You are on page 1of 9

ISA 720 Auditors Responsibilities 11.

objectives of the auditor are:


Relating to Other Information
Consider if there is a material
SCOPE inconsistency between other
information and the financial
1 It deals with the auditors responsibilities
statements or auditors knowledge
relating to other information included in
obtained in the audit
annual report.
Respond appropriately when
2. Written in the context of an audit of identify material inconsistencies.
financial statements by an independent Report in accordance with ISA
auditor
DEFINITION
3. requiring auditor to read and consider
12. (A) Annual report - A document, or
the other information because any
combination of documents, prepared
inconsistency with the FS or auditors
typically on an annual basis by
knowledge can indicate a material
management. annual report contains or
misstatement of the FS with undermine
accompanies the financial statements and
the credibility of the FS and auditors
the auditors report.
report
(B) Misstatement of other information -
4. Assist the auditor in complying with
exists when the other information is
relevant ethical requirements.
incorrectly stated or otherwise misleading.
5. Other information may include amounts
(C) Other information - Financial or non-
or other items intended to be the same as
financial information included in an
the amount in the FS.
entitys annual report.
6. auditors responsibilities relating to
REQUIREMENTS
other information apply regardless of
whether the other information is obtained Obtaining the Other Information
by the auditor prior to, or after, the date of
the auditors report. 13. Auditor Shall:

7. The rule does not apply to preliminary Determine which document is the
announcements of financial information annual report and entitys planned
and Securities offering documents manner and timing of the issuance
Make arrangements with the
8. Do not constitute an assurance management to have a timely
engagement on other information or manner and the final version of the
impose an obligation on the auditor to documents comprising annual
obtain assurance about the other report.
information. If some or all the documents will
9. Law or regulation may impose not be available after the date of
additional obligations on the auditor auditors report - request
management to have a written
representation of the final version
of the document to present when
EFFECTIVE DATE
auditor is available
10. Law or regulation may impose
Reading and Considering the Other
additional obligations on the auditor.
Information

14. auditor shall read other information


OBJECTIVES and, in doing so shall:
Consider the material Consider implications for auditors
inconsistency between other report and communicate how the
information and in the financial auditor plans to address material
statement. Compare selected misstatement
amounts or other items in the other Withdrawing from the engagement
information
Consider material inconsistency 19. If auditor fins that material
between other information and the misstatement exists in other information
auditors knowledge, through audit obtained after date of auditor;s report,
evidence and conclusions reached auditor shall:
in the audit If corrected - perform procedures
15. auditor shall remain alert for necessary
indications that other information not If not corrected take appropriate
related to financial statements or auditors actions considering auditors legal
knowledge can be materially misstated rights and obligations

Responding When a Material Inconsistency Responding When a Material Misstatement


Appears to Exist or Other Information in the Financial Statements Exists or the
Appears to be Materially Misstated Auditors Understanding of the Entity and
Its Environment Needs to be Updated
16. If auditor identifies material
inconsistency, perform other procedures 20. if auditor concludes material
to conclude whether: misstatement, auditor shall respond
appropriately in accordance with the other
Material misstatement of other ISAs
information and financial
statements exists
Auditors understanding of the Reporting
entity and its environment needs to
be updated 21. auditors report shall include a
separate section namely Other
Responding When the Auditor Concludes Information or other appropriate heading
That a Materially Misstatement of the when at the date of auditors report:
Other Information Exists
Auditors has obtained or expect to
17. Auditor shall request management to
obtained the other information
correct other information if proven that Auditor has obtained some or all of
there is a material misstatement. If
other information
management:
22. the Other Information section shall
Agree to make correction auditor include:
shall determent the correction has
been made Statement that management is
Refuses to make correction responsible for the other
auditor shall communicate with information
governance to request that the Identification of:
correction be made. o Other information obtained
by the auditor
18. If the information has not been o Other information expected
corrected after communicating, auditor
to be obtained
shall take actions including:
Statement that auditors opinion
does not cover the other
information
Description of auditors A3. Annual report may be single
responsibilities to reading, document. One or more of the following
considering and reporting on other documents may form part of the annual
information report
Other information obtained prior to
Management report, management
the date of auditors report stated
commentary, or operating and
that auditor has nothing to report
financial review or similar reports
or concluded that there is an
Chairmans statement
uncorrected material misstatement
Corporate governance statement
23. Auditor expresses a qualified or Internal control and risk
adverse opinion, auditor shall consider the assessment reports
implication of opinion
A4. Annual reports may be in printed form
or electronically.
Reporting prescribed by Law or Regulation A5. Annual report can present differently
to meet the information needs of a
24. If audit is required by law to use a
specific stakeholder group or to comply
specific layout or wording for other
with a specific regulatory objective.
information, auditors report shall refer to
Example of reports:
ISA only if it includes:
Separate industry or regulatory
Identification of other information
reports
Description of auditors
Corporate social responsibility
responsibilities
reports
Explicit statement addressing the
Sustainability reports
outcome of auditors work
Diversity and equal opportunity
Documentation reports
Product responsibility reports
25. auditor shall include in the audit Labor practices and working
documentation: conditions reports
Documentation of the procedures Human rights reports
performed
Final version of the other
information in which auditor Misstatement of the Other Information
performed
A6. If a particular matter is disclosed in
Application and Other Explanatory the other information, other information
Material may omit or obscure information that is
necessary for a proper understanding of
Definitions that matter.
Annual Report A7. Concept of materiality may be
discussed in a framework applicable to the
A1. The content can be define by law,
other information. There may be cases
regulation or custom, however, content
where no applicable framework that
may vary within jurisdiction and from one
includes a discussion of the concept of
jurisdiction to another.
materiality, the following characteristics
A2. Typically prepared on annual basis. can determine if misstatement of the
When FS being audited, it covers less than other information is material:
or more than 1 year, annual report may
also be the same.
Considering the common Change in management or those
information needs of users as a charged with governance
group Other information is expected to be
Considering whether users would obtained after the date of the
be influenced by the effect of the auditors report
uncorrected misstatement
Judgments about materiality A15. Instances where the other
information are needed to be approve
involve both qualitative and
prior to issuance, the final version of other
quantitative considerations
information are the one that has been
Other Information approved.

A8. Appendix 1 contains examples of A16. In some cases, annual report may be
amounts or other items that may be single document to be released. In other
included in the other information cases, such documents may not be
required to be released until a later time.
A9. In some cases, applicable financial
reporting framework requires specific A17. If the auditor is unable to ascertain
disclosures but can be located outside of the purpose or timing of such document,
the FS the document is not considered other
information for purposes of this ISA.
A10. XBRL tags do not represent other
information A18. Obtaining the other information in a
timely manner enables any revisions that
Obtaining the Other Information are found to be necessary to be made to
A11. In some cases, documents the financial statements, the auditors
comprising the annual reports are not report, or the other information prior to
clear. In such cases, the timing and their issuance.
purpose of the documents are needed to A19. Other information obtained not on
determine which documents are needed the entitys website but on the entity itself
for annual reports. is the relevant document which the
A12. When annual reports are presented auditor would perform procedures
in different language or when there have A20. Auditor is not precluded to date or
multiple annual reports due to different issue the auditors report if the auditor has
legislation, consideration may be given as not yet obtained some of all of the other
to whether one or more than one of the information.
annual reports for part of the other
information. A21. When other information is dated after
the date of auditors report, he is not
A13. Auditor may communicate with required to update the procedures
management:
A22. ISA 580 establishes requirements and
Auditors expectation in obtaining provides guidance on the use of written
the final version of the annual representations. Auditor may find it useful
report in a timely manner. to request other written representations,
Possible implications when the for example, that:
other information is obtained after
the date of the auditors report All the documents that it expects to
issue that may comprise other
A14. Communication referring to a13 is information;
appropriate for example: The financial statements are
consistent with one another, and
Initial audit engagement
the other information does not
contain any material intended to be the same as in the financial
misstatements; statements.
Management intends to prepare
A27. Amounts or other items to compare
and issue such other information
depends on the following factors:
and the expected timing of such
issuance. Significance of the amount or other
Reading and Considering the Other item
Information If quantitative, relative size of the
amount compared with accounts or
A23. The auditor is required to plan and items in FS
perform the audit with professional Sensitivity of the particular amount
skepticism by considering the other or other item.
information includes and being alert to
information that may be inconsistent with A28. Procedures applicable to address the
FS or auditors knowledge. requirement on par 14a

A24. The engagement partner is required For Information intended to be the


to take responsibility for the direction, same as the FS, comparing the
supervision and performance of the audit information to the FS
engagement. Factors that may be taken For information intended to convey
into account when determining the same meaning as disclosure in FS,
appropriate engagement team members compare words used and
to address the requirements of paragraphs significance of differences in
1415, include: wording used and find out of it
imply different meaning
The relative experience of Obtain reconciliation between an
engagement team members. amount within the other
Whether the engagement team information and the financial
members to be assigned the tasks statements.
have the relevant knowledge to
identify inconsistencies between A29. Evaluation of consistency of selected
the other information and that amounts or other information with the
knowledge. financial statement includes the manner of
Degree of judgement involved in their presentation compared to the FS
addressing the requirements of
paragraph 14-15
Inquiries of a component auditor in Considering Whether There Is a Material
addressing other information Inconsistency between the Other
Information and the Auditors Knowledge
Considering Whether There is a Material Obtained in the Audit
Inconsistency between the Other
Information and the Financial Statements A30. Amounts or items include in the
Other information
A25. May include amount or other items
that are intended to be the same as the A disclosure of the units produced,
amounts in the FS. May include tables, or a table summarizing such
chart or graphs, disclosure providing production by geographical region.
greater detail and descriptions of the A statement that The company
financial results such as total research introduced product X and product Y
and development was XXX in 20XX during the year.
A summary of the locations of the
A26. Auditor is not required to compare all
amounts in the other information that are entitys major operations, such as
the entitys major center of Remaining Alert for Other Indications that
operation is in country X, and there the Other Information Appears to Be
are also operations in countries Y Materially Misstated
and Z.
A37. Other information may include items
A31. ISA 315 (Revised) sets out the not related to FS or beyond auditors
auditors required understanding, which knowledge like statement of greenhouse
includes such matters as obtaining an gas emissions
understanding of:
A38. alert for other indications that other
The relevant industry, regulatory, information that may not be related to FS
and other external factors; or beyond auditors knowledge can be
The nature of the entity; misstated or misleading. Auditor shall
The entitys selection and identify matters such as
application of accounting policies;
Differences between the other
The entitys objectives and
information and the general
strategies;
knowledge that lead the auditor to
The measurement and review of
believe that the other information
the entitys financial performance;
appears to be materially misstated;
and
or
The entitys internal control.
An internal inconsistency in the
A32. The auditors knowledge obtained in
other information that leads the
the audit may also include matters that auditor to believe that the other
are prospective in nature like future cash information appears to be
flow. materially misstated.
A33. Auditor may focus in the other
Responding When a Material Inconsistency
information that that a misstatement of
Appears to Exist or Other Information
the other information could be material. Appears to Be Materially Misstated
A34. The auditors recollection of the audit
A39. In case of inconsistency, the auditor
evidence obtained and conclusions
may request management to support for
reached in the audit is sufficient to
the basis of managements statements in
consider whether there is a material the other information. Managements
inconsistency between the other explanation can be enough to prove that
information and the auditors knowledge other information is not materially
obtained in the audit. misstated.
A35. Referring to relevant audit
A40. Discussion with management may
documentation or making inquiries of provide information that supports the
relevant members of the engagement auditors conclusion that a material
team or relevant component auditors is misstatement of the other information
appropriate as a basis for the auditors exists.
consideration of whether a material
inconsistency exists. A41. there may be instances where other
information is not consistent with the
A36. It may not be necessary for the financial statements or the auditors
auditor to refer to relevant audit knowledge obtained in the audit.
documentation, or to make inquiries of
relevant members of the engagement A42. Auditor may perform to conclude
team or relevant component auditors whether a material misstatement of the
about any matter included in the other other information exists are matters of the
information.
auditors professional judgment in the reliability of representations obtained from
circumstances. them during the audit.

A43. When the auditor may not be able to Considerations specific to public sector
fully assess managements responses to entities
the auditors inquiries, the auditor may be
satisfied that a material inconsistency no A47. In the public sector, withdrawal from
longer appears to exist When the auditor the engagement may not be possible. May
is unable to tell if a material inconsistency issue a report to the legislature to take
no longer appears to exist, the auditor other appropriate actions.
may request management to consult with
a qualified third party. If the auditor may Responding When the Auditor Concludes
not be able to conclude whether or not a That a Material Misstatement Exists in
material misstatement of the other Other Information Obtained after the Date
information exists. Actions the auditor of the Auditors Report
may then take include one or more of the
following: A48. If there is a material misstatement in
other information obtained after the date
Obtaining advice from the auditors of the auditors report, and has been
legal counsel; corrected, the auditors procedures should
Considering the implications for the determine the correction has been made
auditors report and may include reviewing the steps taken
Withdrawing from the audit by management.

Responding When the Auditor Concludes A49. If those charged do not agree to
That a Material Misstatement of the Other revise the other information, the auditor
Information Exists may consider it appropriate to seek legal
advice about the auditors legal rights and
Responding When the Auditor Concludes obligations.
That a Material Misstatement Exists in
Other Information Obtained prior to the A50. When a material misstatement of the
Date of the Auditors Report other information remains uncorrected,
appropriate actions that the auditors may
A44. The auditor may analyze the take, for example:
explanation given by management for not
making the correction if it gives doubt on Provide a new or amended
the integrity management like when auditors report to management
intentionally wants to mislead the auditor. and request that this new or
The auditor may also consider it amended auditors report to users.
appropriate to seek legal advice. Bringing the material misstatement
to the attention of the users
Reporting Implications Communicating with a regulator
about the uncorrected material
A45. A disclaimer of opinion on the misstatement;
financial statements may be appropriate Considering the implications for
when the refusal to correct the material engagement continuance.
misstatement of the other information
Responding When a Material
Withdrawal from the Engagement Misstatement in the Financial
Statements Exists or the Auditors
A46. Withdrawal may be appropriate when Understanding of the Entity and Its
it includes the refusal to correct the Environment Needs to Be Updated
material misstatement of the other
information cast to call into question the A51. The auditor may become aware of
new information that has implications for:
need to modify the statement to refer to
Entity and its environment and the auditors inability to consider
may indicate the need to revise the managements description of the matter in
auditors risk assessment. the other information. The auditor is
Evaluating the effect of identified required to report any other uncorrected
misstatements on the audit and of material misstatements of the other
uncorrected misstatements, if any, information that have been identified.
on the financial statements.
Auditors responsibilities relating to Adverse Opinion
subsequent events.
A57. An adverse opinion on the financial
Reporting statements does not justify the omission
of reporting of material misstatements of
A52. Identification in the auditors report the other information that the auditor has
of other information that the auditor identified in the auditors report. When an
expects to obtain would be appropriate in adverse opinion has been expressed, the
order to provide additional transparency. auditor need to appropriately modify the
statement.
Illustrative Statements
Disclaimer of Opinion
A53. Illustrative examples of the Other
A58. When the auditor disclaims an
Information section of the auditor's report
opinion on the financial statements,
are included in Appendix 2.
providing further details about the audit,
including a section to address other
Reporting Implications When the Auditors
information may overshadow the
Opinion on the Financial Statements Is
disclaimer of opinion on the financial
Qualified or Adverse
statements as a whole.
A54. A qualified or adverse auditors
Reporting Prescribed by Law or Regulation
opinion on the financial statements may
not have an impact on the statement if
A59. Auditor may be required to comply
the matter has been modified is not
with legal or regulatory requirements.
included or otherwise addressed in the
Auditor may be obliged to use a specific
other information and the matter does not
layout or wording in the auditors report.
affect any part of the other information.
Consistency in the auditors report,
promotes credibility by making more
Qualified Opinion Due to a Material
readily identifiable those audits that have
Misstatement in the Financial Statements
been conducted in accordance with
globally recognized standards. The
A55. When the auditors opinion is
auditors report may refer to International
qualified, consideration may be given if
Standards on Auditing.
the other information is also materially
misstated giving rise to the qualified
opinion on the financial statements.

Qualified Opinion Due to Limitation of


Scope

A56. When there is a limitation of scope to


the material item in the financial
statements, auditor will not have obtained
sufficient appropriate audit evidence
about that matter. Auditor may be unable
to conclude any material misstatement of
the other information. The auditor may
APPENDIX 1

Examples of Amounts or Other Items that May Be Included in the Other


Information

Amounts
Items in a summary of key financial results, such as net income, earnings per share,
dividends, sales and other operating revenues, and purchases and operating
expenses.
Selected operating data, such as income from continuing operations by major
operating area, or sales by geographical segment or product line.
Special items, such as asset dispositions, litigation provisions, asset impairments, tax
adjustments, environmental remediation provisions, and restructuring and
reorganization expenses.
Liquidity and capital resource information, such as cash, cash equivalents and
marketable securities; dividends; and debt, capital lease and minority interest
obligations.
Capital expenditures by segment or division.
Amounts involved in, and related financial effects of, off-balance sheet arrangements.
Amounts involved in guarantees, contractual obligations, legal or environmental
claims, and other contingencies.
Financial measures or ratios, such as gross margin, return on average capital
employed, return on average shareholders equity, current ratio, interest coverage
ratio and debt ratio. Some of these may be directly reconcilable to the financial
statements.

Other Items
Explanations of critical accounting estimates and related assumptions.
Identification of related parties and descriptions of transactions with them.
Articulation of the entitys policies or approach to manage commodity, foreign
exchange or interest rate risks, such as through the use of forward contracts, interest
rate swaps, or other financial instruments.
Descriptions of the nature of off-balance sheet arrangements.
Descriptions of guarantees, indemnifications, contractual obligations, litigation or
environmental liability cases, and other contingencies, including managements
qualitative assessments of the entitys related exposures.
Descriptions of changes in legal or regulatory requirements, such as new tax or
environmental regulations, that have materially impacted the entitys operations or
fiscal position, or will have a material impact on the entitys future financial
prospects.
Managements qualitative assessments of the impacts of new financial reporting
standards that have come into effect during the period, or will come into effect in the
following period, on the entitys financial results, financial position and cash flows.
General descriptions of the business environment and outlook.
Overview of strategy.
Descriptions of trends in market prices of key commodities or raw materials.
Contrasts of supply, demand and regulatory circumstances between geographic
regions.
Explanations of specific factors influencing the entitys profitability in specific
segments.

You might also like