You are on page 1of 5

SECTION 31.

Liability of Directors, Trustees or consenting directors or trustees for damages under


Section 31.
Officers

Three-fold duties: SECTION 33. Contracts between corporations with


(O)bedience, (L)oyalty, (D)iligence interlocking directors.
Interlocking Director a director in one corporation who is
Directors of the corporation are its agents. They
also a director in another.
are under obligations of trust and confidence to the
corporation and its stock holders and must act in good Contracts with interlocking directors are valid so long
faith and for the interest of the corporation or its as there is no fraud and the contract is fair and
stockholders with due care and diligence and within the reasonable.
scope of their authority.
If the interest of the interlocking director in
In the absence of malice, bad faith or specific Corporation A is substantial and, on Corporation B only
provision of law, a director or officer of a corporation nominal, the Section 32 shall apply insofar as the latter
cannot be made personally liable for corporate liabilities. corporation is concerned.
*Cases when directors / trustees or officers are liable for Substantial interest - SH exceed 20%
damages (SOLIDARILY LIABLE in PERSONAL Nominal interest SH do not exceed 20%

CAPACITY): Section 32 applies on transactions between


a) He willfully and knowingly votes or assents to corporations with interlocking directors resulting in the
patently unlawful acts of the corporation; prejudice to one of the corporations. It does not apply
b) He is guilty of gross negligence or bad faith in where the corporation allegedly prejudiced is a third
directing the affairs of the corporation; party (not one with interlocking director).
But they are not liable for business losses incurred
Gokongwei, Jr. vs SEC Doctrine by-laws may provide that
because of honest bad judgment alone not amounting
to bad faith or gross negligence. a director of a corporation may be disqualified as a director
of a competing corporation. (valid limitation on interlocking
c) He acquires any personal or pecuniary interest
directors)
in conflict with his duty as such director or
trustee. SECTION 34. Disloyalty of a director.
He shall be held accountable for the profits (as trustee)
which otherwise would have accrued to the corporation. Doctrine of Corporate Opportunity a director is
*Other cases where PERSONAL LIABLITY may attach: guilty of disloyalty when by the virtue of his
office, he acquires for himself a business
a) When he consents to the issuance of watered opportunity which should belong to the
stocks or who, having knowledge thereof, does corporation, thereby obtaining profits to the
not forthwith file with the corporate secretary his prejudice of such corporation.
written objection thereto; The director must account to the corporation all
b) When he is made, by a specific provision of law, profits (by refund) notwithstanding that he risk his
own funds in the venture.
to personally answer for his corporate action; Profits obtained must prejudice the corporation.
c) When he agrees to hold himself personally and
solidarily liable with the corporation. Section 34 applies to directors. Disloyalty of
officers is governed by Section 31.
SECTION 32. Dealings of directors, trustees or
officers with the corporation. When doctrine is not applicable:

Contracts with self-dealing Directors / Trustees / a) Enterprise engaged in is distinct from


Officers generally void. Injury to the corporation is not corporation business
Director may engage in the same general class of
necessary.
business with the corporation so long as he acts in
good faith.
A contract of the corporation with one or more of its
b) Opportunity no in conflict with corporations
directors (or trustees, officers) is voidable at the option of
business
the corporation, unless: not essential to the corporations business;
company resources are not exploited;
a) That the presence of such director or trustee in no direct competition with the corporation
the board meeting in which the contract was c) Opportunity ceases to be a corporate
approved was not necessary to constitute a opportunity
quorum for such meeting; It ceases to be a corporate opportunity and
b) That the vote of such director or trustee was not becomes a personal opportunity when the
necessary for the approval of the contract; corporation is definitely no longer able to avail
itself of the opportunity (e.g. insolvency, legal
c) That the contract is fair and reasonable under
restrictions, any other factor which prevents it from
the circumstances; and, acting upon the opportunity for its own advantage).
If only the 3rd condition is present, the contract should
be ratified by 2/3 votes of the SH of OCS, and, full A guilty director will only be exempt from his
disclosure of the adverse interest of the directors or
liability if his disloyal act is ratified by at least 2/3 vote of
trustees involved is made.
It is silent W/N the vote of the self-dealing director shall the SH of the OCS. Section 34 is silent W/N the disloyal
be counted during the meeting for ratification. director shall be allowed to vote herein.
d) That in the case of an officer, the contract has
been previously authorized by the board of Section 34 applies only where a business
directors opportunity belongs to the corporation and the director
BOD may elect not to question the validity of the takes advantage of that business opportunity for his
contract without prejudice to the liability of the own.
A corporation may be awarded with moral damages based
on its good reputation or business standing when it is
besmirched or debased.
The right and power of a corporation to sue in any court
must be brought by the BOD.
Shareholders in their personal capacity has no right to
SECTION 35. Executive Committee intervene in an action for or against a corporation.

Created by: By-laws 2. Of succession by its corporate name for the period of
Composition: At least 3 members of BOD; time stated in the articles of incorporation and the
non-BOD members may be added certificate of incorporation;
Source of By-laws, majority vote of BOD
3. To adopt and use a corporate seal;
power:
Purpose: To assure prompt and speedy Seal is a device (e.g. emblem, symbol, or
action and solution to important word) used to identify or replace the signature of
matters without the need for a an individual or organization written matter
board meeting. purportedly emanating from such individual or
organization. It may refer also to the impression
Powers: By majority votes of its members, of such a device on documents like certificates
act on specific matters within its of stocks.
competence. A seal is not required for the validity of any corporate act.
ADVANTAGE: presence of such establishes, prima facie,
As practiced in the business, the that the instrument to which it is affixed is the act of the
corporation.
EC may reduce the Directors to
little more than a supervising and 4. To amend its articles of incorporation in accordance
ratifying body. with the provisions of this Code;

Exceptions: (1) Approval of any action for 5. To adopt by-laws, not contrary to law, morals, or public
which SHs approval is also policy, and to amend or repeal the same in accordance
required; with this Code;
(2) The filing of vacancies in the
6. In case of stock corporations, to issue or sell stocks to
board;
subscribers and to sell treasury stocks in accordance
(3) The amendment or repeal of
with the provisions of this Code; and to admit members
by-laws or the adoption of new by-
to the corporation if it be a non-stock corporation;
laws;
(4) the amendment or repeal of A corporation has no power to purchase or hold
any resolution of the board which stock in another corporation unless it is one of
by its express terms is not so the activities permitted by its articles of
amenable or repealable; incorporation.
(5) A distribution of cash dividends When a corporation subscribes to the capital
to the shareholders; and, stock of another corporation, it is required, as a
(6) Other matters as may be rule, to pay its subscription in full. This is based
provided by the board. upon the fact that while a corporation has an
unlimited capacity to contract obligations, it has
Quorum: Majority of all (regardless of being only a limited capacity to pay.
a BOD member) A corporation may purchase its own stock,
however, only when it has "unrestricted retained
Voting: Majority of all earnings" to cover the shares to be purchased or
Alien member: Allowed
acquired.

7. To purchase, receive, take or grant, hold, convey, sell,


Foreigners are disqualified as a Corporate
lease, pledge, mortgage and otherwise deal with such
Officer but is allowed as a member of BOD or other
real and personal property, including securities and
governing bodies as provided in the Anti-Dummy Law. In
bonds of other corporations, as the transaction of the
the latters case, there can be no intervention in the
lawful business of the corporation may reasonably and
management, operation, administration, and control of
necessarily require, subject to the limitations prescribed
the corporation by the members thereof in their
by law and the Constitution;
individual capacity.
In selling securities to the public, the corporation
SECTION 36. Corporate powers and capacity.
must be registered with SEC thru a registration
1. To sue and be sued in its corporate name; statement (as per R 8799).

Incidental power 8. To enter into with other corporations merger or


Corporations de facto may sue or be sued. consolidation as provided in this Code;
A corporation which has been dissolved after the expiration
of the three (3)-year winding-up period ceases to exist de 9. To make reasonable donations, including those for the
jure or de facto. public welfare or for hospital, charitable, cultural,
A corporation not duly registered in accordance with law has
no legal capacity to sue as such. scientific, civic, or similar purposes. Provided, That no
Foreign corporations which transact business in the corporation, domestic or foreign, shall give donations in
Philippines without the necessary license from SEC sue in aid of any political party or candidate or for purposes of
the Philippine courts. partisan political activity;
LIMITATIONS: (a) the amount thereof must be Unless otherwise provided by the Code, to be
exercised by BOD.
reasonable; and (b) the donations must not be in may be exercised even not mentioned in the by-
aid of any political party or candidate or for laws or AOI;
purposes of partisan political activity. b) Sections 37 44.
The limitation that the donations must be
"reasonable" provides a check against scheming Implied Powers powers which are reasonably
directors and officers who may use the authority necessary to execute the express powers and to
as a screen to appropriate corporate funds for accomplish or carry out the purposes for which the
personal ends. corporation was formed.

10. To establish pension, retirement, and other plans for Powers merely convenient or useful are not
the benefit of its directors, trustees, officers and implied if they are not essential, having in view the
employees; and, purposes or objects of the corporation.

11. To exercise such other powers as may be essential The purpose or purposes of the corporation, its
or necessary to carry out its purpose or purposes as AOI, scope of corporate business or enterprise, delimits
stated in its articles of incorporation. (13a) its implied powers.

DISTINGUISH:

Powers of a corporation corporation's capacity Classification of Implied Powers:


or right under its charter and laws to do certain 1. Acts in the usual course of business.
things. Example/s: borrowing money; making ordinary
Primary Franchise corporation's capacity or contracts; executing promissory notes, checks
right under its charter and laws to do certain or bills of exchange; taking notes or other
things. securities; acquiring personal property for use in
Secondary Franchise the right granted to an connection with the business; acquiring lands
existing corporation to use public property for a and buildings to be used as places of business
public use, but with private profit. or in connection therewith; and selling, leasing,
mortgaging or other transfers of property of the
Doctrine of Limited Capacity the right granted to
an existing corporation to use public property for a corporation in connection with the manning of
public use, but with private profit. A corporation the business.
owes its existence to the State and, therefore, it
has only such powers as are expressly and These acts, under ordinary circumstances, are
impliedly granted by law. A corporation, as an necessary in order to run a business.
artificial person, created by or under authority of
law, is without natural rights. 2. Acts to protect debts owing to a corporation.
Example/s: a corporation may purchase
Classification of Corporate Power:
property, act as a guarantor or sometimes even
a) Those expressly granted or authorized by law, run a business temporarily to collect a debt,
Corporation Code and AOI; where otherwise it would have no power to do
b) Those that are necessary to the exercise of the so.
express or incidental powers; and,
c) Those incidental to its existence. 3. Embarking in different business.

Acts or contracts of a corporation outside the scope Example/s: This is especially true with respect to
of its express, implied, and incidental powers are ultra those particular kinds of corporate activities
vires. which are governed by special laws. Thus, a
corporation not organized for that purpose
In determining W/N the corporation has a power to cannot go into the banking or insurance
do an act: business but it may do any isolated act of
banking or insurance in connection with some
a) first, refer to its special charter or its AOI to see
express power. So, it is generally held that a
whether it is within the express, implied, or
corporation may temporarily conduct an outside
incidental powers conferred;
business to collect a debt out of its profits
b) then, to examine the statutes relating to
corporations to see if the act is prohibited; and, 4. Acts in part or wholly to protect or aid
c) in some cases, to consult the general statutes to employees.
see if the act is illegal even in case of natural While the cases are divided, the better view favors
persons. such acts as building homes, places of
amusement, hospitals, etc. for employees, as
It is illegal for a corporation to apply either its capital within the corporate powers.
or profits to business for purposes not contemplated by
5. Acts to increase business.
its charter. The corporation's intended purposes must be
Example/s: contests or sponsor radio or
stated with sufficient clarity in the articles of
television programs, or promote fairs and other
incorporation so as to define with certainty the scope of
gatherings to advertise and increase its
its business.
business.
Expressed Powers powers conferred by the
EXPRESS POWERS IMPLIED POWERS
Corporation Code, the special law creating the
corporation, the General Incorporation Code and AOI.

a) Section 36.
the means and b) By board of directors (or trustees). Similarly, a
Determined by Deals with
The main business, transaction, if within the powers of a corporation,
methods of attaining
objects and purposes may be consented to, ratified, or acquiesced in
those objects and
of the Corporation. by the board of directors (or trustees) if it could
purposes
be authorized by them. If it is consented to or
May change ratified with full knowledge of the facts, it is
according to time, finally and absolutely binding, and neither the
its charter and the
place and corporation nor individual stockholders (or
applicable laws
surrounding members) nor strangers can afterwards sue to
circumstances set it aside or otherwise attack its validity.
W/N they are fairly
incidental to the EP Omnis ratihabitio retrotrahitur ratification by a
W/N it is found in the
Test

and reasonably corporation of an unauthorized act or contract by


charter or law
necessary to carry its officers or others relates back to the time of
them out in the the act or contract ratified, and is equivalent to
original authority.
Except as to intervening rights of strangers
Incidental or inherent powers powers which a
corporation can exercise by the mere fact of its being a
corporation or powers which are necessary to corporate
existence and are, therefore, impliedly granted. They Mode of exercising powers
exist independently of the express powers. (1) If the charter of a corporation prescribes no particular
Example/s: the power of succession; to sue and be mode for the exercise of its powers, they may be
sued; to have a corporate name; to purchase and hold exercised in any mode, provided it is not contrary to law,
real and personal property; to adopt and use a corporate which the stockholders or officers may deem best.
seal; to contract; to make by-laws; to establish branch (2) If the charter requires its powers to be exercised in
offices here or abroad, etc. any particular way by officers or agents, they cannot be
Construction of Powers properly exercised in any other way. In ultra vires
transactions, the fact that a corporation exercises a
(1) They are to be construed strictly; any ambiguity in the power in a mode different from that prescribed by its
terms of the corporate charter must operate against the charter will not necessarily prevent it from acquiring
corporation and in favor of the public. rights or incurring liabilities by reason thereof.

(2) The whole instrument is to be taken together, (3) Where a corporation is organized under a special
including provisos as expressing the final intention and law, the rules governing corporations organized under
purposes of the parties. the general law have no application where the special
statutes provide methods for the regulation and control
(3) Corporate franchises should be so construed as not of said corporation.
to defeat the purpose of their creation.
Power to act as guarantor
The intention of the legislature should always
control. *GR: no corporation has the power, by any form of
(4) Charters are also to be construed in view of the contract or endorsement, to become a guarantor or
circumstances, usages, and practices existing at the surety or otherwise lend its credit to another person or
time they were granted. corporation. A corporation is without implied power to
guarantee for accommodation the contract of its
It is not the province of the court to enlarge the customers with third persons on the ground that it may
powers of a corporation beyond its charter thus stimulate its own business. Such use of its credit is
limitations because circumstances have changed.
clearly beyond the power of an ordinary business
(5) If the charter is susceptible of two meanings, the one corporation.
restricting and the other extending the powers of the
*EXCEPTION: Implied authorization, where the
corporation, that construction is to be adopted which
guarantee "tends directly to promote the business
works the least harm to the State.
authorized by its AOI" or "is an appropriate means by
(6) The provisions of a general incorporation law may which it may reasonably be expected that the business
apply to corporations operating under special statutes in which the corporation is engaged will be advanced."
with respect to the conduct or government of such
corporations as to which no specific provision has been Parent corporations may guaranty the debts of a
made. subsidiary company.

Ratification of corporate acts Section 37. Power to extend or shorten corporate


term.
a) By stockholders (or members). They may
ratify and render valid acts done or authorized *Requirements for extension or shortening of corporate
by the board of directors (or trustees) but which term: an amendment of the articles of incorporation
were beyond the powers of the directors, or acts approved by the majority vote of the board of directors or
done or authorized by the directors at an illegal trustees and ratified at a meeting of the stockholders
meeting, or unauthorized acts of others than the representing at least 2 / 3 of the outstanding capital
directors, provided the acts done are such as stock or by at least 2 /3 of the members in case of non-
may be done or authorized by the stockholders. stock corporations.
APPRAISAL RIGHT of dissenting SH (Stock Corp only). Express Power
An increase or reduction in the capital stock of
It is the right to withdraw SOS; appraisal to the
the corporation is a fundamental change in the
current FMV. corporation.
Extension Section 37 Increase / Decrease of CS needs the approval
Shortening Section 81
of SEC.
Unlike in Section 16 which governs the amendment Limitations
in general of articles of incorporation, the amendment
under Section 37 must be taken at a meeting of the (1) A corporation cannot lawfully decrease its capital
stockholders or members and upon a vote. "Mere written stock if such decrease will have the effect of relieving
assent" would not be sufficient. However, the formal existing subscribers from the obligation of paying for
requirements in the second paragraph of Section 16 their unpaid subscriptions without a valuable
must be complied with. consideration for such release, as such an act of the
corporation constitutes an attempted withdrawal of so
The provision on the taking effect of the amendment much capital upon which corporate creditors are entitled
in the third paragraph of Section 16 upon its approval by to rely. The corporation must submit proof to the SEC
the Securities and Exchange Commission is not that such decrease will not prejudice the rights of
applicable because the date of approval by the creditors.
Commission may be before the effectivity date of the
extension or reduction of the corporate term. The (2) A corporation cannot issue stock in excess of the
effectivity of the amendment relates back to the date of amount limited by its articles of incorporation; such issue
its filing with the Commission in case the latter fails to is ultra vires and the stock so issued is void even in the
act within six (6) months from such date for a cause not hands of a bona fide purchaser for value; and
attributable to the corporation.
(3) A reduction or increase of the capital stock can take
A voluntary dissolution of a corporation may be place only in the manner and under the conditions
effected by amending the articles of incorporation to prescribed by law.
shorten the corporate term. (Sec. 120.)

Section 38. Power to increase or decrease capital


stock; incur, create or increase
bonded indebtedness.

You might also like