Bird Bat Mortality Report Summary (Draft)

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0B24A4SH_cewXV0VhTENxTGp3LVk
Source:
Facility

Adelaide
Adelaide
Arthur
Arthur
Arthur
Bluewater
Bornish
Caribou
Caribou
Comber
Comber
Comber
Conestoga
Conestoga
Conestoga
Cruikshank
Cruikshank
Cruikshank
Cruikshank
Dufferin
East Lake St. Clair
East Lake St. Clair
Erieu
Erieu
Enbridge
Enbridge
Enbridge
Enbridge
Erie Shores
Ernestown
Gesner
Gesner
Gesner
Gosfield
Gosfield
Goshen
Goulais
Gracey
Gracey
Gracey
Grand
Grand Valley
Grand Valley
Grand Valley
Greenwich
Greenwich
Harrow
Harrow
Harrow
Harrow
Jericho
Kent Breeze
Kent Breeze
Kent Breeze
Kent Breeze
Kent Hills
Kent Hills
Kent Hills
Kingsbridge I
McLean's Mountain
Melancthon I
Melancthon I
Melancthon II
Melancthon II
Mohawk Point
Mohawk Point
Mohawk Point
Mohawk Point
Mohawk Point
Naylor
Naylor
Naylor
North Malden
North Malden
North Malden
Oxley
Oxley
Plateau
Plateau
Plateau
Pointe Aux Roches
Pointe Aux Roches
Pointe Aux Roches
Port Alma
Port Alma
Port Alma
Port Dover
Port Dover
Prince
Prince
Proofline
Proofline
Proofline
Providence Bay
Quixote One
Raleigh
Raleigh
Raleigh
Raleigh
Ravenswood
Richardson
Richardson
Ripley
Skyway
South Branch
South Branch
South Kent
South Kent
South Side
South Side
South Side
Springwood
Summerhaven
Summerhaven
Talbot
Talbot
Talbot
Whittington
Wolfe Island
Wolfe Island
Wolfe Island
Wolfe Island

Turbines

37
18
5
5
5
37
45
33
33
72
72
72
10
10
10
5
5
5
5
49
55
55
55
55
110
110
110
110
66
5
5
5
5
22
22
63
11
5
5
5
67
9
9
9
43
43
24
24
24
24
92
8
8
8
8
18
18
18
22
24
45
45
133
133
6
6
6
6
6
5
5
5
5
5
5
3
3
18
18
18
27
27
27
44
44
44
58
58
126
126
4
4
4
2
1
52
52
52
52
6
5
5
38
5
10
10
124
124
5
5
5
4
56
56
43
43
43
3
86
86
86
86
4126

Company

Nextera
Suncor
Schneider Power
Schneider Power
Schneider Power
Nextera
Nextera
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
Brookfield
Brookfield
Brookfield
Nextera
Nextera
Nextera
Enbridge
Enbridge
Enbridge
Enbridge
Dufferin Wind
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
Enbridge
Enbridge
Enbridge
Enbridge
GDF Suez
Wintergreen Co-op
Saturn Power
Saturn Power
Saturn Power
Brookfield
Brookfield
Nextera
Capstone
Boralex
Boralex
Boralex
Samsung
Veresen
Veresen
Veresen
Enbridge
Enbridge
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
Nextera
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
Capital Power
Northland Power
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
Boralex
Boralex
Boralex
Boralex
Boralex
Boralex
Estil
Estil
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
GDF Suez
Kruger
Kruger
Kruger
Capital Power
Capital Power
Brookfield
Brookfield
Sky Generation
Sky Generation
Sky Generation
Leader Resources
Leader Resources
Invergy
Invergy
Invergy
Invergy
Sky Generation
Boralex
Boralex
Suncor
Capstone
EDP Renewables
EDP Renewables
Samsung
Samsung
Boralex
Boralex
Boralex
wpd Canada
Nextera
Nextera
Enbridge
Enbridge
Enbridge
wpd Canada
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta
TransAlta

Location

Red indicates kills exceed threshold

Year

Birds Killed/Year
Per Turbine Per Facility

Bats Killed/Year
Per Turbine Per Facility

MNFR Mortality
Threshold = 14

MNFR Mortality
Threshold = 10

Middlesex, ON
2015
Middlesex, ON
2015
Wellington North, ON
2013
Wellington North, ON
2011
Wellington North, ON
2012
Huron East, ON
2015
Middlesex, ON
2015
Bathurst, NB
2011
Bathurst, NB
2010
Essex County, ON
2013
Essex County, ON
2014
Essex County, ON
2015
Wellington, ON
2013
Wellington, ON
2014
Wellington, ON
2015
Bruce ON
2009
Bruce ON
2010
Bruce ON
2012
Bruce ON
2013
Dufferin, ON
2015
Chatham-Kent, ON
2014
Chatham-Kent, ON
2015
Chatham-Kent, ON
2014
Chatham-Kent, ON
2015
Bruce ON
2009
Bruce ON
2010
Bruce ON
2012
Bruce ON
2013
Elgin, ON
2008
Loyalist Twp, ON
2016
Chatham-Kent, ON
2013
Chatham-Kent, ON
2014
Chatham-Kent, ON
2015
Essex County, ON
2011
Essex County, ON
2012
South Huron, ON
2015
Sault Ste. Marie, ON
2015
Chatham-Kent, ON
2011
Chatham-Kent, ON
2012
Chatham-Kent, ON
2013
Haldimand, ON
2015
Dufferin, ON
2012
Dufferin, ON
2013
Dufferin, ON
2014
Thunder Bay, ON
2012
Thunder Bay, ON
2013
Essex County, ON
2010
Essex County, ON
2011
Essex County, ON
2012
Essex County, ON
2013
Lambton, ON
2015
Chatham-Kent, ON
2011
Chatham-Kent, ON
2012
Chatham-Kent, ON
2013
Chatham-Kent, ON
2014
Albert County, NB
2010
Albert County, NB
2011
Albert County, NB
2012
Huron, ON
2006
Thunder Bay, ON
2015
Dufferin, ON
2006
Dufferin, ON
2007
Dufferin, ON
2009
Dufferin, ON
2010
Norfolk, ON
2009
Norfolk, ON
2010
Norfolk, ON
2011
Norfolk, ON
2012
Norfolk, ON
2013
Essex County, ON
2013
Essex County, ON
2011
Essex County, ON
2012
Essex County, ON
2011
Essex County, ON
2012
Essex County, ON
2013
Essex County, ON
2014
Essex County, ON
2014
Grey, ON
2012
Grey, ON
2013
Grey, ON
2014
Tilbury, ON
2012
Tilbury, ON
2013
Tilbury, ON
2014
Chatham-Kent, ON
2010
Chatham-Kent, ON
2011
Chatham-Kent, ON
2012
Norfolk/Haldimand, ON 2014
Norfolk/Haldimand, ON 2015
Sault Ste. Marie, ON
2007
Sault Ste. Marie, ON
2008
Lambton Shores, ON
2010
Lambton Shores, ON
2011
Lambton Shores, ON
2012
Providence Bay, ON
2013
Bruce County, ON
2015
Chatham-Kent, ON
2011
Chatham-Kent, ON
2012
Chatham-Kent, ON
2013
Chatham-Kent, ON
2014
Lambton, ON
2009
Essex County, ON
2012
Essex County, ON
2011
Bruce County, ON
2009
Grey/Dufferin, ON
2015
South Dundas, ON
2014
South Dundas, ON
2015
Chatham-Kent, ON
2014
Chatham-Kent, ON
2015
Essex County, ON
2011
Essex County, ON
2012
Essex County, ON
2013
Wellington, ON
2015
Haldimand, ON
2014
Haldimand, ON
2015
Chatham-Kent, ON
2011
Chatham-Kent, ON
2012
Chatham-Kent, ON
2013
Amaranth, ON
2015
Frontenac, ON
2009
Frontenac, ON
2009-2010
Frontenac, ON
2010-2011
Frontenac, ON
2011-2012

2.32
2.32
3.25
5.00
23.98
3.97
2.17
1.14
0.16
8.93
4.59
3.91
5.03
2.83
3.13
1.49
1.87
1
0.63
3.73
2.33
3.03
2.08
2.99
2.70
1.25
0.37
1.73
2.50
1.40
3.16
3.32
4.86
5.02
9.13
4.04
9.79
5.53
2.25
3.21
2.17
3.78
6.59
2.27
1.44
1.78
2.73
2.59

8.57
8.57
7.47
23.07
58.94
9.14
9.01
0.74
0.00
14.92
9.93
8.41
9.81
7.02
9.27
17.07
28.94
7.41
20.02
11.44
14.02
7.90
9.85
10.76
19.72
12.83
14.64
17.68
5.50
23.40
27.47
11.75
8.32
14.19
19.25
9.61
16.69
22.76
23.46
7.50
12.83
24.11
4.52
4.42
5.06
3.73
18.36
19.91
9.45
9.90
9.64
11.27
7.60
4.20
4.70
0.10
0.95
0.25

317.1
154.26
37.4
115.4
294.7
338.2
405.5
24.4
0.0
1074.2
715.0
605.5
98.1
70.2
92.7
85.4
144.7
37.1
100.1
560.6
771.1
434.5
541.8
591.8
2169.4
1411.3
1610.4
1944.8
363.0
117.0
137.4
58.8
41.6
312.2
423.5
605.4
183.6
113.8
117.3
37.5
859.6
217.0
40.7
39.8
217.6
160.4
440.6
477.8
226.8
237.6
886.9
90.2
60.8
33.6
37.6
1.8
17.1
4.5

2.14

7.26
8.00
13.26
5.68
6.82
3.05
4.24
5.93
3.48
3.29

23.8
0.0
63.0
0.0
363.1
18.1
10.4
25.0
0.0
0.0
36.3
40.0
66.3
28.4
34.1
15.3
12.7
17.8
62.6
59.2

11.73
3.03

316.7
81.8

5.56
5.77
1.95
2.99
1.36
1.33

244.6
253.9
85.8
173.4
78.9
0.0
167.6

2.74
0.00
2.68
4.03

5.5
0.0
139.4
209.6

0.78
3.26
3.42
3.01
1.45
3.34
1.12
2.43
3.69
6.59
11.14
4.05
0
3.91
5.39
1.49
5.1

4.7
16.3
17.1
114.4
7.3
33.4
11.2
301.3
457.6
33.0
55.7
20.3
0.0
219.0
301.8
64.1
219.3

0.97
6.99
13.4
1.53
2.12

2.9
601.1
1152.4
131.6
182.3
11887.55

51.4
0.0
198.0
0.0
573.2
311.0
276.7
512.5
303.3
145.6
41.2
150.0
149.4
158.0
232.4
59.8
25.1
34.1
437.58
70.56
57.96
523.53
111.78
273.51
696.08
483.56
413.60
535.92
497.64
0.00
452.34
13.60
124.00
28.80
5.22
0.00
451.88
1226.16
602.16
540.80
41.82
59.20
50.00
494.00
32.45
185.10
60.50
908.92
1206.52
89.05
136.30
50.80
45.20
1399.44
451.36
337.55
1144.23
533.63
25.71
1270.22
1719.14

1.73
7.36
9.50
6.65
4.95
0.39
1.41
1.01
0.99
1.40
2.73
3.02
1.73
4.16

4.40
4.31
51.84
46.11
85.42
50.55
24.27
8.24
30.00
29.87
31.60
46.48
11.96
8.37
11.38
24.31
3.92
3.22
19.39
4.14
10.13
15.82
10.99
9.40
9.24
8.58
3.59
3.40
31.00
7.20
2.61
0.00
8.69
23.58
11.58
10.40
6.97
11.84
10.00
13.00
6.49
18.51
6.05
7.33
9.73
17.81
27.26
10.16
11.30
24.99
8.06
7.85
26.61
12.41
8.57
14.77
19.99
1.23

Estimated Raptors Killed Year

Actual
Per Turbine Per Facility
Raptors
Found
Dead
0.17
6.3
9
0.51
9.2
5
0.00
0.0
0
0.00
0.0
0
0.00
0.0
0
0.09
3.3
5
0.42
18.9
13

MNFR Mortality
Threshold = 0.2

85.8
41.76
16.3
25.0
119.9
146.9
97.7
37.6
5.3
643.0
330.5
281.5
50.3
28.3
31.3
7.5
9.4
5.0
3.2
182.8
128.2
166.7
114.4
164.5
297.0
137.5
40.7
190.3
165.0
7.0
15.8
16.6
24.3
110.4
200.9
254.5
107.7
27.7
11.3
16.1
145.4
34.0
59.3
20.4
61.9
76.5
65.5
62.2
0.0
0.0
159.2
58.9
76.0
53.2
39.6
7.0
25.4
18.2

105.78
42422.03

0.13
0.38
0.62
0.10
0.10
0.00
0.34
0.00
0.74
0.00
0.07
0.16
0.00
0.15
0.00
0.07
0.00

9.4
27.4
44.6
1.0
1.0
0.0
1.7
0.0
3.7
0.0
3.4
8.8
0.0
8.3
0.0
7.8
0.0

0.37
0.04
0.00
0.00
0.33
0.20
0.45
0.59
0.03
0.00

40.7
2.6
0.0
0.0
1.7
1.0
9.9
13.0
1.9
0.0

0.25
0.00
0.56
0.00
0.00
0.06

16.8
0.0
5.0
0.0
0.0
2.6

0.44
0.21
0.00
0.15
0.15

40.5
1.7
0.0
1.2
1.2

0.00

0.08

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
10.0

0.00
0.00

0.0
0.0

0.14

2.5

0.13

3.5

0.12
0.13
0.00

5.3
7.5
0.0

0.00
0.08

0.0
4.2

0.00

0.0

0.09
0.17
0.20
0.00

11.2
21.1
1.0
0.0

0.28
0.44
0.08

15.7
24.6
3.4

0.15
0.27
0.19
0.44

12.9
23.2
16.3
37.8
494.7

9
11
1
2
0
1
0
2
0
3
5
1
6
8
7
1
0
2
2/year
0
0
2
2

4
0
0
0
1
8
0
3
0
1
1
0
0
1
1
23
1
0
1
1

Owl

0
0

8.0
10.0
0
1
0
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
0

0
1
0
0
1
1
1
3
4
8
2
3
1
0
0
0
0
0
2
1

0
0
0
2
0
0
0
12
7
2
0
0
0
16
11
2
1
1
0
12
10

Pereg. Falcon

Bald Eagle
Bald Eagle

11

These wind projects did not have data collected yet or did not submit data to the MNRF
Armow
92
Samsung
Huron, ON
2016
Belle River
41
Samsung
Essex County, ON
2017
Bow Lake
36
BlueEarth
Algoma, ON
2015
CAW
1
CAW
Huron East, ON
2013
Cedar Point
46
Suncor
Lambton, ON
2016
Clear Creek
6
GDF Suez
Norfolk, ON
2008
Cultus
6
GDF Suez
Norfolk, ON
2008
East Durham
14
NextEra
Durham, ON
2015
Exhibition Place
1
Windshare
Toronto, ON
2003
Ferndale I
1
Capstone
Bruce County, ON
2002
Ferndale II
2
Capstone
Bruce County, ON
2006
Frogmore
6
GDF Suez
Norfolk, ON
2008
Ganaraska
9
ZEP
Durham, ON
2015
Grand Bend
48
Northland Power
Huron, ON
2016
Grand Valley III
17
Veresen
Dufferin, ON
2016
Grey Highlands
9
ZEP
Grey, ON
2015
Gunns Hill
10
Prowind
Oxford, ON
2016
HAF
5
Vineland, IPC
Niagara, ON
2014
Huron
5
Enbridge
Huron, ON
2002
K2
140
Samsung, Capital
Huron, ON
2015
MERE
2
Mother Earth
Manitoulin, ON
2012
Napier
2
wpd Canada
Middlesex, ON
2014
Niagara Region
77
Boralex
Niagara, ON
2016
North Kent
36
Samsung
Chatham-Kent, ON
2016
OPG Gomberg
1
OPG
Pickering, ON
2001
Port Albert
1
EPCOR
Huron, ON
2001
Port Burwell
66
GDF Suez
Norfolk, ON
2006
Port Ryerse
4
Boralex
Norfolk, ON
2015
Rosa Flora
1
Rosa Flora
Dunnville, ON
2006
Snowy Ridge
5
Capstone
Grey, ON
2015
St. Columban
15
Veresen
Huron, ON
2015
Sumac Ridge
5
wpd Canada
Kawartha Lakes, ON
2016
Wainfleet
5
Rankin, IPC
Niagara, ON
2014
Zephyr
4
Green Breeze, Schneider
Lambton, ON
2012