Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
Corruption is a crime or an offense where a person's liberty, contracts or
benefits from the authorities or of a company after giving money, gifts,
entertainment for parties. In particular, corruption is classified by
Transparency International is an activity that involves the abuse of entrusted
power for private gain. In dictionary Mozley and Whiteleys Law Dictionary,
John B. Saunders gave a definition of corruption by taking or giving money to
the performance or non-performance of their public duties. Additionally,
corruption also have a variety of calls used by individuals as 'kaw tim', 'duit
kopi', 'duit pelincir', 'tangkal pengeras', 'under counter payment' and many
others.
1
human civilization which tainted by nature greedy. According to the
Transparency International (2015), Malaysia has achieved a Corruption
Perception Index (CPI) score of 52 over 100 and ranked at 50 among 175
countries and being recognized as the second least corrupted nation in South
East Asia. Compare to the previous year 2013, Malaysia has lifted up three
notches whereby it was ranked at 53 out of 175 countries. The improvement
of CPI ranking of Malaysia justifies the effectiveness of the efforts by the
Malaysian Government to fight corruption. The effectiveness in eliminating
corruption and improvement in corruption level is mostly depends on the
functions of legislation and government strategies.
The MACC was set up whose main purpose was to eliminate corruption, and
prevent the abuse of power and malpractices. After taking into consideration
the developments taking place in the country and elsewhere, this Act was
revised in 1971 and subsequently repealed and replaced with the Prevention
of Corruption Act 1997. Since its formation, the Anti-Corruption Agency has
played a significant role in combating corruption, investigates and prosecutes
corruption in the public and private sectors, maintaining the integrity of
government administration and promoting awareness among members of the
public of the dangers of corruption and abuse of power.
2
2. Significant Economic Corruption in Malaysia
Corruption is a debatable issue that happens worldwide regardless the
countries are rich or poor, dictatorships or democracies, socialist or
capitalists. Mauro (1995), Knack and Keefer (1995) and Brempong (2002)
found that corruption is negatively related to economic growth. Many
researchers argued that corruption hurts the economic growth because
corruption may create uncertainty environment thereby reduce investment,
government spends less on public project when lower tax revenue, and exert
of "informal cost" could cause other institution ineffective (Diaby & Sylwester,
2014).
David Ng (2006) support by saying, The World Bank assumes this corruption
as one of the biggest threats to economic and social development which may
lead to hinder the development of the country and also undermine the basic
institutions in economic development. According to Wei (1999), low growth of
economic is caused by high corruption level. The cost of corruption can be
separated into four major groups, which are economic, political, social, and
environmental. Moroever,corruption is one of the biggest obstacles to
economic and social development (Lauritzen & Sondergaard, 2012).
Next, the weak governance in the country which due to the failure for both
government transformation program and economic transformation program is
3
one of the causes in corruption. In Malaysia, public perceived that corruption
level is high and the economic growth is slow down by corruption. According
to Caron, Ficici & Richter (2012) a strong relationship between corruption and
weak corporate governance is found. Mounts (2010) stated that weak
government hypothesis refers to government fragmentation leads to higher
public deficits and debt. As the government does not lead their follower
properly, it will incur a country debt. As country growth does not perform well
and thus the government servants unable to get high salary. Lower salary
earned by the public servants is unable to increase their standard of living.
Thus, they are intending to look for some extra money when they perform
their duties. Several cases of corruption involving elites can serve as an
example, Dato Seri Khir Toyo, the former Selangor Menteri Besar, Penang
Chief Minister YAB Lim Guan Eng and more.
4
Chart I
Gupta et al. (1998) also found that corruption can lead to reduced social spending on
health and education. Countries with higher corruption tend to have lower levels of social
spending, regardless of level of development. Corruption lowers tax revenues, increases
government operating costs, increases government spending for wages and reduces
5
spending on operations and maintenance, and often biases government toward spending
on higher education and tertiary health care (rather than basic education and primary
health care).
According to Robert Thobabeen (1991, p.62) buying contracts can be called also
Kickbacks "when government officials may use their bargaining power with contractors
and their discretion in awarding contracts to obtain a fee or service charge for arraigning
the contract. A percentage, usually 5 percent, of the contracts is returned or kicked back
to the public officials by the contractor." According to World Bank report (1997 p.20)
It is important to have in place an effective legal framework that is not only effective, but
also responsive to contemporary challenges. In addition, an independent judiciary that
ensures justice is dispensed speedily and fairly, without fear or favor, is also highly
6
critical in instilling confidence among the people.
Public agencies established with the main objective to meet the needs of the
people and the country. To achieve these objectives, public service delivery
system that is ethically required that government policies will be
implemented effectively. The importance of civil servants ethics is to create
administrative and civil service that is efficient and disciplined through the
application of values that can overcome the problems and weaknesses in
numerous aspects of governance such as financial management, handling
cases of disciplinary, corruption, abuse of power and malpractices prohibited
by regulation, law and religion (Jamiah et al., 2004).
7
Corruption ruins the public trust in government institution and damage the
social capital as well as human capital. Social capital refers to the public trust
on government where the human capital refers to labor productivity. The
effect of social capital decline extensively on low income group and bring less
incentive for the poor to participate in productive activity. The social capital of
Malaysia is ruined and lowers the level of confidence of foreign investors
towards Malaysia.
Secondly, the Malaysian government has tried to improve the public service
delivery system, various policies have been implemented by the government
such as the Fundamental Values and Ethics in the Public Service, which has
been practiced in various programs at the enterprise level such as the
drafting of a code of conduct on business, meet customers and the
establishment of the monitoring team (Ab. Rahman, 2005 & Mazilan et al.,
2005). However, the challenge of establishing and maintaining good service
is hard to bear given the size of public organizations and a large number of
employees.
Last but not least, Modernization. When social and economic development is
not equally balanced with the spiritual development in oneself, therefore it
will facilitate the occurrence of corruption. When more project in development
are decided, it means more cash will be required. Nevertheless, for those who
involves may take this opportunity to earn as much profit as the can. Many
contractors are seen to struggle in order to possess tenders which worth
millions or billions and willing to offer high bribes in bidding process of large
development project.
8
6. Conclusion
We have seen that high levels of corruption have very harmful effects on economic and
political development as in other countries as well as in Malaysia. Among the
implications that can be done is to reform the arena political to reduce
political corruption and eliminate the opportunity to do any corrupt activities.
Then, it is also necessary to strengthen the law enforcement institutions
especially the MACC, judiciary and police. Their enforcement should be
established outright to ensure public confidence in these institutions. In
addition, enforcing the rule of law without fear or favor particular cases
serious. And it is not supposed to have fallen prosecution arbitrarily.
Government should undertake only what it can do well within its resource
constraints. Besides, government should develop well functioning budget
processes, allocate resources strategically, and enable programs and projects
to be implemented efficiently and effectively. Meantime, good financial
management system is also a powerful instrument for preventing,
discovering, or facilitating the punishment of fraud and corruption. In my
point of view, audit and control are viewed as a valuable instrument for
improving government fiscal management and for increasing the efficiency in
the allocation of public financial resources. The introduction or reinforcement
of auditing would be particularly important because it intervenes before
resources are committed. Tax and customs departments as we have seen are
the locus of major fraud and corruption and thus are candidates for inclusion
in national strategies to control corruption. Tax system must be reformed to
reduce the tax burden and state should launch anticorruption campaigns.
Such campaigns can have a legitimizing effect, in that they usually suggest
that the state is serious about fighting corruption.
The movement to enhance integrity has increasingly captured the imagination of various
levels of the Malaysian society. This movement is turning into a social force for the
effective management of the country's success and overcoming of its weaknesses. The
launching of the National Integrity Plan (NIP) and the establishment of the Integrity
9
Institute of Malaysia (11M) have become the most important catalyst towards realizing
the objectives of enhancing integrity. All these will enable Malaysia to steadily move
forward in her efforts to become a developed nation in its own mold, and emerge as a
nation of excellence, glory and distinction.
2798 words
References
Caron, M. I., Fiici, A., & Richter, C. L. (2012). The influence of corruption on corporate
governance standards: Shared characteristics of rapidly developing economies.
Emerging Markets Journal, 2, 20-37.
Diaby, A., & Sylwester, K. (2014). Bureaucratic competition and public corruption:
Evidence from transition countries. European Journal of Political Economy, 35,
7587.
10
Minister of Malaysia. 8 July 2011. Retrieved 28 July 2011.
Gupta, S., Mello, L. D., & Sharan, R. (2001). Corruption and military spending.
European Journal of Political Economy, 17(4), 749-777.
Knack, S., & Keefer, P. (1995). Institutions and economic performance: Crosscountry
tests using alternative institutional measures. Economics and Politics, 7(3), 207227.
Mazilan Musa, Izal Arif Zahrudin, Suzanna Che Moin (eds)(2005) Etika dan Intergriti di
Malaysia:Isu dan Cabaran. Institusi Integriti Malaysia (IIM), Kuala Lumpur.
Mounts, M. E. (2010). Economic growth and the Asian paradox: A study on the
differential effect of corruption in India. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
University of North Carolina Wilmington.
11
www.emeraldinsight.com/0307- 4358.htm. 30(10): 822-836.
Petrou, A. P., & Thanos,(2014) I. C. The grabbing hand or the helping hand view of
corruption: Evidence from bank foreign market entries. Journal of World Business,
49(3), 444-454.
Sequeira, S. & Djankov, S. (2010). "An Empirical Study of Corruption in Ports." MPRA
Paper 21791, University Library of Munich, Germany.
World Bank. (1997) World Development Report: State In a Changing World: New York:
Oxford University Press
http://www.tradingeconomics.com/malaysia/corruption-rank
http://www.jkrbentong.gov.my/
12