Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Occurrence of toxic metals (Hg, Cd and Pb) in fresh and canned tuna: Public
health implications
Maria M. Storelli , Grazia Barone, Giuseppe Cuttone, Daniele Giungato, Rita Garofalo
Pharmacological-Biological Department Chemistry and Biochemistry Section, Veterinary Medicine Faculty, University of Bari Strada Prov. le per
Casamassima Km 3, 70010 Valenzano (Ba), Italy
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Hg, Pb and Cd levels in fresh and canned tuna were determined and assessed by comparing element lev-
Received 28 April 2010 els in these samples with maximum permissible limits set by European legislation. The estimated weekly
Accepted 15 August 2010 intakes by human consuming both fresh and canned tuna were also evaluated for possible consumer
health risks. Among tested metals, Hg had the highest concentrations, followed by Pb and Cd either in
fresh tuna or canned tuna. None of the tested samples surpassed the European regulatory limits xed
Keywords: for Cd and Pb, whereas 8.9% of the tuna cans and 20% of fresh tuna samples exceeded standard for Hg.
Fresh tuna
The size of tuna was a determining factor of Hg burden. A high intake of Hg surpassing the toxicological
Canned tuna
Toxic metals
reference value established by WHO, was associated with consumption of larger size tuna specimens.
Food safety Also canned tuna consumption with Hg concentrations higher than 1 lg kg 1, strongly increased the con-
PTWI sumer exposure. In contrast, Cd and Pb weekly intakes through consumption either of fresh tuna or
Health risk canned tuna did not exceed the toxicological reference values established by WHO, and consequently
there was no human health risk. A continuous surveillance system of Hg content in these shery products
is crucial for consumer protection.
2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction mulating elevated metal levels, tuna is one of the most fre-
quently consumed and commercially available groups of sh
An adequate human diet should satisfy the requirements for worldwide (Burger et al., 2005). These pelagic organisms are
energy and nutritive components including essential polyunsatu- high performance sh with very high metabolism rates and,
rated fatty acids, essential aminoacids, mineral components, vita- thus, high food intake rates, a property that accentuates the
mins and fat. Fish contains all these substances, but the most exposure to trace elements (Kojadinovic et al., 2007). Conse-
important feature of this food is an advantageous fatty acid pro- quently, adverse human health effects may occur if this sh is
le, resulting from the consistent content of essential polyunsat- consumed too often or in large enough quantities. In this context
urated fatty acids, such as eicosapentaenoic and docosahexaenoic it is also of interest to consider canned tuna, which amongst
acid, known to support good health (Usydus et al., 2009). It is canned shery products is doubtless the most largely and fre-
estimated that the consumption of one portion of fatty sh, dai- quently consumed. Canned tuna is, in fact, well eaten in the
ly, delivers about 900 mg/day of n-3 acids, with consequent developed world, especially in Europe because it is convenient
reduction of mortality in patients with coronary diseases and affordable for most working families. Europe is the worlds
(Kris-Etherton et al., 2002). However, the indisputable benets largest market for canned tuna with 34% of the global consump-
deriving by sh consumption may be offset by the presence in tion and Italy is, after Spain, the second country in canned tuna
their meat of toxic metals, such as Cd, Pb and especially Hg, consumption (Food Market Exchange, 2003; Glitnir Seafood
which is present in many sh species often at levels exceeding Team, 2007). Nevertheless, publications on the concentrations
the safety standards established by legislation of the various of toxic elements in canned tuna and dietary intakes of these
countries. In relation to this, it is important to remark that with elements via these shery products in Italy are lacking. Also
the exception of occupational exposure, the main Hg exposure for fresh tuna, information on these topics is rather limited,
for human is the ingestion of contaminated sh, especially larger although the few literature data conrms ability of these large
predators. Amongst those species recognised as potentially accu- pelagic predators to accumulate substantial levels of toxic met-
als, especially mercury (Storelli et al., 2002; Licata et al., 2005).
Corresponding author. Tel.: +39 0 80 5443866; fax: +39 0 80 5443863. In the light of what above reported the objectives of present
E-mail address: m.m.storelli@veterinaria.uniba.it (M.M. Storelli). investigation are the following:
0278-6915/$ - see front matter 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.fct.2010.08.013
3168 M.M. Storelli et al. / Food and Chemical Toxicology 48 (2010) 31673170
Hg concentration ( g g-1 w. w. )
1.5
0.5
0
105 107 109 115 120 120 130 135 139 140 140 145 147 149 150 153 156 172 178 218
Lenght of tuna (cm)
0
0.5
EWI ( g kg-1 bw/week.)
1.5
2.5
b
3.5
1
Fig. 1. Hg concentrations (lg g 1 wet wt) (a) and EWI (lg kg bw/week) (b)/versus length (cm).
bw/week) were well within the safe limits, ranging from 0.40% of ing Pb, the concentrations obtained in the present study were
the PTWI for cadmium to 0.56% for lead. low and generally comparable with those reported in canned tuna
from Turkey (elik and Oehlenschlger, 2007; Tuzen and Soylak,
3.2. Content of toxic metals in canned tuna 2007), Iran (Ganjavi et al., 2010) and USA (Ikem and Egiebor,
2005). The decline of Pb concentrations in the marine environment
Similarly to what encountered in fresh tuna samples, Hg (Nicolas et al., 1994; Tian and Ruiz-Pino, 1995; Storelli, 2008), to-
showed the highest concentrations, followed by Pb and Cd. Hg gether with the advance of new packaging technology, especially
and Cd were detected in all samples analysed with concentrations the use of cans with lacquered walls and mechanical seam that
ranging from 0.04 to 1.79 lg g 1 wet wt (average: 0.41 lg g 1 wet have reduced or in most cases eliminate the leaching of Pb into
wt) and from 0.01 to 0.14 lg g 1 wet wt (average: 0.04 lg g 1 wet the food, can be responsible of low levels encountered in tested
wt), respectively, while Pb was encountered in 40 of samples ana- products (Emami Khansari et al., 2005). Also for mercury, our val-
lysed with levels varying between 0.02 and 0.16 lg g 1 wet wt ues were similar to those reported for canned tuna from other
(average: 0.06 lg g 1 wet wt). Good agreements were, generally, areas of the world (Voegborlo et al., 1999; Kouyoumjian et al.,
observed when our results were compared with those reported 2001; Burger and Gochfeld, 2004; Dabeka et al., 2004; Shim
by other authors. Emami Khansari et al. (2005) reported a et al., 2004; VanDerslice et al., 2004; Ikem and Egiebor, 2005;
Cd concentration range of 0.0050.072 lg g 1 wet wt (average: Ashraf, 2006; Rasmussen and Morrissey, 2007). An evaluation of
0.02 lg g 1 wet wt), while Tuzen and Soylak (2007) exhibited a the content of toxic metals in these canned sh products based
mean value of 0.08 lg g 1 wet wt for canned tuna purchased from on the permissible limits set by European legislation (WHO,
popular supermarkets in Turkey. Other surveys showed that Cd 2006; EFSA, 2009) showed, however, that in none of the tested
concentrations in cans of tuna from Lybia (Voegborlo et al., samples the amounts of Cd and Pb exceed the permissible
1999), Saudi Arabia (Ashraf, 2006) and Iran (Ganjavi et al., 2010) standards. Concerning mercury, level of 1 lg g 1 is normally high
were slightly higher than our values, being 0.18 lg g 1 wet wt, enough so that tuna fell below this level, although this was not al-
0.16 lg g 1 wet wt and 0.15 lg g 1 wet wt, respectively. Concern- ways the case. Of the tuna cans examined, 8.9% surpassed 1 lg g 1.
3170 M.M. Storelli et al. / Food and Chemical Toxicology 48 (2010) 31673170
This ndings, although not allarming because the standards have Catarci, C., Scarpato, D., Simeone, M., 2007. Sostenibilit ambientale ed. economia
nel mercato del tonno rosso. Osservatorio europeo dei sistemi territoriali a
safety margins, may be of concern in consideration of the frequent
vocazione agroalimentare. Franco Angeli editore, New York, pp. 1144.
dietary consumption of this shery product worldwide. In Italy the elik, U., Oehlenschlger, J., 2007. High contents of cadmium, lead, zinc and copper
consumption of canned tuna is in constant growth and amounts to in popular shery products sold in Turkish supermarkets. Food Control 18, 258
2.1 kg per person per year, corresponding to 40 g for week (Food 261.
Dabeka, R., McKenzie, A.D., Forsyth, D.S., Conacher, H.B., 2004. Survey of total
Market Exchange, 2003; Valsecchi, 2006, 2007). Based on this value mercury in some edible sh and shellsh species collected in Canada in 2002.
and the average metal contents it can be concluded that the con- Food Add. Contam. 21, 434440.
sumption of canned tuna is safe because the estimated intakes EFSA, 2009. Scientic panel on contaminants in the food chain. Cadmium in food
30/01/2009. Belgium: EFSA; 2009/03/20. <http://www.efsa.europa.eu/EFSA/
for Hg (0.27 lg kg 1 bw/week), Cd (0.03 lg kg 1 bw/week) and efsa_locale-1178620753820_1211902396126.htm>.
Pb (0.04 lg kg 1 bw/week) (Table 1) were notably lower than the Emami Khansari, F., Ghazi-Khansari, M., Abdollahi, M., 2005. Heavy metals content
respective PTWIs. However, concerning Hg the wide variability of canned tuna sh. Food Chem. 93, 293296.
Food Market Exchange, 2003. Tuna consumption. <www.foodmarketexchange.com/
encountered among the different tested canned products, deter- datacenter/product/seafood/tuna/detail/dc_pi_sf_tuna0401.php>.
mined large uctuations in exposure level. The canned tuna con- Ganjavi, M., Ezzatpanah, H., Givianrad, M.H., Shams, A., 2010. Effect of canned tuna
sumption with Hg concentrations higher than 1 lg kg 1 (from sh processing steps on lead and cadmium contents of Iranian tuna sh. Food
Chem. 118, 525528.
1.17 to 1.79 lg kg 1 wet wt) determined high intakes (from 0.78 Glitnir Seafood Team, 2007. Tuna Seafood Industry Report, August 2007, pp.62.
to 1.19 lg kg 1 bw/week) constituting from 48.8% to 74.4% of PTWI G.U.R.I. (Gazzetta Ufciale della Repubblica Italiana), 1994. Metodi di analisi per la
of MeHg. ricerca di residui di metalli pesanti e arsenico. No. 21 of 27/01/1994.
Ikem, A., Egiebor, N.O., 2005. Assessment of trace elements in canned shes
(mackerel, tuna, salmon, sardines and herrings) marketed in Georgia and
Alabama (United States of America). J. Food Comp. Anal. 18, 771787.
4. Conclusion Kojadinovic, J., Potier, M., Le Corre, M., Cosson, R.P., Bustamante, P., 2007.
Bioaccumulation of trace elements in pelagic sh from the Western Indian
Ocean. Environ. Pollut. 146, 548566.
In all tested samples, Hg exhibited the highest concentrations Kouyoumjian, H.H., Tilbian, M., Najjar, E., 2001. Exposure of the Lebanese
followed by Pb and Cd. The amounts of Cd and Pb were well below population to mercury through shery products and a proposal for a
the maximum permitted concentrations by EU legislation for the screening standard. Leb. Sci. J. 2, 3745.
Kris-Etherton, P.M., Hecker, K.D., Bonanome, A., Coval, S.M., Binkoski, A.E., Hilpert,
human consumption, whereas 8.9% of the tuna cans and 20% of
K.F., Griel, A.E., Etherton, T.D., 2002. Bioactive compounds in foods: their role in
fresh tuna samples exceeded standard for MeHg. In addition, a gen- the prevention of cardiovascular disease and cancer. Am. J. Med. 113, 7188.
eral picture of the results concerning the consumer exposure Licata, P., Trombetta, D., Cristani, M., Naccari, C., Martino, D., Cal, M., Naccari, F., 2005.
showed that Cd and Pb weekly intakes through either consumption Heavy metals in liver and muscle of bluen tuna (Thunnus thynnus) caught in the
Straits of Messina (Sicily Italy). Environ. Monit. Assess. 107, 239248.
of fresh tuna or canned tuna remained within safety margins, while Nakagawa, R., Yumita, Y., Hiromoto, M., 1997. Total mercury intake from sh and
for Hg a different scenario was observed. Hg intakes surpassing shellsh by Japanese people. Chemosphere 35, 29092913.
PTWI were associated with the consumption of specimens of larger Nicolas, E., Ruiz-Pino, D., Buat-Mnard, P., Bthoux, J.P., 1994. Abrupt decrease of
lead concentration in the Mediterranean Sea: a response to the antipollution
size. However, the data obtained clearly indicated that mercury policy. J. Geophys. Res. 21, 21192122.
exposure to human could be minimized if the consumption of tuna Ofcial Journal of the European Union, 2006. Commission regulation (EC) No 1881/
is limited to a certain size. Also the canned tuna consumption with 2006 of 19 December 2006 setting maximum levels for certain contaminants in
foodstuffs. L 364/5.
Hg concentrations higher of 1 lg kg 1 determined high intakes, Ofcial Journal of the European Union, 2008. Commission Regulation (EC) no. 629/
constituting over 45.0% of the PTWI. A better selection of the fresh 2008 of 2 July 2008 setting maximum levels for certain contaminants in
material, including an analysis for toxic elements prior to process- foodstuffs. L 173/6.
Rasmussen, R.S., Morrissey, M.T., 2007. Effects of canning on total mercury, protein,
ing, could surely improve the situation. In addition, risk reduction lipid, and moisture content in troll-caught albacore tuna (Thunnus alalunga).
should include educational campaigns to foster both an under- Food Chem. 101, 11301135.
standing of the relationship among Hg and sh size, sh species, Shim, S.M., Dorworth, L.E., Lasrado, J.A., Santerre, C.R., 2004. Mercury and fatty acids
in canned tuna, salmon, and mackerel. J. Food Sci. 69, 681684.
and trophic levels and to reduce the number of tuna meals to be
Sivaperumal, P., Sankar, T.V., Viswanathan Nair, P.G., 2007. Heavy metal
consumed. Governmental agencies should make more use of news- concentrations in sh, shellsh and sh products from internal markets of
paper and television for such campaigns, since few people learn of India vis-a-vis international stantards. Food Chem. 102, 612620.
advisories from the state publications which the state relies on Storelli, M.M., Giacominelli Stufer, R., Marcotrigiano, G.O., 2002. Total and
methylmercury residues in tuna-sh from the Mediterranean sea. Food Add.
heavily (Burger et al., 1998). The results of the present study sug- Contam. 19, 715720.
gest the need for an increasing effort in controlling the sources of Storelli, M.M., 2008. Potential human health risks from metals (Hg, Cd, and Pb) and
Hg pollution in this area. polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) via seafood consumption: Estimation of target
hazard quotients (THQs) and toxic equivalents (TEQs). Food Chem. Toxicol. 46,
27822788.
Tian, R.C., Ruiz-Pino, D., 1995. Simulation and prediction of anthropogenic lead
Conict of Interest perturbation in the Mediterranean Sea. Sci. Total Environ. 164, 135150.
Tuzen, M., Soylak, M., 2007. Determination of trace metals in canned sh marketed
in Turkey. Food Chem. 101, 13781382.
The authors declare that there are no conicts of interest. Usydus, Z., Szlinder-Richert, J., Polak-Juszczak, L., Komar, K., Adamczyk, M., Malesa-
Ciecwierz, M., Ruczynska, W., 2009. Fish products available in polish market
Assessment of the nutritive value and human exposure to dioxins and other
References contaminants. Chemosphere 74, 14201428.
Valsecchi, A., 2006. Analysis of the Tuna Market at European and World-Wide Level,
paper presented at III European Conference of Tuna, Vigo 1112 September
Agusa, T., Kunito, G., Iwata, H., Subramanian, A., Ismail, A., Tanabe, S., 2005.
2006.
Concentrations of trace elements in marine sh and its risk assessment in
Valsecchi, A., 2007. European markets for canned tuna. In: Subasinghe, S., Papiro, S.,
Malaysia. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 51, 896911.
Anthonysamy, S.M. (Eds.), Proceedings of the Tuna 2006 Bangkok 9th World
Ashraf, W., 2006. Levels of selected heavy metals in tuna sh. Arab. J. Sci. Eng. 31,
Tuna Trade Conference, 2527 May 2006. INFOFISH.
8992.
VanDerslice, J., Murphy, H., Patrick, G., McBride, D., Magoon, S., 2004. Canned tuna
Besada, V., Gonzalez, J.J., Schultze, F., 2006. Mercury, cadmium, lead, arsenic, copper
mercury levels and consumption patterns in Washington State. Presented at the
and zinc concentrations in albacore, yellown tuna and bigeye tuna from the
National Forum on Contaminants in Fish, held in San Diego, Jan. 25-28 and
Atlantic Ocean. Cienc. Mar. 32, 439445.
sponsored by the Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, pp.8889.
Burger, J., Sanchez, J., Gochfeld, M., 1998. Fishing, consumption, and risk perception
Voegborlo, R.B., El-Methnani, A.M., Abedin, M.Z., 1999. Mercury, cadmium and lead
in sherfolk along an East coast estuari. Environ. Res. 77, 2535.
content of canned tuna sh. Food Chem. 67, 341345.
Burger, J., Gochfeld, M., 2004. Mercury in canned tuna: white versus light and
WHO (World Health Organization), 2006. Summary and conclusions of the sixty-
temporal variation. Environ. Res. 96, 239249.
seventh meeting of the joint FAO/WHO Export Committee on Food Additives,
Burger, J., Stern, A.H., Gochfeld, M., 2005. Mercury in commercial sh. Optimizing
Rome, 2029 June 2006. Geneva: World Health Organization.
individual choices to reduce risk. Environ. Health Perspect. 113, 266271.