You are on page 1of 7

Bioresource Technology 81 (2002) 171177

Process balance and product quality in the production of natural


indigo from Polygonum tinctorium Ait. applying
low-technology methods
a,*
T. Bechtold , A. Turcanu a, S. Geissler b, E. Ganglberger b

a
Institute for Textile Chemistry and Textile Physics, LeopoldFranzens-University Innsbruck, Hoechsterstrasse 73, A-6850 Dornbirn, Austria
b
Institute for Applied Ecology, Seidengasse 13, A-1070 Vienna, Austria
Received 30 July 2001; received in revised form 5 August 2001; accepted 16 August 2001

Abstract
Indigo is the most important blue component in the class of natural dyes for cellulose and protein bres. In the moderate
European climate Polygonum tinctorium Ait. could be an interesting source for natural indigo (Vat blue 1). Following a cultivation
of the plant material a simple procedure for the extraction of the indigo precursor indican was investigated with regard to crop and
quality of dye obtained. The dependence of the crop on the storage conditions of the harvested plant material was investigated. The
results quantify the distinct sensitivity of the fresh material to the time of storage before extraction with regard to the amount of
natural indigo obtained, the photometrically determined indigo content in the product and the shade and colour depth observed in
standardised dyeing experiments. A basic set of data is presented, which describes the process in terms of consumption of energy,
water and chemicals and organic waste released from the extraction step. 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Indigo; Natural dye; Textiles; Dyeing; Indican; Polygonum tinctorium Ait.; Dyer's Knotweed; Colour

1. Introduction Due to the importance of indigo considerable re-


search has been performed to replace the chemical
For textile dyeing with natural dyes, indigo has an synthesis of the dye by an application of biotechnolog-
almost unique position as the most important blue ical methods (O'Connor and Hartmans, 1998; Itoh
natural dye (CI Vat Blue 1). Woad (Isatis tinctoria L.) et al., 1999; Bhushan et al., 2000; Young-Am et al.,
and Dyer's Knotweed (Polygonum tinctorium Ait.) were 2000; Shim et al., 1998). At present there is still con-
cultivated in Europe for the production of indigo up to siderable demand for research to optimise these methods
the 17th century. After this time indigo from the Indigo- of biosynthesis with regard to their production costs
plant (Indigofera tinctoria L.) was used because of the (Schrott and Saling, 2000).
superior quality of the dyestu (Schmidt, 1997). At the For the production of eco-textiles based on natural
end of the 19th century the synthetic indigo almost dyes an evaluation of economic and ecologic sources for
completely displaced natural indigo. In 1913 the pro- natural dyes is of growing interest (Geissler and
duction of synthetic indigo had reached more than Ganglberger, 2001). Yellow, red, brown, green and dark
33,000 tons (Schweppe, 1993). At this time mainly grey shades can be obtained from various sources of
woollen clothes were dyed for marine blue textiles with plant material e.g. buds from Canadian Golden Rod,
excellent fastness properties. Madder roots, barks from Sticky Alder tree, Ash-tree
At present the main market for indigo is dyeing of (Bechtold et al., 2001). Despite the various shades that
cotton yarn for the production of denim (Essl, 1999, can be obtained with such dyes the need for indigo as a
2000a,b). The annual production of synthetic indigo is blue component is persistent.
estimated as 22,000 tons of dyestu (Schrott, 2001). As a result, with the historical disappearance of in-
digo farming in Europe there is a considerable lack in
knowledge with regard to simple production of natural
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +43-5572-28533; fax: +43-5572-28629. indigo from plant material with consideration of the
E-mail address: textilchemie@uibk.ac.at (T. Bechtold). ecological standards applied at present. For an ecient

0960-8524/02/$ - see front matter 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 6 0 - 8 5 2 4 ( 0 1 ) 0 0 1 4 6 - 8
172 T. Bechtold et al. / Bioresource Technology 81 (2002) 171177

and ecological production of natural indigo a simple analysed for its indigo content by spectrophotometry
extraction method is required (Th uringer Landesanstalt, and in addition standard dyeings were performed to
1999). From the historical literature it is known that the dene the obtained shade and colour depth in compar-
freshly harvested plant material containing the indigo ison to synthetic indigo. The given results form a basic
precursors e.g. Isatan B (Indoxyl-5-ketogluconat, Isatis set of data required for optimisation and further scale
tinctoria L.) or indican (Indoxy-b-D -glucosid, Poly- up of the extraction process, including methods for
gonum tinctorium Ait.) exhibits a distinct sensitivity on standardisation and quality control of the product.
the conditions of storage and extraction (Schweppe,
1993). Detailed information about the time dependence
of the crop of indigo is needed as a basis to optimise 2. Methods
harvesting, storage of plant material, extraction of in-
digo precursors and dye formation. 2.1. Plant material
In many papers dealing with the production of indigo
from natural sources the amount of indigo formed was The seed material for Polygonum tinctorium Ait. was
determined by analysis of precursor substances e.g. in- obtained from the Th uringer Landesanstalt f
ur Land-
dican or indoxyl or by chemical extraction methods wirtschaft Jena (Dornburg, Germany). Cultivation was
(O'Connor and Hartmans, 1998; Itoh et al., 1999; performed in the moderate climate of Vorarlberg
Young-Am et al., 2000; Shim et al., 1998). For an (Austria) during the summer period of 2000. The plant
evaluation of the overall crop of indigo the formation of material was harvested in the end of September 2000 to
indigo dye should be considered because losses during avoid damage of plants by possible frost during nights.
the (bio)chemical transformation of the precursors of The total mass (leaves and stem) of wet plant material
the dye have to be considered. was approximately 250 kg. To study the inuence of
In this study Dyers' Knotweed (Polygonum tinctorium storage conditions the material was separated within
Ait.) was chosen as a representative plant for further 24 h after harvesting into samples of 1520 kg mass. The
investigation. sample identication and storage conditions are shown
A simple standard procedure, considering both basic in Table 1. After a dened storage time the samples were
technical equipment available to a farmer at moderate extracted with application of a simple standard proce-
costs and ecological demands of a dyestu extraction, is dure (Fig. 1).
presented. Results of an experimental study to deter- Storage at room temperature was chosen as a general
mine the inuence of the storage and the conditions of method. To estimate dierent strategies for longer
indican extraction on the total amount of indigo ob- storage, two samples were air dried with absence of di-
tained per kg plant material and on the dyestu content rect sunlight (Samples 12, 13, Table 1) one sample was
in the dried product are given. The crude indigo dye stored frozen (14) and one sample was stored in water
obtained with the proposed extraction method was (11).

Table 1
Sample characteristics: storage conditions, pH and redox potential (E) at the end of indican hydrolysis, absolute amount of crude dyestu and crude
dye calculated per 100 kg plant material
Sample Storage Indican hydrolysis Mass
Time Temperature pH E Plant material Crude dye Crude dye/100 kg
(d) (C) (mV) extracted (kg) (g) plant material (kg)
1 0.7 ca. 20 4.35 70 7.7 31.4 0.44
2 1 ca. 20 3.99 )80 17.8 95.6 0.54
3 1 ca. 20 4.23 )80 7.2 55.3 0.79
4 2 ca. 20 4.00 )20 19.2 53.2 0.28
5 4 ca. 20 3.85 )170 18.5 19.8 0.11
6 5 ca. 20 3.87 )180 16.8 16.4 0.10
7 6 ca. 20 3.89 )150 15.1 45.2 0.30
8 7 ca. 20 4.04 )80 17.1 55.5 0.32
9 8 ca. 20 4.07 )190 20.8 101.1 0.49
10 9 ca. 20 n.d. n.d. 20.3 69.9 0.34
11 49 ca. 20 4.36 50 20 259.2 1.30
12 49 1015 4.59 )120 18.9 40.2 0.21
13 53 1015 4.56 )70 16.9 18.1 0.11
14 54 < 20 3.73 )50 17.0 20.2 0.12
15 3a ca. 10 4.16 20 2 12.9 0.64
a
Samples 114: cultivation in Batschuns (660 m over sea level) and Tufers (520 m), hills, soil Braunerde; sample 15: cultivation approx. 6 weeks later
in Hohenems, (410 m), at valley, soil: river sediment.
T. Bechtold et al. / Bioresource Technology 81 (2002) 171177 173

Fig. 1. Production scheme for a basic process for natural indigo.

2.2. Extraction of indican and formation of crude indigo dispersed in 20 ml of a solution containing 33 g/l NaOH,
333 g/l triethanolamine (85% o.w.), 50 g=l FeSO4  7H2 O
An amount of 1520 kg of plant material was ex- and 0.8 g/l citric acid. The ask then was lled to 100 ml
tracted in two stages with soft water (<20 ppm Ca2 ). with a solution containing 10 g/l NaOH, 50 g/l trietha-
The rst extraction step was performed for 4 h with a nolamine (85% o.w.) and 5 g=l FeSO4  7H2 O. To com-
volume 40 l at 5070 C, followed by a second extraction plete reductive extraction and dissolution of the dyestu
for 2 h with 20 l water at 40 C. The combined extracts the solution was held at 40 C for 60 min with gentle
were stored for 45 days in open polyethylene contain- shaking every 15 min. The spectrum of the solution was
ers. During this time the solution was stirred for some recorded from 350 to 700 nm using a diode-array
minutes per day to introduce air oxygen. spectraphotometer (Zeiss CLH 500/MCS521 UVVis,
pH and redox potential of the solution were mea- Carl Zeiss (Jena) Germany, 1 mm cuvette). For the de-
sured at the end of the storage period by means of a termination of the content of indigo the absorbance at
glass electrode and a Pt-electrode, respectively (Ag/ 410 nm was used. Synthetic indigo (Indigo Plv. DyStar,
AgCl, 3M KCl reference, Orion 720 A, Orion Research, Frankfurt a. Main, Germany) was used as a standard
Boston, MA). To improve occulation and precipitation dyestu for calibration.
of indigo approx. 1:5 g=l CaCl2  2H2 O (technical grade) P.a. quality NaOH was used, FeSO4  7H2 O,
was added before ltration. The sediment was collected Fe2 SO4 3  78H2 O, CaCl2  2H2 O, triethanolamine, ci-
and ltered through a cotton fabric. After drying in a tric acid, and Na2 S2 O4 were technical grade chemicals.
laboratory dryer at 70 C the amount of crude indigo
was weighed. The material then was pulverised and used 2.4. Determination of the colour strength
in dyeing experiments and for analytical tests.
The colourimetric determination of the colour
2.3. Analytical determination of indigo strength of the natural dye was determined in a series of
standardised exhaust dyeing experiments (Mathis Lab-
The indigo content in the crude dyestu was deter- omat BFA-8, Mathis AG Niederhasli, Z urich, Switzer-
mined by photometry (Bechtold et al., 1992; Merritt land). Depending on the estimated indigo content of the
et al., 2001). An aqueous alkaline solution of Fe(II)tri- product, an amount of 225 g dyestu was pulverised
ethanolamine was used as reducing agent. In a 100 ml and brought to 100 ml with a solution containing
volumetric ask 0.1 g of pulverised crude dyestu was 10 g=l Na2 S2 O4 , 80 ml/l NaOH 50% and 1 g/l dispersing
174 T. Bechtold et al. / Bioresource Technology 81 (2002) 171177

agent (lignosulfonate, Setamol WS, BASF, Ludwigsha- 3 g/100 kg. Only sample 9 showed a remarkable content
fen, Germany). Complete reduction was achieved by of indigo after a storage period of 8 days. In this sample
gently shaking the solution for 1218 h at 40 C. A the photometrically determined indigo content seemed
volume of 20 ml of this stock vat was then used for a to exceed the results found in the dyeing experiments,
dyeing experiment: 10 g of bleached cotton fabric were which can be explained by an increased content of ex-
dyed in a liquor ratio of 1:10. 5 g=l Na2 S2 O4 , 7 ml/l tractable yellow components. A subtraction of the light
NaOH 50%, 10 g=l Na2 SO4 and 1 g/l dispersing agent absorption of coloured by-products extracted was not
(Setamol WS) were added to the dyebath. Within 20 min attempted because in alkaline medium a partial reduc-
the dyebath temperature was raised to 60 C and tion of the indigo is also possible, due to reducing
maintained at 60 C for 45 C. To compensate for the components present in the crude product.
low substantivity of indigo the dyebath was cooled to Sample 15 was harvested from a dierent site of
25 C before removal of the samples. Additional liquor cultivation so the initial indican content was dierent.
was removed by squeezing the samples with a laboratory The material was stored outside for 72 h at 510 C.
padder followed by air oxidation for at least 1 h. After Despite the longer duration of storage a remarkably
complete oxidation the samples were rinsed in water and higher indigo content was found, indicating that a re-
neutralised in a bath containing 1 ml/l acetic acid (80%). duction in temperature permits prolongation of storage
Drying of the samples was performed at 80 C in a before extraction.
laboratory drying unit (Mathis Labdryer, Mathis AG, On the basis of the analytical data and from the re-
Niederhasli, Zurich, Switzerland). The CIELab coordi- sults of the dyeing experiments both the indigo content
nates of the dyeings were measured with a tristimulus in the crude dyestu and the crop of dye per 100 kg
colorimeter (Minolta Chroma-meter CR 210, sample plant material were calculated (Table 2). In the purest
diameter 50 mm, D65). The indigo content was deter- samples an indigo content of approximately 10% was
mined according to the KubelkaMunk function, the determined. Related to the total mass of wet plant ma-
K=S values were calculated from the reectance deter- terial up to 70 g indigo were obtained per 100 kg of
mined at 660 nm (Pye Unicam SP 8100 double beam plants, which corresponds to an indigo content of
spectrophotometer, diuse reectance sphere 0/d). 0.070%.
Standardisation was performed with Indigo Plv. In experiments 12 and 13 the material had been air
(DyStar) using identical procedures for dyestu reduc- dried before extraction. In experiment 12, 3.36 kg air dry
tion and dyeing. material was obtained from 16.9 kg of plant matter and
in experiment 13, 3.50 kg was obtained after drying
starting from 18.9 kg material. Considering a water
3. Results and discussion content of 80.8% the indigo content in the dry material
can be given as 0.35%. In some historical reports only
The analysis of the indigo concentration in the crude the leaves were used for the extraction which would
dyestu obtained was performed by photometry and by require an additional separation step to remove the
standardised dyeing experiments. Assuming an equal stems. The stems represent approximately 50% of the
content of indican in the plant material, the amount of total mass, so results given in such reports tend to higher
crude indigo used for the dyeing experiments was in- values of indigo content (Schweppe, 1993).
creased in proportion to the amount of crude product The tendency of the analytical determination of the
obtained per kg of extracted plants. The natural dyeings indigo content corresponds to the ndings from the
were compared to standard dyeings obtained with dyeing results. The dierence in the calculated indigo
Indigo Plv. BASF (Exp. 16 1% and exp. 17 3% in col- content between the two dierent methods can be ex-
our depth). From a set of standard dyeings the colour plained with the dierent methods for dyestu extrac-
depth was determined for dyeings 115 according to tion and applied instrumental methodology.
the KubelkaMunk function. The results of the in- Besides the colour strength the shade of the dyeings
digo content as function of storage time are given in are of particular interest to determine changes in the
Table 2. dyeing results as a function of the conditions of dyestu
As shown in Table 2 the mass of crude dyestu and preparation particularly with regard to the storage of
the indigo content were directly dependent on the time the plant material.
of storage. A dramatic decrease in colour strength and In comparison to the standard dyeings shown in
indigo content of the products within 23 days of stor- Table 2, dyeings with natural indigo tended towards
age at RT was observed. During the rst two days of more greenish shades which can be seen in the more
storage at room temperature the extractable amount of negative a-values. Sample 2 shows only minimal dier-
indigo decreased from 50 g/100 kg (expts. 1, 3) to 9 g/100 ences of Lab-coordinates compared to the standard
kg (expt. 4). After a storage time of more than 4 days the dyeings, indicating that a good quality of dye can be
extractable indigo content generally dropped to less than obtained without further purication. The CIELab-
T. Bechtold et al. / Bioresource Technology 81 (2002) 171177 175

Table 2
Indigo content in the samples determined by photometry and standard dyeing experiments calculated as crop pure natural indigo per 100 kg plant
material, K=S values of the dyeings (KubelkaMunk value at 660 nm) and Lab-coordinates (CIELab colour coordinates) of the dyeings obtained
Sample Photometry Dyeing
Purity Indigo per K=S L a b Purity Indigo per
(%) 100 kg (g) (%) 100 kg (g)
1 9.2 40.0 10.1 28.22 )2.81 )14.84 12.3 53.6
10.9 27.22 )2.73 )15.11
2 2.1 11.3 8.3 28.75 1.17 )20.29 4.2 22.4
8.3 29.46 1.04 )20.39
3 2.5 19.9 13.3 27.23 )1.76 )17.33 6.29 49.9
13.3 27.03 )1.92 )16.92
4 3.5 8.4 4.5 39.28 )4.36 )16.67 3.2 9.0
4.4 39.29 )4.34 )16.96
5 2.4 2.5 1.1 56.91 )5.22 )13.60 1.4 1.4
1.2 56.54 )5.24 )13.69
6 <2.0 0.5 65.77 )4.52 )10.35 0.6 <1.0
0.5 65.77 )4.52 )10.35
7 <2.0 1.0 57.28 )4.78 )12.28 0.5 1.5
1.1 56.97 )4.70 )12.50
8 <2.0 2.1 50.49 )4.22 )18.12 1.0 3.3
2.0 50.97 )4.19 )17.71
9 3.5 17.0 4.9 37.90 )5.19 )16.49 2.1 10.0
4.7 38.36 )4.97 )16.41
10 2.0 6.9 1.6 52.61 )6.03 )13.04 0.7 2.4
1.6 53.34 )6.23 )12.62
11 <2.0 0.9 56.88 )4.83 )5.12 0.2 3.0
1.2 53.21 )5.47 )5.20
12 <2.0 0.4 69.01 )5.76 )8.35 0.0 <1.0
0.4 69.17 )5.51 )9.34
13 <2.0 0.2 78.03 )7.40 )4.78 2.2 2.4
0.2 77.45 )6.96 )4.48
14 <2.0 0.2 78.76 )7.11 )6.65 1.9 2.3
0.1 78.46 )7.60 )7.09
15 6.2 39.9 7.1 33.17 )4.45 )15.82 10.8 69.4
7.1 32.44 )4.27 )15.85
16 4.3 40.91 )1.74 )22.52
Indigo 1% 4.0 42.72 )2.04 )21.64
17% 8.1 30.85 0.30 )21.59
Indigo 3% 8.1 30.29 0.50 )21.65

coordinates are in good agreement to the data given for The observed decrease in dyestu content in the
dyeings with synthetic indigo (Bechtold et al., 1997; Xin products was accompanied by a distinct shift in shade
et al., 2000). towards yellow/green. The photometric curves given in
Fig. 2 also prove this nding. The spectra of the natural
dyes samples 1, 9, 15 show higher absorption at wave-
lengths above 440 nm indicating an increased content of
yellowbrown components.
For comparison the spectra of the Fe(II)triethanol-
amine complex solution and of the corresponding
Fe(III)-complex also are shown in Fig. 2.

4. Summary

The extraction of the plant material was performed as


a simple hot water extraction to dene a simple basic
technology which could be handled by a farmer imme-
Fig. 2. Absorption spectra: indigo samples 1, 9, 15 (see Table 1),
standards 0.05 and 0.1 g/l indigo in Fe(II)triethanolamine complex diately after harvesting.
solution and spectra of the Fe(III)-form and the Fe(II)-form of the A production scheme for the extraction of indigo
complexes. precursors from Dyer's Knotweed and the following up
176 T. Bechtold et al. / Bioresource Technology 81 (2002) 171177

treatment to form indigo is shown in Fig. 1, important In this case the volume of extract to be handled dur-
data for water consumption, energy and chemicals used ing hydrolysis of indican and indigo formation has to
and for the required storage volume for a certain pro- be optimised with regard to the very large volume of
duction capacity are given in Table 3. liquid that has to be stored during this period.
For an estimation of the indigo crop the technique of After formation of indigo during the hydrolysis, an
harvesting and extraction of the plant material has to be addition of CaCl2 facilitates precipitation and speeds up
considered very carefully because the amount of indigo ltration of the solids.
nally obtained for a given indigo content directly is The addition of chemicals during extraction has to be
inuenced by these steps. An optimisation of the farm- avoided because of the contamination of the plant res-
ing conditions will increase the overall amount of indigo idue, which represents the major part of the organic
obtained at the end of the treatment, but the relation of mass which has to be disposed o and to avoid any
the data for energy, chemicals and water consumption further treatment of the wastewater released from the
for the treatment of a certain amount of plant material precipitation/ltration step.
will remain constant and be mainly independent of the The extraction has to concentrate on soluble pre-
indigo content of the plant. cursors e.g. indican. Losses during storage can be ex-
The data in Table 3 indicate several important factors plained by formation of indoxyl and irreversible
of the process: oxidation of indoxyl to isatin but also can be caused by
The rapid decrease in the amount of indigo deter- formation of insoluble indigo. Indigo formation is ob-
mined in the product proves the importance of per- served following mechanical damage of leaves. In case
forming the extraction in a short time after of indigo formation an extraction by use of solvents or
harvesting the plant material. reducing chemicals (NaOH, Na2 S2 O4 ) is theoretically
The estimated energy consumption for the process is possible, but it has to be excluded because of the
mainly determined by the hot water extraction. For a amount of chemicals released with the extracted residue
scale-up the extraction at lower temperature should and because of expected chemical consumption per kg
be considered to optimise the energy consumption dyestu.
of the process. As a rather high volume of water The results of the dyeing experiments indicate that
has to be used an extraction in cold water would be the shade of the natural dye tends towards more
of particular interest. greenish shades and a careful standardisation of the
Optimisation of the water consumption in the process production process will be required to obtain a constant
by appropriate recycling techniques will be of partic- quality of the natural dye.
ular interest. Data describing indigo formation on the basis of
Identifying the extraction as an essential step with re- analytical results obtained with precursors should be
gard to the amount and quality of the dyestu, a treated with great care because these values describe a
semi-continuous harvesting/extraction is favourable theoretical maximum content and will be too optimistic
because an intermediate storage should be avoided. in many cases.

Table 3
Production scheme and basic requirements for daily processing of 100, 1670 and 167,000 kg/d freshly harvested plant material, corresponding to a
production capacity of 0.060, 1, and for 100 kg/d natural indigo from Polygonum tinctorium Ait.
Process step Production capacity of indigo per day
0.060 kg/d 1.0 kg/d 100 kg/d
Harvesting of fresh plant material per day (kg/d) 100 1670 167,000
60 C extraction of (Indican)
Water consumption per day (m3 =d) 0.3 5 500
Energy consumption per day (k W h/d) 14 5230 23,000
Residue for disposal per day (kg/d) ca. 100 ca. 1700 ca. 170,000
Hydrolysis of Indoxyl to form Indigo required storage volume (m3 ) 1.2 20.0 2000
Precipitation of indigo
Waste water released per day (m3 =d) 0.3 5.0 500
Chemicals consumption per day (CaCl2 ) (kg/d) 0.45 7.5 750
Filtration: amount of wet lter cake formed per day (kg/d) 3 50.0 5000
Drying: energy consumption per day (k W h/d) 3 50 5000
Crop of crude dye per day (kg/d) 0.60 10.0 1000
T. Bechtold et al. / Bioresource Technology 81 (2002) 171177 177

For a technical product standardised dyeing experi- Essl, H., 2000a. Jeans das blaue Phanomen (Teil 2). Textilveredlung
ments should be used, while photometric methods are 35 (1/2), 2327.
Essl, H., 2000b. Jeansdas blaue Phanomen (Teil 3). Textilveredlung
favourable for a comparison of the indigo concentration 35 (3/4), 2730.
under well-standardised conditions. Geissler, S., Ganglberger, E., 2001. Produktion von farbstoiefernden

Panzen in Osterreich und ihre Nutzung f ur die Textilindustrie.
Final report, Inst. f. Applied Ecology, BMfWIT, January 2001.
Acknowledgements Itoh, K., Aoki, S., Yatome, C., 1999. Production of indigo related
pigments by Nocardia globerula. J. Soc. Dyers Colour 115, 233
235.
The authors are indebted to K. Nenning (School for Merritt III, J.T., Beck, K.R., Smith, C.B., Hauser, P.J., Jasper, W.J.,
agriculture, Hohenems, A), A. Riedmann (School for 2001. Determination of indigo in dyebaths by ow injection
gardening, Lebenshilfe, Batschuns, A) for cultivation of analysis and redox titrations. AATCC Rev. 1/4, 4145.
the plant material. Authors thank the Thuringer Land- O'Connor, K.E., Hartmans, S., 1998. Indigo formation by aromatic
hydrocarbon-degrading bacteria. Biotechnol. Lett. 20, 219223.
esanstalt f
ur Landwirtschaft Jena for providing seed Schmidt, H., 1997. Indigo 100 Jahre industrielle Synthese. Chem.
material of Dyer's Knotweed and DyStar for indigo Unserer Zeit 31, 121128.
dyestu. 
Schrott, W., Saling, P., 2000. Okoezienz-Analyse Produkte zum
Kundennutzen auf dem Pr ufstand. Melliand Textilber. 81, 190
194.
References Schrott, W., 2001. Denim wieder im Blickpunkt der Textilindustrie.
Melliand Textilber. 82, 331.
Schweppe, H., 1993. Handbuch der Naturfarbstoe: Vorkommen,
Bechtold, T., Burtscher, E., Bobleter, O., 1992. Konzentrationsbes-
Verwendung, Nachweis. ecomed Verlagsges., Landsberg/Lech,
timmung von Indigo in Ansatz-und Prozessbadern. Text.-Prax. Int.
Germany, pp. 282303.
47, 4449.
Shim, J., Chang, Y., Kim, S., 1998. Indigo and indirubin derivatives
Bechtold, T., Burtscher, E., K uhnel, G., Bobleter, O., 1997. Electro-
form indoles in Poygonum tinctorium tissue cultures. Biotechnol.
chemical reduction processes in indigo dyeing. J. Soc. Dyers Colour
Lett. 20, 11391143.
113, 135144.
Thuringer Landesanstalt f ur Landwirtschaft, Anbautelegramm f ur
Bechtold, T., Turcanu, A., Geissler, S., Ganglberger, E., 2001. Natural
Farberknoterich (Polygonum tinctorium Ait.) 01/99, 1999. Jena
dyes in modern textile dyehouses How to combine experiences of
(Dornburg, Germany).
two centuries to meet the demands of the future? In: Proceedings of
Xin, J.H., Chong, C.L., Tu, T., 2000. Colour variation in the dyeing of
the 7th ERCP (European Roundtable on Cleaner Production),
denim yarn with indigo. J. Soc. Dyers Colour. 116, 260265.
Lund, Sweden, 24 May, 2001, pp. 4546.
Young-Am, C., Yu, H., Song, J., Chun, H., Park, S., 2000. Indigo
Bhushan, B., Samantha, S.K., Jain, R.K., 2000. Indigo production by
production in hairy root cultures of Polygonum tinctorium Lour.
napthalene-degrading bacteria. Lett. Appl. Microbiol. 31, 59.
Biotechnol. Lett. 22, 15271530.
Essl, H., 1999. Jeans das blaue Phanomen (Teil 1). Textilveredlung 34
(1/2), 2631.

You might also like