Lp hc: T duy phn bin

Ging vin: TS. V Th Dng

Bi phn tch video

Cng Phng bao nhiu tui trn chuyn
ng 24h
Hon cnh: Chuyn ng 24 a ra cc bng chng khc nhau cng c tui Cng
Phng 21 thay v 19. C th vic ly thng tin t nhiu ngun: hi gia nh, hng
xm, nhng ngi hc chung vs Phng, truy xt n cun hc b, giy chng nhn
tt nghip lp 5. h s nhn khu ca cng an huyn
Tnh R rng - Ngun thng tin khng r rng.
C th vic phng vn nhng ngi hng xm ly thng tin, nt ch khng
thay i qua tng nm hc trong cun hc b ca Cng Phng, phng vn cn b
t php v tnh php l ca t khai sinh cng c ct ghp cho vic dn xp chng
c c hp l v ph hp. Trn y u l nhng v d m h v khng c cn c
kt lun.
Thng tin trong ng k s h khu, tn Cng Phng b iu chnh nm sinh c
a ra nhng knh bo ch khng tm hiu m lng, y l mt bng chng m
h na. Tuy nhin, khi kim tra ngun thng tin trn trang bo th m cng phng
nhm ln tn vi 1 ngi anh mt sinh nm 93 l Ng Cng Khoa nn mi c s
iu chnh li nm sinh.
Hn na, khi phng vn t php a phng v tnh php l ca t khai sinh th
video ch cng b 1 s ni dung lin quan trong phn pht biu nhng li ct i
phn tr li sau nhm mc ch cng c thm chng c. Cc thng tin nu ra u
khng y v i ti cng m ch l s dn xp hp l cng c kt lun ch
quan t pha VTV (tnh trn vn)
ng n, Chnh xc : Thng tin v s hc b cng khng c kh nng kim
chng v h s thng tin v hc sinh mt ht. Giy khai sinh khng c s, c
quyn l thng tin r rng nhng khng c kh nng kim chng v tn cng
phng ko c tn ng k trong s khai sinh nm 95, trong khi s ng k nm 93
th b mt. Li nm cng tc qun l ca a phng x M Sn.
Cng bng Cc thng tin chng c c a ra t pha ch quan VTV m khng c
th xc minh ngun gc l khng khch quan v p t khi kt lun vi v v tui
ca Cng Phng.
Tnh Logic, Lin quan : V logic th vic iu tra v kt lun khng thuc thm
quyn ca VTV m thuc trch nhim ca cng an.
Chiu su, Chiu rng: Thng tin a ra t nhiu ngun khc nhau nhng khng
i su c th vo mt vn no c.
ngha : Video khng em li ngha cho ng xem m cn to d lun khng hay
v pha Cng Phng, gia nh em v a phng.
Mc ch ca VTV l r rng nhm chng minh Cng Phng l 21 tui. Nhng
cch t cu hi, suy lun trong qu trnh thu thp ngun thng tin l khng chnh
xc, y v khng c cn c. Hm mun gi thng ip n Cng Phng v
Lp hc: T duy phn bin
Ging vin: TS. V Th Dng

khn gi nhn bit c mt s tht rng Cng Phng ang du tui tht ca
mnh.