Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Althoughindividualspinsinquantumdotshavebeenstudiedextensivelyasqubits,theirinvestigationunderstrongresonant
drivingin thescopeofaccessingMollowphysicsisstillanopenquestion.Here,wehavegrown highqualitypositively
chargedquantumdotsembeddedinaplanarmicrocavitythatenableenhancedlight-matterinteractions.UnderastrongmagneticfieldintheVoigtconfiguration,individualpositivelychargedquantumdotsprovideadouble-lambdalevelstructure.
Using a combination of above-band and resonant excitation, we observe the formation of Mollow triplets on all optical
transitions.WefindthatwhenthestrongresonantdrivepowerisusedtotunetheMollowtripletlinesthrougheachother,we
observeanticrossings.Wealsodemonstratethattheinteractionthatgivesrisetotheanticrossingscanbecontrolledinstrength
bytuningthepolarizationoftheresonantlaserdrive.Quantum-opticalmodelingofoursystemfullycapturestheexperimentally observed spectra and provides insight on the complicated level structure that results from the strong driving of the
double-lambdasystem.
pairAlAs/GaAstopDBR.ChargingoftheQDsisensuredby
aberyllium(p-type)-dopinglayer,located10nmbelowthe
QDs.TheQDlayerispositionedatthecenterofthecavity,on
anantinodeoftheelectricfieldtoenhancetheinteractionof
theQDswiththeresonantlaserlight.Theresultingstructure
has an experimentally-estimated quality factor of Q~65 and
showsstrongdirectionalemissionfromtheasymmetriccavity.
ThesamplestructureisshownintheinsetofFig.1(b).
Thequantumdotunderinvestigationisspectrallylocated
closetothepeakofthecavityreflectionspectra,at917.190nm
(1.351782 eV) and features a 9.81.7 eV linewidth under
above-bandexcitationat780nm.Thephotoluminescence(PL)
spectra have a linear power dependence as shown by the
detectedphotoncountsusingasinglephotoncountingmodule
(SPCM)inFig.1(a).Time-resolvedPLmeasurementsunder
weak, pulsed wetting-layer excitation at ~850 nm show a
radiative lifetime of 5972 ps yielding a Fourier-limited
linewidthof6.93eV,which isingood agreement withthe
observed PL linewidths. Applying a magnetic field in the
Voigt configuration Zeeman splits the ground and excited
statesofthepositivelychargedQDintoaquadrupletasshown
inFig.1(c).ForthisQDwefindgh=0.356andge=0.416,which
aretypicalvaluesforthissample[21],whilethediamagnetic
shift factor was fitted to 3.450.02 eV/T. We further
investigatethisquadrupletwithapolarizationanalysisofthe
PL spectra at maximum magnetic field (Bmax=5 T), which
exhibits crossed polarizations between the inner and outer
transitionsasshowninFig.1(d).Theresultinglevelstructure
isthereforeadouble-system,asshownintheinsetofFig.
1(c). The wavy downward arrows depict the allowed
transitions and their polarizations (blue-vertical and red-
FIG.1(a)Above-bandexcitationpowerdependenceoftheemission
fromtheinvestigatedquantumdot.Saturationoccurs at1.250.05
W driving power. (b) Time resolved QD emissionunder wetting
layerexcitationgivingalifetimeof5972ps.Theinsetdepictsthe
samplesstructure.(c)Zeemansplittingofthechargedquantumdot.
TheinsetshowsthefourlevelstructureofthepositivelychargedQD
underahighmagneticfieldintheVoigtconfiguration,alongwith
theallowedtransitionsandthedrivingschemesinvestigatedinthis
work.(d)PolarizationanalysisofPLspectrumat5Tmagneticfield.
observedspectraasafunctionoftheresonantdrivingpower
forfourdifferentexcitationpolarizationangles.Inparticular,
Fig. 2 corresponds to (a) 94 (4), (b) 100 (10) , (c) 110
(20) and (d) 120 (30) excitation (detection) angles. Note
thattheseanglesarequotedwithrespecttotheQDmainpolarizations,asshowninFig.1(d).Asthedetectionisalways
cross-polarized to the excitation polarization, for the lowest
detectionangles,thetwoinnertransitionsandtheirsidebands
arebarelyvisible,whileforlargeranglestheyareeasiertoperceive.
Themost-strikingelementinallfourpowerdependences
ofFig.2isthatforincreasingpowerstheoutertransitionssplit
intotripletstheMollowtripletsandshowlineardependence
ofthespectralsplittingasafunctionoftheexcitationdriving
fieldupto610-3W.IncontrasttoMollowtripletsgenerated
bystandardtwo-levelsystems,theobservedtripletsgenerated
bythefour-levelsystemarecenteredondifferentenergiesthan
thelaserphotons.Beyondthelow-powerregime,theMollow
triplet splitting becomes comparable to the Zeeman splitting
andanevenmorestrikingphenomenonbecomesapparent:the
Mollow sidebands of the inner transitions spectrally overlap
withtheoutertransitions oftheQDand instead ofcrossing,
they show a clear anticrossing. The interaction strength betweentheunsplitoutertransitionsandtheMollowsidebands
oftheinnertransitionscanbetunedbychangingthepolarizationoftheexcitationlaserasshowninFigs.2(b)-(d).
Inordertounderstandthissurprisingbehavior,wehaveto
takeintoaccounttheeffectofthestrongresonantlaseronthe
levelstructureofthechargedQDintheVoigtmagneticfield.
Inthelaboratoryframe,thestrongresonantdrivingleadstothe
dressingofboththetwogroundandtwoexcitedstatescreating
an8-levelsystemwherealltransitionsareallowed.Alessintuitiveyetmoreappropriatewayofdescribingsuchastrongly
drivensystemisintherotatingframe,wherethesystemisstill
described as a four-level structure and its time independent
Hamiltonianreads
de 2
0
cos i sin
0
de 2
i sin cos
H
(1)
cos i sin d h 2
0
d h 2
i sin cos
inthe , , , basiswhere de and dh aretheexcitedandgroundstateZeemansplittings, isthedrivingfield
strengthand isthelaserpolarizationwithrespecttotheQD
mainpolarizationaxis. o L with o theunsplitexciton energy for zero magnetic field, and L the laser frequency.
TheeigenvaluesofthisHamiltonianprovideasetofquasienergies of the system, whose difference reproduces the observedPLenergiesalongwiththeanticrossingbehavior.The
reddottedlinesontopoftheexperimentaldatainFig.2(a)-(d)
bandsoftheinnertransitionsspectrallyoverlapwiththeMollowsidebandsoftheoutertransitionsshowingaclearcrossing
forallexcitationangles.
Inordertofullycapturetheobservedphenomenologywe
use quantum optical modelling, here implemented using the
quantumtoolboxinPython(QuTiP)[25].Wesolvethequantum-opticalmasterequationofthedensitymatrix
d
i
H ,
dt
cn
(2)
superoperatorofthecollapseoperator cn .
Here, cn
13 , 14 , 23 , 24 isthe sponta-
neousemission,whiletheabove-bandincoherentpumpingis
represented by cn
Pab 13
, Pab 14
, Pab 23
, Pab 24
t Xpol ei d available in
2 Xpol
QuTiP.Themodelfullycapturestheobservedphenomenology
asshowninFig.2(e)-(h).
Additionally,wenoteaninterestingfeatureoftheMollow
spectraatlowpowerthatwebelieveisusefulasageneraltechniqueforchargedQDspectroscopy.Forapositively-charged
QD, when the outer Mollow sidebands are brighter than the
innersidebands,e.g.around0.5W,thenge>gh;thiscanbe
mostclearlyseeninFig.2(d)and(h).Ontheotherhand,ifge
<gh,thentheinnersidebandswouldbebrighterthantheouter
sidebands. Thus through the Mollow luminescence spectra,
onecangaininsightintowhichgfactor,georgh,isthelarger
ofthetwo.
Tofurtherinvestigatetheeffectofthestronglaseronthe
four-levelsystemofourpositivelychargedQD,weresonantly
pumpthetwooutertransitions,asshowninFig.3.InFig.3(a)
wedrivethehighest,whereasinFig.3(b)wedrivethelowest
energytransition.Thestronglaserdrivingleadstothedressing
ofthegroundandexcitedstatesofthetransitionbeingdriven,
whichinturngivesrisetoaMollowtriplet,similartothatofa
regulartwo-levelsystem.However,thisdressingalsoaffects
thetwoinnertransitionsaseachofthemdevelopsintoadoublet.WenotethattheMollowsidebandsofthedriventransitionshowasimplecrossingwiththeinnertransitiondoublets.
FIG. 2(a)-(d)PowerdependentexperimentalPLspectraforaQD
stronglydrivenwithalaserspectrallypositionedin-betweenthetwo
innertransitions(0 eV),forfourdifferentexcitation(detection)angles.Theplotsareshowninlinearcolorscaleandhavetheeigenenergiesofeq.(1)superposedinreddottedline.(e)-(h)Calculatedspectrafromquantumopticalmodelingforthesamepolarizationsettings
asin(a)-(d)respectively.
correspondtotheeigenvaluescalculatedfromHamiltonianin
Eq.(1).Superimposingtheeigenenergiesontheexperimental
datainFigs.2(a)-(d)enablesustofurtheridentifyanotherinteresting anticrossing, between the Mollow sidebands of the
twooutertransitions.Themodelsuggeststhattheanticrossing
splittingbetweenthetwoouter-transitionMollowsidebandsis
twicethesplittingbetweentheinner-transitionMollowsidebandandtheouter-QDtransition.Thetwoaforementionedanticrossingsareinstarkcontrasttothebehaviorseenforlower
drivingpowers.At~4.510-3W,wheretheMollowsideband
splittingisabouthalftheZeemansplitting,theMollowside-
*lagous@stanford.edu
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
FIG.3(a)Powerdependentspectrawhenthelaserisinresonance
withthehighestenergytransitionofthefourlevelsystem(transition
1-4oryellowarrowinFig.1(c))at112eV.Thecolorscaleishere
logarithmictohighlighttheghostbranchesofthetwoinnertransitionswhichappearatenergieshigherthananyoftheQDstatesthat
exist in the lab frame. (b) PL spectrum when pumping the lowest
energytransition(transition2-3orvioletarrowinFig.1(c))at-112
eV.ThereddottedlinesaretheeigenenergiescalculatedfromEq.
(1).(c),(d)Modeledspectrawithparametersthatcorrespondtothe
experimentalconditionsof(a)and(b)respectively.
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
[18]
[19]
[20]
[21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
[25]
[26]
B.R.Mollow,Phys.Rev.188,1969(1969).
F.Schuda,C.R.StroudJr,andM.Hercher,J.Phys.B:At.
Mol.Phys.7,198(1974).
Y.Gu,L.Huang,O.J.F.Martin,andQ.Gong,Phys.Rev.B
81,193103(2010).
M.Baur,S.Filipp,R.Bianchetti,J.M.Fink,M.Gppl,L.Steffen,P.J.Leek,A.Blais,andA.Wallraff,Phys.Rev.Lett.102,
243602(2009).
B.Pigeau,S.Rohr,L.MercierdeLpinay,A.Gloppe,V.
Jacques,andO.Arcizet,NatCommun6,8603(2015).
S.Ates,S.M.Ulrich,S.Reitzenstein,A.Lffler,A.Forchel,
andP.Michler,Phys.Rev.Lett.103,167402(2009).
E. B. Flagg, A. Muller, J. W. Robertson, S. Founta, D. G.
Deppe,M.Xiao,W.Ma,G.J.Salamo,andC.K.Shih,NatPhys
5,203(2009).
R.-C.Ge,S.Weiler,A.Ulhaq,S.M.Ulrich,M.Jetter,P.Michler,andS.Hughes,OpticsLett.38,1691(2013).
B. D. Gerardot, D. Brunner, P. A. Dalgarno, K. Karrai, A.
Badolato,P.M.Petroff,andR.J.Warburton,NewJ.Phys.11,
013028(2009).
F.Hargart,M.Mller,K.Roy-Choudhury,S.L.Portalupi,C.
Schneider, S. Hfling, M. Kamp, S. Hughes, and P. Michler,
Phys.Rev.B93,115308(2016).
G. Jundt, L. Robledo, A. Hgele, S. Flt, and A. Imamolu,
Phys.Rev.Lett.100,177401(2008).
H.Kim,T.C.Shen,K.Roy-Choudhury,G.S.Solomon,andE.
Waks,Phys.Rev.Lett.113,027403(2014).
S. Unsleber, S. Maier, D. P. S. McCutcheon, Y.-M. He, M.
Dambach,M.Gschrey,N.Gregersen,J.Mrk,S.Reitzenstein,
S.Hfling,C.Schneider,andM.Kamp,Optica2,1072(2015).
Y.-J.Wei,Y.He,Y.-M.He,C.-Y.Lu,J.-W.Pan,C.Schneider,
M.Kamp,S.Hfling,D.P.S.McCutcheon,andA.Nazir,Phys.
Rev.Lett.113,097401(2014).
X.Xu, B. Sun,P. R. Berman, D. G. Steel, A. S. Bracker, D.
Gammon,andL.J.Sham,Science317,929(2007).
A.Muller,W.Fang,J.Lawall,andG.S.Solomon,Phys.Rev.
Lett.101,027401(2008).
N.Vamivakas,Y.Zhao,C.-Y.Lu,andM.Atatre,NatPhys5,
198(2009).
C.RoyandS.Hughes,Phys.Rev.Lett.106,247403(2011).
A.Ulhaq,S.Weiler,S.M.Ulrich,R.Robach,M.Jetter,and
P.Michler,NatPhoton6,238(2012).
S.M.Ulrich,S.Ates,S.Reitzenstein,A.Lffler,A.Forchel,
andP.Michler,Phys.Rev.Lett.106,247402(2011).
Seesupplementarymaterialformoreinformation.
K.G.Lagoudakis,K.A.Fischer,T.Sarmiento,K.Mueller,
andJ.Vukovi,Phys.Rev.B90,121402(2014).
J.Bennett,J.P.Lee,D.J.P.Ellis,T.Meany,E.Murray,F.F.
Floether, J. P. Griffths, I. Farrer, D. A. Ritchie, and A. J.
Shields,ScienceAdv.2,e1501256(2016).
H. S. Nguyen, G. Sallen, C. Voisin, P. Roussignol, C.
Diederichs, and G. Cassabois, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 057401
(2012).
J.R.Johansson,P.D.Nation,andF.Nori,ComputerPhysics
Communications184,1234(2013).
M.Peiris,B.Petrak,K.Konthasinghe,Y.Yu,Z.C.Niu,and
A.Muller,Phys.Rev.B91,195125(2015).
This document provides supplemental material for the Letter Observation of Mollow Triplets with Tunable Interactions in
Double Lambda Systems of Individual Hole Spins. In particular, we provide more detailed information on the magnetic
spectroscopy of the QD studied in this work as well as statistics for the charged quantum dot g factors. In addition we explain
in detail the differential spectroscopy method that we used for the observation of Mollow triplets with tunable interactions.
FIG. S1. (a) PL spectra of the QD studied in this Letter under zero
magnetic field. (b) Waterfall plot of PL spectra for increasing
magnetic field. (c) Raw peak locations for the two inner and two
outer transitions extracted from multi peak fitting. (d) Center-ofmass energy of the two outer transitions. A quadratic fit allows
estimation of the diamagnetic shift factor.
FIG. S3. (a) Raw power dependent experimental PL spectra for the
QD studied in this Letter when it is driven with a combination of an
above-band laser of fixed power and a resonant laser with variable
power, spectrally positioned in-between the two inner transitions (0
eV), for 120/30 excitation/detection angles. (b) Raw power
dependent spectra with only resonant laser on. Subtraction of (b)
from (a) results in the data presented in the manuscript (in particular
Fig. 2(d)). Note that both graphs are presented in log colorscale to
enable the reader to identify the lines coming from the strongly
driven four-level system.