Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract HVDC power tapping has proven to be the absorbed by the tapping station. So, power tapped Ptap is
appropriate solution for rural AC networks. This tapping can be determined by [5]:
achieved by using series or parallel HVDC tap stations. But,
many researchers have faced some technical and economic issues
Ptap = Itap Vdc (1)
when designing tapping stations with small power ratings. In this
paper, many topologies of tapping converters are reviewed
focusing on their designs and providing pros and cons of each Where, Vdc is the voltage of the main HVDC system
topology.
Itap
Index Terms HVDC tapping, series tapping, parallel tapping,
shunt tapping. Vdc
I. INTRODUCTION
HVDC transmission systems have proved to be the most Load GS
beneficial alternative to transmit bulk electrical power over
long distances when compared to the conventional alternating
current (AC) systems. It also allow the transfer of power Fig. 2. Parallel tap
between unsynchronized AC networks [1]. Parallel taps are associated with higher power ratings than
Although HVDC transmission systems have distinguished series taps and the power of these taps are changed by varying
advantages, most of these systems are based on a point to point its dc current. Also these taps must withstand the full line
transmission scheme. In addition, most of HVDC transmission voltage, so high voltage switches will be used. In addition, it is
lines pass over rural cities which have a relatively weak AC limited to use parallel taps for small loads because the high
networks and have no access to any transmission system. So, voltage and low current ratings of load will lead to high
these cities must be economically supplied from an HDVC installation cost per kW. Unlike the voltage source converter-
system by using HVDC tapping stations [1]. based (VSC) HVDC links, power of the line-commutated
HVDC tapping stations must achieve the following converters-based (LCC) HVDC links is reversed by reversing
requirements [1-7]: it is typically rated as 1-10% of the HVDC the polarity of the DC voltage. This cant be achieved by
links capacity, it must be cost effective and reliable by not reversing current direction [8-10]. So, mechanical switching
affecting the main HVDC line at any fault and taps control arrangement is required when reversing power in the tap
system should not interfere with the main HVDC control station [1-3, 11-14].
system. In this paper, the main types of tapping stations shown Generally, parallel taps can be one of the two types shown
in fig. 1 are reviewed and discussed throughout the paper. in fig. 3 [2]. The single-stage converters are more traditional in
these taps using conventional fully voltage rated, three-phase
II. PARALLEL TAPPING DC/AC converter and a three-phase transformer. The two-stage
The parallel tap shown in fig. 2 will cause a reduction in converters which are known as the parallel-cascaded tapping
current of the main HVDC system by a value of Itap which is stations, step down the voltage using DC/DC converter. It is
HVDC Tapping
Parallel Series
+ +
HVDC AC HVDC AC
link link link link
- -
Vdc
(a) (b) 2
Fig. 3. Parallel tapping types (a) single-stage converters, (b) two-stage converters
Local AC network
A. Single-Stage Converters
1) Forced-Commutated, FC-VSC Fig. 6. NPC VSC
Parallel diodes in the converter shown in fig. 4 are used to
fix voltage polarity of the converter and allow reverse current. 4) Cascaded Current Source Converters (CSCs)
It is also protects GTOs from reverse voltage stresses. In This tap used large inductor to ensure constant current. This
square-wave operation, the converter voltage is constant and current flows through series-connected capacitor-commutated
reversing current direction will reverse power flow. But, valve switch modules shown in fig. 7 (b), inside blocks to ground
voltage stress is low while transient fault current is high. Pulse [15]. The ac outputs from blocks G1 till G4, are connected in
width modulation (PWM) provides independent control of ac parallel to the 110 kV ac bus as shown in fig. 7 (a). Each block
voltage at the expense of higher control power and higher contains three switch modules, one for each phase. The used
frequency harmonic content [11]. tap avoids issue of commutation failure. It provides
independent control of active and reactive power, minimum
switching loss, and lower cost due to lower number of
thyristors. No filters are needed as harmonics are reduced by
time shifts and zig-zag connected transformers. But, this tap
3-phase
requires mechanical switches to reverse current, and a neutral
Transformer grounding transformer for protection [16].
6-pulse, forced
commutated, VSC
Local AC network Itap Itap
Cell
Cell
Cell
2-level VSI
Vdc1
C 2 Cell
Cell
2-level VSI
Cell
Vdc2
Fig. 8. Cascaded 2-level VSCs Cell
Vdc1 3-phase VSI
Cell
2 Local
B. Two-Stages Converters Cell AC network
Cell
Cell
Cell
In this topology, IGBT is used as the switching device in Half-bridge
the VSC. The dc/dc converter steps the HVDC voltage down Fig. 10. MMC-based, series output pole tap
to lower voltage. It may use one of the following three
configurations: resistive voltage divider, capacitive voltage 4) MMC-Based, Parallel-Connected Transformer Tap
divider and modified buck divider. The low efficiency and the This converter contains transformer. Its primary is
high cost due to the special insulated resistors used, made the connected between the midpoints of a single phase leg and the
resistive voltage divider infeasible for tapping. Also capacitive midpoint of split Vdc1 link capacitors as shown in fig. 11. Cell
voltage divider has the same design as the resistive voltage stacks do not suffer from energy drift. Increasing the frequency
divider by replacing the two resistors with two capacitors, it of the AC link leads to reduced size transformer and reduces
suffered from the problem of different charge and discharge the fluctuations in voltages which means smaller size
rates of capacitors. But, this problem is solved by using a capacitors. In case of DC faults in either DC link, transformer
resistance and high voltage rated switch in parallel with the prevents the propagation of fault to the other dc link. This
capacitor. For the modified buck converter, its configuration converter has a minimum power capacity ratio due to
was not shown due to patent applications [17, 18]. transformer-stage, so it can be used with higher dc voltage
transformation ratios [2].
2) MMC-Based, Parallel Output Pole Tap
This converter is VSC-based and considered a dc version of Cell
Cell
the MMC. Each phase leg consists of two cell stacks and its Vdc1
2 Cell
midpoint is connected to one of the terminals of the low
voltage side Vdc2 as shown in fig. 9. In addition to the cell Vdc2
stacks, arm inductors set the rate of change of stack currents.
Besides, cell stacks provide the voltages required to Vdc1
Cell
Diode
Rectifier
3-phase VSI
Cell
Vdc1 Cell
Vdc1
2 Cell Cell
Half-bridge 2 Cell
Vdc2
Vdc2
3-phase VSI
Vdc1 Diode 3-phase VSI
Cell Cell Local Vdc1 Rectifier
2 AC network Cell
Cell Cell 2
Cell Local
Cell Cell + AC network
Cell
Half-bridge
LHv
HV
Valve
Cell 1
Cell 2
Cell 3
Local
AC network
Cell n
LLv Fig. 15. Twelve-pulse, line-commutated, CSC
C Local
AC network B. Forced-Commutated, FC-CSC Using SCRs
3-phase VSI Forced commutated converters as shown in fig. 16, can be
operated with leading power factor. Also, commutation
Fig. 13. Switched-capacitor parallel tap capacitors provide commutation even if in the case of negative
transformers line voltages. But, it adds to the cost of the
III. SERIES TAPPING converter. Independent control of reactive power is not
The series tap shown in fig. 14 will cause voltage drop Vtap, possible with this converter. Also, higher valve and transformer
so the power tapped Ptap can be obtained by (2) [5]: stresses and voltage distortion exists in this converter when
compared to LCC [11].
Ptap = Vtap Idc (2)
Where, Idc is the line current of the HVDC system.
Vtap
Idc
Local
AC network
1-phase
transformer Fig. 21. Soft-switch current-fed converter
1-phase
forced-
commutated I. Current-Fed Inductor-Switched Converter
VSC
3-phase forced- In fig. 22, the dc link voltage of the line-commutated CSC
commutated
VSC is controlled by the firing angle. Inductance L2 is the
Local
commutating reactance and C1 and L1 form a filter to reduce
AC network
the noise fed to the main line. Frequency must be low (300-400
Fig. 19. Series tap with forced-commutated, VSC. Hz), due to the switching of very high current [22].
L1
b) Mechanical Isolation
C1
L2 As shown in fig. 25 (b), a current-to-voltage converter is
connected to a motor-generator drive system. The length of the
1-phase shaft and the insulating material must be sufficient to provide
transformer
required isolation. This tap can be connected directly to the
Rectifier
local AC network. Additional control for the generator must be
included if the generator must synchronize with an existing AC
Inverter
network. But this tap will need maintenance due to the
mechanical part. This topology uses only one power electronic
Local converter [3, 13].
AC network
c) Isolation with Energy Storage Elements
Fig. 22. Current-fed inductor-switched converter This topology consists of a current to voltage converter
J. Current-Fed PWM Chopper connected with an energy storage units shown in fig. 25 (c).
The current-fed PWM chopper shown in fig. 23 is series This energy storage allows the local AC network to function
connected with the line. The voltage of the dc capacitor during low or no current conditions on the HVDC link by
supplied to the inverter, is kept constant by varying the connection and disconnection of these units using switches
frequency of the PWM and the dc current level [11, 22]. SW. The energy storage units which may be sodium Sulphur
batteries or super capacitors, are used to provide isolation. It
has low e ciency and this storage units increase cost [3, 13].
6-pulse 6-pulse
inverter inverter 1-phase VSI
C1
C2
Local Rectifier
AC network
In the topology shown in fig. 24, the H-bridge is made (a) AC network
Local
AC network
(b)
Rectifier
Current
transformer
Inverter
1-phase VSC
Local
AC network