Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hans David Wendt, Lars Heuvels, Eline van Daatselaar and Tim van Schagen
(Group B)
April 3, 2014
Contents
1
2
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Ethylene oxide production . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.1
Reaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.2
Chlorohydrin process . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Distillation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.1
Determination of the adiabatic temperature
3.2
Temperature rise in the reactor . . . . . . .
3.3
Constant reactor temperature . . . . . . . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
rise
. . .
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
2
3
3
3
5
7
9
9
Introduction
In this project we researched the production process of ethylene oxide (abbreviated EtO, C2 H4 O). Ethylene oxide is a frequently used intermediate in
the chemical industry. The reason for this is the easily broken ring (Figure
1), because the breaking of these bonds releases a lot of energy. So ethylene
oxide is a very reactive and much used compound. Because of this, very
much ethylene oxide is produced on a yearly basis. In earlier times, the
production process involved a chlorohydrin process, which was less efficient
then the oxidation process that is used presently. We focussed on the direct
oxidation process, with pure oxygen and not with air. We made this choice,
since the process with pure oxygen is more often used and has a higher production rate. For this process we evaluated mass balances, where different
variables are discussed, like the influence of the conversion, selectivity and
feed rate. We also had a look at the separator units, mainly the distillation
column. Those columns are important for these kind of processes, because
these units improve the purity of the final product. At the end, the energy balance is computed. To evaluate these three processes, we have used
calculation programs like Matlab and Microsoft Excel.
Our research questions are:
How is the mass balance of the production of EtO arranged?
How does the distillation column work for this process?
How are the energy flows in the system set up?
Besides the production process of ethylene oxide, the production of propylene oxide (abbreviated PO, C3 H6 O) also is evaluated. We qualitatively
compare this process to the production process of EtO. The differences and
similarities will be discussed with the following question:
How much differs the production of PO from that of EtO?
2.1
Reaction
CH2 +
O2
Ag
O
2
Figure 2: The formation of ethylene oxide out of ethylene and oxygen catalyzed by a silver catalyst
O
2
+ 5 O2
4 CO2 + 4 H2 O
CH2 +
3 O2
2 CO2 + 2 H2 O
2.2
Chlorohydrin process
The process to make propylene oxide by using chlorohydrins consists basically of three steps: chlorohydration, epoxidation and purification. In the
chlorohydration step, propylene gas and chlorine gas are mixed stoichiometric, while reacting as following to a chloronium ion intermediate (Figure
6):
This intermediate can react in three ways to different products. The desired products are two isomers of propylene chlorohydrin, namely 1-chloro2-propanol (Figure 7) and 2-chloro-1-propanol (Figure 8), which arise from
a reaction with water:
3
Cl
CH2
CH3
Cl
CH3
Cl
Cl
Cl
CH3
H3 C
O
+ H
+ HCl
H + Cl
Cl
Cl
H3 C
O
+ H
+ HCl
H + Cl
HO
Cl
H3 C
CH3
+ Cl
Cl
Figure 9: Reaction of the chloronium ion with chloride to form 1,2dichloropropanol.
Cl
CH3
Cl
+ H3 C
+ Cl
H3 C
+ HCl
O
Cl
Cl
CH3
CH3
CH3
Cl
+ 2Cl + 2H2 O
Distillation
Changing the Antoine parameters makes no sense in the final version, but
we will discuss that later. The parameters are only present to show us the
Antoine parameters. The boiling temperatures are valid for 1 bar, but we
solved the assignment for 4.428 bar, since we could only find Vapor Liquid
Equilibrium (VLE) data for water and ethylene oxide at this pressure. We
made a plot and polynomial approximation of a VLE graph.[9] This graph
can be seen in Figure 12.
5
(1)
A
B
C
Temperature range
Ethylene oxide 1
4.386
1115.1
-29.015
185-280 K
Ethylene oxide 2
5.48696
2022.83
62.656
280-305 K
Water
4.6543
1435.264
-64.848
256-373 K
3.1
Because the oxidation of ethylene to ethylene oxide is an exothermal reaction, there is a lot of energy that is released in the reaction. We want to
know what the temperature rise of the reactor is when we dont let any heat
flow in or out (adiabatic). Weve used an enthalpy balance to determine the
adiabatic temperature rise. We use the steady-state open-system energy
balance (equation 2).[7]
s
H + E k + E p = Q W
(2)
in H in =
out H out
(4)
In this equation we just take the sum of the enthalpy of each individual
component, which can be calculated by multiplying the molar flow with the
enthalpy per mol. In the mass balance section, we already calculated the
molar flows of every single compound in our spreadsheet. These values are
displayed in Table 2.
Compound
Ethylene (g)
Oxygen (g)
Methane (g)
Carbon dioxide (g)
Water (g)
Ethylene oxide (g)
in (mol/s)
2114.286
185.0
6147.692
287.8681
0
0
out (mol/s)
1902.857
0
6147.692
351.2967
63.42857
179.7143
Compound
Ethylene (g)
Oxygen (g)
Methane (g)
Carbon dioxide (g)
Water (g)
Ethylene oxide (g)
A
-6.387880
31.32234
-0.703029
24.99735
30.09200
-23.25802
B
184.4019
-20.23531
108.4773
55.18696
6.832514
275.6997
C
-112.9718
57.86644
-42.52157
-33.69137
6.793435
-188.9729
D
28.49593
-36.50624
5.862788
7.948387
-2.534480
51.03350
E
0.315540
-0.007374
0.678565
-0.136638
0.082139
0.386930
(5)
(6)
H = f H +
Cp dT
(7)
T1
The adiabatic temperature rise depends also on the Tin , we set Tin = 523
K[1] and want to calculate Tout . So Tout is our variable in equation 4. We
used our Matlab code Determination_of_adiabatic_Temperature_rise.m
and the data above to calculate Tout . When we fill in the data with Tin
= 523 K we get Tout = 628.385 K, so the adiabatic temperature rise =
105.385 K.
3.2
If the temperature in the reactor rises, the single pass conversion will rise,
because the reaction will occur faster. When the conversion rises the selectivity will decrease. So a temperature rise will lead to a lower selectivity.
This means that we produce more by-products. When our selectivity decreases the production cost will increase so we dont want the selectivity to
decrease. The temperature is allowed when the reactor is strong enough to
hold these circumstances, but economically we dont want a temperature
rise in our reactor.
3.3
in H in
out H out = Q
(8)
In table 2 we can find the in and out again, because these dont change
when we let the heat flow out. The H in and H out can be calculated because
temperature in reactor is constant = 523 K. We just use equation 7 again
(calculations done with Matlab file: Energybalance_ethyleenoxide.m). The
results are in table 5.
Compound
Ethylene (g)
Oxygen (g)
Methane (g)
Carbon dioxide (g)
Water (g)
Ethylene oxide (g)
H in (kJ/mol)
64.6064
6.8060
-65.5838
-384.4319
-234.0780
-38.3405
H out (kJ/mol)
64.6064
6.8060
-65.5838
-384.4319
-234.0780
-38.3405
(9)
(10)
This gives a heat flow Q = 5.1687 104 kJ/s So we have to absorb 5.1687 104
kJ per second. We use water at room temperature (298 K) to cool down
the reactor, because this is a cheap substance with very few risks. Another
advantage of cooling down the reactor with water is, that we can re-use the
steam for heating up other streams of the process. To calculate the amount
of steam at 373 K that we can produce, we need the heat of vaporization
and the heat capacity of liquid water. To express the heat capacity as a
function of the temperature, we use the Shomate equation again (Equations
5 and 6). The constants for liquid water are depicted in table 6.[11]
A
B
C
D
E
-203.6060
1523.290
-3196.413
2474.455
3.855326
Cp dT = 46.3401 kJ/mol
Hvap +
(11)
298
10
Bibliography
[1] Siegfried Rebsdat, Dieter Mayer, Ullmans Encyclopedia of Industrial
Chemistry - Article Ethylene Oxide. DOI: 10.1002/14356007.a10_117.
published: 15-03-2001, consulted: 21-01-2014.
[2] J. P. Dever, K. F. George, W. C. Hoffman, H. Soo, Kirk-Othmer:
Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology - Artice Ethylene Oxide. DOI:
10.1002/0471238961.0520082504052205.a01.pub2. published: 14-032004, consulted: 21-01-2014.
[3] David L. Trent,
Kirk-Othmer:
Encyclopedia of Chemical
Technology
Artice
Propylene
Oxide.
DOI:
10.1002/0471238961.1618151620180514.a01.pub2. published:
4-012001, consulted: 21-01-2014.
[4] Dietmar Kahlich, Uwe Wiechern, Jrg Lindner, Ullmans Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry - Article Propylene Oxide. DOI:
10.1002/14356007.a22_239.pub2. published: 15-10-2012, consulted:
21-01-2014.
[5] Prof. Dr. Rainer Herges and Dr. Torsten Winkler, Epoxidation
of Alkenes with Peracids. URL: http://www.chemgapedia.de/
vsengine/vlu/vsc/en/ch/2/vlu/oxidation_reduktion/epxo_per_
1.vlu/Page/vsc/en/ch/2/oc/reaktionen/formale_systematik/
oxidation_reduktion/oxidation/addition_sauerstoff/
epoxidierung_mit_persaeuren/mechanismus.vscml.html.
published: 2000, consulted: 21-01-2014.
[6] Shell Oil Company, Patent Preparation Method SMPO Process. Publicatio number: US6989469 B2. published: 24-01-2006, consulted: 21-012014.
[7] Richard M. Felder, Ronald W. Rousseau, Elementary Principles of
Chemial Reactions, 2005 edition. ISBN: 987-0-471-68757-3. published:
2005, consulted: 21-01-2014.
[8] University of Alicante, Conversion: Fundamentals and the difference between single pass and overall conversion. URL: http://
11
12