CHECKLIST CASES ON CONSTITUTIONAL LAW

Constitutional Commission

1. Aruelo vs CA; G.R. No. 107852 October 20, 1993

2. Vital-Gozon vs CA; G.R. No. 101428 August 5, 1992

3. Filipinos Engineering and Machine Shop vs Ferrer; G.R. No. L-31455 February 28, 1985

4. Mateo vs CA; G.R. No. 113219 August 14, 1995

5. National Service Corp vs NLRC; G.R. No. L-69870 November 29, 1988

6. De Los Santos vs Mallare; G.R. No. L-3881 August 31, 1950

7. Salazar vs Mathay; G.R. No. L-44061 September 20, 1976

8. Corpus vs Cuaderno; G.R. No. L-16969 April 30, 1966

9. Mendoza vs Quisumbing; G.R. No. 78053 June 4, 1990

10. Luego vs Civil Service Commission; G.R. NO. L-69137 August 5, 1986

11. Lopez vs CSC; G.R. No. 92140 February 19, 1991

12. SSS Employees Association vs CA; G.R. No. 85279 July 28, 1989

13. Eugenio vs CSC; G.R. No. 115863 March 31, 1995

14. Civil Liberties Union vs Executive Secretary; G.R. No. 83896 February 22, 1991

15. Flores vs. Drilon; G.R. No. 104732 June 22, 1993

16. Quiamson vs Ozasta; G.R. No. L-8321. March 26, 1956

17. Cayetano vs Monsod; G.R. No. 100113 September 3, 1991

18. Brillantes Jr. vs Yorac; G.R. No. 93867 : December 18, 1990

19. Gallardo vs Judge Tabamo; G.R. No. 104848 January 29, 1993

20. Flores vs COMELEC; G.R. No. 89604 April 20, 1990

21. Relampagos vs Cumba and Comelec; G.R. No. 118861 April 27, 1995

22. Norbi Edding vs COMELEC; G.R. No. 112060 July 17, 1995

23. Galido vs COMELEC; G.R. No. 95346 January 18, 1991

24. People VS Inting; G.R. No. 88919 July 25, 1990

25. People vs Basilia; G.R. Nos. 83938-40 November 6, 1989

26. People vs Delgado; G.R. Nos. 93419-32 September 18, 1990

27. Sarmiento vs Comelec; G. R. No. 105628 August 6, 1992

28. National Press Club vs COMELEC; G.R. No. 102653 March 5, 1992

29. Adiong vs Comelec; G.R. NO. 103956; 31 MAR 1992

30. Orocio vs COA; G.R. No. 75959 August 31, 1992

31. Tomas Osmena vs COA; G.R. No. 98355 March 2, 1994

32. Bustamante vs COA; G.R. No. 103309 November 27, 1992

33. Sambeli vs Province of Isabela; G.R. No. 92279 June 18, 1992

34. Saligumba vs COA; G.R. No. L-61676. October 18, 1982

35. PAL vs COA; G.R. No. 91890 June 9, 1995

36. Bagatsing vs Commitee on Privatization; G.R. No. 112399 July 14, 1995

37. VITAL GOZON VS. CA

FACTS: Executive Order No. 119 issued on January 30, 1987 ordered the reorganization of the
various offices of the Ministry of Health where Dr. Alejandro S. de la Fuente was demoted to Medical Specialist
IIfrom being the Chief of the Clinics of the National Children's Hospital. De la Fuente filed a protest with the DOH
Reorganization Board but was ignored and she brought this to Civil Service Commission. While the case was
pending, the position of Chief of Clinics was turned over to and was allowed to be exercised by Dr. Jose D.
Merencilla.Dr. de la Fuente's case was decided and declared that the demotion/transfer of appellant de la
Fuente, Jr. from Chief of Clinics to Medical Specialists II as null and void, the resolution became
final. De la Fuente thereupon sent two (2) letters to Dr. Vital-Gozon, the Medical Center Chief of National
Children's Hospital demanding the implementation of the Commission's decision but she did not
answer Dr. de la Fuente's letters or to take steps to comply or otherwise advise compliance, with the final
and executory Resolution of the Civil Service Commission. She instituted in the Court of Appeals an action of
Mandamus and damages with preliminary injunction" to compel Vital-Gozon, and the Administrative Officer,
Budget Officer and Cashier of the NCH to comply with