCORRUPTEDBYTHEM)NSHORTHOWDOWEKNOWTHATA

COMPUTERAMPLIlEDOURACTIONSCORRECTLY
#OMPUTERGAMESAREJUSTTHATGAMES4HEWORSTTHATMAYHAPPEN
WHENWEPLAYTHEMISTHATWELOSE!CTIVEAMPLIlCATIONISPRESENTIN
PRACTICALLYEVERYGAME-ARIOEMBARKSONMINI NARRATIVESOFITSOWN
WITHASINGLEMOVEOFTHEJOYSTICKTROOPSCONDUCTCOMPLEXMILITARY
MANEUVERS WHILE YOU CONTROL ONLY THEIR LEADER 2AINBOW 3IX  ,ORA
#RAFTEXECUTESENTIREACROBATICSEQUENCESTRIGGEREDBYTHEPRESSOFA
KEY.OTETHATINhNORMALvGAMESTHISAMPLIlCATIONDOESNOTEXIST
WHENYOUMOVEASINGLElGUREONACHESSBOARDNOTHINGELSEHAPPENS
YOURMOVEDOESNOTINITIATEASEQUENCEOFACTIONS
&LASHPROJECTSUSEALOTOFACTIVEAMPLIlCATION)TGIVESMANYPRO
JECTSAMAGICALFEELING/FTENWEARECONFRONTEDWITHANEMPTYSCREEN
THENASINGLECLICKBRINGSAWHOLEUNIVERSETOLIFEEGABSTRACTPARTICLE
SYSTEMSPLANT LIKEOUTLINESORAPOPULATIONOFMINIMALISTCREATURES
7EALSOENCOUNTERTHEUSERASAKINDOFGODCONTROLLINGTHEUNIVERSE
INMANYCOMPUTERGAMESBUT&LASHPROJECTSALLOWUSTOFEELTHEJOYOF
CREATINGTHEUNIVERSEFROMSCRATCH
!CTIVE AMPLIlCATION IS NOT THE ONLY FEATURE THAT &LASH PROJECTS
SHARE WITH GAMES -ORE GENERALLY AS 0ETER ,UNEFELD HAS SUGGESTED
COMPUTERGAMESSERVETHESAMEPURPOSEFORTHE&LASHGENERATIONTHAT
MOVIESSERVEDFOR7ARHOL#INEMAAND46COLONIZEDTHEUNCONSCIOUS
MINDSOFPREVIOUSGENERATIONSOFMEDIAARTISTSWHOCONTINUETOUSE
THEGALLERYASTHEIRTHERAPYCOACHSPEWINGOUTBITSANDPIECESOFTHEIR
CHILDHOODMEDIAARCHIVESFORTHEPUBLICTOVIEW$OUGLAS'ORDON 
&LASHARTISTSARELESSOBSESSEDWITHCOMMERCIALTIME BASEDMEDIA)N
STEADTHEIRICONOGRAPHYTEMPORALRHYTHMSANDINTERACTIONAESTHETICS
COMEFROMGAMES-IKE#LAVERTMIKECLAVERTCOM 3OMETIMESUSER
PARTICIPATION IS NEEDED FOR THE &LASH GAME TO WORK SOMETIMES THE
GAMEJUSTPLAYSITSELF54/0)!BYFUTUREFARMERSCOMDEXTROORG 








&LASHVERSUS.ET!RT
4HE )NTERNET EXHIBITION OF THE 4IRANA "IENNALE  THIS TITLE IS
DEEPLYIRONIC4HEEXHIBITIONDIDNOTINCLUDEANYPROJECTSFROM!LBA
NIAORANYOTHERPOSTCOMMUNISTCOUNTRYIN%ASTERN%UROPEFORTHAT
MATTER4HISWASQUITEDIFFERENTFROMMANYEARLY.ETARTEXHIBITIONS
INTHEMID SWHOSESTARSCAMEFROMTHE%AST6UC#OSIC!LEXEI
3HULGIN/LGA,IALINA4HE.ETARTOFTHESWASTHElRSTINTERNA
TIONALARTMOVEMENTSINCETHE STOINCLUDE%ASTERN%UROPEINA
BIGWAY0RAGUE,JUBLJANA2IGAAND-OSCOWWEREJUSTASIMPORTANT
AS!MSTERDAM"ERLINAND.EW9ORK&EATURINGASMANYARTISTSFROM
THE7ESTASFROMTHE%AST.ETARTACCURATELYREmECTEDTHEECONOMIC
ANDSOCIALUTOPIAOFTHENEWSPOST #OLD7ARWORLD
.OWTHISUTOPIAISOVER4HEPOWERSTRUCTURESOFTHE'LOBAL%M
PIREHAVEBECOMECLEARANDTHEDEMOGRAPHICSOFTHE)NTERNETEXHIBI
TIONOFTHE4IRANA"IENNALEMIRROREDTHEM-ANYOFTHEPARTICIPAT
INGARTISTSWORKINTHEWORLDSKEY)4REGIONS3AN&RANCISCO3ILICON
6ALLEY .EW9ORK3ILICON!LLEY AND.ORTHERN%UROPE
3O WHAT HAPPENED )N THE MID S .ET ART RELIED ON SIMPLE
(4-,THATRANWELLONBOTHFASTANDSLOWCONNECTIONS4HISPROMOTED
ACTIVEPARTICIPATIONBYARTISTSFROMTHE%AST"UTTHESUBSEQUENTCOL
ONIZATION OF THE 7EB BY MULTIMEDIA FORMATS n &LASH 3HOCKWAVE
1UICK4IME AND SO ON n REINSTATED THE TRADITIONAL7EST%AST POWER
RELATIONS.OW7EBARTREQUIRESFAST)NTERNETCONNECTIONSFORBOTHART
ISTS AND AUDIENCES7ITH ITS SLOW CONNECTIONS THE %AST IS OUT OF THE
GAME4HE5TOPIAISOVERWELCOMETOTHE%MPIRE
4HE4IRANA"IENNALEDIDINCLUDEONEARTISTFROM#HINAWHO
CONTRIBUTED A BEAUTIFUL MARTIAL ARTS ANIMATION "UT WE NEVER FOUND
WHOHEWAS4HEONLYTRACEWEHAVEOFHIMISHISEMAILADDRESSZHU?
ZHQ SOHUCOM-AYBEHEDOESNTEVENLIVEIN#HINA







'ENERATION&,!3(&!1
!FTER ) POSTED THE PRECEDING THOUGHTS ON POPULAR NEW MEDIA
ARTCYBERCULTURE MAILING LISTS RHIZOMEORG AND NETTIMEORG  ) RE
CEIVEDMANYRESPONSES(EREAREMYANSWERSTOTWOOFTHEMOSTCOM
MONQUESTIONSTHAT)WASASKED

1UESTION
)SNT THE hSOFT MODERNISMv YOU DESCRIBE SIMPLY A RESULT OF THE
PARTICULAR TECHNOLOGICAL LIMITATIONS OF MULTIMEDIA ON THE .ET #ER
TAINFEATURESOF&LASHAREDESIGNEDTODELIVERANIMATIONOVERANARROW
BANDWIDTHANDYOUSEEMTOMISTAKETHEMFORABROADERZEITGEIST

!NSWER
3INCETHENEW&LASHRELEASE&LASH-8 ALLOWSFORVIDEOIMPORTS
ANDVIDEOSTREAMINGITISPOSSIBLETHATWEWILLNOLONGERlNDTHEAES
THETICSOFTHEh&LASHGENERATIONvhSOFTMODERNISMvON&LASHSITESIN
THE FUTURE 4HATS lNE BY ME -Y CONCERN IN THIS ESSAY IS NOT WITH
&LASHSOFTWAREANDITSLIMITATIONSCAPABILITIESPERSEBUTWITHANEW
SENSIBILITYTHATHASMANIFESTEDITSELFINMANY&LASHPROJECTSOVERTHE
LASTCOUPLEOFYEARS)NOTHERWORDS)AMINTERESTEDINTHEh&LASHGEN
ERATIONv4HISISQUITEDIFFERENTFROM&LASHSOFTWAREFORMATS
&OR THIS REASON THE READERS OF MY TEXT WHO ACCUSE ME OF CON
FUSINGATECHNICALSTANDARDWITHAESTHETICSAREMISSINGMYPOINT4HE
VECTOR ORIENTEDLOOKOFhSOFTMODERNISMvISNOTSIMPLYARESULTOFNAR
ROWBANDWIDTHORANOSTALGIAFOR SDESIGN)TALWAYSOCCURSWHEN
PEOPLEBEGINTOGENERATEGRAPHICSTHROUGHPROGRAMMINGWHENTHEY
DISCOVERTHATTHEYCANUSESIMPLEEQUATIONSETC4HISISALSOWHYTHE
hSOFTMODERNISMvOF&LASHPROJECTSANDOTHERSOFTWAREARTREPLAYTHE
AESTHETICSOFEARLYCOMPUTERART SnS nSOMETIMESINAMAZ
INGDETAIL2EMEMBERATTHISPOINTINTIMEPEOPLEWEREONLYABLETO
CREATEIMAGESANDANIMATIONSTHROUGHPROGRAMMING





'ENERATION&LASH
,EV-ANOVICH


1UESTION
4HEREISNOREASONWHYSOFTWAREARTCANNOTUSEREPRESENTATIONAL
IMAGES OR ANY OTHER FORM 7HY DO YOU ASSOCIATE SOFTWARE ART WITH
NON REPRESENTATIONALABSTRACTVECTOR BASEDGRAPHICS

!NSWER
.ATURALLYSOFTWAREARTISTSCANUSEREPRESENTATIONALIMAGESORANY
OTHERhCONVENTIONALvFORMORMEDIA)TWASNOACCIDENTTHATSOONAF
TERTHEIRARRIVALAT8EROX0!2#INTHES!LAN AYANDHISASSO
CIATES CREATED A PAINT PROGRAM AN ANIMATION PROGRAM OVERLAPPING
WINDOWSICONS3MALLTALKANDOTHERPRINCIPLESOFMODERNINTERACTIVE
GRAPHICALCOMPUTING4HECAPACITYTOMANIPULATEANDGENERATEMEDIA
SHOULD NOT BE SEEN AS AN AFTER THOUGHT TO THE MODERN COMPUTER )T
ISIMPORTANTFORITSIDENTITYASAhPERSONALDYNAMICMEDIUMv!LAN
AY 4OPUTITDIFFERENTLYTHECOMPUTERISASIMULATIONMACHINEAND
ASSUCHITCANANDSHOULDBEUSEDTOSIMULATEOTHERMEDIA
3O)HAVENOTHINGAGAINSTSOFTWAREARTISTSUSINGCREATINGMEDIA
BUT)HOPETHATTHE&LASHGENERATIONWILLEXTENDITSPROGRAMMINGWORK
TOINCLUDEREPRESENTATIONALMEDIA
)NOTHERWORDSINTHEEARLYS
THE PAINT PROGRAM AND THE ANIMATION PROGRAM HAD A REVOLUTIONARY
EFFECTONPEOPLESPERCEPTIONOFTHECOMPUTERALLOWINGTHEMTOSEEIT
LESSASANADDINGMACHINEANDMOREASACREATIVE MEDIUM.OWAF
TERALMOSTTWODECADESOFMENU BASEDMEDIAMANIPULATIONPROGRAMS
ANDTHEUSEOFCOMPUTERSASMEDIADISTRIBUTIONMACHINESGREATLYAC
CELERATEDBYTHE7ORLD7IDE7EB ALITTLEPROGRAMMINGCOULDPROVE
QUITEREVOLUTIONARY
)NSHORTWEARENOWSOUSEDTOTHINKINGOFTHE
COMPUTERASAhPERSONALDYNAMICMEDIUMvTHATWENEEDTOREMIND
OURSELVESANDOTHERSTHATITISALSOAPROGRAMMABLEMACHINE
0LEASECONSIDERHOWPROGRAMMINGHASBEENEMPLOYEDSOFARTO
CREATEUSE STILL IMAGES ANIMATION AND lLMVIDEO 4HERE ARE THREE
TRAJECTORIESTHATCANBETRACEDHISTORICALLY/NETRAJECTORYBEGINSWITH
THEEARLIESTWORKSOFCOMPUTERARTnTHElLMSTHAT/SCAR&ISHINGERS
STUDENTS MADE AT THE 7HITNEY IN THE MID  S AND THAT REPRESENT
A DIRECT LINK TO EARLY TWENTIETH CENTURY MODERNISM 4HIS TRAJECTORY
EXTENDS TO THEhSOFT MODERNISMv OF TODAYS &LASH PROJECTS AND DATA

VISUALIZATIONARTWORKS)NOTHERWORDSPROGRAMMINGISUSEDHERETO
GENERATEANDCONTROLABSTRACTIMAGES
4HESECONDTRAJECTORYBEGINSINTHESWHEN(OLLYWOODAND
46DESIGNERSSTARTEDUSINGCOMPUTER GENERATEDIMAGERY#') (ERE
PROGRAMMINGWASPUTINTOTHESERVICEOFTRADITIONALCINEMATICREAL
ISM0ARTICLESYSTEMSFORMALGRAMMARS!)ANDOTHERSOFTWARETECH
NIQUESGENERATEDmYINGBATSHILLYLANDSCAPESOCEANWAVESEXPLOSIONS
ALIEN CREATURES AND OTHER lGURATIVE ELEMENTS 4HESE WERE INTEGRATED
INTOTHEPHOTOREALISTICUNIVERSEOFNARRATIVElLMS
7HATABOUTUSINGALGORITHMSNOTSIMPLYTOGENERATETHElGURA
TIVEELEMENTSOFANARRATIVEBUTALSOTOCONTROLTHEWHOLElCTIONALUNI
VERSE4HISISTHETHIRDTRAJECTORYPROGRAMMINGINCOMPUTERGAMES
 n  (ERE ALGORITHMS CONTROL THE NARRATIVE EVENTS CHARACTER
BEHAVIOR CAMERA MOVEMENT AND OTHER CHARACTERISTICS OF THE GAME
WORLD n ALL IN REAL TIME 5NFORTUNATELY AS WE ALL KNOW AESTHETICALLY
REVOLUTIONARY COMPUTER AND PLAYER DRIVEN GAME WORLDS FEATURE FOR
MULA DRIVENCONTENTTHATCANMAKEEVENABAD(OLLYWOODlLMAPPEAR
ORIGINALANDINSPIRING'RAND4HEFT!UTOISNOEXCEPTIONDESPITEITS
BREAKTHROUGHSINSIMULATINGAMORECOMPELLINGOPENUNIVERSE
) THINK THIS BRIEF SURVEY SHOWS THAT THERE IS STILL AN UNTOUCHED
SPACE COMPLETELY OPEN FOR EXPERIMENTATION AND CREATIVE RESEARCH A
SPACEINWHICHPROGRAMMINGCANBEUSEDTOGENERATEANDORCONTROL
lGURATIVElCTIONAL MEDIA &OR INSTANCE IN THE CASE OF MOVIES PRO
GRAMMINGCANBEUSEDTOGENERATECHARACTERSONTHEmYTOCOMPOSITE
INREAL TIMECHARACTERSSHOTAGAINSTABLUESCREENWITHBACKGROUNDS
TOCONTROLTHESEQUENCEOFSCENESTOAPPLYlLTERSTOANYSCENEINREAL
TIMETOCOMBINEPRE RECORDEDSCENESWITHIMAGERYGENERATEDONTHE
mYTOHAVECHARACTERSINTERACTWITHTHEVIEWERETC)NSHORTPROGRAM
MINGCANBEUSEDTOCONTROLANYASPECTOFAlCTIONALMEDIAWORK








/FCOURSEONCEINAWHILEWEENCOUNTERSIMILARPROJECTSATPLACES
LIKE3)''2!0(OR)3%!BUTTHEYARETYPICALLYRESEARCHDEMOSTHAT
HAVEBEENCREATEDATUNIVERSITIESANDDONOTREACHSOCIETYASAWHOLE
.ATURALLY ONE MAY RAISE THE OBJECTION THAT AN ALGORITHMICALLY CON
TROLLEDCOMPLEXlCTIONALUNIVERSEREQUIRESTHEKINDOFPROGRAMMING
INVESTMENT ONLY POSSIBLE IN A COMMERCIAL GAME COMPANY OR A UNI
VERSITY!FTERALLTHISISNOTTHESAMEASWRITINGASCRIPTTHATDRAWSA
FEWLINESTHATKEEPMOVINGINRESPONSETOUSERINPUT9ESBUTWHYDO
lCTIONALlGURATIVEWORKSHAVETOFOLLOWCOMMERCIALMEDIAFORMULAS
)FONEACCEPTSTHATTHECHARACTERSDONOTHAVETOBEhPHOTOREALISTICv
THATTHElCTIONALWORLDDOESNOTHAVETOBEEXCLUSIVELYTHREEDIMEN
SIONALTHATCHANCEANDRANDOMNESSCANCO EXISTWITHNARRATIVELOGIC
ANDTHATSTICKlGURESCANCO EXISTWITH$CHARACTERSANDVIDEOFOOT
AGEETCPROGRAMMINGlGURATIONlCTIONBECOMESLESSFORMIDABLE)N
SHORTWHILE)WELCOME&LASHPROGRAMMING)THINKITISMUCHMORE
CHALLENGINGTOPROGRAM1UICK4IME




















0OSTSCRIPT/N4HE,IGHTNESSOF&LASH
7HEN)lRSTVISITEDTHEMOSTFAMOUS&LASHSITEnPRAYSTATIONNETn
)WASSTRUCKBYTHELIGHTNESSOFITSGRAPHICS1UIETERTHANAWHISPER
MORE ELEGANT THAN $OOR OR #HANNEL MORE MINIMAL THAN THE  S
MINIMALISTSCULPTURESBY*UDDMORESUBDUEDTHANAWINTERLANDSCAPE
ENSHROUDED IN FOG n THE SITE PUSHED THE CONTRAST SCALE TO THE LIMITS
OFLEGIBILITY!SIMILARLIGHTNESSANDRESTRAINTCANBEFOUNDINMANY
PROJECTSINCLUDEDINTHE"IENNALESHOW!GAINTHECONTRASTWITHTHE
SCREAMINGGRAPHICSOFCOMMERCIALMEDIAANDTHEMEDIAARTOFPREVI
OUSGENERATIONSISSTRIKING
4HELIGHTNESSOF&LASHCANBETHOUGHTOFASTHEVISUALEQUIVALENT
OFELECTRONICAMBIENTMUSIC%VERYLINEANDEVERYPIXELCOUNT&LASH
APPEALSTOOURVISUALnANDCOGNITIVEnINTELLIGENCE!FTERACENTURYOF
2'"COLORWHICHBEGANWITH-ATISSEANDENDEDWITHTHEAGGRESSIVE
SPREADS OF 7IRED WE ARE ASKED TO START OVER TO BEGIN FROM SCRATCH
4HE&LASHGENERATIONINVITESUSTOUNDERGOAVISUALCLEANSINGnTHISIS
WHYWESEEAMONOCHROMEPALETTEOFWHITEANDLIGHTGRAY)TUSESNEO
MINIMALISMTOCUREUSFROMPOSTMODERNISM)N&LASHTHERATIONALITY
OFMODERNISMISCOMBINEDWITHBOTHTHERATIONALITYOFPROGRAMMING
ANDTHEEFFECTSOFCOMPUTERGAMESANDTHISCOMBINATIONHASCREATED
THENEWAESTHETICSOFLIGHTNESSCURIOSITYANDINTELLIGENCE-AKESURE
YOURBROWSERHASTHERIGHTPLUG INWELCOMETOTHE&LASHGENERATION
)AMNOTADVOCATINGAREVIVALOFMODERNISM)TGOESWITHOUTSAYING
THATWEDONTWANTTOSIMPLYREPLAY-ONDRIANAND LEEONOURCOM
PUTERSCREENS4HETASKOFTHENEWGENERATIONISTOINTEGRATETHETWO
KEYAESTHETICPARADIGMSOFTHETWENTIETHCENTURY BELIEFINSCIENCE
ANDRATIONALITYEMPHASISONEFlCIENCYANDBASICFORMSIDEALISMAND
THEHEROICSPIRITOFMODERNISMAND SKEPTICISMINTERESTINhMAR
GINALITYvANDhCOMPLEXITYvDECONSTRUCTIVESTRATEGIESBAROQUEOPAQUE
NESSANDTHEEXCESSESOFPOSTMODERNISM Sn !TTHISPOINTALLTHE
FEATURESOFTHESECONDPARADIGMHAVEBECOMETIREDCLICHS4HEREFORE
APARTIALRETURNTOMODERNISMISNOTABADlRSTSTEPASLONGASITISJUST
AlRSTSTEPTOWARDDEVELOPINGNEWAESTHETICSFORTHENEWAGE



'ENERATION&LASH
,EV-ANOVICH


/FCOURSE THESEAESTHETICSSHOULDALSO REmECT THEDIFlCULTISSUES
OFGLOBALIZATION4HEREMIXCULTUREWEARELIVINGNOWISNOTONLYEN
GAGED IN REMIXING ALL PREVIOUS CULTURAL FORMS AND TEXTS BUT ALSO IN
REMIXINGVARIOUSFEATURESOFWHATUSEDTOBECALLEDhNATIONALCULTUREv
4HIS INCLUDES EXISTING REMIXES BETWEEN IMMIGRANT POPULATIONS AND
THEIR HOST CULTURES 4HE SOLUTION OFFERED BY MULTINATIONAL CONGLOM
ERATES IS OBVIOUSLY NOT SATISFACTORY n A COMPOSITE THAT TAKES CERTAIN
SIGNIlERS FROM A FEW NATIONAL CULTURES THE &RENCH IDEA OF ELEGANCE
*APANESEMANGAICONOGRAPHYhCOOL"RITANNIAvREFERENCESANDSOON
ONLY TO INTEGRATE THEM INTO A RATHER BLAND AND MONOLITHIC TEXTTHAT
ISSENTROUNDTHEWORLD)TREMINDSMEOFA3OVIET STYLECENTRALIZED
ECONOMYINWHICHTHEOUTPUTOFALLTHECOLLECTIVEFARMSWASlRSTSENT
TOACENTRALISTAUTHORITYONLYTOBEREDISTRIBUTEDNATIONALLY ,UCKILY
INALLCORNERSOFTHEGLOBEMUSICIANSTHEATERGROUPSDANCERSDESIGN
ERSARCHITECTSANDSOONAREEXPLORINGAVARIETYOFREMIXESTHATFOLLOW
A DIFFERENT LOGIC .OBODY KNOWS WHAT WILL EMERGE FROM THIS GLOBAL
CULTURALLABORATORYnANDTHISISWHATMAKESOURTIMESSOINTERESTING
!LTHOUGH MOST OF MY ARGUMENTS IN THIS PAPER ARE ABOUT VISUAL
CULTUREANDVISUALAESTHETICSITISIMPORTANTATTHISPOINTTOEVOKEA
DIFFERENTPRACTICE-USICHASHISTORICALLYBEENTHEARTISTIClELDTHATHAS
ALWAYSBEENAHEADOFOTHERlELDSINTHEUSEOFCOMPUTERSTOMAKEPOS
SIBLENEWAESTHETICPARADIGMS!CTIVITIESINTHElELDOFPOPULARELEC
TRONIC MUSIC OVER THE LAST THREE DECADES TESTIFY TO HOW EMPOWERING
NEW TECHNOLOGIES CAN BE IN WELDING NEW COMPLEX AND RICH REMIXES
BETWEENDIFFERENTCULTURESSTYLESANDSENSIBILITIES7ITHOUTELECTRONIC
ANDCOMPUTINGTECHNOLOGIESnFROMTURNTABLESANDTAPERECORDERSTO
PEER TO PEERlLESHARINGNETWORKSANDMUSICSYNTHESISSOFTWAREONA
REGULARLAPTOPnMANYASPECTSOFTHISCULTUREWOULDNEVEREXIST7ITH
ITSMULTITUDINOUSVOICESANDAREALBOTTOM UPhEMERGENTvLOGICTHE
lELDOFELECTRONICSOUNDWHICHPRETTYMUCHMEANSANYSOUNDTODAY
ISAPOWERFULALTERNATIVETOTHEhTOP DOWNvCULTURALCOMPOSITESSOLD
BY GLOBAL MEDIA CONGLOMERATES AROUND THE WORLD ,ET US HOPE THAT
ARTISTSANDDESIGNERSINOTHERlELDSWILLFOLLOWMUSICSLEADINUSINGA
COMPUTERTOMAKEPOSSIBLESIMILARLYRICHREMIXCULTURES