Professional Documents
Culture Documents
l(June2004)
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
...
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
ofEthiopia,
3 The
is reproduced
on thedustjacketandpage206 ofDonaldCrummey,
Landand
painting
to theTwentieth
Societyin theChristian
ofEthiopia.FromtheThirteenth
Kingdom
Century
Ababa: University
of Illinois Press/James
Ababa
(Urbana/Oxford/Addis
Currey/Addis
PitturaEtiopica
Press,2000). Reproducedhere fromIstitutoItalo-Africano,
University
Tradizionale
as Illustration
1 withthepermission
(Rome,n.d.),piate8, page43. Reproduced
oftheIstituto.
4
See, forexample,thetextspublished
by CarloContiRossini,"NuoviDocumenti
per la
Storiad'Abissinia
nelsecoloXIX,"AttidellaRealeAccademia
NazionaledeiLincei, Series8,
2 (1947),pp.357-416.
5 Dbtra
Tank (Amharictextpublishedas The Chronicleof King
Znnb,YTewodros
Theodore
intoItalian
, editedbyEnnoLittmann
ofAbyssinia
[Princeton,
1902];andtranslated
as M. M. Moreno,
"La cronacadi reTeodoroattribuita
al dabtara'Zanab',"Rassegnadi Studi
, 2 [1942],pp. 143-180); andAlqa WldMaryam,
Etiopici
MhafTarikZTewodros
edited
and
C.
Mondon-Vidailhet
witha Frenchtranslation
as
,
NdguaItyoppzya
published
by
de
Thodoros
II
Roi
des
Roi
un
manuscrit
Chronique
d'thiopie(1853-1868)d'aprs
original
(Paris,n.d.).
6 Abba Tkl
of Adwa,editedand translated
Haymanot
by CarloContiRossini,"Vicende
ai tempidi Ras Ali, eggiacUbie e Re Teodoro,
dell'Etiopiae delle missionicattoliche
secondoun documento
della Reale Accademiadei Lincei,Series5,
abissino,"Rendiconti
XXV(1916),pp.425-550.
This literature,
and unpublished,
is extensively
citedin theworkscitedabove,
published
footnote
andRubenson.
2, byAbir,Crummey
No.1(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVII,
Illustration
1: Churchand Statein Nineteenth
CenturyEthiopia
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
DonaldCrummey
...
ofEthiopia,
No.l(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVII,
the Patriarchateof Alexandria. However, it borrows its style, not from the
hagiographicaltradition,so closely associated with the indigenoussaints of the
Church,but fromthenarrativechronicletraditionclosely associatedwithroyaland
princelycourts.
Slama's Career: A SummaryAccount12
The settingfor Slama's episcopacywas not propitious. The two hundredyears
bitterdoctrinalcontroversies
weremarkedby increasingly
precedinghis appointment
withintheEthiopianOrthodoxChurchconcerningthenatureof Christ.The original
whichhad emergedin theearlierseventeenth
identified
partyof innovation,
century,
itselfwiththeslogan Qeb 'at,or Unction,and arguedthatChristhad become theSon
of God throughUnctionbestowedby God the Father. Othershewed to what they
Alexandrianline. This groupwas knownby thenickname
arguedwas a morestrictly
Karra, or "Knife,"or by its doctrinalslogan, Wld Qeb', "the Son [Himselfis] the
Unction."13
The controversies
betweenthesetwopartieswerediscussedin a number
of councilspresidedoverby theGondrkings,butto no resolution.In 1763 a third
This partywas
partyappearedat a councilheldat Amba Kayla,just outsideGondr.14
based in themonasticorderof Tkl Haymanot,which,since theseventeenth
century
had been based at Azzo, near Gondrand put forwardtheformulathatChristwas
the"Son [of God] by Grace,"or Wldb-$gga . (For thelocationof theprincipal
places mentionedin the text,please see Map 1: Abun Slama's Ethiopia.) An
alternative
formulation
was (Amharic)Y-$gga Log. In thenineteenth
centurythe
partieswerealso identified
by thenumberof "births,"whichtheyperceivedin Christ:
theUnctionists
and theKarra partyarguingforTwo Births;the"Son by Grace" party
arguingforThreeBirthsor SstLddt.15 Relationsbetweenthesepartieswas uneasy,
at best,and violentlyhostile,at worst. Slama's immediatepredecessor,Qeralos
12The
of Slama,probably
basedon a photograph,
was published
onlyknownportrait
by
AaronStern,Wanderings
witha Description
Henry
amongtheFalashasinAbyssinia
together
the
anditsVarious
Inhabitants
2.
of
(London,1862),p. 137. Pleasesee Illustration
13ForCountry
an exploration
ofthedoctrinal
controversies
andthepresentation
of twotextsbearing
on thetheology
oftheUnction,
see Getatchew
on thetheology
ofQeb'at or
Haile,"Materials
Studies.Proceedings
unction,"
pp.205-250inGideonGoldenberg
(ed.),Ethiopian
ofthesixth
international
14-17April1980 (Rotterdam/Boston:
Tel-Aviv,
A. A. Balkema,
conference,
1986).
14
di Abissnia,"
Bessarione
IgnazioGuidi,"Uno Squarciodi StoriaEcclesiastica
, 8 (1900),
pp. 10-25;idem.,AnnalesRegumIyasu II et Iyo'as. CorpusScriptorum
Christianorum
voi.6 (Paris,1912).
Orientalium,
Scriptores
iEthiopici,
Versio,SeriesAltera,
See Getatchew,
Priestsand Politicians,
2 andas ijidexed
"Materials;"
Crummey,
Chapter
for"Qebt","SstLedat","YaagLej", "Tawhedo"
and "Krr";andCrummey,
Landand
for"SonbyGrace,""SstLedt",and"Twahedo".
Society,
pp. 103-104andas indexed
10
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
DonaldCrummey
...
ofEthiopia,
Illustration
2: Portrait
ofAbun Slama
JES,Vol.XXXVII,No.1(June2004)
11
16Donald
"Doctrine
and Authority;
AbunSalama,1841-1854,"
Crummey,
pp. 567-578in
vol.I ofE. Cerulli(ed.),IV Congresso
Internazionale
di StudiEtiopici(Roma,10-15aprile
NazionaledeiLincei,1974). ForOrlos.seedo.571-572.
1972)(Rome:Accademia
17
"Doctrine
and Authority,"
of Ethiopian
doctrinal
Crummey,
p. 573. Slamacomplained
andespecially
oftheThreeBirths
ofJune15,1848,to dieCoptic
divisions,
school,ina letter
Butrus
VII: Rubenson,
Patriarch,
Acta.I, Doc. 103.
18This
is quotedfrom
"Doctrine
andAuthority."
passage
Crummey,
o. 571.
19As referenced
in Crummey,
loc.cit.: C. Rochetd'Hricourt,
Secondvoyagesur les deux
rivesde la merrouge(Paris,1846); C. W. Isenberg
andJ.L. Kropf,
Journals
(Lbndon,1843),
passim,butsee particularly
pp. 90-91,95-96,and226-227; W. C. Harris,TheHighlands
<f
Ethiopia(London:2nded. 3 vols.,1844),DI, ppi 190-191; IndiaOfficeArchives,
Bombay
SecretProceedings,
14 October1842 [j/cfor
189,2060A,Harristo Willoughby,
Ankober,
C. A 5/016,1, Krapfto Coates,Ankober,
184l?]; ChurchMissionary
14
SocietyArchives,
December1841; 2, KrapftoCoates,Ankober,
28 February
1842.
12
: Metropolitan
HaileAbun
Slama
...
andGetatchew
DonaldCrummey
ofEthiopia,
JES,Vol.XXXVII,No.l(June2004)
13
14
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
No.l(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVII,
15
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
DonaldCrummey
...
ofEthiopia,
JES,Vol.XXXVII,No.l(June2004)
17
of episcopalauthority;
lastingconsequencewere: therecognition
episcopal sanction
as a keyelementin royalcoronation;and theestablishment
of doctrinalunitythrough
recognitionof the Wld Qsb 7Karra Christologya's normativeforthe churchas a
whole and the corresponding
suppressionof the Ya-Sgga Log/SostLodt doctrine
and itsproponents.
Alreadyby September,1856, Tewodfosand Slama came intoconflictover church
lands and over the relationshipbetween royal and episcopal authority.36These
conflictsbecame increasingly
bitterand intractable,
but,ironically,
theyservedto reenforceSlama's authority
among the Ethiopianclergy,forwhom he was now the
principalchampion. In 1864 relationsbetweenthetwo ruptured;Slama was exiled
to Tewodros's fortress
of Mqdla; and therehe died,on October25, 1867.37 These
developmentsobscure a more enduringlegacy. Each of Tewodros's successorsTkl GiyorgisII, Yohannss IV and ManitakII- followedthetemplatelaid downby
Tewodrosat thebeginningof his reignas themodel foran EthiopianChristianking:
doctrinalunityin a churchcenteredon episcopal authorityand the adoption,as
- church-sanctioned
normativefor kings, of the maritalpractices of the clergy
monogamy,a radical departurefromthe structured
polygynyof Ethiopia's great
Christiankingsof thefourteenth
and fifteenth
centuries.38
The firstmodernattempt
at reconstructing
church-state
relationsin Ethiopiaended in
shambles. But thetemplatewas compelling.The workof theCouncil of Amba ara
was completedby theworkof theCouncil of Boru Meda, presidedoverby Emperor
Yohannas IV in 1878; and the restoration
of the episcopacy was completedwith
Yohannas'sfourbishopsin 1881.39
36Conti
Rossini,"NuoviDocumenti,"
p. 412; Znnb.YTewodros
Tarik,pp. 29-30; and
WldMaryam,
Chroniaue
. no.25-28.
37
Priests
andPoliticians,
Crummey,
p. 141.
Forthepractices
of Tewodros'ssuccessors,
see DonaldCrummey,
"ImperialLegitimacy
andtheCreation
of a Neo-Solomonic
Cahiersd'tudes
Ideologyin 19thCentury
Ethiopia,"
, 109,XXVIII,1 (1988),pp. 13-43.Forearlierroyalpractice,
see TaddesseTamrat,
africaines
Churchand Statein Ethiopia1270-1527(Oxford: ClarendonPress, 1972),particularly
VI.
Chapter
39Foran accountof
BoruMeda,withreferences,
see Crummey,
and Imperial
"Orthodoxy
Reconstruction,"
pp.440-441.
18
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
DonaldCrummey
...
ofEthiopia*
Text
(p.l) h$.'
P-f-*#"'
-ft-fr-k- ?aa -A
P*X^-":: J ?
**a *n Ai"? aihtxr it-*
}x9HC0 Kfd- HZ*:: <o*
ndA+ AV-J&::<Pm-V+J0-1h,?"lm 7*
UK-:: <o? A-^i Tfcrl<.
1Forhi''rt'i"
. Thetext
isreproduced
as itappears
inthemanuscript,
with
obvious
grammatical
mistakes
annotated.
Punctuation
andoaraeraohine
isours.
2Fora+
hCii-t.fi
Thesentence
is inAmharic.
4 MS "?n45For
MtlM hrfrt1C('+(
No.l(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVII,
19
(DK9li
h^ao- AI <*>W.
M* "V>' hO- M" 7
y#"?4?* atflh -M
ft-fcVC hh00 fi-t
A-frAVU-:: CD(1'
Ia! &
lH^V A-^A
ni#
'7H.v?">HAin4"i?*AP A >n^ A4"y m
?>} mjjv
ft*/jrciJR AV foWt <01)16-::C^ f <*V"fW- AMA*?
.RAAM9WAMA*? at-fh(b
ATati Wi::
SA
IA*
MA* IA-IA
-m1 IAA,- +hn I-V /n A.TS
erntT^^o0-t-f-:: h^at
AT C atfrjfC"0- lg "10*1
*A---fl 4*$9
M69-t:ir^ A MA*! *1 hCA-f-*Af-WJA
f-A-flH++-14*-A+ *A A*-A 1-nCtA /.DA-<Nl+
(p. 2) fflJil-V
K?>}:: ffl/i/'
"V? h" 'jB1d *M
0P/^ hOT *.<10,*C *CPT ftf-fcl
"}fl haf lit n^A-::
PJ-A* <*h-r>C::
atMH hA i nei -ti1 h lna", at-t^fT+m (1*?HHiil "Vii
^jpnjv 7H--n-my +a.a ?* i -ch* w-t h<" ^ahia-wv *n
A4"?
fl/h -HV-A?A-fc
lil hfli.ffth.d
J&l (1TI,A h
rt*JAhyjp
A*-n n^f IT-A-zt-nc Ah::> *>AVM WO- AM AI*?
HhOT
X'VH.i'nh.ciHOTVr/c#fihmSato A*nn* nnA/nv+hA
m hl-ih "7Cf9 HJ
i&lf*
Z('o. J* v-fl::
atel> +"7h^ A.^V 1U* Hl-?C fiPl*?m <5-A*A.
,-fcl<*>>}:;
>A-fcA
dA* dHi--:: AO<-A71+ m+:: ^n,A- 'J&^/hh- AU-l 1WA
m m**" ai.* *n AA"y nh<? en*
"u-n <>w. j&a m^x hAi-^
-ih-+I j-m A/"VC rtn-zh"}!ffl^-n+m.^'o. ma.PI h*"
hrva
A<w.t:: atoeat M Ml -Tt- atatqc9 OMO? A
'+rt-fl
*>-0 hV h" AP-:: ^'w
AfcCJP
Ad<- .+/J.fat-df.^
1M Aj:: fflOA-fc
hA/"Mn.h'tih.C h
H.hVhV AA.IM
AA"?:: H+C /"^J& ^^+0X rt^Yd^
WHhliid -Mii OK+f-kf AdA
+J5"+ A"?d ft,T? +4.0 <dA /l-VAA"7:: atm-t, tf-fr
^'>H t-iac6
vn yA,if^ x<n,i i^ew.:
atm-t, jt-aAll AA"? h"
to%H.W wCh dO
flilt* ft-fcn"7+ d-n*}::
a>a>fl-jp'l M, ft-)-X"}H f<h-C IX*7<-1Xai>l lM-A::ath^OUP *A+
"lf HA-t- ^A 7'rt>{-/">
hCk-tlh:: at+lH i ti-t".:n*7A A*
+J/"h ldA-*w*A*
h<j&rt^-^P7 K9'f--0a- "l l," m-L^P
Pm-VA"> ld/h8
-n -flCy-JHA"*1A *U" at.e+?> aoftaifi hi
at('rM* VPP fflft-XdfeXov> KA h.+OV-tt VP f:: atnfij^y y> HC
h-hM- H++hA *Ai- ft-s"Ah* +hA^ "A+ 0,-f**h/9:: fflf-ilrtXAM"hA^:: ^^-f
iflH *7;::
6 ms
jt+i-nc
7MS
JBA--"
8MS OM
9For
hCA-t/"
20
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
aJrt-i*ii 9.
hw za*-"!- ht-ao7<P0. a>oX'.fr
"idf- atihVCf*
A7P a>9g: h" K&fil WU&:: hV l oociti
nhr-A-"(owrx h Ht *.hv TK00 rx*"
ATW-fcrt
tr-rtf
Hlii *7UA/"Art,C0^ hW HV :: fflfflun1A.f
"fl4>AMT** A1U9+ flV HMlA hUT-f*A-(l -fien OA-t-^
'/"h 1A.P? f 'ito-C <JV mai'} nh" ViV "vh::: <bK9H (l^f
-M-M AJO AA"?
<w.rh^rt ja-nA +WA IM* *::
atl&lP AU 1UA "W4?(DhD-P '9a.-P nh<"V1CV+3::
(1HOTV
f-thl (p. 3) 1-t "ItA /"AA. fV
flV" -HJr-AHhV1*HVAA7
CW y&T*::
+1Cfl* 0^
-
rt
XhA H*"MIA
(W-V*
h/i,"
OT/"C*:: +PA MJA -HH-^MlA" ^1C
hU4?*
nh" +ncn n.+ **a Ah** .en, vn. -f- ait-a- nh"
+PC* AXA-M'+KAA AP"0* n">J+Ju--::
'-H)-<">
T.H. I rt4** hto-W rt-n/VJC:: f>- -*l-HV
^n./-(D+a)7|if-o. nh" Kfhcp
hUV+
A^m.Af-ff^:: fflOA-fc
fcJ&tf-1-7C 0dA+ ? ?h9CV Apm.h-f-o0-::
+hC
-ft AMV rtA"Vffl-HV
OWO-:: MU? l*^
lrtA0
?Ah *feP<P "1 AJ<1rtA"?:: OC1 A-n 31
A*1 rtA"7 lrtV^ dC n*WiA H7-fe+">hA:: V/"* UIC
hflh JMIJM.%t
a>'a>Ufl:: at-t-mwHTr-tM rtA7
HhCrt-A::
fflW7"7j&'- IH^V A-^A --'h hVIt.h'ttfh.C
"rt+l^A:: dnX?+ lili? /: V- 'h jR-OiiA A+H'A (D-h-fi::wv+-l 4A M;% ^1
h<wu m-X-fc::n^jf0fi10
X-VH.^'O/h.CAfcJfU?* hA h
fAlSZao. t'h.0' ot'7-}:: "iT1 AdA If-A-hVbC:: atthfrhOT *-fl/,n
^'fe^ "V? AjfcU"?* hA Xh Ul<*-lN12 AX-fel
^'>l*'n^ 4?"!^:: CB-tdlH* 4*1 (llr-V+i ffl'OH-'i
rtA-flT"Cl- A-flA
A-flrthh't +^Zrt
+*7dlf rtt^ 0h13 *t"76NA0rtA"?::l-t
C+ - A. yAA JiTrY hA <04.+* AX-fel14 V?" ffl+h4-<J-A.
AX"-:: +Ad-- ffllI*
WM::
d-1
AAI-fc"
n^d h<" "1HV^T7 lih M- JR*::
10MS
n^ 08
"msm/
12MS MH
13MS adds(Ih"
14MS X-fel
15MS JAP
No.!(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVII,
21
<Dh>.
A IH^V f-h' ""V6 VJX T-- *l<- rtA
rt?AM TWMs:: rt* n+*PC*
++0A -fi a)C.$:: * -S
tf-A-HfcV(1W M M7" +*VH/O
rtA1A-M +MU-" -WJ-Ji
At-#(]<??*5^A-nl*"y::
('Kii fl"V>J lll^V f-rht")
'Ml A-l ^.wy:: -f*4"fl1UP" Wi-b IA- hV il'llT* mlWd H*1
flrt-
a>hr"t
^7H.^'ah,c MA pA-T oaf v** 011 j&a wi PJ^C
*7H.Mlrh.C1U V**" 1W7 J""* IH^V "V-fc^rt"R* fcSU"??- :
"V?!xrxr- m+ix&oo O'HU':: a>V? # hH^' h<1A^hHl'
frti "*I*,A /<*l
r+ Afth-wy* ^- nhr-^i ffl++-(i
f'Wd * I+ fcjfcU"?* h<rt
A'MC lA-f*+W*:: I+ -rt*A. N7H
m -HI mi *-mmao jn d .h h. ASA.PI -n<- yA ^A *?A IA-17- <DI/-I
ldA-f-wA-:: ffl^'D"H r>
(P-i-tfrw:: (0-t"t"ttlfhC t'V
fl+^A" a)Hi3 nth?"} iih::
V*>
n"
an-t-hO-A?::
(DOR**!
l.A
OfhJH 1XT w^-tm+VO .fi ^A.5 -f"W TP MH -IH-1
<o+-P 2A S'Vn.h'A.C:: <o+/6 P6* H-(' l-1"i
M"
Z.KhW'
HV7o> (p. 4) 5
+rt - *A. 9o/-+ **>S -nWi.4.::UlT-A-"A (l 9* flll^V "V-fe^::
<PSl>- t-t-VOh ?C Arti ldA-l- WA- Afrfl T.f-CXrt2.PA tl^
1A+ A4:: HfrA-HhV I'HV-MRO-AM rtl"? C-fc<J
1& iT+u w+^grp
hVILkil'h.C AM rt^"7 +fh<P<-h X~6lh hUT+ 1-*>C::
+rt fflx-n^n"y*
N^-Mnifsl WAZ-t *h.K. ti.5 h9KS
hUT+
AAO rt^r C-fj*}y#"??* Wti- 17C OThVfrkro-:: +
T-">c nu"y. 1'^'A, ffl^+iA nv/^-h nrh". ><* g-wo A^^n^
n^Crt */i ^^^ "C
hrUK::
ndA+ *:: (H^V "7Crt
AO iM"7 C-fc4y^yr^-:: fflT+ Mh l-A-^Ay OUMC::
n"7C
jBa (1AJPA^'7H.^'n/h.C *7^ 7-flCh",rt-flh^AX^H.Ji-nrh.CH/tC^PVM-t
ili hVi.:
M X^-il "b%9 9A -lif-'"UCh:: a>h.VI
tDhrXrlH
KhW
',t-%a><DnX,ilJ&9
*n<- "rtv T-jy:: 1-n
H+<*> hr'Q^.-:: UP Vl R*/*h^V IM"? Ni^fl T-'JC tao-::
OT,PdA
ffl!/hr+X&t-b + hC 1A9 1C:: VK-in- rt-V
V1 YZ0??* SC-f-KMl*::
,fcH"0*
16MS y**
17MS XArtA18MS *+
22
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
Ijw-jj .^
n^iA-o^ ffl/^o--^
A-)* "/AA"
fhvcf- (oit-fao-nx:?-}
WyV X?"rhA-
A MH.hilHi.C
AHJ&'lA*
+A il^
"}*7lAh, '>n T"H- V7C" Afl (p. 5)23 XA-vMl*'"- AXA- hAI-f VIJt
J^hH^' hA -f-AXA"*
V7
J&-nAi">*?-fc
rhVCfY Ah+f-kf'*
aton^ at-X't.Hhr'Kh hCtt i1fh, hlhn.:: ffljBaA" *0 A4"7 h"/-feiCV
(D-h-b:: fflj&aA"*
+Aj^" XI A4"y iTV-fe-icy?:: ^ (l&9>
"yc+A miw.
nv- K9A.^V
HMhlXrCf HAnh A+
"/AA*24"7.OT A+ n^C^B n^-n^
^-><{.A frfi:: J&aAP HA XAH
iiXAh'J-Ci'
AtlV n-HPoA'<ri.: jaA-<^
hv ^Ah^ A^O
st--x-hA ?n<- nH^rh<-v xnp^ A.^V AA-*HSfhifrcf X"ycA -m
19MS
20For
A.fiWlh.Yi-C
21MS HH-t-rt-n*
22MS omits.
23MS addsa>M
24MS
"IfrlV.
No.l(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVII,
23
24
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama
: Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
*fl l"7d::
2.ftA ""Ah* n.'S +4"n *fl-f*
xtjttn31 a>A/^
ath 1^-Poo. (|g
A2A *>Ah* T-P Xrth"A UIC"
>!-/" WiPo*
IK:: <o-t~hit fl+*A:: l*f,ffl.
V:: mau'A.^ao. hr'tvmfc^+^A MH
A9XAh:: P/t-lil 7T*/" ([A94r CM-::
ohrXrlt-H 3- 7T-/" **A -+ <1 A.n?A::
A+hA
y^"V':: ffllUP'".O +*C1V *0 rt^"7 aH^nim. nX,U- /".Pi32 (ftl
AhCA-Tl11/" aiw-V.-b:: (D+anib l^A- rt-l* -Itt A.ITi h<* .JR?/KnfPVT-bu
(otxvsw H
ffl+JiPvi-n^ -flcy?"
a)-t-a)/n.
^">1
n.*A- h0 Kzih- KrifilV-b::
*cdh^,A ni^A--n,h, P
toxrsiiTi
n> AJ>-33
T-try" * mrxrc::
hr-A-*
hu?*
I "T aARA
vb/
-fc^-crrtir/
31MS
W
33MS
/"PO'
33MS Af*
34ForAd*.The
is forrespectAmhsiism
pluralform
35
MS
xih
IN
o.l (June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVIl,
25
36MS h00
Itshould
beeither
XftOT
or hOTh.f'hCV.
^..P'V.C.
26
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
Translation
Copied (iby Sergew Hable ellassie) froma note belonging to Alqa Azzz,
to be foundat the Libraryof the Holy TrinityChurch (in Addis Ababa).1
Afterhim2came Abba Qerolos3and enteredGondr.4When he confessed, "The
Son is unction," the clergy of Gondr sent him away. They broke his chair
and cross. A serious injustice was committedagainst him. He returnedto
Tsgray5 and lived in Adwa. He died at the hands of people and became a
martyr.He was number 106.
Afterthatcame a false bishop fromArmenia.6Dggazma1 Sb'a Gadis and the
mkwanmt%
of Tagray sent him away. He returnedto his countryand died of
excessivegrief.
1 In Amharic.
Teacherof SergewHable Sellassieand
Alqa Azzz was theOld Testament
Getatchew
HaileattheAddisAbabaHolyTrinity
School.
Theological
Yosabwhodiedin 1803.
Obviously
3
from1815 untilhis deathin 1828. On the metropolitans
Qeraloswas metropolitan
in thistext,see SalvatoreTedeschi,"Ethiopian
mentioned
in Aziz S. Atiya(ed.),
Prelates,"
The CopticEncyclopedia
(Macmillan,1991),vol. 4, pp. 999-1003;and IgnazioGuidi,"Le
listedeimetropoliti
Abissnia,"
Bessarione
detailsofthis
, 6 (1899),pp. 1-16. Theessential
accountof Qeralosare confirmed
by othersources: C. ContiRossini,"La cronacareale
Abissinadall'anno1800all'anno1840,"Rendiconti
dellaRealeAccademiadei Lincei, Series
nel
5, 25 (1916),pp. 889-893;C. ContiRossini,"NuoviDocumenti
perla Storiad'Abissinia
secoloXIX,"AttidellaReale AccademiaNazionaledei Lincei, Series8, 2 (1947),364-365;
Nathaniel
a
Pearce,TheLifeandAdventures
Pearce,Written
ofNathaniel
byHimself,
during
ResidenceinAbyssinia,
the
1810
1819
to
withMr. Coffin's
Accountof
from years
Together
His Visitto Gondar.EditedbyJ.J.Ifalls,Esq. (London:2 vols.,1831),II, pp. 66-67; and
ofDggazma Sb'a GadisWlduto BurrasVII,
Guidi,"Le liste,"pp. 13-14. Fora letter
Patriarch
of Alexandria,
of Qerslos,see Sven Rubenson,
et al
1827,complaining
February
I. Correspondence
and Treaties1800-1854(Evanston/Addis
(eds.),Acta/Ethiopica.Volume
Ababa: Northwestern
Press/Addis
AbabaUniversity
University
Press,1987),Doc. 22.
4 In the
the
forms
are
and"gwndr."
FortheEnglishversion
text,
we will
variably
"gondr"
usetheform
ofwhatthetextoffers.
Gondr,
regardless
5Thetexthas
always"tagre".
6 A number
ofArmenian
ecclesiastics
visitedEthiopia
intheearliernineteenth
Those
century.
whocamein Qeralos'stimeweresummarily
dismissed
fromTagray.However,in theearly
1820s an Armenian
ecclesiastic(almostcertainly
nota bishop)namedHovhannsvisited
welcomed
andsupported
wa,wherehe was warmly
byNoguahlallaseuntilhisdeath
in 1838: RichardPankhurst,
"TheHistory
ofEthiopianArmenian
Relations(ii)," Revuedes
tudesArmniennes
2275-278.
, NS, XIII (1978-1979),
pp.
7
"
"
inthetextis either
The.form
dggazmaor"dggazma."
8
"Rulers,"
"notables,"
"dignitaries,"
"nobility."
JES,Vol.XXXVII,No.l(June2004)
27
28
Slama
: Metropolitan
...
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
DonaldCrummey
ofEthiopia,
20Theterm"Galla"herehasseveral
itrefers
Mostnarrowly
tothedynasty
founded
registers.
ofEthiopiafromDbr
thecentral
inthe1780sbyRas Ali I, or"theGreat,"ruling
povinces
of thedynasty
wereRas Ali II and his mother,
Tabor. The contemporary
representatives
a
brief
toA?e YohannasIII, forwhom,
her
title
who
claimed
Mnn,
marriage
through
Stege
18: ContiRossini,"Cronacareale,"pp. 884, 915; and idem."Nuovi
see above footnote
as the"WrrSk"
andwerefrom
referred
to themselves
documenti,"
p. 380. Thisdynasty
andalliesoftheWrrSk.
"Galla"refers
totheWllorelatives
Yjju. Moregenerally
Givenindifferent
forms,
e.g.,here"gwam."
22The author
bothto MountTaborandthe
mayhave,usedthenameas pun,sinceit refers
thathappened
onit.
Transfiguration
23A conflation
ofPs. 46: 9/47:8 andPs 94/95:3.
24
in
was thecountry
seatofthemetropolitans
theGondrera. (See
nda, Dmbiya,
during
the accompanying
Our
most
detailed
account
Map.)
nineteenth-century comes fromthe
Aaron
Stern:
witha
missionary,
Henry
Wanderings
amongtheFalashasinAbyssinia
together
and its VariousInhabitants
oftheCountry
(London,1862); see pp. 253-255foi;
Description
an accountof Stern'svisitto nda. ThereweremanyFlaSain thenda areaandAbu
Slama gave permission
formissionaries
supported
by the Churchof Scotland'sJewish
to establish
a missionthereon condition
thatanyconverts
wouldbecome
MissionCommittee
members
of theOrthodox
whichaccountsforStern'sparticular
interest.See the
Church,
accountin DonaldCrummey,
Priestsand Politicians.Protestant
and CatholicMissionsin
Orthodox
, 1830-1868(Oxford:Clarendon
Press,1972),pp. 130,133. It is possible
Ethiopia
thattheFrenchtraveler,
CharlesPoncetvisitedthedeposedmetropolitan
AbunSinodathere
in 1699. Poncetbriefly
describes
Sinodaat "Tenket,
a country
housebelonging
to
visiting
No.l(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVll,
29
translated
therelicsof thebishops. The relicsof 12 bishopswerediscovered.One of
themwas foundshroudedin sen,25[thiswas] thecorpseremainso Abba Sinoda26
who was demoted. But theotherbishopswere found,on 24 Tsrr,shroudedin their
regal vestments. He put the relics ojf the threebishops in one coffin. Abba
^ww'YohannasandAbunaYosab,
Krastodolu,who was buriedin Dbr Qw9sqwam,
who were buriedat the churchof Saint Gabriel,were not at nda. He made a
thatthesoldiersand pages of Stege Mnn shouldnotreturn;he issued
proclamation
an excommunication
thattheymaynotenterhis monastery
of Gnda, and came back
and enteredhis seatGondr.
In less than2 months,thefence(?)27of his monastery
was broken,and poundedby
theorderof Stege Mnn,forexcommunication
was trivialforher;she was cruellike
Jezebel.28Abba Slama grievedverymuch. His griefand his prayercame to God.
For he has said in the Gospel, "When you ask the Fatherin my name, he will do
foryou."29 We herebybringthe storyof injusticesvisitedupon Abba
everything
and
how God helpedhimin thYear of Mark,on 24 Ganbot,on theholyday
Slama,
of AbunTdid Haymanot,and on theholyday of Our Lady Mary,called (theHoly
Family's)EntranceintoEgypt.
In themorning,thehighpriestsof Gondrand Swa held counsel by the ordersof
Ras Ali and his motherStege Mnn. The day was a Sunday.30They abolishedthe
Sabbathand the holy days. They said, "Let not thepeople be disturbedon a holy
day." So, theysurroundedthe residenceof Abba Slama as bees would surround
honey.31It [thescripture]
says,"Many dogs surroundedme, and fatbulls seized me.
30
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
DonaldCrummey
...
Slama:Metropolitan
ofEthiopia,
JS,Vol.XXXVII,No.l(June2004)
31
32
HaileAbun
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
Slama:Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
Mk.15:11.
AnallusiontoLk23:34.
50Forthis
"
see ContiRossini,"NuoviDocumenti,"
sequenceofevents,
pp.387,396-397.This
sourceclaimsthatthesourceofconflict
between
WabeandSlamawas theprotection
offered
de Jacobis.See alsoRubenson,
Acta, I, Doc. 103,Slama
byWabetotheCatholicmissionary
to ButrusVII, January
of Slama's
15, 848. Foraccountoftheseyearsfromthestandpoint
relations
withProtestant
andCatholicmissions,
see Crummey,
PriestsandPoliticians
, pp.8991 andreferences.
51Amharic
"tmkol."
52Ps. 93/94:1.
53Fora
sourced-based
accountofthesedevelopments,
see Rubenson,
detailed,
KingofKings.
Tewodros
Haile SellassieI University/Oxford
ofEthiopia(AddisAbaba/Nairobi:
University
III especially
38.
Press,
1966),
Chapter
page
54Foran accountofthisethnic
withitsdistinct
Cushitic
see F. Gamst,The
group,
language,
andWinston,
Qemant.A Pagan-Hebraic
Peasantry
ofEthiopia(NewYork: Holt,Rinehar
andwestern
hinterland
ofGondr,
inthe
1969). TheQamanttodayarefoundinthenorthwest
districts
of Lay Armaaho
andCaiga and,
earlierweremorewidespread
in
Q*Wa.
perhap^,
thereferences
are few,Kasa/Tewodros
seemsto.havehad a specialrelation
with
Although
them.
No.l(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVH,
33
55Cf. "The
ofJames(Jacob)of Serug"in MarcosDaoudandMersieHazen,The
Anaphora
Church
Liturgy
oftheEthiopian
(Cairo,Egypt:1959),p. 291(parae96).
Thesedevelopments
tookplace at thebeginning
of 1848 AD: ContiRossini,"Nuovi
" 395. See also
Documenti
p.
Rubenson,
KinsofKinzs*d. 39.
57Ps 9:17/16.
Possibly,"withtheGala(armv)ofBlw."
59Kasa/Tewodros
had hadhis earlyeducation
at themonastery
of CnkrTklHaymanot,
forwhichseeRubenson,
28-29.
,
King
of
Kings
pp.
60Bana.
34
HaileAbun
DonaldCrummey
andetatchew
Slama:Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
Ras Ali moved to the east, in the directionof his homeland. All thisvictorytook
place in one year,in theyearof Matthew.The end of his defeatwas Wednesday,23
Sne, the holy day of the mightymartyrSaint George [June29, 1853].61 All this
happenedbecause of the griefand the injusticevisitedupon Abba Slama of the
Orthodoxfaith. God helpedAbba Slama; and his enemies,the clergyof Gondr,
wereputto shame.
Thus, in 1846 AM [= Sept. 1853 - Sept. 1854 AD], Daggazma Kasa broughtAbba
Slama of the Orthodoxfaithwhencehe was exiled and broughthim in to Gondr,
the residencyof his bishopric. The clergyof Gondfreceivedhim withsongs and
to
hymns.Theyreceivedhim,withhappinessandjoy, on 24 Ganbot,-corresponding
the (same) day he left[May 31, 1854].62 Abba Slama of theOrthodoxfaithcame
fromhis countryin the Year of Mark; in Mark he leftGondr; and in Mark, he
returned(to it). The whole worldadmiredthismatterverymuch. One said, "Say to
God, yourdeed is terrible."63
Gloryto God who showedus thismatter;amen.
Afterthis,Daggazma Kasa returned
fromGoggamwitha greatamountof booty. At
thattime,Dggazma itemi, theprinceof Goggam,was takencaptiveby his hand.
He [Kasa] camped in Wyna Dga (in a place) called Ambaara.64Being there,he
summonedour MetropolitanSlama fromGondrto him. He came out of his camp
and received him with humilityand affection. They stayed togetherone week
relatedto theOrthodoxfaith.
discussingmatters
At thattime,thekingassembledfrommanymonasteries
therenownederudite,halfof
whomsaid, "JesusChristis theSon of thenaturof theFatherby theunctionof the
Holy Spirit,"and half of whom said, "He was anointedas he has paid tribute,"
61Rubenson
refers
tothisdefeatas theBattleofAyaal.Fora discussion
ofitssignificance,
withreferences,
seeKingofKings,p. 43.
62Theaccountin
"Doctrine
andAuthority,"
hasMay31st.At
Crummey,
p. 576,erroneously
thetimeofSlama'sre-entry
intoGondr,
undertheaegisofKasa,Kasa was stillinGoam.
63Ps. 65/66:3.
64 For thelocationof
Ambarara,
please see theaccompanying
Map 1: AbunSlama's
Ethiopia.TheCouncilofAmbaara,whichourdocument
proceedstodiscuss,was a turning
of Ethiopiaanda starting
pointin thenineteenth-century
history
pointforthere-construction
oftheEthiopian
It didnotdefinitively
resolvethedoctrinal
someof
monarchy.
controversies,
whichpersist
to thepresent,
butitdidseta precedent,
whichwas re-affirmed
the
by Council
ofBoruMedain 1878,ofparticular
tothevariousteachings
oftheThreeBirth,
Yopposition
"Doctrineand Authority*,"
and idem
and
$gga Log sect. See Crummey,
., "Orthodoxy
Reconstruction
in Ethiopia1854-1878,"
Journal
Studies
Imperial
, NS, XXIX,
of Theological
Pt.2 (1978),pp.427-442.
JES,Vol.XXXVII,No.l(June2004)
35
36
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
DonaldCrummey
...
ofEthiopia,
They also said, "The motherof God (died) for redemptionof sinners,while the
apostles and all the saintsand martyrsdie forthinkingabout sin, fortheyare not
freefromthinking
of sin. Therefore,
perfectly
judgmentof deathwas passed against
them."72
They also commita serious heresy. They give the body and blood of Christto a
corpse,aftertheman'ssoul is departed.73
Such is thecreedand ordinanceof thosewho maintain,
"The Son of God was bornby
Grace througha thirdbirth."
Now let us go back to theoriginaltheme. WhenD ggazmaKasa assembledthese
two parties,he asked them about the issue, saying,"Who was the Apostle of
to theland of 'g'azi?"74 Theysaid to him,
Ethiopia? And who broughtChristianity
"It was Abba Slama, theIlluminator."He said to them,"Fromwhose See was Abba
Slama the Illuminatorordained?" They said to him,"From the See of Mark the
Evangelist." (He asked), "Has therebeen anyone of theArchbishopsof Alexandria
who preached a thirdbirthby grace or naturalbirthby the unctionof the Hol
Spirit?" Theysaid to him,"But thisis notin Alexandria,ratherour fathersherehve
taughtus." He said to them,"If yourwordsare a truewitness,thenstaywithwhat
72
thiscontroversy:
"whether
theHoly
Krapf(CMS, C.A5/06,loc.cit.)explicitly
reports
formankind
ornot;"and"Respecting
thedeathofMary,itis saidbyone
Virgindieda victim
thatshediedas an offering
forthesinsoftheworld. . KrapfandIsenberg,
Journals
,
party,
as whether
p. 96, entryforAug. 20, 1839. Othersourcesreportthecontroversy
"equal
adoration
andherSon . . . thequoteis from
[is] duetotheholyVirgin
Harris,
, III,
Highlands
pp. 190-191; butit is equallyreported
by Krapf{Journals,
pp. 90-91); and by C. E. X.
Rochetd'Hricourt,
SecondVoyage
surlesdeuxrivesde la MerRougedanslepaysdesAdels
et le royaume
de Choa (Paris,1846),p. 227. Although
condemned
at theBoruMedaCouncil
of 1878,somemanuscripts
oftheLiturgy
stillpreserve
theformula
"w-masl
wldaamioko
of and prostration
forherwithherSon [are meet]."),e.g.,EMML
("adoration
w-sdgdt"
Haile and WilliamF. Macomber,
A Catalogueof Ethiopian
2969, ff.14b-15a, Getatchew
AddisAbabaand
Manuscripts
Microfilmed
fortheEthiopian
Manuscript
Microfilm
Library,
Vol.VII:ProjectNumbers
2501-3000
fortheHillMonastic
Manuscript
Library,
Collegeville,
,
1983,p. 282.
Collegeville,
(Minnesota)
Thispractice
is notreported
incontemporary
butthereare,indeed,many
sources,
European
of funeralritual,whichincludedirections
to perform
suchan act:
Ethiopian
manuscripts
kzbur"("Makethem[thecorpses]tastefrom
"yalksfowwomu
sm-sgahu
qoddusw-sm-dmu
His holybodyand His honoredblod",e.g., EMML 3562, ff.4a, Getatchew
Haile, A
Catalogueof EthiopianManuscripts
Microfilmed
for theEthiopianManuscript
Microfilm
AddisAbaba andfor theHill MonasticManuscript
Vol.IX:
Library,
Library,
Collegeville,
3501-4000
, Collegeville,
ProjectNumbers
1987,p. 42.
(Minnesota)
anerudite
atthistime.
reference
Ag'azi= Ethiopia(n),
bya political
figure
JES,Vol.XXXVII,No.l(June2004)
37
ourfathers
theArchbishopsof Alexandria,fromMarktheEvangelisttoAbba Petros75
and (our metropolitans)fromAbba Slama, the Illuminator,to the presentAbba
Slama,have taughtus." He declareda proclamationwithsound of thehornsaying,
"Do notdeviatefromthefaithof theseour fathers
archbishopsand metropolitans."
Then,on 13 Nhase, on the holy day of Mount Tabor, on whichthe Fatherwas a
witnessforhis Son, saying,"This is mySon whomI love; listento him,"76
he [Kasa]
enteredthe Palace, and assembledall the clergyof Gondr,fromthejunior to the
senior,and said to them,"Come to be bound,all of you,by thewordsof our father."
Theyall stoodup and wereboundby thewordsof our father.He, too,bound (them)
saying,"The Wordhas become flesh;and thefleshhas become divineby union(with
theWord). Withthisunion,of theWordwiththeflesh,and thefleshwiththeWord,
he [Christ]is77one body and one nature. In his humanityhe knows like theFather
and theHoly Spirit;and by theunion,he is theSon of thenatureof theFather.He is
divinein his humanity."78
He bound all, frommorningto the9thhour(of theday),
lest theysubtract from,or add to, thisfaith. At the 9thhour,a proclamationwas
again issuedwiththesoundof thehorn. All theclergyunanimouslysaid, "We praise
God thepraised,"79
And thecentralwall of quarrelwas demolished.Peace and amity
prevailed.
Afterthis,in the second year,in the Year of Luke [Sept. 1854 - Sept. 1855 AD],
Dggazma Kasa marchedto thecountryof Somento fightwithDggazma Wabe,
thePrinceof Somen and Tsgray. Dggazma Wabe, too, came fromTagraywitha
It is a
largearmy.-Theymetat a battleon thetop of a hill in Somen,called Gwalit.80
seat of ice. The armyofDggazmaWsbe was defeatedquickly. At thattime,of his
, Dggazma Mahzntu,the Princeof Goggam and Damot; ambi
mightymakwanmt
al wld,81Dggazma Hstu;FitawrariAmbaye; and Abeto Lmma Gumdw82
feil. Dggazma Wabe himselfwas takencaptivewithhis son and his makwansnt.
Of his weapons,nothingwas spared,but(wereassembledin thehand of Dggazma
Kasa.
75Thisis
of Alexandria.Forletters
fromEthiopiato Butrusspanning
ButrusVII, Patriarch
theperiod1827to 1849,see Rubenson,
etal, ActaAEthiopica.
L Docs. 22, 103,119.
Volume
76Feastof
Mt 17:5.
transfiguration,
77Thewordfor"is" is in
nw.
Amharic,
78Thisis a statement
oftheWldQeborKarradoctrine.
79Cf.Ex 15:
1,21.
80For an accountof theBattleof
Drsge,Feb. 9, 1855,and a criticaldiscussionof the
see Rubenson,
sources,
pertinent
Ethiopian
KingofKings,pp.44-45.
81Thetexthas "
a translation
to Ga'az oftheAmharic
ambi
abywldu",obviously
epithet
al wMdu"Wldu [who]saidno,"giventoDggazma3tu,Wabe's son,whenhe-refused
tosubmit.
82AlsoanAmharic
"Cuthimoff."
epithet,
meaning
38
: Metropolitan
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama
...
ofEthiopia,
No.l(June2004)
JES,Vol.XXXVII,
39
40
DonaldCrummey
andGetatchew
HaileAbun
Slama:Metropolitan
...
ofEthiopia,
SamuelRubenson
FactorinEthiopia(Frankfurt-am-Main:
PeterLang
(eds.),TheMissionary
GmbH,1998).
94Thebestsuccinct
accountofthedestructiveness
ofthelateryearsofTewodros
is Rubenson,
s sacking
Gondrin 1864and1866and
, Chap.V. Foran accountofTewodros'
KingofKings
andplundering
itschurches,
see ibid.,pp.71-72.
burning
95Unidentified.