Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Mark Anthony Ocloo & Michael Subbey (2008) Perception of
basic education school teachers towards inclusive education in the Hohoe District
of Ghana, International Journal of Inclusive Education, 12:5-6, 639-650, DOI:
10.1080/13603110802377680
Download by: [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] Date: 22 February 2016, At: 10:24
International Journal of Inclusive Education
Vol. 12, Nos. 56, SeptemberNovember 2008, pp. 639650
The purpose of this study is to investigate the perception of basic school teachers towards inclu-
sive education in the Hohoe District of Ghana. The research makes use of a descriptive survey
design, which engaged both qualitative and quantitative research methodologies. A sample size of
100 respondents, comprising of 60 male teachers and 40 female teachers, was drawn from a
population of 600 for the study. A purposive sampling technique is employed to find participants
for the study. The outcome of the research reveals that even though the basic school teachers in
the Hohoe District were exposed to the policy of inclusive education, they identify factors imped-
ing the policy implementation comprising: inadequate facilities available for the teachers to
implement the policy of inclusion and a lack of adequate training for teachers to be equipped
with how to take care of students with disabilities in their classrooms. It is also found that the
Ghana Education Service and other stakeholders of education pay mere lip service to the provi-
sion of services to inclusive school environments. The researchers suggest that the Ghana Educa-
tion Service must provide regular in-service training to the teachers for them to be able to address
the learning needs of the disabled. Additionally, suggestions are raised for Government and other
stakeholders to provide equipment and other facilities for implementation of inclusive education
in Ghana.
Introduction
In Ghana education has traditionally been organized on a two-tier basis: the first is
the special school for children with disabilities such as deafness, blindness and mental
retardation; and the second is the regular school system.1 The system of segregation
dates back to the early post-independence era. Today, very few schools have
attempted and successfully broken down this barrier.
due attention it deserves. This research therefore explores and finds out about the
perception of the basic schoolteachers towards the placement of persons with disabil-
ities in regular schools in the Hohoe District of Ghana.
concept of inclusion gained acceptance in 1994 and was ratified by the United
Nations. Such teachers suppose that persons with disabilities have no place in the
regular classroom. The researchers view was established by Forlin (1998) who
showed that acceptance of a child with physical disability declined when teachers had
six to ten years of experience but was highest among educators with less than six years
of experience.
In addition, most head teachers in Ghana reject the admission of students with
disabilities into their schools with the reason that such disabled children will lower the
academic standard of the school. As revealed by clinical psychologist Avoke (2005),
in doctoral research conducted in Ghana, schools are aiming at results, so the teach-
ers in the regular2 schools do not want to see pupils with special needs. As a result,
they decide for the parents and tell them that the children should go to the special
schools. Such attitudes are strongly noted to be influenced by a desire to ensure a
particular standard in schools.
Moreover, most teachers refuse the placement of the disabled in their classes with
the notion that this may be unrewarding and burdensome. The rejection is stronger
with those children with severe disabilities than those with less severe disabilities. This
view was supported by Center and Ward (1987) when they found out that teachers
are more willing to include students whose disabilities do not require additional
responsibilities on their part.
Based on the above stated problems, the present study focuses on finding out about
the perception of basic schoolteachers towards the placement of persons with disabil-
ities in regular schools in the Hohoe District.
Delimitations
The study was conducted in ten basic schools in the Hohoe District. It covered
primary one- to six-level schoolteachers and would be restricted to the selected
regular schools that are well established with the required staff strength in place. The
required staff strength in place made it possible for the researcher to select randomly
from a fairly large population of teachers present for the study. The well-established
basic schools had the head teachers at post who were involved in the study.
Influencing factors
Obeng (2007) of the University of Indiana, USA, carried out a study in Ghana. A
total of 480 respondents took part in this study. Questionnaires were administered in
the Accra metropolis and in some rural areas in the Eastern Region of Ghana. Data
were then collected and analysed. The purpose of this research was to find out: (1)
how teachers in general education classrooms, both male and female of different
educational backgrounds, view disabilities, (2) the kind of disabilities identified in
Ghanaian classrooms, (3) the type of training teachers receive in connection with
Downloaded by [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] at 10:24 22 February 2016
teaching children with disabilities, and (4) how the training that teachers receive
influences the kind of help they gave to students with disabilities.
Obeng established that although some of the teachers surveyed (young and old,
male and female, rural and urban) had a great love for all their students, they (the
teachers) were not happy to have children with hyperactive behaviour in their class-
rooms. Some of the teachers were against having such children because they
complained that they did not have the necessary training and educational resources
to accommodate these children in an overcrowded classroom. The study recom-
mends that the Ministry of Education and the Ghana Education Service look into
the various ways of helping students with disabilities, especially those with behav-
iour problems. It was also recommended that special education courses be made
core courses for teacher training in Ghana. Workshops that focus on training
teachers on how to incorporate activities that will enhance the abilities of students
with developmental delays to learn are a necessity. This will go a long way to
enhance students learning and ease or allay the teachers fears about their present
predicament.
Teacher attitudes
Research conducted by Agbenyega (2007) of the University of Ghana, Legon,
focused on examining teachers concerns and attitudes about inclusive education in
Ghana. The study combined surveys with qualitative approach to data collection.
After the survey, teachers who agreed to a personal interview were asked questions.
A 20-item Attitudes Toward Inclusion in Africa Scale (ATIAS) was completed by
100 basic school teachers from five Inclusive Project schools and five Non-Project
coeducational basic schools in three different localities: central business, coastal and
suburban areas within the Greater Accra metropolis. A total of 100 basic school-
teachers 33% males and 67% females from the ten schools were involved in the
study.
The study has shown that attitudes and concerns of teachers affect their acceptance
and commitment to implementing inclusion. According to the researcher, it is worth
noting that inclusive education, as implemented by Ghana Education Service policy
and project (Free Compulsory Universal Basic Education: FCUBE), is not leading to
equal and appropriate educational outcomes, particularly for students with disabili-
ties. Rejection of students with disabilities by regular teachers, inappropriate or
644 M. A. Ocloo and M. Subbey
insufficient resources, and a lack of provision of generic support and training services
contribute to these poor outcomes. Agbenyega (2007) has noted that large class size,
professional competency, students needs, teacher beliefs and resources are particu-
larly important for inclusive practice to be successful in Ghana. It is important that
teacher attitude toward inclusive education is studied in-depth on regular bases.
Teacher views
Downloaded by [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] at 10:24 22 February 2016
Challenges
A comparative and cross-national study conducted by Cavusculu (2006) of the Hoges
School, Zuyd, the Netherlands, focused on primary classroom teachers in Maastricht
(the Netherlands) in general education and their counterparts in Ankara (Turkey).
Questionnaires were administered to 80 teachers in total: 40 teachers belonged to
schools in Ankara and 40 teachers to schools in Maastricht. Thus, the total sample
was 80 teachers out of about 400 teachers who were engaged in teaching assignments
involving students with disabilities in mainstream classrooms.
The purpose of Cavusculus study was to investigate: (1) the current knowledge
and views of primary school teachers about teaching students with special educational
needs in mainstream schools; (2) to determine the possible challenges of teachers
Perception of basic education school teachers towards inclusive education in Ghana 645
with this education system; and (3) to see whether or not there are resources to
support teachers in inclusive settings while performing their assignments.
Cavusculu found that teachers in neither country took courses about inclusive
education during their attendance at the university and at the time they engaged in
educational activities in the schools. However, teachers in the Netherlands sometimes
received assistance in inclusive education, in the classroom and outside of it, from the
auxiliary professional members. To an extent, this closed the gap of knowledge about
inclusive education and support. Teachers in Turkey reported trying to provide an
Downloaded by [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] at 10:24 22 February 2016
inclusive education while lacking knowledge about it and not having any support.
From the study it was concluded that the inclusive educational services in Turkey are
facing many problems at the time of implementation. Teacher knowledge about
inclusive education is insufficient and the supportive services are lacking. Therefore,
this education is not successfully provided in Turkey. However, with the necessary
supportive services for inclusive education and the supports that reduce the work load
of the teachers, implementation of inclusive education by a majority of teachers in the
Netherlands is noted to be progressing. Persons having high level of knowledge
relating to inclusive education are provided for the schools and there are fewer
problems reported. The inference from the study is that inclusive schools will suffer
setbacks if support services for the development of the teacher and the inclusive child
are absent.
Research design
A descriptive survey was designed and employed for the study. The purpose is to
generalize from a sample to a population so that inferences could be made about some
characteristics, attitudes or behaviours of the population. According to Osuala (1991)
descriptive surveys are versatile and practical, especially to the researcher, in that they
identify present needs. In the opinion of Fraenkel & Wallen (2000) the purpose of
descriptive research is to observe, describe and document aspects of a phenomenon
as it naturally occurs. In descriptive research the events or conditions either already
exist or have occurred and the researcher merely selects the relevant variables for
analysis of their relationship.
The District houses part of the Akwapim-Togo ranges extending beyond the
countrys eastern boundary all the way to Western Nigeria. These ranges are the east-
ern part of the Voltaian basin, aligning on the south-west and north-east axis. Within
these ranges is the Afadjato the highest elevation in Ghana (880.30 m). A number
of communities are located at the hill tops and can hardly be reached by a motor
vehicle. Another important feature is the Volta Lake at the southern end of the
district. The resources of the Volta Lake in respect of fishing and the lake transport
facility need to be tapped through Kpando district and/or at the southern end of the
district at Kpeve and Have areas.
Considering the Educational sector, the teaching staff position in the District gives
a summary of the number of teachers and teacher/student ratio (Table 1).
A further analysis makes an interesting revelation for the Junior Secondary Schools.
The sector has an average of 6.25 teachers to a school and by the standards of Ghana
Education Service, the minimum requirement of five to a school, has been met for all
schools. The issue, however, is that the required number of teachers are in the arts.
Technical Skills, Mathematics and Science fields have not been met in the JSS
Schools and this affects educational standards in the District.
An analysis of the BECE results does not depict an encouraging situation
(Table 2). It is therefore incumbent upon the District Assembly and all stakeholders
to make a conscious effort to improve upon educational standards in the district.
Sampling technique
The sample is basically the subset of the population. According to Strydon and De
Vos (1998), a sample is a subset of measurement drawn from a population in which
the researcher is interested. For this study, purposive sampling technique was
employed. According to Mason (1996), in the broadest sense, sampling technique
and selection are principles and procedures used to identify, choose and gain access
to relevant units, which will be used for data generation by any method. The study
seeks to replicate a similar study conducted earlier in Accra with a similar approach
Downloaded by [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] at 10:24 22 February 2016
in order to see whether there is any significant difference in the results of this earlier
research and what pertains in the Hohoe District of Ghana.
Limitations
Some of the respondents did not have any background training in special education.
This might have affected the accuracy of their response regarding inclusive education.
In spite of this limitation, the majority of respondents demonstrated some level of
knowledge in special education which might have added to the validity and reliability
of the study.
Some of the respondents defaced and mutilated some of the questionnaires given
out to them. This made it strenuous for the researcher to make out some of the
Downloaded by [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] at 10:24 22 February 2016
Conclusion
The study revealed that the basic school teachers in the Hohoe District were exposed
to the policy of inclusive education. In spite of the exposure, the study showed that
there were hampering factors to the policy implementation consisting of inadequate
facilities available for the teachers to implement the policy of inclusion and a lack of
adequate training for teachers to equip them with how to educate disabled students
in their classrooms. It was also found out that the Ghana Education Service and other
stakeholders did not provide support services for the effective implementation of
inclusion. The researchers suggested that the Ghana Education Service must provide
regular in-service training to the teachers for them to know how to meet the learning
needs of the disabled. Moreover, suggestions have been raised for Government and
other stakeholders to provide equipment and other facilities for easy implementation
of inclusive education in Ghana.
Note
1. Editors note on language: terms for cognitive disability (CD) or intellectual impairment (II)
vary. While CD or II are the preferred terminology of the Editors, we acknowledge that mental
retardation is still currently used in Ghana. Likewise, although the term general education is
preferred to regular education (implying irregular education for students with disabilities) in
Western language and scholarship, we recognize that the latter is currently used in Ghana.
Notes on contributors
Mark Anthony Ocloo is Ghanaian by birth and was born on 29 November 1957 at
Ho in the Volta Region of Ghana. His first degree was in Special Education from
Perception of basic education school teachers towards inclusive education in Ghana 649
the University of Education, Winneba, and his Second Degree from the Univer-
sity of Cape Coast and the East Washington University. He is currently a Senior
Lecturer in the Department of Special Education, University of Education,
Winneba. He specialized in Education for the Visually Impaired. He published
research works both internationally and locally, and his area of interest is the
preparation of materials for the blind and visually impaired.
Michael Subbey is Ghanaian by birth and was born on 7 April 1974 at Michel Camp,
Tema, in the Greater Accra Region of Ghana. His first degree was in Educational
Downloaded by [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] at 10:24 22 February 2016
Foundations from the University of Cape Coast and he is currently pursuing his
Second Degree in Special Education at the University of Education, Winneba.
His areas of interest are inclusive education and the psychology of human devel-
opment and learning. He is currently a Graduate Assistant at the University of
Education, Winneba, and a Senior Tutor in the Department of Education Stud-
ies, St Francis Training College, Hohoe.
References
Agbenyega, J. (2007) Examining teachers concerns and attitudes to inclusive education in Ghana,
International Journal of Wholeschooling, 3(1). Available online at: http://www.wholeschool-
ing.net/Journal_of_Whole_Schooling/articles/3-1%20Agbenyega.doc (accessed 15 May 2007).
Avoke, M. (2005) Special educational needs in Ghana-policy, practice and research, in: Special
Educational Books (Winneba, Ghana, UEW, Department Of Special Education), 31.
Blaxter, L., Hughes, C. & Tight, M. (1996) Guidelines for masters dissertation for campus based, outreach
and partnership students (Birmingham, School of Education, University of Birmingham).
Cavusculu, M. (2006) The key persons of inclusive education: the teacher (Zuyd, Maastricht, The
Netherlands, Hoges School).
Center, Y. & Ward, J. (1987) Teachers attitudes towards the integration of disabled children into
regular schools, Exceptional Child, 34, 4156.
Elkins, J. (1998) The school context. In A. Ashman & J. Elkins (Eds), Educating children with
special needs, 3rd edn, (Sydney, Prentice Hall), 67101.
Forlin, C. (1998) Teachers personal concerns about including children with a disability in regular
classrooms, Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities, 87110.
Fraenkel, J. R. & Wallen, N. E. (2000) How to design and evaluate research in education, 4th edn
(San Francisco, CA, McGraw-Hill).
Gunsalus, C. C. & Morgan, R. L. (1997) Best practices for inclusive schools. Paper presented at
the National Rural Education Association, 89th Annual Convention, The Many Faces of Rural
Education, Tucson, AZ, USA. Available online at: http://www.unr.edu/benchchap04.pdf.
Hayes, A. (2005) Families and disabilities: another facet of inclusion, in: A. Ashman & J. Elkins
(Eds) Educating children with special needs, 3rd edn (Sydney, NSW, Pearson Education
Australia), 3966.
Knight, B. A. (1999) Towards inclusion of students with special educational needs in regular
classroom, Support for Learning, 153, 37.
Mapsea, A. J. (2006) Teachers views on providing for children with special needs in inclusive classrooms:
a Papua New Guinea study (New Zealand, University of Waikato).
Mason, J. (1996) Qualitative research (Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage).
Norwich, B. (1994) The relationship between attitudes to the integration of children with special
educational needs and wider socio-political views, European Journal of Special Needs Education,
9, 91106.
650 M. A. Ocloo and M. Subbey
Obeng, C. (2007) Teachers views on the teaching of children with disabilities in Ghanaian
classrooms, International Journal of Special Education, 22, 96103.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (1999) Inclusive education at
work: students with disabilities in mainstream schools (Paris, OECD Centre for Educational
Research and Innovation).
Osuala, E. C. (1991) Introduction to research methodology (Onitsha, Africa Fep).
Strydon, H. & De Vos, A. S. (1998) Sampling and sampling methods. In A. S. De Vos (Ed),
Research at grassroots: a premier for the caring professions (Pretoria, J. L. Van Schaik Academic),
191.
Thorman, M. (2003) A study on children with disabilities and special education in Ghana: key
Downloaded by [Biblioteca Universidad Complutense de Madrid] at 10:24 22 February 2016
findings for USAID, African Journal of Special Educational Needs, 4 [Special Issue: Inclusive
Education for Persons with Disabilities: General Overview], 10.
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO) (1994) The
Salamanca statement and framework for action on special needs education (Paris, UNESCO).