You are on page 1of 35

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 1 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

1 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
DATE
ADMITTED

DATE
MARKED

EXHIBIT
NO.
1

WITNESS

DESCRIPTION

T. Petrie

Court Order in Case #CV-S-98-531-JBR(RJJ)


dated 11/3/98

T. Petrie

T. Petrie

U.S Court of Appeals 9th Circuit


Memorandum Case #98-17293 re: D.C. Case
#CV-S-98-531-JBR(RJJ) filed 7/22/99
Judgment in a Civil Case No. CV-S-98-531-JBR
(RJJ) dated 9/17/99

T. Petrie

Court Order in Case No. CV-S-98-531-JBR(RJJ)


filed 9/17/99

T. Petrie

Court Order in Case No.2:12-cv-0804-LDGGWF filed 7/9/13

T. Petrie

Court Order to Enforce Injunction in Case No.


2:98-cv-00531-LRH-VCF filed 10/9/13

T. Petrie

Deposition of Cliven Bundy of 10/23/2012

R. Stover
D. Love

Notice of Intent to Impound Unauthorized


Livestock dated 3/19/14

R. Stover

News Now Article of 4/4/14: "Feds: Nevada


Rancher Facing Off Over Public Lands"

10

R. Stover

4/9/14 Facebook Posts from the We


Support Cliven Bundy page

11

R. Stover

4/11/14 Facebook Posts from the We


Support Cliven Bundy page

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 2 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

2 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
4/11/14 Facebook Posts from "The
Resistance 2012" page

12

R. Stover

13

M. Johnson

14

R. Stover
J. Willis

3/28/14 BLM Video of Incident Command


Post

15

M. Hauck
A. Sully

Photo: 4/7/14 of Dave Bundy

16

M. Hauck
A. Sully

Photo: 4/7/14 Sign "Freedom for God"

17

M. Hauck

Video of 4/7/14 Depicting Staging Area

18

M. Hauck
A. Sully

Photo: 4/7/14 Depicting Staging Area

19

M. Hauck
A. Sully

Photo: 4/7/14 taken on SR170 near Staging


Area

20

M. Hauck
A. Sully

Photo: 4/7/14 Depicting Staging Area

21

M. Hauck
A. Sully

Photo: 4/7/14 Depicting Staging Area

22

M. Hauck
A. Sully

Photo: 4/7/14 Depicting Rally Site

3/17/14 Audio Recording of Ryan Bundy

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 3 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

3 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
23

M. Seyler

4/7/14 Facebook Post on Carol Bundy's page

24

M. Carpenter
S. Swanson

4/9/14 Dashcam Footage on Riverside Road

25

M. Seyler

4/8/14 Facebook Personal Message from


Carol Bundy's page

26

M. Seyler

4/8/14 Facebook Personal Message from


Carol Bundy's page

27

J. Willis

28

M. Seyler

YouTube Video: Posted 4/8/14 Episode #675


of "The Pete Santilli Show" titled "Interview
with Cliven Bundy"
4/8/14 Email from OMA to Members re: Alert
Mobilization

29

M. Seyler

4/8/14 Facebook Post from Eric Parker's page

30

L. Briscoe
D. Love

4/9/14 Bodycam Footage with Love & Santilli

31

L. Briscoe
D. Love

4/9/14 Bodycam Footage of Love & Mel


Bundy

32

J. Willis

33

M. Carpenter

YouTube Video: Posted 4/9/14 on WHDT


Channel titled "BREAKING: Feds Prep for
Waco Style Raid of Bundy Ranch"
4/9/14 Bodycam Footage of Blocking of
Convoy

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 4 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

4 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
4/9/14 Dashcam Footage of Blocking of
Convoy

34

M. Carpenter

35

J. Willis

36

J. Willis

37

M. Seyler

YouTube Video: Posted 4/10/14 on "The


Adam Kokesh Show" titled "Pete Santilli from
the Bundy Ranch in Nevada with Protestors"
YouTube Video: Posted 4/9/14 on "The Adam
Kokesh Show" titled "LIVE REPORT from the
riot at the Bundy Ranch, near Las Vegas,
Nevada"
4/9/14 Facebook Post on Carol Bundy page

38

M. Seyler

4/10/14 Email from OMA

39

Carter

40

L. Briscoe
D. Love

41

J. Willis

42

J. Willis

43

J. Willis

44

A. Sully

YouTube Video: Posted 4/9/14 of Telephone


Interview of Ryan Bundy on The American
Voice
4/10/14 Bodycam Footage of Love & Santilli

YouTube Video: Posted 4/10/14 on "The


Franchi Show" titled "Militia Arrives at Bundy
Ranch"
4/11/14 Facebook Post on Operation Patriot
Rally Point re: Ryan Payne as Militia
Coordinator for Bundy Family
YouTube Video: Interview of Ryan Payne on
4/11/14
Photo: 4/11/14 of Staging Area

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 5 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

5 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
45

A. Sully

Photo: 4/11/14 of Staging Area

46

A. Sully

Photo: 4/11/14 of Staging Area

47

A. Sully

Photo: 4/11/14 of Staging Area

48

A. Sully

Photo: 4/11/14 of Staging Area

49

A. Sully

Video: 4/11/14 Speech by Cliven Bundy

50

D. Love

4/11/14 Audio Recording Love & Santilli

51

A. Ellis
C. Simkins

52

A. Ellis
D. Gillespie

Video: 4/12/14 of Stage with Cliven Bundy at


9:40 AM

53

A. Ellis

Video of Gillespie Leaving the Staging Area on


4/12/14 at 9:50 AM

54

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo of Staging Area at 10:33 AM on


4/12/14

55

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo of Staging Area on 4/12/14 at 10:37


AM

Video: 4/12/14 of Stage at 9:37 AM

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 6 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

6 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
56

M. Seyler

Interview of PAYNE on the Ed & Ethan Show


on 4-12-14

57

A. Ellis
C. Simkins

Video of Staging Area on 4/12/14 at 10:50


AM

58

A. Ellis
C. Simkins

Video of Staging Area on 4/12/14 at 10:53


AM

59

A. Ellis

Video of Cliven Bundy on 4/12/14 at 10:58


AM

60

M. Seyler
C. Simkins

Photo of Stage Area on 4/12/14 at 9:04 AM

61

D. Lynch
C. Simkins

Videos of Ammon Bundy in truck Traveling to


Assembly Area

62

D. Lynch

Video of Assembly Area at about 11:20 a.m.

63

D. Lynch
C. Simkins

64

A. Ellis

Video depicting Travel from Exit 112 Entrance


to Assembly Area

65

R. Shilakis

Video re: Followers Arriving at Assembly Area

66

R. Shilakis

Video of 4/12/14 of Post 1

Video of vehicle entering assembly area at


about 11:20 a.m.

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 7 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

7 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
67

R. Shilakis

Video of 4/12/14 of Post 1

68

R. Shilakis

Video of 4/12/14 of Post 1 and 2

69

R. Shilakis

Video of 4/12/14 of Post 1 and 2

70

A. Ellis

Video of 4/12/14 of Assembly Area at 11:29


AM

71

A. Ellis
A. Reeder

Video of 4/12/14 of Assembly Area at 11:41


AM

72

A. Ellis
T. Jackson
A. Reeder
D. Lynch
C. Simkins

Video of 4/12/14 of Assembly Area at 11:42


AM

73

74

75

A. Ellis
T. Jackson
C. Simkins
H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Video of 4/12/14 of Assembly Area at 11:26


AM
Video of Assembly Area at 11:33 AM

4/12/14 Photo of Staging Area at 10:55 AM

76

A. Ellis

Video of NB Bridge at 11:51 AM

77

A. Ellis

Video of Wash at 11:56 AM

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 8 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

8 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
78

A. Ellis

Video from Westside of Wash at 12:08 PM

79

A. Ellis

Video from Westside of Wash at 12:11 PM

80

A. Ellis

Video from Wash at 12:30 PM

81

A. Ellis

Video of Ryan Bundy Speech at 1:37 PM

82

A. Ellis

Video of Wash at 12:44 PM

83

A. Ellis

Video of Interview on NB Bridge at 1:06 PM

84

A. Ellis

Video of NB Bridge at 1:30 PM

85

A. Ellis

Video of Wash at 2:05 PM

86

D. Lynch
C. Simkins

Video of Wash under NB Bridge on 4/12/14

87

D. Lynch
C. Simkins

Video of BLM Position to Skirmish Line on


4/12/14

88

D. Love
D. Lynch
C. Simkins

Video of Love & Ammon Bundy at the Gate in


the Wash on 4/12/14

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 9 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

9 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
89

D. Love
D. Lynch

Video of Love at Post 1 with Lombardo,


Ammon & Dave Bundy

90

D. Lynch

Video of Love, Dave & Ammon Bundy at Gate

91

D. Love
D. Lynch

4/12/14 Video Recording of Gate at 12:20

92

D. Lynch
C. Simkins

Video Recording of Cattle Leaving the Area

93

4/12/14 Dashcam Video from 11:42 a.m. to


12:37 p.m.

94

M. Brunk
G. Johnson
B. Sones
B. Sones

95

G. Johnson

4/12/14 BLM Dashcam in Wash from 11:40


a.m. to 12:43 p.m.

96

S. Serena

Photo on NB I-15 Shoulder near NHP Vehicles


of 4/12/14 at 1:33 p.m.

97

S. Serena

Photo on NB I-15 Shoulder near NHP


Vehicles of 4/12/14 at 1:33 PM

98

S. Serena

Photo from NB I-15 of Wash & SB bridge on


4/12/14 at 12:43 PM

99

S. Serena

Photo from NB I-15 of 4/12/14 at 1:28 PM

4/12/14 Dashcam Video at 2:00 PM Showing


BLM Vehicles Lined Up

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 10 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

10 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
100

S. Serena

NHP Dashcam Video on 4/12/14

101

S. Serena

4/12/14 NHP Dashcam Video of I-15 NB


Bridge

102

M. Madsen
S. Serena

4/12/14 NHP Dashcam Video of I-15 NB


Bridge

103

Photo of Assembly Area near NB I-15 on


4/12/14 at 11:38 AM

104

J. Lombardo
M. Seyler
C. Simkins
C. Simkins

105

M. Carpenter

Dashcam Video in wash on 4/12/14

106

M. Carpenter

Bodycam Video in the Wash on 4/12/14 at


11:57 a.m. to 12:07 p.m.

107

P. Apley

Bodycam Video in Wash on 4/12/14 at 11:53


a.m.

108

P. Apley

Bodycam Video in Wash on 4/12/14 at 11:57


a.m.

109

P. Apley
S. Swanson

Bodycam Video in Wash on 4/12/14 at 12:27

110

C. Simkins

Photo of Assembly Area on 4/12/14

Photo: Followers in Wash on Horseback

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 11 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

11 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
111

R. Shilakis
C. Simkins

Video of Wash from SB side of Bridge behind


BLM

112

R. Shilakis
C. Simkins

Video re: Love walking from gate at 12:28 PM

113

R. Shilakis
R. Stover

Video re: BLM Withdrawing from Area at


12:39 PM

114

R. Shilakis
C. Simkins

Video of Post 3 at 12:42 p.m.

115

T. Schillie
C. Simkins

Photo: Gunman in Wash on 4/12/14

116

T. Schillie
C. Simkins

Photo: Skirmish Line in Wash on 4/12/14

117

T. Schillie
C. Simkins

Photo: Skirmish Line in Wash on 4/12/14

118

T. Schillie

Photo: Skirmish Line in Wash on 4/12/14 at


12:00 p.m.

119

T. Schillie
C. Simkins

Photo: NB I-15 Bridge on 4/12/14 at 12:10


PM

120

T. Schillie
C. Simkins

Photo: Skirmish Line on 4/12/14 at 12:11 PM

121

T. Schillie

Photo of NB Bridge on 4/12/14 at 12:11 PM

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 12 of 35

EXHIBIT LIST

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

12 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
122

T. Schillie

Photo of NB Bridge on 4/12/14 at 12:11 PM

123

T. Schillie

Photo of Wash on 4/12/14 at 12:15 PM

124

T. Schillie

Photo of NB Bridge on 4/12/14 at 12:19 PM

125

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo: Under NB-15 Bridge on 4/12/14


around 11:40 AM

126

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo: Under NB-15 Overpass on 4/12/14

127

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo of of NB-15 Overpass on 4/12/14

128

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo of NB-15 Overpass at 12:26 PM on


4/12/14

129

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo of NB-15 Overpass at 12:26:19 PM on


4/12/14

130

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Photo of NB-15 Overpass at 12:38 PM on


4/12/14

131

H. Gourgeon
J. Woolstenhulme

132

E.J. McEwen
C. Simkins

Photo of NB I-15 Overpass on 4/12/14

Aerial Video from 11:18 to 1:05

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 13 of 35

EXHIBIT LIST

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

13 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
133

S. June
A. Nixon

Ammon Bundy Facebook Photo Page 933

134

S. June
A. Nixon

Ammon Bundy Facebook Photo Page 1014

135

S. June
A. Nixon

Ammon Bundy Facebook Post Page 1015

136

S. June
A. Nixon

Ammon Bundy Facebook Post Page 1017

137

S. June
A. Nixon

Ammon Bundy Facebook Post Page 1018

138

S. June
A. Nixon

Ammon Bundy Facebook Post Page 1048

139

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

140

C. Simkins

141

J. Kempf

Photo: NB I15 on 4/12/14

142

J. Kempf

Photo: NB I15 Bridge on 4/12/14

143

J. Woolstenhulme

Gourgeon Photo of Stage Area on 4/12/14 at


10:38 AM
Photo: Followers on Horseback in Wash

David Williams Facebook Post: Photo of NB15 on 4/12/14

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 14 of 35

EXHIBIT LIST

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

14 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
144

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Video Recording of Wash on 4/12/14

145

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

146

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Video Recording of NB Bridge on 4/12/14

147

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Gourgeon Photo of NB-15 Overpass on


4/12/14

148

H. Gourgeon
C. Simkins

Video Still photo of 4/12/14

149

J. Woolstenhulme

150

A. Gruninger

151

A. Gruninger

Clip from 8 News Now at 11PM Airdate


4/30/14

152

A. Gruninger

Video from Hannity Show

153

J. Woolstenhulme

154

M. Seyler

Video Recording of I-15 NB Bridge of 4/12/14

Washington Post Online Article "Everything


You Need to Know About the Long Gun Fight
between Cliven Bundy and the Federal
Government" of 4/15/14
Clip from 8 News Now at 5PM Airdate 5/8/14

Dahlen Facebook Posting of Photo of I-15 NB


Bridge
Dropbox Photo of Gate on 4/12/14

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 15 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

15 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
155

J. Willis

YouTube Video: "We The People"

156

J. Willis

YouTube Video: "Mexican Standoff"

157

T. Suminski

CAD Reports of 4/12/14

158

E.J. McEwen
C. Simkins

Aerial Video Recording on 4/12/14 at 2:45 to


2:50 p.m.

159

J. Willis

YouTube Video: Stewart Rhodes Interview


with Ammon Bundy of 4/12/14

160

D. Love

5/12/14 Voicemail from Santilli to Love

161

D. Love

9/22/14 Voicemail from Santilli to Love

162

D. Love

11/6/14 Voicemail from Santilli to Love

163

D. Love

11/24/14 Voicemail from Santilli to Love

164

M. Caputo

Recorded Telephone Conversation with


Burleson & Caputo

165

D. Hale

Interview of Todd Engel in Couer d'Alene,


Idaho on 2/21/15

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 16 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

16 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
166

D. Hale

Video of Todd Engel Meeting with Bonner


County Sheriff's Office on 4/22/14

167

J. Willis

168

M. Seyler

YouTube Video: Posted on 4/13/14 "The Next


News Network" titled "Bundy Ranch:
Resolution or Strategic De-escalation"
Screengrabs of OMA Website Mission
Statement

169

M. Seyler

OMA Website Capture dated 4/7/14

170

M. Seyler

Bruckhart Post on OMA Website re: OMA's


Purpose

171

M. Seyler

OMA Post by RYAN PAYNE on 4/23/13 at 2:18


AM

172

M. Seyler

OMA Post by Bruckhart on 6/23/13 entitled


"Dawn of a New Day"

173

M. Seyler

Emails between Payne & Bruckhart re: OMA


Mission Statement of 4/16/13

174

M. Seyler

Email from Bruckhart to Payne re: DC


Clothesline Article on Cliven Bundy of 4/7/14

175

M. Seyler

176

M. Seyler

Email from OMA to Multiple Receipents re:


DC Clothesline Article on Cliven Bundy of
4/7/14
Facebook Posting from R. Lovelien attaching
article about feds rounding up Bundy Cattle
of 4/7/14

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 17 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

17 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
177

M. Seyler

Email from OMA to Multiple Receipents re:


Criticial Situation in Clark County, NV of
4/7/14
Payne Email re:Lovelien Facebook post to
MDTF of 4/9/14

178

M. Seyler

179

M. Seyler

Payne Email of 4/9/14 at 12:18 PM

180

M. Seyler

Payne Email showing Facebook post to MTDF


of OMA Objectives of 4/10/14 at 2:02 AM

181

M. Seyler

Payne Email showing Facebook post to MTDF


of 4/10/14 at 12:00 PM

182

M. Seyler

Payne Email showing Facebook MTDF post of


4/11/14 at 11:22 AM

183

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook posting to MTDF of


4/14/14

184

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook posting to MTDF of


4/14/14

185

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook Subscriber Information


Pages 1-2

186

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook: List of Facebook Groups


Page 66

187

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook: List of Facebook Friends


Pages 76-80

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 18 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

18 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
188

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook: About Me Section Page


104

189

M. Seyler

Lovelien: Facebook Activity for April 2014


Apges 114-116

190

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook Post re: Position of


Government Page 175

191

M. Seyler

Photo Uploaded on 4/26/14 by Lovelien of


Lovelien & Engel on Bridge Page 565

192

M. Seyler

Photos depicting Firearm Pages 581-583

193

M. Seyler

4/8/14 Facebook Post by Lovelien Pages 789790

194

M. Seyler

4/9/14 Facebook Personal Message to


Lovelien Page 956

195

M. Seyler

4/12/14 Facebook Personal Message to


Lovelien Page 957

196

M. Seyler

4/14/14 and 4/17/14 Facebook PM's from


Lovelien Page 958

197

M. Seyler

4/8/14 Facebook Personal Message Page 974

198

M. Seyler

4/9/14 Facebook Personal Message Page 975

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 19 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

19 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
199

M. Seyler

9/25/13 Facebook Personal Message Page


976

200

M. Seyler

4/8/14 Facebook Personal Message Pages


1007-1008

201

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook Personal Message Page


1110

202

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook Personal Message Page


1114

203

M. Seyler

Lovelien Facebook Page 1257

204

M. Seyler

4/6/14 PM from Emery including Lovelien


with post from Bundy Ranch blog Page 1272

205

M. Seyler

Continued Chat from April 7 that shared


Bundy Ranch blog spot link Page 1277

206

M. Seyler

207

M. Seyler

Personal Messages between Bruckhart &


Lovelien re: Roles at Bundy Ranch of Lovelien
& Payne Pages 1530-1532
Lovelien Facebook Personal Messages Pages
1534-1536

208

M. Seyler

4/9/14 Interview of Ryan Payne with LVRJ


Reporter re: OMA

209

J. Willis

Engel video in his vehicle posted on social


media on 3/3/16

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 20 of 35

EXHIBIT LIST

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

20 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
210

M. Seyler

4/23/14 Personal Message between Lovelien


& another person about what he was doing
at Bundy Ranch Page 1555
4/10/14 Personal Message to Lovelien
informing him a "suburban full of guys
coming from Kalispell" Page 1785
4/9/14 Personal Message by Lovelien &
Another User Page 1786

211

M. Seyler

212

M. Seyler

213

M. Seyler

214

J. Woolstenhulme

215

M. Seyler

Photo: White Pick-Up Truck at Staging Area

216

M. Seyler

3/25/14 Wolf Radio Show of Interview with


RYAN PAYNE

217

M. Seyler

218

M. Seyler

Payne Facebook Personal Message between


Payne & others discussing Bundy Ranch
Pages 281-283
6/3/14 Payne Facebook Post Page 290

219

M. Seyler

220

M. Seyler

Group Chat with Lovelien & several militia


groups on 4/8 discussing reasons to go to
Bundy Ranch Pages 1791-1949
Lovelein Facebook Photo of I-15 Bridge on
4/12/14

Payne Facebook Personal Message between


Bruckhart & Payne re: Contacting Bundy
Pages 322-323
3/28/14 Payne Facebook Message where
Payne joins MSDF in Chat with Lardy Pages
350-351

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 21 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

21 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
221

M. Seyler

4/9/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message


Pages 359-360

222

M. Seyler

4/12/14 at 12:36PM Payne Facebook


Personal Message Pages 387-388

223

M. Seyler

Payne Facebook Personal Message Pages 453454

224

M. Seyler

4/9/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message


Pages 456-459

225

M. Seyler

4/10/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message


Pages 463-464

226

M. Seyler

227

M. Seyler

4/9/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message


between Payne & another discussing Cliven
Bundy wants more militia to come to Bundy
Ranch Pages 468-471
4/10/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message
Pages 471-472

228

M. Seyler

229

M. Seyler

230

M. Seyler

231

M. Seyler

4/10/14 Facebook Personal Message


between Payne, TexasMilitiaNorthTexas &
others Pages 473-475
4/11/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message
between Payne & others discussing contacts
at hotel BLM is using & announcing arrival of
another team
4/11/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message
between Payne & TexasMilitiaNorthTexas
Pages 492-493
4/10/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message
Page 501

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 22 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

22 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
232

M. Seyler

4/7/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message


with TexasMilitiaNorthTexas Page 503

233

M. Seyler

4/8/14 Payne Facebook Personal Message


with TexasMilitiaNorthTexas Page 504

234

S. Draper

235

S. Draper

4/11/14 Facebook Post by Parker "worried


DHS going to be pulling people over if that's
true they need more militia " Page 218
4/12/14 Facebook Wall Posts & Personal
Messages by Parker Page 232

236

S. Draper

237

S. Draper

238

S. Draper

239

J. Willis

9/16/14 Parker Facebook Wall Post

240

A. Nixon

5/13/14 Burelson Facebook Page 167

241

A. Nixon

5/8/14 Burelson Facebook Page 173

242

A. Nixon

5/6/14 Burleson Facebook Pages 175-176

4/10/14 Parker Facebook sharing Link to


Franchi's YouTube video featuring Santilli
Page 346
4/10/14 Parker Facebook Wall Post Pages
347-348
4/12/14 Parker Response to Facebook
Personal Message Page 804

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 23 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

23 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
243

S. Draper

4/9/14 Parker Facebook Post to Militia Page


344

244

S. Draper

4/11/14 Parker Facebook Post Page 344

245

S. Draper

246

S. Draper

4/11/14 Facebook Post by Parker with Link to


video of Cliven Bundy speaking at the Moapa
Valley Town Board Meeting Page 345
(2) Parker Facebook Posts on 4/12/14 Page
794

247

S. Draper

248

S. Draper

249

S. Draper

4/14/14 Parker Facebook Group Message re:


Saiga Rifle Page 809

250

S. Draper

4/24/14 Stewart Facebook Comment on a


Shared Photo Page 59

251

S. Draper

4/12/14 Stewart Facebook Posts Pages 64-65

252

A. Nixon

4/30/14 Burleson Facebook Page 179

253

A. Nixon

5/18/14 Burleson Facebook Page 238

4/12/14 Parker Facebook Message to the


"We Support Cliven Bundy" Facebook page
811
4/13/14 Parker Facebook Posts Pages 343344

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 24 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

24 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
254

A. Nixon

4/14/14 Burleson Facebook Page 242

255

M. Boxx

Photo: Observation Post on 4/12/14

256

M. Boxx
G. Johnson
B. Sones
D. Keltner
T. McBride
B. Novotny
C. Simkins
S. Swanson

257

258

Photo: Post 2 before 11:00 AM on 4/12/14

Photo: SETT Position in Wash on 4/12/14

Photo: 4/12/14 Photo of BLM Officer with


Weapon Raised
Body Cam Footage of 4/8/14 Encounter with
Protesters

259

M. Carpenter
S. Swanson

260

S. Draper

Stewart Facebook Posts from 4/11/14 to


4/13/14 Pages 87-89

261

S. Draper

4/15/14 Stewart Facebook post re: Judge


George Page 137

262

S. Draper

4/12/14 Stewart Facebook Page 139

263

S. Draper

4/10/14 Stewart Facebook Link re: Bundy


Ranch on Facebook Page 140

264

S. Draper

4/12/14 Stewart Facebook Post Photo of


Cowboys in the Wash posted to Facebook by
Stewart Page 222

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 25 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

25 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
Video of BLM Leaving Downloaded from
Public Facebook Profile with Stewart
Comment
4/12/14 Stewart Facebook Comment on
Video in Exhibit #265 Pages 234-235

265

J. Willis

266

S. Draper
J. Willis

267

S. Draper

4/12/14 Stewart Facebook Comment Pages


275-276

268

A. Nixon

Carol Bundy Facebook Post of 4/5/14 Page


1311

269

S. Draper

4/12/14 Stewart Facebook Page 65

270

S. Draper

4/11/14 Stewart Facebook Page 66

271

A. Nixon

4/12/14 Burleson Facebook Page 191

272

A. Nixon

Facebook Posts by Burleson on 4/10/14 &


4/11/14

273

A. Nixon

Burleson Facebook Pages 479-480

274

A. Nixon

5/8/14 Burleson Comment on Lewis Photo


Pages 470-471

275

A. Nixon

Burleson Facebook "drove BLM thugs from


battlefield" Pages 483-484

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 26 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

26 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
276

A. Nixon

Burleson Facebook Comment Pages 504-505

277

A. Nixon

Burleson Facebook Personal Message Pages


753-755

278

J. Willis

4/10/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Post Page


185

279

J. Willis

4/11/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Post Page


205

280

J. Willis

4/15/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Post Page


292

281

J. Willis

282

J. Willis

4/29/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Post


indicating Payne is main militia contact Page
7465
4/16/14 Comment Posted to Bundy Ranch
Facebook Page 8823

283

J. Willis

4/16/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Page 11274

284

J. Willis

4/15/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Page 11905

285

J. Willis

4/19/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Page 15457

286

J. Willis

4/18/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Page 16599

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 27 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

27 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
287

J. Willis

4/11/14 Bundy Ranch Facebook Page 16877

288

J. Willis

4/11/14 at 9:53 a.m. Bundy Ranch Facebook


PostPages 2469-2470

289

J. Willis

4/11/14 at 7:59 p.m. Bundy Ranch Facebook


Post Page 2548

290

J. Willis

4/11/14 at 8:07 p.m. Bundy Ranch Facebook


Post Page 2538

291

J. Willlis

4/8/14 at 6:39 a.m. Santilli Facebook Pages


15072-15073

292

J. Willis

4/8/14 Post to Guerilla Media Network


Facebook Pages 1269-1270

293

J. Willis

4/7/14 Bailey Bundy Logue Facebook Post


Page 2771

294

J. Willis

4/15/14 Bailey Bundy Logue Facebook Post


Page 2987

295

J. Willis

4/2/14 Bailey Bundy Logue Facebook Post


Page 3013

296

J. Willis

4/9/14 Bailey Bundy Logue Facebook Post


Page 3267

297

J. Willis

4/20/14 Engel Facebook Post re: Bundy


Ranch Pages 195-197

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 28 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

28 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
298

J. Willis

4/12/14 Engel Facebook Posts from 16:52 to


23:30

299

J. Willis

4/8/14 Engel Facebook Comment Page 200

300

J. Willis

Engel Facebook Comments on 4/13/14 and


4/14/14 re: Bundy Ranch Page 437

301

J. Willis

Engel Facebook Comment on 7/6/14 Page


390

302

J. Willis

4/11/14 Engel Facebook Posts/Comments


Page 441

303

J. Willis

Video posted to Engel Facebook Timeline on


1/10/16

304

J. Willis

Video Posted by Engel to his Facebook Page


on 4/12/14

305

S. Draper

4/15/14 Drexler Facebook Post re: Possible


Return to Bundy Ranch Page 87

306

S. Draper
J. Willis

4/15/14 Facebook Comments by Drexler re:


Use of Bridges at Bundy Ranch Page 90

307

J. Willis

Engel Facebook Comment on 4/12/14 Page


954

308

J. Richter

Summary of Phone Calls from 4/8/14 to


4/12/14 between Cliven Bundy, Ryan Bundy
Ammon Bundy & Payne

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 29 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

29 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
309

T. Schields

Summary of Phone Calls from 4/5/14 to


4/12/14 between Parker & Stewart

310

F. Defazio

Summary of Phone Calls from 3/28/14 to


4/14/14 between Cliven Bundy & Payne

311

C. Duke

Summary of Phone Calls between Payne &


Ryan Bundy on 4/8, 4/9, 4/11 and 4/12

312

T. Schields

Call on 4/11/14 between Drexler & Parker

313

T. Schields

Summary of Engel Telephone Calls

314

T. Schields

Summary of Lovelien Telephone Calls

315

C. Simkins

Photo History for Gregory P. Burleson

316

C. Simkins

Photo History for O. Scott Drexler

317

C. Simkins

Photo History for Todd C. Engel

318

C. Simkins

Photo History for Ricky R. Lovelien

319

C. Simkins

Photo History for Eric J. Parker

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 30 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

30 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
320

C. Simkins

Photo History for Steven A. Stewart

321

C. Simkins

322

R. Stover

Map: Bundy_Ranch

323

R. Stover

Map: Cattle_Location_Overview_with_Land_
Status

324

R. Stover

325

R. Stover

Map:
Cattle_Location_Overview_without_Land_
Status
Map: Incident_04_06_2014

326

R. Stover

Map: Incident_04_08_2014

327

R. Stover

Map: Incident_04_09_2014

328

R. Stover

Map: Incident_Command_Post

329

R. Stover

Map: Incident_Command_Post_I15_Bridge

330

R. Stover

Map: Incident_Property

OPU Presentation - Timeline of Psrker,


Drexler, Stewart, Burleson, Lovelien & Engel

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 31 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

31 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
331

R. Stover

Map: Milk_Barn

332

R. Stover

Map: Protest_Site_Stage

333

C. Johnson

UCE Interview from 8/16/14 of Eric Parker

334

C. Johnson

UCE Interview from 8/16/14 of O. Scott


Drexler

335

C. Johnson

UCE Interview from 10/27/14 of Gregory P.


Burleson

336

T. Thiede

Engel Custodial Interview in Coeur D'Alene,


ID on 3/3/16

337

M. Seyler

Parker Custodial Interview in Ketchum, ID on


3/3/16

338

M. Luem

Burleson Custodial Interview in Phoenix, AZ


on 3/3/16

339

E. Hawks

Stewart Custodial Interview in Hailey, ID on


3/3/16

340

J. Willis

341

L. Briscoe
D. Love
R. Stover

4/13/14 Audio Recording of Engel on Internet


Radio Show
Screenshot: Santili & Love on 4/9/12

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 32 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

32 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
342

R. Stover

Screenshot: Cliven Bundy on Stage at 9:50


AM on 4/12/14

343

D. Love
R. Stover

Screenshot: Ammon Bundy at Gate with Love


on 4/12/14

344

A. Ellis
M. Seyler

Screenshot: Ryan Payne & Ryan Bundy on


Stage on 4/12/14

345

R. Stover

Screenshot: Ryan Bundy on Light on 4/12/14

346

R. Stover

Screenshot: LP/OP on Ridge on 4/12/14

347

R. Stover

Screenshot: Post 1 and Assembly Area at


11:30 AM on 4/12/14

348

Screenshot: Aerial View of BLM Position at


12:01 PM on 4/12/14

349

D. Keltner
R. Stover
S. Swanson
R. Stover

350

R. Stover

Photo: BLM lined up to Leave on 4/12/14

351

J. Willis

Facebook Authentication Letters

352

J. Willis

Google Authentication Letter re: Ryan Payne


Email Account

Photo: View of Bridges & Stover on 4/12/14

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 33 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL

EXHIBIT LIST

33 of 35

United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al


Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
353

J. Willis

Google Authentication Letter re: "The Pete


Santilli Show"

354

J. Willis

Yahoo Authentication Letter re: Jerry


Bruckhart Email Account

355

S. Swanson

356

S. Draper

357

358

359

360

361

362

363

Body Cam Video of 4/10/14

Saiga .223 Caliber Rifle Recovered from


Parker's Garage

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 34 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL


United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al
Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
364

365

366

367

368

369

370

371

372

373

374

EXHIBIT LIST

34 of 35

Case 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL Document 1423 Filed 01/26/17 Page 35 of 35

Case No.: 2:16-cr-00046-GMN-PAL


United States of America v. Cliven Budy, et al
Exhibits on Behalf of Plaintiff
375

376

377

378

379

380

381

382

383

384

385

EXHIBIT LIST

35 of 35

You might also like