Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IN THE
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
Alexandria Division
_____________________________________
)
JOHN BOAL PHOTOGRAPHY, LLC )
)
v. ) Case No. 1:16cv654 CMH/TCB
)
HANNOVER HOUSE, INC. )
_____________________________________)
Defendant Hannover House, Inc. hereby Answers the First Amended Complaint, asserts
its Affirmative Defenses, and states its Claim for Attorneys Fees.
PARTIES
allegations of paragraph 1, and on that basis denies each and every allegation of paragraph 1.
allegations of paragraph 2, and on that basis denies each and every allegation of paragraph 2.
allegations of paragraph 3, and on that basis denies each and every allegation of paragraph 3.
allegations of paragraph 4, and on that basis denies each and every allegation of paragraph 4.
Case 1:16-cv-00654-CMH-TCB Document 37 Filed 02/24/17 Page 2 of 7 PageID# 256
5. Defendant admits the allegations in the first sentence of Paragraph 5, denies the
allegation in the second sentence, denies the allegations in the third sentence up to the comma,
6. The allegations in this paragraph are legal conclusions that do not require an
answer.
8. Defendant admits that this Court has personal jurisdiction over Hannover House,
Inc. by virtue of Hannover House appearing in this matter and not contesting personal
jurisdiction.
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
10. Defendant admits Exhibit 1 and admits the allegations in the first sentence of this
paragraph. Defendant admits that the parties reached an agreement, but denies the allegation
regarding the terms of the agreement, and denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 10.
12. Defendant admits the allegations of paragraph 12, except that Defendant denies
the allegations after the second comma in the first sentence. Defendant admits that it published
______________________________________________
13. Defendant admits Exhibit 4, but denies the remain allegations of paragraph 13.
14. Defendant admits Exhibit 5 and admits that payment had not been made as of the
time of the email exchange. Defendant denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 14.
15. Defendant admits Exhibit 6, but denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 15.
16. Defendant is without information to either admit or deny the allegations of this
17. Defendant admits Exhibit 7, but denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 17.
18. Defendant admits Exhibit 8, but denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 18.
20. Defendant admits Exhibit 10, but denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 20.
21. Paragraph 21 recites procedural events in this litigation; the allegations are not
factual allegations relating to the claims, and therefore no response to the paragraph is required.
22. Paragraph 22 recites procedural events in this litigation; the allegations are not
factual allegations relating to the claims, and therefore no response to the paragraph is required.
23. Paragraph 23 recites procedural events in this litigation; the allegations are not
factual allegations relating to the claims, and therefore no response to the paragraph is required.
24. Paragraph 24 recites procedural events in this litigation; the allegations are not
factual allegations relating to the claims, and therefore no response to the paragraph is required.
25. Paragraph 25 recites procedural events in this litigation; the allegations are not
factual allegations relating to the claims, and therefore no response to the paragraph is required
______________________________________________
26. Defendant admits that it delivered a check drawn on the Escrow Account of the
law firm representing Defendant, and that amount of the check equaled the amount of Plaintiffs
Count 1 claim plus 6% interest. Defendant denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 26.
COUNT 1
28. Defendant herby incorporates its responses set forth in paragraphs 1 through 27,
29. Defendant admits the allegations in the first sentence of paragraph 29, and admits
the allegations in parts (1) and (2) of the second sentence of paragraph 29. Defendant denies the
30. Defendant admits the allegations of paragraph 30 up the second comma of the first
sentence, and denies the remaining allegations of the first sentence. Defendant admits the
32. Defendant admits the allegations of paragraph 32, but denies the allegations
33. Defendant admits Exhibit 6, but denies the remaining allegations of paragraph 33.
34. Defendant admits that it did not make payment of the $1000 due Plaintiff until
______________________________________________
35. Defendant admits Plaintiff would be entitled to damages of one thousand dollars.
Defendant has paid Plaintiff this sum plus interest. Except as admitted, Defendant denies the
COUNT I.A
36. Defendant herby incorporates its responses set forth in paragraphs 1 through 35,
COUNT II
43. Defendant herby incorporates its responses set forth in paragraphs 1 through 42,
44. Defendant denies each and every allegation of paragraph 44 and specifically denies
that Plaintiff owns or is entitled to a copyright of the photographs, and alleges that Plaintiff has
______________________________________________
AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES
2. The photographs in question are works-for-hire, and the copyrights associated with
3. Plaintiff is not the holder of the copyrights, and therefore cannot bring suit for
Copyright Infringement.
agreement, and therefore the claimed assignment is insufficient to support Plaintiffs claims.
5. Defendant has from Plaintiff a license, either express or implied, to use the
Defendant is entitled to its reasonable attorneys fees pursuant to 17 U.S.C. 505 incurred
Respectfully submitted,
______________________________________________
I hereby certify that on February 24, 2017, I served the foregoing Answer and Affirmative
______________________________________________