Reasoned document

SN Clause Description Comments furnished by Views of TI

No. in Specification Directorate.
M/s ASHIDA, Thane M/s ALIND, Trivandrum

1. 6.1.13 6.1.13 The numerical 6.1.13 Our system is 6.1.13 The numerical M/s ALIND
relays shall be capable fix. and we should not relays shall be capable of comment is
of storing minimum go for field storing minimum 5000 acceptable and M/s
5000 events serially configuration. It will events serially with date ASHIDA comment is
with date and time increase unnecessary and time stamp of 1ms not acceptable as
stamp of 1ms accuracy. complication There is accuracy. The events the event definitions
The events definitions provision in SCADA definitions shall be may be configured
shall be configurable software to filter configurable and by relay
and generally include unwanted events generally include tripping manufacturers if felt
tripping of different of different protection necessary in future
protection elements, Firm should give elements, relay pickup, to meet the field
relay pickup, relay reset, mapping file for event relay reset, relay blocked requirement.
CB trip, CB close, so that it can be use due to harmonics or any
changed of status input, while SCADA other restraints, CB trip,
relay setting changed, integration CB close, changed of
trip circuit monitoring status input, relay
etc. The events shall be setting changed, trip
retrievable through an circuit monitoring etc.
external laptop/PC. The events shall be
retrievable through an
external laptop/PC.
2. 6.1.25 6.1.25 The module shall There is a difficulty in Accepted
also be capable to accommodating all the
display I (fault current), mentioned parameters in
V(voltage), clause 6.1.25 viz, fault
R(resistance), current, viltage,
X(reactance), Phase resistance, phase angle,
angle, Delta-I current, delta-I current, fault
fault clearing time and clearing time and fault
fault date & time date & time in LCD
(wherever applicable) of window. The current,
latest 100 faults at relay voltage, resistance and
LCD. The CTs & PTs reactance, phase angle,
 provided at TSS may fault type and fault date
have different ratios, and time will be stamped
hence to display the with the corresponding
actual value (line value) event number. The delta-
of I, V, R, X ect. the CT I current and fault
primary current shall be clearing time can be
settable in the range of accessed with pressing
100 to 3000A in the one scroll key. This will
steps of 50A and PT maintain same event
primary voltage shall be number along with time
settable in the range of of occurrence of fault.
20000V to 30000V in
steps of 500V. On line
current, voltage,
Reactance & Resistance
shall also be displayed
on relay LCD.

6.1.24 The contacts of the relay We should not specify - Accepted

shall be silver / gold contact material The auxiliary relay
plated. The rating of because seal relay used in the relay
output contacts of the manufactures use nos. are of sealed type.
protective relays shall allows such as AgSnO2
be adequate to operate / AgNi_Au Plated etc..
the associated output for better contact
relays. Suitable snubber capacity
to be provided across
the coil.
9.2.1 Damp heat test, steady Dry heat as per - Accepted
(xiii) state as per IEC 60068- IEC601255-1/ By adding these
2-3 IEC60068-2-2 (This will tests the reliability
Damp heat test, cyclic test from +20 to of relay under
as per IEC 60068-2-30 +70deg) different
Cold Test as per environment
IEC60255-1/IEC60068- condition may be
2-1 (This will test from improved.
-25 to +20)
Change in Temperature
IEC60255-1/IEC60068-
2-14 Nb(This will test
 from -25 to +55)
Damp heat study and
damp head cyclic will
test at high humidity

9.2.1 Radiated, radio- IEC had revised - Accepted

(xiv) frequency, IEC60255-26 in may The existing IEC
electromagnetic field 2013. The new is 60255-22 as
immunity test as per marked as ed.3-2013 mentioned in
IEC60255 -22- 3 see note in standard. ( specification has
there is no nuch change been superseded by
test specs / procedure IEC60255-26.
just merge in one all
EMI/EMC)

International Standard
IEC 60255-26 has been
prepared by IEC
technical committee
95: Measuring relays
and protection
equipment.
This third edition
cancels and replaces
the second edition
published in 2008. This
third edition also
cancels and replaces
the following standards:
IEC 60255-22-1:2007,
IEC 60255-22-2:2008;
IEC 60255-22-3:2007,
IEC 60255-22-4:2008,
IEC 60255-22-5:2008,
IEC 60255-22-6:2001
and IEC 60255-22-
7:2003, IEC 60255-
11:2008, IEC 60255-
25:2000 and IEC
60255-26:2008