Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Fig. 1.2.2 Frame Model in the X and Y direction [mm]
2
1.5 Input of Gravity Load
The input of gravity of load is combination of 1 D + 1 L, where D is dead load and L is life load. It can
be showed by table 1.5.1
The gravity load is calculated by multiplying section area of the node with distributed of load, where the
section area of node divided into eight type, it can be indicated byfigure 1.5.1.
3
The weight of the node of the first level until the sixth level subjected to the gravity loads can be seen in
the table 1.5.2, The weight of the node of the seventh level until the eleventh level subjected to the
gravity loads can be seen in the table 1.5.3, The weight of the node of twelfth level subjected to the
gravity loads can be seen in the table 1.5.4
Table 1.5.2 The Weight of Node of 1stLevel Until 6th Level Subjected to The Gravity Loads (1D+1L)
Pattern 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Section Area [m2] 4.32 8.64 9.27 9.45 8.64 17.28 18.54 18.90
Distributed Load
8.55 8.55 8.55 8.55 8.55 8.55 8.55 8.55
[kN/m2]
Concentrated
36.94 73.88 79.27 80.80 73.88 147.76 158.53 161.61
Load [kN]
Table 1.5.3 The Weight of Node of 7th Level Until 11th Level Subjected to The Gravity Loads (1D+1L)
Pattern 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Section Area [m2] 4.32 8.64 9.27 9.45 8.64 17.28 18.54 18.90
Distributed Load
8.52 8.52 8.52 8.52 8.52 8.52 8.52 8.52
[kN/m2]
Concentrated
36.81 73.62 78.99 80.52 73.62 147.23 157.97 161.04
Load [kN]
Table 1.5.4 The Weight of Node of 12thLevel Subjected to The Gravity Loads (1D+1L)
Pattern 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Section Area [m2] 4.32 8.64 9.27 9.45 8.64 17.28 18.54 18.90
Distributed Load
5.65 5.65 5.65 5.65 5.65 5.65 5.65 5.65
[kN/m2]
Concentrated
24.39 48.78 52.34 53.36 48.78 97.57 104.68 106.71
Load [kN]
The weight of the node for the first level until the sixth level of seismic weight can be seen in the table
1.6.2, The weight of the node for the seventh level until the eleventh level of seismic weight can be seen
in the table 1.6.3, The weight of the node for twelfth level of seismic weight can be seen in the table 1.6.4
4
Table 1.6.2 The Weight of Node of Base Floor of Input of Seismic Weight (1D+0.25L)
Pattern 1 2 3 4 5 6
Section Area
12.96 25.92 27.36 25.92 51.84 54.72
[m2]
Distributed Load
6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65
[kN/m2]
Concentrated
86.184 172.368 181.944 172.368 344.736 363.888
Load [kN]
Table 1.6.3 The Weight of Node of 1st Level Until 6th Level of Input of Seismic Weight (1D+0.25L)
Pattern 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Section Area [m2] 4.32 8.64 9.27 9.45 8.64 17.28 18.54 18.90
Distributed Load
6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65 6.65
[kN/m2]
Concentrated
28.74 57.48 61.67 62.87 57.48 114.97 123.35 125.74
Load [kN]
5
Table 1.6.4 The Weight of Node of 7th Level Until 11th Level of Input Of Seismic Weight (1D+0.25L)
Pattern 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Section Area [m2] 4.32 8.64 9.27 9.45 8.64 17.28 18.54 18.90
Distributed Load
6.62 6.62 6.62 6.62 6.62 6.62 6.62 6.62
[kN/m2]
Concentrated
28.61 57.22 61.39 62.59 57.22 114.44 122.79 125.17
Load [kN]
Table 1.6.5 The Weight of Node of 12st of Input of seismic Weight (1D+0.25L)
Pattern 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
2
Section Area [m ] 4.32 8.64 9.27 9.45 8.64 17.28 18.54 18.90
Distributed Load
4.88 4.88 4.88 4.88 4.88 4.88 4.88 4.88
[kN/m2]
Concentrated
21.06 42.11 45.18 46.06 42.11 84.22 90.36 92.12
Load [kN]
6
Geq=0.62 ( 2.8553.878 2.7+ 2.903 2.721.016 2.7 3+ 0.1364 2.7 4 ) =0.495 N /mm2
A
Keq=Geq (2.0)
H
748900 N kN
Keq=0.495 =1566 =15.66
248 mm cm
K 2=Keq ( 1U ) ( 4.0)
kN
K 2=15.66 ( 10.322 ) =10.6167
cm
K 1=10 K 2(5.0)
kN
K 1=10 10.6167=106.167
cm
7
Qd=0.322 15.66 24.8 2.7=337.876 kN
10
Qy= Qd(7.0)
9
10
Qy= 337.876 kN =375.417 kN
9
Qd
dy=
9K 2
337.876
dy= =3.533 cm
9 10.6167
Based on the result of calculation of properties base isolator, billinear hysteresis of base isolator
illustrated by figure 1.7.1
1200
QMax
1000
800
K2
600
Force [kN]
K equivalent
Qy 400
K1
200
0
DY DM
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Displacement [cm]
8
Figure 1.7.1 hysteresis of base isolation system
According to the figure 1.7.1, the input of 36 base isolation system to DYNAT program can be showed by
table 1.7.1.
9
1600.00
1400.00
1200.00
1000.00(SMS Condition)
Padang Spectrum El Centro NS El Centro EW
SA [cm/sec2] 800.00
600.00
400.00
0.00
0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00
The time series response acceleration of simulated earthquake ground motion of El Centro EW indicated
by figure 1.8.2, time series response acceleration of simulated earthquake ground motion of El Centro NS
indicated by figure 1.8.3, The time series response acceleration of simulated earthquake ground motion of
Kobe NS indicated by figure 1.8.4, The time series response acceleration of simulated earthquake ground
motion of Kobe EW indicated by figure 1.8.5.
10
Fig. 1.8.2 Time Series Response Acceleration of Simulated Ground Motion Elcentro-EW
According to figure 1.8.2 the maximum of acceleration for padang city of simulated earthquake ground
motion El Centro EW is 545.74 cm/sec2.
Fig. 1.8.3 Time Series Response Acceleration of Simulated Ground Motion Elcentro-NS
According to figure 1.8.3 the maximum of acceleration for padang city of simulated earthquake ground
motion Elcentro EW is 553.44 cm/sec2.
Fig. 1.8.4 Time Series Response Acceleration of Simulated Ground Motion Kobe-NS
According to figure 1.8.4 the maximum of acceleration for padang city of simulated earthquake ground
motion Kobe NS is 665.06 cm/sec2.
Fig. 1.8.5 Time Series Response Acceleration of Simulated Ground Motion Kobe-EW
11
According to figure 1.8.5 the maximum of acceleration for padang city of simulated earthquake ground
motion Kobe EW is 729.86 cm/sec2.
2 h1 1 222 h1 2 12 2h 2 h2 2
a0 = 2 2
,a 1= 1 12 (2.0)
2 1 1 22
The value of
h1, 1 , h2, 2 of ordinary building is represented by table 1.8.1 and the value of
1
h1, 2 [%]
2
h2, 2 [%]
3
1 4.06 [rad/sec]
4
2 11.21 [rad/sec] Value of damping take 2 % for ordinary
building because the type of structure is steel
structure that has damping value equal 2 %.
1
h1, 2 [%]
2
h2, 2 [%]
3
1 3.43 [rad/sec]
4
2 9.56 [rad/sec]
12
Value of damping take 2 % for base isolator building because the dynamic calculation of structure use
billinear hysteresis till equivalent damping of base isolator is not necessary to consider.
The acceleration response spectrum for 2%, 5% and 19.42% damping of El Centro Ew, El Centro NS,
Kobe EW and Kobe NS can be seen by figure 1.9.1 until 1.9.4.
3000.00
2000.00
SA [cm/sec2] 1000.00
El Centro-EW [h=2%] El Centro-EW [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.1 Spectrum of Acceleration of El-Centro EW with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
13
3000.00
2000.00
SA [cm/sec2] 1000.00
El Centro-NS [h=2%] El Centro-NS [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.2 Spectrum of Acceleration of El-Centro NS with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
3000.00
2000.00
SA [cm/sec2] 1000.00
Kobe-NS [h=2%] Kobe-NS [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.3 Spectrum of Acceleration of Kobe NS with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
3000.00
2000.00
SA [cm/sec2] 1000.00
Kobe-EW [h=2%] Kobe-EW [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
14
Fig. 1.9.4 Spectrum of Acceleration of Kobe EW with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
Illustrated in Figure 1.9.1 until 1.9.4 the spectrum acceleration of structure with 2% damping is bigger
than 5% damping and also the spectrum acceleration of structure with 5% damping is bigger than
19.42%.
The velocity of response spectrum for 2%, 5% and 19.42% damping of El Centro-Ew, El Centro-NS,
Kobe EW and Kobe NS can be seen by figure 1.9.5 until 1.9.8.
600.00
400.00
SV [cm/sec] 200.00
El Centro-EW [h=2%] El Centro-EW [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.5 Spectrum of Velocity of El-Centro EW with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
600.00
400.00
SV [cm/sec] 200.00
El Centro-NS [h=2%] El Centro-NS [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
15
Fig. 1.9.6 Spectrum of Velocity of El-Centro NS with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
400.00
SV [cm/sec] 200.00
Kobe-NS [h=2%] Kobe-NS [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.7 Spectrum of Velocity of Kobe NS with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
400.00
SV [cm/sec] 200.00
Kobe-EW [h=2%] Kobe-EW [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.8 Spectrum of Velocity of Kobe EW with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
Illustrated in Figure 1.9.5 until 1.9.8 the spectrum velocity of structure with 2% damping is bigger than
5% damping and also the spectrum velocity of structure with 5% damping is bigger than 19.42%.
The displacement response spectrum respsonse spectrum for 2%, 5% and 19.42% damping of El Centro
Ew, El Centro NS, Kobe EW and Kobe NS can be seen by figure 1.9.9 until 1.9.12.
16
300.00
200.00
SD [cm] 100.00
El Centro-EW [h=2%] El Centro-EW [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.9 Spectrum of Displacement of El-Centro EW with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
200.00
SD [cm] 100.00
El Centro-NS [h=2%] El Centro-NS [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.10 Spectrum of Displacement of El-Centro NS with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
300.00
200.00
SD [cm] 100.00
Kobe-NS [h=2%] Kobe-NS [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
17
Fig. 1.9.11 Spectrum of Displacement of Kobe NS with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
300.00
200.00
SD [cm] 100.00
Kobe-EW [h=2%] Kobe-EW [h=5%]
0.00
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50
Time Period [sec]
Fig. 1.9.12 Spectrum of Displacement of Kobe EW with 2%, 5% and 19.42% Damping
Illustrated in Figure 1.9.9 until 1.9.12 the spectrum displacement of structure with 2% damping is bigger
than 5% damping and also the spectrum displacement of structure with 5% damping is bigger than
19.42%.
18
8 4.48 0.22 0.04 0.00 -1.66 0.00 0.00 0.03 0.00
9 5.23 0.19 0.04 0.00 0.00 7.78 0.00 0.00 0.58
10 5.62 0.18 0.05 0.00 -0.04 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Total 0.95 0.95 0.58
The summation of equivalent mass ratio in the X direction of table 1.10.1 eigen analysis is 0.95 and the
summation of equivalent mass ratio in the X direction of table 1.10.2 eigen analysis is 1.00 according to
Indonesian code SNI 1726-2014 clause 7.9.1 the minimum summation equivalent mass ratio is 0.90, its
mean the result calculation of dynamic eigen value analysis is ok. Based on the participation factor in the
x direction of table 1.10.1 and 1.10.2, the main of mode shape are mode number [1], [3], [5] and [7].
19
12.00
10.00
8.00
6.00
MODE 1ST MODE 3rd MODE 5th
4.00
2.00
0.00
-0.20 -0.15 -0.10 -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20
The figure 1.11.2 represent main of mode shape of base isolator building.
20
12.00
10.00
8.00
6.00
MODE 1ST MODE 3rd MODE 5th
4.00
2.00
0.00
-1.00 -0.50 0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50
Illustrated on figure 1.11.1 and 1.11.2 the dominant mode shape is the 1st mode shape, it show
displacement building when subjected to the seismic load
1.12. Maximum Response Displacement of Ordinary Building and Base Isolator Building
21
12
10
8
6
Story
NON LINEAR ORDINARY BUILDING BASE ISOLATOR BUIILDING
4
2
0
Illustrated on figure 1.12.1 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
The figure 1.12.2 represent maximum response displacement of ordinary building linear, nonlinear
condition and base isolator building of El Centro NS ground motion in the X direction
22
12
10
8
Story
6
NON LINEAR ORDINARY BUILDING
4
2
0 BASE ISOLATOR BUIILDING
Illustrated on figure 1.12.2 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
The figure 1.12.3 represent maximum response displacement of ordinary building linear, nonlinear
condition and base isolator building of Kobe EW ground motion in the X direction
23
12
10
8
Story
6
NON LINEAR ORDINARY BUILDING
4
2
0 BASE ISOLATOR BUIILDING
Illustrated on figure 1.12.3 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
24
12
10
8
6
Story
NON LINEAR ORDINARY BUILDING BASE ISOLATOR BUIILDING
4
2
0
Illustrated on figure 1.12.4 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
The value of nonlinear analysis ordinary building and base isolator building of all figure 1.12.1 until
1.12.4 showed by table 1.12.1.
Table 1.12.1 Maximum Response Displacement Nonlinear Ordinary And Base Isolator Building
El Centro NS [cm] El Centro EW [cm] Kobe NS [cm] Kobe EW [cm]
Level Ordinar Base Ordinar Base Base Base
Ordinary Ordinary
y Isolator y Isolator Isolator Isolator
0 0.00 51.20 0.00 64.96 0.00 63.47 0.00 38.09
1 3.32 52.95 3.48 67.24 3.79 65.84 3.24 39.58
25
2 9.97 56.01 11.41 71.30 12.05 70.14 10.00 42.13
3 17.83 59.21 22.44 75.62 22.78 74.61 17.99 44.92
4 25.70 62.27 35.32 79.90 34.97 78.64 26.13 48.03
5 31.75 64.64 47.07 83.44 46.80 81.63 32.89 50.87
6 36.12 66.50 56.06 86.48 56.45 84.08 38.02 53.45
7 39.71 68.18 63.00 89.51 63.96 86.25 42.31 56.10
8 43.00 69.70 68.75 92.56 69.68 88.17 46.17 58.75
9 45.88 70.93 73.37 95.27 73.64 89.77 49.27 60.99
10 48.75 72.10 77.29 97.97 76.69 91.21 51.68 63.14
11 51.47 73.13 80.21 100.20 78.97 92.31 53.30 64.92
According to the table 1.12.1 the value of response displacement of nonlinear ordinary building is bigger
than response displacement base isolator building. The biggest of displacement of ordinary building is El
Centro EW and The biggest of displacement of base isolator building is El Centro EW
1.13. Maximum Response Acceleration of Ordinary Building and Base Isolator Building
The figure 1.13.1 represent maximum response acceleration of nonlinear ordinary and base isolator
building of El Centro EW ground motion in the X direction
12
10
8
Story
6
4
2
26
Fig. 1.13.1 Distribution Maximum Response Acceleration Of Ordinary Building
And Base Isolator Building Of El Centro EW
Illustrated on figure 1.12.1 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
The figure 1.12.2 represent maximum response displacement of ordinary building linear, nonlinear
condition and base isolator building of El Centro NS ground motion in the X direction
12
10
8
Story
6
Illustrated on figure 1.12.2 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
The figure 1.12.3 represent maximum response displacement of ordinary building linear, nonlinear
condition and base isolator building of Kobe EW ground motion in the X direction
27
12
10
8
ACC OF NON LINEAR OF ORDINARY BUILDING
Story
6
4
2
Illustrated on figure 1.12.3 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
The figure 1.12.4 represent maximum response displacement of ordinary building linear, nonlinear
condition and base isolator building of Kobe NS ground motion in the X direction
28
12
11
10
9
8
ACC OF NON LINEAR OF ORDINARY BUILDING
7
6
Story
5
4
3
2
BASE ISOLATOR BUILDING
1
0
300.00 600.00 900.00 1200.00
ABS. Acceleration [cm/sec2]
Illustrated on figure 1.12.4 the biggest of displacement is linear analysis ordinary building, and the
smallest of displacement is base isolator building.
The value of nonlinear analysis ordinary building and base isolator building of all figure 1.12.1 until
1.12.4 showed by table 1.12.1.
Table 1.13.1 Maximum Response Acceleration Nonlinear Ordinary And Base Isolator Building
El Centro NS El Centro EW Kobe NS Kobe EW
[cm/sec2] [cm/sec2] [cm/sec2] [cm/sec2]
Level
Base Base Base Base
Ordinary Ordinary Ordinary Ordinary
Isolator Isolator Isolator Isolator
0 - 512 - 603 - 580 - 553
29
1 532 517 635 577 596 576 692 518
2 634 555 719 510 600 540 647 449
3 664 572 745 478 676 456 689 438
4 648 537 721 445 753 474 729 436
5 611 532 691 487 822 500 802 424
6 688 480 851 515 831 513 882 441
7 610 518 820 454 791 494 902 482
8 602 504 717 477 699 499 858 515
9 716 434 704 547 677 518 761 492
10 766 475 820 611 827 467 752 475
11 839 652 918 721 955 647 1004 631
12 1367 892 1439 994 1374 961 1575 806
According to the table 1.12.1 the value of response displacement of nonlinear ordinary building is bigger
than response displacement base isolator building. The biggest of displacement of ordinary building is El
Centro EW and The biggest of displacement of base isolator building is El Centro EW
1.14 Maximum Response Story Drift of Ordinary Building and Base Isolator Building
The figure 1.13.1 represent response story drift of ordinary building and base isolator building of El
Centro EW ground motion in the X direction.
12
0.00
UPPER10.00 20.00
LIMIT MAX DRIFT30.00 40.00
OF BASE 50.00BUILDING
ISOLATION 60.00 70.00
Max. Drift [cm]
30
Fig. 1.13.1 Distribution Maximum Response Story Drift of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building of El Centro EW
Illustrated in figure 1.13.1 the maximum story drift occur in the 4th story, the story drift for nonlinear
analysis of ordinary building is bigger than base islolator building. The story drift of non linear ordinary
building is bigger than upper of limit story drift ordinary building and The story drift of base isolator
building is smaller than upper of limit story drift base isolator and upper of limit story drift ordinary
building.
The figure 1.13.2 represent response story drift of ordinary building and base isolator building of El
Centro NS ground motion in the X direction.
12
Story
4
31
building is bigger than upper limit story drift ordinary building and The story drift of base isolator
building is smaller than upper of limit story drift base isolator and upper of limit story drift ordinary
building.
12
0.00
UPPER5.00
LIMIT 10.00 15.00
MAX DRIFT OF 20.00 25.00 30.00
BASE ISOLATION 35.00 40.00
BUILDING
Max. Drift [cm]
Illustrated in figure 1.13.3 the maximum story drift occur in the 4th story, the story drift for nonlinear
analysis of ordinary building is bigger than base islolator building. The story drift of non linear ordinary
building is bigger than with upper of limit story drift ordinary building and The story drift of base isolator
building is smaller than upper of limit story drift base isolator and upper of limit story drift ordinary
building.
The figure 1.13.4 represent response story drift of ordinary building and base isolator building of Kobe
NS ground motion in the X direction.
32
12
NON LINEAR ORDINARY BUILDING
10
8
BASE ISOLATOR BUILDING
Story
6
4
0.00
UPPER10.00 20.00
LIMIT MAX DRIFT30.00 40.00
OF BASE 50.00BUILDING
ISOLATION 60.00 70.00
Max. Drift [cm]
Illustrated in figure 1.13.4 the maximum story drift occur in the 4th story, the story drift for nonlinear
analysis of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator building. The story drift of nonlinear ordinary
building is bigger than upper of limit story drift ordinary building and the story drift of base isolator
building is smaller than upper of limit story drift base isolator and upper of limit story drift ordinary
building.
According to the figure 1.13.1 until 1.13.4 the maximum story drift occur in the 4th story and all figure
maximum story drift of ordinary building is bigger than the upper limit of story drift ordinary building.
The story drift of base isolator building is smaller than the ordinary building. The values of story drift
nonlinear ordinary building and base isolator building of all figure 1.13.1 until 1.13.4 showed by table
1.13
Table 1.13.1 The Value Of Story Drift Non Linear Ordinary Building And Base Isolator Building
33
UPPER LIMIT STORY
El Centro NS El Centro EW Kobe NS Kobe EW
DRIFT
Leve
l Base Base Base Base
Ordinar Ordinar Ordinar Ordinar Base
Isolato Isolato Isolato Isolato Ordinary
y y y y Isolator
r r r r
1 2.77 1.79 3.31 1.83 3.29 2.24 2.78 1.42 8.08 8.40
2 6.25 3.10 7.96 3.96 7.80 4.19 5.92 2.37 8.08 8.40
3 7.91 3.31 11.09 4.96 10.82 4.48 7.59 2.54 8.08 8.40
4 8.30 3.43 12.93 5.39 12.78 4.18 8.41 2.94 8.08 8.40
5 6.49 2.80 11.74 4.48 12.07 3.20 7.29 2.85 8.08 8.40
6 4.34 2.24 8.97 3.56 9.69 2.63 5.52 2.79 8.08 8.40
7 3.43 1.97 6.94 3.38 7.51 2.34 4.48 3.06 8.08 8.40
8 3.33 1.68 5.74 3.28 5.71 2.07 3.96 3.20 8.08 8.40
9 2.96 1.19 4.59 2.76 3.94 1.68 3.15 2.83 8.08 8.40
10 2.56 0.87 3.78 2.60 2.98 1.48 2.33 2.80 8.08 8.40
11 1.76 0.54 2.63 2.08 2.10 1.11 1.35 2.31 8.08 8.40
12 1.05 0.29 1.44 1.37 1.20 0.74 0.62 1.52 8.08 8.40
According to the table 1.13.1, The biggest story drift occurs in the 4th story and the biggest story drift of
nonlinear ordinary building is El Centro EW with the value of story drift equal 12.93 cm. The biggest
story drift of nonlinear ordinary building is El Centro EW with the value of story drift equal 2.87 cm. It
can be concluded the story drift of ordinary building, not ok because the story drift is bigger than the
upper limit of story drift, the story drift of base isolator building is ok because the upper limit of story
drift is smaller than the upper limit of story drift.
1.14 Relationship Maximum Drift Angle and Story of Ordinary Building and Base Isolator
Building
The maximum layer shear force each story of ordinary building and base isolator building illustrated by
figure 1.14.1 until 1.14.4
34
12
10
8
Story
6
Fig. 1.14.1 Relationship Maximum Drift Angle and Story of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building El Centro EW
Illustrated in figure 1.14.1 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 36910 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 29270 kN.
The figure 1.14.2 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of El Centro NS ground motion in the X direction.
35
12
10
8
Story
6
NON LINEAR ORDINARY BUILDING
4
2
0 BASE ISOLATOR BUILDING
Fig. 1.14.2 Relationship Maximum Drift Angle and Story of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building El Centro NS
Illustrated in figure 1.14.2 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 37710 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 25010 kN.
The figure 1.14.3 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of Kobe EW ground motion in the X direction.
36
12
10
8
Story
6
NON LINEAR ORDINARY BUILDING
4
2
0 BASE ISOLATOR BUILDING
0.00 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09
Drift Angle
Fig. 1.14.3 Relationship Maximum Drift Angle and Story of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building Kobe EW
Illustrated in figure 1.14.3 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 34220 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 21820 kN.
37
12
10
8
Story
6
Fig. 1.14.4 Relationship Maximum Drift Angle and Story of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building Kobe NS
Illustrated in figure 1.14.4 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 35850 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 26780 kN.
1.14 Maximum Layer Shear Force Each Story of Ordinary Building and Base Isolator Building
The maximum layer shear force each story of ordinary building and base isolator building illustrated by
figure 1.14.1 until 1.14.4.
38
12
10
8
Story
6
Fig. 1.14.1 Maximum Layer Shear Force Each Story of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building El Centro EW
Illustrated in figure 1.14.1 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 36910 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 29270 kN.
The figure 1.14.2 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of El Centro NS ground motion in the X direction.
39
12
10
8
Story
6
Fig. 1.14.2 Maximum Layer Shear Force Each Level of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building El Centro NS
Illustrated in figure 1.14.2 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 37710 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 25010 kN.
The figure 1.14.3 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of Kobe EW ground motion in the X direction.
40
12
10
8
Story
6
4
2
0
ISOLATOR BUILDING ORDINARY BUILDING
Fig. 1.14.3 Maximum Layer Shear Force Each Level of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building Kobe EW
Illustrated in figure 1.14.3 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 34220 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 21820 kN.
The figure 1.14.4 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of Kobe NS ground motion in the X direction.
41
12
10
8
Story
6
Fig. 1.14.4 Maximum Layer Shear Force Each Level of Ordinary Building
and Base Isolator Building Kobe NS
Illustrated in figure 1.14.4 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 35850 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 26780 kN.
1.15 Distribution Story Shear Coeffcient of Ordinary Building and Base Isolator Building
The maximum layer shear force each story of ordinary building and base isolator building illustrated by
figure 1.14.1 until 1.14.4.
The figure 1.14.1 represent maximum layer shear force each story of ordinary building and base isolator
building of El Centro EW ground motion in the X direction.
42
12
10
8
Story
6
Illustrated in figure 1.14.1 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 36910 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 29270 kN.
The figure 1.14.2 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of El Centro NS ground motion in the X direction.
43
12
10
8
Story
6
4
2
0 ISOLATOR BUILDING ORDINARY BUILDING
Illustrated in figure 1.14.2 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 37710 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 25010 kN.
The figure 1.14.3 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of Kobe EW ground motion in the X direction.
44
12
10
8
Story
6
4
2
0 ISOLATOR BUILDING ORDINARY BUILDING
Illustrated in figure 1.14.3 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 34220 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 21820 kN.
The figure 1.14.4 represent maximum layer shear force each level of ordinary building and base isolator
building of Kobe NS ground motion in the X direction.
45
12
10
8
Story
6
Illustrated in figure 1.14.4 the maximum layer shear force of ordinary building is bigger than base isolator
building and the value of the maximum layer shear force of 1st story of the ordinary building is 35850 kN
and the value of maximum layer shear force at the 1st story of base isolator building is 26780 kN.
46
1.16 Relationship Max. Story Drift and Story Shear Force of Base Isolator Building (Base Floor)
The figure 1.16.1 until 1.16.4 represent maximum response story drift of Base Isolator Building El
Centro-EW, El Centro NS, Kobe EW and Kobe NS ground motion at the base floor in the X direction.
50000.00
40000.00
30000.00
20000.00
0.00
-80.00 -60.00 -40.00 -20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00
-10000.00
-20000.00
-30000.00
Drift [cm]
UPPER
LIMIT
BASE ISOLATOR
Fig. 1.16.1 Relationship Max. Story Drift and Story Shear Force of Base Isolator Building
(Base Floor) Elcentro-EW
Illustrated in figure 1.16.1 the maximum story drift of base floor is 34.75 cm and the maximum of the
shear force is 25130 kN.
47
30000.00
20000.00
10000.00
0.00
Shear Force [kN] -40.00 -20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00
-10000.00
-20000.00
-30000.00
-40000.00
Drift [cm]
UPPER
LIMIT
BASE ISOLATOR
Fig. 1.16.2 Relationship Max. Story Drift and Story Shear Force of Base Isolator Building
(Base Floor) El Centro NS
Illustrated in figure 1.16.2 the maximum story drift of base floor is 21.72 cm and the maximum of the
shear force is 20800 kN.
.
48
30000.00
UPPER
LIMIT 20000.00
BASE ISOLATOR
10000.00
-10000.00
-20000.00
-30000.00
Drift [cm]
Fig. 1.16.3 Relationship Max. Story Drift and Story Shear Force of Base Isolator Building
(Base Floor) Kobe EW
Illustrated in figure 1.16.3 the maximum story drift of base floor is 27.82 cm and the maximum of the
shear force is 19200 kN.
49
40000.00
30000.00
20000.00
10000.00
Shear Force [kN]
0.00
-80.00 -60.00 -40.00 -20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00
-10000.00
-20000.00
-30000.00
Drift [cm]
UPPER
LIMIT
BASE ISOLATOR
Fig. 1.16.4 Relationship Max. Story Drift and Story Shear Force of Base Isolator Building
(Base Floor) Kobe NS
Illustrated in figure 1.16.4 the maximum story drift of base floor is 33.22 cm and the maximum of the
shear force is 24100 kN.
According to the figure 1.16.1 until 1.16.4 all of the maximum of story drift of base isolator smaller than
upper limit drift of base isolator.
Conclusion
The use of base isolator system on the building with the category of high seismic intensity area is
very effective to reduce the danger of earthquake risk. It can be proved by the analysis that has
been performed on the seismic performance analysis of the base isolator system building and
ordinary building. The result shows that the building using base isolator system can extend the time
50
period of the building which has an effect on reducing the acceleration values in the buildings and
also reducing the shear force of the earthquake.
All of the levels of the behavior of the ordinary building when subjected to the earthquake has the
elastoplastic condition but all of the levels of the behavior of the isolator building when subjected to
the earthquake, all of the levels has the elastic condition. The use of base isolators in the buildings
can minimize displacement large and story drift of the structure. It can be seen from the studies
that have been done by a very noticeable difference from the value of story drift in the building
base isolator system and ordinary building where the value of the maximum story drift of the
building with base isolator system is 2.87 cm and the value of the maximum story drift of ordinary
building is 12.93 cm. According to Indonesia code, the upper limit of the story drift in this study for
ordinary buildings is 8.08 cm and the upper limit of the story drift base isolator building is 8,40 cm.
It can be concluded that the story drift of ordinary building is bigger than the upper limit story
drift of ordinary building and the story drift of base isolator building is smaller than the upper limit
of the story drift of base isolator system.
51