Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Essay Assignment
11/21/2016
The current election season has yielded a host of unexpected outcomes, creating
an atmosphere that most would deem unusual. With this unusual season in mind, there
comes the question regarding the medias interpretations and portrayal of the various
outcomes. Looking particularly at Hillary Clintons concession speech, the varying sides
and angles of support by two popular news outlets will be examined. This examination
will compare and contrast the ways and techniques in which the information
surrounding this speech is portrayed and in return, how this portrayal impacts the
American population.
Beginning with a comparison between the primary source, being the speech
transcript, and the two secondary sources, being the CNN and the Wall Street Journal
news reports, there are some important factors to point out. First, these secondary
sources take the raw information in the form of a speech transcript and bring out the
narrative within. But how do these secondary portray a narrative sense? They look at the
campaign in the form of a journey such as Mrs. Clinton appeared poised to bring her
this includes setting the scene and giving the surroundings for the speech such as Her
supporters even gathered beneath an actual glass ceiling, at Javits Center in New York
as well as much of the seating at Clinton's remarks was for staff and aides (Nelson,
2016). Also, the narrative is told by relaying the mood, emotions, and peoples reactions
such as Quiet moments in the speech were filled with tears, sniffles and some sobs
(Collinson, 2016). These themes portrayed in the secondary sources allow for the
audience to more fully understand the situation surrounding this political event, without
source offers its own advantages. Often within narratives in the news, there are hidden
agendas in which messages are portrayed with a certain bias. Primary sources, such as
her supporters. This allows the audience to interpret what is being communicated via
their own cultural lens, using their own experiences and knowledge to further
understand the messages being communicated. This first hand evidence provided by the
speech transcript allows for a bias-free starting ground for people to base their opinions
on what Senator Clinton has communicated, without being told what to read or how to
they represent the majority of news information received by the American people. To
star, the most logical coverage of an important speech, such as Senator Clintons on
Wednesday, is to pull out impactful and significant quotes and ideas. The attention then
moves to the political agenda that can be displayed by news companies which comes
into play in the particular quotes and ideas being highlighted. In many ways, both the
CNN and the Wall Street Journal articles delivered information from a similar outlook,
taking into consideration the happenings of the speech and the surrounding situation.
However, differences do exist and by looking at CNNs coverage of this speech, it can be
seen that the article provides a more liberal, democratic take on the address as the tone
of the article empathizes with Senator Clinton and her supporters. Throughout the news
article, phrases such as filled with tears, sniffles and some sobs, wiping away tears,
and her voice breaking with emotion were found as an expression of the devastation
this loss was for the democratic party and its supporters (Collinson, 2016). This agenda
appeals to supporters of Senator Clinton as they are experiencing unrest over the
This differs from the coverage found in the Wall Street Journal, which provided
references to Trump were more commonly found, including statements such as Mr.
Trump pulled off one of the biggest upsets in political history on Tuesday, portraying
Trump in a fairly neutral, almost positive light. Similarly, Senator Clinton is also
portrayed in a less idolized way, being described as suffering a shocking defeat at the
and agenda setting themes show the power that news companies have in delivering
messages to the public. Similarly, the particular quotes highlighted within the articles
Similarly, the specific content of the quotes provided in each of the articles
differed in their tone and communication. CNN chose to include quotes highlighting
Senator Clintons deep care and concern for her supporters including her personal
thanks to Anastasia Somoza, a few of her pollsters, members of her campaign crew, and
many others. The article even chose to include outside Tweets from the social media
site, Twitter, from individuals from Donald Trumps campaign highlighting the very
classy speech from @HillaryClinton (Collinson, 2016). The CNN article overall
displaying quite high praise for Senator Clinton regarless of the election outcome. On
the other hand, the Wall Street Journal shared similar sentiment in regards to the
positive talk about Senator Clinton, but also included more discussion of the future
involving president-elect Donald Trump, remarking their battle is over and that the
With this being said, it is crucial to understand how this idea of political bias and
agenda applies to those that are most deeply affected by this form of media: the
American people. As it was seen in the Trump campaign, the silent majority was deeply
impacted by the agenda Donald Trump set through his passion to give those without a
voice a chance and speak out against groups that are disliked or feared. Similarly, in the
Clinton campaign, there was an agenda set in opposition to the Trump campaign in
which Hillary Clinton was portrayed as an accepting, caring figure who sought to bring
hope to a different set of minorities and groups. Through all of the political happenings,
there are many news agencies covering the stories. As it is inherent in our human
nature, people will always speak with some degree of bias or opinion because we every
The key for the American people is learning how to discern and decipher the
messages communicated by the media. Each individual has a lens that they view the
world by which is unique to themselves. It is when one is challenged in their view that
conflict and tension arise. To be able to communicate and discuss areas of overlap or
collision of views is where progress and future orientation begin. In the case of the
current political situation, I have found great enjoyment in using the skills from this
class to be able to differentiate and examine the various viewpoints and schools of
thought between parties and political orientation. Not only have my eyes been opened to
alternative schools of thought, but my own beliefs and convictions have been altered and
then strengthened due to the knowledge gained from this study. My hope is to be able to
use this knowledge and skills to help inform people of the ways to interpret news media
and use this media to spark healthy, productive dialogue and discussion.
Works Cited:
Collinson, Stephen, Dan Merica, and Jeff Zeleny. "Clinton Delivers Painful Concession
Speech." CNN. Cable News Network, 10 Nov. 2016. Web. 21 Nov. 2016.
"Hillary Clinton's Concession Speech (full Text)." CNN. Cable News Network, 9 Nov.
Nelson, Colleen McCain. "Hillary Clinton Concedes: 'This Is Painful, And It Will Be For