Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TRAGIC CHORUSMEN
IN TARANTO AND ATHENS
ESTRATTO DA:
Rivista di antichita
Anno XXI- n. 1-2- Gennaio-Dicembre 2012
A piece of funerary relief sculpture is a hitherto un- hand held some form of staff. The object held in the left
recognised item of evidence for theatre performance in hand is critical to the interpretation, and I shall argue
Taranto (Fig. 1)111. It is carved in the normal pale, close- that it is a mask.
grained limestone used at Taranto (pietra tenera) and In publishing it in 1975, Carter pointed out that the
must have decorated a metope of a naiskosl21. Much of subject was 'not obvious'. In exploring the possibilities,
the upper part, including the figure's head, is missing, he took the figure as that of a female, and so far as the
as is the right edge. The bottom, too, is damaged: the clothing is concerned, one can see why. Since then,
preserved left edge gives the true line. Given the small however, other pieces and other issues have come to
size, the quality of the carving is good, with quite fine light. One thinks, for example, of the on-going discus-
detail. There seem to be traces of reddish paint surviv- sion of the so-called Piraeus relief, Athens NM 1500
ing in the area of the left waist. The figure had the (Fig. 2), with its group of figures in female costume and
weight on the left leg while the right is relaxed and bent carrying masks, as they stand before a reclining figure,
at the knee, as is emphasised by the fall of the drapery. surely Dionysos, and his female partner; the figures are
The garment is tied in high-waisted fashion. The right coming to be recognised as representing a group of cho-
rusmen after a successful performance, and they doubt-
less stand for the whole chorus131. The relief must date
to about 400 BC.
155
fohn Richard Green
156
Tragic Chorusmen in Taranto and Athens
The choice of a young man's participation in a chorus 5)191. On the left is a young man being crowned with a
as a way of commemorating him must have carried con- wreath by Nike who at the same time carries a phiale.
siderable resonance. For one thing the event must have The young man carries a mask, surely again type 55,
come at some cost to the family in terms of the time and and it identifies him as a member of a chorus that had
effort involved for the young man in the learning, the been successful in the competitions. He has some dra-
practice and the training in the music, the words and the pery over his left arm and he holds it away from his
dance in the tragedy or group of tragediesl 71. It must body with his right hand in a way that Trendall saw as
have taken him away from other activities for consider- characteristic of this early phase of his work. A young
able periods of time, and, in cases in which the family pan is shown on the far right, as an onlooker. One sus-
was not particularly wealthy, this must have meant pe- pects that he finds the young man attractive and that
riods in which he was not contributing to the family's this is why he carries a bird in his hand, as a love-gift. It
income. In other words it must have had material as also tells us something of the perceived age of the young
well as emotional significance in the life of the family man1101. The setting, as the tendril with its acanthus leaf
that was now commemorating his passing. It was also of
significance to the family's public face. If he could have
been thought to have performed well, he brought credit 171 On training for tragic chorus, see Wilson 2007, as well as his earlier
to the family on a major public occasion, in front of the piece (Wilson 2000) which presents a useful and persuasive over-
assembled community of families, and even more so if view of the context of Athenian drama in terms of its audience, its
function and its societal setting.
the tragedy had been successful in the competition. rsr See Csapo 2010, 40-52, and Green 2012, written independently and
much delayed in publication.
Recognition of the scene on this relief gives added IJ London 1836.2-24.175 (F 163), said to be from Apulia. Moon 1929,
significance to some images created by the Tarporley pl. 13; Borda 1966,42 fig. 32; Trendall1976 pl. 6b; RVAp I, 47, n. 3/12.
M. C. Tzannes (Tzannes 1997) has useful things to say on this series
Painter in Taranto in the earlier part of his career, near in general.
the beginning of the fourth century181. They include first llOl One notices that he is less well muscled even than the Eros of the
and foremost his bell-krater in the British Museum (Fig. painter's skyphos in the British Museum 1867.5-8.1175 (F 126), RVAp
157
fohn Richard Green
I. ..
158
Tragic Chorusmen in Taranto and Athens
159
John Richard Green
160
Tragic Chorusmen in Taranto and Athens
nomos Painter and his circle which concentrate on the Tarentine, and that it should be only a metope, that is
happiness of successful performers as they join Dionys- one of a series of images rather than a principal image,
os in his sanctuary. Choregic art, at least in vase-paint- implies that it was regarded as just one of the attributes
ing, sits alongside a broader interest at this period in of this well-to-do young man. The iconography must
depicting contests, whether racers in the lampadedro- have been understood. Similarly, thanks to David Jor-
mia, pyrrhicists, participants in musical events or the dan and Peter Wilson, we now seem to have evidence
like. Many of them place emphasis on the young, as can for choruses of local young men in Sicily, probably in
often happen in times of community stress such as Ath- Gela1 231. It looks as if this question is moving towards a
ens was enduring at the time; but that leads into bigger conclusion: communities in the major centres in South
questions than we can deal with here. Italy and Sicily were happy to commit themselves to
participation in the production of imported plays rather
Moving in a slightly different if parallel direction, we than simply pay for visitors to do it. Indeed they were
may call to mind the statue group Athens NM 257, eager to do so if we can judge from the speed with
found in the area of the Theatre of Dionysos in 1832119 1. which Euripides' Heracleidae, Cyclops and Antiope ap-
Although most likely to date to the second century Be, peared in the West1 24 1.
it is generally agreed to copy an original of the later part
of the fifth century1201. The papposilenos carries the To come back to the metope from Taranto, there are
young Dionysos on his shoulder, and he in turn holds some serious issues of chronology. Carter places the
over his guardian's other shoulder the mask with which piece in his Group F which he dates to approximately
we are now familiar, Mask SS with its long hair. It fore- 320-300 Be. The fashion for naiskoi with metopes in the
shadows the way that Dionysos holds it on Apulian podium appears in Tarentine vase-painting from about
vases. It again must represent Tragedy through the 360 BC in the circle of the Lycurgus and lliupersis Paint-
characteristic chorus-type, demonstrating that the equa- ers and it is reasonable to suppose that they emerged
tion already existed by this date. slightly earlier in actualityl 251. A good depiction is to be
found on on a volute-krater from Ruvo that Trendall
We cannot know if the young man of the Taranto re- thought close to the lliupersis Painter in style (Fig. 9)
lief was performing in a tragedy (or set of tragedies) and it shows figured reliefs in the metopesl 261. Another
written locally or in, say, Athens. It is nonetheless im-
portant to be aware that participation in a tragic chorus
1191 Kaltsas 2002, 119 n . 217 (with earlier bibI.); Kaltsas 2004,296 n. 174
was a recognised activity for a young man in Taranto in (Eleni Kourinou-Pikoula; colour ill.).
the earlier part of the fourth century. 1201Kaltsas suggests about 440-430 B.C., but that may be a fraction too
early. Webster thought of it as of the early fourth century.
There has of course been a lot of work recently on the 1211Allan 2001; Dearden 2002, 183-196; Denoyelle 2002, 104-112; East-
performance of Athenian tragedy in the west in the erling 1994; Nafissi 1997; Sourvinou-Inwood 2003, 40-45; Taplin 1999
and now (Taplin 2012) esp . at p. 240. Note also my own comments
years before the end of the fifth century. One thinks of, (Green 2008).
among others, the articles of Allan, Dearden, Denoyelle, 1221 One should not, however, ignore the significant contribution of
Easterling, Nafissi, Sourvinou-Inwood and Taplin1211. Dearden 1999. It includes thorough discussion of these issues.
What has been less clear and received less attention has 1231Jordan 2007, 335-350, and in the same volume, Wilson 2007.
121 On these, see especially Allan (Allan 2001) and Taplin (Taplin
been the circumstances of production in southern Italy 1999), (Taplin 2012).
and Sicily. Did the troupes that carried the plays, their 1251 It is interesting that they appear at about the same time in Luca-
masks and costumes take young Athenian chorusmen nian: see the amphora of panathenaic type decorated by the Prima to
with them? Were, indeed, all the troupes and possible Painter, Berlin 3155, LCS 165/ 920. Lohmann 1979, L 3, pl. 13, 2. At 45
chorusmen Athenian? How were the troupes and their n. 331 he gives a useful list of representations of naiskoi with metopes
on the podium.
performances funded?l 221 Our metope almost certainly 1261 London 1856.12-26.2 (F 276), from Ruvo, RVAp I, 7 /102b, Lohm-
demonstrates that at least one chorusman was a native ann 1979, A 333, pl. 38, 2. There is now a large bibliography on naiskoi,
161
fohn Richard Green
argument in favour of a higher dating is the fact that the and especially on representations of them in vase-painting. From an
motif seems to have had only a limited life. In Attica it architectural perspective, the major point of reference is now Lippo-
occurs from the late fifth century down to about 380-370 lis 2007. There is also a perceptive overview by Mertens 2002, esp.
339-342. Pagenstecher 1912 is still worth consulting. On representa-
(Vari)[271. In Taranto it belongs in the early work of the tions of them, see inter alios Lohmann 1979 and Brandes-Druba 1994.
Tarporley Painter but not later; it disappears very early On their sculpture, most notably in the years after Carter, Lippolis
in the fourth century. 1994.
1271 For this purpose we can leave the Copenhagen relief out of ac-
count. Apart from the fact that there must have been another figure,
In conclusion our young man in Taranto raises a
the young man lets the mask hang down in his left hand, near his leg:
number of issues. First he helps bring attention to a he does not hold it before his eyes. It is also unclear whether the re-
motif that was popular for a limited period at the tum lief was funerary or votive. Copenhagen NCG, I.N. 465, said to be
of the fifth and fourth centuries. It seems to have origi- from Athens, e.g. Webster 1956, n. A 20, pl. 9; Bryld 1984, 63 (ill.);
nated in Athens within a larger iconography centred Green 1994, 157-8 n. 167; Moltesen 1995, n . 72 (ill.) and front cover
(detail, colour); Scholl1995, esp. 233 fig. 16; Scholl1996 335, n. 420,
on dramatic choruses in both sculpture and vase-paint- pl. 21.4; Micheli 1998, 3, fig. 2; Froning 2002, 76 fig. 96. It is usually
ing[281. It occurred at a period of growing emphasis on dated ca 330-320 B.C., but could be somewhat later.
the young as well as a period at which community in- 1281 See especially the first two chapters in Csapo 2010b.
162
Tragic Chorusmen in Taranto and Athens
163
fohn Richard Green
Greci in Occidente. Arte e artigianato in Magna Grecia, Napoli eines Eroskultes in der italischen Vasenmalerei, in BABesch
1996, 87-93. XLV, 1970, 86-117.
Lippolis 2007 = E. Lippolis, Tipologie e significati del monumen- Scholl1995 =A Scholl, Nicht Aristophanes, sondern Epigenes. Das
to funerario nella cittii ellenistica. Lo sviluppo del naiskos, in C. Lyme-Park-Relief und die Darstellung von Dichtern und Schau-
G. Malacrino, E. Sorbo (edd.), Architetti, architettura e cittii spielern aufattischen Grabdenkmiilern, in JdAI CX, 1995, 213-238.
nel Mediterraneo antico, Milano 2007, 80-100. Scholl1996 =A Scholl, Die attischen Bildfeldstelen des 4. ]hs. v.
Lissarrague 2008 = F. Lissarrague, Image and Representation in Chr., in MDAI(A), Beiheft XVll, 1996.
the Pottery of Magna Graecia, in M. Revermann, P. Wilson Slater 1985 = N.W. Slater, Vanished Players: Two Classical Reliefs
(edd.), Performance, Iconography, Reception: Studies in Hon- and Theatre History, in GRBS XXVI, 1985, 333-344.
our of Oliver Taplin, Oxford 2008, 439-449. Sourvinou-Inwood 2003 = C. Sourvinou-Inwood, Tragedy and
Lohmann 1979 =H. Lohmann, Grabmiiler auf unteritalienischen Athenian Religion, Lanham, Md 2003.
Vasen, Berlin 1979. Steinhauer 1998 =G. Steinhauer, Ta Mnemeia kai to Archaiologiko
Mastrokostas 1966 = E. I. Mastrokostas, "'Emanjj.Jam be Mouseio tou Peiraia, Athens 1998.
Mvpptvovvm;", in Xaptcm1pwv de; 'A.K. 'OpA.avoov, III, Stupperich 1977 = R. Stupperich, Staatsbegriibnis und Privat-
Athens 1966, 281-299. grabmal im Klassischen Athen, Diss., Miinster 1977.
Mertens 2002 =D. Mertens, Taranto. L'architettura. Un aggior- Siisserott 1938 =H. K. Siisserott, Griechische Plastik des 4. Jahr-
namento, in Atti XLI Conv. Studi Magna Grecia (Atti Con- hunderts vor Christus, Frankfurt 1938.
vegno Taranto 2001) Napoli 2002,331-342. Svoronos 1911 = J. N. Svoronos, Das Athener Nationalmuseum,
Micheli 1998 = M. E. Micheli, Rilievi con maschere, attori, poeti. II, Athens 1911.
Temi di genere e/o ispirazione poetica?, in BdA LXXXIII, 1998, Taplin 1999 = 0. Taplin, Spreading the Word through Perform-
nn. 103-4, 1-32. ance, inS. Goldhill, R. Osborne (edd.), Performance Culture
Moltesen 1995 = M. Moltesen, Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek: Katalog. and Athenian Democracy, Cambridge 1999, 33-57.
Gr<Ekenland i klassisk tid, Copenhagen 1995. Taplin 2012 = 0. Taplin, How Was Athenian Tragedy Played in
Moon 1929 = N.R. Moon, Some Early South Italian Vase-Paint- the Greek West? inK. Bosher (ed.), Theater Outside Athens,
ers, in PBSR XI, 1929, 30-49. Cambridge 2012, 226-250.
Nafissi 1997 = M. Nafissi, Atene e Metaponto: ancora sulla Mela- Trendall1976 =A.D. Trendall, South Italian Vase Painting, Lon-
nippe Desmotis e i Neleidi, in Ostraka VI, 1997, 337-357. don, 19762
Neumann 1979 =G. Neumann, Probleme des griechischen Weih- Trendall 1987 = A D. Trendall, An Early South Italian Bell-
reliefs, Tiibingen 1979. Krater, Record of the Art Museum, Princeton University
Moltesen 1995 = M. Moltesen, Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek: Katalog. XLVI,2, 1987, 2-7.
Gr<Ekenland i klassisk tid, Copenhagen 1995. Trendall1988 =A D. Trendall, Masks on Apulian Red-Figured
Oakley 1990 = J. H. Oakley, The Phiale Painter, Mainz 1990. Vases, in J. H. Betts, J. T. Hooker, J. R. Green (edd.), Studies
Pagenstecher 1912 = R. Pagenstecher, Unteritalische Grabdenk- in Honour ofT.B.L. Webster, II, Bristol1988, 137-154.
miiler, Strasburg 1912. Trendall 1989 =A D. Trendall, Red Figure Vases of South Italy
Pickard-Cambridge 1968 = A W. Pickard-Cambridge, The and Sicily: a Handbook, London 1989.
Dramatic Festivals of Athens, New York2 Q. Gould and D.M. Tsirivakos 1973-74 =E. Tsirivakos, "'Hvi.oxoc; 'tEXVTic; 'tpayt!cilc;",
Lewis edd.). ADelt XXIX A Meletai, 88-94.
Robert 1882 = C. Robert, Relief im Peiraieus, in MDAI(A) Vll, Tzannes 1997 = M.-C. Tzannes, Kraters, Libations and Dionysiac
1882, 389-395, pl. 14. Imagery in Early South Italian Red-Figure", in 0. Palagia
Rumpf 1953 =A Rumpf, Malerei und Zeichnung der klassischen (ed.), Greek Offerings. Essays on Greek Art in Honour of John
Antike, Munich 1953. Boardman, Oxford 1997, 145-158.
Salta 1991 = M. Salta, Attische Grabstelen mit Inschriften: Beitrii- Webster 1956 = T. B. L. Webster, Greek Theatre Production, Lon-
ge zur Topographie und Prosopographie der Nekropolen von don 1956.
Athen, Attika und Salamis vom Peloponnesischen Krieg bis zur Wilson 1997 = P. Wilson, Leading the Tragic Khoros: Tragic Pres-
Mitte des 4. Jhs. v. Chr., Diss., Tiibingen 1991. tige in the Democratic City, in C. Pelling (ed.), Greek Tragedy
Schauenburg 2008 = K. Schauenburg, Studien zur unteritali- and the Historian, Oxford 1997,81-108.
schen Vasenmalerei, II, Kiel 2008. Wilson 2000 = P. Wilson, The Athenian Institution of the Khoregia.
Schmaltz 1978 =B. Schmaltz, Zu einer attischen Grabmalbasis The Chorus, the City and the Stage, Cambridge 2000, 81-86.
des 4. Jahrhunderts v. Chr., in MDAI(A) XCVIII, 1978, 83- Wilson 2007 = P. Wilson, Sicilian Choruses, in P. Wilson (ed.),
97. The Greek Theatre and Festivals. Documentary Studies, Oxford
Schneider-Herrmann 1970 = G. Schneider-Herrmann, Spuren 2007, 351-377.
164