Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ecology 2007
76, 415 423
Summary
1. Some species have expanded their ranges during recent climate warming and the
availability of breeding habitat and species dispersal ability are two important factors
determining expansions. The exploitation of a wide range of larval host plants should
increase an herbivorous insect species ability to track climate by increasing habitat
availability. Therefore we investigated whether the performance of a species on different
host plants changed towards its range boundary, and under warmer temperatures.
2. We studied the polyphagous butterfly Polygonia c-album, which is currently expanding
its range in Britain and apparently has altered its host plant preference from Humulus
lupulus to include other hosts (particularly Ulmus glabra and Urtica dioica). We investigated insect performance (development time, larval growth rate, adult size, survival)
and adult flight morphology on these host plants under four rearing temperatures (18
285 C) in populations from core and range margin sites.
3. In general, differences between core and margin populations were small compared
with effects of rearing temperature and host plant. In terms of insect performance, host
plants were generally ranked U. glabra U. dioica > H. lupulus at all temperatures.
Adult P. c-album can either enter diapause or develop directly and higher temperatures
resulted in more directly developing adults, but lower survival rates (particularly on the
original host H. lupulus) and smaller adult size.
4. Adult flight morphology of wild-caught individuals from range margin populations
appeared to be related to increased dispersal potential relative to core populations.
However, there was no difference in laboratory reared individuals, and conflicting results
were obtained for different measures of flight morphology in relation to larval host
plant and temperature effects, making conclusions about dispersal potential difficult.
5. Current range expansion of P. c-album is associated with the exploitation of more
widespread host plants on which performance is improved. This study demonstrates how
polyphagy may enhance the ability of species to track climate change. Our findings suggest
that observed differences in climate-driven range shifts of generalist vs. specialist species may
increase in the future and are likely to lead to greatly altered community composition.
Key-words: climate change, dispersal, distribution, host shift, Lepidoptera.
Journal of Animal Ecology (2007) 76, 415423
doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2656.2007.01217.x
Introduction
During current climate warming, some insect species
are expanding their distributions northwards to track
climate changes (Parmesan & Yohe 2003; Root et al.
2003). However, not all species are responding and the
Correspondence and present address: Brigitte Braschler, Biodiversity and Macroecology Group, Department of Animal
and Plant Sciences, University of Sheffield, Sheffield S10 2TN,
UK. E-mail: b.braschler@sheffield.ac.uk
416
B. Braschler
& J. K. Hill
During April 2004, adult females were collected from
two sites in Britain; a core site in south Wales (Wye
Valley, Ordnance Survey 10-km grid reference ST 59;
Fig. 1) where P. c-album apparently persisted during
the nineteenth century range contraction (Pratt 1987),
and a margin site in northern England (York, SE 53;
Fig. 1) which according to recent sightings was recolonized in 1993 (Biological Records Centre data,
CEH Monks Wood). Four females from each site were
used to establish breeding lines for experiments. We also
collected males from each study site, as well as from two
additional sites in central England (Nottingham, SK 63,
re-colonized in 1985; Fig. 1), and in north-east England
(Newcastle, NZ 15, re-colonized in 1995; Fig. 1). Overall,
we collected 12 females (four from Wye Valley, and eight
from York) and 35 males (six from Wye Valley, six from
Nottingham, 12 from York, and 11 from Newcastle).
All wild-caught individuals were used to investigate
differences in adult flight morphology among sites
in relation to range expansion. Four females from the
York site did not lay fertile eggs and were also included
in this analysis.
Wild-collected females were allowed to lay eggs on potted
U. dioica plants in a greenhouse. In order to produce
sufficient insect material for the rearing experiments
and to maintain genetic diversity, F1 female offspring
417
Host plant and
range expansion
Fig. 1. Recent range expansion and present distribution of Polygonia c-album in Britain, and location of study sites. Distribution
records (10-km grid resolution) are plotted for two time periods corresponding with the publication of two butterfly atlases
(Heath, Pollard & Thomas 1984; Asher et al. 2001). Collection sites are from north to south: Newcastle (re-colonized in 1995),
York (1993), Nottingham (1985) and Wye Valley (core site). Females from York and Wye Valley were used in the laboratory
experiments, wild-caught individuals from all sites were used to determine differences in flight morphology between core and
range margin sites. Histogram bars show the number of 10-km Ordnance Survey grid cells with records of the species for each
decade of the twentieth century (P. c-album distribution data provided from the Butterflies for the New Millennium project,
courtesy of Butterfly Conservation and Biological Records Centre).
Direct measures of dispersal are difficult to obtain in
insects (particularly in highly mobile species such as
P. c-album) and many studies have thus inferred dispersal
potential from indirect measures of adult flight morphology. In butterflies, individuals with greater flight
ability generally have relatively larger, broader thoraxes
(comprising predominantly flight muscle, e.g. Berwaerts,
Van Dyck & Aerts 2002). Therefore measures of adult
flight morphology were used in this study as an index
of dispersal ability. We measured thorax shape (width
418
B. Braschler
& J. K. Hill
Results
In total, we analysed data from 1252 F2 laboratory
reared individuals and from 47 wild-caught adults. Overall, females had broader thoraxes than males (F1,1038 = 906,
P = 00027) but males had relatively heavier thoraxes
than females (F1,1035 = 117267, P < 00001), indicating no
clear pattern in our indices of dispersal ability between
the sexes. Larval growth rates did not differ between the
sexes, but adult males completed their development faster
than females (F1,1035 = 1592, P < 00001) because they
were smaller than females (F1,1036 = 6608, P < 00001).
419
Host plant and
range expansion
Fig. 2. Proportion of directly developing P. c-album adults from a range margin (hollow bars) and core (solid bars) population
reared under four different temperatures and on three different host plants. Upper row: females, lower row: males. Ug = U. glabra,
Hl = H. lupulus, Ud = U. dioica.
Survival decreased with increasing temperature (F3,1150 =
622, P = 00003; Fig. 4) and was poorest on H. lupulus
compared with the other two host plants (F2,1150 = 3003,
P < 00001). Lower survival on H. lupulus was most
evident at high temperatures (285 C: 81% survival on
H. lupulus vs. 446% on U. glabra and 490% on U. dioica;
Fig. 4) while survival was similarly high on all three host
plants at low temperatures (e.g. 18 C: 606% survival on
H. lupulus vs. 636% on U. glabra and 676% on U. dioica;
temperature host plant interaction: F6,1150 = 283,
P = 00096; Fig. 4).
In general, effects of temperature and host plant were
similar between core and margin populations. Overall,
performance on the novel host plants was much better
than on H. lupulus regardless of temperature treatment
or population. However, there were some differences in
the ranking of the two novel larval host plants. While there
420
B. Braschler
& J. K. Hill
Fig. 4. Survival of P. c-album from a range margin (hollow bars) and core (solid bars) population reared under four different
temperatures and on three different host plants. Ug = U. glabra, Hl = H. lupulus, Ud = U. dioica.
Table 1. Performance of P. c-album on three different host plants (H. lupulus = original host, U. glabra and U. dioica are new
hosts). Results from Generalized Linear Models on ln-transformed variables. Back-transformed mean SEs are shown
Larval host plant
H. lupulus
U. glabra
U. dioica
d.f.
110 10
206 10
2262 10
313 10
328 10
161 10
172 10
2765 10
262 10
448 10
146 10
185 10
2700 10
271 10
463 10
2
2
2
2
2
16355
4706
13118
2852
25220
< 00001
< 00001
< 00001
< 00001
< 00001
Discussion
Polygonia c-album has shown the fastest rate of range
expansion of any resident butterfly species in Britain
during recent climate warming and is one of only a few
species that appears to be tracking climate changes
(Warren et al. 2001). In this study, we showed that both
adult flight morphology and insect performance depended
on the host plant used, as well as on temperature during
development (Janz et al. 1994; Wedell et al. 1997). In
addition, there were interaction effects between temperature and host plant, as well as between host plant and
population, showing that the consequences of developing
on different host plants may vary across the species
range, and with climate change. Overall, both novel
hosts were better than H. lupulus but U. glabra was the
superior host in the margin population while there were
few differences between U. glabra and U. dioica in the
core population. Interestingly, feeding on H. lupulus
led to greatest investment in the abdomen in the core
population, but was inferior to U. dioica in the margin
population. Thus the only instance where we found
421
Host plant and
range expansion
Individuals from recently founded populations at the
expanding range margin would be expected to have greater
dispersal ability compared with individuals from core
populations (Thomas et al. 2001; Travis & Dytham 2002;
Simmons & Thomas 2004). Indeed flight morphology
in wild-caught males indicated higher dispersal ability
at the range margin in this study. This was apparently due
to different environmental conditions at the study sites
(e.g. habitat quality) rather than due to any evolutionary
changes during range expansion because differences in
flight morphology were not evident between core and
margin populations when individuals were reared under
controlled conditions in the laboratory. Moreover, in
laboratory reared individuals, measures of thorax shape
and relative thorax mass gave conflicting results. Although
measures of flight morphology have been successfully
used in the past to deduce dispersal potential (Berwaerts
et al. 2002) our findings suggest that the relation between
thorax mass and shape is not straightforward in this
species. Wild-caught material was obtained from sites
spanning a greater range of distances from the range
margin, and thus may have had increased genetic
variation compared with laboratory reared individuals,
which may have affected our results. However, given that
few differences between core and margin populations were
detected in any of our measures of insect performance
it is possible that evolutionary changes during range
expansion play a minor role in such a mobile species
(Nylin et al. 2005). The absence of a clear adaptation to
the original host in the core population could also be
explained by high mobility and gene flow back into
the core.
In relation to insect performance, host plants were
generally ranked U. glabra U. dioica > H. lupulus and
this ranking was not significantly affected by temperature. Differences between U. glabra and U. dioica were
relatively small compared with large differences between
these two host plants and H. lupulus, which was the
poorest host plant. Individuals on U. glabra completed
their development the fastest, and individuals reared
on U. glabra and U. dioica also had higher survival and
larger adult size than those on H. lupulus, confirming
that U. glabra and U. dioica are high ranking host plants
for P. c-album (Nylin & Janz 1993; Janz et al. 1994; Nylin
& Janz 1996; Nylin, Bergstrom & Janz 2000). Higher
temperatures also increased the proportion of directly
developing individuals on both of these host plants.
Thus overall we would expect the use of U. glabra and
U. dioica to increase the rate of range expansion of
P. c-album relative to using H. lupulus, especially under
increasing temperatures.
There is little information on the degree to which
P. c-album utilized U. dioica or U. glabra historically in
Britain except for anecdotal evidence that the first
generation may have used U. dioica early in the season
when H. lupulus had not yet developed sufficiently (Pratt
1987). However, the ability to exploit different host plants
may be facilitated if larvae retain the ability to develop on
former host plants even when the oviposition preferences
of the adults change (Janz, Nyblom & Nylin 2001). For
example, P. c-album is now exploiting U. dioica, which is
an ancestral host plant that is exploited by many other
closely related Nymphalini species and is also used by
many European populations of P. c-album (Janz et al.
2001). In addition, the three host plants examined in this
study are all closely related and comprise an ancestral
host plant clade for Polygonia species (Weingartner,
Wahlberg & Nylin 2006) and this may also explain the
shift on to new host plants by this species.
P. c-album uses different host plants throughout its
European range, and the degree of specialization on
different host plants varies geographically (Janz 1998).
H. lupulus is apparently the historically preferred host
plant in Britain (Pratt 1986, 1987), but our results showed
it is generally a poor host plant in both core and margin
sites. However, an historical advantage of H. lupulus may
have been its wide availability through cultivation for
the beer industry, particularly if such sites were situated
in warm locations (e.g. south-facing slopes). In addition,
our laboratory reared larvae were provided with highquality young leaves from a single location, but plant
quality may vary across the butterfly range, or with
temperature, and this deserves further study.
Further range expansion of P. c-album will be influenced
by the distribution of the host plant species within
Britain. H. lupulus is common in the south of Britain where
P. c-album is now ubiquitous, but is rare in the north
where the other host plants occur widely (Preston,
Pearman & Dines 2002). H. lupulus may increase its
distribution with climate warming, but exploitation of
U. dioica and U. glabra that occur widely in northern
Britain will allow the mobile insect to colonize new areas
without waiting for range expansion of its original
422
B. Braschler
& J. K. Hill
Species are predicted to shift their distributions polewards
in order to track future climate warming (Hill, Thomas
& Huntley 1999; Hill et al. 2002; Thomas et al. 2004).
However, range shifts are likely to be limited to mobile
generalists, such as P. c-album, where range expansion
is not limited by the loss and fragmentation of natural
habitats (Warren et al. 2001). Results from this study
illustrate the flexibility of polyphagous generalist species
and demonstrate how the incorporation of novel host
plants into larval diets may result in species having
greatly enhanced abilities to track climatic changes. Our
results indicate that this flexibility may lead to unexpectedly rapid range expansion in generalist species, and
that current host plant preferences may underestimate
future range changes in some species. The degree to which
similar host-plant shifts will occur in other species
remains to be seen, but such shifts are likely to be the
exception rather than the rule. What is more clear is
that tracking of twenty-first century climate warming is
likely to be restricted to generalist and mobile species
of relatively low conservation value, and that this may
lead to greatly altered community composition in the
future (Menndez et al. 2006).
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the Forestry Commission and
Tilhill Forestry Ltd for permission to work at their
sites. Sren Nylin and Nina Wedell gave helpful advice
on insect rearing, and Tim Yardley helped setting up
the experiment. We thank Butterfly Conservation and
the Biological Records Centre (CEH-Monks Wood) for
P. c-album distribution data. Comments by Thomas
Merckx and two anonymous referees improved an
earlier version of the manuscript. The project was
funded by NERC.
References
Asher, J., Warren, M., Fox, R., Harding, P., Jeffcoate, G. &
Jeffcoate, S. (2001) The Millenium Atlas of Butterflies in
Britain and Ireland. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Berlocher, S.H. & Feder, J.L. (2002) Sympatric speciation in
phytophagous insects: Moving beyond controversy? Annual
Review of Entomology, 47, 773815.
Berwaerts, K., Van Dyck, H. & Aerts, P. (2002) Does flight
morphology relate to flight performance? An experimental
test with the butterfly Pararge aegeria. Functional Ecology,
16, 484 491.
Brown, J.H. (1984) On the relationship between abundance and
distribution of species. American Naturalist, 124, 255279.
Coll, M. & Yuval, B. (2004) Larval food plants affect flight
and reproduction in an oligophagous insect herbivore.
Environmental Entomology, 33, 14711476.
Crozier, L.G. (2004) Field transplants reveal summer constraints
on a butterfly range expansion. Oecologia, 141, 148157.
423
Host plant and
range expansion
Nymphalidae): the choice between bad and worse. Ecological Entomology, 18, 394398.
Nylin, S. & Janz, N. (1996) Host plant preferences in the
comma butterfly (Polygonia c-album): Do parents and
offspring agree? Ecoscience, 3, 285289.
Nylin, S., Bergstrom, A. & Janz, N. (2000) Butterfly host plant
choice in the face of possible confusion. Journal of Insect
Behaviour, 13, 469482.
Nylin, S., Nygren, G.H., Windig, J.J., Janz, N. & Bergstrom, A.
(2005) Genetics of host-plant preference in the comma
butterfly Polygonia c-album (Nymphalidea), and evolutionary implications. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society,
84, 755765.
Parmesan, C. & Yohe, G. (2003) A globally coherent fingerprint of climate change impacts across natural systems.
Nature, 421, 3742.
Pratt, C. (1986) A history and investigation into the fluctuations
of Polygonia c-album L. the Comma butterfly. Entomologists
Record and Journal of Variation, 98, 197203, 24450.
Pratt, C. (1987) A history and investigation into the fluctuations
of Polygonia c-album L. the Comma butterfly. Entomologists Record and Journal of Variation, 99, 2127, 6980.
Preston, C.D., Pearman, D.A. & Dines, T.D., eds (2002) New
Atlas of the British and Irish Flora. Oxford University Press,
Oxford.
Root, T.L., Price, J.T., Hall, K.R., Schneider, S.H., Rosenzweig,
C. & Pounds, J.A. (2003) Fingerprints of global warming on
wild animals and plants. Nature, 421, 5760.
Simmons, A.D. & Thomas, C.D. (2004) Changes in dispersal
during species range expansions. American Naturalist,
164, 378395.
Singer, M.C. & Thomas, C.D. (1996) Evolutionary responses
of a butterfly metapopulation to human- and climate-caused
environmental variation. American Naturalist, 148, S9S39.