You are on page 1of 38

9910 85-121

**

[]

99 8 10 99 9 27
*




**

85
9910

200664

200472

1






200474




86

199926-27

20007-8


NCC


2006167

R. Hague & M.
Harrop, 2004: 268

87
9910

200734

1995129-141

20026432002280-282
Hans Peters
200521-
43

2007

2


2004




2004629

88

44

2005
57

89
9910

200596

2004374

200026

200697

90

2004198


M. Duverger

2007126-127136-137
3

2004218

2006166

91
9910

200557
2004
197

1999262

92

2
4567
8

4


5


6

7


8

93
9910

2006132

2007
735
9


10

9









10



94

200652

11

2006

NCC

2006902006

200692








11
NCC NCC

13 7 2 1 3
4




NCC

95
9910

2006
110
20051002007166


11 15
11 13

NCC

2008a46

96

NCC
12


1/4

12

97
9910

2008160-161

13

14

13


14
NCC

98

15

2008249


2007
2006
15







99
9910

16

2007a156

2007
174

16




100

2008191-192

2008
192 17


NCC

18

19

17



2008a
2007
18




19
NCC

101
9910



NCC





102

20083-4

103
9910

20 21 22
23

20



21


22



23




104

NCC
24


25
26

NCC




24





25
2008


26
2010 8 10 http://news.epochtimes.
com.tw/6/7/3/31343.htm

105
9910

2007159171

--

2007b138

106

NCC

2008a280

2006139

107
9910

27

2007190

NCC

27

108

4
2008149

109
9910

28

NCC

200651

28

NCC
2008

110

200688

29

NCC
NCC

NCC

29




200019

111
9910

2009210-211

NCC

NCC

2008b9

30

31 32

30


31

112

200690

2008b2

2008151-152

2005


199940
32

113
9910




NCC

NCC
2009

114

33 34

33
2008b252

34







2008b

115
9910

200436

116

2005 288 83-


102
2007NCC 2010 8 10
http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2007/new/apr/10/
today-t1.htm
2006 80 129-
133
2008
2006 2010 8 10
http://www.cardu.com. tw/news/detail.htm?nt_pk=7&ns_pk=
644
2005
2004
108 20-36
2007
717-738

2007 NCC
96 176-192
2006
86 58-78
2007
151 156-168
2008
2000 66
18-19

117
9910

2007
1995
2006 137
5-24
2007 NCC
96 159171
2007a NCC
96 156
2007b 96
136-140
2006 86 137-
142
2008 9 1-23
2002
631-667
2008a 2010 8 10
http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2008/new/nov/14/today-o3.htm
2008b


2002
269-300
1999
2007 33 1
1-38
2008 2010 8 10
http://udn.com/NEWS/NATIONAL/NATS6/4492043.shtml
2004
2006

118

137 41-59
2004
2005
2008-

131-156

2005
2000
1-49
2006
200922 2010 8 10
http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2009/new/apr/10/ today-p4.htm
2007 148
121-138
2008a 3 1-
50
2008b 109
247-253
2009 97
12 124
205-211
2000-
12 1 1-45
2006
87 87-92
2007
2008 NCC 2010 8 10
http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2008/new/nov/23/today-

119
9910

life8.htm
2004
2004
244 71-80
1999
2 1-44
2008a
2008b 101
1-59
2007 2010 8 10
TVBShttp://www.tvbs.com.tw/news/news_list.asp?no=blue 2007071413
0708
2006
Hague, R. & M. Harrop (2004). Comparative Government and Politics: An Introduction.
Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

120

An Observation of the Separation of


Powers in Taiwans Independent
Administrative Authorities and the
Administrative Organizations Act
Lian-Wei Hsu *

Abstract

Independent administrative authorities in other countries have been in


existence for years, but in Taiwan this is something new. The independent
Regulatory Commissions role of insisting on professionalism in the
administrative power represents the expert role. Such an expert of all
experts or elitist mentality may throw the separation of powers off balance,
damage the unitary executive theory and politics of accountability, and
create a conflict between administrative supervision and independent
execution of administrative duties. This article discusses relevant issues from
the constitutional perspective of separation of powers and the
administrative organizations act.

Keywords: independent administrative authority, separation of powers,


unitary executive theory, J.Y. Interpretation No.613, spoils
system

*
National Sun Yat-Sen University Institute of China and Asia-Pacific Law Studies Ph.D.
Candidate, Tainan City Government Law officer.

121
9910

122

You might also like