Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nicole Vu and Thomas C. Kupiec are affiliated with Analytical Research Laboratories, Inc., Oklahoma City, Oklahoma; Jessica R. Lou is a PharmD Candidate
at the Oklahoma University Health Science Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma.
Table 3. Properties of Selective Media Used in Table 4. Selective Media and Their Usage in United
Testing by United States Pharmacopeia Chapter States Pharmacopeia Chapter <62>.3
<62>.3 Temperature Time
Growth Growth Indicative Test Medium (C) (Hour)
Medium Promotion Inhibition Reaction Bile Tolerant Mossel Enterobacteria
Gram-negative Enrichment Broth 30 to 35 24 to 48
Mossel Enterobacteria E. coli
Violet Red Bile Glucose
Enrichment Broth P. aeruginosa S. aureus
Agar 30 to 35 18 to 24
Violet Red Bile E. coli E. coli
E. coli MacConkey Broth 42 to 44 24 to 48
Glucose Agar P. aeruginosa P. aeruginosa
MacConkey Agar 30 to 35 18 to 72
MacConkey Broth E. coli S. aureus
Samonella Rappaport Vassiliadis
MacConkey Agar E. coli E. coli Samonella Enrichment
Rappaport Vassiliadis Broth 30 to 35 18 to 24
Samonella Xylose Lysine
Enrichment Broth S. enterica S. aureus Deoxycholate Agar 30 to 35 18 to 48
cultured on Columbia Agar for an indication Bile Glucose Agar + >10 to <102
test. A list of the selective media and their and incubated at <10
usage in USP Chapter <62> procedures is 30C to 35C for 18
provided in Table 4. In general, the presence to 24 hours. Growth
of any colonies on these selective media of colonies are recorded, and the MPN of with the Japanese Pharmacopeia (JP)
indicates presumptive identification, which bacteria is determined according to Table 5. XVI Chapter 4.05 Microbial Limit Test.
must be confirmed by suitable identifica- USP General Chapter <1111> Acceptance
tion tests. The product complies with the When to Perform United Criteria for Pharmaceutical Preparations
test if no colonies are detected or confirma- States Pharmacopeia and Drug Substances for Pharmaceutical
tory identification tests are negative. Chapters <61> and <62> Use is practically harmonized with the EP
Section 5.1.4, and JP Chapter G4 (12).5
The International Conference on
Quantitative Test for Bile-Tolerant Harmonization (ICH Q4B) recommends
Gram-negative Bacteria that the official pharmacopeial texts con-
Testing Frequency
The quantitation scheme is conducted cerning microbiological tests and accep- In-process and Release Testing
similar to the Most Probable Number tance criteria for nonsterile products According to the Code of Federal
(MPN) method described in USP Chapter be used interchangeably within the ICH Regulations (21 CFR 211), each lot of a com-
<61>. A set of 10-fold serial dilutions of regions. Therefore, both USP Chapters <61>: ponent (e.g., in process or raw materials) or
the product in Mossel Enterobacteria Microbial Enumeration Tests and <62>: drug product that may potentially become
Enrichment Broth containing products Tests for Specified Microorganisms are har- contaminated with objectionable organ-
equivalent to 0.1, 0.01, and 0.001 g is pre- monized with the European Pharmacopeia isms during the manufacturing process or
pared for enrichment at 30C to 35C for (EP) 7.0 Sections 2.6.12 and 2.6.13, also its period of intended use must first pass
microbiological testing. Written procedures to prevent objectionable organisms in nonster- mation should be included in the testing
ile drug products must be in place, as well as appropriate laboratory testing for each batch. program6:
Additionally, in-process materials must be tested for identity, strength, quality (product
and microbial), and purity, and be approved or rejected during all stages of production.6 1. Sample size and testing intervals based
on statistical criteria
21 CFR 211.84(d): Each lot of a component, drug product container, or closure that is 2. Storage conditions of samples retained
liable to microbiological contamination that is objectionable in view of its intended for testing
use shall be subjected to microbiological tests before use. 3. Reliable and meaningful testing
methods
21 CFR 211.113(a): Appropriate written procedures designed to prevent objection-
4. Carrying out the test in the same con-
able microorganisms in drug products not required to be sterile, shall be established
tainer as the final marketed product
and followed.
5. Testing drug products intended for
21 CFR 211.165(b): There shall be appropriate laboratory testing as necessary of reconstitution both at the time of
each batch of drug product required to be free of objectionable microorganisms. dispensing and during the period of
in-use
Stability Testing
The following guidelines are expressed in
Furthermore, a written testing program to assess stability of drug products should be
ICH/FDA guidance documents:
established. Provided that a sufficient number of batches are tested, this information
will determine appropriate storage conditions and expiration dates. The following infor-
ICH Q1A(R2)/FDA: Testing per-
formed during a stability program
should include analyses for product
Whats Under
attributes that are susceptible to
change during storage and that are
likely to influence the products
Your Hood?
quality, safety, or efficacy7
ICH Q6A/FDA: Acceptance criteria
should be set for the total count of
aerobic microorganisms, the total
count of yeasts and molds, and the
absence of specific objectionable
bacteriaThese should be deter-
mined by suitable procedures,
using pharmacopoeial procedures,
and at a sampling frequency or time
point in manufacture which is jus-
IMI offers a complete range of products designed specifically
tified by data and experience.8
for sterile compounding including our renowned line of
Prep-LockTM Tamper Evident Caps for luer lock syringes.
Additional guidance is provided in USP
Easy installation for the pharmacy and easy removal for the Chapter <1163> Quality Assurance in
nurse...no more fumbling with sticky, brittle tape or bulky Pharmaceutical Compounding3 and <1191>
bags. Secure your sterile IV preparations and enhance Stability Consideration in Dispensing
USP <797> compliance! Practice3 where microbiological quality
FREE Sterile Samples for Evaluation! is a condition of sample stability. Thus,
microbial limit is one of the recommended
Innovative Sterile Products tests, and frequency of testing should be
for Compounding Pharmacies sufficient to establish the stability profile
800-344-2554 of nonsterile preparations. For long-term
www.imiweb.com International Medical Industries, Inc. stability study, the test is usually conducted
at 6- to 12-month intervals.
Pharmaceutical Compounding 2014.indd 1 2/17/2014 11:24:49 AM
Repeat Testing Table 6 lists microorganisms that are pri- can adversely impact the quality and safety
A procedure for investigating test results marily foodborne, but some of these species of the finished product.10
that fail to meet given microbial limit can persist in pharmaceutical or healthcare
specifications should be established by the products. One such example includes the Water Activity of
manufacturers, and this procedure should many cases of contaminated alcohol wipes Non-Sterile Products
containing Bacillus cereus species, which
allow for confirmatory testing. However, and Relationship to
contributed to one fatality in a child and
the logic and rationale for conducting the
eight other deaths that have not yet been
Microbiological Quality
retest should be based on sound scientific (United States
judgement.4 In the event that a root cause positively linked. Of note, no yeast or mold
species are officially included in the FDAs Pharmacopeia Chapter
cannot be determined, all values obtained
(original and re-test) must be reported and list. The information in Table 6 may poten- <1112>)
taken into consideration when evaluating tially be of interest in determining which Traditionally, low-water activity has
the microbial quality of the product. The organisms should be added to an objection- been used to control microbial deterioration
FDA expressed the following opinions4: able list. Additionally, any organisms that of food. Reduced water activity (aW) greatly
persist in high level within any manufactur- assists in the prevention of microbial
Data review must evaluate the ing process should be strongly considered proliferation in pharmaceutical products.
relationship between the organ- an objectionable candidate because they Additionally, low-water activity promotes
isms found in test samples, and the self-preservation and thereby prevents
potential for the existence of other microbial growth within pharmaceutical
objectionable conditions. drug products. However, it should be noted
Table 6. The U.S. Food and that resistant microorganisms, including
The importance of identifying all Drug Administration List of spore-forming Clostridium spp., Bacillus
isolates from either or both total Objectionable Foodborne spp., Salmonella spp., and filamentous fungi,
plate count testing and enrichment Organisms.11 may persist within the product although
testing will depend upon the prod- they may not proliferate. Non-aqueous liq-
Gram-negative Organisms
uct and its intended use. Obviously, uids or dry solid dosage forms will not sup-
Aeromonas hydrophila and other species
if an oral solid dosage form such as port spore germination or microbial growth
Brucella species
tablet is tested, it may be accept- due to their low-water activity.
Campylobacter jejuni
able to identify isolates when test- When formulating an aqueous oral or
ing show high levels. However, for Coxiella burnetii topical dosage form, candidate formulations
other products such as topicals, Cronobacter species should be evaluated for aW so that the drug
inhalants or nasal solutions where Francisella tularensis product may be self-preserving, if possible.
there is a major concern for micro- Miscellaneous bacterial enterics: For example, small changes in sodium
biological contamination, isolates Plesiomonas shigelloides chloride, sucrose, alcohol, propylene glycol,
from plate counts, as well as enrich- Salmonella species or glycerin in a formulation may result in
ment testing should be identified. Shigella species the creation of a drug product with a lower
Vibrio cholerae Non-O1 Non-O139
aW that can discourage the proliferation
So, the first consideration should be the of microorganisms in the product. This is
Vibrio cholerae Serogroups O1 and O139
total numbers of microorganisms present. particularly valuable with a multiple-use
Vibrio parahaemolyticus
High levels of bioburden may indicate a product that may be contaminated by the
Vibrio vulnificus
manufacturing process is out of control, or end-user.
Yersinia enterocolitica
that a spoilage organism is proliferating in Water activity is the ratio of water vapor
the product. If the numbers of organisms Gram-positive Organisms pressure in the product (P) to vapor pres-
in the product are not large, the next con- Bacillus cereus and other Bacillus species sure of pure water (Po) at the same tem-
sideration is whether those organisms are Clostridium botulism perature. Water activity can be determined
objectionable. One approach is to transfer Clostridium perfringens directly from the partial vapor pressure or
the enrichments prepared in the compen- Enterococcus species dew point, or indirectly by determination
dial test to non-selective media in addi- Listeria monocytogenes
of equilibrium relative humidity (ERH%).
tion to the required selective media. Any Pharmaceutical drug products with water
Mycobacterium bovis
colonies recovered and identified should be activities well below 0.75 are excellent can-
Staphylococcus aureus
evaluated using a risk-based approach sug- didates for reduced microbial limit testing.
Streptococcus species
gested in USP Chapter <1111>.9 Table 7 contains suggested microbial limit
in USP <61> and <62>, but practitioners Oral suspension 0.87 Fungi TAMC, TYMC
and manufacturers should be aware of the Topical ointment 0.55 None Reduced testing
possibility for contamination by organ- Lip balm 0.36 None Reduced testing
isms not included in the USP list. Similarly, Suppositories
products with low-water activity may resist (vaginal, rectal) 0.3 None Reduced testing
microbial proliferation, but contaminating Compressed tablets 0.36 None Reduced testing
microorganisms may remain viable and Liquid-filled capsule 0.3 None Reduced testing
potentially be pathogenic. Therefore, aW TAMC = total aerobic microbial count; TYMC = total combined yeasts and molds count
measurements cannot solely be used to
justify the elimination of microbial testing
For Use in the ICH Regions. Microbiological [ICH Website.] October 1999. Available at:
for product release. Contamination con-
Examination of Non-Sterile Products; www.ich.org. Accessed April 7, 2014.
trol is a preventive activity that demands Annex 4AMicrobial Enumeration Tests 9. Roundtable: 15 Years in Pharmaceutical
conscientious adherence to GMP and good General Chapter; Annex 4B(R1)Test for Microbiology [American Pharmaceutical
compounding practice. Specified Micro-organisms General Chapter; Review Website]. October 30,
Annex 4C(R1)-Acceptance Criteria For 2013. Available at: www.ameri-
Pharmaceutical Preparations and Substances canpharmaceuticalreview.com/
References For Pharmaceutical Use. [ISPE Website.] Featured-Articles/148857-Roundtable-
1. Vu N, Lou JR, Kupiec TC. Quality control Available at: www.ispe.org. Accessed April 7, 15-Years-in-Pharmaceutical-Microbiology/.
analytical methods: Microbial limit tests for 2014. Accessed January 16, 2014.
nonsterile pharmaceuticals, part 1. IJPC 2014; 6. U.S. Department of Health & Human 10. Sutton S. What is an Objectionable
18(3): 213220. Services. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Organism? [American Pharmaceutical
2. Clontz L. Microbial Limit and Bioburden Code of Federal Regulations Title 21, Part Review Website]. October 12, 2012. Available
Tests: Validation Approaches and Global 211. Available at www.accessdata.fda.gov/ at: www.americanpharmaceuticalreview.
Requirements. 2nd ed. Boca Raton, FL: CRC scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/CFRSearch. com/Featured-Articles/122201-What-is-
Press 2009. cfm?CFRPart=211. Accessed April 7, 2014. an-Objectionable-Organism-Objectionable-
3. United States Pharmacopeia Convention, 7. International Conference on Harmonisation. Organisms-The-Shifting-Perspective/.
Inc. United States Pharmacopeia 36 International Conference on Harmonisation Accessed January 16, 2014.
National Formulary 31. Rockville, MD: US of Technical Requirements for Registration 11. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. 2012a.
Pharmacopeial Convention, Inc.; 2013: of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use. ICH Bad Bug Book: Handbook of Foodborne
Chapters <61>, <62>, <1111>, <1112>, <1163>, Harmonised Tripartite Guideline. Stability Pathogenic Microorganisms and Natural
<1191>. Testing of New Drug Substances and Products Toxins, 2nd Edition. [FDA Website.]
4. U.S. Department of Health and Human Q1A (R2). [ICH Website.] February 6, 2003. Available at: www.fda.gov/downloads/
Services. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Available at: www.ich.org. Accessed April 7, Food/FoodSafety/FoodborneIllness/
Guide To Inspections of Microbiological 2014. FoodborneIllnessFoodborne
Pharmaceutical Quality Control Laboratories. 8. International Conference on Harmonisation. PathogensNaturalToxins/ BadBugBook/
Available at: www.fda.gov/ICECI/ International Conference on Harmonisation UCM297627.pdf. Accessed February 21, 2014.
Inspections/InspectionGuides/ucm074914. of Technical Requirements For Registration
htm. Accessed February 18, 2014. of Pharmaceuticals For Human Use.
5. ISPE Glossary of Pharmaceutical ICH Harmonised Tripartite Guideline. Address correspondence to Nicole Vu, PhD,
Biotechnology Terminology. Guidance Specifications: Test Procedures and Acceptance Analytical Research Laboratories, Inc., 840
for Industry. Q4B Evaluation and Criteria for New Drug Substances and New Research Parkway, Suite 546, Oklahoma
Recommendation of Pharmacopeial Texts Drug Products: Chemical Substances Q6A (4). City, OK 73104. E-mail: nvu@arlok.com