Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BRANDING
HOW ASSOCIATIONS
CAN CREATE AN
INDISPENSABLE BRAND
...AND WHY MOST DONT
Bill Jerome
Vice President/Chief Strategy Officer
Page Stull
Group Account Director
Marketing General Inc.
PAGE 2
SUMMER 2009
The value of the Coke brand was estimated at $67 billion in 2006 by Interbrand and
BusinessWeek and at $44 billion in 2007 by MillwardBrown Optimor in the BrandZ top
100 ranking.
SUMMER 2009
PAGE 3
AN ASSOCIATIONS BRAND
SHOULD DRIVE THE ENTIRE
ASSOCIATION.
PAGE 4
SUMMER 2009
mind. Such stories made the Nordstrom brand famous. When Sears
continues to replace tools over 10 years old, its clear that an unequalled
commitment to quality is a credible, driving force behind their brand.
On the other hand, when a home improvement store claims to make
home repairs easy, but expands beyond its ability to provide enough helpful
staff, its true brand changes from helpful to frustrating. When any service
organization fails to resolve issues within a reasonable time, when a friendly
airline starts to charge for additional bags or change of flights, or when a nohassle bank starts to charge for every service, then the experience conflicts with
the promise. These organizations still have a brand, but its changed for those
who have experienced itthe brand is not what the organization says it is.
A BRAND MUST FOCUS ON THE
NEEDS OF A SPECIFIC, DEFINED
AUDIENCE.
SUMMER 2009
For example, when fire captains become fire chiefs, they eagerly join
the International Association of Fire Chiefs. They aspire to be part of that
organization and they know that whenever they are contacted by the
association, it will be with information vital to their success. They have
eliminated fluff communications. Their brand is simple: key support and
information that will always be important, useful, and indispensable to firefighting leadership.
PAGE 5
PAGE 6
SUMMER 2009
4) Thinking that the best brand depends on what the leadership thinks.
Indeed, good leaders drive an association with their insights and vision.
However, even experienced leadership is not always in touch with all the
needs of the current membership. Too often leaders refer to the typical
member and develop a brand vision that fits an average perception. However,
usually there are many distinct segments, each of which desires a very specific
brand value. This is why so many first-year members do not renew: their
perceptions and needs are not being served under an umbrella brand which
treats all members alike.
Dominos Pizza is a very successful brand, centering on delivering a
family meal or a party menu quickly and conveniently. It also serves a variety
of food options. However, if left to the original brand vision of the leadership,
it would be delivering only cheese and pepperoni pizza (as the founders
wanted to hold to a brand that focused on quick delivery, not variety).
Fortunately, they stayed in touch with the needs of a growing customer base
and altered their brand accordingly.
SUMMER 2009
PAGE 7
She simply did not have a vision or the mindset that she could achieve
anything higher.
Associations, on the other hand, enjoy average renewal rates of around
85%. They achieve this because they have unique opportunities to create
trust and develop a relationship between members and their associations.
Take that, corporate brands!
But such loyalty carries high demands and expectations. Associations
cannot settle for a brand that simply describes benefits. Association
brands need to step up and form a genuine sense and commitment toward
indispensability. If achieved and delivered in a program that meets the
changing needs of progressing members, there is little or no reason
associations cannot keep their members for life.
ASSOCIATION LEADERSHIP
SHOULD DEMAND BRAND
EXECUTION THAT CREATES A
SENSE OF INDISPENSABILITY.
Benefits Delivery
Mission/Vision
Indispensability Uniqueness
Benefits Delivery
AN ASSOCIATION BRAND IS A
COMBINATION OF THE MISSION,
CRITERIA FOR INDISPENSABILITY,
UNIQUE RESOURCES, AND THE
DELIVERY OF BENEFITS.
PAGE 8
SUMMER 2009
Now that we know the mistakes to avoid and the ways to measure the
brand, how does an association go about defining its unique position? How
does it formulate and then summarize its value proposition and brand?
How does it ensure that the brand aligns the vision of an often
transitionary leadership and the ongoing needs of its members and
constituency?
The answer lies in a four-part process that leverages the insights and
perspectives of the two elements that make each association unique: a
mission-driven leadership and its membership community. The process
involves quantifying the vision of the leadership, identifying the greatest needs
and expectations of the membership (and the association community),
measuring and improving the quality by which the association meets current
and future needs, and outlining strategies and programs to fulfill the brand.
1. Definition
A BRAND IS FULFILLED BY
DEFINING THE VISION,
DETERMINING SPECIFIC DEMANDS,
AND PERFECTING THE DELIVERY
OF WHAT IS MOST IMPORTANT TO
AN ASSOCIATIONS MEMBERSHIP.
4. Brand
Fulfillment
2. Demand
3. Delivery
The Association Brand Process starts with input from the associations
leadership. This includes the associations mission and the leaderships vision
as well as trends, research, expectations, resources, competition, and other
challenges that the association and its membership face. It creates a clear
understanding of what the brand looks like as it is fulfilled. This is the
Definition of the Brand. It is the framework of the ultimate goal and the
commitment to get there.
SUMMER 2009
This definition reflects the passion of the staff and volunteer leadership.
It includes the core basics of what the association will always represent. It
should also embrace the aspiration of the leadership in outlining what the
association will become to deliver the greatest impact on the profession or
industry. It also includes special goals for its members: what members
should think about the association, what they should believe about the
association, and what they should do as members of the association.
PAGE 9
PAGE 10
SUMMER 2009
3) Measure Perceptions
Finally, the experience of the brand is established and clarified by
measuring the Delivery of the Brand. What can each audience expect in
tangible and intangible benefits? What can they expect from resources,
services, and communications to ensure that members fully use and
appreciate what the association provides? This all starts with insights
collected from indispensability surveys, which in addition to ranking what is
most important to members also reveal their current perceptions of how
well the association is delivering on those attributes through its specific
programs and services.
Former members will provide insightful clues about brand delivery by
comparing their expectations when they joined with their perceptions of
how the association under-delivered on those expectations.
THE BRAND STIMULATES EACH
DEPARTMENT TO BECOME A
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE.
SUMMER 2009
PAGE 11
From this process, it is then easy to create the slogans, taglines, look,
communications priorities, and conference strategies that communicate the
brand clearly and effectively.
That is why the most effective brand process leverages the vision of its
leadership, but then affirms and refines it through the insights of each
audience including internal staff and volunteers as well as sponsors and
relevant media.
Correctly defined, a brand creates passion and excitement among the
associations staff by providing them with a focus and vision of what the
association is committed to deliver. Each department is capable of
becoming a competitive advantage for the association. New services and
programs are developed, knowing that they are appropriate and expected
by members. Communications not only provide information that members
can use, they also actively document and promote the associations success
in areas important to membership. Brand execution ensures that members
are aware of, exposed to, and involved in the proper resources that will
make the associations mission a critical part of their lives.
From a membership perspective, prospects will join an association
based on their ability to immediately grasp the basics of the brand:
What the association vision provides for their success
How its resources could and should be used
Why they can trust the association to deliver on those expectations
Members will renew their membership based on how well they have
PAGE 12
SUMMER 2009
AN ASSOCIATION BRAND
ATTRACTS MEMBERS BY ITS
PROMISES; IT RETAINS THEM
THROUGH THE MEMBER
EXPERIENCE.
TM
SM