Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Short communication
Jason C. Ganley
Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Colorado School of Mines, 1613 Illinois Street, Golden, CO, USA
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: An experimental module for senior-level reaction engineering/reactor design students is
Received 4 April 2015 described. The module is used to characterize the kinetics of dye (food coloring) neutral-
Received in revised form 28 May ization by household bleach, and the reactor system is congurable for use in either batch
2015 reactor or continuous-stirred tank reactor (CSTR) modes. The reactor temperature, volume,
Accepted 22 June 2015 reactant feed rates, and reactant concentrations may be adjusted to enable students to
Available online 2 July 2015 obtain a wide range of kinetic data. Dye concentrations in the reactor are monitored by
absorbance spectroscopy, and the kinetic rate law is determined directly from the batch
Keywords: reactor performance data. Students use the completed kinetic rate law to compare exper-
Reaction kinetics imental steady-state CSTR performance data to the mathematical models derived from
Batch reactor reactor design equations. Finally, the students use the kinetic behavior of the system to
CSTR design a hypothetical plug-ow reactor for the same chemical reaction and a set of stated
Reaction engineering operational goals.
Reactor design 2015 The Institution of Chemical Engineers. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Tel.: +1 303 384 2163.
E-mail address: jganley@mines.edu
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ece.2015.06.005
1749-7728/ 2015 The Institution of Chemical Engineers. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
education for chemical engineers 1 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 2026 21
those developed for chemical engineering students, involves The reactor was used above a heating/cooling plate and a
simple batch reaction rather than reaction within a contin- magnetic stirring assembly. The heating/cooling plate consists
uous reactor with feed and exit ows. One reason for this of an aluminum (alloy 1100) base with an integrated copper
limitation is the difculty in measuring dye or bleach con- uid tube. The plate is approximately 13 mm in thickness,
centrations (and thus reaction extent) in owing streams, and is supplied with water from a circulating heater/chiller
or within agitated reactors that have continuous reactant with digital temperature control. The reactors are agitated
entrance and product exit ow streams. with a Teon -sheathed magnetic stir bar 5 cm in length.
Dye concentrations in the reaction solutions are con- Agitation of the solution within the reactor assists in main-
veniently measured by monitoring the absorption of the taining the temperature of the reactor contents (the FRP is
appropriate wavelengths of light passing through the solution an excellent thermal insulator), and also generates sufcient
both before and during reaction. For example, aqueous solu- solution blending to maintain well-mixed conditions in the
tions of the food coloring FD&C Blue #1 (erioglaucine) absorbs case of CSTR operation. The square cross section of the FRP
visible light most strongly at about 628 nm. The absorption tube simplies the placement and gasket sealing of the tubing
(or transmission) of this red-orange light through solutions and optical ports, and also enables enhanced mixing versus a
of Blue #1 is typically measured using commercial visible cylindrical geometry; the sharp corners naturally bafe the
light spectrophotometers, which are generally intended for stirred reactor (Meyers et al., 2002), mixing the contents while
use with samples contained in a glass or plastic cuvette. reducing vortex formation in comparison to a cylindrical tank
Further, optical scanning of the sample is typically carried without bafing (Kresta et al., 2006).
out in a chamber that is shielded from external light. Light A total of ve ports exist in the reactors sidewalls. Two
absorbance or transmittance may also be measured with a of these are tubing connections for the dye and bleach feed
laser/photodiode combination for the wavelength of interest solutions, located above the free liquid surface. The plastic
(Delgado et al., 1998), however this type of system introduces feed lines connected to both of the feed ports each include a
a potential hazard (laser radiation) and requires signal calibra- small (ca. 40 cm) upstream segment, designed with stainless
tion, manipulation, and translation for the photodiode/media steel tubing and compression ttings as a double-pipe heat
interface selected for data acquisition and recording. exchanger. This segment also shares a uid connection to the
In the present communication, a method for arranging a circulating heater/chiller which enables simultaneous control
combination of inexpensive benchtop devices for measuring of the reactor and feed temperatures. Two aligned ports near
dye concentrations in batch and ow reactors is described. the bottom of the reactor sides are tted with watertight brass
The model reactor designs are created for use with a visible glass sights. These sights serve as the mounting points for
light spectrophotometer, a ber optic probe, and an electronic ber optic connections from both the halogen light source
data logger. Students are provided with a choice of two food (Dolan-Jenner Industries; Fiber-Lite MI-152) and the ber optic
coloring dyes: FD&C Blue #1 (peak absorbance 628 nm) and detector probe (Vernier Software & Technology; SVIS-FIBER).
FD&C Red #40 (peak absorbance 502 nm) for the experiment. The nal port, centered near the bottom of the front side of
the reactor, serves as the drain tubing connection. This drain
connection includes an isolation valve attached to a segment
2. Experimental apparatus and operation of exible plastic tubing. The end of the exible drain tubing
methods may be xed at various elevations with a ring stand clamp,
enabling hydrostatic control of the reactor volume. Feed and
All dye and bleach solutions are prepared by laboratory teach- drain connections are only used during CSTR operation, and
ing assistants prior to the start of student section laboratory the illumination and detection ports are used for every experi-
sessions. The dye solutions are prepared from powdered dye mental run. Solution absorbance is measured by incorporating
sources (SigmaAldrich) and tap water. The bleach used is the ber optic probe into the detection port of the miniature
a concentrated commercial grade solution (Clorox Company; spectrophotometer (Vernier Software & Technology; SVIS-PL).
8.25 wt% NaOCl), which is used both directly and in dilutions All absorbance data is collected and recorded with a hand-held
with tap water as required for the creation of reactor feed electronic logger (Vernier Software & Technology; LABQ2).
solutions.
The specic design features of the experimental appara- 2.1. Batch reactor operation
tus for each reactor type (batch and CSTR) were developed
over the course of three semesters of student use, leading to When testing the reactor in batch mode, students rst ll
the nal (unied) apparatus described here. A schematic illus- the reactor partway with tap water, covering the glass sights
trating the combined batch reactor/CSTR vessel is shown in within. The spectrophotometer is set to monitor absorbance
Fig. 1. at the wavelength of interest (628 nm or 502 nm), and the
The reactor body consists of a square berglass-reinforced intensity of the light source is manually adjusted so that the
plastic (FRP) tube section, closed at one end (the reactor bot- absorbance reported on the logger display is very nearly zero.
tom) by edge-joining a square aluminum (alloy 5052) plate This value is recorded as the dye-free absorbance reference,
with a two-part, waterproof epoxy adhesive (J-B Weld Com- representing the absorbance of water and the ber optic detec-
pany; JB-KWIK). Both the aluminum plate and FRP tube have tion cable at the selected wavelength. At this point, students
edge lengths of 7.62 cm. The FRP tube section is approximately may add a small dose of commercial bleach solution to the
20 cm in length, with a wall thickness of 6 mm. This cre- water in order to observe that there is no absorbance caused
ates a maximum functional reactor volume of approximately by the bleach itself. The reactor is then drained.
750 mL. The aluminum plate has an approximate thickness of Dye solutions are made available to the students at pre-
3 mm. Aluminum alloy 5052 was chosen for its high thermal mixed concentrations (26 M for FD&C Blue #1, and 2060 M
conductivity and for its generally high resistance to corrosion for FD&C Red #40) in insulated 18 L dispensers. Typically, two
by bleach solutions. different dye solution concentrations are available for each dye
22 education for chemical engineers 1 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 2026
Fig. 1 Isometric (left) and front-view (right) schematics of the reactor vessel used for both batch reaction and CSTR
operation: FRP housing (a), dye feed port (b), bleach feed port (c), light source port (d), ber optic detector port (e), drain
connection (f), and aluminum alloy base (g).
color in a given lab session. The dye dispensers labeled with operation, students use tap water to adjust the illumination
the dye concentrations within, and are cooled or heated with intensity and to determine and record the absorbance of dye-
immersed coiled copper tubing connected to the circulating free water. Once the tap water is drained from the reactor,
heater/chiller. Sufcient (500 mL) dye solution is measured exactly 300 mL of dye solution with double the typical concen-
by graduated cylinder and added to the empty reactor vessel. tration ranges as in the batch reactor experiments (412 M for
Students once again record the measured absorbance at the FD&C Blue #1, and 40120 M for FD&C Red #40) is added to the
wavelength of interest, which represents the absorptivity of reactor, and the absorbance for full-strength dye is recorded.
the solution and optical system at full dye strength. Students measure the solution depth at this point as well, so
The students then begin agitation of the solution with that the volume of reactor internals (ttings, stir bar) may be
the magnetic stirrer, and start the time-based acquisition calculated using Archimedes method. Magnetic stirring is ini-
of absorbance data. A pre-measured dose of concentrated tiated, time-based data acquisition commences, and exactly
commercial bleach (8.25 wt% NaOCl, specic gravity = 1.09) of 300 mL of a pre-mixed bleach solution (between 10 and 40 mM
between 2 and 8 g is then added to the solution. This small in NaOCl) is added to the dye solution.
dose of bleach does not signicantly impact the temperature At this time, two diaphragm feed pumps (ChemTech,
of the solution, but its volume is used to determine the total Pulsafeeder) are switched on to deliver dye and bleach solu-
solution volume within the reactor vessel. As the dye and tions continuously to the reactor. The pumping rates of dye
bleach react, students observe a gradual reduction in solution and bleach solutions are independently adjustable up to
absorbance, which is plotted in real time on the data logger 80 mL min1 , although in practice these rates are kept identi-
display. Reactor temperature is continuously monitored with cal during laboratory experiments in order to best match over
an immersion thermocouple. When the absorbance has nearly time the initial state of equal parts dye and bleach solutions
returned to its dye-free value, the data logging is manually within the reactor. The reactor drain is opened, and the exible
halted, and the data is saved. After draining the reactor once drain tubing is suspended at a xed height with a ring stand
again, students carry out further trials using various combina- clamp. The reactor is gravity (siphon) drained, so a higher
tions of the other available bleach doses and the dye solution drain tubing exit leads to a larger steady-state reactor volume
of alternate concentration. Between six and eight batch reac- and a longer solution residence time. Liquid level is measured
tor trials are typically accomplished in about an hours time. with a thin stainless steel rule, and the reactor temperature is
The number of completed trials depends both on when stu- measured with an immersion thermocouple as before. When
dents decide to terminate data collection, and on the reaction the reactor contents reach a steady-state conversion, as indi-
rate as inuenced by the reactors temperature. Fig. 2 illus- cated by an unchanging absorption reading, students simply
trates the raw data from three batch reactor experiments with change the vertical position of the drain tubing to achieve a
identical initial reactant concentrations and differing reactor new reactor volume and associated solution residence time.
temperatures. Alternatively, students may adjust the feed ows for dye and
bleach solution to new (identical) rates without adjusting the
2.2. CSTR operation elevation of the drain tubing. Between four and six CSTR tri-
als are typically accomplished in about an hours time; mostly
Operation of the reactor in CSTR mode involves the use of depending on the magnitude of changes to the reactor volume
additional laboratory equipment and slightly alters the gen- or feed ows from one experimental trial to the next. Fig. 3
eral experimental technique. As in the case for batch reactor illustrates the raw data from a typical 1-h CSTR experiment;
education for chemical engineers 1 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 2026 23
Fig. 2 Raw batch reactor absorbance data at () 12.0 C, () 25.4 C, and () 38.1 C. For each trial, dye is FD&C Blue #1,
reactor volume is 500 mL, initial dye concentration is 3 M, bleach dose is 4 g.
both a reactor volume change as well as a reactant feed ow by the students in characterizing the reactor, as well as how
rate change are sequentially examined in this particular case. the experimentally determined reaction kinetic information
is used for further reactor design.
Students perform the batch reactor and CSTR experiments in Experiments involving the batch reactor conguration are
laboratory sessions taking place over the course of 2 h. Each designed to allow the students to elucidate the overall
group spends equal time operating the reactor in the batch dye/bleach reaction kinetics, including the temperature-
and CSTR modes. The following subsections describe the basic dependence of the reaction. The rate law which describes the
background theory and the methods of data analysis used rate of the disappearance of dye (rD ) is presented with four
Fig. 3 Raw CSTR absorbance data for three sequential trials using FD&C Blue #1. Dye feed concentration is 12 M, bleach
feed concentration is 20 mM, reactor temperature is 23.5 C. Vertical dashed lines indicate the operating regions: 600 mL
reactor volume and 78.4 mL min1 total feed rate (a), 350 mL reactor volume and 78.4 mL min1 total feed rate (b), and 350 mL
reactor volume and 27.4 mL min1 total feed rate (c).
24 education for chemical engineers 1 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 2026
Fig. 4 Linearized absorbance plots for batch reactor operation with identical initial FD&C Blue #1 concentrations and
different bleach doses. Reactor volume is 500 mL, initial dye concentration is 3 M. Bleach doses for each trial are () 3 g and
() 6 g. The apparent reaction rate constants (k ) are displayed next to each linear t.
Finding the range of reactor dye conversion resulting from condition changes) are generally carried out with condence.
the adjustment of the temperature of one or both reactant Teams of students are also observed to be actively assist-
feed streams over a specied range. ing other teams within the laboratory session for example,
those teams beginning the lab period with CSTR experiments
The PFR model is developed in a straightforward manner. advise teams that switch to the CSTR in the middle of the
Beginning with the differential PFR design equation in terms lab period. This results in a very productive and cooper-
of dye (D) and bleach (B) concentration, the constant volume ative environment that does not overstress the laboratory
and reactor conversion (X),
ow (V), supervisors.
The laboratory module is executed very near the end of
dX the semester, and long after the lectures introducing such
o]
V[D = k[D] [B] (3)
dV chemical reaction engineering topics as rate law determina-
This equation may be easily integrated to obtain an algebraic tion, the implementation of reactor design equations, and
formula for the reactor conversion as a function of reactor the use of numerical methods for reactor simulation. The
volume. overall quality of the resulting student work is very good,
and the students generally do not struggle to discuss the
4. Observations of student work and results of their experimental investigations. The extension
module feedback of fully analyzed batch reactor and CSTR data to the design
of a hypothetical PFR is accomplished with similar success.
As is the case with most hands-on experimental projects Senior-level students apply the various writing and repor-
that also require data analysis and a formal report, students ting techniques used in the junior-level thermodynamics
divide their efforts between hands-on laboratory work and and unit operations laboratories to produce concise reports
time spent carrying out computational analyses. Prior to per- of signicant analytical depth to satisfy the learning objec-
forming the laboratory, students are provided with a detailed tives and course outcomes that are related to the laboratory
electronic document which includes a basic explanation of the module.
nature of the experiment, sequential operating instructions Student feedback regarding the homogeneous kinetics lab-
for the illumination/sensor and data acquisition systems, and oratory module has been generally very positive. Student
a short discussion of the signicance of the collected data for attitudes and responses toward the module and its deliv-
both batch and CSTR modes of operation. In the execution ery indicated greater student satisfaction as the experimental
of laboratory experiments, the number of procedural ques- hardware and the instructional documentation were each suc-
tions and clarications requested by the students is by far the cessively rened over the three semesters that the experiment
greatest at the very beginning of the lab. These inquiries are has been in use. Faculty instructors appreciate the exible
mostly students ensuring that the plan for carrying out the application of the reactor units (as either batch reactors or
lab work is properly understood. Students receive immedi- CSTRs) and the integration of data acquisition into the experi-
ate feedback by seeing the response of each reactor system ment. From an administrative point of view, the dye and bleach
in real-time via the data acquisition interface. As a result, reactors have received good reviews by offering a low opera-
the subsequent experimental trials (or implemented reaction tional cost.
26 education for chemical engineers 1 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 2026
5. Conclusions References
While the incorporation of laboratory modules into senior- Arce, J., Betancourt, R., et al., 1998. The reaction of a food colorant
level chemical engineering courses is by no means universal, with sodium hypochlorite: a student-designed kinetics
the faculty in the CBE department at CSM recognize the experiment. J. Chem. Educ. 75 (9), 11421144.
Corsaro, G., 1964. A colorimetric chemical kinetics experiment. J.
benets of providing students with practical, hands-on exper-
Chem. Educ. 41 (1), 4850.
iments that demonstrate the concepts learned in the lecture Delgado, P., Kasko, A., et al., 1998. An experiment in applied
and literature-study aspects of these courses. The present optics: determination of the kinetics of the oxidation of an
communication details an inexpensive, reliable, and safe organic dye. Chem. Eng. Educ. 32 (3), 174197.
experimental system that may be provided to chemical engi- Henary, M.M., Russell, A.A., 2007. An inexpensive kinetic study:
neering undergraduate students enrolled in kinetics and the reaction of FD&C Red #3 (erythrosin B) with hypochlorite.
reactor design courses. The dye and bleach reaction system is J. Chem. Educ. 84 (3), 480482.
Kalmatsky, B., 2013. An improvement to: the reaction of FD&C
exible in its operation serving as a batch reactor or as a CSTR
Red #3 (erythrosin B) with hypochlorite. J. Chem. Educ. 90,
with very little required adjustment between modes. The 17081709.
laboratory module was well-received by the undergraduate Kresta, S., Mao, D., Roussinova, V., 2006. Batch blend time in
students, instructional supervisors, and course faculty. Mod- square stirred tanks. Chem. Eng. Sci. 61 (9), 28232825.
ule planning and execution ensured that the experimental Meyers, K., Reeder, M., Fasano, J., 2002. Optimize mixing by using
trials and any associated data analysis exemplied core reac- the proper bafes. CEP Mag. (AIChE) (February),
4247.
tion engineering principles. Student reporting was expanded
Pickering, M., Heiler, D., 1987. Kinetics of oxidation of bromcresol
beyond simple data reduction so that students also design a
green. J. Chem. Educ. 64 (1), 8182.
PFR reaction system to accomplish a stated set of operational
goals.