You are on page 1of 68

UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 1

CHAPTER I

Introduction

Education plays an important role to the development of social-political and

economic growth of any nation; therefore effective teaching is essential. Effective

teaching does not only revolve around getting the vast amount of knowledge into the

learner it dig deeper into the technicalities, ensuring that teaching is based on assisting

the learners progress from one level to another while allowing the learner to slowly

evolve and make sense of content independently (Parasuram et.al, 2014). In that case,

learning style preferences should be identified immediately (Billings & Halstead,

2012) to understand ones own learning style preference is to help understand ones

own thinking to be aware which style and methods of learning to be used and thus

select the most effective and efficient means to go about learning. Students need to

know what implies on their knowledge in order to achieve a positive outcome

(Bradshaw & Lowenstein, 2011).

Teaching is a complex and demanding activity that involves mastery of

content, classroom discipline, techniques of organization, and demanding of teaching

skills. (Fitzpatrick as cited by Abu Hasheesh 2011), In addition, Effective teaching

requires nursing educators shift from a teacher-centered to student-centered approach,

which can foster independence in learning, creative problem-solving skills, a

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 2

commitment to life-long learning and critical thinking. Learning experience can be

adapted to the environment and are influenced by the environment in which they

occur. Awareness and comprehension of one style of learning enables one to adapt the

learning environment to provide good quality education (Bradshaw & Lowenstein,

2011).

Nursing Education is currently governed by CHED memorandum number 14

which is a competency based curriculum (Daplas, 2012). The current curriculum is

aimed to foster global competitiveness and respond to global trends and standards

(CHED, 2011). Recently changes in the Philippine Education landscape like Outcome

Based Education would affect teaching methodologies. Outcome Based Education

involves competency based learning standards together with outcome based quality

assurance monitoring and evaluation (Colinares, 2014).

Background of the Study

In traditional teaching methods, teacher is the controller of the discussion and

gives general idea to the students with the use of white board and marker while the

students will take the important notes and will try to memorize it. In this concept of

teaching methods the students will not develop critical thinking as well as

independent learning.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 3

Tests are the most significant indicator of student performance and degree of

learning. Students who belong in the same class sit down and take a single set of

examinations, which they should pass. Most of the examinations are taken from

fundamental resources, such as textbooks and other publications that are relevant to

the subject.

Educational technology roles in the delivery of instructional program

upgrading the quality of teaching learning in school, increasing the capability of the

teacher to educate learning, for students to give mastery of the lesson and evaluating

the use of technology to boost education paradigm shift that gives importance to

student centered student learning.

Nowadays the approaches of Modern teaching method in lessons are widely

different from the other method by use of games, computer presentations, video clips,

power point presentation and other activities that will encourage the student to

participate. The effective use of educational technology is vital to solving many of our

current educational challenge, it is important to keep up with technology advances in

order to recognize potential solutions. Tools are abundant, but we must be able to

recognize how to influence their capabilities in order to improve the learning

experience. Educators must be knowledgeable in new emerging hypermedia

technology known as information and communication technology (ICT) to be able to

reach and engage students in ways that the students are willing to learn.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 4

Statement of the Problem

1. What is the demographic profile of the respondents in terms of:


1.1. Age
1.2. Gender
1.3. Year level
1.4. Civil status
1.5. Educational attainment
2. What is the significant difference between traditional and modern teaching

methods as to:
2.1 Pretest
2.2 Post test
3. What is the perception of the respondents in terms of:
3.1. Traditional Teaching Method
3.2. Modern Teaching Method

Hypothesis

Ho: There is no significant difference in the learning process of the nursing students

between the traditional and modern teaching methods.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 5

Significance of the study

This study will benefit the following:

Nursing Educator This study will be a guide for them to be aware in the needs of

the students, and also they were able to adopt the more effective method that will help

them to boost the motivation of the students.

Student Nurses As a primary beneficiary this study will help to discover their

learning capabilities and this will help them to evaluate their learning preference.

Future researchers This study will serve as a basis of reference for conducting

their research study.

Definition of terms

Traditional teaching method the teachers are using white board and marker as

their tool in conducting lectures. The teachers are the one who is responsible and set a

role in classroom.

Modern teaching method in this method of teaching, the teacher are using power

points and video clips presentation.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 6

Scope and Limitations

This study focused on the effectiveness of traditional teaching method and

modern teaching method among 2nd year nursing students with a total number of 24

students in Universal College Paraaque. It is also focused on the preference and

perception of the student with regards to the two method of teaching which is

traditional teaching method and modern teaching method. This study does not include

the learning styles of the respondents.

Conceptual Framework

Figure 1: IPO framework of Traditional and Modern Learning.


INPUT PROCESS Output
Respondent's Lecture on Post test on both
Demogprahic Traditional methods of
Profiles: Teaching Method teaching and it's
age Lecture on result
gender Modern Teaching Self made
civil status Method Questionnaire
educational Evaluation
attainment
Pretest on
Traditional and
Modern Teaching
Methods
In figure 1 above shows our conceptual framework of this study, it is

presented to give view of the work to be done. The study progressed using I-P-O

model. The inputs or the independent variables are the demographic profiles of the

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 7

respondents to be analyzed and the two methods of teaching. Each of those methods

weve conducted a pretest to analyze their baseline knowledge about the topic given.

The process is the strategy to be used such as gathering data through

conducting a lecture on each of those to methods that used. The possible output or the

dependent variable is the respondents performance on process by conducting a post

test and a self-made questionnaire that will be based on their evaluation.

The researchers wants to find out on what type of teaching method they can

easily comprehend based on the results of the post test conducted and their statement

on the questionnaire given and on how to present lecture in traditional way. They

regard students as having 'knowledge holes' that need to be filled with information.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 8

CHAPTER II

Review of Related Literature

Traditional Teaching Method

Traditional teaching method is cheaper than the modern teaching methods

which make it more suitable in the schools of rural areas. This method facilitates more

interaction between the teacher and the student as compared to the modern teaching

methods. On whiteboard a teacher or student can draw, write or manipulate images

thus providing a very interactive and interesting platform. We can also say that in

traditional teaching there is more discipline in the class and does not require any

special technical knowledge and can focus more on his subject for imparting the best

knowledge to the students (Thakur, 2011)

In a traditional classroom setting, reflective activities can be facilitated by

small group discussion. Classroom arrangement needs to be non-theatre in style (rows

of disk facing a podium). Optimally the classroom can be arranged so that students

can face each other, or the desks can be arranged to allow for several small

discussions groups (Bradshaw & Lowenstein, 2011).

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

There are lots of advantages and disadvantages in traditional

teaching method, advantages will help to raise the performance

level of the students while the disadvantages are factors that cause

the delay of the progress of the student. Sheahan (2015) mentions

and explains how these four advantages affect the students.

Collaborate learning, Classroom environments promote and

stimulate a dynamic known as collaborative learning. Collaborative

learning translates into a type of learning in which the pairing or

grouping of students is required to complete a task or to come to a

specific outcome. Volume 7 of the Virginia Tech's "Journal of

Technology Education" explains that collaborative learning enhances

students' critical thinking skills. Teaching in a classroom gives

students the opportunity to engage in live discussions in which they

are forced to use their critical thinking skills to formulate opinions or

arguments. Social development, they experience social interactions

with peers and establish rapport with teachers. Helping children

develop socially is an important aspect within the realm of their

academic education. Classroom teaching environments help

students figure out how to resolve conflicts, work in teams, get

along with those from different cultural backgrounds and give

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

presentations in front of peers. Such experiences are valuable in

shaping students' communication and listening skills, as well as

growing and maturing emotionally. Educational Advantage, teaching

in a classroom environment opens up opportunities for teachers to

do more with their lesson plans. Rather than lecture students and

make them take notes, classrooms keep children stimulated through

interactive and interesting activities. When students are engaged in

their studies, they retain more of the material and really learn the

information. Classroom teaching also accommodates different types

of learners. For instance, students who are visual learners can excel

in a classroom setting where theatrical presentations, storytelling or

movies contribute to the lessons. Hands-on learners may also do

well in a school room. Organization, Traditional classroom settings

teach students how to develop organizational skills, beginning with

the basics, such as arriving to school on time. In a live classroom,

students are held accountable for being prepared to do school work,

which includes having done their homework the night before, being

ready for pop quizzes, turning in assignments by their due date and

being prepared for in-class discussions. In effect, students learn how

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 9

to organize their time, prioritize their assignments and get their

homework done.

Hammond (2014) also emphasized the following disadvantages of traditional

teaching methods. Class Size, class discussions become less effective with a class size

greater than 20 students. As the class size grows beyond this point, individual voices

become unheard and the opportunity for the class to get off topic increases. Skilled

teachers begin to notice this problem with fewer than 20 students, but with effective

class management you can hold your class together. Few Dominate, the class

discussion environment allows a few individual students to dominate the class

conversation. This tendency benefits your strongest students, the individuals already

most familiar with the subject. Other students are able to relax into the background

and participate less often in the class discussion. This freedom leads to a relaxation of

their student responsibilities. They are free to assume that they can avoid studying,

reading assignments or individual contemplation of the subject. This problem

escalates as the class size increases. Time Consuming, the nature of class discussion

makes the process very time consuming. The process of exploring a subject, while

keeping students on task in the discussion, requires far more time than classic lecture

style instruction. Short class periods may not be sufficient to accommodate a

complicated subject matter or to fully explore a daily objective. This forces you to

either abridge your lesson plan, leave a subject unfinished or resume the discussion

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 10
11

during another class period in which you had intended to discuss another matter.

Additionally, it is difficult to judge the necessary length for specific issues, making

designing lesson plans very challenging. Off Track, classroom discussions naturally

open avenues for discussion between instructors and students but also between

students and other students. While these discussions are the focus of the class, they

can turn toward areas you do not intend and even move entirely away from the point

of the discussion. While it is possible to redirect an errant conversation back on track,

valuable class time is lost and you risk losing your student's focus on the subject

matter.

Modern Teaching Method

From the last decade the use of high tech equipment in the educational

institutions has increased in a rapid rate. Now there are a lot of modern gadgets which

can be used for improving the teaching in the classroom. Use of LCD projector in the

educational institutions is becoming very common nowadays; this type of teaching is

seen mostly in the higher education institutions which have good infrastructure.

Teacher prepares the power point slides and which are displayed on the LCD screen

with the help of a projector. The projector can also be connected to a laptop/computer

for displaying the relevant videos of the subject on the projector. Use of interactive

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 12

whiteboards in the classroom is very interactive and provides the touch control of the

computer applications. Modern teaching methods create more interest among the

students with the help of interesting animations and videos. Research has shown that

use of visual media for

teaching helps the students to understand the subject better and also helps students to

memorize the concept for longer time. With the help of modern teaching methods

teacher can cover more syllabus in lesser time as they don't have to waste their time in

writing on the blackboard (Thakur 2011).

For any computer assisted teaching strategies, technological support is an

imperative. Ensure that whatever, web-based instructional strategy or software you

intend to use is supported by the technical support of your institution. Both teachers

and student involved in computer enhanced learning activities need to be familiar

with the equipment. Faculty need to have access to appropriate software and the time

and the support to develop expertise with any new software or programs. Specific

computer requirements should be conveyed the students as required so students as

required, so students financial aid can help defray the cost of the

equipments/software or students should have access to computer at school (Bradshaw

2011).

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

Simulations can be classified as computer-based, screen-based, or human-

based. In computer-based simulations, the entire learning process can take place alone

or online with other learners. A computer can direct screen-based simulation, with the

simulation learning process projected onto a large screen. Finally, human-based

simulation includes the use of a mannequin simulator that is directed by a computer.

(Poikela, et.al. 2014)

Although many people still consider traditional universities as the best way to

achieve knowledge and get a diploma, modern teaching method proves to be a great

alternative. Students have the chance to study in their own time and especially for

free. It represents a great way to study many fields and to boost the level of self-

motivation. They say modern teaching method is effective because students can finish

their homework quickly, and there is more time left for hobbies or for finding a job.

An access to all resources of a traditional course helps participants learn wherever

they are, leaving them the freedom to choose the time for study. With basically an

Internet connection, a person can attend different courses. Among the advantages of

modern teaching method there are the responsibility and self-discipline of student. In

this teaching methods, there is also a disadvantages noted that only a small group a

person can develop properly specifically the following: At school, students learn how

to make friends, be patient, get rid of disappointment, and especially to compete.

Competition between colleagues can be very stimulating and students will only

benefit from it. Modern teaching method cannot offer human interaction.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 13

Another disadvantage refers to the fact that modern teaching method cannot cope with

thousands of students that try to join discussions. Also, modern teaching method can

be difficult, if it is meant for disciplines that involve practice (Slavich & Zimbardo,

2012)

E-Learning as a method of modern learning was studied as to the viewpoint of

students experiences. The researcher based on the respondents transcriptions were

able to identified the following composite themes 1) Use of computer technology, 2)

New way of learning, 3) Continuous presentation, 4) Artistic delivery and 5) Lack of

student teaching interaction. (Abalos, 2012)

Students learning

Students can learn to think critically while adequate preparation and active

participation in such activities as case studies and group discussions. Nurse educators

often use case studies to promote critical thinking and thorough exploration of nursing

situations. Critical thinking is the process of searching, obtaining, evaluating,

analyzing, synthesizing and conceptualizing information as a guide for developing

ones thinking with self-awareness, and the ability to use this information by adding

creativity and taking risks.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 14

Traditional teaching method relies mainly on a method that utilizes textbooks,

lecture notes, memorization and recitation techniques. Delivering education through a

traditional format sees no priority in catering to the rich and diverse learner

population or the need to develop critical thinking, problem solving, and decision

making skills, but instead directs learners to assume a non-thinking and information-

receiving role (Parasuman, R. et.al., 2014).

Modern Learning arouses students curiosity and interest (Salandanan, 2012).

Modern teaching methods are commonly known as innovative, and it involves the use

of technology, animation, special effects and is generally learner self-directed and

interactive in nature (Parasuram, R et.al.).

This study was anchored on various models including Learning, Creating, and

Using knowledge: Concept maps as facilitative tools for schools (Novak, 2010) where

in Traditional education is concerned with the teacher being the controller of the

learning environment. Power and responsibility are held by the teacher and they play

the role of instructor and decision maker.

Visual learners prefer to see lecturers actions and facial expressions,

illustrations and often prefer to take down detailed notes to absorb information.

Auditory learners are subdivided into two Listeners. And Talkers they learn best

through listening through what others say. Tactile / Kinesthetic learners prefer hands-

on approach and are characterized by learning by doing. (In a study conducted in a

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 15
16

college of nursing in the Philippines. (Corpuz & Lucas, 2014). Utilizing the VARK

(Visual, Auditory-Read/Write, Kinesthetic or Tactile) learning style model developed

by Neil Fleming. It was found out that majority of their students are predominantly

visual then auditory. (Caguitla, 2013).

Synthesis:

With the given factors in relation to the gathered related literature of both

modern teaching method and traditional teaching method both have its own

advantages and disadvantages. Traditional teaching method provides social interaction

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 17

among the fellow students and teacher which promotes critical thinking, which is

commonly seen in a common classroom based setting where the teacher is controller.

On the other hand, traditional teaching method is time consuming because it requires

a detailed and broader class discussion.

With the technological advances nowadays, access to any information is

already possible by means of internet browsing and computers and other forms of

media devices. It is commonly observed in this generation students are already

equipped and knowledgeable in computer or technical skills and through this it is

more efficient for them to study specially in searching for their projects and home

works. On the contrary, disadvantages of this teaching method lack or limited social

interaction, which is commonly seen in an online study.

Chapter III

Methodology

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 18

Research Design

The study utilized mixed method embedded design, it is a type of research

which is characterized as a scientifically rigorous research project comprising of both

a qualitative or quantitative core component. These supplementary components of the

research fit together to enhance description, understanding or explanation and can be

conducted both simultaneously and sequentially with the core component (Munhall,

2012), A mixed method studies will facilitate features of quantitative (statistics and

objectivity) and qualitative (subjectivity, narration and interpretation) (Cacanindin,

2010; Carpenter and Streubert, 2011; Lacaba-Bago, 2011; Fraenkel, J.R, 2013). An

embedded design is characterized by a design in which the quantitative data is

supported by the qualitative data (Munhall, 2012; Polit and Beck, 2012). The research

design specifically aims to make a comparison between two or more groups

(traditional teaching method and modern teaching method) in one variable (students).

Table 1: Mixed Method

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

SEQUENCE / TIMING
EQUAL
CONCURRENT SEQUENTIAL

P A1:QUAL + QUAN B1: QUAN QUAL

R (Triangulation) QUAL QUAN


Dominant A2: QUAN + qual B2: QUAN qual
I
QUAL + quan quan QUAL
O
Note: (Explanatory design)
T
(Dominant: B3: QUAL quan
I
Capital) qual QUAN
R
Not (Non- Dominant:
T (Exploratory design)
Embedded Small Caps)
Y B4: QUAN (qual)

QUAL (quan)
Embedded A3: QUAN (Qual)
(Embedded
QUAL (Quan) Design)

Adopted from Polit and Beck (2012)

Participants

The study used a combination of purposive and random sampling technique

specifically lottery method. This type of probability sampling technique identified the

participants as they have number slip. The slips are mixed and 12 numbers of

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 19

respondents are chosen. The participants are nursing students regardless of age,

gender, civil status, year level and educational attainment. The purposive part of the

sampling design established criteria like: He/she must be willing to participate in the

study. In this study transferees are not included for maybe the curriculum in their past

school is dissimilar here in our institution.

Settings

The study was conducted at Universal College of Paraaque formerly known

as Universal Colleges of Nursing with a five story building located at 8273 Dr. A.

Santos Avenue, Paraaque City. Mr. Domingo Tay was the founder of Universal

College of Paraaque that was built and established in 2005 this institution caters

multi-disciplinary courses which include Bachelor of Science in Nursing recognized

by Commission on Higher Education (CHED).

Measures

This study used a self-made questionnaire designed specifically for the study

in order to assess the students feedback between the two methods of teaching which

are traditional teaching method and modern teaching method, it is also used to

evaluate the effectiveness of both methods. The self-made questionnaire composes of

three parts. Part I assessed the demographic profile (age, gender, year level,

educational attainment and civil status) of the participants while Part II determined

the students feedback using Likert scale. The 20 items question in Part II objectively

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 20

stated to assess the students feedback by checking the preferred actual score through

Likert Scale which categorize as strongly agree, agree, strongly disagree, and

disagree. Strongly agree means the participants totally agrees to the statement;

Agree means the participants partially approves a point or part of the statement;

Strongly disagree means the participants did not completely believe in the

statement; Disagree means the participants have doubts about the statement. Part III

assessed the perception of the respondents regarding the two methods of teaching.

The questionnaire also subject for validity and reliability. We asked the group of

experts to check and validate the content of the questionnaire and to measure its

reliability using Cronbach Alpha method. Chronbach Alpha is the most commonly

used coefficient ranges from 0 to 1 with a higher coefficient indicating that the items

are consistently measuring the same variable. (Kim, 2014).

Data gathering procedure

Prior to conducting a research the group secured consent to facilitate the study

with the following school officials: College Dean and School Vice President. The self-

made questionnaire was validated by a Filipino teacher who is currently teaching in a

secondary public school and a nursing research coordinator from a university. The

pilot testing was done in the Universal College of Paranaque with students as our

respondents coming from the Bachelor of Science in Nursing in Third year level

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 21

comprised of 6 students. For the actual testing of the study, it was facilitated also in

the Universal College of Paranaque with respondents coming from Bachelor of

Science in Nursing in Second year level with total number 12 students. Modern and

traditional teaching method are both utilized to evaluate which method has greater

impact on students learning in accordance with gathered score in pre-test and post-

test. To test the reliability of the self-made questionnaire in relation to the response of

our respondents in evaluating the effectiveness of both teaching method, the group

made use of Chronbach Alpha with the acceptable range of 0 to 1. The result of

reliability was .949 indicating the tool is reliable. The group tabulated the data of the

following: demographic profile, pre-test and post test scores from both modern and

traditional teaching method and significant statistical data.

Secure Validation of
Pilot
Letter of Self-made
Testing
Consent Question

Actual Chronbach Tabulation


Testing Alpha

Tabulation Data analysis


of actual and
data interpretation

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 22

Statistical Treatment

The t test is one type of inferential statistics. It is used to determine whether

there is a significant difference between the means of two groups which are of interval

or ratio type of data (Polgar, S. & Thomas, S.A., 2013). With all inferential statistics,

we assume the dependent variable fits a normal distribution.

Formula: t-test for Correlational samples

2

D


n


2
D


D
t=

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 23

Where:

D2=t h e of squares of t h e difference between t h e pretestt h e prestest

the post test

D2=the summation of thedifference between the prestest the post test



D=the mean differcne between the pretest the post test

n=the sample s ize

For T-test two independent sample group:

X 1 X 2
t=

( SS1 + SS2
n1+ n22 )( 1 1
+
n 1 n2 )

Where:

t = the t test SS1 = the sum of squares of group 1


X1 = the mean of group 1 SS2 = the sum of squares of group 2

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 24

X2 = the mean of group 2 n1 = the number of observations in group 1

n2 = the number of observations in group 2

( x 1 ) 2 ( x 2 ) 2
SS 1= x 21 SS2= x 21
n1 n2

Chapter IV

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

Analysis and Interpretation

This chapter focused on the results of the data gathered from the participants on

the settings of the study in order to determine the effectiveness of the traditional

teaching method and modern teaching method among nursing student.

To answer major problem number 1, Frequency distribution was used.

Demographic Profile of the Respondents

In determining the effectiveness of teaching using the traditional and modern

teaching method the researcher includes the demographic profile of the participants in

terms of gender, age, civil status and educational attainment. As shown in a table

below most of the respondents are Female with the percentages of 83% while Male is

17%. Majority of the respondents belong in the age bracket of 15-20 years old which

yielded a percentage of 42% and a frequency of 5 students, while 25 % of our

respondents belong to 26-30 years old or equivalent to 3 students. Moreover, there is

8% of the respondent belonging to the 31-45 years old and 8% under the age bracket

of 36-40 years old. It also indicated below that 92% of the respondents are single and

the remaining 8% is married. In regards to educational attainments, most of the

respondents belong to college undergraduate level with a total of 75% while the

remaining 25% is in second courser category.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 25
26

Table 1:
Demographic Profile of the Participants

Profile Frequency Percentage


Gender
Female 10 83%
Male 2 17%
Total 12 100%
Age
15-20 5 42%
21-25 2 17%
26-30 3 25%
31-35 1 8%
36-40 1 8%
Total 12 100%
Civil Status
Single 11 92%
Married 1 8%
Total 12 100%
Educational Attainment
College Undergraduate 9 75%
Second Courser 3 25%
Total 12 100%

2. To answer problem no. 2: The significant difference between traditional and

modern teaching methods. Descriptive statistics such as Mean and Frequency

distribution was used.

2.1 Pre-test

The table shows that traditional teaching method is most eminent than modern

teaching method

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 27

No. of Students Pre-test PD Pre-test HD


(traditional teaching method) (modern teaching method)
1 2 2
2 3 3
3 3 3
4 4 3
5 4 3
6 4 4
7 4 5
8 5 5
9 5 5
10 5 5
11 5 5
12 8 6
TOTAL 52 49
MEAN 4.3333 4.0833
2.2 Post-test

The table shows that traditional teaching method has a higher score compare to

modern teaching method.

No. of Students Post-test PD Post-test HD


(traditional teaching method) (modern teaching method)

1 8 4
2 8 6
3 8 6
4 8 7
5 8 7
6 9 8
7 9 8
8 9 9
9 10 9
10 10 9
11 10 9
12 10 9
TOTAL 107 91
MEAN 8.9167 7.5833

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 28

According to the tabulated data of scores from the pre-test and posttest of both

teaching methods, the result gathered indicates that traditional teaching method has a

higher results compare to the scores of modern teaching method.

3. To answer major problem no. 3, the independent T-test and Qualitative analysis

of the transcription will be used.

3.1 Traditional teaching method

Base on the data gathered, half of the students choose traditional teaching with

the following reasons; easily understood, efficient note taking, detailed content,

facilitates learning through auditory means, provide better explanation and slow

delivery of content, on the contrary half of the student find out that this method, the

presentation is boring and aside from that there is a lack of visual aids or tools thus

the students need to take down notes that causes hand sore, and lastly the pace and the

delivery of information presentation is slow.

According to Thakur 2011, Traditional teaching method is cheaper than the

modern teaching methods which make it more suitable in the schools of rural areas.

There is more interaction between the teacher and student in traditional teaching

methods as compared to the modern teaching method. Therefore traditional teaching

method facilitates interaction between the students and the professor.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 29

Respondents breakdown of answers (Traditional Learning)

Question No. 1

The method facilitates retention of information.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay madali kong natatandaan ang mga impormasyon sa

paksa na tinatalakay.)

Question No. 1 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%
3 (Agree) 4 33%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that 67% of the respondents strongly agree and 33% of

them agree that using Traditional Teaching Method helps them to retain the

information being discussed.

Question No. 2

The method helps me to understand difficult content

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 31
30

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang maintindihan ko ang mahihirap na

nilalaman.)

Question No. 2 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The result above indicates that 75% of the respondent strongly agrees that

using Traditional Teaching Method will help them to understand difficult content with

the topic discussed while 25% of them agree.

Question No. 3

The content of the topic explains well using the method.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay naipaliwanag ng maayos ang mga nilalaman ng paksa.)

Question No. 3 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The result above shows that 75% of the respondents strongly agree that the

content of the topic explains well using Traditional Teaching Method, while the 25%

of them agree.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 32

Question No. 4

The content is arranged in a clear, logical and orderly manner.

(Ang nilalaman ay naayos ng malinaw, lohical at tamang paraan.)

Question No. 4 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%
3 (Agree) 4 33 %
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that the arrangement of content is clear, logical and

orderly manner using Traditional Teaching Method. Majority of the respondents

strongly agree, with the total percentage of 67% while the rest choose to agree with

the percentage of 33%.

Question No. 5

The materials used are adequate to the topic being discussed.

(Ang mga materyales na ginamit sa pagtuturo ay sapat para sa paksa na tinatalakay.)

Question No. 5 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25 %
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 33

The results shows that the materials used are adequate to the topic discussed

using Traditional Teaching Method, 75% of respondents strongly agree and 25%

agree.

Question No. 6

The content of the topic was consistent with the course objectives.

(Ang nilalaman ng paksa ay alinsunod sa layunin ng kurso.)

Question No. 6 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 10 83%
3 (Agree) 2 17%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

In the table above shows 83% of the respondents strongly agree and 17%

agree that the content of the topic was consistent with the course objectives using

Modern Teaching Method.

Question No. 7

The method helps me to become more comfortable in my study.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas maging komportable ako sa

aking pag aaral.)

Question No. 7 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
34
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

3 (Agree) 4 33 %
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The results above indicate that 67% of the respondents strongly agree and

33% agree that Traditional Teaching Method helps them to be more comfortable in

their study.

Question No. 8

The method covers all the details of the topic that should be discussed.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nasasakop lahat ng detalye na kailangang ituro.)

Question No. 8 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%
3 (Agree) 4 33 %
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that most of the respondents strongly agree with the

percentage of 67%, that using Traditional Teaching Method covers all the details of

the topic discussed. And remaining 33% of the respondents agree.

Question No. 9

The method catches my attention to focus on the topic being discussed.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 35

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nabibigyang atensyon upang mag pokus sa paksa.)

Question No. 9 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 6 50%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that there were 50% strongly agree and 50% agree that

the method used catch their attention to focus on the topic using Traditional Teaching

Method.

Question No. 10

The method helps me to explore and stimulates my thinking capacity.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mahasa o mapalawak ang aking

kaisipan.)

Question No. 10 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%
3 (Agree) 4 33%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that 67% strongly agree and 33 % agree that Traditional

Teaching Method helps them to explore and stimulate their thinking capacity.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 36

Question No. 11

The method covers most of the details you expected to be discussed.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nasasakop ang karamihang detalye na inaasahan kong

maituro.)

Question No. 11 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 7 58%
3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that 58 % strongly agreed and 42% of the respondents agree

that using this method, most of the details they expected to be discussed was covered.

Question No. 12

The material used is/are appropriate to the topic being discussed.

(Ang mga materyales na ginamit sa pagtuturo ay angkop sa paksamg tinatalakay.)

Question No. 12 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above indicates that 75% strongly agree and 25% agree that the

material used is appropriate to the topic discussed using Traditional Teaching Method.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 38
37

Question No. 13

The method helps me to be more confident in my study.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas madagdagan ang kumpyansa

ko sa aking pag-aaral.)

Question No. 13 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The result above shows 75% strongly agree and 25% agree that using

Traditional Teaching Method helps them to boost their confidence in their study.

Question No. 14

The method helps me to improve my potential in my learning capabilities.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mapahusay ang aking potensyal na

kakayahan sa aking pag-aaral.)

Question No. 14 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 7 58%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 39

3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

This table shows that 58% of the respondents strongly agree and 42% agree

that Traditional Teaching Method helps them to improve their potential in learning

capabilities.

Question No. 15

The method helps me to enhance my creativity and resourcefulness to make my

learning easier.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nahahasa ang aking pagka malikhain at kaparaanan

upang mas mapadali ang aking pag-aaral)

Question No. 15 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 6 50%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 40

The table above shows that 50% strongly agree and 50% agree that modern

teaching method is effective in enhancing their creativity and resourcefulness to make

their learning easier.

Question No. 16

The method provides sufficient information about the topic.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakapagbibigay ng sapat na impormasyon ayon sa

paksa.)

Question No. 16 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that 75% of the respondents strongly agree and 25%

agree that using Traditional Teaching Method provides sufficient information about

the topic.

Question No. 17

The method helps me to make learning more interesting.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 41

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang maging interesado ako sa aking

pag aaral.)

Question No. 17 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The results above indicates that 75% of the respondents strongly agree while

25% agree, that using modern teaching method helps them to make their learning

more interesting.

Question No. 18

The method helps me to easily understand the topic being discussed.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas madali kong maunawaan ang

paksamg tinatalakay.)

Question No. 18 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%
3 (Agree) 4 33%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 42

The table shows that 67% of the respondents strongly agree and 33% agree,

that using Traditional Teaching Method helps them to easily understand the topic

being discussed.

Question No. 19

The method helps me to improve my critical thinking.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas mahasa pa ang aking kaisipan

sa pag aaral.)

Question No. 19 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 6 50%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that 50% of the respondents strongly agree and 50% agree

that the method used helps them to improve their critical thinking.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 43

Question No. 20

It helps me to become more motivated in my study.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang lalong ganahan akong mag aral.)

Question No. 20 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 6 50%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that 50% strongly agree and 50% agree, therefore it

shows that the method used helps them to become more motivated in their study.

3.2 Modern teaching method

Based on the data gathered, half of students choose modern teaching method

with the following reasons; easily accessible through internet, easily understood, clear

visual presentation, easier to study, availability of the resources through internet,

research focus, broad content, realistic visual aids, visually stimulating, accessibility

of hand-outs and on the contrary some of them find out this method time consuming,

fast pacing, uninteresting in technological learning tools and lastly the dependency on

hand-outs.

Modern teaching method proves to be a great alternative. Students have the

chance to study in their own time and especially for free. It represents a great way to

study many fields and to boost the level of self-motivation. Hence, Modern teaching

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 44

method encourages the student to participate to the discussion using computer

presentation such as video clips and power point, moreover the theory Modern

teaching method proves to be a great alternative and a viable option as a part a

teaching method (Torcedo NNT, 2013). Students have the chance to study in their

own time and especially for free. It represents a great way to study many fields and to

boost the level of self-motivation. Thus, Video presentation seems to be a viable

teaching option. (Torcedo NNT, 2013) and modern teaching method enhances the

creativity of the students when it comes to their study.

Question No. 1

The method facilitates retention of information.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay madali kong natatandaan ang mga impormasyon sa

paksa na tinatalakay.)

Question No. 1 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 1 8%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 45

The table above shows that half of the respondents with the percentage of 50%

strongly agree that using Modern Teaching Method can help them to retain the

information being discussed. On the other hand five of them agree and the one of

them disagree.

Question No. 2

The method helps me to understand difficult content

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang maintindihan ko ang mahihirap na

nilalaman.)

Question No. 2 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 7 58%
3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The results above indicate that 58% strongly agree that using Modern

Teaching Method will help them to understand difficult content with the topic

discussed and 42% of them agree.

Question No. 3

The content of the topic explains well using the method.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 46

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay naipaliwanag ng maayos ang mga nilalaman ng paksa.)

Question No. 3 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 7 58%
3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The results above shows that, the content of the topic explains well, using the

Modern Teaching Method, in which the respondents strongly agree with the

percentage of 58% in contrary 42% of them agree.

Question No. 4

The content is arranged in a clear, logical and orderly manner.

(Ang nilalaman ay naayos ng malinaw, lohical at tamang paraan.)

Question No. 4 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%
3 (Agree) 4 33 %
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that the arrangement of content is clear, logical and

orderly manner using Modern Teaching Method. Majority of the respondents strongly

agree, with the total percentage of 67% while the rest choose to agree with the

percentage of 47%.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 47

Question No. 5

The materials used are adequate to the topic being discussed.

(Ang mga materyales na ginamit sa pagtuturo ay sapat para sa paksa na tinatalakay.)

Question No. 5 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 6 50 %
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The results shows that the materials used are adequate to the topic discussed

using Modern Teaching Method, 50% of respondents strongly agree and 50% agree.

Question No. 6

The content of the topic was consistent with the course objectives.

(Ang nilalaman ng paksa ay alinsunod sa layunin ng kurso.)

Question No. 6 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 7 58.3%
3 (Agree) 4 33.3%
2 (Disagree) 1 8.3%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 49
48

In the table above 58.3% of the respondents strongly agree that the content of

the topic was consistent with the course objectives using Modern Teaching Method,

while 33.3% agree and 8.3% disagree.

Question No. 7

The method helps me to become more comfortable in my study.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas maging komportable ako sa

aking pag aaral.)

Question No. 7 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 5 42 %
2 (Disagree) 1 8%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The results above indicate that 50% of the respondents strongly agree that

Modern Teaching Method helps them to be more comfortable in studying while 42%

agree, in contrary 8% disagree.

Question No. 8

The method covers all the details of the topic that should be discussed.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nasasakop lahat ng detalye na kailangang ituro.)

Question No. 8 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 50

3 (Agree) 4 33 %
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that most of the respondents strongly agree with the

percentage of 67%, that using Modern Teaching Method covers all the details of the

topic discussed. And remaining 33% of the respondents agree.

Question No. 9

The method catches my attention to focus on the topic being discussed.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nabibigyang atensyon upang mag pokus sa paksa.)

Question No. 9 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 1 8%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that there were 50% strongly agree and 42% agree that

the method used catch their attention to focus on the topic using Modern Teaching

Method. However 8% of the respondent disagrees.

Question No. 10

The method helps me to explore and stimulates my thinking capacity.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 51

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mahasa o mapalawak ang aking

kaisipan.)

Question No. 10 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 ( Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that 75% strongly agree and 25 % agree that Modern

Teaching Method helps them to explore and stimulate their thinking capacity.

Question No. 11

The method covers most of the details you expected to be discussed.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nasasakop ang karamihang detalye na inaasahan kong

maituro.)

Question No. 11 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 5 42%
3 (Agree) 7 58%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that 42 % strongly agreed and 58% of the respondents agree

that using this method most of the details they expected to be discussed was covered.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 52

Question No. 12

The materials used is/are appropriate to the topic being discussed.

(Ang mga materyales na ginamit sa pagtuturo ay angkop sa paksamg tinatalakay.)

Question No. 12 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 3 25%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above indicates that 75% strongly agree and 25% agree that the

material used is appropriate to the topic discussed using Modern Teaching Method.

Question No. 13

The method helps me to be more confident in my study.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas madagdagan ang kumpyansa

ko sa aking pag-aaral)

Question No. 13 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 6 50%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The result above shows 50% strongly agree and 50% agree that using Modern

Teaching Method helps them to boost their confidence in their study.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 53

Question No. 14

The method helps me to improve my potential in my learning capabilities.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mapahusay ang aking potensyal na

kakayahan sa aking pag-aaral.)

Question No. 14 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 4 33%
3 (Agree) 8 67%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

This table shows that mostly of the respondents agree with the total percentage

of 67% while 33% strongly agree that Modern Teaching Method helps them to

improve their potential in learning capabilities.

Question No. 15

The method helps me to enhance my creativity and resourcefulness to make my

learning easier. (Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nahahasa ang aking pagka malikhain at

kaparaanan upang mas mapadali ang aking pag-aaral)

Question No. 15 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 54

3 (Agree) 2 17%
2 (Disagree) 1 8%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%
The table above shows that 75% strongly agree that modern teaching method

is effective in enhancing their creativity and resourcefulness to make their learning

easier.17% of the respondents agree while 8% disagree.

Question No. 16

The method provides sufficient information about the topic.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakapagbibigay ng sapat na impormasyon ayon sa

paksa.)

Question No. 16 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 6 50%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table above shows that 50% of the respondents strongly agree and 50%

agree that using Modern Teaching Method provides sufficient information about the

topic.

Question No. 17

The method helps me to make learning more interesting.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
56
55
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang maging interesado ako sa aking

pag aaral.)

Question No. 17 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 9 75%
3 (Agree) 2 17%
2 (Disagree) 1 8%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The results above indicates that 75% of the respondents strongly agree and

17% agree, that using modern teaching method helps them to make their learning

more interesting, however 8% disagree.

Question No. 18

The method helps me to easily understand the topic being discussed.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas madali kong maunawaan ang

paksamg tinatalakay.)

Question No. 18 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 6 50%
3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 1 8%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%
The table shows that 50% of the respondents strongly agree and 42% agree,

that using Modern Teaching Method helps them to easily understand the topic being

discussed, while 8% disagree.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 57

Question No. 19

The method helps me to improve my critical thinking.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang mas mahasa pa ang aking kaisipan

sa pag aaral.)

Question No. 19 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 7 58%
3 (Agree) 5 42%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

The table shows that 58% of the respondents strongly agree and 42% agree

that the method used helps them to improve their critical thinking.

Question No. 20

It helps me to become more motivated in my study.

(Ang paraan ng pagtuturo ay nakatutulong upang lalong ganahan akong mag aral.)

Question No. 20 Frequency Percentage


4 ( Strongly agree ) 8 67%
3 (Agree) 4 33%
2 (Disagree) 0 0%
1 (Strongly disagree) 0 0%
Total 12 100%

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

The table above shows that 67% strongly agree and 33% agree, therefore it

shows that the method used helps them to become more motivated in their study.

Computation: (traditional)

D = -55

D2= 3025

D = -4.5833

2

55


n


30252

4.5833
t=

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 58

2

55


12


2
3025

4.5833
t=

4.5833
t=
9150625252.083
12 ( 11 )

4.5833
t=

9150625
132
( 3025 )
12

4.5833
t=
3150372.92
132

4.5833
t= 23866.4615

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
59
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

4.5833
t=
154.4977

= 0.0315

Computation: (modern)

D = -39

D2= 1521

D = -3.25

2
39

12


15212

3.25
t=

3.25
t=

2313441
12(11)
1521
12

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

3.25
t=
2313441126.75
132

3.25
t=
2313341.25
132

3.25
t=
17525.108

3.25
t=
132.3824

= -0.02455

( 71.0002 ) 2
SS 1=252.3486
12

(732510 ) 2
SS 2=286.5004
12

SS 1=252.3486420.0859 SS 1=5004447.1424

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 60

SS 1=167.737 SS 1=160.642

3.55001 366255
t=

( 167.7371+160.642
12+122 )( 1 1
12 12 )
+

0.11254
t=

( 328.379
22 ) ( 0.083+0.083 )

0.11254
t=

( 328.379
22 ) ( 0.083+0.083 )
0.11254
t=
(14.9263 ) ( 0.166 )

0.011254
t=
(14.9263 ) ( 0.166 )

0.011254
t=
2.4778

0.011254
t=
1.5741

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE 61

t=0.072 - COMPUTED VALUE

t=1.77TABULATEDVALUE

To facilitate qualitative analysis transcription of data. Pseudostatistic was

used. Pseudostatistics is a method wherein themes are identified and its frequency

among the respondents are tabulated (Munhall, 2012; Polit and Beck, 2012)

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
62
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

Pseudostatistics: Traditional Method

Traditional Total Traditional Total

Advantages Disadvantages
Easily understood 3 Lack of visual aids/tools 2
Efficient note taking 6 Slow delivery of content 3
detailed content 2 Pace of information 1

presentation
Facilitates learning 2 Boring presentation 1

through auditory

means
Provide better Prolong writing notes causes

explanation 2 hand sore 1


Slow delivery content 1

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
64
63
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

Pseudostatistics: Modern Method

Modern Total Modern Total

Advantages Disadvantages
Easily understood 2 Fast pacing 4
Easily 3 Uninterested in technological 1

accessible(internet) learning tools


Clear visual 2 Time consuming 1

presentation
Easier to study 1 Dependency on hand-outs 1
Availability of 2

resources(internet)
Research focus 1
Broad content 1
Realistic visual aids 1
Visual stimulating 1
Accessibility of 1

handouts

The themes explored and explained in this study is limited to 4 which consists

of the main advantage and disadvantage for both Traditional and Modern teaching. An

excerpt of the response of the student is listed below.

Efficient Note Taking (Traditional method main advantage)

Traditional kasi mas medaling maintindihan kasi detalyado tapos mas madaling

intindihin kasi sinusulat mu, as verbalized by S4

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
65
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

Slow delivery of Content (Traditional method main disadvantage)

Manual kasi siya kaya mabagal, as verbalized by S3

Easily accessible (Modern method main advantage)

mas mabilis siyang gamitin, as verbalized by S3

Fast Phasing (Modern method main disadvantage)

mabilis kaya mahirap intindihin, as verbalized by S2

The themes identified are due to a variety of factors. Learning-Centered

Principles like Cognitive & Metacognitive factors, Motivational and Affective factors,

Developmental and social factors and individual differences factors. The variety of

factors seen in the Pseudostatistics is primarily due to the thinking / learning style and

the diversity (aptitudes, attitudes and behaviors). (Corpuz & Lucas, 2014)

CHAPTER V

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
66
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

Summary of Findings

This chapter focuses on the results of the data gathered from the participants at the

setting of the study in order to determine the effectiveness of traditional and modern

teaching method among nursing students.

1. The significant relationship of demographic profile in terms of


1.1 Most of the participants are female 83% (10); male 17% (2).
1.2 Most of the respondents 42% (5) belong to 15-20 years old;17% (2) belong to

the age bracket of 21-25 ; 25% (3) belong to 26-30; 8% (1) range in 31-35;

8% (1) 36-40 years old.


1.3 Most of the respondents are single 92 % (11); 8 % (1) married.
1.4 75 % (9) of the respondents are college undergraduate; 25 % (3) are second

courser.
2. The overall mean of the pre-test and post-test of traditional and modern teaching

method:
2.1 Pre-test

2.1a Traditional teaching method (4.3333)

2.1b Modern teaching method (4.0833)

2.2 post-test

2.2a Traditional teaching method (8.9167)

2.2b Modern teaching method (7.5833)

3. The overall mean of perception of the respondents using quantitative in terms of:
3.1 Traditional teaching method (3.6625)
3.2 Modern teaching method (3.5500)

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
67
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

4. The perception of the respondents using qualitative in terms of:


4.1 Traditional teaching method
4.1a Main Advantage efficient note taking 50% (6)
4.1b Main Disadvantage slow delivery of content 25% (3)
4.2 Modern teaching method
4.2a Main Advantage easily accessible (e.g. internet) 25% (3)
4.2b Main Disadvantage fast pacing 33% (4)

Our study utilized the t-test for correlational sample to compare the means of

pretest and post test scores or result of both teaching method. The t-test for correlated

samples result of traditional teaching method is 0.0315 while for modern traditional

teaching method is 0.02455 which indicates that there is no significant difference in

the learning process of the nursing student between the traditional and modern

teaching method. There is no perfect method for all learners in all setting (Bastable,

2011)

Conclusion:

Based on the findings this study concluded as follows:

1. There is no significant difference in the learning process of the student

between the traditional and modern teaching method.


2. Based on the transcribed interview the advantage of traditional teaching

method appears that most of the student perceived that the method facilitates

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
68
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

efficient note taking. On the other hand the student states that the said method

is slow in terms of delivering of content.


3. Based on the transcribed interview the modern teaching method help the

student to be more active in terms of visual stimulation that results to increase

in class participation. While the disadvantage is fast phase of lecture that made

the students difficult to follow the flow of the discussion.

Recommendations:

Based on the result of the study the researcher would like to recommend the

following:

Nursing educators to gauge which teaching method that is effective to learning

process of the students.

Nursing Deans and coordinators to formulate a framework for assessment,

monitoring and evaluation of students that is specific to their learning needs.

Nursing students encourage the student to participate on this research in order to

evaluate what kind of teaching method they can easily comprehend.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque
UNIVERSAL COLLEGES OF PARAAQUE

Future researcher to increase the number of respondents for more reliable result

and integrate the learning style of the students as to being Visual, Auditory and

Kinetic learners.

Traditional Teaching Method vs. Modern Teaching Method:


Effectiveness among nursing student in Universal College of
Paraaque

You might also like