2013 1 Vol.28 No.

1
23 1 TRANSACTIONS OF CHINA ELECTROTECHNICAL SOCIETY Jan. 2013

1 1 1 2

1. 102206
2. 330000

TM77

Zoning Scheme of Regional Autonomy Backup Protection

Jiang Xianguo 1 Wang Zengping 1 Li Chen 1 Tang Wei 2
1. State Key Laboratory for Alternate Electrical Power System with Renewable Energy Sources
North China Electric Power University Beijing 102206 China
2. Jiangxi Electric Power Economic Research Institute Nanchang 333000 China

Abstract A zoning scheme of regional autonomy back-up protection was proposed in this paper.
Firstly, the zoning principles including the protection scope of main stations, the treatment method of
boundary components, and the tactics coping with main stations failure were formulated. With these
principles the protection system will possess the following characteristics. The first point is information
need and communication delay are balanced to ensure information completeness and protec tion rapidity.
Another is each component can be protected independently by at least one main station for the purpose
of simplifying protection coordination strategies. The third is that faults are able to be decided
accurately with the decision function failure in any main station so as to enhance the adaptability of the
protection system. Based on those, the zoning methods were presented. The narrow sense adjacency
matrix was defined to select main stations and divide the protection scope of each main stat ion. Then
the paper analyzed the operation logic of regional back-up protection and faults can be cleared reliably
in various conditions. At the last, analysis results of the actual system verified the effectiveness of this
zoning scheme.
KeywordsRegional autonomy back-up protection, zoning scheme, boundary component, narrow
sense adjacency matrix, operation logic

50837002 973 2012CB215200

20110036110003
2011-06-17 2012-06-07
 28 1 235

[1-3] [4-8]

Intelligent Electronic DeviceIED
1

IED

[9,10]

[11,12]
2

[1314]

[15]

2 3

2


 236 2013 1

2
3 B 2
L2
3 B 2

2 3

2
Fig.2 Treatment method of boundary components
20ms 3





5ms
300km
1.5ms
3
300km
4
1 B 4
B 1 B 7 B 4 3
250 km 400 km
B 1 B 4 B 7

3
1
Fig.1 Protection scope division of main stations
2
10

2 B 4
L2 B 4 L2
B 2 B 3 L2 B 1 B 4 3 10
B 4 B 1 Fig.3 10-bus network
 28 1 237

3.1 534 Ci2

B i
n A
nn A (m) 6 B i
m
CSi Bi C1i Ci2 C 12
3
i
1 ijm
Aij ( m) 4
0
B i CSi
1

m 1 B i
A( m) logical( Am ) logical En

Ak & logical( Am )

k 1
B i B i+1
2 6
m2En n logical(X)
X 1X&Y 7 Ci2+1 B g B g
(m)
X Y A Bi+1 C1g C3i +1
m
m m
Bg CSi C1g
C1i +1 CSi

B B i i
B C1g
Ci3+1 B g
C1i ,Ci2 ,C3i ,CSi B i
C1i B i Ci2 B i B C1g
C3i +1
C3i B i
CSi B i
C1g
C3i +1 CSi
87 Ci2+1
Ci2
B i+1
Ci2
Bg , Bg +1 ,Bg +2 , 3 B i+1

C3i

B i C3i B i 6
300 km 7
87
B i C3i CSi CSi CSi+ 1 CSi + 2 C C
S
i
S
i +1

Ci2 CSi +2

3.2 3 10
1 B i B 3 2
2 AA(2) A(3) B i B 3
C1i ,Ci2 ,Ci3
C13 = B1 , B2 , B4
3 Ci2 B g C1g Ci3
C3 = B7
2
5
B g 3
C1g B g C3 = B5 , B6 , B8

4 C1g Ci3 345 B 3

B 76 B 3

 238 2013 1

4.1
CS3 = B3 C13 C32 B5 , B6 = B1,B2 ,B3 , B4 , B5 , B6 , B7

6
B 3 CS3

B 7 678
4
4



4 10
Fig.4 Selection result of main stations in the 10-bus
network

CS3 = B1 ,B2 ,B3 , B4 , B5 , B6 , B7 3 L7
B 7 B 7
C7 = B1 ,B2 ,B3 , B4 , B5 , B6 , B7 , B8 , B9 , B10
S
7
S 13 14
C10 = B7 , B8 , B9 , B10 13 14
3.3
14 14
2 14 15 B 8
16






7 3



50ms 40ms
5ms
20ms 120ms
160ms
210ms
0.5s3s

4
4.2

 28 1 239

3 B 7
L7 14
B 10
B 7 L4L5 L6 L7
3 L7 791214
B 7 B 10
L7
B 10
8 13 B 4
5

500kV
4.3

B i LiLi+1Li+2
Li p
B i
LiLi+1Li+2
Li Li+1Li+2

6 500kV
Fig.6 Structure of Shandong 500kV power grid


7

t tmax t 8
t max
0.5st 0.5s
t 1s
5 7 500kV
Fig.7 Selection result of main stations in Shandong
500kV power grid
25 6
L1

L24
5
Fig.5 Operation logic after the substation DC power
supply disappeared
 240 2013 1

500kV area protection based on genetic information fusion

Tab. Zoning results of Shandong 500kV power grid technology[J]. Transactions of China Electrotechnical
Society, 2010, 25(8): 174-179.
1 B1 B1B4B6B7 [5] , , , .
2 B3 B2B3B5B7 B8B9B11B12B13 [J]. , 2010, 34(5):
3 B7 B1B2B3B4B5B6B7 B8B9B10B11B12B17B18 66-71.
4 B 11 B2B4B5B6B7 B8B10B11B12B13B15B17 B18B19B22B23B24 Zhang Baohui, Zhou Liangcai, Wang Chenggen, et al.
5 B 13 B3B7 B8B9B11B12B13B14B16B17B18B21 Wide area backup protection algorithm with
6 B 18 B6B7B8B10B11B12B13B15B17 B18B19B20B22B23B24B25 fault-tolerance performance[J]. Automation of
7 B 19 B11B18B19 B20 B21B23 Electric Power Systems, 2010, 34(5): 66-71.

8 B 21 B9B14B16B19B20B21B23B24B25 [6] , , .
[J]. , 2008,
6 28(22): 87-93.
Yang Zengli, Shi Dongyuan, Duan Xianzhong.

Wide-area protection system based on direction

comparison principle[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE,

2008, 28(22): 87-93.

1
[7] , , , .

[J]. , 2010,

30(31): 100-107.

Ma Jing, Li Jinlong, Wang Zengping, et al. Wide-area

2
back-up protection based on fault correlation factor[J].

Proceedings of the CSEE, 2010, 30(31): 100-107.

3
[8] , , .

[J]. ,

2010, 34(4): 44-48.

Zhou Shu, Wang Xiaoru, Qian Qingquan. Fault
diagnosis approach based on bayesian networks for
[1] , , , .
wide area backup protection of power system[J].
[J]. , 2007, 31(1): 1-3, 32.
Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2010, 34(4):
Li Zaihua, Bai Xiaomin, Ding Jian, et al. Analysis of
44-48.
the Western Europe blackout[J]. Automation of
[9] M M Eissa, M Elshahat Masoud, M Magdy Mohamed
Electric Power Systems, 2007, 31(1): 1-3, 32.
Elanwar. A novel back up wide area protection
[2] . [J]. ,
technique for power transmission grids using phasor
2004, 28(9): 14-17, 27.
measurement unit[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power
Chen Deshu. Preliminary research on security
Delivery, 2010, 25(1): 270-278.
protection technology of large-scale power grid[J].
[10] J Tang, P G McLaren. A wide area differential backup
Power System Technology, 2004, 28(9): 14-17, 27.
protection scheme for shipboard application[J] . IEEE
[3] . [M].
Transactions on Power Delivery, 2006, 21(3):
: , 2007.
1183-1190.
[4] , , , .
[11] , , , .
[J]. , 2010, 25(8):
[J]. , 2007,
174-179.
31(3): 72-78.
Wang Yang, Yin Xianggen, Zhang Zhe, et al. Wide
Wu Kecheng, Lin Xiangning, Lu Wenjun, et al.
 28 1 241

Principle and realization of the hierarchical region Yin Xianggen, Wang Yang, Zhang Zhe. Zone-division
protective system for power systems[J]. Automation and tripping strategy for limited wide area protection
of Electric Power Systems, 2007, 31(3): 72-78. adapting to smart grid[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE,
[12] J C Tan, P A Crossley, D Kirschen, et al. An expert 2010, 30(7): 1-7.
system for the backup protection of a transmission [15] , , , .
network[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, [J]. ,
2000, 15(2): 508-514. 2011, 31(28): 95-103.
[13] , , , . Li Zhenxing, Yin Xianggen, Zhang Zhe, et al. Study
[J]. , on system architecture and fault identification of
2010, 34(19): 48-52. zone-division wide area protection[J]. Proceedings of
Li Zhenxing, Yin Xianggen, Zhang Zhe, et al. Zone the CSEE, 2011, 31(28): 95-103.
division and implementation on limited wide area
protection system[J]. Automation of Electric Power

Systems, 2010, 34(19): 48-52. 1986

[14] , , .

[J]. , 1964

2010, 30(7): 1-7.