Professional Documents
Culture Documents
30 (2006) , 23 34.
ITAK
c TUB
Received 07.03.2005
Abstract
A review of the effect of changes in moulding parameters on polymeric composite injection moulding is
presented in this paper. The emphasis of this work is on the use of short fibre reinforced polymer composite
in the injection moulding process. The behaviours of fibres that influence the performance of the injection
moulding process, like fibre orientation and distribution, fibre concentration and fibre length, are initially
reviewed. The effects of mould design such as the effect of gate design, the effect of the runner system and
the effect of cooling channels are then studied. The effects of processing parameters, particularly the effect
of injection speed, are also discussed. Finally the use of mould flow simulation software is reviewed.
Key words: Injection moulding, Simulation, Fibre orientation, Mold flow analysis.
23
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
200
Stress [MPa]
150
100
50
0
0 0.005 0.01 0.015
Strain
Figure 1. Stress-strain graph with fibres oriented in the direction of strain and transversal to strain (Davies et al., 2002).
24
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
and flow behaves extensionally; thus the transverse Stretching aligns fibres in the direction of
fibre alignment present at the gate is retained. The stretch.
fountain flow behaviour resulted in a shell-core struc-
ture of fibre reinforced injection moulded parts (Fig- Such a condition is exemplified in the case of con-
ure 3). It is apparent from the graph that the centre verging and diverging flow (Figure 4). In diverging
of the part is strongly oriented transverse to the flow flows, the fluid is stretched bi-axially in the plane
and fibres at the edges of the part are strongly ori- perpendicular to the flow direction and the fibres
ented parallel to the flow. tend to be aligned in the cross flow direction. While
Anon (1999) provided 2 basic guidelines for flow- in converging flows, the fluid is stretched along the
induced alignment: flow direction and the fibres tend to be aligned in the
Shear flows align fibres in the direction of flow. flow direction.
Gate
t1 t2 t3 t4
1.0
0.8
Orientation, fp
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-1 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0
25
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
A single parameter fp can be used to present agent it contains (Richardson, 1987). Variation with
the distribution of fibre orientations. This condition fibre volume in the fibre direction is illustrated in
holds true when all the fibre are all in parallel planes Figure 6.
as in thin layers. When all orientations are equally Brunings et al. (1989) compares 2 main types
likely, this parameter becomes 0 and when all the of the PA family, PA 6,6 (30%) and PA6 (40% ).
fibres are perfectly aligned along a reference direc- He concluded that the stiffness of pedal PA6 in the
tion, fp becomes 1. When the fibres are all aligned at dry state is higher than that of the pedal made from
right angles to the reference direction, fp is -1 (Anon, PA66 due to higher glass content.
1999). The variations of fp properties from 0 to 1 are
represented in Figure 5. Effects of fibre length
Matthew and Rawlings (1994) describe factors
that affect fibre orientation distribution: Thomasons (1999) study on fibre properties in glass
Geometrical properties of the fibre fibre reinforced polyamide 6,6 revealed that the av-
Viscoelastic behaviour of the fibre-filled matrix erage fibre length is reduced in all aspects of the pro-
Mould design cessing, i.e. chopping of the fibres, the compounding
The change in shape of the material produced by and the moulding, and finer fibres end up shorter in
the processing operation. the composite.
Generally, the mechanical strength of the composite An assembly of moulds consists of a sprue, runner,
depends on the amount of glass or other reinforcing gate, fixed half and moving half, core and cavity,
26
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
fp = 0.0 random
900
800 uni-directional
700
tensite strength (MPa)
600
500
400
bi-directional
300 (woven roving)
200
random in plane
100 (chopped strand mat)
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
glass content (wt %)
Figure 6. Tensile strength of a glass reinforced plastic versus glass content (by weight) in the fibre direction (Mayer,
1993).
27
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
ejector pins, return pins, cooling channels, ejector mixes adequately, while the fibres align themselves
plate/rod, sprue puller, guide pins, locating plugs, with the flow along the weld line. Jetting results
backplate and spacers. In the injection moulding when plastic flows through a gate and into a cavity
process the placement of gates, runners and cool- without sticking to the mould walls and produces a
ing channels can dramatically alter fibre orientation. rope-like flow or jet, which is then compressed into
Gating is perhaps the most important aspect of the the part (Anon., 2003).
tooling design (Richardson, 1987). Kim et al. (2003) investigated flow patterns and
The types of material to be used for the mould the occurrence of defects that varied with 4 different
cast depend on production volume. For instance, in gate locations (cases 1-4) for an automobile junc-
high production volume, steel is favourable due to its tion box with integral hinges using numerical anal-
wear resistance and durability. While for low volume ysis (Figure 7). That study revealed that a prop-
production or prototype applications, it is common erly determined gate location leads to better resin
to cast moulds from low melting point metals, such flow, thus avoiding defects such as short shot and
as aluminium and zinc, since they are less expensive hesitation marks due to the hesitation effect. The
and are faster to build. hesitation effect occurs in parts of varied thicknesses
where the flow moves preferentially into a thicker
Effects of gate design area. This causes the adjacent thin area to freeze off
while the thicker area fills. Such an effect occurs in
The placement of the gate is an important consider-
cases 3 and 4 in Figure 8.
ation that can often affect shrinkage, moulding effi-
ciency, and part performance (Strong, 2000). Studies
by Davies et al. 2002) and ORegan and Akay (1996) Effects of runner system
agreed that the gate design plays an important role
In injection moulding, melt polymer flows through
in predicting average fibre orientation and resultant
a delivery system consisting of a sprue, a run-
fibre length. Additional fibre attrition occurs when
ner system and gates into individual cavities. A
the gate dimensions are decreased and, with larger
proper runner-system is important, especially for
gate arrangement, average fibre length can be found
a multiple cavities mould since it dictates the fill-
longer in the core region (ORegan and Akay, 1996).
ing pattern, prevents overpacking, diminishes faulty
Primary considerations in designing the gate are its
moulded product parts and increases productivity.
number, size and location. Generally, the gate thick-
Li and Shen (1995) provided 2 main design criteria
ness is 40% to 60% of the part thickness (Beck, 1980).
that should be kept in mind while designing the run-
There are no exact rules for the number of gates
ner system:
for a polymer injection mould. However, 2 factors
that can be considered are material flow length and
part volume. Flow length refers to how far the poly-
mer must flow from the polymer injection location.
Parts with thicker walls cause the material to flow
easily in the thick region compared to parts with Case 3
Case 1
thinner walls, hence a long flow path. Thus, for
thinner parts (shorter flow length) additional gates Case 2
are needed to fill the part. Generally, larger parts,
Case 1
thinner walled parts and higher viscosity materials
require more gates to fill a part. An additional gate
acts to reduce fill pressure, especially when the flow L1
length is long for the wall thickness and material
used. This produces a lower injection pressure, lower
shear rate and lower shear stress levels.
An intensive study by Akay and Barkley (1985)
on the effects of jetting for short glass fibre
polypropylene revealed that jetting is most emphatic L2
with decreasing mould gate dimension. This causes a Figure 7. Analysis model and gate locations (Kim et al.,
weld line to develop in which only the polymer melt 2003).
28
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 8. Predicted flow front for each gate location: (a) Case 1, (b) Case 2, (c) Case 3, (d) Case 4 (Kim et al., 2003).
The pressure loss and total volume in the run- jection pressure, injection speed, injection time, fill-
ner system should be as small as possible, ing time, melt temperature, ejecting pressure, mould
The viscous heating generated by the flow in the temperature, mould geometry shape, material prop-
runner system must be eliminated to avoid degrada- erty of melt, melt speed and heat transfer action of
tion of the polymer material. flow field (Shen et al., 2002).
Processing techniques such as injection moulding
Effects of cooling channel have a devastating effect on fibre length (Matthew
and Rawlings, 1994). Figure 9 shows a polymer com-
A method of cooling is usually incorporated into the posite sampled after the process of injection mould-
mould to speed the solidification of the plastic. Thus, ing. They explained further that the degree of fibre
holes are usually bored in each half of the mould length degradation depends on several process pa-
through which a heat exchange fluid, usually water, rameters such as screw design, shear rates, and melt
can circulate. For parts requiring tight dimensional viscosity and fibre volume fraction.
control or uniform mechanical properties, uniform
Whilst fibres even down to 50 m in length may
cooling is essential. If the part does not solidify uni-
retain some ability to reinforce, it is the fact that
formly in the mould, residual stress will occur as a re-
actual fibre length and its distribution are uncertain
sult of differential shrinkage. An efficient cooling sys-
that can cause problems.
tem also aims to minimise such undesired defects as
sink marks, differential shrinkage and part warpage. Strong (2000) describes some factors that affect
the temperature of the system (for both the melt and
the mould temperature) as:
The Effects of Processing Parameters
Shot size larger shots take more heat
The process parameters that affect the quality of in- Injection rate faster filling creates higher melt
jection moulding products include cooling time, in- temperatures because of shearing
29
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
(a)
30
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
350
300
250
200
kN
150
100
50
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
Time (s)
Simulation 1 Simulation 2 Simulation 3
Simulation 4 Simulation 5 Simulation 6
31
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
1
MPI simulation
0.9
Published result (experimental)
0.8
0.7
0.6
a11
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-1 -0.88 -0.738 -0.577-0.399 -0.206 0 0.206 0.399 0.577 0.738 0.88 1
Fractional distance to the midplane
Figure 13. Fibre orientation in flow direction at 20 mm from the gate (Zainudin, 2002).
Zainudin (2002) compares the simulation results with 10% by weight glass fibre reinforced polycar-
of the short fibre orientation distribution (FOD) ob- bonate composites. Figure 13 indicates that a similar
tained by Moldflow Plastic Insight (MPI) to pub- trend clearly exists between published experimental
lished experimental results of fibre orientation of results and the predicted results of the fibre orienta-
centre-gated disc by Neves et al. (1999). The model tion pattern in an injection moulded polycarbonate
used for both studies is a centre-gated disc moulded disc.
However, huge amounts of data compiled by the more, the accuracy of the simulation results is often
simulation programs frequently make the identifi- doubted in the application of high glass fibre content.
cation of the optimal design and process selection Kim et al. (2003) studied and compared the fibre ori-
very difficult due to the complex non-linear interac- entation of injection moulded fibre-reinforced com-
tions between design and process variables. Further- posite using image processing and numerical simula-
32
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
tion. They concluded that the result of fibre orienta- fects shrinkage, moulding efficiency and part perfor-
tion distribution by the numerical simulation (using mance.
Moldflow) is consistent with that obtained from the One of the processing parameters that affect fibre
image intensity method for low fibre content (30%). orientation is the filling speed.
However, the distribution cannot be predicted for Although many studies have been carried out in
high fibre content (50% and 70%) due to the effects the areas of cavity filling for injection moulds, those
of fibre interaction. pertaining to the relationship between the design of
the injection mould and the product process and
Conclusions product quality are still scarce, especially for glass
fibre reinforced composite automotive clutch pedals.
From this review, the following conclusions can be
drawn:
Fibre orientation and distribution greatly affect Acknowledgements
the final product property since elastic modulus is
much higher when a stress is applied in the direction The authors wish to acknowledge the contribution
of fibre orientation compared to it. Its orientation of Associate Professor Dr Megat Hamdan and As-
and distribution depend on the geometrical proper- sociate Professor Dr Shamsuddin Sulaiman of Uni-
ties of the fibre, viscoelastic behaviour of the fibre versiti Putra Malaysia. This work is funded by the
filled matrix and mould design. Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovations,
Gating (size, location and number) is one of the Malaysia, under IRPA grant scheme project number
most important aspects in mould design since it af- 09-02-04-0323-EA 001.
References
Akay, M. and Barkley, D., Processing-Structure- Chun, D.H., Cavity Filling Analysis of Injection
Property Interaction in Injection Moulded Glass- Molding Simulation: Bubble and Weld Line Forma-
Fibre Reinforced Polypropylene, Composite Struc- tion, Journal of Materials Processing Technology,
ture, 3, 269-293, 1985. 89-90, 177-181, 1999.
Anon., MPI Manual release 2.0, Moldflow Inc., 1996. Davis, B., Gramann, P. and Riows, A., Ef-
fect of fiber orientation anisotropies on the
Anon., Notes on Injection Molding, Intelligent Sys- structural performance of molded FRP com-
tem Laboratory, Michigan State University, Home- posite parts. The Madison Group of Poly-
page: islnotes.cps.msu.edu/trp/inj/inj time.html., mer Processing Research Corporation, Home-
1999. page: www.madisongroup.com/Publications/ Ther-
Anon, Designing with Plastics: The Fundamen- mosets/cfa2002.pdf., 2002.
tals, Homepage: www.ticona-us.com/literature/ Fung, C.P., Hwang, J.R. and Hsu, C.C., The Ef-
documents/VC 7 01 335res 72.dpi.pdf., 2003. fect of Injection Molding Process Parameters on the
Beck, R.D., Plastic Product Design, Van Nostrand Tensile Properties of Short Glass Fiber-Reinforced
PBT, Polymer-Plastics Technology and Engineer-
Reinhold Company Inc, New York, 1980.
ing, 42, 45-63, 2003.
Breitfeleder, E., Processing Recommendations for Kim, H.S., Son, J.S. and Im, Y.T., Gate Location
Injection Moulding of J& A Thermoplasts, www. Design in Injection Molding of an Automobile Junc-
J-a.de/eng/ProcessingRecommendations.pdf# tion Box with Integral Hinges, Journal of Materials
search=Thermoplasts., 2003. Processing Technology, 140, 110-115, 2003.
Bright, F.P. and Darlington, M.W., Factor Influ- Lee, S.C., Yang, D.Y., Ko, J. and Youn, J.R., Ef-
encing Fibre Orientation and Mechanical Proper- fect of Compressibility on Flow Field and Fiber Ori-
ties in Fibre Reinforced Thermoplastics Injection entation during the Filling Stage of Injection Mold-
Moulding, Plastic and Rubber Processing and Ap- ing, Journal of Materials Processing Technology,
plication, 1, 139-147, 1981. 70, 83-92, 1997.
Brunings, W.D., Hauck, C. and Muller, D., Devel- Li, C.S. and Shen, Y.K., Optimum Design of Run-
opment of Vehicle Pedals Made from Glass Fibre Re- ner System Balancing in Injection Molding, Inter-
inforced Polyamide, Kuntstoffe German Plastics, 5, national Communication in Heat and Mass Transfer,
37-38, 1989. 22, 179-188, 1995.
33
SHAHARUDDIN, SALIT, ZAINUDIN
Matthews, F.L. and Rawlings, R.D., Composite Ma- Shen, Y.K., Liu, J.J., Chang, C.T. and Chiu, C.Y.,
terials: Engineering and Science, Chapman & Hall, Comparison of the Results for Semisolid and Plas-
London, 1994. tic Injection Molding Process, Int. Comm. Heat
Maxwell, J., Plastics in the Automotive Industry, Mass Transfer, 29, 97-105, 2002.
Woodhead Publishing Ltd., Cambridge, 1994. Spina, R., Injection Moulding of Automotive Com-
Mayer, R.M., Design with Reinforced Plastics: A ponents: Comparison between Hot Runner System
Guide for Engineers and Designers, The Design for a Case Study, Journal of Materials Processing
Council, London, 1993. Technology, 155-156, 1491-1504, 2004.
Mayer, C., The Moldflow System of Computer
Strong, A.B., Plastics, Materials and Processing,
Aided Polymer Flow Analysis, Materials and De-
Prentice Hall Inc, New Jersey, 2000.
sign, 6, 239-243, 1985.
Nardin, B., Kuzman, K. and Kampus, Z., Injec- Thomason J.L., The Influence of Fibre Proper-
tion Moulding Simulation Results as an Input to ties of the Performance of Glass-Fibre Reinforced
the Injection Moulding Process, Journal of Materi- Polyamide 6, 6, Composite Science and Technol-
als Processing Technology, 130-131, 310-314, 2002. ogy, 59, 2315-2328, 1999.
Neves, N.M., Pontes, A.J. and Pouzada, A.S., Ex- Vlachopoulos, J. and Strutt, D., Overview: Poly-
perimental Validation of C-Mold Fibre Orientation mer Processing, Material Science Technology, 19,
Predictions in Short Fibre Reinforced Polycarbon- 1153-1160, 2003.
ate Disc, Proceedings of 2nd ESAFORM Confer-
ence, Guimaraes, Portugal, 171-174, 1999. Waterman, N.A. and Ashby, M.F., Elsevier Mate-
ORegan D. and Akay, M., The Distribution of Fi- rials Selector, Volume 3, Elsevier Science Publisher
bre Lengths in Injection Moulded Polyamide Com- Ltd., Essex, 1991.
posite Components, Journal of Materials Process- Zainudin, E.S., Fiber Orientation of Short Glass
ing Technology, 56, 282-291, 1996. Fiber Reinforced Injection Molded Thermoplas-
Richardson, T., Composites: A Design Guide, In- tic Composites, Master Thesis, Universiti Putra
dustrial Press Inc., New York, 1987. Malaysia, Malaysia.
34