Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Objectives
2.
To expand the test scope from previous tests carried out in 1994-96
To obtain comprehensive temperature profile information, in order to evaluate the
fire-retardant properties of this helideck
To measure temperature distribution when the Helideck is subjected to a hydrocarbon pool
fire;
To understand the thermal behavior of the Helideck when the deck fire is extinguished using
a water spray system;
To collect data and analyze the temperature changes in the different structural layers of the
decking and girders, so as to obtains temperatures : time change curve at the designated test
points, temperature distribution on top surface of the decking and in the vertical direction of
the structure
Test model
The test model is a square helideck of size 12m x 12m. The material used for both decking and girder
is AA6082-T6. All fasteners are SS316 (A4-70).
A Helifire water spray system was installed into the helideck. This consisted of a sensor, an
activation mechanism for the water spray and pop-up nozzles in the helideck.
Refer to Fig 1 for general understanding and details.
3.
Test equipment
Thermocouples, Type K, diameter 1mm, made from nickel chromium-nickel silicon, which
can withstand high temperature up to 1300C. Protective sheathing was installed near sensor
contact points, to isolate high temperature flame radiation created during the fire at the
locations, and therefore minimize temperature measurement errors.
A processing module (ADMS): 8 units of the module were used. Each module has eight A/D
switches, through which data is collected and sent to a data server (computer)
Page 1 of 7
15 Nov 2004
4.
Locations of thermocouples are shown in Fig 3; the choice of their locations was based on where the
fire area would be and possible temperature distribution in the area. According to the test
requirements, the following four methods were used to lay the thermocouples:
At all locations not subject to high temperature: three thermocouples on the top surface,
mid-web and bottom of the decking;
At all locations subject to high temperature: four thermocouples on top surface, mid-web
and bottom of the decking, and one the mid-web of girder beam which is placed below
decking;
At locations near high temperature areas: two thermocouples on the top and bottom surface
of the decking;
At locations outside the above areas: one thermocouple on top surface of decking
Labelling and Identification of thermocouples: To avoid confusion in testing & installation, all
thermocouples are labelled and installed as per Fig 3, and their connections to the modules are also
checked.
5.
Fire Tests
Temperature measurements were carried out for two tests, in accordance with the fire test programme:
Test A Un-manned platform scenario/completely passive operation: 200L of Jet Fuel would be
ignited on the Helideck; no fire-fighting equipment was to be used. The Helideck would retard the fire
working on a purely passive basis. Temperature changes with time, height of flames and area of fire
spread would be recorded simultaneously. Unburned fuel collected would be measured.
Page 2 of 7
15 Nov 2004
Test B Manned platform scenario with Helifire water spray system: 200L of Jet Fuel would be
ignited on the Helideck and the Helifire water spray system would be activated immediately to
extinguish the fire. Temperature changes with time, height of flames and area of fire spread would
be recorded simultaneously.
6.
Observations
The behaviour of the fires in both tests were recorded via the abovementioned measurement
equipment and also captured by video camera. Significant temperature/time observations:
Test A (refer to Fig 4)
Max Temperature
Recorded
Time
Description
17:10:00
17:11:28
17:14:30
17:15:00
17:16:00
17:18:08
17:40:00
6 M 39 S
33C
330C
280C
260C
270C
100C
160C
Max Temperature
280C
In the above test, the fuel was burning as it spilled onto the test deck. A surface fire was quickly
established although there was a delay in temperature rise in the structure. This can be attributed
to the higher specific heat characteristic of aluminium alloys. It was also observed that the fire
reached a peak and began attenuation when unburned fuel commenced discharge at the drain
point. No flames were seen coming through drain gutter & fuel collection tank. The fire was
contained in a localised area and no re-ignition occurred after fire die down.
Jet Fuel recovered after test was more than 190 litres, or about 95% of the initial burn volume.
Page 3 of 7
15 Nov 2004
Time
Description
17:40:00
17:40:32
17:40:50
Below 70C
115C
Below 50C
Max Temperature
0 M 50 S
115C
As the water spray system was activated before the fire reached its full intensity, the temperatures
and flame heights recorded were much lower than those in Test A.
Details of temperatures measured at each testing point can be found in Figs 6 to 30.
7.
7.1.
Analysis of Results
Temperature gradients caused by the deck-based fire
Test A: 200 litres of Jet Fuel were ignited and the fire was left to attenuate on a purely passive
basis. The total duration was about 6 minutes 40 seconds, of which, fire spread took about 2
minutes. The fire was into stable burning for about 4 minutes and 10 seconds. The rationale for
letting the fire burn until it self-extinguished was to observe any structural changes in the
helideck after the fire.
It can be seen from Fig 4 of temperature distribution that the fastest temperature rise occurs at
test points 2 and 3 at a speed of approx 1.5C to 2C per second. Only these two test points (2
& 3) reached temperatures above 250C and for a duration of about three and half minutes.
During this period, temperatures measured at all the other test points were below 250C. The
highest temperature measured on the helideck was 280C; at 2 minutes 40 seconds from ignition.
After the fire was seen to be abating, temperatures decreased with the only exceptions at test
point 2 & 3. This shows that the fire was greatly reduced, not only in its intensity but also in
area. When the fuel on the surface had disappeared, i.e. fire had extinguished itself,
temperatures on the deck started to fall. There was a sharp temperature drop at 17:18:08, which
was caused by the use of 2 litres water at test points 2, 3, 5, 6 and 7. However, the temperatures
rose again at these points after the water had evaporated. For test points not affected by the
water, there was no sharp temperature drop observed, i.e. the deck in the area was under a natural
cooling process.
Page 4 of 7
15 Nov 2004
Test B: The test was conducted about 22 minutes after the above test, and the deck
temperatures were higher than ambient temperatures. As this test was conducted mainly to test
the effectiveness of the pop-up water spray system, the fire centre was shifted to the centre of 4
numbers of pop-up nozzles. In this area, there were less thermocouples installed and therefore,
less data were collected. As shown in Fig 5, after ignition, the temperatures at test points 18 &
19 were quickly increased. The water spray system was manually activated 32 seconds after
ignition of fire. Once the water spray commenced, deck temperatures dropped almost
immediately. The one exception was at test point 18, which was directly under the fuel tank and
an area difficult for water to reach. From the measured results, it can be seen that there was no
further increase in temperature after the water spray system was activated, and the highest
temperature was only 115C.
The overall temperature distribution at the different layers of the deck is shown in Figs 6, 7, 8 &
9.
From these figures, it can be seen:
Temperatures at cross section of decking -2 & -3 were influenced by the surface
temperature -1. As surface temperature increased in -1, both -2 & -3 were increased,
even though the temperatures measured were much lower in comparison to the surface
temperature. For example, at test point 2, when its surface temperature at 2-1 was
measured at 280C, the temperature at 2-2 mid-web of decking was 200C and at 2-3
bottom was 150C. Therefore, the gradient of temperature is considerably large.
Similarly, the gradient of temperature across girder beams was also examined, and the
influence of heat on the girder is much smaller than that of decking. The max
temperature rise here was about 35C, and average temperature change is within 15C.
7.2.
The longitudinal direction of decking is along the decking extrusion direction, and it is also the
direction in which the fuel is channelled away. The transverse direction is perpendicular to the
longitudinal direction.
Test A: The fire centre was around Test point 2, and it was where the maximum temperature
was measured. From Fig 10, it can be seen that the longer the distance from the fire, the smaller
the temperature changes were. Referring to Fig 11, the graphs show temperature distribution
along test points 2, 3 & 4. Temperature changes at Test points 2 & 3 are similar, but
temperature at test point 4 was much lower, which means that fire did not spread in same
intensity to nearby areas.
Test B: As the fire centre was shifted toward the centre of the deck, the max temperature
measured was 115 0C at test point 18, and temperature changes in other areas are negligible.
Page 5 of 7
15 Nov 2004
7.3.
There were two to three testing points on the decking and two on the girder in selected locations
in order to examine the gradient of temperature across the structure. It is observed that the
surface temperature is normally the highest, and, logically, temperature would reduce from top to
the bottom of the deck structure.
8. Significant Findings
Test A:
1.
2.
3.
4.
When 200 litres of jet fuel was ignited & left to burn until self-extinguished, more than
95% of the fuel was channelled away through the decking and recovered unburned.
Less than 5% of the fuel remained on the surface and burned in a localised area. The
special configuration of the decking suppressed the fire immediately, reduced the area
of fire spread and resulted in lower temperatures in the structure as a whole. From the
test data collected, only two small areas reached temperatures of 280C and this lasted
for 2 minutes and 40 seconds. The temperature was less than 250C in all other areas.
During the fire, the speed of temperature rise was faster than that of natural cooling
after the fire was extinguished.
On the deck surface, there were temperature gradients along both longitudinal &
transverse directions. In the areas which were distant from fire centre, there was very
little temperature change.
Across the deck structure, temperature gradient was larger near the fire centre. Taking
test point 2 as an example (Fig 16), the temperature on the surface (2-1) is 280C, at
mid web (2-2) was 200C and at bottom (2-3) was 150C. The temperature difference
of the top and bottom surface is 130C, and this gap is close when the test points are far
away from the fire centre.
Test B:
1.
2.
In comparison to the Test A, the maximum temperature and flame height were greatly
reduced. Apart from the fire centre, temperature rise in the whole deck is very
minimal.
The use of water is very effective in extinguishing a fire on this helideck.
Page 6 of 7
15 Nov 2004
Preamble
The undersigned has been commissioned by Aluminium Offshore Pte Ltd, Singapore, to conduct
various tests on the fire-suppression capability of the Astech aluminium enhanced safety helideck
and the efficiency of the Helifire water spray system. This is an independent report on the tests
carried out on 21st to 23rd September 2004 with our technical team.
Page 7 of 7
15 Nov 2004
280
17:10:39
17:11:20
17:12:00
17:12:40
17:13:21
17:14:02
17:14:44
17:15:25
17:16:06
17:16:47
17:17:27
17:18:08
17:18:48
17:19:29
17:20:09
17:20:49
17:21:29
17:22:10
17:22:50
17:23:31
17:24:11
17:24:51
17:25:31
17:26:11
17:26:51
17:27:31
17:28:11
17:28:51
17:29:31
17:30:11
17:30:51
17:31:30
17:32:10
17:32:50
17:33:30
17:34:10
Temperature ( C)
300
Igniting
Watering
1st Test_Upper Surface
Extended Limited
Natural Cooling
260
240
220
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
Time (hh:mm:ss)
25-1
1-1
2-1
3-1
4-1
5-1
6-1
7-1
8-1
9-1
10-1
11-1
12-1
13-1
14-1
15-1
16-1
17-1
18-1
19-1
20-1
21-1
22-1
23-1
24-1
Fig 5
Time (hh:mm:ss)
17:59:41
17:59:01
17:58:21
17:57:41
17:57:01
17:56:20
17:55:40
17:55:00
17:54:20
17:53:38
17:52:58
17:52:16
17:51:35
17:50:54
17:50:14
110
17:49:34
17:48:54
17:48:14
17:47:34
17:46:54
W atering
17:46:12
17:45:32
17:44:52
17:44:12
17:43:32
17:42:52
17:42:12
17:41:32
17:40:52
Igniting
17:40:12
17:39:32
17:38:51
Temperature ( C)
130
Stop W atering
120
C ooling
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
25-1
1-1
2-1
3-1
4-1
5-1
6-1
7-1
8-1
9-1
10-1
11-1
12-1
13-1
14-1
15-1
16-1
17-1
18-1
19-1
20-1
21-1
22-1
23-1
24-1
10
180
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
210
200
190
170
160
150
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
Time (hh:mm:ss)
1-2
2-2
3-2
4-2
5-2
6-2
7-2
8-2
9-2
10-2
12-2
13-2
14-2
15-2
16-2
17-2
18-2
19-2
20-2
22-2
50
40
30
20
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
160
150
140
130
Test.1-2:No.3pt Layer
120
110
100
90
Time (hh:mm:ss)
1-3
2-3
3-3
4-3
12-3
13-3
14-3
15-3
17-3
18-3
22-3
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
60
55
50
6-4
7-4
8-4
20-4
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
Time (hh:mm:ss)
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
65
60
20-5
6-5
7-5
8-5
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
Time (hh:mm:ss)
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
300
280
260
240
220
200
180
160
2 5 -1
1 -1
2 -1
6 -1
1 3 -1
1 7 -1
2 0 -1
2 2 -1
2 3 -1
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
Tim e (h h :m m :s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
300
280
260
240
220
200
2 -1
3 -1
4 -1
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e (h h :m m :s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
260
240
220
200
180
160
140
5 -1
6 -1
7 -1
8 -1
9 -1
1 0 -1
1 1 -1
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e (h h :m m :s s )
200
180
160
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
240
220
1 2 -1
1 3 -1
1 4 -1
1 5 -1
1 6 -1
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
130
120
110
100
1 7 -1
1 8 -1
1 9 -1
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
Fig 14
Surface Temperature Measured in Transverse Direction
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
150
140
130
120
110
100
1 -1
1 -2
1 -3
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
300
280
260
240
220
200
180
2 -1
2 -2
2 -3
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
300
280
260
240
220
200
3 -1
3 -2
3 -3
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
200
190
180
170
160
150
140
130
4 -1
4 -2
4 -3
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
260
240
220
200
5 -1
5 -2
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
260
240
220
200
180
160
6 -1
6 -2
6 -4
6 -5
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:29
17:15:38
17:16:46
17:17:54
17:19:01
17:20:08
17:21:15
17:22:23
17:23:30
17:24:37
17:25:44
17:26:50
17:27:57
17:29:03
17:30:10
17:31:16
17:32:23
17:33:30
17:34:36
17:35:43
17:36:49
17:37:57
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:34
17:44:41
17:45:48
17:46:56
17:48:03
17:49:10
17:50:16
17:51:23
17:52:33
17:53:40
17:54:49
17:55:55
17:57:03
17:58:09
17:59:16
18:00:23
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:43
18:04:50
18:05:57
18:07:03
Temperature ( C)
260
240
220
200
7 -1
7 -2
7 -4
7 -5
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e (h h :m m :s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
62
60
58
56
54
52
50
48
8 -1
8 -2
8 -4
8 -5
46
44
42
40
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
T im e (h h :m m :s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
240
220
200
180
160
1 2 -1
1 2 -2
1 2 -3
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
240
220
200
180
160
140
1 3 -1
1 3 -2
1 3 -3
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e (h h :m m :s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
240
220
200
180
160
140
1 4 -1
1 4 -2
1 4 -3
120
100
80
60
40
20
T im e (h h :m m :s s )
42
40
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
50
48
46
44
1 5 -1
1 5 -2
1 5 -3
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
T im eDistribution
(h h :m m
:s s )the Section at Test Point 15
Fig 26 Temperature
Across
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
54
52
50
48
46
1 7 -1
1 7 -2
1 7 -3
44
42
40
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
22
20
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
130
120
110
100
90
1 8 -1
1 8 -2
1 8 -3
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
T im e ( h h : m m : s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
36
34
2 0 -1
2 0 -2
2 0 -4
2 0 -5
32
30
28
26
24
22
T im e (h h :m m :s s )
17:11:06
17:12:13
17:13:21
17:14:30
17:15:39
17:16:47
17:17:55
17:19:02
17:20:09
17:21:16
17:22:23
17:23:31
17:24:38
17:25:44
17:26:51
17:27:58
17:29:04
17:30:11
17:31:17
17:32:24
17:33:30
17:34:37
17:35:43
17:36:50
17:37:58
17:39:07
17:40:14
17:41:21
17:42:28
17:43:35
17:44:42
17:45:48
17:46:57
17:48:04
17:49:10
17:50:17
17:51:24
17:52:33
17:53:41
17:54:49
17:55:56
17:57:03
17:58:10
17:59:17
18:00:24
18:01:30
18:02:37
18:03:44
18:04:51
18:05:57
18:07:04
Temperature ( C)
34
32
2 2 -1
2 2 -2
2 2 -3
30
28
26
24
T im e (h h :m m :s s )